Actions

Work Header

Dear Thorin

Chapter 4: Greetings from Mirkwood

Notes:

Ch. 4 commences what was never posted to ff.net and the countdown to who Bilbo's One is.

Chapter Text

Dear Thorin,

Before you go gallivanting off to see Thranduil, I demand that you read this entire letter! (If someone else is reading this, stop Thorin before he leaves.) Yes, I have returned from Umbar. I will not say where I landed or how long I’ve been back as I will not have you getting ideas. Yes, I managed to make my way into Mirkwood. I have been Thranduil’s guest for several months now. That’s right, months. He graciously allowed me to rest within his house and tended to my wearied state. He has been a most elegant host and I thank him heartily for his discretion. He has offered assistance in my return to the Shire.

Ah, the Shire. You have no idea how I long to behold my homeland once more. During my voyage from Umbar, I started to dream of Bag End. I dreamed of my cozy chair, my books, and my bed. That was nothing compared to my dreams of the Shire itself. I once dreamed I flew over the whole landscape, seeing everything anew. I saw hills of verdant green and fields of dappling yellow and sun-kissed gold. They rolled beneath me, rippling happily as though they were welcoming me home. I saw the great Party Tree standing majestically against a tapestry of diamond, sapphire, and gold. Its great trunk puffed with pride while its wizened branches, decorated with a blanket of autumn, rustled a greeting. I flew over the homes of my neighbors and kin. My dream ended when I came to the door of Bag End. The image of that round, green door remained with me after I woke. Oh, Thorin. Returning to the Shire will be bittersweet for I know I may no longer have a home.

I know what you’re thinking. You’re thinking that I’m being foolish for I have a home. With you. As Consort of Erebor. Oh, Thorin. I still held out hope that my absence would make you see sense. I had hoped you would realize the foolishness of your persistence. Alas, all my hopes were for naught. During my time in Thranduil’s house, I passed many days with him in conversation. I learned much about Erebor during those talks.

Our conversations ultimately turned to the reason why I ran. To be honest, I was reluctant to share why. After all, Thranduil is an Elf of high quality. What care would he have for a hobbit bereft of his mate? To my great astonishment, he was quite sympathetic to my plight. He understood, far better than you, my reasons for running. You should not be surprised that he cursed your stubbornness. He even shared what happened to some of his kin who dared disregard their marks. The fates of those poor Elves would make even you shiver with fear, Thorin. When I asked him if you had taken a wife, he regaled me with information that makes me curse your fat head!

Apparently, you have risked open insurrection by refusing to take a wife. Several prominent lords have offered you their daughters and you have refused them all. You claim that you are engaged! I was horrified to learn that you threatened to kill several lords if they continued to pester you. You narrowly avoided assassination twice! The Consort’s Chambers are always maintained. You allow no one to enter but yourself. You have even replaced the Consort’s Chair. According to Thranduil, that only occurs when a king considers himself exclusive to one lover. You have even kept fresh a wardrobe of royal garments. All of them are sized not for a dwarf, but someone smaller. I nearly had a fit when he told me you have a crown made for someone of my size.

Oh, Thorin.

Thorin, Thorin, Thorin!

Before I start yelling at you, I’m going to take this opportunity to yell at your two dimwitted nephews. Yes, Fili and Kili, I mean you! How dare you! How bloody dare you! How dare you fill your uncle’s head with such nonsense that he’s angered others to the point of civil war! Are you two so dense that you cannot see reality? Are your desires so blatantly entrancing that they’ve blinded you to the truth? I DO NOT LOVE THORIN! I WILL NEVER LOVE THORIN! He is not my soulmate! I will not risk madness or catatonia just to please a king whose ego overpowers his brain!

As for you, Thorin…

What must I say? What must I do? What must I accomplish to make you understand that I will never be yours? Are you so blinded by your own feelings that you cannot see the reality in front of you? Think about it! I ran from you, have travelled to parts no hobbit should ever go to just to escape you, and returned via secret routes to avoid you! I have written primarily out of courtesy. I will not have the rest of the Company think me dead because you will not give up your pursuit. Thranduil suggested I be honest with you. I’ve decided to take his suggestion and reveal all that I was hoping never to say

Not once have I ever thought of you as a lover. Frankly, the thought of lying with you fills me with disgust. You are a handsome dwarf, I will admit that, but not once has this admission led to a desire to bed you or be bedded by you. I do not want you. Any physical intimacy between us would be marred. You would delude yourself into thinking I was being coy. What you would perceive as loving caresses and kisses would be forced actions on my part. Any moments of sexual intimacy would definitely be forced. I would not take any pleasure from being with you. I would feel nothing but dread at your touch. The distance I would keep between us would enrage you and that is something I do not wish to experience again.

