Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 2 of Handholding
Stats:
Published:
2015-08-02
Completed:
2015-08-18
Words:
59,104
Chapters:
3/3
Kudos:
82
Hits:
0

Rough Drafts

Chapter 3

Summary:

Bilbo and Thorin's tryst comes to a bad end.

Notes:

It is over! Thanks everyone for sticking around and reading! Keep in mind that this is the chapter where thearchive warnings I put up go into effect... Enjoy :^)

Chapter Text

Thorin led the way back down the Mountain, speedily making his way back to the Front Gate. He held Bilbo’s hand with his own, but he did not have a care to see whether or not the hobbit was keeping up. Too consumed, he was, with the thought of his gold lying alone, unguarded.

 


 

“The Lonely Mountain. It is ours,” Thorin said, standing under the arch that remained of the Front Gate.

“Yours, really,” said Bilbo.

“Mine,” Thorin agreed. He pulled Bilbo close to him, holding him against his chest. The dwarf breathed deeply in relief once inside the Mountain. Finally, it was his. He nosed at the coarse and burned hair at the back of Bilbo’s head in a tender gesture. His gentle manner fell away quickly. Lifting his head, he loudly began to bark out orders. Everyone was to scout out the various entrances to the Mountain, and to make sure they were all sealed.

Everyone, that is, except for himself and Bilbo.

“There are six entrances to the Lonely Mountain. She is shaped like a six-pointed star, with six spurs that come out from her skirts.” Thorin paused, peering into a room on his left. Whatever he saw was not what he was searching for; he frowned and kept walking. For once, during their time in the Mountain, Thorin walked slow enough for Bilbo to keep up. The dwarf was enjoying himself immensely— enough to walk at a leisurely pace and help Bilbo up the stairs. “There is a door between each spur, as well as a guard-post. Then, of course, there is the secret entrance, so that makes seven entrances. I figure that two dwarves to inspect each door, discounting the secret one, as it is already destroyed, is good enough. They do not need us.”

“You do not have to explain yourself to me, Thorin,” said Bilbo. He adjusted the grip on his torch, and lifted it higher above his head to avoid the smoke. “I would much rather have a tour by you than look at some old doors. Now, where is it that we are going?”

“I thought to show you the royal quarters, as they are not so far away from the Great Hall. Perhaps the Company could sleep in there once we ensure the Mountain is sealed, and safe from all those brigands on their way.” Bilbo did not like much the way Thorin referred to the starving Lake-men, and their elven allies, but he did not say so. “At first, I was going to show you the Mountain’s Chamber of Records, as I recall your home being filled with many a book and scroll. But that will take a great many dwarf-stair to reach, and I do not believe you are quite up to the task. And I fear that some of the ancient architecture of this place may be crumbled far beyond safe use; I would not risk it, just to show you some old books written in a tongue you do not speak.”

“I would like to see it one day, anyhow,” said Bilbo. “But thank you for thinking of my feet, and my hobbit-legs.” Thorin smiled, and Bilbo liked to think that he held his hand even tighter. “Did you know, Thorin, that I’ve been thinking about writing a story about all this?”

“The tales of this journey are already in the process of being recorded, no doubt, in the dwarven tongue, as well as Common speech. However,” declared Thorin; “I will treasure your word above those of a poet or scholar. I did not know you wrote any,” finished the dwarf lamely.

“It is nothing to make a fuss about. A Gentlehobbit has little to do, generally, so I started writing as a way to pass the time. Poems and songs, mostly. You’ve heard some of them, and doubtless you will hear more, as courtship will make you my captive audience. At any rate, I have never written anything quite of the magnitude of this quest, and that is just of the bit that has happened so far. I have a feeling yet that the last chapter has not come to pass.”

“What is it about my palace that makes you so despondent, dear heart? Why do you act so, when the purpose of our journey is finally fulfilled?”

“It is not your palace so much as it is the armed elven host I expect at your door. It will come any day now, you see, and I do not know how well I will do under that sort of stress. Now that you mention it, however, it is rather dark in this place. Perhaps a skylight would make my mood a touch brighter.”

“Not many dwarf palaces boast great holes in their sturdy roofs, lest they be naturally occurring. That was no negative answer, Bilbo, and do not frown so. The Lonely Mountain can be one of the first. As soon as we are rid of the thieves who think to steal from me, Dáin’s folk will aid in the restoration and redecorating of the Mountain. They will see about your skylight, I’m sure.”

“I am glad to hear it. Now, Thorin, how much longer shall we be walking? And do you think we could stop for luncheon soon? Though all I have is a bit of cram in my pocket, I would like to stop and eat it sometime soon.”

Thorin did not say anything. Instead, he led Bilbo up one last flight of stairs, and past a series of dingy and moldy looking tapestries. At the top of the stairs was a set of heavy stone doors. The doors were carved elaborately, and faintly gleamed. Hundreds of years of dust and grime masked the precious stones set into the door and the gold inlaid into the seams.

“More dwarf doors,” said Bilbo. “What say these? Do you need a password, or a queer little ceremony to open ‘em up?”

“Nay,” said Thorin. “The only thing that kept these doors closed were two outfitted guards, each with a silver-hafted axe. And even then, no dwarf would go in during the reign of Thrór; few would risk the consequences. On the doors, there,” (here he pointed); “you can still see the picture that once gleamed, depicted in polished and precious stones. There is the sign of my house: a crown of seven stars.”

“To show that the rulers of Durin’s folk live within?”

“You guess well, Bilbo. Through these doors are the royal quarters. And to answer your former question, we can eat within. I will light the torches, and we shall have a little picnic. Though feasting was done in the Great Hall, the ruling family often had meals in the privacy of their own quarters.”

Then, Thorin let go of Bilbo’s hand and pushed on the doors. They were no secret entrance. They were a pair of well-made dwarven doors. As a result, they swung in soundlessly, lifting up clouds of dust into the air. Bilbo coughed as Thorin walked in, lifting his torch high over his head.

