Actions

Work Header

Oak and Mistletoe

Chapter 3: To Taste

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

On the morning of the third day after his discovery about the mistletoe, the first thing Bilbo did was to take down his brewing concoction from a shelf in his larder. The bottle felt heavy in his hands as he carried it into the kitchen, minding his step on the way. He placed it gently on the counter, closer to the wall than to the edge, and went to find a decanter, a funnel and a fine cotton cloth for sieving before starting the filtering process.

He poured it slowly down into the glass decanter, watching the wilted remains of the herbs and plants pile up on the cloth over the funnel. As he tilted the bottle to get the final drops, the mistletoe berry tumbled out, landing squarely in the nest created in the funnel. Bilbo had already squeezed its juice into the potion before dumping the rest of it in with it, but now it had shrivelled up, a tiny pale husk of what it had been on the oak. The mistletoe had given up its life force.

Bilbo folded the cloth around the residue of the plants, squeezing it for any remaining liquid, before dropping a stopper into the decanter. He lifted it up to the sunshine coming from the window, wanting to look at the final product. The colour of the liquid was a pale yellow, most likely from the wormwood, and the consistency was not unlike any other distilled wine. As he moved the decanter back and forth, the liquid clung to the sides of it, receding more slowly than water would have done.

As he studied his work, he heard heavy footsteps coming from behind him.

‘Is that it?’ Thorin’s low voice moved closer as the dwarf came to stand next to Bilbo at the counter.

‘Yes,’ Bilbo said as he put the potion down again.

‘It doesn’t look like much.’

‘Enough for five mouthfuls.’

Thorin hummed and sat down at the kitchen table, spreading his hands in front of him on the worn wood. Bilbo could hear his heavy boots shifting on the stone floor of the kitchen behind him as he placed the decanter aside and pulled out a pan from the cupboard.

‘What are you doing?’ Thorin asked.

‘Making breakfast,’ Bilbo said as he went past him out into the larder. The cold potatoes from the day before would do excellently, just needed to be fried crispy. And maybe some scrambled eggs as well.

‘I can see that.’ Thorin said as he moved back in his seat with a sudden movement, the legs of his chair scraping over the floor. ‘I mean, why are you doing that now?’

‘I usually have breakfast in the mornings.’ Bilbo said as he walked back into the kitchen, balancing two eggs in one hand and the bowl of potatoes in the crook of his elbow. ‘Are you sure you don’t want me to make some for you as well?’

‘No, thank you. I still have some waybread in my pack that needs eating.’

Bilbo swallowed drily in an instinctive response as he remembered from a couple of days ago when Thorin had showed him what he had eaten on the road instead of visiting inns and taverns. It was a small, nearly-white square of dry bread. Bilbo had tried a small bite of it, immediately feeling his tongue sticking to his teeth as all the moisture disappeared from his mouth. The taste was non-existent, the texture was unpleasant, and the best thing Thorin had to say about it, was that it didn’t spoil in his pack and that it was filling.

Thorin tapped his fingers against the table and made a disgruntled sound as he watched the hobbit cut the potatoes into thick slices before placing them gently in the pan, listening to the butter sizzle.

‘I thought you said the drink was ready after two days and two nights?’ Thorin tried again after a while. The tapping on the table picked up the pace and grew louder.

Bilbo turned over the potatoes, pleased with the golden colour. ‘I did.’

‘Then drink the blasted thing, kiss me and let’s get the disappointment over with!’ The tapping stopped as Thorin ran an abrupt hand over his hair, his fingers tangling near one of his braids. He pulled them roughly away, taking with them a few hairs which had snagged in his heavy ring.

Bilbo lifted the potatoes from the pan and onto his plate before turning around to answer Thorin. ‘Disappointment?’

‘Yes, disappointment.’ Thorin sighed heavily. ‘I don’t mean any slight against your good intentions or your- or your skill. But I’ve had to get my hopes up so many times. I have had to see my family, my father especially, beaming expectantly at me once I had swallowed the last drops of a bitter potion or once some sorcerer had finished chanting some words at me. And every time – each and every time – I’ve had to disappoint them.’ Thorin rubbed a hand across his eyes. ‘And I know that every time the hope left my father’s eyes, he secretly blamed me. For not being strong enough to fight and defeat whatever this,’ his hands gestured stiffly at his own body, ‘whatever this is.’ His voice grew quiet as he finished.

