Actions

Work Header

Oak and Mistletoe

Chapter 8: To Understand

Chapter Text

The latch fell softly into place as Thorin closed the door behind him.

He shivered. The fireplace had been roaring in his father’s bedroom, and the chilly hallway was both a relief and a shock after that heat.

‘Was he happy to see you?’

Thorin looked up at his sister who waited quietly on the other side of the hallway.

‘I think so.’ He exhaled a long breath. ‘I don’t know. He called me by name but I don’t know if he saw me.’

Her eyes softened as she nodded in understanding. ‘He’s had better days.’

‘When did it begin?’

‘Sometime in the middle of summer. He’d start growing unusually tired at council meetings, diplomatic dinners, often losing the thread of the conversation. Then one morning his personal servant knocked insistently on my door, telling me that his Majesty wasn’t able to get out of bed.’ She pressed her lips together at the memory. ‘He’s stayed there ever since.’

Thorin swallowed. ‘What does Óin say?’

She blinked rapidly. ‘He says--’ Her hands twisted in front of her. ‘He says— Oh, Thorin.’ She covered her eyes with her hand, her shoulders rounding in on her body, almost turning away from her brother as she tried to control her uneven breath.

Thorin watched Dís for a moment before stepping closer, slowly raising his arms before enfolding her in a firm embrace. He could feel her stiffening slightly in surprise, her breath stopping for a moment, before she slowly rested her head against his shoulder, her arms holding him as well. Her tear-streaked cheek touched the side of his neck and the smell of metal was in her hair. He tightened his arms around her, needing her warmth.

They stood together for a while, the silence of the hallway quieter than the silence at their father’s bedside.

Her forehead pressed against his shoulder. ‘This is the first time,’ Dís whispered, ‘the first time you’ve held me this close and meant it, truly meant it.’ She sniffled against him.

‘I know,’ Thorin said.

Her arms tightened around his middle. ‘When your first letters came, telling us what had happened, what the hobbit healer had done for you—’

‘Bilbo,’ Thorin corrected, almost without thought.

She leaned back and looked up at him, her eyes fastening on his. ‘What Bilbo had done for you – I couldn’t believe it. It sounded like Mahal himself had appeared in the Shire and shown you his favour. After all these years…’ She shook her head, a small smile pulling at her lips. ‘It’s incredible.’

‘If it was Mahal,’ Thorin said, ‘then he chose Bilbo Baggins as his instrument.’ He smiled as well. ‘And I’m glad he did.’

Dís brushed the last of her tears from her cheeks as she moved back from the embrace. She looked up at her brother, trying to read this new expression on Thorin’s face. ‘You should have invited him to come with you,’ she said. ‘You must have known that he would have been celebrated as a returning hero by our people and showered with gifts of gratitude. I, myself, am ready to offer him half of our treasury for returning my brother to me.’

Thorin looked away, allowing himself to imagine Bag End. It would be filled to the brim with dwarven gold and jewellery if Dís had her way. Every shelf, table and mantelpiece would be covered with it, and Bilbo would have to move very quietly through his home for fear of disrupting any of the fineries. Thorin smiled wider as he imagined Bilbo eating his scrambled eggs from gold plates and drinking his tea from gold cups. Somehow, it just didn’t fit.

‘I couldn’t ask him to come,’ he said to her. ‘He’s the only healer in his village. It would be unfair of me to - I couldn’t ask him.’

Dís nodded, still studying Thorin’s face.

Thorin looked away from that probing gaze. ‘You didn’t move my chambers while I was away, did you?’

‘No, they’re where you left them. I had your bags and packs brought up.’ She walked in the direction of Thorin’s chambers and he followed. ‘Your pony seems to be quite sturdy and strong. I think she might do very well as a mining pony. What do you think?’

‘No.’ Thorin couldn’t imagine a creature from the green Shire down in the dark pits of Erebor. ‘Just – just keep her in the royal stables for now. Tell the grooms to keep her well-fed and exercised.’

‘As you wish,’ Dís said, stopping in front of the door to Thorin’s chambers.

