Actions

Work Header

Never Be a Day

Chapter 4: Act Two

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

He looked magnificent.

Bilbo was frozen in place on the main staircase of the Opera House, staring up at the imposing figure in red that stood above them all. The music and dancing fell away into terrified silence as the attendees at the Masquerade realized that the Opera Ghost had decided to grace them with his presence.

“Have you missed me?” the dwarf asked, his low, amused voice shivering down Bilbo’s spine. “Did you think that I had left for good? No matter. I have written you an opera!”

The score was tossed at the feet of Masters Farmun and Alfrid, and he continued down the stairs, mocking Otho and Lobelia as well as the owners. As if that alone hadn’t been enough to make Bilbo’s knees weak, the brief, searing glance of blue eyes meeting his from behind the elaborate dragon mask was certainly sufficient to finish the job.

But it was only a passing breath, and then the dwarf tore his gaze away and was looking to another-

To Frodo, standing wide-eyed at the bottom of the stairs and seeming torn between fear and adoration.

Bilbo, heart hammering and stomach twisting sickly, closed his eyes and had to look away. He was grateful for the chaos following the Phantom’s retreat and Sam’s reckless attempt to follow him, for rescuing the lad gave him something else to concentrate on, something else to do.

Torn between fear for Frodo, longing, and jealousy, the hobbit needed every precious moment of distraction that he could get.

--

“You’ll do as we say!” Master Farmun thundered at Frodo, and not even Sam’s outrage was enough to quiet him. “This might be our only chance to catch this trouble-making dwarf, and I’ll not have it ruined just because you’ve gotten squeamish about him. You were happy enough to let him tumble you before.”

Frodo swallowed down nausea and shook his head mutely, unable to find any more words. He had pleaded his case already, but even with Sam and much of the backstage crew on his side, their words meant little to the Opera House’s owners now that they saw him as bait to catch the Phantom with. As if he wasn’t likely listening in on them right at this moment, hearing all of their plans and making his own accordingly....

The rest of the crowd in the room had descended into a shouting match with everyone trying to make themselves heard, and Frodo couldn’t stand the noise anymore. He left the room, with Sam close on his heels.

“I’m sorry, Frodo,” the other hobbit said softly, pulling him aside, “but they’ll not listen to the likes of me. I’m just a gardener, after all.”

Frodo smiled, sad and fond all at once. “You’re much more than that, Sam, at least to me. You know that.”

“I do,” Sam said, and smiled his own shy, joyful smile at the thought of the promises they had made each other. It was a delight to watch, and eased a little bit of Frodo’s fear...but not enough.

The door opened again and Bilbo slipped out of the room as well, his face carefully blank as it always was when the Phantom was brought up-

Frodo didn’t know why it hadn’t occurred to him before.

“Bilbo!” he called, stepping out of the shadows as the older hobbit passed them both without seeing them. “Bilbo, please-”

His uncle froze, before turning to them with that same blank-faced look. “I don’t know more than anyone else,” he said stiffly, but broke off at the sight of Frodo and Sam’s faces.

“That’s not true, Mr. Bilbo,” Sam put in apologetically, “and we all know it. Please, can’t you help us? Can’t you help Frodo?”

Bilbo, clearly struggling with something, turned his face away to hide whatever expression he could no longer conceal by will alone.

“Very well,” he whispered after a long moment. “Come with me.”

The older hobbit puttered once they reached his room, fussing with the lamps and clearly delaying the conversation. Frodo sensed that Bilbo needed time to put his thoughts in order, but was not intending to try and avoid talking to them altogether.

“You will both have heard stories of the dragon attack,” he began once they were all finally sitting down. The younger hobbits both nodded. Although the attack was long past, the story was still told frequently, about how Lord Girion of Dale had followed the dragon into the Mountain with his last Black Arrow and slain the beast with the help of the Dwarves of Erebor. “Before my time, of course, but many were injured and misplaced by the attack, and there was chaos in the aftermath. Those who feed on the misfortune of others unfortunately thrive in such times.”

Bilbo took a slow breath, frowning at his clasped hands before slowly beginning the main part of his tale. “I do not know who he was before, only that half of his face had been badly burned in the dragon’s attack on Erebor. He was caught by slave traders, and sold into one of the traveling freak shows that you will see on occasion. They left Dale and wandered Middle Earth for many years, I believe, before returning to the city here. I was still young myself then, and had only recently joined the Opera. Some of the others wanted to see the show, and I got dragged along.