Bilbo floundered, not quite knowing what to say to such an outburst. So he decided to stick to what he knew best. He padded silently to stand next to Thorin’s tense shoulder which jerked when he placed a light hand on it. The dwarf looked up at him, a deep line travelling from the middle of his forehead down between his eyebrows.

Bilbo gave a small smile. ‘Do you want me to show you how to make the best scrambled eggs in all of Middle-earth?’

Thorin blinked. ‘What?’

‘Come on,’ Bilbo said, giving a small push to Thorin’s back. ‘Let me show you.’

Thorin stood up and followed Bilbo to the stove, his feet shuffling hesitantly over the floor.

‘So, most people will tell you to melt the butter while you whisk the eggs together in a bowl. Don’t do that.’ Bilbo cracked one egg and then the other directly into the pan before adding a nub of butter. ‘Just chuck it all in at once and start stirring while you heat it.’ He gestured for Thorin to step closer as he got started on the eggs.

Thorin looked up from the yolks being broken by Bilbo’s brisk spatula to stare at the hobbit standing next to him. Bilbo’s face was intent on his work, his lazily tied morning robe slowly opening with the constant movement of his arm.

‘And as soon as you notice the eggs becoming the least bit firm,’ Bilbo continued, ignorant of Thorin’s study of him, ‘you immediately take the pan from the heat, you see? But never stop stirring.’

Thorin looked away from Bilbo’s curls to the pan. ‘Is it done then?’

‘No, but it’s still cooking, see? Keep it off the heat for a moment or two and then,’ Bilbo said as he lifted the pan back on the stove. ‘You put it back on the heat, still stirring.’

Thorin looked down at the yellow mass, slowly gathering into soft peaks.

‘And back off again,’ Bilbo said, lifting the pan from the stove.

‘And then back on again?’ Thorin asked after a moment.

Bilbo smiled up at him. ‘You’re learning! Yes, one more time will do it, I think,’ he said, putting down the pan.

‘Why are you teaching me this?’ Thorin shook his head. ‘You must know that it’s wasted on me?’

‘Because,’ Bilbo said, looking at the egg fluffing up, ‘when you have the full use of your senses back, I don’t want you to spend your life eating mediocre scrambled eggs. A lot of people don’t know how to make them properly, you know. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve been served dry, yellow flakes and been told it’s scrambled eggs.’

The eggs were close to gathering and Bilbo took it off one more time, stirring the mass until he felt it had the right consistency.

‘And now we have to stop it cooking,’ he said. ‘Could you pass me the butter from the counter?’

Thorin turned around to scoop up the small dish and knife and held it out for the other to take.

Bilbo fished the knife from Thorin’s grip, his other hand still holding the pan. ‘Just hold still,’ he said as he sliced a large nub, his hand brushing Thorin’s as he did, and flicked it into the pan. As the cool butter melted and mixed, the eggs stopped cooking completely, leaving behind a delicious mass of yellow velvet.

‘Once you’re better,’ Bilbo said, as he scooped the eggs onto the plate with the potatoes, ‘I hope you’ll share a meal of scrambled eggs with me. It really is something to be savoured with all your senses.’ He scraped the pan clean.

‘If I get better,’ Thorin muttered as he sat down on the other side of the kitchen table, watching Bilbo sit down as well and begin salting his breakfast.

‘When you get better,’ Bilbo corrected, taking the first bite.

‘You sound awfully sure,’ Thorin said. ‘So why can’t you drink that yellow concoction now?’

‘Because,’ Bilbo began before swallowing a mouthful. ‘Because I need all morning to prepare what you’ll need after that first kiss.’

Thorin’s eyes widened. ‘What? What will I need? Why do you need so much time?’

Bilbo looked down at his plate, trying to hide his amusement at the dwarf’s obvious and terrifying suspicions about the potency of a hobbit’s kiss, before looking back up.

‘You must give me some time to prepare one of the best meals ever served in Bag End. I wouldn’t want to disappoint your burgeoning taste buds.’

