Actions

Work Header

Starting a Stone

Chapter 3

Notes:

. . . I've done a bit of retconning in regards to the dates, because I don't know why I thought it would be autumn. It's not. It's May. A few details in earlier chapters have been changed to reflect this. The seasons may now carry on as they should. Sorry for the confusion.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

When Prim returns, some hours later, with no news of Bilbo and the sharp pinch of worry around her mouth, she finds Bag End neat and orderly, smelling of lemon and soap, everything tucked away in perhaps not its proper place but at least a place where it fits. Thorin is sitting on the front step, hammering out the hinge pins until they’re straight again. Prim leans in, looks over his shoulder, and says, “You didn’t have to do that.”

            Thorin shrugs, and doesn’t look up.

            “No, I mean it. I saw what state the place was in. I would have cleaned it up.”

            “You had other things to do,” Thorin says, and adds, truthfully—a little bitterly—“I didn’t.”

            “Well, thank you.”

            “You didn’t find him, then?”

            “No, but we’re still looking. The Shire is larger than it seems, you know. Look, it’s nearly noon. Why don’t you take a break, and we’ll see what’s in Bilbo’s pantry for luncheon?”

            “There’s nothing in his pantry,” Thorin says. “I checked. I don’t know what he’s been eating, these past few days, but apart from a few potatoes and a barrel of apples, and your basket of pastries, there’s no food in the place. What was left about the kitchen was days old, or weeks. Some of it untouched.”

            Prim’s face falls. “I didn’t know he wasn’t eating,” she says. “I should have come to check on him sooner.”

            “He looked fine last night. And we were going to have tea this afternoon.”

            “Hobbits eat at least six meals a day. One afternoon tea is nothing. It’s unheard of. It’s . . . I’m worried. I had no idea it was this bad.” Prim twists the fabric of her skirt in her hands, and then smoothes it out. “Right. There’s one last place I have to check.”

            “I’m coming with you,” Thorin says, standing.

            “That’s not—”

            “I’m coming.”

            “Hmm.”

            Thorin stares her down, not arguing, not directly, but argumentative all the same.

            “Fine, but keep quiet about it.” Leading the way, Prim takes them around the back side of Bag End, past the windows cut into the gentle slope of the hillside. “This is Bindbole Wood,” Prim tells Thorin as they leave cleared fields for high, close trees. “Stick close to me. It’s easy to lose your way.”

            “You really think he’s in here?” Thorin asks, ducking under a branch. He still can’t name Bilbo, can’t think of him as the same person as Bo Took.

            “We used to come here as kids. No one really does anymore, so it’s the perfect hideout.”

            “I can see why.” Thorin winces as he pushes through a tangle of branches that leave scratches down the side of his face and arms. Twigs snag in his hair, ruining whatever braids he has left since he last bothered to fix them. He isn’t wearing armour and again wishes for it. When he goes to free his axe, thinking to clear a path, Prim stops him with a hand on his arm.

            “Don’t,” she says. “Not here.”

            “We can hardly get through.”

            “That’s the point of a hideout. Come on, it’s not much farther.”

            It’s easy enough for her, Thorin thinks; she’s smaller, lighter, more agile. She can duck under the lower branches with ease, sure on her bare feet while Thorin smacks his head on things and trips over roots that catch at his boots. Just as he’s feeling he’d rather set the place alight than fight his way through any longer, they come out into a small, low clearing. The forest floor has sunk beneath them; Thorin can hear running water, faintly, not a stream but perhaps a little brook somewhere off to the side. The ground is mossy and the air is still. Even though they’re out of the trees branches still crowd the sky overhead, arcing up around them on all sides. In the center of the clearing is a tree larger than any Thorin’s ever seen, though the ground it stands on is so low that it looks no taller than the rest of the forest. Part of the way up the trunk there’s a hole, wide and dark.

            “Stay here,” Prim says, and picks her way forward to the tree, hardly making a sound. Thorin looks around, listening, waiting. When Prim reaches the tree she pushes herself up on tip-toe, grabs the edge of the hole, and hauls herself inside the trunk. There’s a muffled thump as she—presumably—falls inside, and then a moment of tense silence. “Thorin! Come here!” she shouts, her voice muffled by the wood. Thorin, boots slipping on the mossy ground, runs for the tree. Standing on one of the roots, he can look down into the hollowed out trunk. Prim is crouched next to Bilbo, who appears to be asleep. “Help me lift him out,” she says, and hauls Bilbo’s arm across her shoulders, drags him upright. Leaning into the opening, Thorin catches Bilbo’s hands and pulls. The angle is awkward and a strain on his back but Bilbo is surprisingly light. Prim gives a shove from below and Thorin gets an armful of limp Hobbit. He lays Bilbo down at the base of the trunk and drops his arm back inside to help Prim out. Something in the wood shivers, a dry rustling in the otherwise quiet afternoon, and though Thorin’s eyes may not be as keen as a Hobbit’s he turns to look into the dark trees, breath caught in his throat.

            “We should get him out of here,” he says, as soon as Prim’s found her feet.

            “I thought that’s what we were doing.” And then Prim looks around, and her face falls, and she says, “Right, let’s be quick about it. You take his legs.”

            Thorin bends and lifts Bilbo entirely, putting the Hobbit over his shoulders, legs on the left and arms on the right. He gets hold of Bilbo’s right hand across his chest, wraps his other arm around Bilbo’s legs, and straightens up. “I’ve got him. You lead,” Thorin tells Prim. She looks him over, one eyebrow raised. Doubtful. “It’s faster this way,” Thorin says. “Go.”

