Chapter Text
The first time I see you, you take me by surprise. I’ve never met a hobbit before. I’ve never met anyone quite like you before. Where did Gandalf find you? Who are you? Who are you, that you offer yourself to a mission doomed to fail so readily?
You have beautiful eyes, I think. “So, this is the hobbit,” I say.
You come with us, despite our bumpy start. That's the second time you surpise me, the second of many, many times. I thougt I'd scared you away, but here you are, holding up the signed contract with such pride in your eyes and a smile on your lips. I wonder- no, I hope, for your sake, that it will still be there when we reach our destination.
Good luck, Master Burglar, I think. “Give him a pony,” I say.
The journey isn’t kind to us, but you hold yourself up remarkably. You prove yourself to me, to us, more times than necessary.
Stop putting yourself in danger, I think. Stop making me so scared for your life. It’s more important than any of this. You’re more important. “I have never been so wrong in all my life,” I say.
It’s not quite what I meant, but as I hold you in my arms, it’s almost enough.
So many times we almost die, so many times we almost don’t make it. Not enough times, not enough for me to say what’s lingering in the back of my mind, often in the front, on the tip of my tongue... Not enough.
I ride beside you one day. The sun breaks on your honey curls and in that moment, your mob of hair is the only gold I see, the only gold I can ever imagine I’ll need.
You’re the most curious creature I’ve ever met, I think. You shine brighter than the stars at night. You make me question things I never thought to question before. I say nothing.
Later, I tell myself. We will have time later, and I will tell you everything. Once we’ve won the mountain, there’ll be enough time to tell you what I can’t say, not now.
There is no time when we’ve reclaimed the mountain. I’m inside its halls and you’re next to me, talking to me, and as I look at you I remember a glimpse of golden sunlight, a glimpse of golden curls and I smile, almost smile, but the gold of my fathers is too heavy, too bright, demanding my attention, drowning out the words - my treasure, my love - before I get the chance to say them aloud.
My whole treasure, united in these halls, I think. "Nobody rests until we've found the Arkenstone," I say.
Everything happens so fast. There is never enough time, not for us. Now you’re over me, hovering close, I’m lying in the dirt and this is not at all like I imagined this to go, how it’s supposed to end. I can hear you voice, speaking frantically, and I’m dying, I realise that now, I’m dying-
You’re so beautiful against the bright sky, so bright I almost can't bear it. But your face is twisted in pain, in horror, it’s all wrong, I’m dying, you realise that now-
And I feel the words coming on again, pressing to get out. I’m dying, but they don’t have to die with me. How peculiar, I think, that I can only say them now, now that it’s too late.
You wince as the words leave my lips, "go back to your books and your armchair", oh, my love, I have to die, but you don’t have to die with me. Finally, for once, they do as they should.
You know what they mean, you know, don’t you?
I look into your eyes and suddenly I can’t help but smile, because I think I can almost see the words you kept inside behind them, like you can see them in mine, and we’ve been so stupid, such stupid fools, haven’t we, my treasure, my love?
Tell me I'm not wrong, tell me. But you don't have to, not really. I see it now. I see it.
The things I didn’t say at all. I wonder, do they match the things you didn’t? Would we, had we ever said them aloud, have looked at each other in silence before breaking into a smile, brimming with joy as we reached out to one another?
Would it have made a difference? Would it have mattered at all, even if it had still ended like this, with me dying in the dirt and you begging over me to stay with me, no, no, don’t you dare-?
I like to believe it would have. I like to believe.
