Chapter Text
As a much younger, more carefree hobbit, Bilbo Took-Baggins had often found himself in scrapes that made his friends and neighbors question his sanity. That child, they would tell each other in exasperated voices, has a death wish. Who ever heard of climbing a tree so high that the branches wouldn’t hold you? What in all of Middle-Earth did he think he was doing?
“Like as not he was searching for fairies or some such nonsense,” Peony Proudfoot would sniff to her daughter as they worked together in the garden. “It’s a wonder he only broke his arm falling out of that tree. If I ever catch you doing something that dangerous you’ll never see the outside of his house again.”
Her daughter had replied meekly that she wouldn’t, and the subject had turned, but a variation of that same conversation was likely had by all parents and children following that particular adventure of Bilbo’s. For a time his friends had stayed away from him, worried that their parents would assume they were climbing trees, and Bilbo had been miserable. His mother had laughed merrily.
“They’ll come back soon enough,” she assured him, “it’s only that their parents worry, you understand. They don’t quite know what to make of you. That’s okay; they don’t know what to make of me, either.” A fond look stole over her face as his father came into the room. “The only one who ever did was your father,” she said, and Bungo had smiled at her.
“Well, now, that’s not quite true,” he said in his soft, measured voice. “There are plenty of things about you that I don’t understand. I’m having a good time figuring them out, however.” He’d come over and pecked her cheek, ruffled Bilbo’s hair. “You’re a good lad, Bilbo,” he said, “and curiosity is not so bad a thing, after all.”
Bilbo wondered, as he picked his way delicately over piles of gold, what his father would say if he knew that his son was currently deliberately walking very close to a large dragon. He doubted it would be anything good.
Thorin had pulled him aside before he’d entered the tunnel that morning. “We have no proof that Smaug is alive, but there is no need for you to risk yourself. What we really need is proof that the treasure is still there. Don’t risk yourself; grab something small and come back out. Smaug is not to be tangled with.”
“Right,” Bilbo had answered. “I’m sure I’ll be fine.” He had been very glad that his voice did not shake and betray his nervousness. Now that the moment had come, he had been more grateful than ever for his little ring. With its help, he need not deal with the dragon at all, he was sure.
Thorin had hesitated a moment, looking around a little furtively, then spoke. “Should you…there is a stone, within the mountain. It is larger than most, and almost seems to glow. If you should see it, I would very much like you to bring it to me. Don’t go looking for it,” he added hastily, “Just, if you should happen to come across it…”
Bilbo had nodded, and then almost before he knew it he had been walking up the tunnel, escorted by Balin.
“Now, laddie, there’s nothing to it,” Balin had said, and his voice had been shaking. “You’re small and quick; there’s no reason that Smaug should even see you. I’m sure you’ll be fine.”
They stopped where the mouth of the tunnel widened into a room. “Here is where I’ll leave you. Be careful, laddie.”
Bilbo had forced a smile and clasped Balin’s arm. “I’ll be back before you know it,” he said, then took a deep breath and stepped into the room. There was a pause behind him, then the sound of heavy footsteps hurrying away down the tunnel. Bilbo took a deep breath, then slipped on his ring.
The city within the mountain was vast, and had the others not thought to give him an idea of where he would be going Bilbo might have gotten lost. Luckily they had told him how to find the main hall, which is where they thought Bilbo might best be able to get at something to bring back to them, and he found it with little trouble. He entered the room and stared, mouth dropping open.
The room glowed with a faint golden light; Smaug had somehow moved most, if not all, of the gold into the area, and it covered every available surface in a giant pile. Even one step forward would place Bilbo on the gold. In the center of the room the gold bulged slightly. That area pulsed in and out in a regular rhythm, and just underneath it Bilbo could make out blackish-red scales. Smaug is alive then, he thought, but it held little surprise. He had expected something like this. With a small sigh he cast his eyes around, looking for something to pick up and take back with him.