            The forest around them seems closer than before, its branches sharper, paths darker. Prim loses her footing and catches her dress on brambles; the cloth tears before she can pull free. Thorin’s chest is tight, as if he can’t get enough air. Slung across his shoulders, Bilbo is barely breathing. “Hurry up,” Thorin rasps.

            “I’m trying,” Prim snaps back, sidling around a tree that’s blocking their way. It takes them longer to get out than it did to get in and Thorin tries to shake off the feeling that they’re growing in circles. This forest is practically in Bilbo’s backyard; he and Prim used to play in it when they were young. They can’t be lost. It’s just a trick of the light. “Almost there, now,” Prim says. “Watch your step.”

            Through a gap in the leaves, Thorin can see blue sky, fence posts. Prim disappears up ahead. Thorin emerges into sunlight blinded and sinks to his knees as soon as they’re free of the trees. The air is crisp, the wind touched with damp, and he feels suddenly foolish for his moment of near-panic. For someone who has spent so much time in the dark places of the world, he should hardly fear a forest. It’s not as if the forest can collapse in on him, or any number of things that a mountain can do when things go wrong.

            “You all right?” Prim asks. “I can carry him for a bit, or fetch someone to help.”

            “I’m fine.” Thorin stands up again, resettles Bilbo on his shoulders. “Let’s get him inside.”

            They lay Bilbo down on his bed—freshly straightened by Thorin, along with the rest of the rooms—and crack the window open. While Prim sets about making tea in the kitchen, Thorin sits in a chair beside the bed and watches the breeze play with Bilbo’s curls, studies the face of a man he’s not sure he knows. “What was that place?” Thorin asks Prim when she returns. “That tree.”

            “I told you. Bindbole Wood.”

            “What’s wrong with it?”

            “There’s nothing wrong with it. It’s just an old wood.”

            “And he’s just sleeping, is he?” Thorin asks, gesturing towards Bilbo. Prim has the good grace to look caught in a lie. With a sigh, she settles herself at the foot of the bed.

            “I don’t know what’s wrong with Bilbo. But Bindbole Wood really is just old, I swear. Most avoid it because there’s nothing in there, just a lot of trees, and you saw how difficult it is to walk. Hobbits don’t like dark spaces, for all that we live in holes in the ground. We like light, air, open fields. Bilbo and I took to exploring there whenever we wanted to get away from it all. We found that tree years ago. We used to have tea parties inside.” Prim puts her hand over Bilbo’s ankle. “His parents never minded but mine would shout if they knew I’d been so we kept it secret. It’s just suspicion, nothing more.”

            “That is not what your face said in that clearing.”

            “I was worried,” Prim says. “And hungry. We never did have luncheon.”

            Thorin sighs. What had Bo said to him, the other night, about keeping secrets? It must run in the family. “Fine, then. Go and eat. Leave me that tea. I’ll see if I can wake him.”

            “Sorry, but even though you’ve just carried him out on your back, I’m not leaving you alone with my cousin. I hardly know you, or what you want from him.” Prim stands, walks to the other side of the bed. “Bilbo?” she asks, and shakes him gently. “Wake up, Bilbo.”

            “Does your village have a healer?” Thorin asks.

            “Not quite. Bilbo, come on, wake up.” Prim shakes him a little harder, and props a pillow behind his head. “He probably just got tired, or hit his head, or . . .”

            Thorin is watching when Bilbo opens his eyes. It’s brief, so quick he might have imagined it, but there’s a moment when those eyes are liquid-dark and Thorin could swear he’s looking at Bo. Then the Hobbit blinks, and groans, and once again it’s Bilbo lying there, ashen-faced, pushing Prim’s hands away. “Stop shaking me,” he grumbles. “I’m going to be sick.”

            “Here,” Thorin says, and offers his arm, thinking to help Bilbo to the sink. Bilbo leans forward, starts to rise, and throws up over Thorin’s boots. “Or not,” Thorin sighs.

            “I’m sorry, I’m so sorry,” Bilbo is saying, his eyes watering as he wipes at his mouth with his sleeve.

            “It’s all right, ssssh, you’re fine. Go and get some towels, would you? And water?” Prim rubs Bilbo’s back, her hands soothing and steady. “Thorin,” she says, “towels?”

            “Hang on.” Thorin grimaces as he sits and unlaces his boots. He leaves them on the floor and heads off in his socks, disgruntled. Half of him means to leave Bag End entirely, leave Bilbo to Prim’s care and write the whole thing off as a mistake. He surprises even himself when he goes back to the bedroom, some towels over one shoulder, a basin of water in his hands. Prim takes a towel and begins to mop up the floor. Thorin dips another towel into the basin and holds it out for Bilbo, who takes it and wipes his mouth and hands.

            “Sorry,” Bilbo says again.

            “It’s fine,” Thorin tells him, though it’s really not. His boots have seen worse, sure, but not for a long time, and then he had other pairs. These are the only ones he has. They’re going to be a pain to clean.

            “Not much of an introduction.” Bilbo reaches up and pulls another towel off Thorin’s shoulders, wets it and drapes it across the back of his neck.

            “Introduction?” Prim asks, looking up from the floor. “You two met yesterday. Or were you lying to me about that, too?” she asks Thorin.

            “I didn’t lie to you!” Thorin snaps. Bilbo winces at the noise. Quieter, Thorin continues, “We did meet last night. I’m sure he’s just . . . ill. Or forgetful.”

