Actions

Work Header

An Unexpected Invitation (And What Happened Next)

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Even though Thorin had not expected anything different, seeing that the group of new arrivals to Erebor did not contain a hobbit made the constant ache that Bilbo’s absence caused within him flare up into a hot, stabbing pain.

The worst thing about it was that he had no one to blame for the fact that Bilbo wasn’t there other than himself. He had driven him away, terrified him and broken his heart. It was really no surprise that he had not accepted the invitation to return to Erebor.

It had taken Thorin two days to wake after the battle. His first memory upon regaining consciousness was of his two sister-sons throwing themselves at Azog to defend him and being cut down themselves. The second was of him dangling Bilbo over the sickeningly high edge of the battlements, and the fear in his eyes as Thorin held him at his mercy.

If he hadn’t been entirely free of goldsickness when he awoke, those two memories burned what was left of it from his mind entirely.

His first fear was assuaged as soon as Balin entered his tent and told him that Fili and Kili were fine, despite the handful of new scars and broken bones between them, already awake and pestering the healers to be let out of bed.

But when Thorin asked for news of Bilbo, Balin’s expression fell into one of gentle sympathy. For one heartstopping moment, Thorin had believed him to be dead. Then Balin sighed. “He’s gone, Thorin.”

“Gone where?” Thorin croaked, a new ache somewhere beneath his ribs making itself known.

“Back to the Shire,” Balin explained gently. “He asked for news of you, and the others, then he left.” Balin patted his shoulder, more gently than usual in concession to Thorin’s injuries. “I think he just needs a little space. He’ll be back, Thorin.”

But Thorin knew otherwise. He had threatened Bilbo, frightened him and probably left bruises on his skin. What reason would he have to come back to Erebor? Why would Bilbo even consider forgiving him?

Bilbo made it perfectly clear that he hadn’t forgiven him, anyway. He had written to every single member of the Company, aside from Thorin. He’d sent a message to Balin to let him know that he had arrived safely home. Then he had sent another to Bofur, and then gradually one to all the others.

There were never any letters for him, not that Thorin expected one, and all of the dozen letters he had started lay unfinished in a box in his chambers. There was nothing he could possibly write that would convey the depths of his regret, or how much Thorin missed him.

He had reclaimed Erebor but it did not feel like home. Not without Bilbo.

It had been Balin’s idea to invite Bilbo to the ceremony to commemorate the dead. He hadn’t told Thorin about it until after Rogi and Dorn had already left. Thorin had been torn then between an irritated sort of gratitude and an uncomfortable sort of hope.

Bilbo’s absence was answer enough to crush what little hope remained in him.

It wasn’t until later that evening, when he was in his study with only his nephews for company when there was a knock on the door. When Kili pulled it open, Rogi was stood there awkwardly, an envelope held in his hand.

“Your majesty,” he began, bowing. “The halfling Master Balin instructed us to see asked us to deliver a message for you.”

Kili all but snatched the envelope out of Rogi’s hand, while Fili thanked and ushered him out of the door. Thorin was barely aware of that happening, his whole attention was fixed on the envelope, where the phrase To the King Under the Mountain was written in tidy letters.

It was not as good as Bilbo being there, of course, but maybe it was a start of some sort of reconciliation between them.

That hope lasted for as long as it took for Thorin to unfold the slip of paper inside the envelope and read the first line of Bilbo’s letter.

My dear Fili.

Thorin hadn’t thought the ache inside him could get any worse, but clearly he was wrong. It felt like a warg was mauling him all over again.

“Uncle?” Fili said cautiously. “What does Bilbo say?”

“I don’t know,” Thorin replied bitterly, thrusting the letter at him. “The letter is for you.”

Thorin wasn’t entirely sure how he made it back to his rooms. His mind was too busy dwelling on what the letter had meant.

He had never expected Bilbo to forgive him, not after what he had done. But having the hope of reconciliation and then having it snatched away was a blow he had not expected.

He had not been dwelling on it for very long before there was a frantic pounding on the door. When he ignored it, his doors burst open. He sighed to himself. Only his nephews would come into his private rooms uninvited and he did not feel like talking to them, not just yet.

