Actions

Work Header

The Gift of the Garden Born

Chapter 4: The Consequences of Secrets

Summary:

Below is a bit of an interesting head cannon for Kili that I have been planning for some time. I think it is also cannon for "of the Stone of Erebor" but will likely never come up.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Bilbo had been spending far too much time in the repository for Thrain’s children. He knew this, knew he should stay away, but his feet drew him back time and time again. Which was fine when he wasn’t caught at it.

“Who’s to say it isn’t the will of Mahal?” Kili cried even as Bilbo came through the open doorway. That should have been the first clue to turn the other way, the open door. Unfortunately, he wasn’t thinking and kept moving until Kili fixed him with a frantic look. “You can see it, can’t you, Bilbo?”

“See what?” Bilbo regretted the words the moment they slipped from his lips. Eru, the whole Durin family was present.

Kili flung an arm out, gesturing at the sculpture he most often lingered over.

“There is nothing to see, Kili. No one could have foreseen your actions,” Thorin said sharply.

“This is my son,” Kili said, beating his chest. “My son. I know this in the depth of my being. And look at him. He is amlâkhuzd.”

Bilbo considered the word. His Khuzdul was poor, but if he was parsing that correctly, it meant half of dwarf. Looking carefully at the sculpture, Bilbo took in the long limbs that seemed out of proportion. He had noticed that before. But never before had he noted the way a small pointed ear seemed to peek from the carefully carved hair.

Before Bilbo could formulate a reply, or find a way to calm everyone as was his wont, Dis let out a heartbroken cry and fell to her knees. Kili screamed in rage and ran from the room, almost knocking Bilbo over. Thorin dropped at his sister’s side and wrapped her in his arms while Fili stood, looking between his disappearing brother and shattered mother.

“Go,” Thorin ordered. “Don’t let him do anything rash.”

“Like propose?” Fili asked darkly. But then he shook his head and strode out, his passage barely slower than his brother’s.

Bilbo stood, frozen, until his heart settled down to a rhythm he could live with. Thorin was speaking softly to Dis in Khuzdul, too soft for Bilbo to make sense of. He didn’t want to intrude… but…

“I’m sorry,” he said, very softly himself. “I’ll go.”

“No,” Dis said before he could take more than a step.

“Nana’,” Thorin said, “you should rest.”

“No,” she spat, shrugging off Thorin’s arm. “No, tell him. Or I will. Perhaps in the telling we will find some sense…” She collapsed in on herself again, tears flooding her eyes.

Bilbo walked over and settled at her side. “Hush, sister. All will be well. Kili will calm down.”

Dis laughed, but it was not a happy sound. “Kili. Khajamê. Perhaps he is right.”

“Dis. I never expected you to encourage such madness.”

Despite her compressed position, Dis slugged her brother hard enough to knock him away. “Do not talk to me about madness.”

“Please,” Bilbo said, catching Dis’ hand. “Please. Calm down. You are both concerned about Kili. I understand.”

Thorin sighed deeply. “No, you don’t.” He tucked Dis back against his chest. “When Dis was pregnant with her second child…” He paused, looking down. Something passed between the two siblings before he began again. “We were still wandering then. I was quite concerned about Dis. The pregnancy had not been easy and we were desperate to find a place to settle for the last month or two.”

“Vili, my husband, was scouting ahead when he was attacked by orcs,” Dis said, pressing a hand to her belly with a pained look. “When we were brought word…”

“He was dead, and Dis collapsed. I got her settled and called for a healer, but it was too late. She lost the child before....”

Bilbo glanced toward the door Kili had so recently run through, uncertainty and confusion jittering through him.

“My baby,” Dis wailed. “My precious son, taken from me.”

“He took but a single breath,” Thorin said sadly. “He was still too young to face the world. But Dis… Dis…” His voice broke.

“He took my son. I demanded he give him back,” Dis hissed, beating her hand against the floor.