            “Bilbo, would you give us a minute?” Prim grabs Thorin by the arm and pushes him out of the bedroom. After closing the door behind them she rounds on him, small and purposeful and earnest. “I need you to be honest with me. You know more than you’re letting on and I don’t have any answers of my own, so I need yours. Now.”

            “I don’t have any answers.”

            “Liar.”

            “I don’t. And you know more as well.” Thorin stares her down. “Whatever’s going on in this place . . .”

            “Is none of your concern,” Prim replies. “Now why don’t you tell me who you really are?”

             “I did tell you. I’ve taken on work as a blacksmith. Ask—”

            “I don’t care about whatever you’ve done for the miller. I care about what you’re doing to my cousin.”

            “. . . I’m not doing anything to him.”

            “Oh no?”

            “No.”

            They face off in the hall, both with their arms crossed, neither willing to be the first to break the silence. Thorin glances down at his feet, uncomfortable without his boots. Prim has leaves in her hair, hints of Bindbole Wood. Their standoff is unbroken until Bilbo opens the door behind them, causing them both to jump. “If you’re finished talking about me,” Bilbo grouses, “I have questions of my own.”

            “And if we’re not finished?” Prim asks him.

            “Well, then . . . It’s my house. We’re civilised folk. Let’s take this into the sitting room and talk about it like adults. Er, after I get a clean shirt, that is.” Bilbo retreats back into the bedroom, leaving Prim and Thorin to stare each other down. At last Prim huffs and shakes her head, goes off to the kitchen. Thorin loiters by the bedroom door, catches a glimpse of Bilbo undressing—stomach, bare arms, tousled hair—before tearing himself away and stomping into the sitting room where Prim’s laid out tea and her pastries.

            Thorin watches Bilbo eat; more precisely, he watches Bilbo pick apart the pastry piece by piece rather than eat it, and tries to square it with the Hobbit who devoured everything on his plate the other night in Michel Delving. They can’t be the same. Prim puts away at least three pastries and two cups of tea before saying anything more, while Thorin eats about seven and no tea.

            “So,” Bilbo says, clearing his throat. “What are you doing here?”

            “What do you remember?” Thorin asks, before Prim can answer.

            Bilbo frowns. “Can we start . . . elsewhere?” The thing is, he doesn’t remember anything, beyond a knock at his door last night. He supposes it must have been Thorin, though what they talked about he couldn’t say. Then he supposes he must have fallen asleep, and had some sort of nightmare. None of this explains why Prim’s got leaves in her hair and Thorin’s face is scratched, or why they both smell so strongly of the earth, or why Bilbo feels as if he’s run halfway across the Shire in his sleep. There is definitely something wrong with him. “Please?”

            “Why aren’t you eating?” Prim asks.

            “Not hungry,” Bilbo says, and then looks down at the mess of crumbs he’s made and winces. The table is startlingly clean, and he’s gone and ruined it.

            “Bilbo.”

            “What, Prim? I’ve just emptied my stomach on our guest’s shoes. I’m not really feeling up to pastries at the moment, thank you.”

            “Your pantry’s practically empty,” Prim says.

            “Is it?” Bilbo responds, mildly. “I meant to go to the market today. I’ll fill it again.” How had he let it get empty? Didn’t he buy groceries just the other day? Bilbo rubs at his temples, closes his eyes.

            “Fill it, and let it rot,” Thorin says, his voice rough against the silence in the room. “Do you remember where you were two nights ago?”

            Bilbo is quiet. “Home,” he says after a while. “Asleep.”

            “Do you have a brother?”

            “No.” Bilbo shakes his head. “No, why on earth would you ask that?”

            “Have you heard the name Bo Took before?” Thorin presses.

            “I know the Tooks, of course. My cousins. But there’s no one called Bo.” Bilbo turns to Prim. “Are you hearing this?” he asks. “What do you make of it?”

            “I know you don’t have a brother,” Prim says, “or any cousin called Bo. But this one’s convinced you do. Has a sketch and everything. Show him, Thorin.”

            Thorin reaches into his pocket for the portrait and comes up empty. It’s not in his tunic, or his cloak. “It’s gone,” he says, more to himself than to the other two. “But how . . .?”

            “We found you in Bindbole Wood,” Prim tells Bilbo, with a significant look. “In that old tree.”

            Bilbo bites his lip and turns away. “I’m tired,” he says, his voice gone cold. “I’d like you to leave now.”

            “But—”

            “Now,” Bilbo repeats. “Please, and thank you.”

            “I’m not leaving.” Prim stands up, hands on her hips. “Not until I know you’re all right.”

            “I’m fine.”

            “You are not.”

            “Prim, please? We’ll talk tomorrow. I just want to rest.” Bilbo gives her his best beseeching eyes and, predictably, she caves.

            “Fine, but I’m coming back first thing, and you are going to eat breakfast. A proper breakfast.”

            “Wonderful,” Bilbo tells her. “First thing. Yes.”

            “Come on, then,” Prim says, inclining her head towards Thorin. “You and I are going to have a talk.”

            Bilbo watches them go from his kitchen windows. Only when they’re down the path and safely out of sight does he pour the remainder of his tea down the sink and retreat to his bedroom. He still doesn’t have a front door, which is the main source of his worries. He could barricade himself in the back study, he supposes, but what’s the point if he can, apparently, get out anyway? “Really, I hate you,” he says to the empty room, to the mirror over his dressing table. He’s not an idiot; he knows there’s something going on that he doesn’t understand. Leaning down, supporting himself on outstretched hands, Bilbo studies his own face in the mirror and tries to remember. Yesterday. Last night. This morning. Time has never been this confused for him before.