A small, jewel encrusted cup lay near him. Bilbo reached out and grabbed it, and as he did his eye caught on something glowing slightly to his right. He tilted his head to look properly, and there it was, not five feet away. The Arkenstone. The jewel that Thorin had sent him in to find; the stone so precious that he hadn’t been able to convince himself to wait until the dragon was taken care of to obtain it. Bilbo looked between the stone and Smaug, assessing the risk. Smaug appeared to be asleep, and the Arkenstone wasn’t far. If he was very careful and quiet, he was sure he could retrieve it without being caught.
He moved forward cautiously, checking to see that the dragon lump remained unmoving with ever small rustle of clothing or clink of coins. The dragon did not stir. After what seemed like forever but was probably only about a minute, he reached the glowing stone. Up close it was even more impressive: a pure white stone shot through with lodes of red, the center almost seeming to pulse with an orange red glow. Bilbo picked it up and held it to the light, transfixed for a moment, then hurriedly placed it in his pocket. Time to leave. He turned to go.
There was a clinking of many coins next to him as the dragon raised its head. It tilted it’s head, focusing one giant orange eye where Bilbo stood.
“Leaving so soon?” it rumbled. “I’m sure you’d agree that it’s bad manners to enter a home and take something valuable without even stopping to introduce yourself.”
Bilbo slid to the side as fast as he could, taking refuge behind a large chest. “I only wanted to keep from disturbing your slumber, O Smaug, “ he replied, “for though I wished to look upon your fierce and mighty form, I did not want to cause you inconvenience.”
“You came to look upon me, little thief?” Smaug asked, sounding amused. “Then why do you cower and hide. Please, come out and see me, and allow me to see you, as well.”
“Oh no, I couldn’t!” Bilbo cried. “I am very small, and unworthy to be seen next to Smaug, the Greatest and Terribleist of Calamities.”
“I think I will be the judge of that. Pray, what is your name, my tiny new friend-the-thief? You know mine; I would have a fair exchange.”
Bilbo was at a loss. He did not want to give the dragon his name, but he had to answer, and fast.
“I, I am called many things,” he said. “I am Barrel rider, Spider Slayer, and Troll Tricker. I have travelled over hill and under dale, through wood and water. I have braved the dungeons of elves and the lairs of goblins and Gollum-things, all to meet you, O Smaug the Splendiferous.”
“Now, let’s not get carried away,” Smaug answered. “Tell me, brave little Rider, if you have come here only to gaze upon me, then what is my treasure doing in your pocket?”
Bilbo’s eyes widened. “T-treasure?” he stuttered. “In my pocket? What-“
“Do not lie to me! I know each piece of treasure in my possession and I know that two of them currently reside in your thieving little pockets. I knew this day would come; I’ve known for years. Would it surprise you, my little Rider, little Slayer, to know that you positively reek of dwarf?” A large tail came lashing down inches from Bilbo; he shrieked and fled while Smaug laughed.
“Yes, little thief, liar, betrayer, I know who you are with. I know what it is they want, and had I a mind to allow you your life, I would have you tell them that they shall never receive it.” He chuckled, and it began to grow very warm. “As it is, fire and your charred little corpse should convince them quite nicely.”
Bilbo had just enough time to get out of the dragon’s way before fire belched from its mouth, singing the hair on the tops of Bilbo’s feet and causing his hands and arms to blister where they were uncovered. His jacket smoldered slightly, and he beat at it with panicked hands, skittering away as fast as he could.
“Still alive?” Smaug cried, delighted. “You are a quick one! Run, unseen Rider, and perhaps you will escape with your life. Your friends, however, won’t be so lucky.” It rose up to its full height, and Bilbo noticed in a half aware, half panicked way that there was one spot high on its breast that appeared to be missing a scale. That’s where we’ll have to aim, he thought deliriously, then registered what had been said.
“What do you mean, my friends?” he asked, sliding behind a tall column so as to be out of the range of fire. “It is true that I traveled with a Company of dwarves for a time, but we split up just outside the Mirkwood and I haven’t seen them since. They were heading somewhere else.”
