Chapter Text
Sam stopped in his tracks so quickly that the pony he was leading bumped into him, dumbstruck at the beautiful and familiar voice filtering back from the main stage.
“Mr. Frodo?” he whispered, turning towards the curtains to try and get a glimpse. “Could it really be Mr. Frodo?”
“Frodo Baggins? Of course it is! Where’ve you been all week?” piped up another hobbit to his left, dressed as one of the chorus.
“The lead tenor, Otho, walked out a few days ago and Frodo is taking his place as lead!” chipped in another chorus member, coming up on his right. “He’s just been in the chorus with us up until now, but he has a private tutor too and has gotten much better.”
“Oh,” Sam whispered, his heart clenching painfully again as he actually did catch a glimpse of Frodo up on stage, with his beautifully tailored costume and singing so magnificently. He was just as- as wonderful as Sam remembered from their childhood friendship so many years ago, playing through the gardens and the woods together, with Frodo making up songs as they went along and Sam joining in as best he could.
“Are you new, then?” asked the first hobbit, elbowing him to get his attention. “I’m Pippin, by the way, Pippin Took.”
“And I’m Merry Brandybuck,” the hobbit to his right introduced himself.
Sam managed to tear his eyes away from Frodo, not wanting to be rude. “Sam Gamgee. I’m new, just started a couple of days ago, and it’s been such a rush with the show openin’ I scarcely had time to remember my own name!”
“Understandable,” Merry agreed, grinning shrewdly.
“Samwise!”
Sam turned quickly to find the formidable stage manager, Mr. Bilbo, passing by. “Yes, sir?”
“That pony will need to be around to the back soon, so don’t dawdle too long.”
“No, Mr. Bilbo, sir!” Sam swallowed, not having meant to be caught woolgathering at his first show. But the older hobbit smiled slightly to let him know it was all right, and hurried on.
“We’ll find you after the show and get you caught up on the gossip, shall we?” Merry offered.
“If- If that’s all right, I’d be much obliged!” Sam said, and led the pony onward. The other two hobbits waved him off with easy smiles.
He probably doesn’t remember me, the hobbit reminded himself, trying to temper his excitement at seeing Frodo again, I was just the gardener’s son, and I’m not much more than that now. What was it Mr. Bofur said? “Wrangler of flora and fauna”? And who would have known an opera would use so many real flowers and animals and such like! Unfortunately, there was no live Oliphaunt, even though this particular production was set in far south Harad. But maybe I’ll be able to say a quick hello to Mr. Frodo sometime...surely he wouldn’t mind that.
He sent one last, wistful smile back in the direction of the stage. He may not remember me, but I surely do remember him.
--
Frodo came awake slowly in an unfamiliar bed to soft, tinkling music.
Even with hours of sleep intervening, something in his soul still quivered with joy and longing. That voice was all he could remember for a long, long moment, deep and yearning, pulling at something profound inside him that Frodo wasn’t honestly sure he could even explain....
Then everything else came back to him too, and he opened his eyes with a small gasp.
Carefully, he pulled himself out of the bed and rose. He remembered mist, and a lake, and-
Stepping out onto the ledge revealed that none of it had been a dream after all. The great arched cavern was supported by sturdy square columns, carved with intricate geometric designs and strange bearded figures. Clever light fixtures lit up the land and glittered in the water of the glassy lake below. Turning back towards the bed, he found the source of the tinkling music, a music box carved into the shape of an exquisitely detailed red dragon curled around a miniature treasure hoard.
If all of this was real, then so the rest of it had been, the long journey down from the Opera House through the maze of tunnels and carefully constructed passages...and the one who had led him here.
The Opera Ghost, the Phantom.
He was both as frightening as the tales told by the stagehands and chorus members, and as amazing and intense as Bilbo’s stories had always painted him. His eyes were blue and had burned with an intensity that had almost taken Frodo’s breath and voice away. The half of his face not covered by the mask was handsome, framed by long silver-streaked dark hair and short beard. Strong hands that had obviously built so much down here in the depths below the Opera House had beckoned Frodo ever further through his personal kingdom, and had coaxed such breathtaking music from the large harp that stood in pride of place to one side. Those same strong hands had caught and carried him when he fainted after the long night and the sight of the strange carving of a hobbit (of Frodo) decorating one of the long, covered walls.
Frodo swallowed. All along...all along, Frodo’s teacher had been none other than the Opera Ghost himself.
He could not say, now, if he had guessed it before meeting the dwarf face to face.
Frodo made his way down from the ledge outside the bedroom alcove. It was strange to think of either his elusive teacher or the Phantom of the Opera doing something as prosaic as sleeping...and certainly he was not sleeping now, seated instead at his organ and scribbling furiously at the sheets of music set there.