They walked for a while in silence. Bilbo wanted to stop every three steps, to take everything in. Finely carved statues, set into walls. The ceiling was carved with skill, in varying geometric shapes. Nothing resembled anything living, most unlike the art of the Shire. Still, it was all very beautiful, in its exotic and interesting patterns. Tapestries, eaten away by time, hung damp on almost every wall. Every few paces, a door was carved into the stone. Bilbo itched to peer inside and see what sort of things dwarf royalty kept in their rooms, how folk of such high standards lived, but still Thorin walked on. To stop himself from getting distracted by every little thing he saw, Bilbo kept his eyes on his feet. To his delight, even the floors were beautiful. They were paved straight, and inlaid with glittering stones of blue and white and green. They reflected the light of Thorin’s torch, and threw multi-colored spots along the walls and across Bilbo’s feet.

“It is beautiful in here,” said Bilbo. He looked up, and just in time, too. Otherwise he would have run right into Thorin’s back. The dwarf had finally stopped, and he faced an indentation in the wall. Bilbo made to grab Thorin’s hand, but before he could, it was lifted to brush away cobwebs. They were everywhere in the Mountain, of course, but now was the first time Thorin made a move to wipe them away. They had wrapped around a granite statue of a stately looking dwarf.

The statue had Thorin’s nose, and the same tattoos. Still, they were different. The dwarf wore more jewelry in his ears and nose, and had more chains wrapped about his neck. His eyebrows were not nearly as bushy as Thorin’s, though his beard was twice as long. The clear difference was in the hard look in the eyes, and the harsh set of the lip.

“Thrór, King Under the Mountain,” said Thorin. He turned to Bilbo. “A dwarf of all dwarves, yet still he lost this place.”

“You won’t. You shall lose me before you lose this Mountain.” Bilbo stepped closer to Thorin, and lifted up his free hand to the dwarf’s face. He traced the hard line of his cheek, and the wrinkles that lined his eyes. Thorin’s beard twitched. The direct light of the torch cast his face in sharp relief, but Bilbo ignored the shadows. “And you will never lose me,” he said.

“Never is a strong word to come from such a small creature.”

“Well, I mean it. I would not be parted from you, not from any action of my own. I would swear it, had I anything to swear by. Now, you will have some more strong words from me if we do not have that luncheon soon, and I mean that, too!”

“I believe you,” said Thorin, with a bit more cheer than he had before Bilbo had said his piece. “Come, it is not that much longer of a walk.”

 


 

It was not much of a picnic, but it was made into a grand event by the setting and the company Bilbo had. The dining chamber could have sat fourteen formally, and even more, had someone wanted to place extra chairs along to the table’s edge. It had been dark and dismal when they first entered, but Thorin relit the lamps lining the walls (they still, somehow, had oil in them), and everything was lit merrily thereafter. Thorin entertained Bilbo with stories of the dwarves who once made their busy way about the royal quarters, holding his hand over the finely carved table. Often he would sit back, and just gaze at Bilbo in the golden light of room, watching the hobbit glow golden-brown in his too-big seat.

Thorin looked every bit a King, sitting at the head of the table in his gold-washed mail and fine woven cloak. He poured the tepid water from his waterskin into jeweled goblets, and his dark eyes glittered at Bilbo over the gilded rim of the chalice. The way the dwarf sat as he ate his cram, Bilbo could imagine he was instead feasting on finely roasted lamb, and drinking the finest vintage wine.

The effect was a bit ruined every time he tasted the dry waybread, but not so much that he totally dismissed the image. He rather liked imagining Thorin as the King he could— would— be.

“Are you finished?” asked Thorin abruptly, just as he finished a tale about a rather clumsy manservant.

“Er,” said Bilbo. “Yes. I’m done eating, anyway. Why?”

“I want to search the Treasure Room for a while, before the Company gathers once more at the Front Gate.”

“What for?”

“The Arkenstone,” said Thorin, impatiently. “I want it within my grasp before the invaders arrive. And it will take some time to search through all the gold my grandfather amassed, as you pointed out before. I was going to ask you if you knew the way back to the Front Gate yourself.”

Bilbo looked down at the table, and traced a small gouge in it with his fingernail. He did not want to meet the dwarf’s eyes, as he thought Thorin might be able to see guilt somewhere in their depths. He hoped his hand was not sweating with nerves, as Thorin was holding it, and would surely notice. The King’s Jewel was, thankfully, no longer inside his breeches. Instead, it was wrapped in a bundle of rags, which was functioning as his pillow. Still, he was beginning to feel a bit guilty about keeping the jewel from Thorin. Perhaps he would have given it to Thorin, had it still been in his pocket. At least, that was what the hobbit told himself.

“If I knew the way back to the gate, I would not go. I would help you look,” said Bilbo. “My eyes are keener than yours, you know.”

For a brief time, Bilbo felt almost that Thorin would kiss him again. He leaned closer to him, across the table, and something fierce alighted in his eyes. The dwarf just smiled, however, and squeezed Bilbo’s hand.

“It would not take keen eyes to spot the Arkenstone,” said he. “It shines like a star, or the pale Moon: it would take just one torchbearer to find it. Once light is cast upon the stone, it glints with a thousand beams of white radiance.

“Still, I accept your offer. Come, let us leave this place.”

And just like that, Thorin seemed to forget all the fondness he once had for the room. He extinguished the lamps quickly, ignoring their finely wrought shape. He left the jeweled chalices on the table, and paid no mind to the carvings on the walls, the ones he had described so fondly for Bilbo in Rivendell. All was forgotten, in the imagined light of the Arkenstone.

 


 

“Should we go?” Bilbo called out. Thorin had wandered away earlier, saying that Bilbo was searching his section of the chamber well enough on his own. (Which was a bit funny, as Bilbo was not putting any effort into searching. He stooped low, and picked up things to inspect them, sure. But he was going at such a slow pace that it was as if he was not searching at all. He snorted when Thorin complimented him, but the dwarf could not hear him over the sounds of gold coins clinking together.) Now all the hobbit could see of him was the small pinprick of his torch, which bobbed slowly as the dwarf climbed over his treasure. “Surely the Company wonders where we are!”