“No, they were not. The escorted you here to die for them, and die you shall. But no matter, it was not of them I spoke. They will be easily dealt with once I show your new friends the consequences of aiding thieves.”
“No! No, don’t; they didn’t know what I was doing, that I was coming here, they only wanted to help!” Bilbo cried, flying out from behind the column. He couldn’t let the innocent people of Laketown suffer, not if he could stop it. He tugged the ring off of his finger. “Here I am! If you want to punish someone so badly, I’m right here!”
Smaug regarded him coolly. “You care about them,” it said. “They helped you and you do not want to see them suffer; you feel you owe them a debt.” It smiled, and to Bilbo that smile was the most frightening thing that had happened yet. “I don’t think I will kill you now, little burglar,” it said. “No. You will keep. First, I will destroy Laketown, then your dwarven friends. Then, little burglar, I will come for you. Do try to run; it makes it much more fun.” And with a great roar of fury, Smaug rose into the air, pushed himself out of the main hall, and was gone.
“No, oh no,” Bilbo cried, and ran after. He had no hope of catching the dragon and even less of stopping it, but he ran all the same. At the mouth of the tunnel he collided with Thorin.
“He has gone. Smaug has left the mountain!” Thorin cried, his eyes alight. He gripped Bilbo’s arms “At every turn you surprise me. How did you manage it, Bilbo?”
Bilbo shook his head, trying to speak through his gasps for breath. “No. No, no, no, He’s…he’s angry, he knows they helped, we have to do something.”
“Bilbo, I can’t understand you. What are you saying?”
He struggled out of Thorin’s grasp and stared at him with wide, terrified, eyes. “He’s heading for Laketown! He’s going to destroy it, to punish them for helping us. We have to help them, Thorin!”
Thorin’s eyes widened; he bowed his head. “There is nothing to be done,” he said. “We cannot return fast enough to be of any assistance; the best we can do is get ourselves killed as well.” He paused, then, “We can try to send some notice with a thrush, perhaps, though I doubt it will beat Smaug there.”
“Better than nothing,” Bilbo cried, “Hurry!” He took off down the tunnel, Thorin close behind, and when they got out they located a thrush as speedily as possible and gave him the message, Bilbo only just remembering to add that Smaug had a plate missing before the little bird was off.
“Find Bard, if you can!” Bilbo yelled after it, remembering his solemn face. Bard had believed in the dragon; he would not waste time with unnecessary doubt.
Thorin watched it go, then sighed heavily. “May the wind favor that little bird; may it find its way speedily to the town and give them our message. May they listen, and be saved.” He turned to Bilbo, his face suddenly eager. “Did you see it, Bilbo? The treasure, was it still there?”
Bilbo stared. “Yes,” he said slowly, “the treasure is there, in the main hall. I found-“
“What? What did you find?”
Bilbo hesitated, looking up at Thorin. There was something in his eyes that Bilbo did not like to see. He reached into his pocket.
“I found a cup,” he said, pulling it out and showing them all. Thorin took it; he studied it a moment then passed it on to Fili, and it continued to pass from hand to hand as Bilbo spoke. “I grabbed it and tried to leave, but Smaug must have heard me, because he woke up and I had to hide. But he knew I was there, and he knew what I’d taken.” Bilbo bowed his head, tears filling his eyes as he thought of the suffering that was about to be brought down on the heads of the people of Laketown. “Now he’s after them and it’s all my fault.”
“You can’t think like that, laddie,” Balin said, putting a hand on his shoulder. “The dragon would not have slept much longer; it is not in their natures to be dormant for long.”
Bilbo shook his head. “I know you’re trying to comfort me, and I appreciate it,” he said, “but Smaug is going after Laketown because they helped us, and because he knew that I-I care about what happens to them.” He stared off the way that Smaug had flown, and could just make out the sight of a tiny black speck shooting flames. He clenched his fists.