‘Taste…’ Thorin trailed off. ‘You’re going to try to start with taste?’

Bilbo swallowed another bite and nodded. ‘It seemed to be the most easily managed sense. It wouldn’t overwhelm you all at once, like sight or hearing.’

Thorin licked his lips. ‘When will we do it, then?’

‘Just in time for luncheon,’ Bilbo answered before popping a golden slice of potato in his mouth.

 

X—X

 

Bilbo was sure he heard the legs of his dining table groan when he placed the final bowl on it. The entire surface was covered with plates, bowls, platters and jugs, all of them filled with the best that Bilbo’s kitchen and garden could boast. A lot of it was produce; berries, fruits and vegetables, easy and simple flavours for Thorin to begin with. But Bilbo had also produced a large steak and mushroom pie with a golden crust, a freshly-baked seedcake to replace the one wasted on Thorin’s first meal in Bag End, and a large loaf of sourdough bread with various cheeses.

As he looked up from his admiration of a full morning’s work, Bilbo spotted Thorin lurking just outside the dining room, shifting from one foot to the other.

Bilbo smiled. ‘Come in, come in! It’s all ready now.’

Thorin allowed himself to be lead by the small hobbit to sit at the top of the table, gazing down at the frankly intimidating display of hobbit cooking.

‘What if—,’ Thorin swallowed hard as he looked up at Bilbo. ‘What if it doesn’t work? You’ll have wasted all this food for nothing.’

Bilbo scoffed. ‘Not for nothing. Most of it will keep very well in the larder or the cool cellar, and I can offer the rest of it to my neighbours, Hamfast and Bell Gamgee and their six children. They’d go through all of this within a day or so. And besides,’ He said as he turned to take the decanter and a small glass from a side cupboard. ‘It will work.’

Thorin made no reply as he warily watched Bilbo pour a small amount of the yellow liquid into the glass and raise it to his mouth.

Bilbo could feel a slight tremor in his hand and steadied it through sheer force of will. Despite his assurances to Thorin, there was always a hint of nerves whenever a new potion was to be consumed. Had the text been properly translated? Had he read it correctly? Had he forgotten anything in the process? Had the potion been somehow contaminated? All these questions worried at the edges of his mind as he closed his eyes and drained the glass. He detected a strong bitterness with a hint of earthy soil before swallowing the potion down.

He opened his eyes to see Thorin looking up at him from his place at the table, a tightness around his eyes giving away hints of worry. ‘How do you feel?’ Thorin asked.

Bilbo nodded quickly. ‘Fine,’ he said though he was acutely aware of his body, waiting for any sign of unrest. ‘Fine.’

He breathed deeply before stepping closer to Thorin. ‘And now for the second part.’

‘Oh,’ Thorin glanced away. ‘Right.’

‘Just…’ Bilbo hesitated next to Thorin’s chair. ‘Look up at me?’

‘Right.’ Thorin raised his head, his eyes coming to rest on Bilbo’s face.

‘Right,’ Bilbo said, licking his lips before hunching his shoulders over to reach Thorin’s mouth. The first thing he came into contact with was Thorin’s nose, bumping into Bilbo’s soft cheek and making him move back with a small jerk. They both mumbled quick apologies before angling their faces slightly and finally touching their mouths together.

It was barely a kiss. More like a brush of dry lips against dry lips while Thorin kept his eyes open, staring blindly at Bilbo’s forehead. Bilbo’s hands were held awkwardly in front of him, not wanting to lean against Thorin’s shoulders or his chair. He started to feel a twinge in his lower back from standing so stiffly and disengaged from Thorin’s unmoving mouth, taking a couple of steps away as he did.

Thorin ducked his head, licking his lips as he looked down at the empty plate in front of him.

‘Did you feel anything happening?’ Bilbo asked as he sat down next to him.

‘There was… something.’ Thorin narrowed his eyes in thought. ‘A small itching sensation, not exactly painful. I could feel it inside my mouth.’ He shrugged. ‘But I might just have been imagining it.’

Bilbo nodded. ‘That’s promising. Now,’ he said and looked over the table. ‘what should we have you try first?’

Thorin drew in a deep breath. ‘I have no idea. There so much of it.’