            He’d been going to visit the Old Took. At least, that’s what he’d planned to do. Apparently he’d ended up in the Wood instead, hiding out in the hollow tree. Apparently, he’s also got a cousin or a brother or a stranger called Bo Took who wears his face. Presumably, wears his clothes. “Bo Took,” he says, shaping the words, tasting them. “Is that your name, then? You might have chosen a better one.” Bilbo laughs a little, bitterly, and he’s not sure it’s entirely his own laugh. It’s awful, not knowing your own self. It’s awful and he hates it.

            There are a few daylight hours left that he knows he should go out and take advantage of, but he’s exhausted. What he wants is a bath, and his dressing gown, and to warm his toes by the fire. Bilbo tears his gaze away from the mirror—it’s unsettling, watching and waiting for something to change—and goes out into the hall. He avoids any glimpses of the vacant front doorway, and so doesn’t see Thorin there, silhouetted against the garden gate, standing guard.

 

----

 

For all that he tells himself there’s no point to it, Thorin can’t bring himself to walk away from Bag End. If anyone asks, he reasons, he’ll tell them he’s watching over the place, since there’s still a gaping hole where the door should be. No one does ask, though, either too intimidated or simply disinterested. Prim had dragged Thorin back to the Green Dragon, interrogated him over pints about his intentions and his schemes—her words, not his—and while he had generally been honest with her, he hadn’t been entirely forthcoming. There is something going on here that he doesn’t yet understand. More curious is the fact that, no matter how much he wants to see Bo again, Thorin can’t quite get Bilbo out of his mind either. And that, to him, makes no sense at all. He should only be interested in one or the other. Not both, and especially not both equally, not when he was about to go to bed with Bo and all he knows of Bilbo is the lightness of his body when slung across one’s shoulders. Leaning against the gate, arms crossed over his chest, Thorin ignores the chill of the night wind through his cloak and keeps his eyes trained on the windows of Bag End, watching for lights, shadows, movement. The place is quiet. Perhaps Bilbo has gone to sleep.

            While he waits, Thorin finds himself wishing he had his harp. It would give his cold fingers something to do; the motion of strumming is soothing, repetitive in the same way that striking blows with a hammer is repetitive, just enough variation to focus the mind. It has been a long time since he’s played. His best harp, wrought with gold inlay on the column and neck, a gift from his mother, either burned in Erebor or is now part of a dragon’s hoard. The one he played in the Blue Mountains from time to time—mostly when his nephews were particularly stubborn about going to sleep and Dís despaired of telling them another story—was not essential enough to pack for this journey. It is also precious to him and he feared vagabonds on the road. One dirty, sour Dwarf with a blacksmith’s tools does not offer a threat; give that Dwarf a shining harp of polished walnut and he presents a target. Thorin doesn’t doubt that he could overpower any who might waylay him on the road, but the risk of breaking the harp in the ensuing struggle is too high. He never learned the art of making them; after his mother’s was lost to him, his brother Frerin made the other. Frerin was always good with his hands.

            Blowing on his fingers to warm them, Thorin walks a quick circuit of the garden fence. Across the way, the Hobbit family called Gamgee—friendly neighbours, according to Prim, but Thorin wonders if her notion of “friendly” isn’t a bit too generous—have a light burning, and he can see shadows moving beyond the curtains. Someone’s sheep are bleating to each other, soft and low, down by the Water. The Shire is never completely quiet, even at night. If he walks far enough away from Bag End, Thorin can just hear snatches of conversation from the open windows of the Green Dragon. He thinks of their beds with something close to, but not quite, longing. He does not have the money for another night’s stay, and it’s not a bad night to be outside, as long as you have some shelter from the wind. Back at the garden gate, Thorin hesitates, his hand over the latch, and then opens it and steps inside. He sits in the front doorway, back against the curved frame, tucked out of the wind. With his sword eased from the scabbard, ready at his side, Thorin folds his arms across his chest, crosses his legs, and resumes his guard.

            The lights go out at the Gamgee windows. Thorin sighs, and stretches his neck. It’s quiet inside Bag End. Whether Bilbo’s sleeping or just tucked away in some back room, Thorin does not know. The urge to go inside and check is nearly overwhelming. It’s also incredibly foolish, and Thorin doesn’t understand where it could be coming from, or how to make it go away. He re-crosses his arms, checks that his sword is still within easy reach, and settles again. An hour passes, maybe two. Sometime between the dark of midnight and the first light of dawn, he falls asleep.

            When Thorin wakes, Bilbo is standing over him, tapping his foot as if impatient but looking almost fond, his lips pressed into something that might be a smile. “What are you doing?” he asks. “Sleeping in my doorway. Don’t you have a bed? Someplace more comfortable?”

            Thorin groans and shifts his weight—his neck is stiff, his back sore from pressing against the doorframe. “As it happens,” he says, standing slowly, “I don’t.” With the two of them standing in the doorway it suddenly feels crowded. Thorin takes a step back reflexively, his hand moving out of habit to the sword still loose in its sheath even as his wakening mind registers that Bilbo isn’t a threat. Not that it matters, as before he can complete the movement Thorin steps off the edge of the front step and loses his balance. Bilbo’s hand shoots out and grasps his arm, slight but enough to steady Thorin so that he doesn’t completely fall over.

            “Careful,” Bilbo says, tugging Thorin forward. “Watch yourself. Don’t crush my flower boxes.” Thorin glances over his shoulder, concerned, and Bilbo laughs. “No, no, you’re fine, they’re not in any danger. All right?”

