Chapter Text
seven
Thorin had been grumbling about this decision non-stop for the past few hours, sitting atop his horse, about why they had to accept the help of the elves. Every elf here knew about his dislike for elves, but to all of their credit, they did not offer any word of insult against him.
The Company and the elves were riding along a steep mountain ledge, walking slowly around a very twisted road. They were all hungry and dirty, in need of a good night’s sleep and something better than a river to bathe in. The soundtrack of the journey was grumbling, muttering and groaning, and even Bilbo wouldn’t be above taking someone’s head off for a few minutes of peace and quiet.
And then they turned the corner, and even Thorin was quiet for once, stunned into silence by the beauty of it all.
Rivendell was as beautiful as when Bilbo had left it so many years ago. The vines still twisted around the marble buildings, forming the most intricate patterns, and there was still the sword, broken in pieces, that lay in the marble woman’s arms.
He could hear faintly the galloping of horses, and he wondered what Lord Elrond would know and what he would remember, if anything. The Lady Galadriel, well, he had more faith in her to remember his previous life, because of that gift of foresight Frodo had told him about.
“Mithrandir.” An elf came striding down the steps, his hand extended in good faith.
“Ah Lindir,” Gandalf said, and they muttered together in such rapid Elvish that Bilbo couldn’t understand a word they were saying. Gandalf could sense Thorin’s discomfort here, especially because they were speaking in Sindarin, and switched to Common.
“I must speak with Lord Elrond,” Gandalf said politely.
“My Lord Elrond is not here,” Lindir replied, glancing over the dwarves heads.
“Not here? Where is he?”
A horn blew, and the galloping got faster, until a pack of horses came rushing into the courtyard. The dwarves bustled together, forcing Bilbo into the middle of the pack. They all drew their weapons, preparing for some sort of battle, but Bilbo knew that Elrond would not fight them, not now.
“Gandalf,” Lord Elrond said, surprise evident in his voice, as he dismounted his horse and went over to hug Gandalf.
“Lord Elrond,” Gandalf said, something close to a smile dancing over his lips. He returned the short hug cordially, and then muttered something to Lord Elrond in Sindarin.
Lord Elrond replied, and they had a full conversation in something that Bilbo could only catch words out of. Something about hunting Orcs that had come up from the South and a Hidden Pass.
“Strange for orcs to come so close to our borders. Something, or someone, has drawn them here,” Elrond concluded, which made Bilbo’s chest puff up a bit in pride. Good to see his elvish skills weren’t completely gone.
“That may well have been us,” Gandalf admitted, chuckling. Elrond looked like he was about to smile. Thorin made a move from his position in the middle to the front of the pack, sensing that Lord Elrond was about to greet him.
“Welcome Thorin, son of Thrain,” Elrond said cordially, making Thorin scowl.
“I do not believe we have met,” he said gruffly.
“You have your grandfathers bearing. I knew Thror when he ruled under the mountain.” Elrond was intending to be polite, but Thorin’s deep dislike of elves saw an opportunity, and seized it. Bilbo wanted to hit him over the head with a hammer.
“Indeed. He made no mention of you.” And there it was, Thorin, being as rude as ever to an elf-friend who wanted nothing more than to offer him food and lodgings.
“Now, now, Master Oakenshield, there is no need to be rude. Greetings, Lord Elrond, my name is Bilbo Bag…” Bilbo began, but he was cut off by Lord Elrond.
“Bilbo Baggins, yes. I have heard about your peculiar tale from the Lady Galadriel,” he said kindly in Sindarin, gazing down at Bilbo. “Perhaps we shall discuss it over dinner?”
“What is he saying? Does he offer us insult?” Gloin roared, not understanding the kind sentiment Lord Elrond was trying to convey.
“No, Master Gloin, he’s offering you food,” Gandalf translated, as a blush of embarrassment spread across Gloin’s cheeks. The dwarves all turned in so that they were in some form of circle and muttered to themselves in Khuzdul, before Gloin spoke again.
“Oh, well, in that case, lead on.”
***
Dinner was not as raucous as the last time, but it was definitely still a sight to behold. Kili was relieved this time that he didn’t have to make the same mistake with the elves, because even though he was gender blind, he had had more practise this time around.
Bilbo found himself at the head of the table, making pleasant conversation with Lord Elrond, and listening to the sea of complaints that seemed to be flooding out of the dwarves.
“Try it, just a mouthful,” Dori tried to insist, holding a spinach leaf up to Ori’s mouth.
“I don’t like green food,” Ori replied bitterly.
“Where’s the meat?” Dwalin said, lifting up some leaves from a bowl. Oin on the other side of him, was carefully examining a small white flower on the edge of his fork.
“Do they have any chips?” Ori questioned, looking down the table to see absolutely nothing but green food. Every single dwarf at the table bar Bombur was fuming, while on the opposite end, Bilbo, Bombur, Lord Elrond and Gandalf were trying to contain their laughter.
Lord Elrond, probably having years of experience in this sort of thing, was doing the best job of it, as he was sitting calmly at the head of the table, the only giveaway that he found something amusing was the twitch of his lips every time he heard a dwarf complain.
Gandalf, on the other hand, was terrible. He was biting his lip and clenching his fists, all in a vain attempt not to give away the fact that he was laughing. Luckily for him, all of the dwarves were too busy complaining to notice.
“When should we tell them?” Bombur whispered at Bilbo.
“Let them figure it out for themselves. Its fun watching them squirm,” he replied, giggling. Thorin glared at them both from the other end of the table, almost like he had heard them, but dropped his glare almost a second later.
It took the dwarves another fifteen minutes to finally ask Bombur what was going on, all the while Bilbo munched calmly on a stick of celery.
“Did you really think I would get here and not go straight down to the kitchens?” Bombur said incredulously, watching as a group of elves started bringing out some real food, lamb and pork, potatoes and carrots, all of the foods that would make up a true dwarven meal. All of the dwarves cheered at this development, making Bilbo smile.
He remembered how much they missed this on the road, so it wouldn’t do to have them miss it when there was an opportunity for them to have some.
For the first time in a long time, each and every dwarf was smiling widely, including Thorin, who when Bilbo made eye contact with him, tilted his head in acknowledgment.
That sly dwarf. He knew all along. But then again, what else was Bilbo expecting? Thorin always knew everything that was going on with his company, from Kili flirting with the elf in Mirkwood, to Bilbo’s deep dislike of the Sackville-Baggins’s. Thorin was observant like that, always noting what was going on in case he could use that information later.
It was later, when Lord Elrond, Thorin, Gandalf, Balin and Bilbo were gathered together in the courtyard where the sword was held, where Thorin’s observations would later be used. He was refusing to give the map up to Lord Elrond, instead holding it firmly in his hand and waiting for someone to respond to it. He could only judge whether Lord Elrond was worthy to see this map using time and patience.
“Your pride will be your downfall,” Gandalf growled at Thorin. If only he knew how true that prediction would come. “You stand before one of the few in Middle Earth who can read this map. Show it to Lord Elrond.”
“Thorin, no,” Balin whispered, but Thorin had already handed it over. This time, he would forsake those observations, but only for the time being, because he needed that map read.
“Erebor,” Elrond said with surprise in his voice, his eyes lighting up. He looked up at Thorin, but Thorin was unyielding, giving no information away with his face. “What is your interest in this map?”
“It’s mainly academic. As you know, this sort of artefact sometimes contains hidden texts. You still read ancient Dwarvish, do you not?” Gandalf broke in, trying to make sure Thorin didn’t do anything stupid. Privately, Bilbo thought that he was right to make sure of that, because Thorin was known to act rashly around elves.
Elrond held the map up to the light of the moon, examining it closely. He said something in Elvish, and Bilbo smiled.
“Moon runes!” Gandalf said excitedly, “Of course. An easy thing to miss.” He directed the last part at Bilbo, almost like he was scolding him for not remembering about them. Bilbo just rolled his eyes.
“In this case it is true, for moon runes can only be read by the light of a moon of the same shape and season as the day on which they were written.” Elrond said diplomatically, not taking his eyes off of the map.
“More importantly, can you read them?” Thorin said impatiently, and Bilbo could see his patience starting to wear thin.
“I do not know yet, but I can find out. Follow me please,” Elrond said, turning and walking down the path, leaving the rest of them to follow out. Eventually, they found themselves in a clearing surrounded by two gushing waterfalls, and Bilbo smiled.
Elrond walked up to the crystal table and placed the map down flat, watching and waiting for the moon runes to show themselves.
“These runes were written on a mid-summers eve, by the light of a crescent moon nearly 200 years ago. It seems you were meant to come to Rivendell. Fate is with you Thorin Oakenshield, for the same moon shines upon us tonight.” Elrond said, smiling to himself. Fate may have been with him, but all the same, he did not require it in this instance.
“Stand by the grey stone when the thrust knocks, and-” Elrond begun, cut off only when Bilbo finished the reading for him.
“The setting sun with the last light of Durin’s Day will shine upon the key-hole.” Bilbo finished.
“You already knew it Master Baggins, before you even stepped foot in Rivendell. Perhaps it is time to hear your curious tale now?” Elrond said. “The Lady Galadriel most definitely would like to hear it. Master Oakenshield, would you like to join us?”
Thorin had no grounds on which to decline, for that could anger any member of the White Council, and so he hesitantly accepted, following out back to the courtyard. Balin left them to go and find the rest of the Company, most likely to share the news about what the moon runes said.
So here he found himself, standing in the doorway awkwardly in front of the most powerful group of individuals in the entirety of Middle Earth, about to hear for a second time how he failed, failed his people, failed his company and failed his nephews. How most importantly, he failed Bilbo Baggins.
The Lady Galadriel was standing regally at the edge, and she turned slowly to face them.
“Lady Galadriel,” Gandalf said softly, a hint of surprise in his voice.
“Mithrandir,” she replied, the faintest hint of a smile flicking over her face. “It has been a long time.”
“Age may have changed me, but not so the Lady of Lorien.,” he complimented, and Bilbo could see something there, something that might have been true in years past.
“I had no idea Lord Elrond had sent for you,” Gandalf queried.
“He didn’t. I did.” Saruman came striding out from around the corner, and Bilbo’s skin ran cold, goose-bumps spreading all over him. He knew what Saruman had done, how he had sided with Sauron, but something told him that he should give Saruman the benefit of the doubt, because at this point in time, he had not yet chosen that path.
“Saruman,” Gandalf said, the faintest hint of frost decorating his voice.
“You’ve been busy of late, my friend. Tell me Gandalf, did you think these plans and schemes of yours would go unnoticed?” On the outside, Saruman seemed to be being polite towards Gandalf, but his tone was ice cold, like he didn’t want any of Gandalf’s plans to be carried out.
“Unnoticed? No, I’m simply doing what I feel to be right,” Gandalf tried to reason, but Saruman looked unconvinced.
“The dragon has long been on your mind,” Galadriel said ethereally, looking at Gandalf.
“It is true, milady. Smaug owes allegiance to no-one, and if he should side with the enemy, a dragon could be used to terrible effect,” Gandalf said, trying to convince them about Sauron, but to no avail.
“What enemy? Gandalf, the enemy is defeated. Sauron has been defeated, and he can never regain his full strength. Always you must meddle, looking for trouble where none exists,” Saruman interjected, making Bilbo think that maybe his heart was already with Sauron, instead of here with the White Council.
“Actually, there is trouble and Sauron has not been defeated,” Bilbo spoke up, attracting strange looks from the rest of the council, except for Galadriel, who continued to stare out over the cliff.
“What?” Elrond said, surprise in his voice.
“In a cave beneath the lair of the Goblin King, there is a creature named Gollum. In his possession currently is a ring, the One Ring,” Bilbo said, remembering the perils he went through when he had that Ring, and the perils that Frodo went through.
“And how do you know this?” Saruman said curiously, his brain already whirring to try to think of ways to disprove what Bilbo is about to say.
“Because I will come to bear this ring, and so will my nephew, in an attempt to destroy it in Mount Doom, like it should have been many years ago. This ring will tempt and trick, and will bring about the rise of Sauron again. We are no longer at peace, Lord Elrond, for Sauron is rising again,” Bilbo revealed.
“And how can we be sure that he is telling the truth?” Saruman interjected.
“I have looked into his soul, and I see no lie present. He does not wish any ill will upon us, and so there is no reason for him to lie to us about something as serious as this,” Galadriel said gently, looking fondly at Bilbo.
“So then Gandalf, you were right,” Elrond said diplomatically.
“Just a feeling,” he replied modestly, for the first time in his entire existence. Bilbo looked like he was about to cry.
“So then, Master Baggins, what can you tell me about the future?” Saruman asked politely.
“What do you already know?” Bilbo asked, and Elrond replied, prompting a conversation between Saruman, Gandalf and him.
“Your soul is open to me. You have suffered many hardships, young Hobbit. You carried that ring for much too long,” Galadriel said psychically to Bilbo.
“That ring was the cause of all my problems, but it played an integral part in reclaiming the mountain. Without it, I fear I would not be a very good Burglar. After the Mountain was reclaimed, I hid it away for seventy years, until it was passed to my nephew Frodo, who carried it to Mt Doom, along with three other hobbits, Samwise Gamgee, Meriadoc Brandybuck and Peregrin Took, Aragorn and Boromir, two men, Legolas Greenleaf, an elf, and the dwarf Gimli, son of Gloin. The Fellowship of the Ring, they were called,” Bilbo interjected into their conversation.
“And Sauron?” Saruman queried, the faintest twinge of panic in voice. Goosebumps spread up and down Bilbo’s arms like wildfire. Maybe Saruman had already turned to Sauron.
“Was defeated, as evil should be. As evil always is in these cases,” Bilbo said reflectively, watching Saruman intently to see what his reaction would be. To his credit however, he gave nothing away.
“What about Smaug?” Elrond asked.
“He is shot down over Laketown by a man named Bard, a descendent of Girion. But it is what happens after that I would much like to prevent,” Bilbo said, worry seeping into his voice.
“And what is that exactly?” Gandalf asked.
“Thorin Oakenshield fell prisoner to the gold sickness, and started a war with elves and men in order to keep every penny hidden away in his treasury,” Bilbo said sadly, looking at Thorin.
It was then that Thorin moved from his position in the doorway, shifting when Galadriel began to talk to him. “Your soul has been through much already, things that you do not remember. You are a hero, Master Oakenshield, and you should be sure to remember that.”
“But…” Thorin tried to interject, but Galadriel continued nonetheless.
“Remember all you have sacrificed for your people, for your family. Remember what the Arkenstone does Master Oakenshield. Remember that when you find it,” she said wisely.
“The Arkenstone may be precious, but it is also cursed beyond measure. It is the reason for the dragon sickness, and the reason for the war to come,” Bilbo recalled.
“So what do you propose that we do?” Elrond asked.
“The quest must continue as planned,” Thorin interjected, the worry for his homeland seeping in.
“And it shall, just that Arkenstone must never be allowed to be in Thorin’s possession, for it may be the downfall of us all.” Gandalf said decisively, looking at Thorin, and he nodded gravely, knowing he was right. He must not be allowed to possess the Arkenstone.