“She stole my axe, still covered in blood and afterbirth.” Thorin shook his head. “Strode out to the nearest rock outcropping and chipped off a hunk. Ruined that blade.”

“More important things than your axe,” Dis said, slugging her brother weakly.

“I know,” Thorin said, pressing a kiss to his sister’s hair. “The results were rough, but she started praying all the same.”

“It didn’t want to work. Blood of the mother. Blood of the father. But Vili was dead and gone.”

“She used blood from the child, from herself, from Fili—”

“Anything to get my son back. His body could not live, so I gave him another.”

“It worked,” Bilbo breathed, tears filling his eyes. “Kili…”

“He has always been a little strange,” Thorin said softly. “There must be some price for stretching the gifts of dwarrow and Mahal so far.”

“He is my son,” Dis said forcefully. “He was always meant to be.” She struggled to her feet and strode to a niche. Inside sat the one statue Bilbo had been trying to make sense of for some time, the one that was falling apart. She grabbed it up and held it out. “Father knew—” Her voice broke as the sculpture finally dissolved to dust at her touch.

“One stone traded for another,” Bilbo said, catching Dis as she crumpled again. “I did not know.”

“No one does,” Thorin said. “Fili may remember some, but... You are the first we have ever told.”

“Then Kili…?” Bilbo paused, not sure what he meant to say.

“We never told him,” Dis said, pressing her beard into Bilbo’s waistcoat. “Everyone thinks my babe survived.”

“It was safer to let them think so,” Thorin said.

“I won’t say anything,” Bilbo said.

“I know,” Thorin said. Then he sighed deeply. “I do not know what to blame this latest madness on.”

“If he was destined to be, in one way or another…” Bilbo pressed his free hand into the dust that surrounded them now. “Then maybe this too was meant to be.”

“A dwarf and an elf?” Thorin spat.

“Which upsets you more, brother dear?” Dis spat through her tears. “One of Thranduil’s kin or one of your own?”

“Tauriel is no kin to Thranduil,” Bilbo said, surprised by how sharp he sounded. “Completely different breed of elf.”

“There are multiple breeds?” Thorin said.

Dis broke into cackles. “Daft, stubborn fool.”

“Thorin, really,” Bilbo said.

~ ~

The tension between Kili and his uncle continued to rise in the following weeks, until the two could not be in the same room together without an argument breaking out over something. Bilbo watched, concerned through it all until the day mention of trade with Dale, of all things, was the trigger. That day, when Kili stormed out, Thorin turned to Fili and asked when he would be starting to bring home inappropriate possible spouses.

“That daughter of Bard’s perhaps?”

The look of anguish and horror in Fili’s eyes as he stalked from the council room was the utter end for Bilbo. The hobbit turned and glared hard at Thorin, who did have the sense to look abashed as he watched his heir leave.

“Unbelievable,” Bilbo hissed. “I suggest, Thorin Oakenshield, that you pull your head out of your ass and get over this before you drive both of your nephews from Erebor.” He brightened a moment as the appropriate thought (threat) struck him. “After all, I shall have to follow. Oh, with both of them we could return to the Shire. I’m sure my Took cousins would adore having them around. And Fortinbras would give me control of Bag End again. Yes, go right on as you have. It will be good to see home again.”

Thorin looked shattered, his blue eyes dark with pain and guilt, almost enough to make Bilbo feel sorry for his words.

“Think upon the consequences,” Bilbo said, and Thorin nodded gravely.

~ ~

Bilbo found Tauriel first, oddly enough. She was waiting outside the council chamber, rather than having followed Kili to wherever he’d taken to hiding out.

“You will help him?” she asked. No, pleaded.

“I will try,” Bilbo swore. In return, Tauriel led Bilbo to a small tunnel, seemingly too small for the towering elf, that in turn led to a crack in the mountain that was probably an air vent. Beyond was a small, flat area, not large enough to hold soil but with room to walk and sit. Out there, Fili and Kili huddled together, braids all but intertwined as they held each other.