            “Yes.” Thorin brushes Bilbo’s hand off his arm, not harshly but firmly. He is not quite himself when he’s just woken up, particularly not if someone else—someone unknown—has woken him. “I did not mean to sleep in your doorway,” he says, now firmly on both feet, albeit a step below Bilbo. At this level, the Hobbit’s eyes are nearly even with his own.

            “Oh no? Then what were you doing?”

            “Keeping watch.”

            “While asleep.”

            Thorin can feel his face growing warm. “I didn’t mean to fall asleep,” he very nearly growls. “I was . . . concerned. Regarding your lack of security.” He gestures at the gaping hole that was once Bag End’s front door. “I can fix it for you.”

            “Not before breakfast, surely?”

            “What?”

            “Breakfast. Or do Dwarves not do that?”

            “We do,” Thorin says hesitantly. “Will your cousin be joining us?”

            “Prim’s not really one for mornings.” Bilbo laughs lightly. “She’ll be here for second breakfast, I shouldn’t wonder.”

            “You have two?”

            “Don’t you know anything of Hobbits?”

            “Very little,” Thorin says. “I’ve only really spoken with three.”

            “Well, there’s Prim, and me, so . . . who’s the third?” Bilbo asks, blinking as the early morning light breaks over far-off hills.

            “It’s not important.”

            Bilbo raises an eyebrow, waiting. Thorin doesn’t say anything more, so the Hobbit finally shrugs and sticks his hands in his pocket. “You’d better come in, then,” he says, turning on his heel. “Hard to eat on the doorstep.”

            With some measure of reluctance, Thorin follows Bilbo inside. They eat a strangely companionable breakfast—or at least, Thorin eats and Bilbo picks at his food, managing some toast with honey and little else—and words come easily to them. They don’t talk about yesterday. Instead they talk about gardening. Bilbo may have been joking about the flower boxes, but only because he has a much larger expanse of a garden, winding around Bag End, largely designed to look unkempt though actually painstakingly maintained by Bilbo’s neighbour. “The illusion of wilderness,” Bilbo says, and smiles into his still-full cup of tea.

            “Seems a waste of effort,” Thorin says.

            “Does it?”

            “Yes. Why not just leave it?”

            “It’s . . . something to pass the time, I suppose.”

            “Do you find yourself at a loss often?”

            “Hobbits are simple folk,” Bilbo tells him, which is not a proper answer. “We like simple things.”

            “If by simple you mean pointless . . .” Thorin trails off, suddenly aware that he’s being unforgivably rude to his host. He looks up, chagrined, but Bilbo hasn’t lost his smile.

            “Do you not garden, then, in . . . Where are you from, anyway?”

            Thorin pauses, a forkful of eggs halfway to his mouth. What answer should he give? East, or West? Truth, or lie? Bilbo watches him, and waits. Thorin swallows. “A mountain very far from here,” he says. “I have not seen it in many years.”

            “And why not?”

            “It was taken from us. From my people. But I have sworn that someday I will return, and take it back.” Someday soon, Thorin thinks, though he doesn’t say it; he can’t even hint at Erebor without renewing his promise to himself.

            “I’m sorry.”

            “Hmm.” Thorin looks down at his plate, and finishes off his eggs.

            “So you’re, what, a wandering blacksmith now? Seems exhausting.”

            Thorin shrugs. “It’s work.”

            “Exhausting work.”

            “There is no alternative.”

            “Isn’t there? You couldn’t, I don’t know, settle down somewhere new? Surely there are plenty of mountains out there.”

            “Not for me. I have only one home, and I will not disgrace it by taking another.”

            “All right, all right, I didn’t mean . . . Sorry. I don’t know very much about Dwarvish culture.” Bilbo reaches across the table to refill Thorin’s cup of tea. “Can’t read any of your books, you know. I can see that I’ve offended you, which wasn’t my intent. I was just curious. Must be a family fault, or something, peculiar to my own. Few Hobbits are curious, really.”

            “You haven’t offended me,” Thorin says. “I apologise as well.”

            “Oh, don’t, let’s not get all formal again. We were having a pleasant conversation. Let’s just . . . talk about something else. You could tell me how you plan to repair my door, for instance. I thought it was broken in two?” Bilbo carefully says “broken” and not “torn,” and “it was” instead of “I did it”; which is, of course, what he’s been suspecting since he woke yesterday to Prim’s concerned face and a Dwarf scowling at the side of his bed, and no memories of where he’d been or what he’d been doing.

            “It was. You’ll need a new door. I can fashion one for you, if you know of a supply of lumber.” Thorin knows that he could simply go out and fell one of the trees behind Bilbo’s house, but something about that wood has made him wary. He’s in no hurry to return, not unless he has to.

            “I don’t, but someone around here must. I’ll go over and ask Hamfast after breakfast. Are you finished?”

            Thorin could eat at least twice as much as he’s already had, to fill the long-standing emptiness of his stomach, but he nods and shoves away from the table, gets to his feet. “Thank you for the food,” he says, and if the words come out stiffly, Bilbo doesn’t seem to notice.