‘I think we should start with something simple,’ Bilbo said he picked up a small bowl of strawberries. They had just been picked from his garden and still retained some of the sun’s heat under their skin. He held it out for Thorin to pick one. ‘Strawberries.’

Gingerly holding the small fruit between two fingers, Thorin looked up at Bilbo. ‘And if it doesn’t work?’

‘Then there are more books in my library and more plants in my stores. We’ll just try again until we get it right,’ Bilbo said and gestured for Thorin to take a bite of his chosen berry.

Thorin opened his mouth and placed the strawberry between his teeth, closing them to take a bite.

And then his eyes widened.

It felt like a long-shut door opening up to the world outside and the strong sunlight was streaming in, almost overwhelming Thorin with its intensity. He closed his eyes, allowing himself to be immerged into these new sensations. It was like every inch of his tongue stood at attention, pricking up only to be smoothed back down by this marvellous flavour. His mouth watered and he swallowed with a gulp, sweeping the small bite of the strawberry around his mouth and down his throat.

Bilbo could feel his own shoulders sag with relief at this obvious display, and he couldn’t stop himself grinning when he saw the almost euphoric expression on Thorin’s face.

‘How is it?’

Thorin opened his eyes and stared at Bilbo. ‘It’s- it’s- I can’t describe it.’ He quickly pushed the rest of strawberry into his mouth, chewing quickly; seemingly afraid that what he was experiencing would disappear if he didn’t hurry.

‘Another?’ Bilbo held out the bowl, still smiling.

Thorin grabbed four berries and stuffed them into his mouth, his cheeks bulging out like a greedy squirrel.

Bilbo laughed then and took a strawberry for himself, savouring it slowly as he observed Thorin coming to grips with what he was experiencing.

‘Do you like strawberries, then?’

Thorin chewed and swallowed his mouthful. ‘They’re… I lack the words.’

‘Well, you could call the taste fruity, or fresh, or summery, but basically they’re sweet.’

‘Sweet…,’ Thorin murmured, ‘I think I like sweet.’

‘Good. Then you should try these small tomatoes.’ Bilbo held out another bowl and Thorin picked one out, popping it into his mouth immediately.

Thorin chewed quickly, his eyes blinking as he came to grips with another flavour. ‘Yes, this one’s sweet as well. But there’s something else. Something that tickles the tongue.’

‘Sourness. Tomatoes have a bit of sourness to contrast the sweet. But they’re not completely sour like, for example, lemons.’

‘Lemons? Do you have any?’ Thorin looked up into Bilbo’s face, his eagerness barely concealed.

‘Well, not here but there’s some in my larder. I didn’t think you’d want to eat lemons for your first real meal.’

‘Please?’ Thorin leaned forward. ‘I’d like to try them. I want to try it all.’

‘As you wish,’ Bilbo said as he stood up with a smile to fetch them.

For the next hour, Bilbo and Thorin sampled a bit of every piece of fruit and vegetable available in Bilbo’s smial and garden. Bilbo helped give Thorin the words to describe what he was tasting, while thoroughly enjoying Thorin’s astounded expression every time he discovered a new combination of flavours. They then moved on to the bread and cheeses, sampled a bit of the seedcake and drank cups of milk, apple cider and wine before ending it all with a large slice of steak and mushroom pie.

Thorin gazed down at the golden, buttery crust and the creamy sauce filled with large chunks of meat and mushroom spilling out of the slice.

‘It’s incredible.’ He looked up at Bilbo, his eyes soft. ‘For the first time in my life, I’m actually looking forward to eating what’s on my plate.’

‘Then let’s hope my pie lives up to your expectations,’ Bilbo answered with a grin, picking up his knife and fork to get started on his own slice.

‘No, I mean- Thank you. So much.’ Thorin shook his head in wonder. ‘Even if the other four stages should fail, I would still be eternally indebted to you for what you have given me here today.’

‘I’m owed a debt by a dwarven prince of Erebor?’ Bilbo gestured at himself with the tongs of his fork, widening his eyes for dramatic effect. ‘I must think long and hard on the best way to collect that debt. How much of your father’s kingdom are you willing to give up in exchange for a slice of steak and mushroom pie?’