Tauriel swore to see they weren’t interrupted before Bilbo stepped out onto the ledge. “Ah, my boys,” Bilbo whispered, his voice stolen away by the wind. Still, Fili looked up, glaring. The look softened in an instant when he saw Bilbo.

“Dear, dear, boys.” Bilbo crouched down beside them. “I know it hurts. But you know they only protest from love.”

Kili snarled though Fili tried to sooth him with gentle touches.

“Love? How is it love to separate me from the one I love, to deny me the happiness my mother even now speaks of from her own marriage?”

Bilbo sighed and made a very important, and potentially dangerous, decision.

He turned to Fili. “How much do you remember from the day Kili was born?”

Fili did not get a chance to answer. Kili quickly said, “It was the day Adad was killed. I was born early when Amad heard of his death. What of it?”

“Yes and no,” Bilbo said, then paused before saying more as Fili began to speak, his eyes lost in deep remembrance.

“That’s what they told us… but I remember blood, and pain. Amad screaming in anger. Thorin crying.” As he spoke, Fili violently rubbed a line across the palm of his hand.

Bilbo gently tugged that hand free of the other and soothed the redness on Fili’s palm with his own fingers. He wasn’t sure how he first noticed, look or touch, but after a moment he could see a scar, very faint, across the width of Fili’s palm. “Did you get this that day?” he asked softly.

Fili startled and bit his lip. “I don’t know. Sometimes I dream of Amad cutting my hand and dripping my blood on a stone, but that doesn’t make sense.”

“You were so young, it makes sense you would hide the truth in dreams,” Bilbo said.

“What do you mean?” Kili demanded. He caught Fili’s hand and looked at the scar. “He’s always had that.”

“Probably since the day of your birth,” Bilbo said, catching Kili’s hands in his own. “I only learned by accident. Your birth was not an easy one.” And Bilbo told Kili and Fili exactly what Thorin and Dis had told him.

When Bilbo was done, both lads looked horrified.

“That… explains so much,” Fili breathed.

“Yes, that my kin fear my actions because I’m an abomination,” Kili spat. He was shaking, though Bilbo suspected it was as much fear as anger. “There are plenty who would have me killed if they knew…”

Fili let out a pained snort of laughter. “Suddenly the emphasis on proper procedure in crafting a child makes so much more sense. They were warning us against Amad’s mistake.”

“Oh, both of theirs, I suspect,” Bilbo said. “But I doubt—”

“Who knows?” Kili demanded.

“Your mother and your uncle,” Bilbo said. “I learned only because your mother was so distraught. And now you, though I suspect I will be cast out for telling you.”

“Not if we don’t tell them we know,” Fili said.

“You expect me to go on as normal… knowing what I am?” Kili rose halfway to his feet, arms waving wildly.

Bilbo grabbed Kili’s hand and pulled him back to the ground. “No!” He held tight, looking into Kili’s eyes until there was a moment of sense in them. “You are Kili, son of Dis, of the line of Durin. You are kin to Thorin, King Under the Mountain, and Fili, heir to the throne. Nothing has changed.”

Kili hissed out a pained breath. “Abomination.”

“Stone traded for stone,” Bilbo said firmly, and described how one carving had dissolved to dust. “You were meant to be.”

Fili bit his lip and hesitantly asked, “How can you be sure?”

Bilbo sniffed and gave them a very Bagginsish look. “I doubt Aule is going to do anything he doesn’t want to, no matter who begs. Therefore, he had a purpose in permitting the ritual to work. Besides, I’m a hobbit. We can recognize an abomination just fine, and while spiders and goblins are abominations, and orcs…” He shuddered at the memory. “Disgusting. The living earth abhors them. But you, my dear boy, are just that. A boy. A dwarrow. Perhaps a bit different from others. There are likely consequences for bending the rules even when one of the Valar does it.”