“I remember how they laughed.” Bilbo’s voice dropped, old rage not fully concealed under the softness. “Everyone laughed to see the ‘mutilated dwarf,’ and they jeered and threw things into the cage at him. It made me sick. It still makes me sick, to think on it now.”

Frodo swallowed down an ill feeling of his own, imagining it all too clearly. He clutched Sam’s hand a little tighter, and was glad when Sam squeezed comfortingly back.

“But I think that they had made a mistake in returning to Dale with him,” Bilbo continued his story. “I think that he knew where he was, and realized that he was close to home. I was the last one out of the tent that day...and so I was the only one to see him attack his captor, breaking the chains that held him and using them to strangle the man.” The hobbit’s voice and gaze went distant again with remembered anger. “I would have helped him, I think, if I’d been able. As it was...”

Bilbo sighed, and his expression eased into something sadder. “As it was, I was only able to help him escape afterwards, and to avoid the pursuit which followed.”

“He was weak, ill from his long mistreatment and the terrible burns which never had been treated properly to begin with. I knew of a place where he could hide, near the Opera, and I brought him food and clothes and medicine, sneaking out at night to spend what hours I could with him. We- We talked a lot, for there was little else to do as he recovered his strength, and though he would not speak of his own past, he was happy to hear about life in Dale and whatever news I had of the Mountain. I spoke of the Opera, and he told me of his love of music, and that he hoped to attend one day. He was kind enough to give me tales of the larger world, though they must have been tainted by his own memories
of being trapped by that horrible band of Men. He was intelligent, and well-spoken, and made me laugh, and I was even able to make him laugh, a time or two, and he had the most beautiful smile...”

Frodo’s heart ached, as he suddenly realized the direction his uncle’s story was going. Bilbo looked up at them with a hesitant smile, his hands spreading in a helpless gesture, trying to encompass all that he had felt.

“We never spoke of it directly, but I believe that he meant to go back to the Mountain once he was strong enough. Before he was well, though, the mob from the traveling show found him. I don’t know how, and I worried for many years that they had somehow tracked me as I went to see him. But I later learned that there was a price on his head, for killing the Man who was his keeper, and I think others had been searching for him in hopes of claiming the reward.

“Fortunately, their desire for revenge made them stupid, and rather than just kill him outright and be done with it, they tried to set his face on fire again.” Bilbo shuddered at whatever memory lingered in his mind, and Frodo felt a thread of nausea curl through his stomach again, remembering what lingered behind the mask that the Phantom wore. “They partially succeeded, but fortunately I arrived in time to stop them and to get him away. The damage had been done, though, and was beyond my limited healing skills, and so I-” The older hobbit swallowed. “I brought him to a healer. Of course, in doing so I exposed him to the authorities and he was put into custody for questioning about the death at the traveling show. In his pain and fever, I do not think that he fully understood that I was trying to save him, and knew only that I had betrayed him to the authorities. He screamed and cursed at me as they took him away, and I could only let them do it, for he would have died without proper care and I- I couldn’t let that happen.”

Bilbo’s expression when he looked up at them again was pleading, begging for understanding. “He was- He meant too much to me by then, you see, and I don’t know how he felt, but the thought of him dying....” He shook his head sharply, eyes closing in pain. “I just couldn’t.”

“How did he come to be in the Opera House, then?” Frodo questioned softly when Bilbo did not speak again.

“Oh,” his uncle said, and nodded. “Well, I...helped him to escape the city jail, once he was healed enough to move safely. He followed, but refused to speak to me. The caverns below the Opera House seemed like the best place for him to stay for a time while he finished healing. I showed him the way, he spoke once to say that he never wanted to see my face again...and that was that. He made himself a home there, as you have seen.”

“But why did he never go back to the Mountain, Mr. Bilbo?” Sam asked then.

“I don’t know,” Bilbo admitted quietly. “I think that the second attack, and the accusations against him for killing to escape his enslavement, may have broken his spirit past the point of feeling as though he could go home. Or perhaps that was never his intention to begin with – as I said, we did not speak of it directly. Instead, he took advantage of the space and resources here to develop his talents. He is an architect of great skill, as well as a composer, a master harpist in his own right, and a magician and a smith...truly, a genius.”

“I think that genius might have since turned to madness,” Sam said, gently, and pain flashed across Bilbo’s face as he looked away.

Frodo didn’t know what he was feeling. Pity and sympathy and horror and fear and love and a thousand things between. The Phantom had given him so much, taught him so much...but was now trying to ensnare Frodo as surely as he had once been ensnared, and Frodo did not think he could forgive him that, nor the attacks against Sam and the rest of the cast and crew. That no one had actually died yet seemed to be based on whatever scraps of goodness the dwarf had left in his soul...but those were dwindling fast.