Thorin picked a piece of flaky crust from his pie. ‘You’re teasing me.’

‘Yes, I am.’ Bilbo put down his cutlery and reached out to lay his hand on Thorin’s forearm which was resting on the table between them. ‘But it pleases me immensely to see you like this, even if it’s just to satisfy my own pride in my cooking. I can’t tell what a blow it suffered that first morning when you didn’t appreciate that fine omelette I had cooked for you.’

‘Will you cook it for me again? Before I leave?’

Bilbo smiled. ‘Of course.’ He patted Thorin’s arm once and returned to his plate. ‘Now, let’s see if this one’s to your liking as well.’

Thorin took a bite. ‘Oh.’ And another bite. ‘Remember how you had trouble saying what flavour the cheeses were? Well, this is the same. It’s not sweet, not bitter, not sour, nor salty, but it’s delicious. The crust tastes like the butter I had with the bread but the filling is some indefinable good.’

‘I think meaty is the closest word I can come up with,’ Bilbo said as he chased a piece of mushroom around his plate with a fork. ‘And there’s thyme in there, as well.’

‘Thyme?’ Thorin said before stuffing a forkful of pie in his mouth.

Bilbo chewed and swallowed. ‘One of the herbs from my garden. It’s very good in any cooked meat dishes.’

‘Like the basil you said that I must try together with the tomatoes?’

‘Yes.’ Bilbo nodded. ‘Once your nose gets fixed, I’ll take you through all the herbs in my garden and the spices in my stores. And you can taste them and smell them to your heart’s desire until you learn all their names.’

‘Will that be the next one? Scent?’ Thorin took another bite, his eyes never leaving Bilbo.

‘I don’t know. It might be too much for you this early on. You can’t shut it off like you can with taste.’

Thorin nodded in understanding and they ate in silence for a while after that, Bilbo thoroughly enjoying the small sounds of satisfaction coming from Thorin’s side of the table before the dwarf finally scraped his plate, trying to get every last bit of his meal into his mouth.

Bilbo stood up then and began to clear the table. Most of the vegetables and fruits could go back in the larder with the seedcake and the bread. The rest of the pie would go to the Gamgees. Because Bilbo had the sudden urge to cook all his recipes for Thorin, wanting to show him everything that food could be. The lunch they had just had was only the tip of the iceberg, a slow start for Thorin’s budding palate. So the Gamgees would enjoy the steak and mushroom pie, and Bilbo was free to make whatever he wanted for supper tonight.

When he returned from the larder, Bilbo paused in the doorway as he spied Thorin stopping in the middle of piling up empty dishes to look down at the last bit of the matured cheddar. He hesitated then quickly snatched it from its dish and pressed it into his mouth. The large chunk distorted his right cheek and he chewed quickly, probably hoping to have finished before Bilbo came back.

Bilbo padded to the dining table and stood next to him, innocently gazing up at Thorin. The dwarf stopped the movement of his jaw and looked away as he swallowed with some difficulty. A touch of red spread over his cheeks as he kept his gaze averted from Bilbo, busying himself with stacking the last plates.

But Bilbo would have none of it. ‘Are you sure you’re not a particularly tall hobbit, Thorin?’

Thorin looked back at Bilbo as his brows rose with curiosity, his hand slowly putting down the last dish.

Bilbo continued, ‘Because it has always been the custom of hobbits to have the last part of their meals while they’re clearing the table. It’s often the tastiest bit.’ He cut a thick wedge of one of the hard cheeses, popped it in his mouth, picked up the stacked dishes and walked away into the kitchen.

Thorin stared after him for a moment before picking up the dish with the pie and following him, his middle feeling warm and filled as he moved down the cosy hallway of Bag End.

 

X—X

 

After they had cleaned up, Bilbo offered Thorin some of his home-brewed ale to drink while they sat on the bench outside Bag End.

As he looked at the brown drink in his cup, Thorin said, ‘Home-brewed ale? Where did you brew it? In your witch’s cauldron?’ The corners of his mouth lifted hesitantly as he looked at Bilbo next to him on the bench, hoping the hobbit understood his jest.

Bilbo exhaled a short laugh. ‘Ah, yes. And it’s full of bat wings and spider legs and the skin of a toad caught under a full moon. That’s what gives it its flavour.’

