Chapter Text
Even before the stone giants made their presence known, Bilbo felt that climbing the mountain was a bad choice. As they moved steadily upwards, the rain increased, as did the wind, and soon he felt like it was all he could do to remain standing, let alone keep pushing forward. He had always enjoyed the rain; as a younger hobbit he had spent many hours running about in it, heedless of any real danger. Somehow the rain in the Shire seemed less brutal, less destructive than this rain, the thunder more welcoming. His feet, which had always been steady on the ground, couldn’t seem to find the purchase he needed to move swiftly. Despite himself he began to agree with Kili: this mountain was angry, and it wanted them off.
Soon enough, they all found out how right Kili actually was, and the ensuing battle between the two giants would have left Bilbo shaking like a leaf even if he hadn’t nearly been thrown off of a cliff. He knew that he would relive that horrible minute of dangling by his fingertips in dreams for years to come. Worse, Thorin had nearly fallen off himself saving him, and the words he had flung at Bilbo had landed hard, the mere memory enough to make him flinch miserably where he lay pretending to sleep. Oh, he was a foolish hobbit, that much was certain. Such a foolish, silly little hobbit, to think that he could be anything more than a hindrance on this quest, that me might even be able to help. Such a silly, foolish, pathetic little hobbit to think that Thorin Oakenshield might ever look upon him with anything more than disdain. He thought again of Thorin’s words, of his furious face, and blinked back sudden tears.
It’s no use, he told himself, huddling as far into his clothes as he could. You were not made for this. You are a hobbit, a tiny, insignificant little hobbit, and you cannot be brave. You are not a Took, no matter what Gandalf says. You are a Baggins, and were made for simple things, your books and fire and garden, not for adventure and dragons and quests. It would be better for everyone if you just returned to where you belong, before you cause any more trouble.
He had been working up to this final decision since the beginning of the journey, he knew. He never should have stepped outside of his front door – he wasn’t built for it. His mother had been the adventurer; he was far more like his father, steady and dependable. He had known this, and still he had tried to be something he most definitely was not, swayed by a song and a pair of sad blue eyes and the persuasive whisper of maybe.
For just a moment, Bilbo closed his eyes and curled harder into himself. He bit the inside of his lip as hard as he could and clenched his hands into tight fists, then he forced himself to relax, to open his eyes and cautiously peer into the darkness around him. Everyone was deeply asleep; he could hear Bombur’s and Gloin’s snores from across the cave, Kili’s muttering and Dori’s snuffling. There would be no better time.
Slowly, cautiously, Bilbo rose. He took up his pack and his bedroll and picked his cautious way through the mass of sleeping dwarves, ignoring the small voice inside of him that screamed coward and instead listening to the far more sensible one telling him that this was the only way. He nearly made it out, when he heard a soft call of his name.
Bofur. Of all the dwarves, he had been the nicest, the one most eager to extend the hand of friendship. Bilbo wished that it were anyone else that had caught him out. He didn’t want to disappoint Bofur, too.
“I have to go. I’m useless to anyone here, and I miss my home. I never should have come.”
Bofur shook his head. “It’s hard for everyone, Bilbo, but it will get better. It will.”
“No, it won’t. I am not meant for this. I miss my home, and my books, and I can’t do this.”
Bofur sighed. “I understand-“
The mix of dismay that it should be Bofur who saw him leave and the despair that he had failed those who trusted him, as well as some test of life that he had hardly been aware he was taking, caused Bilbo to finally snap. “No, you don’t understand!” he cut Bofur off, “How could you? You’re dwarves, you don’t have a home-“ Bilbo stopped there, instantly contrite, knowing that he had said something unforgiveable. Bofur gently waved him off. The face he turned to Bilbo was one of the saddest he’d ever seen, but still his voice was kind and honest as he wished him every happiness.
Bilbo shifted from foot to foot. He should go. He would never have a better opportunity. And yet…despite himself, he didn’t want to go. Bofur’s face had wiped out all of his self-pity in one fell swoop, and now he was nothing more than ashamed. He missed his home and he missed his books, but at least he had those things to return to. How could he sit and whine about how unfair his life was to those who had had it so much worse for so long? Despite himself his eyes flicked to Thorin, and found his eyes open and watching him, full of the same censure and disappointment they had held almost since the first moment he’d first laid eyes on Bilbo.