He was, however, much dressed-down from the night before, with no coat or gloves and a loosened cravat, his long hair pulled back into a low tail.
Heart beating hard and butterflies fluttering fast in his stomach, the hobbit approached him carefully, earning himself only a glance and a brief, quick smile before the dwarf’s attention returned to the music in front of him. Unsure of exactly what he was doing or what he wanted, Frodo stepped closer, resting a hand carefully on the Phantom’s shoulder. The dwarf did pause then, leaning back and closing his eyes in apparent relief at Frodo’s gentle touch along the uncovered part of his brow, soothing away the lines of concentration that creased it.
All of that was gone the moment Frodo summoned the courage to pull away the mask.
“Damn you!” the dwarf cried, pushing him away even as Frodo stumbled back in shock and horror. “You little rat! Is this what you wanted to see? Curse you!”
The terrible scarring (as if half of his face had been burnt mostly away) was now covered by the dwarf’s broad hand, but Frodo had seen enough. He held himself still and quiet, wide-eyed as the Opera Ghost ranted and raved in anger (or fear...?)
“Can you even dare to look or bear to think of me?” he whispered at last, anger quieting down into pleading. “Frodo, dearest Frodo...fear can turn to love, can it not? And if any could learn to see past this, past my monstrosity, it would be-” Some emotion Frodo couldn’t identify passed over his face too quickly to catch, and his voice hitched just briefly before he continued, “Surely it would be you? Oh, Frodo...”
The hobbit, getting carefully to his feet, said nothing. No words would come to him, and he wasn’t sure he could have spoken them aloud anyway, but he made himself step forward without hesitation, returning the mask to the dwarf’s outstretched hand. The Phantom replaced it on his face and rose, keeping his face turned away for a long moment before taking a deep breath and seeming to collect himself.
“Come, we must return. Undoubtedly those two fools who run my theater will be missing you.”
When he held out his hand again, Frodo took it.
--
“‘Mystery after Gala Night,’” Master Farmun read from the missive on his desk, “‘Mystery of the Tenor’s Flight.’ Goodness, these people have quite the imaginations, don’t they?”
“Damn them all. Are they all going to walk out on us?” complained Master Alfrid, sneering at the sheet sent by their informers working out on the streets.
“Don’t be ridiculous, Alfrid,” Farmun said, sitting back and taking another drink of his wine. “It’s all free publicity...and gossip is worth its weight in gold, as we well know.”
“But we barely have a cast...” Alfrid whined, trailing off as he saw the look on Farmun’s face.
“It seems you’ve got one too,” the larger man said with distaste, seeing the last note in Alfrid’s stack and waving his own with its unfamiliar and ominous raven seal. Alfrid hesitated, then opened the letter and read aloud: “Master Alfrid, last night went much better than would be supposed under new management. Naturally, Frodo enjoyed a great success, and his leading role was by far the best decision made regarding the Gala; we were hardly bereft when Master Otho left. The chorus was acceptable, and the dancers need work; I suggest you see to a new dancing instructor immediately. Try not to make the mistake of choosing yet another Elf.”
Able only to gape at this singular missive, Alfrid made no protest when Farmun shared his own: “Master Farmun, a brief reminder: my salary has not been paid. You may send it by return of post. Debtors are not appreciated in Dale, and I’m sure you would not want any hint of such a thing to affect your reputations here. I appreciate your prompt payment.”
The new owners of the Dale Opera House, lately of Esgaroth, stared at each other for a long, speechless moment.
“Who would have the gall to send such a thing?” Master Farmun burst out then, outraged. “These are both signed ‘O.G.’...”
“Who the hell is he?” Alfrid sneered, but the unwelcome answer dawned on them both in the next moment.
“Opera Ghost!”
“What sort of spectre needs money?” Farmun wanted to know, fortifying himself with another draught of wine.
“He’s clearly,” said Alfrid, heading to the side cupboard for a glass of his own, “quite insane!”
“No question there-”
The door burst open, and the new Master of Live Props rushed in.
“Where is he?” Sam Gamgee demanded, quite ferociously considering his usual demeanor.
“You mean Otho?” Alfrid asked automatically.
“I mean Mr. Frodo!” Gamgee replied heatedly. “Where is he?”
“How should we know?” Master Farmun wanted to know.
“You’re in charge around here, aren’t you?” the Halfling demanded. “He ain’t been home all night! And then after looking high and low for him, all I find is this note from you!”
“We didn’t send any notes,” Alfrid warned, sneering slightly. If they had, it certainly wouldn’t have been to a halfling stagehand. Some of those dancing girls, on the other hand...
“Who would it ‘ave come from, then, if not you?” Gamgee demanded, seemingly not to be cowed with the matter of Baggins’ supposed safety at stake. He thrust the letter towards them, and Farmun waved for Alfrid to fetch it for him. Alfrid did, grumbling under his breath. Why did he always have to be the one to get up and fetch things?