Thorin’s eyes glinted with amusement as he lifted the cup to his lips, tipping the ale into his mouth. He held it there shortly before swallowing.

‘Do you like it?’ Bilbo asked, taking a sip from his own ale.

‘I don’t know… I like the first sweetness that hits the tongue but once I swallowed there was a bitter taste as well.’ Thorin licked his lips. ‘I don’t know,’ he repeated, pulling in another mouthful.

‘Ale is not to everyone’s taste,’ Bilbo said as he leaned back, enjoying the sun on his face.

‘Growing up around warriors,’ Thorin said as he studied Bilbo’s profile, ‘I was often invited to taverns with my shield brothers after the training of the day was done. Ale flowed freely on those occasions and the younger guards were expected to show their worth by matching the others cup for cup, no matter how they liked the flavour.’

‘You grew up around warriors? Is that usual for the crown princes of Erebor?’ Bilbo shifted on the bench, turning more fully towards Thorin.

‘No, it isn’t.’ Thorin turned as well. ‘There is the basic weapon’s training, of course, and after that the crown prince would be put to work in managing the realm and learning diplomacy in preparation for the throne. But my father didn’t want that for me.’ He stopped and lifted his cup for a deep, slow swallow.

Bilbo was now sitting completely sideways, his knee folded on the bench between them.

Thorin sighed. ‘He was afraid that any proximity to the treasure hoard, any work involved with supervising the mining of gold, any acceptance of foreign gifts, they would all worsen my… my affliction and lead me down the same path that my grandfather took. Better to keep my mind and my body tired with strenuous swordplay every day with the guards.’

‘But what about when you’re king? You can’t rule a dwarven kingdom with just the swing of a sword.’ Bilbo took a perfunctory sip of his ale but all his attention was focused on Thorin.

‘There’s my elder sister, Dís,’ Thorin said. ‘She took up all the work my father didn’t want me doing and it’s expected that she’ll support me when I take the throne,’ Thorin said with a grimace before taking another drink of ale, ‘even though she would make a far better ruler than I’d ever be.’

It was on the tip of Bilbo’s tongue to ask why Thorin’s sister couldn’t be king – or rather, queen – instead of him, but he washed it away with a sip of ale. It was not the place of a hobbit to question the customs of dwarves, and Thorin had been more forthright with him than he had any right to expect from a prince.

And this day had been so nice, as well. The whole last week, as a matter of fact. Listening to Thorin’s heavy foot steps down the hallway, feeling the sturdy presence of the dwarf behind his back in the kitchen, hearing his low voice telling him about Erebor. And today, seeing Thorin’s eyes finally light up with pleasure had been something that Bilbo would never forget. And it had made him greedy for more, wanting to give Thorin the second kiss already, yearning to experience more of the world afresh through Thorin’s newly-awakened senses.

Bilbo leant back against the bench and closed his eyes. He could hear birds swooping over the meadow in front of his smial; their mating calls mixing with the low buzzing from a neighbouring hive of bees to make a lovely music to his ears.

But it was suddenly interrupted by the sound of stifled laughter coming from the lane passing by his bench. He opened his eyes to see a pair of young hobbits, barely out of their tweens, walking slowly by his smial. They kept whispering together, their eyes darting from Bilbo to Thorin before descending into giggles as they moved past his gate and kept glancing over their shoulders back at the couple on the bench.

‘Have the hobbits of the Shire never seen any dwarves before?’ Thorin asked, his fingers tightening around his cup.

‘They have. The dwarves from the Blue Mountains pass through here sometimes.’ Bilbo took another deep swallow, letting the ale linger in his mouth as he hoped that would be an end to that conversation.

Thorin still gazed after the two hobbits. ‘Strange…’

‘I wouldn’t let it trouble you,’ Bilbo said as he looked down on his outstretched feet. ‘Some people just like to laugh.’

The sun didn’t seem as warm anymore nor the birds so musical. And the ale had grown too bitter in Bilbo’s mouth. But he said nothing. It would only ruin Thorin’s first day, his first real day.

Notes:

There's fan art for this chapter: Ruto drew the scene where Bilbo teaches Thorin to cook scrambled eggs.