As he had spoken, Bilbo watched Kili’s face, watched hope grow in his eyes and some of that Durin stubbornness come back.

“So bearded or no, your family loves you.” Bilbo tugged at the scruff that was still all Kili could grow. “They threatened the gods to keep you with them.”

Kili began to smile, but as quickly the joy fell from his face and tears welled in his eyes. “Then why…? Why won’t they accept…?”

Bilbo sighed. “Your uncle is a stubborn ass with an unreasonable hatred for all elves. If you’d fallen in love with a human it might have been easier, but as it is he fears his actions... “ He paused, looking for the right words.

Fili took up the thought somehow. “They fear they did wrong and so look for signs of their failing. They aren’t really afraid of you, but for you.” He pulled his brother to his chest. “As you said, there are those who would kill you for what they did.”

Sobs wracked Kili’s frame, and his brother held him, tears trickling down his own face. Bilbo sat at their side, holding Kili’s hand, until the emotional storm passed and they could all face each other again.

“I do love her,” Kili said, ending the silence.

“I know,” Bilbo said. “And I think your mother is coming around.”

Kili looked up in shock, though Fili just looked thoughtful.

“She wants you to be happy, first priority,” Bilbo said. “You just need to be a bit more patient. Honestly, you’re barely of age yourself. The two of you have centuries ahead of you. And it isn’t like Thorin has cast Tauriel from the mountain, no matter how much he blusters.”

“See, nadad, I told you they were softening.” Fili grinned at his brother, and Bilbo could see just why the dwarrow were taking to calling him Fili the Golden.

“And I promise to keep working on them,” Bilbo said, tweaking Kili’s braid, “if you promise to work on your temper.”

~ ~

At dinner, Thorin was shocked when Kili came up to him and actually apologised for his rude behavior that afternoon. He wasn’t more specific, but it was enough to raise a wave of guilt in the king. He murmured an apology as well, and made sure to offer one to Fili when he came in.

But the real shocker was when Dis walked into the hall where they still served a communal meal for those in the mountain without time or resources to cook at home. The crowd was the same size it had been that winter, though that was a much smaller portion of the mountain’s inhabitants these days, and Dis looked through them all until she found a towering head of red hair. And then, oh, Mahal, she brought the blasted elf to the head table and sat Tauriel on her right. Right between herself and Thorin.

“Dis,” Thorin hissed at her.

“Shut up, nadad. If there is a chance she will be my daughter some day, I will get to know her now.” And Dis did not bother to keep her voice down, speaking so all at the—now silent—table could hear.

Thorin wanted to disappear, longed for Bilbo’s magic ring for an instant so he could escape. But there was no way to leave without making a scene, and he’d made enough of those of late.

The only comfort in listening to Dis quiz the elf about her life, interests, and emotional attachment to Kili, was the way Bilbo smiled proudly at Thorin from across the table.

~ ~

Thorin found Bilbo in Thrain’s repository and was shocked to find his burglar quite close to his son. In all the times Thorin had found Bilbo in this place, never had the hobbit come close to any of the children, seeming to understand instinctively how personal such contact would be.

“Bilbo?” Thorin spoke softly, but the hobbit still startled and something wood clattered to the stone sill of the niche.

“Ah, Thorin, I’m sorry.” Bilbo shuffled back, looking embarrassed and worried.

Thorin stepped closer and realized the wood was a carefully carved arm. It looked like it would fit perfectly against the broken shoulder resting against the stone niche. “What is this?” he asked, carefully picking up the little arm. The wood was silky under his calloused fingers, soft as the skin of a child.

“Ah…” Bilbo stood frozen, eyes fixed on the carving.

“I’m sorry,” Thorin said, holding out the arm. “Should I have not…?”

“No… It’s not…” Bilbo sighed and seemed to relax a little. “I’m the one intruding. It’s for you.” He reached into his pocket and pulled out something which he held out.

