Chapter Text
“What happened last night!?”
“Were you really knocked out by a potato?”
“How did you know Bofur’s song?”
“That’s right, ye just started singin’ with me! Don’t get me wrong, you were astounding!”
“And your head lass? It looked like a hard fall, it did!"
“Did those elven healers fix you up?”
“But then, where were you all morning?”
“Was it worse than it looked?”
“Are you going to die!?”
“Whoa, whoa, whoa!” I brought up my hands as a barrier from the frenetic dwarrows encompassing and drowning me in their rapidly enounced, numerous inquiries, spoken one over the other. “... Whoa.”
Once my ears were no longer assaulted, I did a brief survey of my surroundings.
The guest quarters were organized in two separate corridors of multiple rooms that began right after the sort of entry hall or balcony we were currently in. This facility had obviously been utilized as a shared space for the company, and judging by the ground filled with bedrolls, all preferred sleeping as a tight unit as much as they could.
Kili, after dragging me inside forcefully, was part of the swarming dwarrows around me. His brother stood more to the side, arms crossed and in a semi-confused, semi-concerned position. One he seemed to share with Dwalin on his right side. Beside them, Nori was mindlessly playing with a pocketknife and acting as if nothing short of Aulë entering the room would surprise him.
Neither the dwarf king nor his burglar were present. I figured Bilbo would most likely be exploring, as I had the occasion to do, and Thorin would be brooding somewhere, as usual.
When an awkward silence took place, I sighed in anticipation of the weariness this conversation was about to cause me. Immediately, I was pushed suddenly yet somewhat carefully onto an armchair near the fireplace. A light blanket was deposited on my shoulders from whom I assumed was Dori, based on the motherly, protective gesture. Oin appeared in front of me before I could blink, taking hold of my head and patting the top part of my head insistently, despite my hands trying to push him away. I’d already been confirmed out of danger by Elrond, this was unnecessary. “Oín—”
“This will take longer if you don’t stop squirming," seeing as I kept struggling, he admonished me gently, “Need to be sure you’ve not cracked your head open or managed to cause any damage.”
“But I’m—”
“I’m sure you may feel alright, lass, it does not mean you are. Head wounds can be tricky,”
“I know!” I said louder to make sure I was heard. “But I’ve talked to Lord Elrond, he said it was fine.”
“An elvish healer—” I cut Gloin’s disapproving comment before he could utter it and turned to address all those in the room. “—and the best of his kind!”
A few seconds of silence passed until a grunt came from Dwalin. Whether he approved or not, I couldn’t tell. “Hmph. Just be careful.” Those words worked like a charm in lifting the tense atmosphere and unbinding everyone’s voices. Thank goodness there were no more off-putting comments about elves and their ways, only kind reprimands and some pats on the back.
After the initial raucous that my presence caused eased off, all dwarves returned to their previous activities, Nori and Bofur inviting me to a card game along with Gloin and Dwalin. The last person, I did not expect to partake in such games, but I had suspicions he merely wanted to keep Nori from cheating or attempting to.
I won the first game thanks to beginner’s luck and most likely the intentions of the other players to go relatively easy on me. Then the level of difficulty increased along with the level of fun. Fíli ended up joining us, teaming up with his brother, causing Gloín to complain and teaming up with his brother, which of course made Dwalin do the same. And Nori attempted too, but Dori rejected the request before he could try, which the latter rebutted by affirming he wanted to ask Ori in the first place anyway. The only ones keeping themselves from joining the general silliness were Bofur, too busy laughing, and Bombur, who’d already won five turns in a row and didn’t need anyone’s help to beat our asses.
I feared a repeat of last night when cards began to be thrown around. Even Ori—who’d been mostly knitting away from us—had to cover from a few projectiles.
Sometimes I truly wondered if these dwarrows had any sense. Not an hour had passed since I had been berated for not being careful enough!
Luckily, the front door opened before Kíli could let go of the chair he held up high in the air. From my position hidden under the table (obviously the best survival strategy), the furry feet were enough to guess who’d entered.