When he looked up, however, he paused at the sight of Fili’s face. It was drained of all colour and there were tears standing out in his eyes.

Thorin pushed himself out of his chair. “What is it?” he asked, slow dread uncoiling within him. Whatever was in the letter must be bad news indeed to have Fili look like that.

“Uncle,” Fili choked. “Bilbo thinks that you’re dead.”

“What?” he asked, thinking he must have misheard. How could he possibly think that?

Fili pushed the letter at him. “He does, read it! Why else would he address a letter for me as the King Under the Mountain?”

My dear Fili,

I know that the forthcoming ceremony must be a very difficult time for you. It must be daunting indeed to lead your people to remember those that they have lost when you are still grieving yourself. I know you must miss Thorin terribly, but remember how much he loved you and Kili. He saw you both as his own beloved sons and I am sure that he would be proud beyond words to know what a fine job you have done ruling Erebor since the battle.

I only wish that I could be there to support you in person during the ceremony, not just in the words on this piece of paper, but for all of the new strengths I found within myself on our journey, I am afraid I am not strong enough to return to Erebor, not even to see all my dearest friends again.

Thorin’s death is like a wound in my heart that won’t stop bleeding. I miss him. I have done every day since the battle, and it is a difficult indeed knowing that your uncle died despising me for my treachery. That knowledge seeps into all of the memories I have of my time with him, and it poisons any comfort that I may have otherwise found in them. I would do anything to have the chance to apologise to him, to try and explain or to try and save him. I cannot help but feel that if I had not angered him so before he joined the battle that he would still be with us. You know better than I how reckless anger made him.

And that is why I cannot come to the ceremony. I cannot bear to walk on the ground where I betrayed him and where he died, or stand on the battlements where – well, I am sure you heard the story. I am sorry, Fili. I just can’t.

My thoughts are with you, though, as always, and I hope you know you can write to me any time, or even visit if your duties ever spare you. Tea is at four, but you are welcome any time.

Please pass on my greetings to the others and thank Balin for the invitation.

Your friend,

Bilbo

Thorin had read the letter three times over before he noticed that Balin was standing over him, saying his name in concern.

“Balin,” Thorin whispered. “Bilbo thinks that I am dead.”

Balin’s face was very grave. “I know. The lads came and told me.”

“He thinks I died hating him. He thinks that it is his fault.”

Thorin looked down at the letter again. The writing became messier towards the end of the letter, as if Bilbo’s hand had started shaking. Some of the ink had been smudged as well, as if Bilbo had been weeping when he had been writing.

And Thorin had thought Bilbo was angry with him. In truth, he had been afraid to reach out to him, only to have Bilbo turn from him in his anger, when all this time, he had been mourning. Grieving, all alone, with no one to comfort him or tell him that it was needless.

“I am sorry,” Balin said suddenly. “I think he must have misunderstood what I told him after the battle. I should have questioned him when he started crying. I shouldn’t have assumed that it was simply from relief. When he tried to leave I should have asked him why, but I thought…”

“What?” Thorin asked gruffly.

“I thought he was afraid to face you,” Balin said frankly. “But I thought that once you wrote to him that he would come back.”

“I…” Thorin trailed off. In the face of Bilbo’s all too real grief, the reasons he hadn’t written seemed foolish. “I’m going to the Shire,” he said instead. “First thing in the morning.”

Balin nodded. “I’ve already arranged for ponies for you and the lads – they’ve insisted on going to make sure that you don’t “mess it up.” Thorin sighed, unsurprised. “But for Mahal’s sake, Thorin, write to him first. You don’t just want to turn up on his doorstep and give him the fright of his life!”

Thorin nodded, his attention already drifting back to the letter. He touched one of the tearstains on the paper and made a fierce, silent vow that Bilbo would never shed another tear because of him again.

Notes:

Thank you all so much for all the kudos and encouraging comments on this fic! It really means a lot.

Oh, and I keep forgetting to say but I'm on tumblr now.