            So Thorin spends the better part of the day hammering out the ironwork design of the strap hinges that played out across the inside of the original door, making straight what had been bent nearly double—bent from the inside outward. It’s easy enough work to re-shape them with a fire and a hammer. Thorin tries very hard not to think about how they were ruined with bare hands. Prim comes by in the late morning and badgers Bilbo into eating some seed cake and more tea, and then watches Thorin none too subtly as he works. He ignores her completely, and after a while she disappears back into Bag End, presumably to pester Bilbo again. Bilbo’s neighbour drops off a cartload of ash planks, brought over from the saw mill down the river, and Thorin spends another hour or so fashioning nails, using what he could pull from the broken door and some scrap metal he’s been carrying around for too long. It’s well into the afternoon by the time he has the door shaped and ready to hang. Bilbo’s been hovering for a while, in and out of Thorin’s workspace, faintly inquisitive but largely absent-minded. He shows up again just as Thorin is hauling the door upright to align it with the hinges, and Thorin enlists Bilbo into holding things straight while he sends the last nails home, securing Bag End’s new door with a few steady swings of his hammer. All that’s left is to paint the outside the same rich green it was before.

            “Thank you,” Bilbo says, as Thorin wipes his brow and studies his handiwork.

            “Not my usual set of skills,” Thorin admits. “But it is strong, and it will hold.” They share a look, neither wanting to speak about what, precisely, it will be holding against.

            “I should hope so. The pride of your reputation rests on it. After all, what Hobbit will commission work from someone who can’t even repair a door?”

            Thorin frowns. Bilbo does have a point. Perhaps he should have just left the door the way it was; but then, what would that say about his skills, to have seen a problem and not fix it? No, he had to intervene. But if this is where it got him, has he set himself up for future troubles?

            As Thorin goes on frowning, Bilbo laughs. “I’m joking again. Don’t you joke? Or do Dwarves not have a sense of humour?”

            “We do,” Thorin says, embarrassed at not recognising the tone of sarcasm in Bilbo’s voice. When Bilbo is sarcastic, he sounds so like Bo, and it’s disarming to hear. “It’s simply different from yours.”

            “Tell us a Dwarvish joke, then.”

            “What?”

            “Come on.” Bilbo reaches out and nudges Thorin’s arm. “I’m listening.”

            “. . . I can’t think of any.”

            “Well. We can come back to that. But don’t think I’ll forget. I have a very good memory,” Bilbo says, and then winces a bit, because that used to be true but these days he’s possibly the least reliable person in all of Hobbiton where memory is concerned. Thorin catches the wince and Bilbo turns his face away. “Do you, er, want to stay for dinner?” Bilbo asks, speaking more to the coat rack than the Dwarf right beside him.

            “I’ll take my leave,” Thorin says, with a shake of his head. “I’ve . . . imposed.” Thorin slings his weapons and tools over his back and tugs the door open. It’s smooth on its hinges. He smiles, in spite of himself, and then realises Bilbo can probably see him and steps out onto the doorstep.

            “Wait.” Bilbo puts a hand to Thorin’s arm. “It’s the least I can do. You’ve been a great help, truly.”

            “Will your cousin be joining us?”

            “Prim left ages ago. She has her own family to worry about.” Bilbo steps out to stand even with Thorin on the doorstep. He has to tilt his head to look into the Dwarf’s eyes. The afternoon sun is low and golden in the sky and he squints against its light. “To be honest,” Bilbo says, “I’m a bit tired of eating alone.” He wonders, as he says it, if it’s true. Hobbits are not, by nature, solitary creatures. Bilbo has become so, partly of his own choosing and partly of a gradual estrangement from the rest of the Shirefolk. Perhaps something as simple as a face across the dinner table will bring back his appetite? It seemed to work for breakfast. It can’t hurt to try. And if he must have company, Bilbo thinks, he finds himself strangely preferring this Dwarf standing before him and looking down with a mix of interest and suspicion. At least Thorin wears his emotions with some subtlety. The same can hardly be said for Prim, much as Bilbo loves her, nor any other of his countless Hobbit relatives. What’s the worst that can happen? That dinner goes awfully? that Thorin leaves and thinks him incurably odd? that they never speak again? None of those are all that terrible.

            “Stay for dinner,” Bilbo says, after their silence has dragged on more than long enough.

            And Thorin looks him over, head to toe and back again, and says, “All right.”

            As Bilbo goes through the pantry, pulling ingredients for dinner—ingredients Prim practically had to force into his arms earlier—he recognises that he’s being fairly foolish. If his worries are true, and whatever it is that has been happening to him does, in fact, happen every night just after sundown, then he’s cutting things awfully close by inviting Thorin to stay for a meal. Weighing a sack of potatoes in one hand, Bilbo has to admit that he’s started to become frightened of being left alone, and having Thorin working in his doorway all afternoon was surprisingly comfortable. Comforting, even. He’s not quite ready to let that go yet, even if it is reckless.

            While a chicken roasts in a cast-iron pan over the fire, Bilbo sets Thorin to work peeling potatoes. “Where on earth has all my silverware gone?” Bilbo mutters, pulling drawer after drawer open, napkins in hand as he tries to set the table. “I swear Prim moves it all around just for fun.”

            Thorin ducks his head and keeps peeling resolutely. He’s not one to let other take the blame for his actions, but he’s also wary of disturbing this tentative peace they seem to have reached, not far removed from furtive conversations behind closed doors. He keeps stealing glances at Bilbo as he works, trying to figure out who this man is, and who he isn’t. He isn’t Bo Took, for one thing; their mannerisms are completely dissimilar, even down to the way they speak. Bilbo’s voice is lighter, more precise; he complains a great deal, and has yet to make any advances of even remotely the same sort as Bo made. While true, that last fact isn’t something Thorin particularly wants to think about, largely because he can’t decide how he feels about it. So he concentrates on his potatoes, slicing them into neat chunks for Bilbo’s stew pot, and he concentrates on the lines of Bilbo’s back, bent over the hearth.

            “How long are you staying in the Shire?” Bilbo asks.

            “Not long.”

            “Another night? Two?”