Thorin held out his hand, and Bilbo deposited two items into it. Little feet, carved of the same wood as the arm still held in Thorin’s other hand. Two feet with hardy toes and wisps of hair on their tops. Holding them, something deep within him seemed to settle in place and he knew they were perfect.

“Bilbo… how?” He desperately wanted to turn and press each piece into place, but he refrained.

“You told me of dwarves… But I did not tell you of hobbits.” Bilbo bit his lip and his fingers kept twitching, as if he wanted to reclaim what Thorin still held. “We are fecund as a rule, as fertile as our fields, but there are always exceptions. The Green Lady taught us a way for those who were unlucky otherwise… or for couples who could not have children in the normal way between the two of them.” His cheeks pinked most becomingly in the lantern light. “We don’t use stone like dwarrow.”

“Understandable,” Thorin said. “You are creatures of earth, not stone.”

Bilbo nodded. “Yes, and so we craft a child of wood and clay, and plant them in the garden.”

“The earth your cousins brought,” Thorin said, seeing the whole of it in an instant.

“My mother was injured on one of her adventures, so I was born from the gardens of Bag End. It is why…” Bilbo pursed his lips and tugged on the end of his Durin braid. “Why I could help Fili.”

“You think… we could complete…”

Bilbo nodded. “I don’t know if your prayers will work. It might be better to plant him and see… but… I don’t even know if you want a child. But the Lady has driven me… I’m sorry.”

Thorin realized he had said nothing in the face of this incredible offer. A child. His child. Who he thought would never be because of the problems with his carving. And Bilbo thought he could be born. Thorin carefully set the wood pieces down in the niche next to the stone whole and wrapped his arms around Bilbo, trying to express his deepest gratitude with his touch.

“I have no words,” he whispered into curly hair. “Akhminruki astû, akdâmuthrabê. Such a gift.”

“You’re going to have to make it official now.”

Recognizing the new voice as his sister, Thorin held still against his burglar’s fight to move. “It is well,” he whispered into hobbit curls before he let go. “She is right. We should announce our marriage,” he said more generally.

“Marriage?” Bilbo squeaked, green eyes wide. “Oh no. Thorin, I didn’t mean to… Oh dear.” And he ran off before Thorin could grab his arm or reason with him.

“Why didn’t you stop him?” he snarled at Dis, staring down the hallway at his deepest wish running away.

“He is not mine to stop,” Dis said, standing beside the doorway. “I must ask, brother, have you mentioned previously that you two are all but wed?”

The warmth of his cheeks told her all, he was certain.

“Males,” Dis spat. “Try his garden. And explain more fully this time. In small words.”

Thorin slugged her in the shoulder, hard, as he walked past. But she was right. He could have handled that better.

Notes:

Dwarrow (Khuzdul) terms

Akdâmuthrabê - my burgler
Akhminruki astû - Thank you wholeheartedly (to a male)
Amlâkhuzd - Half-dwarf
Azanulbizar - The Dimrill Dale outside the east gate of Moria. Site of the final battle of the War of the Dwarrow and Orcs
Bintarg - Beardless
Durub - uncle
Dwarrow - The proper plural of dwarf per Tolkien.
Irakdashatê - my nephew
Khajam - my gift
khajmel - gift of all kifts
Khuzdul - The language of the dwarrow
Mahal - The Maker. Khuzdul name for Aulë, the Smith, creator of the Dwarrow
Masmith - Jewel that is young
Nadad - Brother
Nana' - sister
Rêdel - heir of all heirs
Tharkun - Gray-man or Staff-man.The Khuzdul name for Gandalf.

Elvish terms

Elleth - elf-maid in Sindarin
Tengwar - script used for Sindarin

Hobbitish terms

Faunts - Immature hobbits that are not yet tweenagers. (Children)
Mathoms - usless trinkets. Hobbits tend to collect them around the house and then gift and regift them at birthdays and the like. Big mathoms might be put in a mathom house for everyone to have a gander at.