Actions

Work Header

A Three-Strand Braid

Chapter 2

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

When Tauriel arrived back to Dale, Bard took the game from her gratefully, before he took a closer look at her face.

“Did something happen?” he asked her, concerned. “Did you and Kili have an argument?”

“Not an argument,” she replied, still a bit shaken. “Just… a bit of a misunderstanding.”

Although that was probably an understatement. Kili had made an attempt to enlighten her about why Fili was giving her courting gifts as well, before rushing back to Erebor to tell his brother what had happened, leaving her just as confused as before he began his explanation.

“I’m sure it will sort itself out,” Bard said comfortingly, patting her on her shoulder. “And if it doesn’t and you want me to send him packing the next time he comes, let me know.”

That made her smile a little. She didn’t need Bard’s protection, but it was kind of him to offer. “That isn’t necessary, but thank you.”

Bard nodded, obviously still concerned but willing to accept her word. She followed him back into the house, and let the simple routine of preparing a meal, followed by Sigrid and Tilda to styling her hair and Bain asking for somewhat gruesome details about fighting spiders to ease her mind, even if she did find herself playing with both Kili’s runestone and Fili’s brooch after the children had gone to bed.

The next morning, she found Fili at the front door, hand raised to knock, as she prepared to leave for the day.

“Ah,” he said, obviously surprised. “I was wondering if we could go somewhere and talk – only if you want to though, I’m not…”

Tauriel couldn’t help a small smile at his uncharacteristic babbling. “I think that talking is a good idea,” she agreed.

Tauriel grabbed her bow in case they came across any more game, and then they walked together through Dale. Fili called out greetings to some of the dwarven workers, and Tauriel nodded at those who waved at her, but between them was silence.

It wasn’t until they reached the rabbit snares that she had set out the previous day that Fili spoke, looking at the trapped rabbit rather than her, pulling out one of his many knives to help prepare them.

“I think that there has been some sort of misunderstanding between us,” he began.

“Yes, I think so too,” she agreed. “What-” she began.

“How-” Fili asked at the same time, and they laughed, the awkwardness between them breaking.

“What were you going to say?” Tauriel asked, still laughing.

“How many spouses do elves have?” he asked. “Just the one?”

“Yes,” Tauriel said quietly. “Just one, for our whole lives, no matter how long we spend apart or if one of us dies.”

“It’s a little different for dwarves,” Fili said. “With us, it’s not uncommon for brothers to court the same person, though once a dwarf falls in love, their feelings never change.”

Tauriel stared at him, the rabbits forgotten. “I see…” She trailed off. She couldn’t get her head around it; it was completely foreign to her.

Fili was watching her carefully. “Does that idea disgust you?” he asked, his voice neutral but his eyes sharp.

She shook her head instantly. “No,” she replied. “It’s just…strange to me.” She was turning the pieces around in her mind, trying to get it to fit with what little she knew of dwarven culture, which she had discovered after meeting Kili, was woefully small and mostly inaccurate.

He laughed a little. “I suppose it is strange, if you are not used to it. I think it’s strange the other way round. For us though, it’s quite sensible. The tradition started way back, because there are fewer dwarrowdams – female dwarves – than there are males, and not every one of those is interested in marriage. ”

“That is sensible,” Tauriel replied. Once she knew the reasons behind it, the tradition made sense, especially among the practically minded dwarves. “Is it only brothers that court together? And only woman – dams? – that take two husbands?”

“Oh no,” Fili said. “It’s the most common, but certainly not the only way it has to be. While it’s usually brothers, it could also be cousins, or very old friends, or two who are already lovers. Any two dwarves, really, that know each other well enough to spend a life together, whether or not they are already, or ever will be, a couple.”

“I see,” Tauriel said slowly.

“And it’s not unheard of at all for two dwarves to court another male, or two dams another dam, though that’s a bit rarer. Bombur’s two eldest daughters are courting Gloin’s youngest daughter, and last I heard they were looking around for a dwarf of good standing who wants to be a father but not a husband to help them get with child.” He shrugged. “Most dwarves care little about whatever gender – if any – their partners are.”

