Chapter Text
“Wait, wait— I’m sorry, what did you just say?” I stammered, my voice coming out croaked and disbelieving. The fight had stayed a glorious blank in my mind, from when my feet picked up speed until I was dropped onto an eagle's back. Everything in between? Nothing. Nada. Niet. Recollections of unintelligible sounds, flashes- a blank canvas. I didn't even recall seeing Ori anywhere. How could he have seen me kill? Of all things? And what exactly did I even kill??
“There was... a warg," I could detect a slight tremor in his voice, which assured me of the veracity of his statement. It must have marked him if he still vividly recounted it, "Right in front of me. You came out of nowhere and... beheaded it.”
Now, that did not sound like me. At all.
“I did? Are you sure? Like, a hundred percent sure?" I took hold of his shoulders firmly and searched his gaze for any hint of uncertainty. "Ori, focus. I can’t kill a warg, I could barely kill that snake the other day! And it stood still!"
“I know what I saw." He assured me, unrelenting. "Erell, without you I’d be dead. You killed the beast and suddenly collapsed, right before an eagle carried us out of the battlefield.”
“But— How—”
“I’m not sure. All I know is that one second that warg stood, fangs bared, ready to chop my head off and spit my braids, and the next, it was on the ground in a puddle of blood, and you were there.”
“And...nobody else saw?”
“No. But I did not lose my mind–! It happened.” The conviction in his words took away those I could have used to refute.
I let go of Ori's shoulders and distanced myself a few feet, trying to make sense of it all. The Valars' warning echoed in my thoughts. "You will find yourself changed." Changed? By which means? I hadn't felt any different.
Except... everything else did.
And I needed to be sure.
Ori watched me, his gaze steady as I grappled with the questions swirling inside my head, my thoughts boiling over like a kettle left too long on the fire of doubt. I jolted at the feeling of his gloved hand on my back and was taken aback at the pure compassion and understanding lodged in his eyes. I had expected fear, disgust, or betrayal.
But when he spoke, I knew all he wished was to understand.
“Erell. What happened exactly?”
“I’m… I don’t...know,” I said, truthfully.
“Erell...” Ori sighed like he worried I would avoid the subject or deflect again.
“No, I swear, I’ve got no idea how... or why...” I trailed off, an idea slowly emerging into my mind. If I couldn't figure out what happened back there then...
Someone— no, scratch that.
something could.
“...but I know how we can find out.”
“Did anyone see you?” I whispered to Ori once he'd joined me in the garden behind the farm. It had been a few hours since we met Beorn, who'd granted us hospitality. As I suspected, once the skin-changer wound up with a company of 13 dwarves, a wizard, and a hobbit, one more human did not make much difference. I'd barely left an impression on him.
We still had a day ahead of us before needing to get back on the road. Enough to rest and tend to our wounds. It was also the perfect time for Ori and I to obtain answers. He'd agreed to meet out of earshot. Thankfully, Beorn's farm covered a good chunk of land and it was easy to find a hiding spot.
“No," He assured. "I told my brothers I would look for material to make more quills before we depart again.”
“Good.” His face wore a sour look, it must feel wrong to lie to his brothers. Ori was as honest as can be. I offered a smile. "We can do that after if you want. This shouldn't take too long."
He nodded, a bit relieved, then grew serious. “Remind me; why must we act in secrecy?”
“I don’t want to make a fuss, if this ends up not being what I think it is.”
And because diving too deep into details might alter the future. To have some control over the events to come, I need them to unfold as much as they would in the original story.
Ori nodded, still a bit unsure but curiosity overpowered the lasting doubts.
“And... what is it, exactly?”
In lieu of an answer, I unclasped the straps of my backpack's main pocket and reached in. Ori's eyes trailed my movements as if expecting a troll to appear. When I pulled out the book, however, they widened in recognition. His expression shifted from concern to confusion. “A book? Hold on—” I cut him off before he had the chance to flee— or convince himself I was a pervert. Or both. Probably both. I wouldn't blame him, from the looks of this situation.
"Not porn! Don't worry." I winced. "Sorry I lied to you. And it's also not just a book. It's a magical one. Or cursed, depends on how you see it."
And because actions are worth more than words, I knew I ought to show him rather than endeavor to explain and confuse him further. The pages fluttered under my fingers as I quickly ran through them. The written proportion of the book struck me. It was larger than the last time. Yet the book itself didn't feel heavier or bigger. The global amount of pages hadn't been altered then. My chest tightened. What would happen once there were no more pages? I was linked to this book. Its presence meant mine. Was it... some kind of ultimatum?
A page half-written made me halt. After that, the whole thing was a blank space. I studied the amount in my left hand. It looked to be a bit more than a third overall.
Ori's audible gasp broke me from my thoughts.
“It... It’s writing itself...”
I shook my head. “On the contrary...”
His eyes narrowed before he corrected himself. “You’re writing it! But how in the seven dwarfs lords...”
“Still no," I sighed. "That’s not me, not exactly. To be completely honest with you, I don't know what it is either." The ink spread across the paper, forming words in slow, repetitive, and constant brushes from an invisible quill. The ink dried up immediately, so when I brushed a thumb over the letters, it returned unstained. It could not be wiped away.
Was this some shitty metaphor? As in, the past can't be erased and whatnot? My sole purpose was to change the past. I didn't need any poetic hidden meanings to tell me what to do, no thank you.
“Whatever it is," I said, supporting my head in one hand, "It knows me.”
It was Ori's turn to shake his head. He'd taken the book from me to examine it further and his face scrunched up like he'd swallowed an insect. “It’s... it’s more than that. It watches you. Looms over you, at every breath...” He trailed off, looking both fascinated and alarmed. His movements were skittish, struggling to make sense of it all, trying to grapple with that reality and failing.
"Where did you get this?" He asked after a long minute.
"In Rivendell's library. I stumbled on it by chance."
"This doesn't look like a lucky finding..." He mumbled out, I snorted.
"It's probably not, but I have no explanation to give you for it." Any explanation I could come up with to describe the utter... insanity of that surreal experience would end up being too hard to put into words anyway.
"I'm just as lost as you are." I settled.
"There is got to be something we can try to– to understand–"
"LADS, DINNER!" Came Bofur's bellow, just before I could answer him. I hastily shoved the book back into my bag in case someone came to look for us. "We should go," I told Ori. When he appeared to want to oppose, I assured him we could always find another moment to talk. A huge weight had been lifted from my shoulders already. It wasn't much, but breathing already seemed easier after sharing this with someone.
In the few days after coming upon all these new elements, I'd felt overwhelmed, lost, lonely... if Ori hadn't come up to me, demanding answers, I never would've shared it with him. At least that was what I had willed myself to do from the moment Galadriel spoke to me in the library. Since I couldn't be sure of the extent of the knowledge I could safely reveal, I'd taken the intimate decision to not reveal anything at all…within the limits of the truth of course. I was an awful liar, always had been. Even as a little child, I could never help the nervous mimics that would give me away.
Even now, the thought of openly lying to Ori, to anyone I cared about actually, had never even crossed my mind because I knew it would be futile to do so. Of course, I wasn't about to let it slip inadvertently into a conversation. (Though that would be fun, hey, guess what, there's a chance I'm connected to some creepy book, also I know all about your lives, your past, future, and all and I've been making buddy-buddy with what is basically your gods. Bilbo, kiss Thorin now. Ha.)
Before reaching the farmhouse, I whispered to Ori a quick thank-you which was as much for his initial inquiry as for his support of the whole thing. I hoped he knew how much it mattered to me.
"Hey," I poked Ori with a stick once, if the snores were any clue to go by, everyone else had fallen asleep. "Wake up. Ori, come on. Don't fall asleep yet."
He grumbled some unintelligible things which contained words like "bugger off", " 's too late" and after a second of realization, whispering, "oh right", just as he rotated to face me from his bedroll.
"You'll get your beauty sleep, don't fuss. We had a discussion to finish, first."
"Mmh-mm." He said through a yawn. "You don't look troubled about any of this."
I gave a shrug. "Figured that if it should have done something, it would have done it by now. I've been carrying this book since Rivendell and nothing happened." Almost nothing if we don't account for the, ahem, literal gods... but that wasn't a subject I was ready to breach.
"Do you think it's linked to what happened during the battle against the orcs?" Ori's low voice asked though we both knew his question was a rhetorical one.
"Definitely. Maybe... I don't wish to get ahead of myself but it might even be the source of it." That was the only explanation I could come up with. The Valar said I would find myself changed, but they also mentioned that I ought to keep the book close to me and intact at all costs. "I think... it's all linked. The book, the... the kill and me."
"You?"
I nodded. "Remember when I arrived? I'm not from this world, Ori, I've never been. Or at least not from Middle-Earth or anywhere on Arda. Gandalf brought me here and before you ask," I said before he could interject, "He doesn't know much more than I do. I've tried asking him."
"I'm guessing it amounted to nothing?" Ori sounded defeated. I didn't say anything in response. Gandalf appeared to know more than most, but even his knowledge had limits. "Will you be alright?" He asked, pulling me from my train of thought. I took a minute to think it over. If what resulted in the warg's death corresponded to the Valar's warning, it may eventually happen again. This... blur of time and space. However, it hadn't felt, at any point, like losing control of myself.
If anything, I had never been more in control of my own body, or the surroundings. Perhaps just a little freer, but entirely in charge of what I did. Of what I aspired to accomplish. At that time, my sole focus was the company and their protection. Ori said I'd saved him.
But that meant he had been in danger, in a different way than he would've been in the original timeline, or saving wouldn't even have been required in the first place. Something I'd done had provoked it. I scoured my memory. And then, like a light bulb flickering to life, the answer suddenly dawned on me.
In that hectic moment, Ori had grabbed my offer to climb onto a different tree than his brothers'. Which, while it meant he did not have to experience dangling in the air, he was subjected to a whole other type of ordeal instead and fought with the rest of us. And would have died if not for that sudden rush of... killing impulse, apparently.
Don’t be so sure of your lack of abilities.
Those were Galadriel's own words. Had she known, from the start?
"Erell?" Ori called. I realized I must have zoned out and still hadn't answered his question. The rest of the company were all huddled up close to each other, sleeping soundly under the safety provided by our host.
"Don't worry about me. As long as I keep it safe," I hugged my bag closer, "I'm sure nothing will happen. It's no use worrying when there is nothing else the book can give us. I'll send a letter to Elrond once we make it to Erebor." However strange this all became, I couldn't let it stray my mind from the original quest. First, make it to Erebor in one piece. Maybe try to smoothen the edges with the woodland elves, hopefully, stop the war and warn everyone in time of the orc armies. Save the Durins.
Whatever mysteries and magic led to it didn't matter. As long as none of the objectives suffered, I had to push those speculations aside.