This person was soon joined by another, bigger figure whose loud sigh I immediately recognized.
The smaller being marched into the room full of conviction and shouted for everyone to hear, surprising even Oín. “Now, what does this mean? Are the lot of you not capable of acting civilized if we’re not watching you? And you Erell, ” With bad timing, I raised my head at the sound of my name, “What in Yavanna’s name are you doing here?”
“Alright so— I can explain.” I began with an already nervous tone. Thorin and Bilbo’s reactions concerning last night's events were the ones I apprehended the most— because I had no idea what they would be.
The company's, I had anticipated, at the very least.
In Bilbo’s case, I’d seen his face of pure horror and defeat back then. But it seemed to me a tiny, teeny smile of amusement had emerged on his face at some point. Then again, the vegetable raid might have confused my memories together.
As for the other unknown in this equation, well… let’s say I had a fifty-fifty chance. The dwarf king would either be somewhat approving, as had been my first thought, while keeping a measured opinion, to appear diplomatically correct, or he might not care at all. But surely, I tried to reassure myself, Thorin could not react too badly. He didn't even have to know all the details of what happened. If he accused me of sympathizing with the elves, I could always say I had no choice regarding the circumstances.
"Forget it," I blurted out finally, noticing I had failed to add to my sentence and that the silence in the room was getting uncomfortably long, "I can't explain, I'm just-"
My gaze crossed Thorin's. Time stopped.
It was cold. So very cold. A glare I had only ever seen Thorin use with those he deemed enemies. I wish I were kidding when I say the look he gave me sent a shiver down my spine and all of a sudden my breath was stuck in my throat and I couldn't speak.
Immediately, I looked down, not that anyone had seen the cause for it since Thorin had been standing off—beside Bilbo—and all eyes were on me.
"I..." How stupid. How completely foolish I had been. My brain couldn't function enough to reason and was stuck to only wonder over the fashion with which I could have provoked his anger, his wrath to this extent.
Looking back, I probably should have taken a second to calm myself down, breathe, and think. Perhaps I would've avoided the upcoming events.
But in my defense, well I had no defense. My mind, seeing what I fiercely believed being a look of plain disapproval, of scorn, coming from a person I wished to earn the approval of...
Unsurprisingly I panicked. I simply couldn't figure out what I had done, but it didn't matter. If Thorin Oakenshield was mad at you, you should question every act and deed done in his presence. At the very least, if you did not beg on your knees for forgiveness first.
Thankfully I had some dignity left (that's not true, my body had just frozen up entirely) and refrained from doing anything.
Instead, I wondered what I had misunderstood, what I had misread in his attitude, in his character, and tried to voice that interrogation, but all I got out was an accumulation of gibberish and unintelligible phrases.
From the corner of my eyes, I could see the other's confused expressions. My heart felt like it was going to beat out of my chest, its rhythm getting faster and faster. A nervous laugh escaped me, the pressure felt too high, but why? Was I simply too scared to get in trouble?
What if this was the end? My brain supplied to me in a frenzy. Did he find my disruption insolent? Disrespectful?
The rational side of my brain screamed that the dwarven king wouldn't take offense to this type of situation, but that voice went unheard.
"Yes?" Bilbo, sensing I would not get farther by myself, added. "Was there something you wanted to say?" Oh no. Was it just me, or did he sound accusatory as well? Obviously, he wouldn't have enjoyed being a part of what happened. Had his view of me deteriorated to the point any hope of future friendship was lost?
Call me dramatic, but it's not every day you get an opportunity to be friends with the Bilbo Baggins. His approval meant a lot to me, perhaps even more than his future husband's.
Feeling as if the ground was going to come apart beneath my feet, I let out a hurried "I'm sorry!" and relied on my fight or flight instinct to, well, flee.
Not even looking back, I ran from the scene, leaving everyone befuddled. I left the rooms, slowed my pace to fast walking, and stopped somewhere in the gardens. I spotted a lovely white bench filled with intricate designs and sat down, though I wasn’t out of breath at all. I simply needed a minute or two to process things and what I had just done.
