Chapter Text
By six o’clock, Bilbo had already changed his shirt twice, rearranged the table three times, and informed Thorin no fewer than four times that he was perfectly calm, which would have been much more convincing if he had not been saying it while darting from the kitchen to the sitting room with the urgency of someone trying to prevent a minor disaster.
Thorin, for his part, had learned that offering help was safest when done carefully.
“Where do you want this?” he asked, standing at the edge of the kitchen with a bowl in both hands.
Bilbo turned from the oven, curls already falling loose around his face from the heat. “Not there, that’s where the potatoes are going.”
Thorin glanced at the completely empty patch of counter. “I see.”
“You don’t,” Bilbo said, taking the bowl from him and setting it down two inches to the left. “But that’s alright.”
Thorin watched him for a moment, then reached out and caught the dish towel hanging off Bilbo’s shoulder before it slid to the floor. Bilbo looked up, blinked once, and the flush in his face deepened a little, though whether from the heat or from Thorin leaning so close was difficult to say.
“You are fussing,” Thorin said.
“I am hosting.”
“You are fussing while hosting.”
Bilbo sniffed and turned back to the oven. “Well, someone has to maintain standards.”
Thorin let the corner of his mouth lift. “And here I was thinking you invited them because you wanted your friends over.”
Bilbo pulled the tray out, squinted at it, then set it down and blew out a breath through his nose. “I do want them here. That is not the issue.”
“No?”
“No.” Bilbo picked up a spoon, put it down again, then finally faced him properly. “It is only that this was meant to be a simple dinner, and somewhere along the line it became…” He glanced toward the table in the other room, where the good glasses were already set out and the candles had been lit even though it was not yet dark enough to warrant them. “…something of an occasion.”
Thorin’s gaze followed his. “That sounds like you.”
Bilbo narrowed his eyes. “That could have been insulting.”
“It was not.”
“Mm.” Bilbo looked at him another second, then his expression softened despite himself. “Take the bread in, would you?”
Thorin obeyed without argument, which only made Bilbo look more suspicious.
“I’m starting to think you’re being agreeable on purpose.”
“I am always agreeable.”
Bilbo laughed outright at that. “You are many things, Thorin Oakenshield. Agreeable is not one of them.”
Thorin set the bread on the table and looked back at him. “And yet I am still here.”
That quieted Bilbo for half a beat. He lowered his gaze, smiling to himself as he adjusted the sleeve of his shirt. “Yes,” he said more softly. “You are.”
The knock at the door came before either of them could say anything more.
Bilbo started for it at once, then stopped and turned back. “Do I look alright?”
Thorin gave him a long look that began at his face and ended, very deliberately, at the cuffs of his shirt. “Yes.”
“That was not a proper answer.”
“It was an honest one.”
Bilbo huffed. “Hopeless.”
He opened the door to Bofur first, which felt fitting somehow. Bofur swept in like he brought his own weather with him, warm and cheerful and already smiling.
“Well,” he said, looking past Bilbo with obvious interest, “it smells incredible in here. Ori, I told you he’d outdo himself.”
Ori, standing just behind him with a neat little parcel balanced in both hands, smiled shyly. “I said he might not want extra dessert.”
Bilbo’s entire face softened at once. “You brought dessert?”
Ori held it out. “Only something small. I thought it might be nice to contribute.”
“That is very kind,” Bilbo said, taking it with both hands as if it were something delicate and precious. “Thank you. And don’t listen to Bofur, I am perfectly capable of restraint.”
Bofur leaned to one side and looked over Bilbo’s shoulder toward the dining table. “That is a bald-faced lie.”
“Get inside,” Bilbo said, though he was laughing when he said it.
Nori slipped in after them, one hand tucked into his coat pocket, the other holding a bottle by the neck. He glanced once around the flat, taking in the candles, the table, the amount of food visible from the doorway, and then looked at Bilbo with far too much understanding.
“I’m not saying a word,” he said.
“You were about to.”
“That was before I decided watching you squirm would be more entertaining.”
Bilbo pointed toward the sitting room. “Go be unbearable somewhere else.”
“Gladly.”
The last knock came only a minute later. Dwalin stood on the other side with the expression of a man who already regretted attending but had shown up anyway out of loyalty, which, for Dwalin, was practically affection.
“You’re late,” Bilbo said.
“I’m on time.”
“You’re not.”
Dwalin stepped in and handed him a bottle. “Then I’ve brought compensation.”
Bilbo took it, glanced at the label, and raised his brows. “This is actually good.”
Dwalin grunted. “Obviously.”
By the time everyone had settled into the flat, the room felt properly occupied. Bofur had somehow ended up near the kitchen before Bilbo could stop him, Ori was helping carry things to the table without needing to be asked, and Nori had already appointed himself drinks duty with the kind of casual efficiency that suggested he trusted no one else to pour properly. Dwalin took in the whole scene from near the sideboard, arms folded, saying nothing, which usually meant he was more amused than he cared to admit.
Thorin moved through it all with more ease than Bilbo would have expected a month ago. He carried dishes when Bilbo passed them to him, steadied the back of Bilbo’s chair when it caught against the rug, and once, when Bilbo turned too quickly and nearly brushed straight into him, simply put a hand to his waist and set him back where he belonged.
Bilbo did not look at him for a second or two after that.
Dinner began in that pleasant, half-chaotic way good dinners often did, with everyone talking at once for the first few minutes, passing plates and correcting one another and reaching across the table with muttered apologies. Bilbo had put Thorin at his right without making any sort of fuss about it, though Bofur noticed immediately and Nori definitely did, but for once both of them kept their observations to themselves.
For nearly ten whole minutes, in fact.
“This is ridiculous,” Bofur declared at last, sitting back with his fork in hand and the expression of a man personally wounded by good food. “I mean that sincerely, Bilbo. I don’t know how you expect anyone to behave normally after this.”
Bilbo looked up from serving Ori a second helping of potatoes. “You were never going to behave normally.”
“That’s true,” Ori admitted, smiling down at his plate.
“It’s still very good,” Bofur said. “Best potatoes I’ve had in ages.”
“That’s because Bilbo puts too much rosemary in them,” Nori said.
Bilbo stared at him. “Too much?”
“I didn’t say it was a problem. I said it was too much.”
“That means it’s a problem.”
“It means you’re committed.”
Across the table, Dwalin tore off another piece of bread. “You’re all talking too much.”
“That is because we’re enjoying ourselves,” Bofur said.
Dwalin pointed with his knife. “And that’s why your food’s getting cold.”
Ori, who had been smiling quietly into his glass for the last minute, glanced at Bilbo. “You seem nervous.”
Bilbo nearly dropped the serving spoon.
“I am not nervous,” he said too quickly.
Nori took a sip of wine. “You are a little.”
Bofur perked up immediately. “Oh, is this why everything’s so fancy?”
“It is not fancy.”
“Bilbo,” Nori said dryly, gesturing at the candles.
Bilbo followed the gesture, then looked back at him. “Those are decorative. They were already there.”
“They were not,” said Thorin.
Bilbo turned to him in betrayal. “You could have supported me.”
“I do not lie well.”
“That has not stopped you before.”
Thorin’s brows lifted. “When have I lied to you?”
Bilbo opened his mouth, paused, then had the decency to color a little. “That,” he said, “is entirely beside the point.”
It was at that exact moment that there came another knock at the door.
Everyone stopped.
Bilbo closed his eyes.
“No,” he said, before anyone else could. “Absolutely not.”
“Maybe if you ignore it, it will go away,” Nori suggested.
“Nothing in this building has ever worked that way,” Bilbo muttered, pushing back his chair.
He crossed the room and opened the door to find Gandalf standing there with a small tin of white paint in one hand and a brush in the other.
Bilbo stared at him.
Gandalf looked down at the brush as if only just remembering he held it. “Ah. Good. You’re home.”
“What,” Bilbo said, very flatly, “are you doing.”
“There was a chip in the paint by your doorframe.”
Bilbo looked at the doorframe. Then at Gandalf. Then back at the doorframe.
“There is not.”
“There was.”
“When.”
Gandalf shrugged. “Earlier.”
“And you came to fix it at dinner time.”
“I keep unusual hours.”
From the table, Bofur called, “Let him in, Bilbo, I want to see where this goes.”
Bilbo turned his head just enough to glare in that direction. “You are not helping.”
“I rarely do.”
Gandalf, apparently taking Bilbo’s exhausted silence as permission, stepped inside and handed the paint and brush to a bemused Thorin as he passed. Then he stopped at the table, looked over the spread with visible approval, and without the faintest scrap of shame picked up an empty plate from the sideboard and began serving himself.
Bilbo looked back at the open door, as though considering the possibility of simply walking out and starting a new life elsewhere.
Ori, trying and failing not to laugh, asked, “Should I move over?”
“Don’t trouble yourself,” Gandalf said, already taking the last open chair. “I shan’t be in the way.”
“You are the definition of in the way,” Bilbo replied, closing the door and returning to the table.
“Then it’s fortunate you’re fond of me.”
Bilbo sat down with a sigh. “That is not the word I would have chosen.”
“Of course not.”
The interruption, absurd as it was, scattered the conversation just enough that everyone needed a moment to resettle. Gandalf helped himself to the potatoes and approved of them aloud, which earned him a muttered “well, naturally” from Bilbo. Bofur asked whether the chipped paint had a tragic backstory. Nori wanted to know if Gandalf carried emergency paint supplies with him everywhere he went. Gandalf, maddeningly, answered both questions with complete seriousness.
It should have ruined the moment.
Instead, somehow, it made Bilbo less tense. Or perhaps it only made continuing to delay feel more ridiculous.
He put down his fork, wiped his hands once on his napkin, and looked around the table.
“Since we have now apparently reached the point of no return,” he said, “I am going to say what I meant to say before the building itself began interfering.”
That got everyone’s attention quickly enough. Even Gandalf paused, though only so he could eat while listening.
Bilbo took a breath. For the first time all evening, he let himself look directly at Thorin instead of glancing and looking away again. Thorin met his gaze with the same steady calm he always had, and something in Bilbo’s chest settled.
“I asked you all here because there was something I wanted to tell you together,” Bilbo said. “Properly. Not by accident, and not because Bofur notices far more than he should, and not because Nori would inevitably work it out and then hold it over me for the next six years.”
“I wouldn’t wait that long,” said Nori.
“Five, then.”
“Much better.”
That got a small laugh around the table, enough to loosen Bilbo again. He pressed on.
“Anyway,” he said, a little pink around the ears but smiling now, “Thorin and I have been together for the past few weeks.”
This time the pause that followed felt intentional rather than awkward.
Ori smiled first, bright and immediate. “Bilbo, that’s lovely.”
Bofur slapped one hand against the table in delight. “I knew there was a reason this dinner felt important. Good for you. Both of you.”
Nori raised his glass. “About time.”
Dwalin let out a rough sort of huff that, with him, nearly qualified as laughter. “You’re all late. I was first.”
Bilbo turned toward him at once. “That is not something to be proud of.”
“It is when I had to pretend not to know while the rest of them walked around clueless.”
“We were not clueless,” Bofur protested.
“You were,” said Nori.
Ori glanced between them all, smiling into his wine. “I’m very happy for you,” he said, quieter than the others, but no less sincere.
Beside Bilbo, Thorin had gone very still in the way he often did when feeling something deeply and trying not to show too much of it all at once. Bilbo noticed, of course he did, and under the table his hand shifted just enough that the side of his little finger brushed Thorin’s against the chair seat between them.
Thorin turned his hand over.
It was the smallest touch in the world, barely there, but Bilbo’s breath caught anyway.
“And I,” said Gandalf, because of course he chose that moment, setting down his fork with maddening satisfaction, “knew giving you that key was a good choice.”
Bilbo covered his face with one hand.
Bofur nearly choked laughing. “He actually said it.”
“Oh, he has been waiting to say it,” Bilbo said through his fingers. “He’s been waiting for weeks.”
“Not weeks,” Gandalf said. “A little over a fortnight.”
“You see?” Bilbo dropped his hand and looked around the table as though appealing to reason. “He kept track.”
“It was a significant administrative decision,” Gandalf replied.
Nori leaned back in his chair. “That is one way to describe meddling.”
“I prefer ‘foresight.’”
“You would.”
Bilbo looked sideways at Thorin, who, to his credit, had the decency to appear faintly embarrassed at last.
“You might at least pretend to be sorry,” Bilbo murmured.
Thorin looked back at him. “Would that help?”
Bilbo considered it. “No.”
“Then I won’t.”
That made Bilbo laugh, helplessly and with real affection in it, the last of the evening’s nerves finally gone.
Bofur raised his glass first. “Well then,” he said, grinning around the table, “to Bilbo and Thorin, and to whatever improbable chain of events got us here.”
“To Bilbo and Thorin,” Ori echoed warmly.
Nori lifted his glass as well. “Try not to make us suffer through another secret this long.”
Dwalin raised his own with a grunt. “Do better than the rest of us.”
Gandalf, naturally, joined in too. “To excellent judgment.”
“No one is drinking to that,” Bilbo said.
But they drank anyway.
After that, the night loosened all at once. The game came out after dessert, and immediately devolved into the sort of chaos Bilbo ought to have expected from the people he’d chosen to invite. Bofur argued with the rules on principle. Nori improved them in ways no one else agreed with. Ori tried very hard to keep things orderly for almost twenty minutes before giving up and laughing along with the rest. Gandalf played as though he knew things he shouldn’t, which, knowing him, was entirely possible. Dwalin won the first round by sheer stubbornness and denied caring when Bofur accused him of taking it far too seriously.
Bilbo ended up half turned in his chair toward Thorin more often than not, and every now and then he would lean in to say something low, just for him, or nudge his knee under the table when Bofur got too loud or Nori too insufferably smug. Thorin, who had once been so rigid in company that every word from him felt carved out of stone, had softened in ways the others plainly noticed. He still spoke less than the rest of them, but when he did, it was easier now, dry where it used to be curt, amused where it used to be severe.