It took Thorin a while to make his way back to Bilbo’s side. Once he got close enough for the hobbit to see his face, Bilbo saw that the dwarf looked almost wrathful. “I suppose that means you haven’t found the stone either?” Bilbo shook his head. “I will find it. I should command the whole of the Company to search down here, so that it may be delivered to my hands within hours.”

“There are perhaps better things the Company could do to prepare for the armies that are approaching, Thorin. You would do well to listen to Röac’s words, I would say. But you are their King, and I doubt they will listen to me much for orders anymore, so do whatever you see fit. Anyway, whatever the Company will be commanded to do, they cannot receive orders until we go and join them at the Front Gate. So do let us go.”

Thorin thought that he would stay, and Bilbo could see the idea in the calculated gaze the dwarf gave his treasure. The hobbit was going to get Thorin to come to the Front Gate, however, even if he had to drag him bodily up the countless dwarf-stairs it took to get there. He grabbed Thorin’s hand and tugged, pulling the dwarf out of his musings.

“Why are you in a hurry?” asked Thorin. He pulled his hand out of Bilbo’s grasp, and instead threaded his arm through the hobbit’s. Together they plucked their way out of the Treasure Room. “What awaits you at the Front Gate that has you so eager?”

“Balin has some wrinkled old apple slices in his pack that I have been wanting to burgle,” said Bilbo cheekily.

Thorin laughed at that. “I am pleased to hear that your hobbit appetite still lives on. We had luncheon mere minutes ago, my dear, and already you crave more. I would not have you burgle, however, not anymore. I have my gold, and you never have to steal a thing again. You may have whatever you like— so long as you do not eat my treasury into ruin.”

The apples were the easiest lie to tell. The hobbit, of course, did not want a snack so strongly that he was willing to walk for hours, to climb stairs for it. What he wanted was to have Thorin stop talking about the Arkenstone so often. Everytime the dwarf mentioned it, Bilbo was feeling an increasing amount of guilt. And as long as they were in the Treasure Room, Thorin would continue to dwell on it. He would continue speaking of it, and Bilbo would not always be able to hide his shifty eyes. At least outside of the vast chamber, Thorin could be distracted by other things.

It was hard work to walk from the roots of the Mountain up to the Front Gate, but Bilbo found it was not so dreadful the second time around, since on the second trip upwards, Thorin was actually speaking to him. He wondered if his legs were getting used to the arduous climb, and shuddered to think that the stairs might do away with the last bit of fat he still had around his middle.

Perhaps he did need something to eat.

Another walk through the Great Hall, and a stroll along the River Running, had the two once again at the Front Gate. Balin, Dwalin, Nori, Bofur, Bombur, and Bifur were the only pairs who had made it back so far. Thorin told Bilbo that he would not be making any orders until everyone was there, and then took back that statement.

“I changed my mind,” he said. “An command from your King: I order you to go and get those apple slices you so desire, Master Baggins.”

He was in good humor, and spoke in a teasing manner: it seemed that at least three entrances to the Mountain were destroyed already.

“Certainly, my King,” said Bilbo, mimicking Thorin’s tone. He bobbed and bowed, and waved an imaginary hood in front of his knees, obviously making fun of how Thorin had introduced himself at Beorn’s home. Only once he had startled a laugh out of the dwarf did Bilbo talk to Balin.

 


 

“Where are we going?” asked Bilbo.

“A further tour of the Mountain. If we hurry, we can catch another sight of Fíli and Kíli before they go over the rise at the Southern spur.”

“That doesn’t answer my question,” grumbled Bilbo. For all his protest, he still let Thorin pull him along, up more dwarf-stairs than he cared to count.

Thorin showed him rather than told him. He took him up to the battlements. They were high up on the Mountain, and were accessed by a low doorway. A narrow walkway ran along the side of the Mountain, and there was a high wall with arrow-slits that protected those walking along from a nasty fall.

It was freezing, that high up on slopes. At the Front Gate, breath barely misted, and it was just cold enough to make you want a hat or a scarf over your ears. Up on the battlements, the wind blew fiercely, and Bilbo wished that his cloak was tallowed, to keep it from flapping about so much. Hobbits did not much care for winter, made for warm weather and green grass and harvest as they were, but the cold was good for two things, in Bilbo’s mind. It cooled the burns still on his feet wonderfully, and it gave him an excuse to stand closer to Thorin.

He wrapped his arms around Thorin and asked (with his voice rather muffled, pressed into Thorin’s side as it was), “Did you really wish to come up here to see your nephews off? I thought the wall we built at the Gate was high, but this is even worse, Thorin.”

Thorin was peering over the wall of the battlements, that was true. But his eyes were not fixed on the blue hoods that were making their way down the slope. They were focused further South, and to the East. In the air, tens and hundreds of birds were still flying about— and heading to Dale. If Thorin squinted, he could see the teeming mass of an army approaching the ruined city.

“I came to see if I could see the army Röac’s kin speak of. They are indeed heading to Dale. But to answer your question, aye, I did want to make sure Fíli and Kíli made their way out of the Mountain safely.”

At that, Bilbo unhooked his arms from Thorin and tried his best to peer over the wall. Only, it was a dwarf-wall, and a bit too small for a hobbit, even if he stood on the tips of his toes.

“I will take your word on that,” said Bilbo. “I am almost glad I cannot see over the wall; I could not bear to see the whole of the desolation. And the height I could drop from!”

“There is another reason I brought you here,” Thorin said, beckoning Bilbo closer.

“Why, but you already have three reasons!” Bilbo cried. He approached Thorin again, and stood before him, wrapping an arm about the dwarf. With his free hand, he kept count of his reasons, ticking off a finger for each one he said. “To see two nephews, to see who-knows-how-many Elves and Men, and to make Bilbo Baggins freeze to death. Come, what else could draw you here?”

