Chapter Text
Dear Thorin,
It’s been ten years since that horrid day. The day I lost you. And yet this is the first time I’ve been able to take a quill to paper and write down the words I have long since wanted to say to you without turning coward and running away. I do that a lot, you see. Run away. I ran away when you said those words in the Misty Mountains, though the goblins pulled me back in. I ran away from the spiders of Mirkwood and left you all to fend for yourself. And then I ran away after you threw me from Erebor, so angry at my theft of the Arkenstone. I never looked back. Not once. Which brings me to the reason I have been so scared and ashamed to speak with you. The Arkenstone.
Oh, it was a beautiful gem, I won’t deny that. But to me, a hobbit of the Shire, it held no real worth outside of it’s exterior beauty. Though I admit, it was a bit more special to me because I knew it was special to you. In the end it was just a rock. A pretty, shiny little rock. Yet it was the reason for your madness. Not the only reason, granted, but the piece that would have sent you far over the edge and you would have been lost to us forever. I couldn’t let that happen. Not to you, not when I had the means to stop it. So I gave it to your imagined enemies, to Thranduil and Bard. Thranduil wanted only to lord this victory over you, but Bard’s people were in dire need of help. Like your own people when Smaug had come and forced you to flee into the wilds. I thought I was doing the right thing.
You saw it differently.
I still dream of that night. I wake up in cold sweats and hoarse screams. I feel your hands wrapped around my neck and have to rush to my mirror to check for bruising. There never is any, but I still check. More than the battle, more than Smaug in his infinite terror, those dreams scare me the most. Sometimes you finish the deed, throw me off the wall and to the rocks below. Sometimes you are more sinister and I am thrown into a dark dungeon to rot away from the sun. Those dreams are the worst, and I have trouble sleeping for the days to come.
Frodo makes things easier. I was so bitter when I came home, so lonely and aching for the company I had lost. Frodo, my cousin and new ward, brought that to me. He is the only good in my life I must admit.
I’m not sorry for what I did, Thorin. You were crazed, could not see the damage that was being done. And you were scared. I know that now. You had such a hard life that when all your dreams came true you couldn’t help but be wary. What new threat would appear and take all you hold dear? Life had been so cruel to you in the past that you were ready for it to be so again. I think that is why you fell so easily to the Gold Sickness, because you were always waiting for things to go wrong. I won’t apologize for taking the Arkenstone in the hopes of curing you. I will apologize for not trying to do more. For not telling you the truth because I was a coward. But here it is now.
I love you, Thorin Oakenshield. I loved you since that night Balin told us of your glory in Moria. I loved you greater still when you shared with me the ruin of your line in Rivendell. My heart was lost to you at the Carrock when you embraced me and held me so dearly. And my heart was lost when you left this world, leaving me behind and alone.
Forgive me for not telling you, Thorin. Perhaps if I had things would have turned out differently. But I didn’t and now you are dead. Another thing I am sorry for.
You will never read this letter (how could you, being entombed in stone until the world is remade?), but I think I shall send it along to Erebor anyway. Perhaps Balin will be so kind as to leave it on your tomb, along with some flowers for the boys. Fili and Kili loved when I taught them the secret hobbit language of flowers. Some heather and daisies would do nicely for them. For you, though, I would have left yellow tulips. Only those.
I hope we may meet again in the next world, Thorin. Perhaps then I will find my courage and be able to tell you all that I couldn’t while we lived.
With all my heart and soul, yours faithfully,
Bilbo Baggins, Your Burglar.
Dear Master Baggins,
You are forgiven, though it is my apology that should be the one given. And I would not take your yellow tulips. From you I will only take red. Nothing else.
Yours always, in this life and the next,
Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain and Yours Most Devoted.