“I think I understand,” Tauriel said slowly, still trying to take it all in. Her hand crept up to toy with her brooch as she thought.

“I can’t help but notice that you are still wearing the brooch,” Fili said quietly. “I will not hold you to an offer that you didn’t know you were accepting...”

“Fili,” she interrupted, struck by a sudden thought. “Did you make me this offer because of Kili? Or because you are following your people’s traditions? Or because you wanted to?” Despite all her confusion, she didn’t want to be courted by anyone who didn’t really want her.

He looked surprised at her blunt question, and took a long moment to consider his words.

“Kili knew how he felt about you the first moment he saw with you,” Fili told her quietly, and Tauriel stared at him wide-eyed. “Some dwarves love like that, instantly and irreversibly. I am not like him,” Fili admitted. “But I am fond of you, and not just for Kili’s sake, or because you saved his life – or my life,” he added, as if that were a lesser accomplishment. “I would like the chance to court you to see what could grow between us.”

“That seems fair,” Tauriel said, and Fili grinned. “But I have one last question – if we decide that we are not a suitable match, what happens then, to us, and between you and Kili?”

“If we decide that we are not suited,” Fili said with a small smile, “we part way as friends, with no blame laid on either of us. We would not be forced to marry just to follow the tradition – as you know, Gloin is married, yet, Oin is not. He was only ever interested in his craft, and no one would have forced him to marry when he did not want to, or Gloin to remain unmarried because his brother prefers it that way.” He paused as Tauriel nodded her understanding. “And as for Kili and myself – he is my brother. I have loved him since before he was born. There is nothing that will ever change that.”

“That’s good to know,” Tauriel said, relieved. She hated the thought of there being any conflict between them, especially not for her sake.

“So,” Fili asked carefully, “Now that you know what the brooch means, will you wear it?”

“I…” Tauriel trailed off, and watched as Fili’s face fell a little, though he tried to hide it. “I’m not very good at this,” she admitted.

“What do you mean?” Fili asked carefully, one of his hands coming down to toy with the knife at his hip.

“When I was a Mirkwood Guard, I didn’t… I was focused on my duty, and then I was made Guard Captain and… I never thought that I would…”

She trailed off, embarrassed, but Fili didn’t tease her, just nodded encouragingly.

“What I am trying to say,” she began again, “is that matters of love, and courtship are new to me. Meeting Kili was a shock in more than one way.” Fili laughed, and suddenly she knew exactly what she wanted to say.

“I’d be honoured to wear it,” she replied earnestly. “I also care for you a great deal, and I would like to know what there could be between us.” Fili already bright smile grew even wider and Tauriel felt warm at the knowledge that she had caused it. “I only ask that you inform me if it seems that there are any other traditions that I am going to be unfamiliar with. And have patience with me, as I am still getting used to this.”

“That’s seems more than fair,” Fili said, his grin not dampening at all. “But I also should ask how marriage is done among your people – I would like to make you as comfortable as possible.”

“Well,” Tauriel began slowly. “Among my people courting is quite informal – we have centuries to get to know each other, after all. We don’t have any ceremonies or anything, the first time a couple…” she trailed off, suddenly awkward. “The first time they lie together they are considered married.”

Fili’s eyebrows rose and his pleased grin turned wicked. “So we would both have to lie with you at the same time to be considered married? I’m sure we can figure something out.”

Tauriel felt her face heat up and she turned back to the snared rabbits.

“You’re blushing!” he observed in delight. “I didn’t even know elves could blush!”

“You’re terrible,” she muttered, and he laughed.

“Come on, let’s finish these,” he said. “Bilbo told me to invite you for dinner, if you’d like, and we should tell Kili what’s happening before he wears a hole in the floor with his pacing.”

---

Kili could obviously tell from the moment they both arrived in Erebor that they had managed to resolve the misunderstanding, because he threw his arms around them both in a massive relieved hug.