“‘Do not fear for Mr. Baggins,’” Farmun read, frowning, “‘the Spirit of Music has him under a wing. Do not attempt to ever see him again.’”
“You see? If you didn’t write that, then who did?”
The door burst open for the second time to admit Otho Sackville-Baggins and hangers-on, led by his wife Lobelia, who brandished (Alfrid rolled his eyes) yet another of the damned notes.
“Where is he?” Lobelia demanded, Otho following just behind with a tremendous scowl on his face.
“Ah, welcome back,” Farmun said smoothly, actually rising from his chair. “Wine?”
“Your new stagehand, where is he?” Lobelia snarled. “Where is the hobbit who sent this disgusting letter? You!” She pointed at Gamgee, who gaped at her in confusion. Alfrid narrowed his eyes, trying to decide if it was faked or not. The halfling seemed honest enough, but it was the honest-seeming ones you had to watch out for.
“What are you talking about? Why would I have been sending notes to the leading tenor?”
“Why indeed?” asked Otho, sneering at Gamgee.
“You dare to tell us that this isn’t the letter you sent?” Lobelia shrilled, disbelieving.
“And just what am I supposed to have written?” Gamgee demanded, still standing his ground. Lobelia slapped it into his hand scornfully and drew back to her husband’s side.
“‘Your days at the Dale Opera House are numbered. Frodo Baggins will be singing in your place tonight. Your fate, should you attempt to take his place, will not be a kind one.’”
Both managers gaped for a moment too long, giving Lobelia time to speak up again.
“It’s quite obvious who sent this: this stagehand that the little upstart has taken for a lover!”
Gamgee’s face darkened into a scowl, strangely disturbing compared to the halfling’s normally cheerful expression. “Now you see here, Lobelia Sackville-Baggins! You keep a civil tongue in your head when speaking of Mr. Frodo! I certainly didn’t write any nasty letters to no one, least of all you!”
Lobelia and Otho, who were rapidly going red with anger at being scolded by a mere stagehand (Alfrid couldn’t blame them; the temerity of the halfling!), were fortunately cut off when Farmun quickly downed the rest of his wine and then stepped out from behind the desk.
“There have been far too many of these notes for my taste,” he declared, and Alfrid nodded in emphatic agreement. “And far too many of them have been about the young Mr. Baggins. Why, we’ve hardly heard any other names since we came but his-”
“Frodo Baggins has returned.”
They all turned to see Bilbo Baggins standing calmly in the doorway. Alfrid immediately disliked the careful blankness of his face, and indeed had disliked the little stage manager since they had arrived. The older Baggins didn’t give so much as an inch within his own domain, and did not seem very impressed with either of his new masters.
“Well, I trust he’s had his romp and gotten it out of his system,” Alfrid sneered.
“Can I see him, Mr. Bilbo, please?” Gamgee gasped, worry overcoming his previous anger.
Something flickered over Baggins’ face too quickly to catch, but his eyes were fixed on Alfrid and his voice was colder when he next spoke. “No. He is in need of rest and to be alone for a time. He is unharmed, Samwise, I promise. He will see you later.”
Gamgee sagged with both relief and disappointment. Otho and his wife looked about ready to boil over again.
Alfrid and Farmun glanced at each other. Neither had missed the note in Baggins’ hand, and neither of them wanted to deal with it. Farmun shook his head sharply when the halfling started to hold it up, and turned away.
Baggins narrowed his eyes at Farmun, then raised a questioning eyebrow at Alfrid. Alfrid scoffed and waved the halfling away. He’d had quite enough of that nonsense for a lifetime!
The halfling stage manager shrugged, then turned and went back out the door. Alfrid had the odd and unpleasant sensation that the shrug was a strongly implied “on your head be it.”
He ignored the feeling, and joined Farmun in trying to lure their lead tenor back to work.
--
Bilbo crept silently up the stairs as the sound of Frodo and Sam’s voices faded below him. He couldn’t be sure, but he suspected...
Coming to the still-open doorway leading onto the Opera House’s roof, he sank down onto the top step, holding his breath, not quite daring to actually look out in case-
“You will curse the day you did not do all that the Phantom asked of you!”
Even now, even in anger, even focused so completely on another...that deep voice did things to Bilbo’s soul that he dared not think on save in the darkest hours of the night.
The memory of Frodo and Sam’s voices twined in song came back to him, and he couldn’t stop himself from singing softly, just barely above a breath, “Let me be your freedom, let daylight dry your tears. I’m here, with you, beside you, to guard you and to guide you...”
But no voice answered him, and Bilbo curled in on himself, his hand pressed over his heart as though that would help to stop the pain.