The others surrounded him and they all watched for what felt like hours, each hoping to see the black speck fall, but it did not. They packed tightly together as though they were freezing, their eyes wide and terrified as they watched Laketown burn. Bilbo soon began to give up hope. It was over; the thrush had perished in its mission, or Bard had died before he could be told of the scales. Bilbo wanted to bury his face in his hands, but he refused. This was his fault, and he would force himself to watch every single agonizing moment of it. He did not know it, but he had begun to cry. Bofur reached out and grasped his arm; Bilbo groped for his fingers and held them tightly without looking away.
“Mahal’s sake,” whispered Gloin, “Will it ever stop?”
Bilbo shook his head. “Not until the entire city is reduced to ashes,” he replied, voice choked. “Not until-wait! Wait, did you see that? Just now! It fell! The dragon fell, I saw it!” He strained forward, pulling out of Bofur’s grasp and nearly dangling over the edge of the cliff they were standing on. More than one pair of hands pulled him back as his friends cried out in alarm.
“I think he’s right!” Ori yelled excitedly, thumping Bilbo on the back. “The dragon Smaug has been felled!”
“It was your message, Bilbo; it told them how to stop the dragon,” Fili said, beaming, and Bilbo shook his head.
“That wasn’t my idea, it was Thorin’s. Thorin! The dragon is dead.” He turned to share a grin with him at the good news, then frowned as he realized he was nowhere to be seen. “Where is Thorin?”
“Over there, near the mountain,” Kili answered, pointing. “He started that way the second you said you’d seen Smaug fall, Bilbo.” He laughed, “He must be in a hurry to air out the stench of dragon.”
Bilbo did not laugh. Nor did Balin or Fili, he saw, though the others seemed amused enough at Kili’s statement. Both were staring at Thorin’s rapidly retreating back with faint frowns creasing their foreheads.
~****~
As the days wore on, Bilbo became more and more concerned with the way Thorin was acting. He had thought that the king would want to begin the process of rebuilding Erebor right away after taking it back; that he would at least wish to fortify it and make some rooms inhabitable for the company. Thorin, however, had other ideas. Everything was postponed in the search for the Arkenstone, and what time wasn’t spent searching was spent in counting the massive amounts of treasure that lay within the hall; counting and cataloguing and though it pained Bilbo to think it, gloating. Thorin’s mind was consumed with wealth, and he could see little else beyond his obsession.
Worse, the madness was starting to affect the others. The more time that they spent counting gold and gems and looking, always looking for the heirloom which they would not find, the more their eyes began to glow with the same fever that was in Thorin’s. They began to care less about other things: Ori quit making hints about visiting the library, Bombur complained less about his stomach, the grumbling about lack of sleep trickled to nothing. Even Fili and Kili seemed to take less joy in their normal mischief, though whatever madness had infected the others appeared to affect them the least. Bilbo suspected that Kili’s infatuation with the elven lass and Fili’s subsequent worry had something to do with it.
Kili would often steal away outside to gaze into the distance and brood, and Fili was never far behind, so they were the first ones to notice that Dale had become populated once again, this time with refugees from Laketown. They called Bilbo outside to look first.
“They’re going to come here to ask for help,” Fili said, “to claim their share of the riches of Erebor. I do not think that Thorin will like that much.”
“No,” Bilbo said absently, looking at the fires being built in the ruins of the old city. “I don’t think he will.” He looked at the other two, who were both fidgeting. “I don’t understand why you’re telling me this, to be honest. In the end, it’s Thorin’s decision whether or not to help, isn’t it?”
“We-ell yes, but we hoped that if you were the one to tell him, things would go more smoothly-“
“-considering you’re the only one he listens to anymore-“
“-the only one who can pull his attention from the gold-“
“-or the Arkenstone-“
“-so you might be their only hope!”
Bilbo stared. “You’re joking,” he replied flatly. “You’re going to send me in there on the hope that Thorin might listen to me. He never listens to anything I say.”