“I have done you a great wrong, Frodo,” Bilbo said softly, interrupting his spinning thoughts, “and I am sorry for it. I am sorry that this has fallen on you now. In the beginning, I- Well, I knew that he would teach you well, none better, and I thought that letting you learn to make the most of your voice and talents was the best thing I could do for you...but I should never have let it go this far. I should never have let my own feelings – my own fear and jealousy – get in the way of keeping you safe. Even if you cannot forgive me for it, know that I do care for you, my lad, for both of you, and that I am sorry.”

“It must have been hard,” Frodo realized, understanding now how painful the Phantom’s interest in himself must have been for Bilbo, who obviously still loved the dwarf deeply in spite of everything.

Could Frodo blame him for that? He might have loved the Phantom himself, if the circumstances had been different.

“That’s no excuse-”

“I forgive you, Uncle,” Frodo said softly, waiting steadily until Bilbo returned his gaze, and smiling wryly when the older hobbit’s eyes shimmered with tears. “And I will forgive you all the more if you’ll help us now. You know a great deal more about him and about what he has built down below than you’ve ever let on, right?”

“Surely with your help, Mr. Bilbo,” Sam put in then, seeing Bilbo hesitate, “we can make sure it comes out all right for everyone?”

Bilbo swallowed. “He will not want to see me...”

“I think,” Frodo said carefully, thinking back to everything he had seen during the one night he had spent down in the Phantom’s lair, “that perhaps he misses you more than you know. He has a- a strange shrine down there, with a very detailed carving on the wall of- well, I had thought it was of me when I first saw it, but now I’m not so sure. I’ve thought about it a lot since then, and I think that maybe it was actually meant to be you. Have you truly had no other signs that he has forgiven you?”

The older hobbit was frowning, but it was a thoughtful frown. “It is- It is possible that he might at least be willing to speak to me. But it is you that he lo-”

“I think that he loves the idea of a hobbit who admires him and who has not betrayed him,” Frodo interrupted, still thinking quickly, “more than he feels any real love for me.” The Phantom’s intentions were hard to pin down, even now. There had definitely been elements of seduction and romance in his interactions with Frodo...but only to the point of bringing Frodo to him and keeping him within that orbit. That the Phantom was interested in having Frodo share his bed in a carnal way had never come up.

This whole story seemed to become more convoluted by the day, and little of it made sense to Frodo, now that he was stepping back and trying to look at it with some mental distance. His own feelings for the Phantom were still too complex to untangle, but he was nevertheless certain that he wanted to be with Sam and no other, and that was the only thing that he really needed to be sure of right now.

“Will you help us, Uncle Bilbo? Please?”

Bilbo, seemingly having come to his own conclusions, sighed and sat back in his chair. He seemed both relieved and resigned, but he nodded without hesitation. “Yes, my lad, I most certainly will.”

“Thank you, Mr. Bilbo!” Sam grinned, and Frodo leaned into him, grateful when Sam’s strong arm came around his shoulders. Bilbo’s smile softened and became fond as he looked at the two of them.

“It is only what I should have done from the beginning. Now, since the plans of our dear managers are laughable at best and undoubtedly already known to our friendly Opera Ghost, let’s come up with something better, shall we?”

--

The pain and betrayal in the Phantom’s face when Frodo removed his mask in front of the entire Opera House was something that he hoped to never see again for as long as he lived.

The pain of it cut deep into his own heart, even against the glad relief that Bilbo’s plan clearly remained unknown to the Phantom. He had known of everything Masters Farmun and Alfrid planned, of course, but that he did not know of this meant that they might still have a chance.

When the Opera Ghost dropped them through the stage and down into his cavernous kingdom, Frodo held on and prayed that it wouldn’t take long for Bilbo and Sam to follow.

--

Sam got there first.

“Let him go!” his love pleaded through the bars of the gate. “Please, let him go! Can’t you see you’re hurting him?”

“Your lover makes a passionate plea,” the Phantom sneered at Frodo.

“Sam, it’s useless-”

“I love him!” Sam insisted. “Does that mean nothing to you? I love him! Show a little compassion-”

“The world showed no compassion to me!” The Phantom’s furious snarl silenced them both for a second, and he regained his composure quickly. “But please, Master Gamgee, do come in.”

The gate rose slowly and Sam hurried inside, wading through the chest-high water as best he could. The Phantom started down into the water himself, leaving Frodo back on the shore. Behind Sam, the gate began to lower again.