Finding my courage might declare itself to be a trickier task than I originally thought. If I couldn’t even face my allies, what would I do in front of real enemies?
I hadn't realized it fully, or I wrongfully thought I did, but Bilbo's feats and shows of bravery in the face of danger were truly remarkable. It's easy to feel as if you could do everything others do, as if gathering enough will is effortless. Truth is, when you have not been trained to face hardships, the inner strength required to resist all self-preservation instincts is tremendous. Bilbo possessed such a strength.
Conflicted to the very pit of my being, I was unable to know if I did, too. I had dreamed of adventure, of losing myself in a foreign world, and suddenly all those dreams did not only live through my imagination. They had become a reality I found myself unable to face, as an inexperienced teenager with little to no skills.
Although another part of me supplied, Bilbo himself was—is—in quite a similar situation, wasn't he? Dreaming and fantasizing about quests and wonderful adventures with no intention of ever acting on them until it was forced upon him.
And so, he found his courage when the people he had grown to care for and admire found themselves in vulnerable positions. While the road would surely be harder for me, (since my knowledge of this world, however advanced couldn't possibly compare with anyone truly born in it, let alone an ambitious, map-loving hobbit), it did not mean I could, did not mean I had the right to give up so early in the adventure.
Some people were counting on me after all. Thorin and his nephews, though they weren't aware of it yet. Little Estel, whose friendship I had gained. If I strategized well enough once the time came, I might even be able to save other lives, in the midst of the battle or through small acts of coercion. A butterfly's ability to flap its wings and alter major decisions that would be taken in the future.
Indirectly, I could even come to Bilbo's aid. What broke me at the end of The Hobbit, not counting the dead, was the effect this whole thing had had on him. Broken, he came back. In heart and soul. Thanks to that foul ring, the rest of his life would not even have the benefit of being worryless.
Yes, I assured myself, this was only the beginning. To lose faith now would be futile.
Full of resolutions, I clenched fists and breathed in slowly before releasing, to regain my whole composure. It was time to go back and demand explanations, explain myself while at it, but mostly defend my case. What I did last night could not mark the end of my journey. Not so soon, I wouldn't permit it.
I'll convince Thorin if it's the last thing I do.
As soon as I thought those words, as if summoned, the company's leader appeared in front of me. This was not a good day for my heart, which almost jumped out of my throat.
It must have been clear on my face since Thorin's expression immediately became apologetic. "My apologies. Did I scare you?"
Shaking my head, I reassured him, "No, I was a bit surprised but that's my fault for being scatterbrained," His earlier scowl came back to mind, and I stood up straighter. Outer expression much more serious to hopefully convey a double meaning, "Such carelessness will not happen again."
A long minute passed without either of us saying anything to fill the silence. I could see Thorin's face darken by the second. My whole body shouted for me to escape, leave this tense atmosphere as far as I could but I resolved it not to falter this time.
Resilience paid, for after what felt like hours, Thorin's eyes quit scrutinizing the stone pillars. He sighed deeply before asking.
"May I sit down?" I nodded numbly. I had not been expecting any politeness of any form, but I didn't dare reject it.
This battle-hardened king sat down, then, with a random girl in the middle of a flower garden. Moreover, an Elven garden. Never did I wish for a camera more than during this very moment.
At least I kept that mental picture to myself.
I waited for him to talk. And he did, after a few minutes I regarded as spent searching for the right words. I let him have them without interrupting, my sympathy high for that matter.
"First of all, I wish to clear up whatever misunderstanding I may have caused." Misunderstanding? I was confused as to what he meant. I'd found the situation I was in very self-explanatory and not at all prone to ambiguity. "It appears you have taken my acts of indifference as resentment I possessed towards you."
Was it not? I argued internally, I wouldn't call glaring at someone this harshly indifference.
Thankfully, I held my tongue this time.
"It wasn't," Thorin added as an afterthought, almost reading mine. "And it is the second reason for my presence here."
I was clueless as to what he would say. Altogether lost in a conversation that had stopped being logical the moment he sat down.