Secondly, why would I want to remain in Erebor? Erebor is not my home. Mountains, especially the interiors, are not for hobbits. They belong to beings of stone and darkness. We hobbits are beings of earth, sun, and open spaces. I am tied to the earth and sun just as you are tied to the mountain and that thrice-damned stone. I know you’re arguing that I could have that in Erebor. Knowing you, you would create a garden of unimaginable beauty for me somewhere on Erebor’s slopes. You would have gardeners plant every imaginable tree, flower, and shrub to give me something wondrous. In truth, I would find it wondrous, but I could never truly enjoy it. No artificial garden will ever replace the beauty of the Shire. What I would crave most is the feeling of openness. The feeling of being able to walk out and lose myself in the space around me. If I were to remain in Erebor, I would be a prisoner. I would be chained to that single garden. You must also realize the danger I would be in. Hobbits and dwarves function differently in darkness. You thrive where we falter. You would see me wither in the mountain’s darkness. The cold I had while Laketown would pale in comparison to the illnesses we hobbits suffer from when deprived of sunlight.

There are other valid reasons I can list, Thorin. I know a good many of your followers see me as the “Shire-rat who used his wiles to seduce the innocent king.” They don’t want me around and I’m going to oblige any foolishness by staying. Another is that I only promised to help you reclaim your home, not to stay permanently. I have no desire to be a king’s chained pet, spoiled and drowned in gold and jewels. There is nothing in Erebor that tempts me to stay. There are other reasons, but one supersedes them all.

Ultimately, Thorin, I cannot bring myself to trust you. I wish I could say that I felt safe around you, but I don’t. Truthfully, I don’t think I’ll ever be able to trust you again.

If you think I’m speaking of the gold-sickness, then you are partially correct. During my travels, I dreamt of you. Do not presume I longed for your arms. I dreamt of the day you succumbed to that darkness. Do you have any idea how foul you looked? I woke often, gasping for breath as my skin remembered the dark promise of your rage. You looked so foul, so evil. I know you will promise that the gold-sickness is gone. Yet I can never trust that promise or any promise you make. I would always wonder when you would succumb again. I would always dread the day you started to paw at your gold and riches like a slobbering Orc. I would especially dread the day you turn your hands in hate upon me. I know I would never leave Erebor alive if you ever succumbed again. That mountain would be my tomb. That darkness will never leave you, Thorin. So long as you breathe, you will always carry that malice within you. The bounty of Erebor will remain a temptation and I cannot be a part of it.

The other reason I can’t trust you is the Shire. I can’t trust that the Shire would be safe if I ever did anything to anger you. You’re likely rolling your eyes. I know you think you would leave the Shire alone. Take this into consideration. Could you leave the Shire alone if you learned it contained riches? Could you swear that my fellow hobbits would remain free, unencumbered by useless demands from a place they’ve never heard of? Can you honestly claim that you wouldn’t send an army to lay the Shire to waste if I didn’t submit as you wished? Could you make those promises honestly, Thorin? Could you?

I will end this letter now. The hour grows late and I still have much to prepare for. I am returning home. I don’t know if I will be welcomed or cast out. If the former, I will spend the remainder of my days in peace. If the latter, I will seek aid from my Took kin before seeking a new home. More importantly, I wish to pay a visit to a dear relative of mine. Before I say goodbye, I will tell you this.

Don’t send search parties to Thranduil. He will not appreciate angry dwarves on his doorstep. It will be for nothing anyway. Though I return to the Shire, I will not be going by the regular way. Thranduil has provided a map that will send me along a less-travelled path to the Shire. His son will escort me to the border and see me off. I sincerely hope it’s as empty as advertised.

Finally, do not think you will be able to catch me. By the time you receive this letter, I will have a two month head start.

Farewell
Bilbo