At one point Bilbo reached over to steal one of Thorin’s cards, purely because he could, and Thorin caught his wrist before he got very far.
“That,” Thorin said, “is cheating.”
“That,” Bilbo replied, making no effort whatsoever to free himself, “is affection.”
Bofur made a strangled sound into his drink. Ori hid a smile behind his hand. Nori said, “That is unbearable,” though his expression suggested otherwise.
Thorin looked at Bilbo another moment, then released his wrist only to set the stolen card in front of him. “Then keep it.”
Bilbo stared, blinked once, and then smiled in a way that made Thorin look away first.
Later, when Ori began to droop sleepily against the side of the sofa and Bofur threw a folded napkin at Nori for accusing him of inventing rules again, the evening started winding down of its own accord. Plates were cleared in stages, glasses refilled one last time, and the loudness of the room softened into something warmer and slower. Gandalf announced, around his final sip of wine, that the paint would simply have to wait until another evening, which earned him a look from Bilbo so withering that even Dwalin laughed.
One by one, they began to leave.
Ori thanked Bilbo twice, once for dinner and once for letting him bring the cake. Bofur hugged him hard enough to lift him half an inch off the floor, then did the same to Thorin, who endured it with the patience of a man being tested by the gods. Nori clapped Bilbo once on the shoulder and murmured something low that made Bilbo smile and roll his eyes at the same time. Dwalin lingered just long enough to fix Thorin with a meaningful look, then Bilbo as well.
“I meant what I said,” he told them both.
Bilbo folded his arms. “You usually do.”
“Good.” Dwalin nodded once. “Then listen.”
After that, even Gandalf went, though not before patting Bilbo on the shoulder and telling him the chip in the paint had “worked out better than expected,” which nearly got the door shut on his sleeve.
When the flat finally emptied, the silence that followed felt full rather than lonely. There were dishes stacked in the sink, abandoned cards on the table, a folded throw half slipping from the arm of the sofa where Ori had dozed. Bilbo stood with one hand still on the door for a moment, then turned and looked over the room with the faint, dazed expression of someone only now catching up to his own evening.
“Well,” he said. “That happened.”
Thorin, who had been gathering glasses, glanced toward him. “You survived it.”
“Barely.” Bilbo stepped further into the room, then smiled. “Though I will admit, that went better than I feared.”
“You feared it?”
Bilbo gave him a look. “I cooked for six people, invited them here to announce a relationship I have spent weeks trying not to look too pleased about, and then Gandalf appeared in the doorway with paint and an agenda. Yes, Thorin. I feared it.”
Thorin set the glasses down and crossed the space between them. “And now?”
Bilbo looked up at him. “Now I think I was silly.”
“Yes.”
Bilbo narrowed his eyes. “That was not the correct response.”
“It was the honest one.”
Bilbo tried to stay offended and failed almost immediately. “Terrible answer.”
Thorin’s hand came to rest at Bilbo’s waist, steady and familiar now in a way that still made Bilbo warm all over. “You were lovely.”
That caught him off guard enough that he went still.
“Oh,” he said.
Thorin’s thumb shifted once against his side. “You always are.”
Bilbo stared at him for a long moment, visibly trying to decide whether to laugh, kiss him, or say something clever. In the end he settled for stepping closer, both hands coming up to smooth the front of Thorin’s shirt where there was nothing wrong with it.
“You know,” he said, softer now, “you are much easier when there isn’t an audience.”
“I am easy enough.”
Bilbo snorted. “Now who’s lying?”
Thorin bent his head, just a little. “Stay and find out.”
Bilbo laughed then, quiet and fond, and leaned in until his forehead rested briefly against Thorin’s chest. “I do live here,” he reminded him.
“Good,” Thorin said. “Then I shall stay.”
Bilbo lifted his head again, smiling in earnest now. “I was hoping you would.”
They did clean a little, because Bilbo would never leave the whole mess until morning, but not much. Enough to stack the plates, enough to save the leftovers, enough to blow out the candles and set the chairs back where they belonged. It was slower work than it ought to have been, interrupted by touches that lingered and by Bilbo reaching around Thorin only to have Thorin catch his hand and kiss his knuckles as though that were the most natural thing in the world.
By the time they were done, the flat looked lived in again rather than prepared. Bilbo stood in the middle of it, hair a little messy, sleeves rolled, cheeks still pink from the warmth of the kitchen and the wine and the long evening, and Thorin thought, not for the first time, that there was nowhere else he would rather be.
Bilbo caught him looking.
“What?”
“Nothing.”
“That means it’s something.”
Thorin considered denying it, decided against the effort, and said only, “Come here.”
Bilbo did.
And this time, with the door shut, the dishes done, and no one left to interrupt them, there was no reason at all not to kiss him.