“A serious predicament we are in, dear hobbit, yet still you jest. Bilbo, you may notice that there is no one else here. No dwarves, for they do not wish to freeze. No ravens, for they do not know we are here yet, though they could soon find us— we are not exactly inconspicuous with our bright mail and colorful hoods. There is a great deal of privacy, up on these battlements, with no one else around.”

“Why on Middle-earth would you need so much privacy for?” asked Bilbo, craning his neck to fix Thorin with a quizzical eye. He smiled widely, to let Thorin know that he knew exactly why the dwarf wanted privacy.

“A kiss,” said Thorin. “Or rather, dear Baggins, a Kiss, a proper one.”

“Proper as in how a Baggins is supposed to be?” asked Bilbo. “Because I do believe I gave you one of those already, Master Oakenshield.”

“Perhaps the sort of proper a Took would find suitable,” said Thorin. “That is what your mother’s name was, correct?”

“Yes, that was her name. Though kindly try not bring up my mother whilst we are in this sort of situation, if you please.”

“Never again will I,” swore Thorin. Then, when Bilbo did not say anything, simply smiling up at him, he said in a most shockingly informal tone: “Well? How about it?”

“It what?”

“A Tookish Kiss. I am expecting one now, Bilbo. Would you disappoint your King, your heart?”

“Certainly not,” said Bilbo. “Especially when he makes such a reasonable request. Now, a Tookish kiss, or Kiss, rather? You should be quite glad, Thorin, that we are out here alone...”

 


 

It was hard to keep Thorin from going into the Treasure Room. Always he was drifting to the edges of the Company, one or two steps away from standing truly apart. Always he wanted to dwell on the Arkenstone, and gaze upon all the gold that lay there. Always Bilbo would try to keep him with the Company. Often it did not work, but the hobbit still tried.

Now it was not only the fact of the Arkenstone that made Bilbo want Thorin to stay by his side. Every time the dwarf disappeared into the roots of the Mountain, he would come back in the foulest of moods. He would sit away from where the Company worked, and he would fix his gaze onto one spot. There he would stare, and get a look upon his face as if he were concentrating hard on something. And whatever it was he had his mind stuck upon, it was not happy.

Once Bilbo sat next to him, against the smoothly carved tunnel the River Running ran through. With Thorin, he watched the Company direct the water into a narrow channel so that would not destroy the wall they constructed to cover the Front Gate. The Front Gate was tall, and still the wall was taller. There were gaps in the stone to see (or shoot) through, but no entrance. When Bilbo asked how they would get out, a dwarf pointed to a ladder and a system of ropes and pulleys.

“What are you thinking about?” the hobbit asked once he was sat next to Thorin. “I have not seen you this angry since I pulled you out of the Forest River.”

“The gold. The treasure,” said Thorin. “I know what you think, Bilbo: that I am a dwarf consumed by gold lust, with no eye for the troubles I face. An open gate, my sister-sons out of the Mountain, all while enemies approach. But I do not dwell upon the gold because of how I value it, how I desire it.”

“Why do you dwell upon it then?”

“The treasures in that chamber are the heirlooms of my house, and of those who once dwelt near because of the goodwill of the Mountain and her King. All about are dark memories. In every piece I recall all the labors and all the sorrow of my people. I think of all that transpired to bring me back to this place, and how all the criminals approaching my gate plan on taking it all as spoils. I cannot allow it.”

Bilbo did not know what else to do, so he took Thorin’s hand and patted it in a way he hoped was soothing. He liked Thorin’s explanation for his behavior and his sour looks, but he was not sure he fully believed it. The dwarf denied his lust for the gold, but Bilbo had seen the hungry look in his eyes as he searched for the Arkenstone. He remembered the queer way the dwarf changed his behavior in the Treasure Room, the first time they combed through it for prizes. He could not forget the angry words Thorin had with him on Ravenhill, nor the words he gave to Röac.

He supposed both were true. Thorin was angry because of the news of armies advancing onto the Mountain for a bit of gold. He was angry that after all his struggles to reclaim the Mountain, suddenly there were folks in line to take an ill-deserved share of the spoils. But Bilbo knew that treasure did strange things to the minds of dwarves. And Thorin was no exception.

 


 

“I tire of black news on black wings,” said Thorin, watching Röac fly off once more to his nest.

“We all want peace,” said Balin. “Who knows whether we will get it.”

“Well, no one wants to avoid fighting as much as I do.” Bilbo stood with Thorin, his hand on the small of the dwarf’s back.

“Bilbo, you are the answer to it all. You can give the invaders and brigands one of your stern talking-tos, perhaps,” said Thorin. “Scold them so thoroughly that they have to turn around with their tails between their legs.”

“I cannot tell if you are jesting or not,” Bilbo told the dwarf. “Even if you are, I should like to give that Elvenking a bit of a tongue lashing, even if it is only to tell him that he should leave out more extra food, in case he gets more invisible guests. And also, to work on his spider problem.”

“It will take more than a few words to turn away that elf,” said Balin darkly.

 


 

Many days had passed, and many of them Bilbo saw neither hair nor hide of Thorin. The dwarf spent more and more days in the Treasure Room, rather than with the Company and Bilbo. One night, he had not been in the little chamber behind the Front Gate for ten minutes when they all heard heavy footsteps coming from behind them. Thorin stood up quickly, letting go of Bilbo’s hand (which he had been holding), to approach the dwarf running to them: it was Balin.

He explained that he had been keeping watch when suddenly, many a score of bright lights and fires sprang up to the South, in Dale.

“They have come!” Balin said, breathing heavily. He had run quickly down from the battlements, and was quite out of breath. “And their camp is very great. They must have come into the valley under the cover of dusk, along both banks of the river.”

Bilbo did not sleep well that night.

