Actions

Work Header

Death Be Not Denied

Chapter 2: Death Comes for Tea

Chapter Text

Thorin had certainly not misled the Wizard when he had promised to look after the Hobbit. But as he had told the Wizard on the outset - the duties of Death were not easily set aside. With one thing and another, he'd managed to almost entirely forget his meeting with the Wizard and the Hobbit under the hill until he was quite rudely reminded many weeks later.

Although the learning curve had been steep, Thorin was actually very good at his job and more often than not, he arrived at his appointments with time to spare. This time, the stones had guided him to a busy side street in a merchant district of a northern city of Men and with some time left, Thorin noted, glancing down at the cat’s eye.

The street had been built wide enough to allow for two carts to pass in opposite directions but enterprising street vendors and Men stopping to make deliveries had narrowed the avenue to considerably less than that. As a result, the street rang with the competing cries of merchants hawking their wares and angry cart drivers frustrated in their forward progress. Through it all passed throngs of men and women and children out on business or mischief.

Between the buildings and the wagons, the merchants and the people, the oxen and the street dogs, everyone was pressed cheek to jowl except for Thorin. Murdêl stood alone and unremarked upon, a rock around which all other activity flowed. And from his back, Thorin gained just enough height to oversee it all.

Today his gaze was caught by a group of children; boys just on the cusp of young adulthood. One enterprising lad had distracted a vendor as a few of his friends pawed through a bushel of apples behind the the Man’s back. They had chosen their target poorly though because even as they made to pocket the fruit the vendor turned about and laid into them with broom and strident voice. The boys immediately scattered, vaulting over barrells and dodging grasping hands as nearby vendors joined the fray.

One boy got tangled in a bit of awning and went tumbling into the crowded street. He missed the hooves of the closest horse but the grace of the Valar was not with him. The rearing animal spooked a nearby pony, which broke free from its traces and bolted, causing several carts to upend. In no time at all the scene was a mess of yelling Men and braying animals as carts and people and animals all became hopelessly - and fatally - entangled.

A bitter frown creased Thorin’s face. The cat’s eye was once again fully dilated and there was no question as to who he was here for. Gently he urged Murdêl forward, clearing a path through the crowd of onlookers and desperate Men. No one met his eye or seemed to notice him or the ram but everyone stepped from their path as if they had some sudden coincidental need to shift a pace to the left or right. Mortals rarely saw Death, unless he was there specifically for them, but they always seemed to know when he was near.

Two wagons had come to rest in the center of the street in a mess of broken spars and boards jutting in every direction, heedless of the fragile human flesh that occupied that same space. Thorin dismounted in the center of the commotion and crouched low to look through the tangled debris.

A human man lay crushed beneath what was once the wheel of a wagon, eyes dulled in death. Thorin passed him by; he was obviously not in need of Thorin’s attentions. Deep within the wreckage, a small hand lay flat upon the cobblestones. Every few moments, the fingers flexed against the stone and a soft whimpering inhale could be heard.

"Murdêl. The wagon."

Murdêl stepped forward on carefully placed hooves until he was close to what had once been a driver’s box. Leveraging his shoulder beneath the broken wood, he leaned against the wreckage with all his considerable weight, and the pile shifted just enough for Thorin to finally reach his charge.

Death extended an arm to lay his hand against the boy’s chest and swiped his hand quickly along the broken skin, fingers closing around his palm. When he withdrew, a small shining stone lay in his hand and the boy was still. Tucking the soulstone safely away, Thorin extricated himself from the scene and began to thread his way back through the crowd with Murdêl following close behind.

He sidestepped the hushed group of boys looking on and carded one hand through his hair unhappily. He understood all too well the purpose of Death but the collection of young souls was never a pleasant task. He only attended those whose fate had become inextricably knotted in the weave or whose life had been cut unexpectedly short. Appointments with children always seemed to be the later and no matter how many times he performed these duties, he could not help but feel a bit bitter at the loss of what that child could have been.

He had just made it to the edge of the crowd when a small voice spoke suddenly in his ear. "Thorin?"

Thorin's heart nearly rabbited out of his chest at the unexpected address and he whirled around in a tight circle looking for the source. Murdêl snorted and pushed close, offering his bulk as a shield.

It was then that Thorin abruptly remembered the Hobbit and the gem he'd left with him. His instructions had been straightforward, Hold the gem and call me if you have need. Mounting quickly, he firmly took the reins and commanded, "The Shire, Murdêl."

The great ram gathered himself beneath Thorin and leapt straight over the milling crowd, landing with a clatter of hooves on a patch of suddenly cleared cobblestones. With another great leap they were away from the city of Men and the countryside was blurring around them. Middle Earth was by no means small and Death was in need from one far flung corner to the other. Such was his power that he could be anywhere he needed with very little notice, even half way across the continent in the lush green of the Shire.

Murdêl came down quickly upon the same hill Thorin had visited not so very long ago, this time leaving deep furrows in the soil in his haste. Throwing himself from the saddle, Thorin drew his sword and pulled his cloak more closely about him as he raced down the side of the hillock. He crashed through the round door with little thought to the painted wood and followed the pull of his ruby to a warm, bright room at the back of the Hobbit hole.

As he cleared the doorway, there was the sudden sound of shattering pottery. Thorin brought his sword up to guard against an attack and scanned the room hastily for the threat.

It was empty except for the Hobbit, clutching fearfully at his chest. "Oh, dear."

Thorin blinked slowly and then surveyed the room again sure that he must have missed something.

"Now see here, you! You can't come barreling into someone's home like that!"

Thorin's gaze was drawn back to the single occupant - the Hobbit standing alone in his kitchen with a shattered pot at his feet - with a snap. He had puffed up his chest and his hands had migrated to his hips, his face flushed in anger. "What do you mean by barging in like that?" he demanded.

With nothing to direct it towards, Thorin's battle readiness flashed over to anger. He threw back his hood to reveal his face and snarled, "You called me, Hobbit! And I see no reason for it except perhaps your desire to tug on my leash!"

Bilbo spluttered and went a deep red. "How dare you! I did no such thing! Do you always blame others for your poor manners?"

Manners! As if that was the primary concern here. Thorin growled low in his throat and pointed menacingly at the small gem he had spied lying on a cleared counter. "I am not the one with poor manners here, Halfling. You do not lie well."

Bilbo went white in anger and then at the sight of the gem the righteous indignation seemed to drain from him leaving him slightly reduced.

"Oh. Well." He seemed uncertain of his words and his hands had gone from his hips to twist once fretfully in the air at his side. "I didn't think you were real,” he offered in a more tempered voice tinged with embarrassment.

Thorin blinked in consternation, his sword lowering to rest point down by his boots. "You pulled me from my duties to satisfy your curiosity?" he half growled, torn between anger and surprise at the sheer gall of the being before him.

"Oh, no, certainly not." The Hobbit made to step forward and then glanced down at his feet and the mess of pottery shards and dark liquid. Looking up, he addressed Thorin more civilly.

"Please. Have a seat. I'm terribly sorry. Let me clean this up and I can offer you some tea."

Thorin looked at him, amazed. "Tea? I have duties to attend to, Hobbit."

While he was speaking, Bilbo had crouched down and gathered up the remains of his tea pot with a damp towel, soaking up the mess of tea leaves and spilled liquid in the process.

"Nonsense. There's always time for tea. Unless I called you in the middle of...” At this he looked up at Thorin, eyes full of some strange mixture of sympathy and horror.

Honesty took Thorin's tongue before he could think better of it. "No. I had just finished."

"Well then. Tea it is,” Bilbo decided for them both. “It's the least I can do, having made such a mess of this."

Without quite knowing how he lost the argument against afternoon tea, Thorin found himself seated at the kitchen table with a fragrant cup and a plate full of pastries. His sword, boots, and cloak had been whisked off to parts unknown by the Hobbit before he could register a complaint, leaving him feeling peculiarly under dressed. Shortly after the Hobbit left the room, Thorin heard the front door close with perhaps a bit too much emphasis. He could just make out the sound of the Hobbit muttering to himself about guests who didn’t have the decency to close the front door after themselves as he made his way back toward the kitchen.

Thorin replaced the smile that wanted to tug at his lips with a neutral look as Bilbo seated himself across from him with a satisfied air. He was sure he had been in more awkward situations but he was hard pressed to name one as he found himself sitting across from the Hobbit in nothing more than his shirt sleeves and trousers, holding a delicate cup of tea. The silence stretched painfully between them and Thorin was finally forced to take a sip of tea for lack of anything else to do.

"Again," Bilbo started in an overly loud voice that he quickly corrected with a flush. "I’m sorry for calling you so abruptly. You see, I woke on the couch all those weeks ago and I thought it must have all been a bit of an odd dream. The Wizard and the..." here he waved his hand vaguely in a circle around chest height, which Thorin took to be a reference to Tharkûn’s soulstone.

"But there was your note and the jewel. And I thought, I’d just put it away. Out of sight, out of mind, they say." The Hobbit gave a bit of a self deprecating smile and picked up his pastry only to set it back down immediately thereafter. Thorin couldn’t help but watch, entranced as the Hobbit made an odd sort of moue with his mouth, pinching his lips and twitching his nose once.

"But it was still there, you know?” He didn’t seem able to look directly at Thorin. Instead his eyes flitted between the table and Thorin’s right shoulder. “In the drawer, of course, but also on my mind. And I thought, well, what could it hurt? Holding the jewel and calling for you?” With one hand he turned his plate a quarter turn to the left, then turned it back, fidgeting.

“It sounded ridiculous, you know? And then when nothing happened, I'd know, right?" He didn't seem to require any response from Thorin for all that he had asked the question because he continued on without a pause. "And then suddenly you were here with that sword in my kitchen and I’m quite certain it wasn’t you at all at first, but then it was. And really,” he admonished with a stern frown, “you scared me near to death."

At the last, Thorin's brows rose straight up to his hairline and the Hobbit went suddenly a bit pale. "I... I didn't mean... What I meant to say was..."

Thorin snorted, no longer able to hide the small twitch of a smile that he could feel teasing at the edge of his lips. "Peace, halfling. You have apologized already."

Bilbo bristled, although whether more because of Thorin's ill concealed amusement or his comment, was unclear. Perhaps both as he immediately admonished Thorin. "Bilbo. My name is Bilbo. And I'm a Hobbit, thank you very much. Not a halfling."

Thorin canted his head slightly in silent apology and put down the teacup in favor of taking a bite of pastry. The tart had a pleasant sharp taste to it that Thorin couldn’t quite identify. Surprised he took a more substantial bite and looked up to catch Bilbo smiling to himself in satisfaction over the sound of Thorin's pleased hum.

"So. Um. I interrupted you at your." Bilbo seemed to lose steam as he searched frantically for a polite word to encompass the realities of death. “Duties?” he finally settled on, flustered.

For some reason, Thorin found himself carefully wiping his fingers on a much too delicate table napkin and drawing forth the child's soulstone from his inner pocket. Reverently, he laid it on the table then unwrapped the felt cloth from around it so it sat glowing softly from a bed of velvety black. It was a small thing, no larger than a peach pit and striated in ice blues and pale greens that reminded Thorin of early springs in the far north.

A quiet gasp brought his attention back to Bilbo.

"It was a child of Man. Caught in an accident with a wagon."

The Hobbit made a soft, wounded sound and covered his mouth with faintly shaking fingers. "It's beautiful," he murmured quietly.

Thorin could only nod. He had always found them so himself; each soulstone glowed with an inner light that was captivating.

"What do you do with them?" the Hobbit asked curiously. He reached out with a tentative finger as if to stroke the little stone. "You don't keep them, do you?"

Thorin looked up sharply, hand immediately reaching out to shelter the stone. "Of course not!" he growled, quickly bundling the soulstone back up in its cloth and tucking it safely away. "I am Death, not a soul eater."

Bilbo blinked at the unfamiliar term and quickly pulled his hand back. He looked down at it in surprise, as if he hadn't even known he had been reaching for the stone.

"Sorry," he stammered. "I meant no offense. I seem to be doing this all wrong," he muttered, half in self reproach and half in apology. He sighed to himself then soldiered on quickly. "Do you know how he came to be here? Gandalf, I mean?”

Thorin shook his head but once again the Hobbit seemed to need little response from him. The tale poured from him in a rush of frustrated words and punctuated by restless gestures of his hands.

“He showed up at my gate that very same morning. I hadn’t seen him in years, not since, well, not for a very long time,” he amended clearly avoiding some topic. “I hardly even remembered him. But then he was going on about leaving and telling me not to worry as he had called on a friend who would look after me.” Bilbo sniffed in order to clearly convey how absurd he still found that idea to be. “And then before I’d turned about, you were there and he was gone. And I still have no blasted clue who you are or why any of this has happened."

The Hobbit set his mouth firmly and stared at Thorin obviously waiting for a reply. At a loss, Thorin sat back stiffly in his seat. "The Wizard told you who I was. I am Death. As to the other, I have no more idea of why the Wizard did what he did than you."

The Hobbit huffed. "I know you say you are Death, but really what does that mean?"

Thorin could only look at him in confusion. What did it mean to be Death? What an odd sort of question.

Bilbo drew in a deep breath and finally settled enough to curl his hands around his teacup. "Thorin. I am a Hobbit. And as a Hobbit, when I die, I expect that I shall be laid to rest next to my parents and my soul will travel to the ever green fields and I shall be reunited with those who have passed before me. Never before have I heard of a soulstone or disappearing in a blinding light or any of this magic that seems to follow you."

Thorin stared at him. How did someone explain something as basic as death? His tongue twisted around the only words that he could offer.

"All things in Middle Earth die and it is my responsibility to see that they make it to the after. For Hobbits that is Yavanna's Fields. For Dwarves, the Halls of Waiting. I sent Gandalf to the West, as was his wish, and I will see this soul off as well," he noted absently brushing the softest of finger tips across the quilted fabric of his vest.

"But there must be so many. How can you possibly attend us all?" the Hobbit asked with an honest look of confusion.

Thorin groped for the right words. "Most people die and their place in the weave is filled with new threads. The same way you don’t ask your heart to beat, I don’t actively need to assist them. But some threads are twisted too tightly with others or cut unexpectedly. Those I attend to personally." It was a far less elegant and true explanation then the reality but it was the best that Thorin could articulate.

It seemed to satisfy the Hobbit or at least give him some partial understanding for he nodded and looked thoughtful. "You must be very old, then." he mused seemly without forethought.

Thorin couldn't help the bark of laughter that the statement startled from him. Bilbo flushed in embarrassment. "I'm sorry. I seem to be all wrongfooted today."

"I am not the first Death nor shall I be the last," Thorin offered with a wry grin.

Rather than putting him off, this only seemed to further intrigue him. Thorin had met all types of people in his travels but rarely one so openly curious about him.

"Were you born to it then? How does one become Death?"

Images of a long ago battle pushed to the front of Thorin's mind. He no longer heard the screams or smelled the blood of the dead and dying; the memory was old and worn. But he could still clearly see Death standing over him, an incongruously golden Elf reaching out for his soul. That still had the power to invoke a hard ache in his chest.

"I killed my predecessor to became Death," he offered before he could think better of it, mind tangled in threads of memory.

There was a clatter of porcelain as the Hobbit dropped his teacup onto his saucer. Thorin’s attention was drawn back to the present, musings broken. "Excuse me?" Bilbo asked, aghast.

Thorin smiled with perhaps a touch of vindictive glee. If one was going to be overly curious then one should be prepared to be discomfited. "It is the way of these things. There was a battle and Death had come for me. In my despair, I raised my sword against him. If we are careful we have our own protections, but either he was not careful that day or he had grown weary of the duty. My sword struck true and I became Death."

The Hobbit made a small sound of horror and his gaze flickered off in the direction of the hall, most likely wondering if the sword he’d divested Thorin of was the same weapon that had slayed Death. The sword had been his since his majority and had indeed killed Death in that fateful battle but it was just a sword. Nothing more nor less.

"I have made the best of my fate and will continue to perform my duties until one day I am reckless or ready to lay down my burden."

There was a much more to the story than what he had shared with the Hobbit and by the look on his face, Bilbo knew that too. But he didn't press further. Instead he moved on to another question.

"How long ago was that?"

Thorin did a quick mental calculation and to his surprise came up with a number far larger than the last time he'd thought on it. "I died during a battle between Dwarves and Orcs in the second age."

Bilbo was visibly aghast at his response. "You've been doing this since the second age?"

Thorin could only offer a small shrug of his shoulders. Time meant something different when you had lived as many years as Thorin had.

"That's barbaric!" Bilbo exclaimed in righteous fury.

Thorin flinched from the sudden attack, free hand clenching into a fist. His skin prickled with a sudden rush of hot anger. It was far from the first time he’d been railed against; the dying often cursed him. That didn’t diminish the unfairness of it though. Death was a necessary part of living, not some evil perpetrated on Middle Earth through malice.

Bilbo continued on seemly unconcerned with Thorin’s own mounting anger. "You’ve been forced to spend the last age travelling Middle Earth and collecting these stone things?"

"Soulstones." Thorin offered, thrown off by the sudden turn in conversation.

"Yes! Those!" Bilbo said pointing at him with a stiff finger. "Don't you get tired of it all? Or lonely?" he asked, abruptly seeming to lose steam.

Thorin stared at him for a moment, unsure how to deal with anger on his behalf. It was a rare occasion that it was not directed at him and he felt rather bewildered by the Hobbit’s outrage. "I rest," he protested, with the first thought that came to mind. One of the first lessons Thorin had learned was that he could simply take a break when needed and death would wait for him. Not indefinitely of course, but plenty long enough for him to rest.

"And I eat."

"You eat?" Bilbo asked stunned.

Thorin looked blankly at the small portion of pastry left on his plate and Bilbo followed his gaze. Spying the obvious truth to Thorin's words, he colored again.

"I am Death, not dead." Thorin remarked wryly. He barreled on as the Hobbit opened his mouth again to speak. There was little chance of him getting a word in if he didn't make room for them himself. "And I am not lonely."

It was true that there were few people that Thorin interacted with, and most were dead, but that didn't mean he was lonely. The Hobbit’s mouth had gone tight and he obviously had something further to say on the matter. Before Bilbo could offer whatever argument or sympathy was on the tip of his tongue, though, a shadow passed before the large round window and Thorin found himself looking at Murdêl across the intervening space. The great ram shook his head heavily back and forth as if to chivvy Thorin.

Bilbo immediately stood and marched over to the large round kitchen window to investigate.

"What is a ram doing in my flower garden?" he asked hotly.

Thorin glanced at his wrist where the stones on his cuff flashed sharply. His time was spent, it appeared. With a feeling a little like regret, he rose. "That is Murdêl,” he answered as he placed his teacup and plate on the sideboard. “And it appears as if I am needed."

Bilbo turned back to him as Thorin crossed to the doorway and into the hall. Looking left then right, he oriented himself on the front door and located his missing items set beside it. He strode over quickly and drew them on, setting ties and buckles with practiced ease and repositioning his sword on his back.

Bilbo appeared at his elbow, Thorin's ruby held out stretched in his open palm. "Did you wish to take this?" he asked, offering the stone to Thorin.

"No," Thorin shook his head. "Tharkûn asked me to look after you and I doubt he did so just so you could offer me tea."

At this Bilbo smiled. He drew back his hand with the gem tucked away in his closed palm. "I did enjoy tea, even if it was unexpected," he offered with a self conscious grin.

Privately, Thorin agreed. While he might have been loath to baldly admit it to the Hobbit, it had been far too long since he'd spent any significant time with another mortal. People would sometimes try to engage him in conversation when he was making a collection but somehow he didn’t think that would quite count as an acceptable social engagement by the Hobbit’s reckoning.

"Will you perhaps come again? If you have time?"

Thorin couldn't imagine when that might be but he found himself nodding just the same before stepping out the door to meet Murdêl. It had been an odd morning, but not an unpleasant one.

"Goodbye, Bilbo Baggins."

"Goodbye, Thorin Deathless." Bilbo returned with amused formality.

Once again, Thorin found the world around him blurring as Murdêl leapt away but the deep green of the Shire seemed to trail after him for a long time thereafter.