Bilbo held those eyes for just a moment, then gave up. He would stay. He had to. But he would also give up; would no longer allow Thorin’s meeting every point of some long-forgotten list of requirements make him think that he could find someone who might just suit him right down to the ground, someone who might be able to defy the Took curse. That foolishness would end here.
He turned back to Bofur, ready to tell him this, but found the dwarf’s eyes glued to his waist. “Bilbo..?” he said softly, and Bilbo realized this his little sword had taken on a blue glow.
“Oh, no,” he whispered, and out of the corner of his eye he saw Thorin jump up, no sleep in his eyes as he yelled for the others to wake. It was far too late for anyone to do anything, however, as the very ground beneath their feet slid away and they all fell into a heap in the goblin tunnels below.
~****~
If he had the breath for it, he could have screamed with frustration, but he was too frightened. Once again, he had tried to help and only made things worse. Now he was separated from the rest of the group, had no way out, and to top it all off, had to face down a creepy little creature who would kill him as soon as look at him. His tiny sword – what had Balin called it? A letter opener? – seemed more ineffectual than ever when faced with the weird creature’s menace, but Bilbo held it dutifully in front of him just the same. It was something to keep the thing at bay for the moment, at any rate. Something to put between them.
“Is it tasty? Is it juicy?” the thing asked, and Bilbo cringed in disgust. He had a feeling that it would not stay back for much longer, and he trembled. He was no warrior; if that thing charged him it would win, and Bilbo would end up a meal. He opened his mouth and words came out, though he hardly heard what it was he said. A white haze of panic had settled over his mind, and he could not think around it.
Suddenly the mad creature was capering and dancing in front of him, giving out giant smiles that frightened Bilbo more than its menace had. Part of him wanted to turn and run, try his chances, and another part wanted to put the sword down and let the creature come at him. Let it be over. The second part was weaker than the first, and knowing it was there suddenly made Bilbo furious –at himself, at the creature, at this whole stupid journey.
No. You have faced trolls and giants and Thorin’s wrath. This thing is nothing compared to that. You will not cower, Bilbo Baggins. You will fight.
Bilbo forced his back straight, his hand steadied. He focused all of his attention on actually listening to the words coming from the thing’s mouth, and was baffled to learn that it was speaking of riddles. His brow furrowed. Riddles, then. He could work with riddles.
“if I win, I go free,” he said, and the thing cocked it’s head, smile fading, eyes going cold and calculating. Bilbo met its gaze calmly, ignoring the churning of his stomach.
The thing smiled slowly. “If it wins, it goes free,” it agreed, then the smile widened. “if it loses, we eats it whole.”
Bilbo thought about it. “Fair enough.” He did not intend to lose, and he knew that the creature in front of him didn’t either. He also knew that it wouldn’t play fair; even as it returned to its other, more manic personality, the cold gleam stayed in its eyes. There would be no easy escape, even if he won. Still, best to put that out of his mind for the moment. He stuck his sword back on his hip and got down to the business of surviving.
Riddles were something of a hobby of Bilbo’s – though he had not been the type of hobbit to take part in boisterous war games for longer than he could recall, he had always loved to read, and to puzzle, and riddles gave his mind something to pick at when he was feeling lonely and miserable. Both of his aunts had loved them, and the three of them had spent many a morning trying to stump each other over breakfast, laughing when they managed it and kicking their legs when they could not. It was those bright mornings that Bilbo called on as he and the creature played, and he was surprised to realize that in spite of the danger he was in, he was enjoying himself. The creature was cleverer than his appearance would lend anyone to believe, and the riddle trading lasted for several minutes before the other personality came in to end it.
“Final one,” it hissed, glaring at him. Its fingers twitched, flexing as though they were already wrapped around his throat. It took a step forward, and Bilbo took one back, swallowing hard. “Ask us a question.”
Bilbo thought. His mind was going blank again. Every riddle in his repertoire suddenly seemed far too easy, and he knew that if this creature guessed the right answer it would consider the game won and jump him. Bilbo had no intention of letting it eat him in any case, but he wanted to win fair and square. It was a matter of pride, which was wholly ridiculous considering the situation but no less true for all that. He cast about in his mind for the riddle, the one riddle that would stump the dirty creature and maybe buy his life. He could think of nothing. The creature smirked and sketched a little bow. “Time’s up,” it whispered, and prepared to pounce.
“Wait! I’ve got one! What…what have I got – got – in my - in my…pocket! Yes! What have I got in my pocket?” The creature stopped, confused, and Bilbo breathed a sigh of relief.
“Cheating,” it muttered furiously. “It’s cheating, precious. That isn’t a riddle, makes no sense. It must forfeit, it must.”
“It will not,” Bilbo answered, affronted. “You told me to ask a question, I’ve asked it. Now you must answer. What have I got in my pocket?”
The thing glared at him. “Three guesses,” it demanded, and Bilbo nodded graciously. There was no way it could figure out the answer, not with three hundred guesses, for who would expect a shiny golden ring to be in a traveling hobbit’s pocket? Bilbo himself never would have expected it, but he was glad he’d absently picked it up when he’d seen it glinting on the ground. Perhaps his luck was finally changing.
“Handses!” it cried, and Bilbo, who had just removed his hands from his pockets, shook his head.
“Try again.”
It bent low to the ground, muttering to itself about bats and toads and fish and bones in a rapid tone. Bilbo stared at the scrap of cloth it was wearing. If these were things it regularly kept in its pockets, as they must be, he hadn’t the faintest where said pockets were located.
“Knife!”
“I’m afraid not. Last guess.” He heard the cheeriness in his own voice and tried to tone it tone. It would do no good to look as though he were gloating. There was still one guess left to go, and it wasn’t beyond the realm of possibility that he might figure it out.
The creature’s face went through a series of contortions, and then he cried “string,” and almost on top of it, in the lower, more murderous tone, “or nothing.”
“That was two guesses, and both wrong,” Bilbo replied, and now it wasn’t cheer but relief coursing through him. Perhaps it would honor its promise after all. Perhaps it would let him go free. He tapped the little lump in his jacket pocket, feeling a wash of fondness for it. What good luck that he’d picked it up, he thought again, what wonderful luck.
The creature shrieked and flung itself on the ground, writhing and jerking as though it were dying, and Bilbo hastily stepped farther out of its reach. The noise that made stopped the tantrum; it turned to look at him and Bilbo read his own death on its face. “You – you have to let me go. You agreed.” He hated the way his voice came out – thready and desperate – but he was having a hard time getting his breath suddenly and that was the best he could do.
“Did we promise?” it hissed back, crawling forward. Bilbo skittered away. “Did we, Precious? And what has it got in its pockets, then? We can find out, yes.” it reached down into the filthy rag it wore as clothes, groped for a moment, then froze, eyes wide. “Where..?” Those large eyes fixed on Bilbo again and it snarled. “You. You stole it. Thief! Give it back, it’s mine!” And it lunged.
Bilbo took one giant step back and lost his footing. He fell, back slamming into the ground, head hitting hard enough for his vision to go out momentarily, and then the creature landed on top of him, snarling. His hands clawed at Bilbo’s chest and throat, and the stench of its breath filled his nostrils and made him gag. Bilbo struggled wildly, but the thing was strong and wiry and would not be dislodged. Cold, dirty hands locked about his throat and began to squeeze, it was drooling and gibbering madly, laughing through the disjointed words that poured from its mouth. Its eyes bulged. Bilbo stopped trying to pry it off and flung both arms to the ground beside him, scrabbling desperately for something, anything to use as a weapon. His grasping fingers hit something hard, bounced off, grasped it. It was a good sized rock, and Bilbo used the last of his strength to bring it up and into the side of the creatures head, sending it sprawling. It rolled twice and landed a few feet away, dazed and blinking, a bit of blood trickling from its ear.
Bilbo sat up, gasping, and rubbed at his neck. His throat was on fire, even swallowing hurt. He wanted nothing more than to sit and shake and try to compose himself, but he hadn’t hit the creature that hard, and it was already struggling to its feet. Bilbo ran.
He had no clue where he was going, or if it was even in the right direction to get out; no idea if he was running towards something even nastier than what he was trying to leave behind. All he could see was the path in front of him, all he could hear was his own terrified panting. He took a sharp turn and noticed a small space to try and hide in – if he could squeeze through before the creature turned the corner as well and saw him, he might make it out. He flung himself at the space and tried to force himself through it – he was stuck briefly but with a mighty heave and the tearing of every button on his waistcoat he forced himself through. He overbalanced and fell on his back again, buttons flying. The force of his fall knocked the ring out of his pocket and into the air, and he reached for it without really thinking about it. Somehow it slid on his finger, and then the creature was once again upon him.
Bilbo held his breath and prayed that it would not see his little hiding place. He’d been so desperate to get away from the mad thing that he hadn’t realized that he had merely managed to trap himself. If it looked in and saw him, he would have no escape. The only way out was the way he had gone in. He knew with a sudden clarity that he was going to die, and even in his terror had time to be amused that he’d managed to get his wish: it would not be a broken heart that killed him, after all.
He unsheathed his sword as the creature finally looked into his little hideaway, prepared to fight desperately for his life…but the creature’s eyes passed over him without seeing. It turned around in a circle, scratched its head. “Where did it go, Precious?” it muttered. “We was right behind it. How did it escape us?” It pounded one dirty fist on the rock next to it, cursing. “Tricksy little thief! But we will find it, Precious, we will, and we will make it pay for what it stole from us. We will hurt it and cut it and make it pay, make it squirm and scream. Make it bleed.”
Bilbo shuddered at the rage in that voice, and then the creature was scurrying away, heading farther down the tunnel. Bilbo gave it a couple of moments, then followed. Perhaps there was a way out. He followed that path for a bit, then realized that it was getting brighter. He picked up his pace, nearly running, and almost ran over the creature before he realized it was there. He stopped. The creature was standing just outside of an opening in the rocks, one that led to daylight. It was peering out, searching no doubt for Bilbo, still somehow completely unaware that the hobbit he sought was right behind him. The shoulders in front of him tensed, and suddenly it spun around, its wide eyes searching the tunnel behind it. Still it did not see Bilbo, and he knew it was his one chance. He toyed briefly with the idea of killing the creature to make sure that it could never come after him, but he knew that he could not do it. Even though it had terrified him, even though he knew that it would not hesitate to kill him should it realize he was there, Bilbo could not look into its pathetic, wasted face and feel anything but pity and revulsion. Whatever had happened to the thing, whatever had made it the way it was, its existence was surely punishment enough. Instead of using his sword to cut its throat, Bilbo pressed himself against the wall and skirted around the creature, emerging out into sunlight with the sound of its howls of rage and sorrow ringing in his ears.
Bilbo did not stop once he was out of the cave. He ran full tilt down the embankment, his breath screaming out of his lungs, sure that any moment he would feel that horrible creature’s fingers tugging on his coat pulling him back into the tunnels to finish him off. That did not happen, however, and soon he was well clear of the cave, surrounded by trees and feeling safer, though not by very much. He slowed, stopped, and was seized with a horrible cramp. He bent over, hands on his knees, and retched, eyes closed.
Very slowly, the cramping stopped. His heart slowed to its normal rhythm, and the roaring in his ears died down. With that gone, he could make out several voices. It was his companions, not far off, speaking in tense voices, and Bilbo moved towards the sound, so grateful to have found them again he nearly wept. Then he registered what they were saying.
“-thought of nothing but his cozy hobbit hole since he came.” Thorin’s voice was hard, angry, and Bilbo fell back against a tree, shoulders slumping as he heard the mutters of agreement from the rest. Of course. None of them could know that he hadn’t been planning on leaving them behind – what Thorin had witnessed before their descent into the goblin’s lair could only make him think that Bilbo had taken off at the first opportunity. Bilbo peered around his tree. Not one face showed anything other than full agreement; Gandalf only looked troubled. Bilbo bit his lip. If he wanted to, he could leave. They thought him a coward already, believed that he would run out on them in their time of need, why not prove them right?
Bilbo shook his head, gritting his teeth against that thought, which seemed far too tempting. No. He’d decided to stick with them, he’d survived the horror that dwelt deep inside the caves to return to them, and he would not back out now. He would see this through to the end, whatever it may be. He stepped out from behind the trees.
~****~
If there was one thing he had learned on this journey, it was that Thorin could not be trusted to make sound decisions for himself, Bilbo thought furiously as threw himself at the orc about to chop of the head of a very foolish King. Whenever he did make a decision, horrible things happened. Things that inevitably put himself and others in danger. Not that Bilbo was exactly up to making decisions either, considering how he was only too willing to throw himself in front of a sword meant for another’s neck. It was almost funny. Bilbo had been so terrified of the Took Curse his entire life that he’d created walls surrounded by thorns to protect himself from the possibility of it ever happening to him, and in the end it would be the unwitting result of that very protection that wound up doing him in. Thorin Oakenshield was a menace, and if they all got out of this alive, he was going to tell him so at the first opportunity, tentative peace that they’d achieved only minutes before be damned. This sort of thing could not go on – it was no good for Bilbo’s poor nerves. He tackled the orc and with a combination of pure luck and gravity, managed to kill it, then flung himself to his feet and stood protectively in front of Thorin, doing his best to shield him from any other attacks. The Pale Orc’s eyes fixed upon him, and Bilbo gulped. He was going to die.
Well, he was not going to die cowering. Squaring his shoulders, he prepared to boldly face his next challenge, but before Azog could call his riders down on him there was a shout from behind and the rest of the company was there, out of the trees and ready to battle for their King and freedom. Bilbo let out a sigh of relief and charged into the fray with them, slashing his sword as best he could and trying to always place himself between each threat and Thorin, who had not yet opened his eyes. He did not know if they could win this battle – there were many orcs and many wargs and the company was already exhausted from their fight and flight in the goblin tunnels – but he knew that none of them would allow themselves to be taken alive, even if Azog wished it. This would be a fight to the death, one way or another. Had he thought about it, Bilbo would have expected to be more afraid than he was. He would be afraid later. For the moment, he only had room for survival.
The arrival of the eagles was a blessing, and a younger Bilbo would have delighted in the flight away from the orcs, entranced by traveling through the sky to the sound of beating wings. The elder Bilbo might have enjoyed it as well, were it not for his worry over Thorin, a worry that had sunk cold claws into his chest and refused to let go. He kept anxious eyes on the prone form lying in one of the eagles claws for the entirety of the flight, and when they set down wanted to throw himself at the King to make sure he was alive. He held back, however, knowing it was not his place. Thorin would not thank him for his concern, he knew. He would probably despise him for it, as he despised him for so much else. Still, when Gandalf announced that Thorin would live, Bilbo went weak with relief, and very nearly spilled to the ground.
As if Gandalf’s pronouncement was a signal, Thorin’s eyes fluttered, then opened. He peered around unseeingly for a moment, then he murmured something too low for Bilbo to hear. Gandalf’s posture, however, relaxed, and Bilbo saw his face crease in a fond smile.
“It’s all right. Bilbo is here. He’s quite safe.” He said, stepping aside so that Thorin might see for himself, and Bilbo gave a surprised jerk. Had that too-low murmur been Thorin enquiring about him? His stomach fluttered oddly, and he took a small step forward into Thorin’s line of sight, starting to smile.
When Thorin’s gaze fell on him he scrambled up, advancing towards Bilbo with fury in his eyes. Gandalf did his best to restrain him, but he threw off the constraining hand and kept coming. Bilbo shuffled back in alarm.
“You. Did I not say that you would be a burden? That you would not survive in the wild? That you had no place amongst us?”
Bilbo’s heart sank. Could he do no right in Thorin’s eyes? How had he gone wrong by saving his life? He looked at the ground in defeat as Thorin stopped a mere pace from him, telling himself again that he must stop allowing Thorin’s disappointment to hurt him. They were nothing to each other, after all. Why should it sting so much that Thorin still hated him?
“I have never been so wrong in all my life,” Thorin continued, and Bilbo’s head snapped up with astonishment. Surely he had heard wrong. He caught a brief glimpse of Thorin’s face – could that usually stern face really be smiling at him with so much affection? It had to be his imagination – before he was enveloped in strong arms and pulled into a fierce hug. Bilbo tensed in surprise, then hesitantly brought his own arms up to return the embrace, his eyes sliding closed with how very good it felt to be held in such a way, by such a-.
Oh, he thought, and then: oh, no.