            Thorin shrugs. “Until there’s no more work to be had here. Perhaps a week.”

            “You work quickly.”

            “No quicker than most.”

            “Hobbits take things at a very slow pace. You’ll figure that out soon enough, if you stay. Pass the potatoes?”

            Thorin hands over the bowl and Bilbo takes it, empties it into the pot. They move easily together in the kitchen. It’s startlingly similar to dodging the boys in Dis’s kitchen in the Blue Mountains, and the familiarity of it all makes Thorin smile. “Something funny?” Bilbo asks, and Thorin shakes his head.

            “Just memories,” he says.

            “I never did thank you,” Bilbo says, “speaking of memories, for getting me out of the wood. Prim told me you were quite the hero.”

            “Your cousin exaggerates.”

            “Still. Thank you. I . . . do remember a bit, now.”

            “Oh? And what do you remember?”

            Bilbo feels his cheeks flush and he speaks into the stew pot, rather than look Thorin in the eye. “You carried me. Rather like a sack of these potatoes.”

            “That’s not—”

            “Please don’t tell me even that memory is false. There are enough gaps in my past days. I’d like to think I’ve recalled at least one thing correctly.” Bilbo smiles up at Thorin, softly, hesitantly, and though his hands are steady on the dishcloth he feels a rush of air past his ears, the faint sensation of falling. Outside Bag End’s round windows, the sun is sinking lower into the lush Shire hills.

            “You’re heavier than potatoes,” Thorin mumbles.

            “Excuse you,” Bilbo says, his voice a bit higher than he means for it to come out. He straightens out the dishcloth, smooths his hands over the embroidery. “I should hope so.”

            He hadn’t really meant for Bilbo to hear, but Thorin lets out a short breath of laughter.

            “Even if I’m . . . not quite the Hobbit I once was.” Bilbo glances down, notes how loosely his shirt hangs, how his suspenders fall flat against his stomach, stretched taut. If this goes any further, he’ll have to get someone to take in his trousers. It’s almost embarrassing. Thorin doesn’t seem to notice, and Bilbo is oddly grateful for the cultural barrier. Being built as he is, Thorin probably doesn’t worry about whether or not he weighs more than a sack of potatoes.

            While they’re sitting at the table, over steaming plates of dinner, Bilbo makes Thorin recount the past day’s events, tries to piece together the time he’s lost. Bindbole Wood never used to frighten him; now he draws the curtains on the back rooms, not wanting to feel as though he’s being watched. Thorin is a solid presence in Bag End’s dining room, his elbows on the table, his knees a touch too high for Shire-made furniture. Thinking “here, now,” over and again to himself, Bilbo watches the clock on the mantelpiece tick and holds on to his surroundings. If the switch comes when he is not alone, what then? What will happen? He has to stay here, now; he cannot let go.

            As it turns out, Thorin makes that decision for him. “It’s late,” the Dwarf says, pushing back from the table and standing silhouetted against the last light in the sky. “I should go. Thank you for dinner.”

            “Oh, no, it’s— My pleasure. Are you sure you . . . What I mean is, there are more than enough rooms here. You’re welcome to stay.”

            “I don’t want to intrude.”

            “Really, it’s no trouble.” Bilbo smiles nervously. He’s tempting fate, he knows; but what will happen? If someone is watching him, will he be able to stay? The thought of Thorin leaving, and of him alone, in the dark, losing hold of himself, frightens him. Never mind that it’s happened before, and will probably happen again. He does not want it to happen right now. “No trouble at all.”

            “I have not experienced such kindness from your neighbours,” Thorin says slowly.

            “Well, no, they’re generally a, how should I say it, a subdued lot. They don’t like to have much to do with outsiders.”

            “And you?”

            “I suppose I’m the odd one out.”

            “Hmm.” Thorin rubs at the back of his neck. Bilbo watches him, head tilted to one side. “If you’re certain . . .”

            “I am.”

            Thorin can’t deny that he’s curious—it’s clear that Bilbo’s hiding something, and yet inviting him in all the same—nor that the promise of a bed he doesn’t have to pay for is one that’s very hard to resist. So he nods his head, murmurs his thanks, and follows Bilbo down Bag End’s winding western hall to a side bedroom. Not, he notes, on the back side of the smial, but rather adjacent to Bilbo’s own rooms.

            Bilbo opens the door and gestures inside, but then his hands fall against his sides and he fidgets. “Right, then,” he says, “the bath is down that hall, and uh, that’s—” Bilbo swallows. “Uh. That’s—” He chokes on the tightness in his throat, lungs burning. It has never felt like this before, has never hit him this hard. Stumbling, Bilbo reaches out a hand to catch himself and grasps not the doorframe but Thorin’s arm, solid, warm.

            “Bilbo? What is it?” Thorin steps closer, gets a hand behind Bilbo’s back in case he falls.

            All Bilbo can do is shake his head, try to warn Thorin off. He can feel the heat rising behind his eyes, the room dropping away from him. No, no, this isn’t what he wanted; this isn’t how it’s supposed to work. “Sorry,” he bites out, gritting his teeth, his hand white-knuckled against Thorin’s sleeve. “Sorry.” For all that he’s gripping so tightly, he feels nothing beneath his fingers, no threadbare cotton, no smooth leather. He cannot even feel his fingers. Numbly, Bilbo slips free, retreats back towards his room shaking his head.

            “Bilbo?” Thorin calls, reaching out for him.

            “Goodnight,” Bilbo says, and it feels like a goodbye.

            Thorin is left standing in the hallway, his arm bruised, staring at a closed door.