The dinner that evening was as fine as any other she’d had in Erebor, the last awkwardness she always felt as she first entered faded away as she sat with Fili and Kili on either side of her, helping Ori practice his Sindarin.

Later, when the meal was finished, the dishes, miraculously unbroken, were cleared away, and the dwarves had broken out their instruments, Tauriel overheard Bilbo ask Thorin quietly “So, both of the boys are courting Tauriel?”

“Yes,” Thorin answered, and she couldn’t tell if his answer was a grumble or merely low.

“And… that’s alright?” Bilbo asked, sounding as confused as she had been earlier.

“Is that not done amongst hobbits?” Thorin wondered, and Bilbo laughed.

“Hobbits are polite enough to know that what goes on behind closed doors among adults is none of our business, even if we are nosy enough to speculate about it over afternoon tea,” Bilbo replied, sounding amused. “I just don’t want any of them to get hurt.”

“They won’t,” Thorin assured him, his voice warmer than she’d ever heard. “It’s not uncommon among dwarves – the same dam married Bofur and Bombur.”

“Really?” Bilbo asked. “That explains a lot – I just thought that I’d misheard whenever they mentioned her name.”

Thorin chuckled. “I promise you, everything will be fine.”

Tauriel relaxed then, watching as Fili and Kili played their fiddles, and Bofur danced along (badly). If Thorin thought that everything would be alright between them, then she had a lot more confidence herself that it would.

When the party was in full swing, and they could slip away unnoticed, Kili took her hand and led her deeper into the heart of the mountain. She didn’t mention her discomfort, but he must have known because he squeezed her hand tightly and didn’t let go.

“We want to show you something,” Kili told her. “We’re not far away now.”

This deep within the mountain it was dark, even for her elven eyesight, with only the occasional torch to light the way. But Tauriel could hear the sound of running water get louder.

“Is that a waterfall?” she asked, but Kili only grinned and didn’t answer.

“Here we are,” Kili said, and Fili emerged from around a corner, obviously waiting for them. Tauriel had to duck her head under a beam, and then she stared in utter shock.

“This is the River Running,” Fili told her with a small smile. “Its source is just ahead, but from here…” he trailed off, waving her hand.

From where they were standing, the water was tumbling through a high break in the cavern wall, and at this time, the moonlight made the water shine silver.

“It’s beautiful,” Tauriel said; her voice caught in her throat. The fact that they had known that she would like this left her feeling incredibly touched.

“We thought you’d like,” Kili said, squeezing her hand again.

“We know that you find the idea of living in Erebor difficult,” Fili added. “We want you to know that there are things here that you’ll like.”

“I know there are at least two things I like here,” she said, and she was only not embarrassed when she saw how pleased they were at her words.

They exchanged a glance between them, one that was surprisingly nervous, and then Kili said, “There is a special braid that dwarves put in each other’s hair when they are courting – we were hoping that you would let us put one in yours.”

“You’ll have to show me what to do,” she agreed, perching on a rock so they could reach her hair properly.

“I’ll show you,” Kili said. “Fili’s hopeless at braiding.”

“Hopeless is a strong word. You’re not much better.” Fili objected, and Kili snorted.

“Who do think does his hair for him? And why do you think that I don’t bother with mine?”

Their fond bickering made her smile as they put the braid in her hair, three small plaits – one for each of them - to make up one larger one, before repeating it for both of them. She reached up and touched it carefully, noticing that they were doing the same.

“Thank you,” she said, not sure if she what exactly she was thanking them for, but knowing that she meant it.

They must have understood, because they sprawled next her to her and half on top of each other, and they stayed long after the moonlight faded from the waterfall and the only light came from the torches.

---

She saw Fili and Kili almost every day after that, usually together, but sometimes one or the other of them were caught up in their duties in Erebor. They would often join her working in Dale or hunting, occasionally setting up an archery or knife-throwing competition. Sometimes they would camp overnight, and she would listen to their stories about Ered Luin, and their family, and the journey to Erebor. She would tell them about her life in the Woodland Realm, the endless battles with the spiders, and about how much she had wanted to see beyond their boarders. She found herself spending more time in Erebor, and she was slowly learning to see the beauty in the stone (and they understood that she would always prefer the starlight).