“That’s not exactly true, though,” Fili said earnestly. “He does listen to you. He actually manages to pay attention to you for about five minutes every day, and that’s more than the rest of us get.”
“You might not realize, because he usually saves the love-sick looks for when you’re not paying attention,” Kili added with a grin, but it was a shadow of his old one. Too little sleep had put dark circles under his eyes, and he leaned against the side of the mountain as though it was the only thing propping him up.
Bilbo frowned at him. “Have you been taking care of yourself at all?” he demanded.
Kili waved him off. “Never mind me; I’m just tired.” He smiled slyly. “I’ll promise to get some rest tonight if you promise to talk to Thorin.”
Bilbo sighed. “Fine, I’ll talk to him. Not that it’ll make any difference. But both of you are going to get a decent night’s sleep if I do, understand?”
“Yes, Uncle Bilbo,” they chorused, and Bilbo rolled his eyes.
Figuring there was no time like the present, Bilbo left the two and went to seek out Thorin. He wasn’t hard to find, as he hardly ever left his treasure, but Bilbo planned on making him this time.
When Thorin caught sight of him, his face lit up. “Bilbo!” he cried, striding forward, and Bilbo thought for a moment that he might actually listen to him.
“Have you come to help?” Thorin asked. “We could use your eyes.”
“What? Oh, no, I’m not here about that. Thorin-“
“You have not once helped us search,” Thorin said, eyes narrowing. “Why is that, Master Baggins?”
Bilbo sighed. “If it means that much to you, I’ll help later. But first, I wanted to talk to you about-“
“Why later? Why not now?”
“Because I’m trying to talk to you, Thorin!” Bilbo yelled, exasperated. The small amount of chatter that had been going on around them ceased as everyone turned to stare at the two of them. Lowering his voice, Bilbo continued, “Because I’m trying to tell you something, if you would but listen. Because the people of Laketown need our help, and I was hoping-“
“The people of Laketown are here?”
Bilbo ground his teeth together. “No, they are not,” he replied, forcing himself to speak calmly. “They are currently in Dale, but I think that at some point they will-“
“Everyone! To the gate!” Thorin cried, and moved past Bilbo, his face hard and cold. Bilbo watched him go, shaking his head. He had a feeling that when the people of Laketown did make it to Erebor, they would not like the welcome they received.
Thorin insisted that they place a watch on Dale, so they were well aware when the elves joined the men in Dale, and fully prepared to receive the lone rider that came to them early the next morning. Bilbo recognized Bard from a distance and let out a small sound of relief. Thorin heard it and shot him a dark look. “You know that man?” he asked, and Bilbo nodded.
“We met on our last night in Laketown. He bought me a drink and we spoke a bit; he was the one I sent the thrush to.” He hesitated, then recklessly pushed forward. “They were very hospitable, the people of Laketown, weren’t they? Very accommodating.”
Thorin did not answer, merely turned his head to watch Bard ride up.
“Well met, King Thorin,” Bard called up to him. “And how are you faring this morning?”
“Well enough, Master Bard.”
“I am glad to hear it. I wish I could say the same for my people. Will you not speak to me?”
Thorin made a slight nod and moved down the stairs to where there was a small place in which the two of them could speak. Bilbo could not make out their words from where he stood, but he could see Thorin’s face grow more and more cold, and he could tell by the tone of their voices that the argument was growing heated. Finally Bard said something that made Thorin snap. He yelled at him to get away before an arrow was put into his head, and he reared back from his own spot in a fury, his face a thundercloud.
“So this is what the word of Thorin Oakenshield comes to?” Bard cried. “Make no mistake, if you do not aid us you will have your war.” He climbed back on his horse and rode back to Dale, where Bilbo knew he would have to tell his people as well as the elves that there would be no help from the dwarves of Erebor.
Then what Bard had said registered. “War?” he asked, and Balin let out a small sigh.