 


 

Thorin did not return to the Treasure Room the day thereafter. He wished to see what the elves and men would do next. As such, he was there when a company of Big Folk riding horses approached the Front Gate. They were all arrayed as if going into war: the Lake-men wore full armor, with swords at their sides, and there were two elvish bowmen riding with them. The dwarves and Bilbo all peered through various holes in the wall (they had laid it dry— as such, there were gaps) to watch and see what they would do.

The elves and men dismounted and picked their way carefully along the banks of the River Running. They stopped short when they saw what the dwarves had done to the Front Gate. They were surprised to see the tall and thick wall, as well as the pool of water that came as a result of the channel they had figured earlier in the week.

The group of them stood at the edge of the pool, speaking and gesturing at the wall. Balin nudged Thorin meaningfully and at last, the dwarf hailed them.

“Who are you,” he called in a loud and deep voice that carried through the stone, “that come as if in war to the gates of Thorin son of Thráin, King Under the Mountain, and what do you desire?”

He got no answer. As soon as the elves and men heard his voice, a large number of them turned swiftly about, heading back to their camp. Three or four of them remained behind, and they gazed awhile at the Gate and its defences. Soon enough, they were gone too.

Just because Thorin resided with the Company at the Gate did not mean that he spoke with them. While the dwarves and Bilbo went off to do other things, he remained standing, looking through the gaps in the stone. What he saw did not please him: Bilbo could hear him grumbling and growling all the way from where he sat, which was next to Glóin, all the way across the entrance chamber.

That day, the Lake-men and the elves moved their camp from Dale to directly in front of the Mountain. It sat in between the South-East and South-Western spurs, directly within the arms of the Mountain. The move was completed, with tents and people situated alike, just as the sun dipped below the distant trees of Mirkwood. Once all was settled, fires and torches flared up, and the rocks of the Mountain echoed with voices of mirth and song, as they had not done for many a day. Along with with the constant rumble of speech, there was the sound, too, of harps and of music. As it all echoed up into the dark space behind the Gate, Bilbo imagined that the chill of the stone was lifted. He could almost smell the fragrance of woodland flowers blossoming in spring.

Once Thorin was satisfied that the folk outside would do nothing more for the rest of the night, he stepped away from the Gate. He joined the loose circle the Company had formed near the channel of the River, in between Bilbo and Glóin. Close as he was to everyone, he did not speak. He did not touch, either. Though Bilbo edged closer and laid out his hand, Thorin did not acknowledge it. He kept his eyes on the gate.

Bilbo longed to escape the Mountain, then. He wished to be free of the dark and the cold. He wished to be warming himself next to a fire, rather than catching a chill at the side of a dwarf King who was doing a fine job of ignoring him. He wanted to be surrounded by mirth and the gentle notes of elf-harps. Most of all, he wished to be eating something warm and filling. He was not the only one who felt this way: the younger dwarves whispered amongst themselves that they wished things had turned out differently. They said normally, they would welcome such as the joyous folk outside as friends.

The scowl Thorin had been wearing since that morning somehow deepened. The Company noticed, and quickly made amends to their words against Thorin’s actions. They brought out the harps they had recovered from the hoard (Thorin had not been the only one combing through the Treasure Room), along with flutes and viols and fiddles and drums. They made music to soften Thorin’s mood and ease his frown. It worked, as it was no elvish music. It reminded Bilbo of the deep and rumbling song they had sung long before in his little hobbit-hole.

Only, instead of singing of the Mountain and the gold they had lost, they sang of what would be done, since now it was theirs. Durin’s wandering folk would return, and Thorin would take his throne. They sang of the Dáin’s people coming from across the desolation to aid Thorin in destroying his foes. Most of all, though, they sang of all the treasure that now belonged to Thorin.

The song had many verses, and when at last it ended, Thorin was well pleased. At any rate, he was in a much better mood from before. He smiled widely and grew merry, and clasped Bilbo’s hand. He laughed aloud at what Bilbo said, although none of it was particularly witty. He pulled the hobbit close and spoke to him of the Iron Hills and his distant cousin, Dáin. He wondered aloud how long it would be until they arrived at the Lonely Mountain, if he had set out as soon as the message from Röac reached him.

Before, Bilbo would have been pleased to have Thorin so close, to have the strong warmth of his hand resting broadly on his. Then, however, at the Gate, it only made Bilbo’s heart fall. He felt that both the song and Thorin’s talk sounded far too warlike.

 


 

The second time the Lake-men approached the Mountain, the Company watched as Thorin grabbed a bow and a quiver of arrows before they all climbed up to the top of the wall. The hobbit knew little of parleys between lords and kings, but he was sure that weapons were not supposed to be involved.

Though the arrows were not used during Thorin’s long talk with Bard, Bilbo was still not comforted. The parley had not gotten anyone anywhere. The hobbit was sure that Thorin would accept Bard’s terms. Because certainly, it was mostly their (Bilbo conveniently forgot how he was the one who egged Smaug on) fault that the dragon had razed Lake-town. Bilbo saw nothing wrong with parting with some of the treasure in order to rebuild the town of Men. And anyway, had Thorin not promised to keep Lake-town’s hospitality in mind once he reclaimed the Mountain?

But Thorin did not think at all of this. He was loathe to part with any of his treasure, and his mind was plagued with the thought of all the suffering and labor his people had gone through to have the Mountain once more within their grasp. He would not part with any of his gold, certainly not with an armed force at his gates. Certainly not with an armed elvish host at his gates! He told Bard as such, and the Man shook his head.

“The Elvenking is my friend, and he has succoured the people of the Lake in their need, though they had no claim but friendship on him,” said he. “We will give you time to repent your words. Gather your wisdom ere we return!” With that, the Man turned his horse and went back to his camp.

The elves and men were gone for many an hour, and during that time Bilbo tried to impart his wisdom on Thorin. He clasped the dwarf’s hand and begged for him to listen.