The dwarf king went on, "I have a..." He straightened in his seat. My nerves were being tested. "... Confession to make. I must address this matter and I sincerely hope you will have enough kindness in your heart to not let this affect your judgment of our kind," Wow, spoken like a true politician.
"I was the one who-"
"Threw the potato?"
"Why—, yes, but how—"
I had no idea. I truly didn't, but in the span it took him to pronounce his last sentence, or start to, something flashed in my mind. Thorin's next words. I knew them a few seconds before they were uttered and instantly repeated them out loud.
A wave of panic began building up. Once again, I did not have control over my actions.
Last time had been during my reading session. Even at the library, before I had been aware of The Book's existence. The same force attracted me then and kept its hold on me. There was no more doubt. From the moment I entered this library—no, from the moment I entered this world, I had been tied to this book, and to whatever energy it contained.
Panic would have taken hold of me though, hadn't I remembered who I was speaking with and why. I obviously couldn't reveal the truth of what had truly happened—so I shrugged my hands and improvised a believable enough explanation. "Y-your speech just made it apparent."
Lies had never come easy to me. My heart pounded in my ears, blood rushed to my cheeks. I could only hope those symptoms of internal crisis went unnoticed.
All trace of trepidation vanished when Thorin hummed in agreement. At last! I leaned back against the backrest; knees that had been jerking up and down under the tension immobilized.
So focused on relieving myself of all suspicion, my own words had failed to hit me till now. "Wait a minute—" Taken aback, I pointed my index at Thorin. "How, I mean, why did you... throw a potato? At me?"
Thorin was the last individual I would've guessed as the evildoer on this affair. Heck, suspecting him hadn't even crossed my mind! Earlier, waiting for Estel, I had reviewed in my head the scene as best as I could, and Lindir, least likely out of everyone involved to act harshly in any way, had still seemed a more plausible option than Thorin fucking Oakenshield. When you are aware of the kind of person he is, you instantly relieve him of all accusations for one good reason: he does not give any shit when it comes to things that don't concern him or those he considers close to him.
His opinion of you might change. Most likely will. But unless harm is caused, I used to think no force in this world would be able to get any concrete and deliberate action out of him. In French jargon, I'd call him blasé.
I had not seen him partake in the food fight in the movies either. How did I manage to annoy him this much, and is that a feat I should be proud of?
No? Okay.
"It was not my intention." I snapped back to reality, his deep, almost quiet, and rumbling voice pulling me from my thoughts. And was this remorse I heard?
"What do you mean?" I questioned, fully willing to get to the bottom end of this story. An unintentional deed already appeared as a more probable outcome.
Thorin maintained that same tone of voice as he continued, "As condiments were thrown all over the place, an unfortunate, but inevitable turn of events had a... regrettable potato hurled at myself.
You must understand, as my position requires, I have seen many battles. Have trained to pare all threats alikes. An unknown object flung in my direction had me react the same way I would have on the battlefield."
"Please get to the point, Master Thorin." The story needed no suspense, we all know what occurred.
"... Yes, I shall. My arm, on instinct, reflected the hit. Only it appears I wrongly judged the power behind that strike, for it took you down, instead."
"And did a good job of it!" I laughed awkwardly, then fell silent which made it all the more awkward. So maybe the exiled king wasn't one for sarcastic humor.
Thorin's frown at my attempt to lighten the situation had the advantage of being quite telling. His shoulders tensed. His breathing hovered, slow, and controlled at the cost of great willpower. Had it been any other time, I would've chosen to step back a few meters, as a safety precaution. Right now, however, I had to get to the bottom of this story. And toughen myself up a bit.
Plus, Thorin looked like a kicked puppy. His apparent guilt made me feel remorse in return. There was no world in which I could simply leave him believing I held any grudge or bitterness regarding the potato case. "Ehm," I offered, an ample smile to appear as jovial and unbothered as possible, which I was. "It was just a potato. And an accident. I'm not angry."