 

----

 

It’s probably a fairly foolish idea, but Thorin spends the night at Bag End all the same. After trying, to no avail, to get a response from Bilbo through the door, and short of breaking it down by force, the next best thing seems to be to simply stay nearby. Just in case. In case of what? Thorin asks himself, and can’t answer. Perhaps he wants to know if there will be another door to hang back on broken hinges come morning. Lying on his back on the spare bed, staring at the curved ceiling, Thorin runs a hand over the tenderness on his forearm, feels the ghost-imprint of Bilbo’s surprisingly strong grip. There is something wrong here, that much is obvious. What’s less apparent are the details, and what anyone is meant to be doing about them. So Thorin shifts on the mattress—softer than he’s had in a long time—and presses an ear against the wall adjoining his room to Bilbo’s, and listens. Hears nothing. No pacing footsteps. Not even quiet breathing.

            Bilbo’s face had been so flushed in the hall, his eyes wide and dark. What if he’s sick? Lacking a proper healer, it’s small wonder Hobbiton hasn’t been overrun by disease. Uncomfortable memories of his own people ill and starving on the road drive Thorin out of bed to pace by the window. The night air is warm and still, as if the season is finally making the turn into a proper summer. Warmer weather means that he can travel farther afield, go for longer without shelter. It means he won’t see the Blue Mountains again for a long time. Won’t see his family, not after he makes one last trip back before the season comes in full.

            His mind now turned far from comforting thoughts, Thorin pulls away from the window and returns to bed. The quiet next door persists, no matter how hard he listens. Eventually, lulled by the softness of a summer night, the crickets out in the garden, Thorin falls asleep.

            The soft creak of the bedroom door wakes him—not Bilbo’s door but his own, followed by light footsteps on the floorboards. Thorin’s hand clenches on instinct around the hilt of the knife beneath his pillow and he tenses his muscles, readies himself to spring up. A cloud crosses the moon and pale light shines in through the window, throwing a line of white over a turned-up nose and wry smirk. “What are you doing here?” Thorin hisses, loosening his grip on the knife but not letting it go.

            Bo Took grins at him and shrugs. He sits on the edge of the bed, entirely casual, as if he hasn’t just broken into someone’s home—never mind if they’re related. “I heard you were around,” he says. “Thought I’d come and . . . say hello.”

            “How did you get in?”

            “Oh, Bilbo’s home isn’t nearly as secure as he thinks it is.”

            “The front door was locked. I know it was.”

            “And you think Hobbit holes have only one door? Shows how much you know.”

            “You’re . . . trespassing.”

            “He won’t mind,” Bo says, waving a hand. “Do you?”

            “What?”

            “Do you mind?” Bo repeats, slowly, shifting closer. “We were . . . interrupted, the other night. Never got to finish what we started.”

            Thorin sits up, moves back against the headboard. The bit of distance that he opens up between them is immediately closed as Bo slides forward. “Where did you run off to that night? Why?”

            “Something came up. You know how it is. But I’m here now.”

            Thorin frowns. Neither of them should be here, and they especially shouldn’t be picking up where they left off here. But Bo’s hands are on his knees, pushing them apart, fingers running up the inseam of Thorin’s leggings. It’s a bit difficult to think of propriety.

            “Come on,” Bo is saying to him. “Let me lead the way. Wasn’t that what we agreed on?”

            Shaking his head, Thorin reaches for clarity. Finds none. Only heat tugging at him from within, urging him closer, further, anywhere other than staying still. All is silent next door. Even the crickets have gone to sleep. Bo looks up at Thorin expectantly, hair falling across his forehead, teeth glinting in the moonlight as he smiles. There’s something fey about him, some kind of wildness Thorin cannot give a name.

            “We’ll have to . . . keep quiet,” Thorin breathes, and tilts his head back, exposes his throat. Offers himself up, consenting.

            “If you’re worried about Bilbo overhearing,” Bo says, running cool fingers along Thorin’s collarbone, “don’t. He’s out for the night.”

            “How do you—aahh—know that?” Thorin shivers.

            “I checked,” Bo says, and shifts his hips forward. “Now, enough about Bilbo. Unless you’d rather it was him in here, with you.”

            “No, I—” Thorin’s protest is cut off, whether because he doesn’t know how to answer or because Bo’s lips are on his, pressing forward. It doesn’t matter. The results are the same. Later, much later, Thorin will have more than enough time to worry about it. For now, all he has, all he can think of, are Bo’s hands on his shoulders, pushing him down into the mattress; Bo’s fingers skating over the bruise on his forearm, the scars along his ribcage; Bo’s legs on either side of his own; Bo’s eyes swallowing up  the brightness of the moon.

            It is not like he imagined.

            Afterwards, leaning back against the headboard, Thorin runs his fingers through the tousled wreck of Bo’s hair and marvels at how it stands on end, smiles at the softness around Bo’s middle as they lie together, close but not touching, too warm in the summer night. Afterwards, Thorin falls asleep.

            When he wakes he is alone, and once again staring at a closed door.

Notes:

So with the holidays & moving back to school, I left you all hanging a bit longer than I would've liked. Sorry about that. Thanks for your patience, and for staying with this story. I really appreciate all the kudos and comments, and please remember to go and give the artist (thehobbitpanda on tumblr, demonatic here on Ao3) your support as well! This is a joint effort. Art: cover, bitter smithing, aforementioned awkwardness in doorways.

Next time, on "awkward conversations in doorways and halls" (what may as well be this fic's alternate title): Bilbo learns some things, Thorin is conflicted about some lots of things, letters.