She was starting to be unable to picture her life without them in it.

She had realised long before, when she’d heard that Kili had been hit with a Morgul arrow that she had loved him. She had felt a strange recognition in their first meeting, a strong bond with someone who many people would assume should be her enemy. Her feelings for Fili were different, slower to develop, based around friendship and admiration, but were steady and strong. However, she had a similar moment of revelation about Fili when they were stopped in the marketplace of Dale by a delegation from Mirkwood.

“Feren,” Tauriel said in surprise, of course recognising one of Thranduil’s guards. “Nae saian luume'.”

“Tauriel,” he said with a nod of his head. “I come with a message from King Thranduil.”

“Really?” she said in surprise. Thranduil was not usually one to go back on his word lightly, especially not after she had so openly defied him.

“He has heard that you are associated with not just one, but two dwarves. If you cease all ties with them, he will welcome you back into the Woodland Court.”

She heard Fili stir behind her, grabbing Kili’s arm as he went to intervene, but she didn’t stop to consider her answer.

“No,” she said unhesitatingly. “I will not.”

Feren's nose wrinkled slightly. “They have corrupted you,” he said disdainfully.

“They have done no such thing,” she replied angrily. “I love them, and they me.”

Feren sighed deeply. “They will die, Tauriel, and the century you have spent with them will seem like nothing at all. You will not even be reunited with them after death.”

“If I only have a century with them, then I will treasure every moment,” she said firmly, and she felt them stand at either side of her, supporting her.

Feren sighed. “I have my answer then. You know what to do if you change your mind.”

“I won’t,” she said, and watched as he nodded regretfully and turned away.

“He sounded like he had something spiky stuck up his robe,” Kili said, glaring after him.

“You love me?” Fili asked, and they both turned to look at him, Kili’s frown melting into a smile, one that Tauriel couldn’t help but mirror.

“Of course I do,” she said, and bent down to kiss him in the middle of the marketplace while Kili cheered alongside them, and Fili’s murmured “I love you too” was almost lost in the noise.

“Bilbo thinks that Thranduil is just concerned for you, but that he will come round,” Fili told her comfortingly when he pulled back, his hands still on her hips. “He’s invited him to our wedding, when we're ready for one anyway, along with Legolas.” He wrinkled his nose, not entirely able to hide what he thought of that.

“I bet Thorin’s thrilled,” Tauriel replied with a little laugh. She didn’t regret her choice to leave, not in the slightest, but she did miss Thranduil and Legolas, and she did hope that their estrangement would not last long. Not the lifetime of her lovers, certainly.

“Yeah, he’s ecstatic,” Fili agreed, rolling his eyes.

“While we’re happy to get elven married to you any time you like, the others will be very unhappy if we miss out on the chance to have a party,” Kili told her, smirking a little.

Tauriel smiled brightly as Fili swatted at him, and Kili dodged out of the way, laughing. "Bombur is already planning a cake!" he said, all wounded innocence and mischievous eyes. "And Dori has already designed all the decorations. I'm only thinking of them!"

The idea of courting two people, loving two people, had been utterly alien to her at first, but now, as she watched them, bright and laughing and happy, she could not picture her life without either of them in it.

In her heart, she knew that Feren wasn’t entirely wrong – he was wrong about them corrupting her, of course, but not about them only having a century or so together. But as strange as their courtship had been at the beginning, she was happier now than they had ever been, and if she only had a century with them, she did not want to waste any time with hesitation.

Notes:

Nae saian luume' - It has been too long.

I don't see Fili and Kili's relationship as romantic, but since it is a bit ambiguous I tagged for incest just in case.

I really enjoyed writing this - Fili/Kili/Tauriel is a fast growing OT3 for me! - and I hope that you have enjoyed it as well! Thank you for the prompt!