“Those people deserve some recompense for what we brought on their heads,” he said, “and they will be willing to fight for it. Without our help they may not survive.”
“Then they should ask the elves, as they seem so willing to help,” Dwalin retorted, and the others made noises of agreement.
Balin shook his head wearily. “You know as well as I do what King Thranduil is hoping to gain from aiding the folk of Laketown. He hopes to lay claim on a share of the mountain’s treasure – there are gems here which he has always coveted.”
“I don’t care about Thranduil,” Bilbo said, “but we do owe the people of Laketown. Why can’t Thorin see that?”
“You best stop talking now, Burglar, before you get yourself in trouble. Those that don’t know of what they speak would do better to keep their mouths shut,” Dwalin told him, glaring. Bilbo looked around and noticed that none of his friends seemed particularly friendly, all of the sudden. Only Balin and Kili looked like they agreed with Bilbo at all, and even their glances were reproachful.
He put up his hands in surrender. “My apologies. I meant no disrespect. I just want to repay our debt, is all.”
Dwalin’s expression softened. “I understand, but that isn’t your decision.” He smiled. “When we find the Arkenstone, Thorin will calm down. He’s just upset because we haven’t found it yet.” He clapped Bilbo on the shoulder, then headed off to resume the search, all but Balin following.
The old dwarf looked very troubled as he gazed towards Dale, and Bilbo checked over his shoulder to make sure the others were gone before asking quietly, “Do you think that Thorin would be better with the Arkenstone? If we were to find it, I mean?”
Balin shook his head. “Thorin sees that stone as the symbol of his right to rule. His grandfather felt the same, and his greed for it drew a dragon down upon us. No, laddie. I do not think that having the Arkenstone would do anything less than make Thorin’s sickness even worse.” He wiped at his eyes absently. “I had hoped that the gold lust would not touch him; that he would be able to resist it. He had to go through so much, I thought that surely he would be able to fight the madness that has always run through his line. It seems I was wrong. It has taken hold, and I fear that nothing will loosen its grip.”
“Is there no way to make him see sense?”
“Greed is a powerful thing, laddie. His grandfather lost a kingdom to it and still it consumed him. I do believe that Thorin is stronger than his grandfather; but I cannot guess what it would take to knock the sickness loose. It might take a war.” And Balin turned his head back towards Dale, lost in his own thoughts.
Later that day Bilbo was summoned to Thorin’s side as he wandered about, pretending to look for the Arkenstone but in truth pondering all that had happened since they had opened the door. He went to Thorin with some reluctance, not wanting to deal with this new Thorin who could not see reason. He was pleased to see that his friend’s eyes were mostly clear, however, and he was holding something behind his back.
“I want you to have this,” he said, and brought his hands around with a flourish to show off a brilliant mail coat made of some sort of shimmery material. “Mithril,” he said, handing it over. “It is the strongest material that we have ever crafted; when you wear this, no spear or arrow will pierce where it covers. Try it on.”
Bilbo took the mail and slipped it over his head. It went nearly to his knees, and he smiled, thinking how ridiculous he must appear. He turned the smile on Thorin, ready to share the joke, but the look on the other’s face stopped him. Thorin did not look like he thought the sight of Bilbo in a mithril coat was amusing in the least. There was something fierce in his eyes, something almost greedy, but not the same greed that the gold inspired. This greed caused Bilbo to shiver, and not only with fear. “Thorin,” he started, and then found his arm grasped and his body steered into a small alcove, away from the rest of the Company.
“I’ve been thinking,” Thorin said, and Bilbo’s mouth went dry. Had the sight of Bilbo in mithril somehow broken through to the old Thorin Oakenshield? Could Thorin really be asking what it seemed, right now, once again at the worst possible time? What would he say if he was? Should he do what his heart wanted and accept, even if it brought them both nothing but pain?
He was so focused on his own whirling thoughts that he missed Thorin’s next sentence. “I beg your pardon?”
“I said, I’ve been thinking, and I know now why we haven’t found the Arkenstone. One of them is false. One of them has betrayed me.”
“One of them…Thorin, you can’t be serious.” Bilbo felt very foolish indeed. Of course Thorin’s mind was still on the Arkenstone; it would take more than Bilbo Baggins to divert his thoughts. “They are your friends; your kin. They followed you all this way because they love you, and now you want to believe them false? Think about what you’re saying!”
“Then why haven’t we found it? We’ve searched everywhere, and have nothing to show for it. How is that possible, if one of them has not taken it?”
“You’ve hardly searched everywhere; that’s not possible. The stone could be anywhere. It could be buried at the bottom of all this gold. No one has betrayed you, Thorin.” Bilbo bit his lip uncertainly, then plunged ahead. “I’ve been thinking as well. It’s occurred to me that I also gave my word to the people of Laketown, that I would repay them for the kindness that they showed us.
“It was nobly done,” Thorin agreed, grasping his shoulder and giving a light squeeze, “but I fail to see how-“
“Well, I was thinking…why don’t we give them my fourteenth share?” Thorin stared at him, and Bilbo hurried to explain. “A fourteenth of this vast treasure is far more than I could spend in twenty lifetimes. I really don’t need it all, so I was thinking that we could perhaps let the people of Laketown have it, to rebuild. I’d feel much better if that were the case.” He looked up hopefully, but Thorin’s face had closed down.
“You do not want your share.”
“It isn’t that, truly. It’s more that I don’t need all of it, and if it could help prevent war…”
“Did Fili put you up to this?”
Bilbo blinked, bewildered. “What? No, of course he didn’t. I came up with this all on my own. Thorin-“
“Where were they,” Thorin said, his voice harsh, “when Smaug first came? Where was the sympathy of men when we were the ones starving, burnt and begging for even a scrap of food? Where were they through the years that followed? Oh, they offered us food and warm beds enough when they thought they stood a chance to gain, but when there was no hope of a reward beyond doing a kindness, they turned us away, and you would have me part with my treasure to satisfy their greed? No, I think not.” He turned away from Bilbo and strode down the hall. “If you have no need for your share of the treasure we will be glad to hold on to it, and please tell my ungrateful nephew that heirs can always be changed.”
Bilbo stared after him, mouth open. “Of all the pig headed, unreasonable, stubborn…hold on to it indeed! As if he ever intended to part with even a coin; not the way his mind’s been poisoned. Heirs can be changed, can they? Poor Fili, he must have tried to talk some sense into Thorin as well. I do hope he didn’t take anything that Thorin said to him to heart; he is not himself. Well, Bilbo Baggins, your great plan came to nothing. What now?”
Bilbo found a spot by himself. He sat down and thought for a long time. Once or twice he pulled out the Arkenstone and stared at it, lost in thought. It was a pretty gem, to be sure, but it was still just a stone. He turned it over and over in his hands, and as the sun set over the mountain, he suddenly realized what he had to do.
That night, after all the others had finally given up preparing for the morning’s battle and gone to sleep, Bilbo snuck away. He waited until he was out of sight of everyone then slipped on his ring, hurrying to drop a rope over the side of the mountain and climb down. He had to be swift; he had to finish his task and be back before first light.
It seemed to him, as he ran, that there was a voice in his ear, encouraging him to simply get away. What did he owe any of them, really? The voice asked. He’d done his part. He should take the Arkenstone and the ring and go, disappear into the night and leave the others to their fate. Bilbo shook these thoughts out of his mind - they frightened him because they did not sound precisely like his own – and sped up. He reached Dale late into the night, and he hoped that Bard would still be awake at such a late hour.
He was. In fact, he was in an audience with King Thranduil and none other than Gandalf, and they all stared in amazement when Bilbo appeared in front of them. Bard and Gandalf smiled to see him, but Thranduil merely regarded him coolly.