“Welcome, then, to my kingdom. Did you think that I would harm him?” He waded closer to Sam, who set his face in a determined expression and came on. “Why should I make Frodo pay for the sins which are yours?”

In a movement too quick to follow, the Phantom had thrown his lasso up out of the water, catching Sam unawares and binding him swiftly to the gate.

“No!” Frodo cried, desperately starting into the water himself as the Phantom’s noose tightened around Sam’s neck. None of this was part of the plan. Where was Bilbo?

“Now watch your back! Now raise your hand to the level of your eyes!” the Opera Ghost taunted. “There is nothing that can save you now,” he jerked the rope cruelly, “except perhaps Frodo.”

Frodo froze, ignoring Sam’s frantic headshakes and choked pleas for him to run. He refused to leave Sam now.

“Start a new life with me,” the Phantom said harshly, turning back toward Frodo. “If you love him so, then buy his freedom with it, and remain with me. If you do, then I will let him go. If not, I will kill him now.” All of the pain and anger and betrayal was back on his face, and Frodo felt helpless against it, helpless when presented with two such terrifying options. “This is your choice. This is the point of no return-”

“No, Thorin.”

Frodo almost sagged to his knees in relief.

The Phantom’s (Thorin’s?) head whipped frantically to the side at the sound of Bilbo’s voice, hiding the ruined half of his face from the older hobbit, as if he could not bear for Bilbo to see it. His jaw worked silently, but aside from his harsh breaths, no sound came from him. His blue eyes stared wildly out into the cavern, emotions flashing too quickly over his face for Frodo to follow.

From the high ledge where he had appeared, Bilbo began to slowly work his way down and around the cavern.

“Let Sam go, Thorin, please. He and Frodo don’t need to be a part of this.” Frodo risked a quick glance at his uncle. Bilbo’s calm was mostly a front, if the look in his eyes was any indication, but it was a good front.

The dwarf still had not turned his head. He seemed to flinch away a little at the request, and the rope did slacken in his hands, just enough that Sam was no longer choking for breath. Frodo nearly darted forward to seize it entirely from him, but was too afraid to disturb this fragile stalemate.

“Why are you here?”

The dwarf’s – Thorin’s – first words since Bilbo’s arrival were harsh, but there was a desperate, pleading undertone to them that Frodo knew he was not imagining.

“I’m here for you, Thorin,” Bilbo said, closer now. He glanced at the carved mural on the way past, and his mask of calm slipped briefly but was back again the next moment as he worked his way past the great organ and down to where Frodo was standing. “I’m here because this has gone on long enough, and because I miss you.”

Thorin flinched again, and the rope slackened more, only to tighten again as something ugly and pained crossed his features. “Don’t lie to me. You betrayed me-”

“I was trying to save your life!” Bilbo shouted, his hands curling into fists. “I couldn’t help you, and you were dying, and I had to do something-”

“So you betrayed me to those who hunted me for daring to free myself from slavery, and for what? For me to live a cursed life alone down here?”

“That,” said Bilbo, his voice terribly calm once more, “was never my intention. Look at me, Thorin.”

The dwarf jerked his head away again, his unruly long hair further hiding the ruined half of his face.

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, steady and coaxing, “look at me.”

Still, the dwarf would not turn, and Frodo could no longer see enough of his face to know what he might be thinking. He and Sam both remained silent and still, scarcely daring to breathe lest they interrupt whatever was happening here.

“Let me be your shelter, let me be your light. You’re safe, no-one will find you,” Bilbo’s clear tenor, a little rusty but true, was a shock to everyone in the cavern. “Your fears are far behind you...”

Even through the almost-unpleasant jolt of hearing Sam’s song for him from so many months ago on his uncle’s lips, Frodo still did not move, and for a long, aching moment there was utter silence.

Then, just as Bilbo’s face was beginning to crumble into despair, a deep, beautiful bass voice took up the next words.

“All I want is freedom, a world with no more night...and you, always beside me, to hold me and to hide me...” Slowly, Thorin let the rope slide free of his hands, and began to turn hesitantly toward where Bilbo stood at the edge of the lake, joy beginning to light the older hobbit’s face.

“Then say you’ll share with me one love, one lifetime,” Bilbo pleaded, “let me lead you from your solitude... Say you need me with you here, beside you...anywhere you go, let me go too...”

Stunned by the open love and joy on Bilbo’s face, Thorin began to wade back toward the shore, his movements halting and unsure, but growing in confidence with his voice. “Say you’ll share with me one love, one lifetime...say the word and I will follow you...”