His silence outstretched. I gulped and added hurriedly, "If anything, I'm glad you don't wish to kick me off the company."
Thorin's face seemed to morph in this instant. He turned to look at me fully. His brows went up, leading to the widening of his eyes. A leaf fell from the tree above us. I watched its slow descent to the ground, overwhelmed at being so abruptly focused on.
" 'Kick you off?' " Thorin repeated as if the idea was inconceivable. I expired. "Why would I do such thing?"
“I haven’t exactly been the best utility up to now…” My heart pounded in my chest. If he hadn’t realized now, he probably would later on. Best to rip off the bandage now instead of growing too attached.
“Your usefulness or abilities aren’t important.”
Huh?
“When I first heard of the signs concerning a possible return to Erebor, I… thought for a long time. Two things only were inevitable. Erebor needed to be retaken and many would die if we were to pursue this quest.
Recruiting began soon after. I had made sure to warn my people of those two elements in the announcements. Many already considered the Blue Mountains as their home, did not wish to lose it a second time, or judged their stay essential. As such, and knowing the risks, I could not order a single dwarf to come against his will.
Those at my side today have chosen to be here, despite the risks, the dangers, the hardships. In the same manner, it isn't my place to tell them what to choose. This company's members have decided to follow me, come what may. It is the sole condition to join this quest.
My doubts or feelings towards you are insignificant. The wizard has his reasons to bring you and Bilbo on this journey, and while it certainly is a... hassle, I'll admit,...
Ouch. Still blunt, huh?
...I cannot afford to reject his advice." It made sense. Deep down, Thorin knew his quest was a desperate act to retake the mountain. While his pride represents a hindrance, especially when elves are involved, the King within owns a profound understanding and care for his people's best interest.
Losing that ability is what almost led to numerous deaths, defeats, and dishonor over his entire kind.
"Then again," He added almost contemplatively. I perked up from my misconception of his speech being over. "I hope, for your own well-being, that you are aware of the perils standing ahead of us." Oh, I couldn't be more aware. In fact, I was more aware than anyone in this world. Perhaps even Galadriel who, in all her magnificence and power, didn't know the future as well as I.
I never doubted those long hours spent analyzing Middle-Earth, its tales, and creatures would someday be of use (or save my life in the best (worst?) scenarios). I secretly wanted to boast about it.
I could feel this instant would be decisive for Thorin's future view of me. So I quickly sobered up and gravely complied. We stared at each other in dead silence, as I willed myself to be brave and level with his heavy, unforgiving gaze. This time, I would not falter.
Right when I was beginning to fear crying because my eyes had stayed unblinking for so long, a gust of wind blew past our spot in the garden and brought a small amount of pollen to my face. Inevitably, I sneezed.
But, as I raised my head after wiping my nose in the crook of my arm, a chuckle erupted from Thorin. A sincere one. I smiled sheepishly, but it grew into a grin as the company leader uttered his next words. "Perhaps my judgment was premature. I expect you will continue to act unexpectedly in the future. Spontaneity, unpredictability. Those are the reasons why evil has always been defeated." Truer words have never been spoken. Especially concerning this world's history.
"Hm. Was that your strategy for the potato attack?" Again, sarcasm was perhaps not the best option to end this conversation, but he did just ask for surprises. Luckily, only snickering echoed my jest so maybe I'd judged him too hastily.
"You are as smart-mouthed as my nephews. No wonder they have taken such a liking to you."
Unable to provide an answer, I lingered, watching Thorin take his leave. He turned around after a few steps and inclined his head in invitation to follow him back to the quarters, where everyone would be. My only hope, as I trailed with eager feet the slightly rocky and bumpy path ahead one last time, high trees, vivid flora, and forever undisturbed waterfalls, was to avoid giving explanations.
This conversation reassured me in many ways, though it only provoked more unrest whenever I recalled the book's influence on me. My chest was constricted at the mere thought of it.
However, let's not forget today's major event. Thorin Oakenshield k-oed me with a potato and then had the generosity to make me a detailed summary of how exactly it happened. This will be on my testament.