“And how did you get in here, when I left specific instructions that we were not to be disturbed?” he asked, and Bilbo sketched a small bow, hurriedly pocketing his ring. He thought he saw Gandalf’s eyes track the movement, but they glanced away so fast he could hardly be sure.
“I have my ways, Majesty,” he answered, “and I’d be glad to explain them to you, but now really isn’t the time.”
Thranduil’s eyes narrowed, but Bard grinned. “A nice way to get around the question,” he said with some amusement, “and one that I might not let you get away with, were you not so very correct. There is little time for explanations that can wait until later. I don’t think you came here with the leave of your King Under the Mountain.”
“No,” Bilbo agreed, “Thorin will not yield. He will fight you over the gold in the mountain, and he will die. I-I wish to prevent that, if I can.” And he reached into his pocket and brought out the Arkenstone.
Three sets of eyes widened as they beheld the stone, glimmering softly in the candlelight. “You are far braver than I would have thought, Master Baggins,” Bard said finally, meeting Bilbo’s eyes. “I have heard tales of this gem, and I cannot believe that he parted with this willingly.”
“Of course he didn’t,” Thranduil snapped, impatient. “Obviously it was stolen.” He gave Bilbo a disdainful glance. “Tell us why we should trust a thief to keep his word.”
Gandalf started to speak, but Bilbo interrupted. “I’m no theif. Well, I am, but I haven’t taken anything that wasn’t owed me. Thorin promised me a fourteenth of the treasure; I took this as my share.” He looked at Bard. “If you take this to him and offer to trade, he will. He values it more than anything, at the moment. Only, don’t be too hard on him; don’t tease him unnecessarily. He is not himself.”
“And what if we were to take the stone and be on our way?”
Bilbo looked at Thranduil calmly. He did not know why the elf wanted to provoke him so badly, but he refused to rise to it. “You won’t. What would be the point, when you have someone who would be more than willing to pay any price for it so close? I do think that there are things in the mountain you want, but this stone is not one of them. I don’t know why you dislike Thorin so much, but I do know that in spite of it you’ll offer to trade the stone, because it is the best option.” He gave Bard and Gandalf a smile, and nodded at Thranduil, who he had greatly impressed with his words and actions, though he did not know it. “And now I must be getting back before I am missed. Good luck.”
“Will you go? Thorin’s wrath will be fierce when he finds out. If you wish it, you may take refuge with us.” The offer, surprisingly, came from Thranduil, and Bilbo offered him a tentative smile.
“I know that he will be furious, but I cannot betray him twice over. Thank you for the offer, but I must go back.”
Thranduil returned the smile, and Bard shook his head. “I wish you would stay,” he said, “but I can tell you will not change your mind. Good luck, brave Bilbo. I hope that everything works out peacefully.” He took Bilbo’s hand in his and gave it a firm shake. “You are a rare sort of fellow; would that there were more in this world like you.”
Gandalf stood. “I will walk with you for a time,” he said, and ushered Bilbo out of the tent. They walked in silence for a while, and then Gandalf stopped. “I can’t join you just yet,” he said. “There is much to be done before the morning. Are you sure you will not stay? Thorin will not lightly forgive what you have done.”
Bilbo sighed heavily. “I know. But I can’t steal away into the night; I can’t. I have to hope that he is able to forgive me.”
“It is not his forgiveness you should be worried about, it is his temper. I worry that he may harm you.”
“Harm me? Thorin? I know that he’s succumbed to gold madness, but surely I needn’t fear he will harm me.”
Gandalf looked at Bilbo gravely. “You do not understand how bad of a temper Thorin Oakenshield has. If I thought I could keep you safe by demanding you stay with Bard and Thranduil, I would, but I know you would just sneak away. But be careful, Bilbo.”
“I will, I promise.” Bilbo reached up and curled a hand around one of Gandalf’s wrists; he squeezed lightly. “I have a feeling everything will turn out fine.”
“You are a very good sort of fellow, Bilbo Baggins, and very brave,” Gandalf said wryly, “but you’re an awfully bad liar.”