“We can avoid fighting if you would submit to the Man’s pleas,” said the hobbit. “This siege they want to put us in could be ended in a thrice if we just give them the gold they ask for, and maybe deserve, if you would ask me.”

“Therein lies the issue, dear hobbit,” said Thorin. “They wish to put us under siege. They camp at our gates with an armed host, and then say all they wish to do is parley. I will give no gold to a Man who stands at my gate with sword in hand. I will give no gold to an elf-friend. Instead, I will give him that!” The dwarf cast a very significant look to the bow of horn he had brought to the wall with him. He pulled his hand from Bilbo and crossed his arms with a stern look.

And indeed, Thorin was true to his word. The men of the Lake returned later, with banner-bearers and trumpeters. One of the trumpeters blew a long and loud note, and cried out his message in a well-rehearsed tone.

If Thorin would not submit to the demands of the Lake-men and the Elvenking of Mirkwood, then he would be declared their foe. And the demands were these: one twelfth portion of the treasure hoard of Thorin should be given to Bard, as the dragon-slayer and as the heir of Girion, Lord of Dale. Then, the trumpeter added, “If Thorin would have the friendship and honour of the lands about, as his sires had of old, then he will give also somewhat of his own for the comfort of the Men of the Lake.”

Then, Thorin gave them that, as in, he seized his bow of horn and fired an arrow at the trumpeter who had delivered the message. It struck the shield of the Man, and quivered there as the trumpeter replied in kind.

“If that is your answer,” he called, “in the name of Esgaroth and the Forest, we declare the Mountain besieged. You shall not depart from it, until you call on your side for a truce and a parley. We will bear no weapons against you, and we leave you to your gold. You may eat that, if you will!”

The Men left swiftly then, and the dwarves were left at the Gate consider the turn of events. Some found fault, they voiced none of it. So grim Thorin had become with things that they would not dare to speak against him. Even so, most of the Company agreed with him— except old Bombur and Fíli and his brother. Bilbo, of course, who wanted to avoid any sort of fighting, was most displeased. As Thorin left the Gate to return to the Treasure Room, he did not even attempt to stop him.

 


 

Many days passed, and much of the time within the Mountain was spent within the Treasure Room. The dwarves spent their waking hours piling and ordering the treasure. Now, at last, Thorin spoke aloud of his Arkenstone to the whole of the Company. He bade them eagerly to look for it everywhere.

Bilbo did not sort treasure, nor did he look for the Arkenstone. Thorin would often stand at the top of the stairs that led down to the Treasure Room, and he had Bilbo stand next to him. Some days, he would depart the chamber entirely and sit instead in the Great Hall (which had since been cleaned of dust and old bones), at the head of the table, in his Grandfather’s great stone seat. He would have Bilbo stand next to him, and spoke to him often. None of his words were happy. He dwelt upon war and gold, and Bilbo no longer expected tender words when the dwarf clasped his hands. Instead, he waited for fierce words of fighting and betrayal.

One day, as they stood above all the gold, Thorin held Bilbo close to him and declared loudly to the Company below: “The Arkenstone of my father,” he said, “is worth more than a river of gold in itself, and to me it is beyond price. That stone of all the treasure I name unto myself, and I will be avenged on anyone who finds it and withholds it.”

Once he was satisfied that the whole of the Company heard and understood him, the dwarf looked fondly down upon Bilbo. The hobbit smiled weakly up at the dwarf, and hoped his legs were not shaking as badly as he imagined they were. He was afraid at these words, wondering what would happen if the stone was found (wrapped up in his pillow). Still, he did not speak of anything concerning the Stone. Before, he had considered making a show of finding it in the treasure, and presenting it to Thorin. He had been feeling most guilty every time the dwarf mentioned it, and for a while he almost did hand it over.

But as the days passed, and Thorin’s demands for the Arkenstone became more frequent and feverish, the makings of an idea came into his little head. The hobbit would not hand over the King’s Jewel: he had bigger plans for the Stone.

 


 

Many days had passed since Thorin’s threat, and Bilbo finally had most of his plan thought out. It was night, and he was up upon the top of the wall with Thorin. They watched the lights of the camp below them. Trying to ignore an unpleasant mix of nerves and guilt boiling in his stomach, Bilbo frowned as Röac flew down from the busy skies and alighted upon Thorin’s arm. The raven delivered the news that Dáin and more than five hundred dwarves were now two days’ march from Dale, coming from the Iron Hills in the North-East.

“However, they cannot reach the Mountain unnoticed,” croaked the old Raven, “lest there be battle in the valley. This is no good news. Though your kin are grim folk, they are not likely to overcome the host that besets you. And even if they did, what will you gain, Thorin Thráin’s son? Winter and snow approaches, hastening quickly behind the iron-shod feet of your kin. How shall you be fed without the friendship and goodwill of the lands about you? The treasure you hoard is likely to be your death, dwarf!”

Thorin was not impressed by this. “Winter and snow will bite both men and elves,” he said blithely. “They may find their dwelling in the desolation grievous to bear. With my kin behind them and winter upon them, they will perhaps be in softer mood to parley with.”

Röac clacked his beak disapprovingly, and flew off. Thorin watched the bird with hardened eyes, and turned to Bilbo, doubtless to say sort of irate words. Following him down through the Mountain into the treasure room, the hobbit, who normally would have spouted off words of meaningless comfort to the dwarf, shook his head. He grabbed Thorin’s hand and held it tightly, against his chest.

“Do not stay here and dwell in your anger,” said Bilbo. “Do let us go down to the Treasure Room. How about I help you look for that Arkenstone this once, eh?”

Thorin, pleased with the hobbit’s offer, quickly agreed, and led the way down the long ladder that ran up the wall. When they had walked a while from the Gate, nearly halfway down to the Treasure Room, Bilbo stopped in his steps. Thorin stopped too, looking quizzically at Bilbo, who had suddenly dropped his hand.

“Climbing all these stairs,” said the hobbit. “Well, you know how tired it makes me Thorin, me dear. I believe I shall go off to bed, and join you down there in the morning, with fresh eyes and rested feet.”