Bilbo held out his hand to the dwarf as he neared, and they sang on together, “Share each day with me, each night, each morning...”

“Say you love me,” Thorin pleaded as he took Bilbo’s hand, falling to his knees at the hobbit’s feet.

“You know I do,” Bilbo whispered, caressing Thorin’s face, both sides, gently with his other hand.

“Love me,” they murmured together as Bilbo leaned down, “that’s all I ask of you...”

Frodo came back to himself as they kissed, and could finally tear his eyes away. Immediately, he turned and continued across the lake to help Sam free from the ropes, though his intended had already managed to work his way free from a couple of the knots. Pulling the hated noose over Sam’s head and tossing it away, Frodo kissed him as soon as Sam was free, and slumped gratefully into the other hobbit’s strong embrace.

When they stopped, they looked back to find Bilbo and Thorin still wrapped up in each other on the shore, barely parting from their kisses long enough to exchange low words that the two younger hobbits couldn’t make out.

A distant echo of voices pulled Frodo’s attention away, though, and he strained to hear.

“Track down this monster,” came the faint chant of a mob, “he must be found!”

“You must go,” Thorin said then, pulling away from Bilbo as the sounds reached him as well. “You must leave me-”

“Frodo, Sam, take the boat and go,” Bilbo said calmly, refusing to let go of the dwarf’s hands. “If they take the left-hand passage out beyond the gate, that will lead them away from the crowd, won’t it?”

Thorin stared at Bilbo, but nodded slowly. “Bilbo...”

“If you think that I am leaving you now,” the older hobbit said pointedly, “or ever again, then I advise you to reconsider.”

“It’s probably best to listen to him,” Frodo offered, hesitantly.

“Mr. Bilbo generally knows what’s best,” Sam chipped in, obviously still disgruntled over his near-strangling, but still willing to encourage whatever was happening between Thorin and Bilbo.

Thorin turned and blinked at them, as though he had largely forgotten they were there. Frodo met his gaze determinedly, and the dwarf’s eyes softened slightly as they looked at him.

“Frodo, I-” he stopped, voice rough, obviously not knowing what words would be right, after everything that had passed between them.

I admire you. I did love you, in a way. I will miss you. I will miss your music. I’m sorry for hurting you.

Frodo felt rather all of those things himself, so he let the wry smile curl his mouth, and nodded. Then he turned back to Sam, who had (with some trepidation) gotten the boat ready and was waiting for him. Looking at his intended, Frodo felt his smile bloom into a full, joyful grin, which Sam returned easily. Beside them, the gate began to rise so that they could slip away before the mob from the theater above arrived.

Looking back, Frodo hesitated. “Will you be all right?” he asked Bilbo.

His uncle nodded. “I will. Keep each other safe and happy, my lads.”

“We will, Mr. Bilbo,” Sam promised, and Bilbo shooed them off, smiling as he leaned back into Thorin’s embrace where the dwarf had wrapped himself around the shorter hobbit.

“You keep each other safe and happy too!” Frodo called, and they both waved. He turned away to take up another pole to help Sam navigate the tricky water-filled corridors.

He looked back just once more, right before a bend would take them out of sight of the main cavern.

Bilbo and Thorin were both already gone.

Feeling a little melancholy at the fact that he would probably never see either his uncle or his teacher ever again, Frodo took a deep breath and set himself to looking ahead.

After all, he had a long, happy life with Sam to look forward to, and hopefully (in spite of everything) a successful career as well.

“Say you’ll share with me one love, one lifetime,” he sang softly, and could sense Sam’s enormous grin even though they both kept their eyes on the route ahead.

“Say the word and I will follow you,” Sam continued, in his rough but pleasant voice.

They slipped away through the kingdom beneath the Opera House, singing softly together and looking ahead to brighter days.

Notes:

(We did our Tolkien marathon and it was amazing: all filmed versions of The Hobbit and Lord of the Rings in 50 hours. I feel like it's been much longer than a week since I last posted, but it was totally worth it.)

Anyway, here is Act Two! As usual, lyrics and some dialogue were either taken straight or borrowed with slight alterations from the original musical.

It's probably clear by now, but part of this was my exploring a dynamic that at least gets hinted at in the play (and shown a bit more clearly in the movie), namely, Madame Giry's feelings for the Phantom. They of course go completely unacknowledged by him in the original story...but it has always intrigued me as a potential alternate version of the story. So. I hope that isn't too sacrilegious to PotO fans. >.> Hopefully this covers everything satisfactorily, and you like the ending!

Short epilogue next week, and then something new! Comments/kudos are much appreciated. :)