Thorin put a hand on the handle. ‘I’d--’ He turned his head slightly towards Dís. ‘I’d like to be alone for now. It was a long journey.’

She nodded. ‘Of course.’ She brushed a hand over his back and looked up at him. ‘I’m so happy to have you back again.’

Thorin gave her a small smile before opening the door and stepping into his rooms.

The first thing that struck him was their sparseness. No hangings or paintings decorated the walls, there were no carvings in the wood of his furniture, and every fabric was a basic brown or grey. Thorin hadn’t needed anything more than this half a year ago.

His packs had been placed in the middle of the room, the smaller bags leaning against his filled travelling pack. Thorin took quick steps, walking to them with purpose, needing to find what he had packed with care a couple of months ago in Bag End.

It was covered with several layers of cloth and nestled away between his clothes. Its blunt edges appeared as he uncovered it, running his fingers over the simple wooden frame. He lifted it away from the pack and placed it on the seat of a chair, leaning against the back.

It was the Shire, or at least the part of it which contained Bag End. The small watercolour had hung over Thorin’s bed there, and it would now be the first decoration in his home at Erebor.

His eyes took in the lush green of the scenery, needing it now more than ever. The round doors of the hobbit holes were spread across it, the dots of colour lending some cheer to the image. At the very top of the picture was a green door. Thorin focused in on it, kidding himself into seeing a small figure sitting on the bench outside the smial. He could just make out the white of the shirt and the red of the waistcoat. He wondered how long he had been sitting there. Had he just enjoyed a small cup of ale after dinner? Or had he spent all afternoon reading in the sunshine? Would the wind pick up, rustling his curls and making him shiver? Would he stand up, stretch and walk back inside? And then Thorin’s eyes focused on the closed, green door again, and the figure was gone from the bench.

He blinked. The green colours receded from view, and he was standing in his rooms in Erebor once more.

The sound of quick steps came from outside his door, like someone hurrying past to get to his father’s chambers. Maybe a servant with a change of linen or a tray of simple foods for the bedbound king. Thorin felt a stab of guilt. His father was close to passing into the other world, and all he could do was stand here and disappear into his memories of a single summer. As much as Bilbo had changed his life, he had a duty to his father now.

He heard a door open and close. He remembered how he had looked, lying quietly in that bed. His father had never looked smaller than he did then. His crown had been removed along with his robes of state, and he looked frail and old. His skin was thin, stretching over his bones. His hair and beard lay listless. A great king of dwarves laid low at the end of his life.

Could you have helped him, Bilbo? I never asked and you never said. Maybe it was because we both knew the answer. No matter how deep you dug in your library, no matter how many plants you gathered in the forest, it wouldn’t have helped, would it? Because there’s no cure for death - the final death at the end of a long life.

Thorin felt an itch in his body, like he was waiting for something to happen. He tried sitting down but soon bolted up again, walking stiffly around the room. He didn’t want to see anyone else but he also didn’t want to be alone with his thoughts. Making a decision, he walked back out the door and went to sit by his father’s bed.

 

X—X

 

The snow was falling thick and fast outside, covering the view from Bag End in a white blanket. Bilbo stood back from the window, letting the small curtain fall down as he did. It was the eve of the first day of Yule, and all of Hobbiton had retreated indoors to gather with their families in preparation for the festivities.

Bilbo looked up at the portraits of his parents over the fireplace, framed as they were by some evergreens in the spirit of the season. Maybe he would even bake some of Baggins special Yule bread to have with his tea tomorrow.

The crackle of the fire was the only sound as he settled into the chair in front, picking up his new book in preparation for an evening of reading.

After a couple of pages, he stopped and reread a particularly amusing passage. He lingered over the words, enjoying the apt turn of phrase. He wanted to read it out loud, feel his tongue twist around it, giving his best recital to bring out the comedy.

He looked up from the page, preparing to perform to the audience. But there was no one there. The chair on the other side of the fireplace was empty. It had been empty for more than four months now. And now Bilbo felt silly, reading to an empty room.

He cleared his throat and looked back down at the page, trying to focus on the words. They had often done that, Thorin and him. They had often sat next to each other after the last meal of the day, one or both of them reading. Some evenings they’d do more talking than reading, others they were content to merely sit together in silence, caught up in their own books. And sometimes they would read to each other. Bilbo preferred reciting the humorous bits, wanting to make Thorin laugh. And Thorin would often go through Bilbo’s histories of Middle-earth, reading out every passage where elves were being greedy, prideful or just plain idiotic with a barely concealed glee before Bilbo challenged him into another playful discussion about the worth of elves.

Bilbo smiled. Those evenings were what he missed the most, now that he was alone again.

The log settled in the fire, the sound of it bringing Bilbo back from his memories. He shook his head, relieved that this seemed to happen less and less now. It had been a lot harder in the beginning. He remembered returning to Bag End on that day. The windows had looked dark in the sunshine, making his home seem hollow and empty. When he had stepped through the door, the silence of the many rooms had overwhelmed him in a way that it hadn’t done since the death of his parents. And in the days following, he would often stop what he was doing when something - a word, a taste, a smell – would remind him of Thorin, of something he had said, had done, the way he laughed, the way he grumbled. And so Bilbo would stop, and he would remember.

He looked unseeing into the flames of the fireplace. Those had been the toughest days.

Bilbo shook his head again and decided to make another attempt at his book. But he had only read two sentences when he was interrupted by three heavy knocks at his door.

He frowned. Most of Hobbiton knew well enough to stay inside when the snow fell like this and even more so on the eve of Yule when the pleasures of home were that much more enticing.

He stood up, leaving the book behind in the seat of the chair. He wondered briefly if there was any need of his help but the knocks had been measured and even. Not the frantic pounding of someone in need of urgent attention. And they had been quite heavy, very unlike the light knocking of a hobbit.

Bilbo suddenly stopped halfway between his chair and the door, feeling the colour leave his cheeks. What if…? It was unlikely to be him but maybe someone of his kin with a message for Bilbo? No ravens had stopped at Bag End since Thorin’s departure, though Bilbo had often tracked their movement across the sky until they were out of sight. He felt silly hoping for anything after months of nothing but…

He almost fell over his feet, covering the distance to the door as fast as he could. He took a moment to calm his breathing before pulling open the door to greet his visitor.

‘Gandalf?’ Bilbo took a step back, blinking fast as he looked up at the wizard. ‘Wha- what are you doing here?’

‘Now, Bilbo Baggins, is that any way to greet an old friend who has come to visit?’ Gandalf’s deep voice held notes of amusement.

Bilbo’s hand still held onto the door frame. ‘I didn’t know you were coming past the Shire.’

‘Neither did I, until I was. And here I am.’ A small pile of snow fell off the brim of his hat. ‘Am I invited in?’

‘No, no – of course. Yes.’ Bilbo stepped back, averting his gaze, afraid that Gandalf would read too much in it. ‘Won’t you come in?’

The wizard’s robe swept over the floor, the edge of it stiff from the freezing snow. Bilbo closed the door after him, leaning back against it as he watched Gandalf duck his head around the hanging candelabra.

‘I suppose you’ll want tea?’ Bilbo regretted the curt words as soon as he had said them, but the disappointment was still stinging him.

Gandalf narrowed his eyes, studying Bilbo. ‘Please.’

Trudging past, Bilbo barely offered Gandalf a second glance as he made his way to the kitchen. Rarely did the wizard appear without some purpose of his own. But Bilbo had learned a long time ago that this purpose would only appear when Gandalf was ready. It would be no use questioning him before he had at least finished his first cup of tea.

Steam billowed up from the kettle, and Bilbo poured the hot water over the leaves in the pot before bringing it out into his parlour where Gandalf sat waiting.

‘Thank you,’ he said, warming his hands around the cup as Bilbo poured. ‘It’s a bitterly cold night to be out walking.’

Bilbo sat down, filling his own cup. ‘I somehow didn’t think that wizards felt the cold?’

‘Oh, we do, we do. Perhaps more than others at times.’

Bilbo took a cautious sip of tea instead of replying to that cryptic remark.

Gandalf finished his own sip. ‘I’ve been meaning to congratulate you,’ he said, ‘on your great success in curing the dwarven prince.’

‘Thorin,’ Bilbo added quickly.

‘Ah.’ Gandalf nodded. ‘And I also wanted to know how you did it.’

Bilbo pursed his lips. ‘Well, after Thorin told me what you had said, it was fairly easy to guess what you meant.’

Gandalf tilted his head slightly to the right. ‘What I said?’

‘Yes, you know. About the – oh, what was it? – about the original view of Bilbo Baggins. And that’s what led me to the large oak.’

‘Oak?’

‘Yes, with the summer mistletoe?’

‘Ah, you used the life force of the mistletoe?’ Gandalf nodded. ‘Very good, very good.’

Bilbo frowned. ‘Don’t sound so surprised. You’re the one who pointed me to it.’

‘Was I?’ Gandalf’s brows lifted. ‘Oh, I suppose I was. Well, it all turned out as it should anyway.’

‘No, hang on.’ Bilbo stabbed the air with his finger. ‘Are you saying that you meant no riddle with those words?’

The corners of his mouth twitched. ‘Not everyone is as fond of riddles are you are, Bilbo. I’m sure I only meant those words as a recommendation of your skills to old King Thráin. And I was right, after all.’ He smiled gently at Bilbo over his tea cup.

Bilbo breathed out a short laugh as he dropped his hand. ‘All this time, I thought I had been acting on the advice of a wizard. And it turns out I was relying on nothing but my own judgment.’

‘As you should be.’ Gandalf hummed as he put down his tea cup. ‘And it was a good thing you found the cure so fast, and that Thorin was able to reach Erebor before his father’s death.’

Bilbo stilled, holding his breath. ‘The king is dead?’

‘He passed away at the beginning of winter, surrounded by his family as he drew his last breaths. The ravens were sent out bearing the message shortly after.’

Bilbo looked down, focusing on his hands in his lap. The king was dead. And some small piece of hope that Bilbo didn’t even know he had been holding onto was dead, too. It had been foolish of him to even entertain the idea that Thorin might be able to return to him, even if it was just for a visit. Because now the crown prince had his duties to his kingdom. The king is dead. Long live the king.

‘I’m--’ He cleared his throat. ‘I’m sorry to hear it.’

‘And now it remains to be seen how Thorin will do as a ruler. Thankfully, he has his sister to help him.’

‘I’m sure he will do very well.’ Bilbo was still looking at his hands. ‘He has a kind and honest nature.’

‘Does he, indeed?’ Gandalf said before finishing the last of his tea. ‘The sickness must have concealed that when I met him before the summer.’ He leaned back in his chair. ‘But now, would you mind terribly giving an old man shelter over the Yule days? I’m afraid I can’t face this snow again before I’ve rested my feet and dried my robe.’

Bilbo blinked. ‘Of course! I’m sorry that I didn’t invite you immediately. My mind seems to be miles away these days.’

‘I can see that. So, I invited myself.’ Gandalf’s eyes twinkled. ‘And I wanted to see if you’ve acquired any new additions to your excellent library. I am sure it will soon rival the one in Minas Tirith in everything but size!’

Bilbo gave a small smile. ‘I’m sure it won’t.’ He pushed back from the table. ‘I did get a very interesting volume recently,’ he said, standing up and moving away from the table. ‘But some of it is in a language unknown to me. Perhaps you can look at it for me?’

‘Of course, dear boy. Of course.’

And so they spent the evening together, pouring over the foreign words and phrases until the fire slumbered in its crate and the candles were low. Gandalf talked no more about Thorin and his father, and Bilbo didn’t ask.

It was only when Bilbo was alone in his room, when he closed his eyes, trying to sleep, that the memories returned to him again. And the strongest one was of Thorin lying in the grass outside Bag End and smiling up at him.

 

X—X

 

‘Come on, Uncle Thorin!’

‘Take it easy,’ Dís warned as she followed Fíli and Kíli down the stairs, Thorin coming up behind her. ‘They’ll knock a hole in their heads with the way they’re sprinting around.’

‘They’re just boys,’ Thorin said, ‘and they’re excited about showing me their surprise. And Mahal knows I need something exciting after that council meeting.’

She slowed at the bottom of the stairs, waiting for him to catch up to her. ‘It wasn’t as bad as all that.’

‘You think spending an entire day discussing trade regulations is exciting?’

She shrugged. ‘There were some interesting points raised, and it was a necessary discussion to have.’

‘You might find it interesting. I struggled to follow most of it.’

She looked up at him. ‘It will get easier, Thorin.’

‘Will it?’ he asked, striding forward to follow his nephews.

It was the start of spring, several months after the death of his father. The King’s crown lay in the treasury, waiting for the day when Thorin was ready to take up the mantle, to take up his birthright. But while Thorin might be born to be king, he had yet to feel like he was meant to be king. All his life had been drowned by his sickness and now, after finally being able to breathe the air again for a short while, he was being pushed into a position for which he had never prepared.

He looked back at his sister following him. She had prepared. She had taken up all the work a king’s heir should have been doing and done it better than Thorin would have ever done. And she liked it, as well. Thorin thought back to how she had been in that council chamber – listening attentively to others while her eyes were sparkling, her mind already formulating a counter-argument and then delivering it with relish. He also remembered her at their father’s funeral procession, the two of them walking together at the front. She had carried herself like a queen, head held high but with sorrow in her face. He remembered how their people had looked to her to guide their behaviour in that time of grief, how one dwarrowdam had reached out and kissed the hem of her robe, wanting to pay homage to such obvious majesty. Dís was everything that a monarch should be. And Erebor would be lost without her.

He reached the door to his room where Fíli and Kíli were fairly bouncing with excitement.

‘The surprise is in my room?’ he asked.

‘In a manner of speaking,’ Fíli said with a grin.

‘Yes, you will definitely see the surprise in your room,’ Kíli added, nudging his brother in his side.

‘Stop trying to be cryptic, boys,’ Dís said as she joined them. ‘And give your uncle his surprise. Maybe that will put a smile on his face.’

Thorin glanced at her as Fíli and Kíli opened the door and beckoned them to come inside.

The room looked the same as when Thorin had left it that morning, nothing added and nothing taken away. The watercolour still hung over his bed, its green colours looking especially vibrant against the stone wall.

Fíli and Kíli went around the room, dousing candles and banking the fire until the only light was the pale one coming from the window behind the curtains. They led the way to the window, pulling and pushing at Thorin until he was positioned perfectly centred in front of it before each grabbing a curtain.

‘Ready?’

Thorin rolled his eyes good-naturedly. ‘Ready.’

The curtains were pulled back. At first, they only revealed the early night sky, the dark blue at the horizon blending into the deepest black at the top of the archway of the world. But as Thorin stepped closer to the window, small spots of light emerged from the darkness. He looked up, following the lines of stars, comparing their sizes and seeing shapes emerging. They spread out further and further, creating a ceiling of speckled light.

Without thinking, he opened the window and leaned out, craning his neck to take in as much of the sky as he could. It seemed to be above him and all around him, the darkness not closing in on him but unwinding into all directions, unending and full of stars.

When he had ridden from the Shire to the Erebor, his gaze had been down and front and his mind always hundreds of miles behind him. When he had arrived at Erebor, he had burrowed deep into the mountain, first attending his father’s bed and then his funeral. And when the crown had waited for him, he had been overwhelmed with a king’s responsibilities. There had been no time or inclination to look at the stars.

‘We met some sort of travelling wise woman in Dale today,’ Fíli said behind him. ‘She said that the night sky would be filled with more stars tonight than on any other night in the year.’

‘And we thought that no one would appreciate it more than you, Uncle Thorin’

Dís saw her brother’s mute appreciation and patted her sons on the back. ‘You’re good boys,’ she said with a small smile.

Kíli tried to catch his uncle’s eyes. ‘Did you ever see anything like this before, Uncle Thorin?’

Thorin’s lips felt dry and he licked them. ‘N-no. Never.’

Fíli tilted his head to the side. ‘You can’t see the stars in the Shire?’

Thorin looked over his shoulder at him. ‘I’m sure you can. But Bilbo never showed them to me.’

‘Well,’ Kíli said, ‘then it’s a good thing you came back to us so we could show you.’

Thorin turned and looked back up at the sky.

But he would have shown me, he thought. If they had had time enough, Bilbo would have shown him the stars. Thorin was certain of it. But it had only been one summer. And anyway, what would have been enough time to spend with Bilbo? More than one season? A year? A life?

Thorin breathed deeply. Even though it was spring, the night air still bore the crisp frost down from the top of the mountain, carrying with it the smell of many freshly sprouting herbs and weeds. It reminded him of the smell in Bilbo’s kitchen when he was drying his plants above the stove.

As he focused on a particularly bright star, a sudden unsettling thought entered into his mind. Maybe Bilbo had never looked, really looked at the sky at night? After all, their light does nothing for Bilbo’s plants, and you can’t cure a sickness by knowing the constellations. You can’t read them like a book nor gather them in a sack for later use. The stars were for the travellers, navigating through the world. And they were for the farmers and the priests, keeping track of the seasons and sowing the right crop or performing the right ritual. But Bilbo was not a farmer or a priest, and he was definitely not a traveller. He had no need of the stars, so maybe he had never looked at them.

Thorin’s hands gripped the windowsill hard, his skin whitening against the stone.

‘Uncle Thorin?’

The voice was distant, so distant that he had no idea whether it belonged to Fíli or Kíli. Something had shaken lose in his mind, and now his memories, his duties and his wishes whirled between each other as he tried to recapture them and put them in their proper places. And in the centre was the urgent desire to show Bilbo the stars, to give this small thing back to him who had given the world to Thorin. Everything else seemed to pale in contrast to this single urge. And Thorin’s thoughts calmed and he started to make sense of it.

‘Thorin?’

He felt a hand on his arm, and he finally turned back to his family. Dís stood the closest, a deep wrinkle running down the middle of her brow as she looked at him. Fíli and Kíli stood behind her, sharing a concerned glance.

‘Was it too much at once?’ Dís asked. ‘The stars, I mean?’

‘No.’ He shook his head, feeling it clear for the first time in months. ‘Not at all. They helped me to see clearer and further. And I came to a realization.’

‘What realization?’

‘That I know now what I need to do. And I need your help to do it.’

 

X—X

 

Bilbo’s leather satchel beat against the middle of his thigh as he walked slowly down Bagshot Row. It had been a long and busy day. First, there had been the farmhand who had cut his foot with his scythe. The wound had been deep and the patient had been squirmy, giving Bilbo an ache in his back after bending over for so long to clean and bandage it. Then there were the family of eight where all the fauntlings had woken up with mysterious rashes which needed to be first cooled, then diagnosed as the effects of playing among stinging mulberry bushes for an entire day, and now Bilbo had an evening of mixing up enough ointment to last the family for a week to look forward to. Lastly, there had been a broken ankle which Bilbo had reset and supported as best as he could, but he still worried that it wouldn’t heal properly and that Iris Cotton would walk with a slight limp for the rest of her life.

He sighed and adjusted the strap over his shoulder and trudged onwards. The sun was unusually hot for the last month of spring, its beams only managing to make Bilbo more tired and grumpy. But at least it was better than winter. During the winter, he had spent too much time indoors with his memories as his only company. Bilbo needed the work, needed something to occupy his hands and his mind. Even if it only amounted to tiresome days like this one.

He would have to cook dinner when he got home and as he walked, he mentally went through the contents of his pantry, trying to come up with ideas which would take the least amount of effort to prepare. And then he would disappear into his bed, wanting to end the day as soon as possible.

Bag End came into view. Bilbo didn’t want to look at it, almost expecting there to be a line of more people asking for his help. But as he walked closer, he was able to make out some movement on the roof over his door. It wasn’t the wind rustling the tree or a foolhardy fauntling who had climbed too high. It was small and black and… Bilbo squinted. Was that wings?

The bird turned sideways, revealing its distinctive black beak, the beak of a large raven.

The leather satchel picked up speed in its swings, beating harder against Bilbo’s thigh. But he paid it no mind as he ran as quickly as he could towards his home.