“I do not forget the stiffness of your hobbit-legs,” said Thorin, smiling still with the thought of Bilbo’s previous offer. “You would do well to rest, love. Who knows how long these days coming will last? I will see you come morning. Then we will search long and thoroughly.”

“Good-night!” called Bilbo, as Thorin descended the steps. He began to walk as soon as the dwarf was out of earshot. He quickly made his way to where he was sleeping, which was in a little corner in the inner chamber just within the Gate. However, he was not there to sleep. From his pack he withdrew a coil of rope and a bundle of rags. Any dwarf watching would not have known what the hobbit carried, which is lucky, since inside the untidy bundle was the gleaming Arkenstone.

Bilbo, holding his two bundles close to his chest, began the difficult process of climbing to the top of the wall. It took a great deal of climbing and edging along narrow lips of stone. Much too adventurous for a simple hobbit on his own, like Bilbo was. He was much more comfortable making the climb with a sturdy and strong dwarf at his back, like Dori or Glóin. Still, he did it himself, and only slipped twice. He had to do it; he had to do it deliver the King’s Jewel to the hands of Bard and the Elvenking.

 


 

There was no gentle clasp of thanks. No sweet caress in the foul dungeons of Mirkwood. It was not even a tight squeeze and a violent tug, to lift him back onto a forest path. There was at least still some love, some fondness in that. The hobbit longed for the soft touch and cool blankets he had had in that room in the Lake-house. Bilbo had so long admired the dwarf’s broad, strong hands. Warm and callused and burned, they were, yet still a King’s hands. Powerful and gentle, always Bilbo sought to reach out and clasp one. He wanted to rub his thumb across their backs, and kiss his knuckles and his polished rings.

Bilbo had never imagined this dwarf, his hands, to touch him like this. So long had they been a comfort to him, a place of solace. There was fire, foul goblins, choking, loathsome creatures in dark caves; but then there was also this one spot of light, this touch that his dwarf King offered him. No longer.

Now, the dwarf he loved— (for that was a good word for it, though our hobbit ached for a less painful way of saying how he felt)— had his hands tightly gripping him like a vice. The dwarf had at first gone for his throat, but instead settled for the hobbit’s waist, so that he could hold Bilbo tightly and shake him like a rabbit.

All for the sake of that stone, the one that Bard now held glimmering in his hands.

Thorin was shouting something, and it did not quite reach Bilbo’s ears. The poor fellow was terrified, and rightly so. He had given the King’s Jewel to Bard, all for Thorin’s benefit, and now see where it got him. All he had was care for Thorin, and what was the dwarf doing in return? Shaking him and pushing him and shouting about throwing him to the rocks.

That was where Bilbo began to hear what the dwarf was bellowing at him.

“By the beard of Durin!” the dwarf had yelled. At first, he had suffered from a loss of words, but now he was quite able at verbally lashing the hobbit he was continuing to shake roughly. “I wish I had Gandalf here! Curse him for his choice of you! Curse him for bringing you to me! May his beard wither! Never should I have trusted his honeyed words, nor your false touch! I will throw you to the rocks!”

Bilbo looked fearfully between Thorin and the rocks below him. Then he shut them tightly, once the dwarf began to follow through on his threat, and lifted him up in the air. For one terrifying second, the hobbit was suspended in midair. He moaned and grasped uselessly at Thorin’s hands, praying that he would be put down, praying that he would not be thrown to the rocks and the shallow pool below.

And then Thorin did put him down, though not because of any fondness for Bilbo or his pleading touches. It was because of Gandalf, who had suddenly revealed himself.

“Here is Gandalf!” shouted the wizard. “And none too soon it seems. If you don’t like my Burglar, please do not damage him. Put him down, and listen first what he has to say!”

“You are all in league!” shouted Thorin, finally dropping Bilbo safely on top of the wall. “Never again will I deal with wizards or their friends.” Then he turned to Bilbo, and said in a voice that would not carry: “What have you to say, you descendant of rats?”

“Dear me!” said Bilbo. “This is all very uncomfortable. Remember when you said, Thorin, that I may choose my fourteenth share? You said it on the doorstep, while you held— well, never mind what you were doing. Perhaps I took it too literally— I know now that dwarves are politer in word rather than deed. It was at a time, all the same, when you seemed to think that I was of some service. My dear!” Bilbo fought the emotion growing in his voice, and the lump that was determined to settle in his throat. He willed his voice not to tremble. “Descendant of rats, indeed! Is this all the service of you and your family that I was promised, Thorin? Is this the care and gentleness I was to be given? Forgive me, as I thought this would all work out in everyone’s favor. Or at least rid us of this siege, and abate any fighting, so that you could have peace with the elves, and I with you. Please take it that I have disposed of my share as I wished, and let it go at that!”

“I will,” said Thorin grimly. Bilbo, in later years, imagined that the dwarf’s dark eyes were wet and his voice hoarse as he said, “I will let it go. And I will let you go at that, as well— and may we never meet again! You have betrayed me, Bilbo.” And then he turned and spoke once again in a loud voice: “I am betrayed. You all guessed rightly that I could not forbear to redeem the Arkenstone, the treasure of my house. For it I will give one fourteenth share of the hoard in silver and gold, setting aside the gems; but that shall be accounted against the promised share of this traitor, and with that reward he shall depart, and you can divide it as you will. He will get little of it, I doubt and hope not. Take him, if you wish him to live (I would not); and no care of mine goes with him!

“Get down now to your friends!” he said aside to Bilbo then, “or I will throw you down!”

“What about the gold and silver?” asked Bilbo weakly.

“That shall follow after, as can be arranged,” said Thorin. “Now get down! Get out of my sight!”

He pushed Bilbo away, and turned from him. Balin then stepped forward and helped Bilbo down the wall with the aid of ropes. Once he was down, the Company watched him walk away with a great deal of shame and pity in their hearts.

