Chapter Text
Fíli had gone straight to his room after he’d left and rested his back against the door, banging his head slowly against it. He should have known better. Should have never followed her in the first place. Should have just let her kill that damn stag and move on with his life.
He’d have married this Dagní girl and got on with trying to run his kingdom, content in the knowledge that he’d never known love and so would be unable to miss it. Who knows, perhaps he and Dagní would have actually gotten on really well, and come to love each other just as Thorin said they would.
However, Fíli did know love now. He knew the beautiful searing pain he felt within himself. Knew how he wanted to wallow forever in it and allow it to consume him. Knew that being without her hurt more than he could ever know. That the very thought of her face could make the world seem a happier place and that being with her made the world come to a standstill.
She was his marlûno, his khebabmudtu, his ghivashel. To be without her felt like he wasn’t a whole person anymore. She had taken a part of him with her and was keeping it safe for him until they’d meet again and they’d feel whole again.
Yet he’d just agreed to marry another person. To live without her forever more. He’d likely never see her again, and she might never know why. Might never understand. But his duty to his kingdom came first. He had to do right by the people, she’d taught him that. If his marriage to Dagní could bring about the happiness and well being of others where a relationship with Sigrid would not, well then his choice was clear enough.
However, in the privacy of his room, he could allow himself to wallow in sadness for perhaps a little longer. He heaved a big sigh and let himself cry. Cry as he did when he was only a boy and mourning the loss of Frerin. Cry as he did when he was lost in the woods and the Eldar Woman had come to find him.
Have heart, little prince. All will be fine.
Fíli jumped. Where had that voice come from? It sounded like his bagûna, but it couldn’t be surely? How could she have gotten past the guards? He tiptoed to his window and looked out into the palace gardens. It was peaceful and quiet out there, the birds had already sung their evening song, and there was nothing but the low hoot of the owls as they sought out one another admits the darkness. Fíli stared at the forest where he’d always run to when he wanted to get away from his duties as a prince.
He wanted to run there now. However, running and hiding was what children did. It was what Fee would do, and he was no longer Fee. He was Prince Fíli. He had to remember that.
“Fee?” came a small knock at the door “Fee, it’s me, Kee, let me in?”
“Go away Kee.” Sighed Fíli “I just want to be alone.”
“I know that’s not true brother.” Said Kíli through the door
“Yes it is Kee.” He huffed “Just leave me alone. I’ll be alright. I’m an adult, I can handle things.”
“You’re not of age yet Fee.” Came the voice through the door “Now let your baby brother come and comfort you.”
Fíli rolled his eyes and tutted to himself, but went over to open the door anyway. Outside, he found a sheepish looking Kíli holding a mug of hot cocoa and a tray of biscuits.
“Bombur told me to give these to you.” He said simply, placing them down on his bedside table. “How you holding up Na’?” he asked
Fíli bit his lip and took a deep breath. “I’m fine Kíli, honestly. I’m fine. I always knew this was going to happen. I told myself not to get too involved with anyone and so, I mean. Best it happens now than further down the line before it’s too late.” He sniffed slightly, turning away from Kíli “It’s like Thorin said. It’s only marlith. I’ll get over it soon enough.”
“Only marlith?” said Kíli incredulously “There’s nothing only about marlith!”
“You would say that though Kee, don’t you understand? You fall in love with the drop of a hat! But it’s not all dashing knights and True Love’s First Kiss in the real world Kíli! We don’t live in a fairy tale and it’s time you understood that.”
“Fee, you’re being stupid come on don’t-”
“Don’t call me Fee.” He snapped “I’m Fíli. Crowned Prince Fíli of Clan Longbeard, first in line to the throne of Erebor and heir of Durin. That’s who I am, not some young apprentice at a castle with not a care in the world other than for his sweetheart.”
“You’re both Fee and Fíli.” Said Kíli, softly. “You need to have both parts in order to be true to yourself. You can’t just try and ignore one part of you in the hopes of becoming more like the other half. It’s not how it works.”
“Well, it doesn’t work for us like it does for normal people, Kee.” Sighed Fíli, sitting down on his bed “If we want to live in a castle and never have to want for food, if we want to have plush beds and running water, well then we’ve got a duty to fulfil. And that duty often means doing things you don’t want to do.”
“Like marrying someone you’ve never met, even though you’ve already found your marlûno?”
“Even if I have found my marlûno.” Whispered Fíli
“Why don’t I marry Dagní instead, aye?” said Kíli, coming down to sit next to him. “The Blacklocks still get their royal prince and link to the throne, plus they get to inherit the title of ‘Lord of the Blue Mountains’ which I know they’ve been wanting to get their mits on for years, and they still get a crack at the throne!”
Fíli laughed “It is very kind of you Nadadith. But I could never let you go through with that. How could I watch you throw away your own chance at happiness?”
“Because I fall in love at the drop of a hat and have never known love like you do now.”
“But someday you might.” Pleaded his brother “And after all, it is better to have known the joys of having your marlûno close to you and missing them each day, then to live your life unaware of where they might be because you’re too busy trying to make a loveless marriage work.”
“Well, maybe Dagní is my marlûno.” Said Kíli definitely “I mean, I’ve never met her, have I? Nor have you, how do we know that this isn’t just the universes’ plan to get us together.”
Fíli laughed at that “Oh Nadad.” He said pulling him in to rest their foreheads together “I forget just how young you are sometimes.”
“And you, brother, forget that you are young as well.” He smiled
The brothers broke apart and flopped down onto the bed together, staring up at the ceiling as they did when they were children.
“So what are you going to do?” asked Kíli after a while
“Marry Dagní and bring happiness to the kingdom.”
“I mean, about Sigrid, she has a right to know everything. I mean, she’ll hear about the Prince getting married to someone who isn’t her, and, okay so she’s clearly not the most up-to-date person considering she’s been close enough to kiss your ugly face and still didn’t recognise it as belonging to her Future King, but at the very least she’ll know you’ve disappeared and don’t plan to see her again, leaving no explanation as to why.”
“I was going to write her a letter.” Said Fíli, simply.
“A letter? You were going to write her a Dear Jansí letter? Oh Nadad that is so not fair on her. You need to meet her! Tell her the truth face to face and have one last day of freedom. Go and tell her that you’re Fee and Fíli and that you both love her. Let her know that she’s your marlûno.”
“How?” said Fíli hopelessly “I mean, Balin’s going to have me running around getting everything ready, and Thorin will no doubt be giving me even more speeches about duty and nobility and all of that. How will I get out?”
“The same way we did when we were kids.” Shrugged Kíli “Hop out of your window onto the roof and slide down the tiles until someone catches you at the bottom.”
“Kee, I weigh more than twice that I did when I was eight. I don’t think it’s going to work.”
“Honestly, it’s like you don’t trust me at all!” sighed Kíli
“Considering the number of broken bones you’ve had due to your own escape attempts, I think I’m within my right to be doubtful of your abilities.”
“Look, I’ll think of something, just, when you hear Thorin shouting, take your chance and run, okay?”
There was another soft knock on the door “Fíli, it’s Mum, can I come in?”
The brothers looked at one another uncertain what to do.
“I promise I won’t try and tell you what to do, or have a go at you. I just want to know if you’re okay. I’ve got something to give to you.”
“You can come in then, I guess.” Called out Fíli
Dís entered the room cautiously “Well doesn’t this remind me of old times.” She smiled as she noted the boys sitting on the bed together, “just like when you were just little badgers trying to stay up all night to watch the dawn.”
“Yes Mum, we know.” Said Kíli, rolling his eyes “We were very cute and adorable at the time and now we’re big grown men.”
Dís sighed “Not as old as your uncle or yourselves might think.” She came over to sit between them on the bed
“I know that you’re determined to go through with this Fíli.” Said Dís seriously, “and whilst I cannot say I would do the same in your shoes, or that I agree that you’re doing the right thing,” Fíli was about to open his mouth to complain when Dís silenced him with a finger “However, I know that what you’re doing is a noble thing indeed, and I am so happy to have raised a boy who cares so deeply about those around him. However.” She said mysteriously “I thought that perhaps you needed to think about a certain someone in particular.” She grinned, and from the depths of her long midnight blue gown, she withdrew a slightly startled looking Rek.
Rek squawked at her indignantly and tossed her beak from side to side. “I know Rek, I know. You don’t like being stored there as much as the other Karâk, but I had to sneak you out of there without anyone noticing!”
“It seems you’re both plotting against Thorin then.” Sighed Fíli holding out his arm for Rek to jump onto.
“Well, somebody has to keep him on his toes.” Chuckled Dís “Now, what are you going to say in this letter then? Would you like some help writing it?”
“’Amad!” complained Fíli “It’s personal. I’m not going to tell you what I’m going to send!”
“Oh come on my little lion, I’m not going to blabber to the whole castle. I just want to give you a hand!”
“You don’t want to be kept out of the loop anymore. I know you questioned Rek when she got back from delivering the first letter, don’t pretend you didn’t.” said Fíli sternly “But I also know that Rek wouldn’t say anything after I told her not to.” He smiled fondly at the raven “Isn’t that right girl?” he squawked
Dís heaved a sigh “Very well. Keep more secrets from your mother. Continue to lie to her if you must, but at least tell me the name of the person who’s captured my son’s heart in such a way.”
“Sigrid.” Said Fíli, her very name brining joy to his heart
“A beautiful name.” she smiled “Come now Kíli, leave your brother to it, he’s going to have a big day tomorrow I’m sure.” Smiled Dís fondly, throwing an arm around her youngest.
“You’re not going to fall in love with someone you’ll be doomed to never get to be with, are you karakith?”
“Not if I can help it ‘Amad” he smiled, “It seems like a whole lot of bother if you ask me.”
“That it is my child, that it is.” She kissed the top of his head as they walked back to their rooms.
Fíli had no idea what to write to her. How could he explain everything to her in only a letter? Kíli was right, he’d have to see her in person, but how to set the tone correctly…
He chewed on the top of his quill thoughtfully, earning a glare from Rek for disrespecting one of her brethren’s feathers in such a way. Eventually, he found the correct words and wrote out the message as neatly as he could, passing it to Rek to give to Sigrid.
“You know where to find her, yeah?” He asked, Rek giving a nod of her head in response “Brilliant.” He said, taking her to the window. “Fly fast my friend.” He called as she flew out of the window and into the dark “Fly fast and true.”
Fíli stayed there for some time, enjoying the cool breeze and clinging to the idea of seeing Sigrid again, rather than the realisation that it could well be for the last time.
*
Thranduil had been true to his word and even though it was coming up to midnight, she was still wide awake and working in the kitchen. There was a soft tapping at the window, and Sigrid stood up excitedly, hoping it to be a Raven with a message.
She was in luck! It was Rek again (she could tell by the shape of her beak) and once more, she had a scroll tied to her foot with red ribbon.
With eager fingers, she took the message from the bird, who she rewarded with some giblets from dinner, and read the message from Fee.
She re-read the letter twice, frowning as she did so. She sat down, her hand on her heart, trying to take it all in. She thought she understood what he was saying, but surely she had to be misinterpreting it?
Amrâlimê,
I wish I could write to you with gladder tidings.
I wish I could write to you with promises of being together forever and always.
However, I value you too much to lie to you anymore.
Know that all I have said to you of my feelings and of my innerself is true.
However, I have not been honest with you in regards to my outerself.
I do not wish to explain all of this in a letter, but please,
let me know if you are able to be free tomorrow so as we may talk.
News has arisen here at the castle that means it may be our last chance to be together, and I’d hate to waste it due to another misconception.
I promise there will be no arresting or kidnapping this time.
Yours forever
Fí
“What does it mean?” said Sigrid, looking to Rek for help “What does he mean ‘news has arisen here’, what news? What news of the royal household would affect us being together?”
Rek cocked her head to one said and snapped her beak.
“Why can’t humans and birds share a common tongue as well.” Muttered Sigrid impatiently.
“What’s all this ‘innerself’ and ‘outerself’ stuff even mean?” she bit her lip “It’s like he’s saying he’s lied to me but not. Like he’s been keeping secrets from me as I have from him. But- oh.” She said setting the letter down on the kitchen table and staring at it like it might combust
“He’s not, Fí. He signed it Fí not Fee. He’s- oh. Fíli.” she stared at the letter uncertain how to react to the news that her Prince Charming really was a prince.
Rek hopped over and began to tug on her sleeve, clearly impatient for a reply.
“Yes, yes, you damn bird, ow!” she cried as Rek have her a sharp nip with her beak “Hold on now you.” She said wagging her finger “Don’t have a go at me when it’s your master who’s been the one causing all this trouble.” She went to the drawer and withdrew some parchment and some ink, and set about considering how to reply.
She’d considered writing and telling him to Fuck Off, but found she could not find it in her heart to do so, after all, she’d kept secrets from him as well. She tapped her quill on the tip of the ink pot, thinking carefully and began to write.
My beloved Prince Charming,
What a world it is, where lovers lie to each other to cover up truths they share.
You are not the only one with royal lineage,
though yours has lasted a little longer perhaps.
You my want to look up people who can communicate with the song birds,
and their connection to the line of King Girion the wise.
Oh what a fool I’ve been to not realise who you were sooner!
You must think of me as such a simpleton.
Though I do understand why you kept it a secret.
There is certainly something special about being seen as an equal.
Alas, love of mine, I do not know if I will be able to see you tomorrow.
My stepfather was very angry at me for returning so late the other day, he practically has be under lock and key. However, if you are able to come to the farmhouse in the afternoon, my stepfamily will be out performing
completely legal and morally correct deeds at the club.
Knock twice on the door with the thrush carved into it, and I will know it is you.
Forever yours, beholder of my heart
Lady Sigrid
When Fíli got the letter, he had to read over it several times to make sure he fully understood, then again once more just to appreciate the fact that it had been her hand that had written it. He was becoming a sentimental, love sick idiot, and if the situation wasn’t so serious- he’d rather love the feeling.
“So Sigrid is from the line of Girion? But, her family are dead so she can’t be Lord Masterson’s child… Unless…” he thought back to his lessons with Balin over the lords of the counties and their histories. Dale, being the largest county in the kingdom, had once been a kingdom in it's own right. However, a plague had struck it to it's knees, and King Girion decided that it would be better to give up his title and pass the kingdom into the care of Erebor than to see his people suffer further more.
Despite being the largest county, it was also one of the poorest. He’d only met the previous lord once, when he was very young, but he could recall his faded robes and work roughened features… he couldn’t remember much else… Perhaps she would fill him in on the details tomorrow? He wanted to know more about her past, wanted to know Sigrid for exactly as she was, just as he wished she knew him for who he was.
But if Sigrid really was a rightful heir to Girion, then she was nobility in the eyes of the law. Oh how things could have been so different if they’d come clean sooner! But alas, no. Not anymore. He was promised to a strong and hairy clanswoman with actual power and lands. Thorin would never allow him to break off the engagement just so as he could marry a penniless Lady living in a dusty farmhouse whose lands were ruled by a greedy and selfish Lord.
That night, Fíli went to bed clutching the letter to his chest, and wondered what Kíli and his mother were planning for Thorin. He would feel sorry for him, if he had not already gone behind his back and betrayed his trust. Quite frankly, Thorin was due some sort of punishment for his behaviour, and he was quite happy to let the rest of his family deal it to him.