“Farewell!” Bilbo called, a trembling in his voice. He scrubbed viciously at his eyes and made his way to Gandalf, who quickly wrapped him in his grey cloak.

 


 

Bilbo awoke painfully, and all alone, lying down on the flat stones of Ravenhill. There was no one near. A cloudless sky was above him, cloudless, cold, and free of wheeling birds. The hobbit was shaking with cold, and his hands and feet were as chilled as blocks of stone, but his head burned with fire. He raised a hand to his brow and felt a drying sort of stickiness there.

“Now I wonder what has happened?” said the hobbit to himself. “At any rate I am not yet one of the fallen heroes of that battle; but I suppose there is still time enough for that!”

Then he sat up, though not without a great deal of effort and pain. Looking down from the guard-post, he saw no living goblins in the valley laid out before him. He sat there for a while, letting his head clear. After several minutes passed, the fellow thought he could see elves moving around in the rocks below. He rubbed at his eyes and peered down, and sure enough, there was a camp still in the plain some distance off. And at the wide and tall Gate below him, a group of dwarves seemed to be removing the wall he had helped put up. Yet besides that, all was deadly still. There was no sound of voices, and no echo of song. The very air trembled with sorrow.

“Victory, then,” said Bilbo. He rubbed at his sharply aching head, and blinked away the tears pain had brought to his eyes. “It all seems like very gloomy business, yes.”

Suddenly he was aware that there was a man climbing up the rocks to Ravenhill. Bilbo supposed his head was so addled from the bump on his head that he could not notice what was right in front of him.

“Hullo there!” called the hobbit in a shaky voice. “Hullo! What news?”

“What voice speaks among the stone?” said the man, stopping in his trek. He peered about him among the stones, searching for a speaker. It was then that Bilbo remembered he had his ring on (he had put it on right as Gandalf announced the goblin army that was approaching yesterday— was it yesterday?).

‘This invisibility has its drawbacks after all!’ thought Bilbo. ‘Otherwise I might have spent a warm and comfortable night in bed, down at the camp!’ Then, he took off his ring.

“Its me, Bilbo Baggins!” he cried. “Companion of Thorin!” Bilbo had forgotten what had transpired between him and Thorin, and was quickly reminded of it in that moment. It was a pain that felt like something had struck him in his gut. Shaking his head, he looked up at the man.

“It is well that I have found you!” said the man. He had walked the last few strides to where Bilbo was sitting. “You are needed and we have looked for you long. You would have been numbered amongst the dead if Gandalf had not said that your voice was last heard in this place. That is why I am here; I was sent to look for the last time. Are you much hurt?”

The man bent down to get a good look at Bilbo. “I had a nasty knock in the head,” said Bilbo. “Luckily, I have a helm and a hard skull. All the same, I feel sick if I move too quickly, and my legs are like straws, fit to break.”

“I will carry you then,” said the man. He picked Bilbo lightly up, and made his way down the Mountain. As they travelled down, the man would not tell Bilbo why he was needed. He said that Gandalf wished to deliver the news, and that Bilbo had better be patient. Well, Bilbo did not wish much to be patient. Good for him, the man who carried him was swift, and knew where he was going. His legs were much longer than any dwarf’s, and so it was not long before Bilbo was set down before a tent in Dale. Standing in front of the tent with his arm in a sling stood Gandalf. Bilbo shuddered to think that even the wizard had been harmed in the battle. He worriedly wondered how his friends— how Thorin had fared.

“Baggins!” exclaimed Gandalf, as the hobbit was set down at his feet. “Alive after all. I am glad! I began to wonder if even your miraculous luck would see you through that battle! A terrible business, it was, and nearly disastrous. But news of that can wait. Come!” he said suddenly, his voice more grave than Bilbo had ever heard it. Not even on that burning cliffside had Bilbo heard his friend sound so grim. He trembled under the heavy gaze of the wizard. “You are called for.” He pulled Bilbo up onto his feet, and letting the fellow lean upon him, led him into the tent. “Hail Thorin!” said he as they entered. “I have brought him.”

There in the tent lay Thorin Oakenshield. He was wounded most grievously, with deep cuts and gouges riddling his skin. His side looked almost crushed, struck so heavily as it was by the goblins. Bandaged he was, but blood steadily soaked through it all. The black blood of goblins flecked his skin as well, and the hobbit ached to wash it away. Bilbo felt something lodge in his throat, and he walked quickly and silently to Thorin’s side. On the other side of the dwarf’s bed was his rent armor and notched axe. Thorin looked up at him as he approached, and in spite of all his wounds, all his pain, he smiled.

“Farewell, my good thief,” said he. “I go now to the halls of my fathers, until the world is renewed. I go now to a place where gold and silver has little worth. I wish to part from you in friendship. I would take back my words and deeds at the Gate.”

Bilbo swallowed heavily and sank slowly to his knees. “Good-bye, my King Under the Mountain,” he said. He did not cry, though tears threatened to spill from his eyes. He wanted Thorin to hear what he had to say, and he would not have Thorin hearing him sob in his last moments. He smiled weakly. “And speak not of friendship. This is a bitter adventure, to have it end this way. I would have contented myself with those rainy days in the woods, or dances in the rose-lit gold, with your steady hand at my side. No treasure can amend this. Yet, Thorin, I am glad to have shared in your perils— it is more than any Baggins deserves.”

“No!” said Thorin. “There is so much good in you that you do not know, child of the kindly West. Some courage and some wisdom, blended in measure. Brave and clever you are, and I would have had you and your council at my side for many years. I could have treasured you and your hobbit spirit. If more of us valued food and cheer and song above hoarded gold, it would be a merrier world. Be it sad or merry, I must leave it now, dear Baggins. Farewell.”

Bilbo did not turn away, not for a while. Nor did he cry. Not then. He looked down at the face of Thorin Oakenshield, bloody and bruised. He slowly pulled his hand out of the dwarf’s dead grip.

Series this work belongs to: