Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationship:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Stats:
Published:
2015-05-16
Completed:
2015-05-31
Words:
76,700
Chapters:
12/12
Kudos:
2,029
Hits:
0

The Ghost And Mr Baggins

Chapter 5

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“But this doesn't make any sense!”

“It makes perfect sense, you're just not listening very carefully!”

“Well excuse me for seeing the blatant plot holes for what they are,” Bilbo groans, leaning back in his chair, away from the typewriter.

“Are you saying my story lacks in continuity?” the Captain narrows his eyes, lounging, for entirely selfish reasons, Bilbo suspects, right next to his own painting on the ottoman.

“I'm saying it lacks in truth!” he jabs a finger at him, “obviously you're keeping more to yourself than you're actually telling me! What about the years you spent in Spain? What about your training, and before that? What about your childhood?”

“Oh please, no one cares about all that!” the ghost waves his hand dismissively.

“Goes to show, you've never read a good memoir,” Bilbo accuses him, “that's all that anyone cares about! It gives the story depth! Shows where you came from, engages the reader and makes them sympathize! Honestly, this is rudimentary storytelling!”
“Are you telling the story, or am I?” the Captain crosses his arms.

“You are, but I am responsible for making it presentable, aren't I?” Bilbo reminds him, “and I can't very well achieve that if I know next to nothing about you. I get the air of... of debonair mystery, I really do, but the story cannot be all riddles! For example, this – there's a blank space years long between your enlisting in the navy and working your way up to commanding your own ship. This is important knowledge!”

“It's boring knowledge, is what it is,” the ghost counters stubbornly, beginning to pace the room, growing irritated, “nothing happened in those years, except for tedious training day and night, and trying my best to survive under the reign of this or that tyrannical Commander.”

“And how exactly is that boring?” Bilbo laughs, if a bit hysterically, losing patience himself, “the young recruit with his own idea about the rules, struggling with authority and never quite settling? See? That's something we can build on, isn't it?”

“Hmph,” is Captain Durin's dignified response.

“Let's see, then – you joined the navy alongside your brother, didn't you?” Bilbo flits through the sporadic notes he's managed to wring out of him so far, “had that always been something you two wanted to do? Or did he decide to follow the example of his older brother? What happened to him, anyway?”

The ghost stops abruptly by the window, his hand briefly hovering over the brass telescope, before grumbling over his shoulder: “That's personal.”

“Of course it is personal, for crying out loud!” Bilbo exclaims, “it's your story! How do you expect it to be written without getting a little bit personal?”

“You ask too many questions.”

“And you don't answer nearly enough of them. Do you want this book written or not?!”

Staring down a ghost – most definitely one of the things Bilbo would have laughed over had someone suggested them a couple of months ago. Alas, if he once thought this would be in any way ordinary, he doesn't harbor any such illusions anymore.

Same goes for this storytelling business – perhaps he'd expected the Captain would actually be willing to share the story with him. And it is an interesting one, Bilbo can sense it, but maybe not for all the same reasons Captain Durin seems to think so. All is well with swashbuckling adventures and daredevil voyages, but for all their abundance, Bilbo is far more interested in the man behind them.

But if the man behind them himself won't divulge anything that might be in the general vicinity of too personal, then, well, Bilbo will have to start investigating on his own. As one does.

And there's no one more excited about sharing gossip, unintentionally or otherwise, than a certain Missus Gamgee and her flock of town mothers, gathering in her store on the lazy afternoons like clockwork. Bilbo has managed to find his way to their midst quite easily – if the fact that he's a bachelor living in an allegedly haunted house and raising a boy entirely on his own was enough to spark their interest, then earning their trust by playing along and expressing genuine interest in them, as well as playing his role of a slightly mysterious but warm (and tragically lonely, the ladies have decided) newcomer, has plunged him right in their midst, probably the only man privy to their gatherings and gossip sessions in the small garden behind Missus Gamgee's store.

Between advising Missus Eglantine Took on planting her tomatoes, and sharing his prized shortbread recipe with Missus Esmeralda Bolger, he's officially earned their trust enough so that he can try and pursue his own interests for just a bit.

“I'm afraid nobody knows very much at all about the Captain,” Missus Gamgee declares, all the other ladies nodding, when Bilbo finally phrases his question, “he never was a particularly warm fellow. Always off on his travels, of course. One could never be too sure he was really there, even when he did decide to stay, because he rarely ever came to town. Always had someone else pick up his groceries, from what I remember.”

“That sister of his used to look after the house while he was gone, didn't she,” Missus Took adds, “a very nice lady, two beautiful boys, but one didn't see much of them either. I understand she was a widow, poor thing.”

“Was?” Bilbo quirks an eyebrow, attempting to sound as innocuous as possible, not dreadfully curious at all, “what happened to her and her boys, do you know?”

“Not really, no,” Bell Gamgee hums pensively, “they just stopped coming one day, didn't they.”

“Yes, yes, I suppose they did,” Missus Bolger nods, “all of a sudden. They were very private people, after all.”

“I remember they called a doctor to their house that one time,” Missus Bolger chimes in, “for one of the boys, I believe. Remember?”

“Oh, that's true, they did,” Missus Gamgee recalls, “poor old doctor Brown. My husband was the one who drove him there, I think...”

“Why? What happened?” Bilbo has forgotten his biscuit dunking in the tea for too long, and it dissolves into useless mush.

“Oh, I couldn't tell you that even if I tried, I'm afraid,” Bell chuckles, “such a long time ago, it was.”

“Hmm,” Bilbo ponders, “and what about the doctor himself? Is he still... around, so to speak?”

“Yes, yes, lives in town still. Retired now, I believe,” Missus Took offers, “we still see him around, don't we Esme, in the market sometimes. He's... well, his mind is not all there anymore, you see, but still makes the best peppermint cough drops around...”

“What is with all this sudden interest in the Captain's family?” Missus Gamgee pays closer attention, and Bilbo only smiles politely, shuffling in his chair.

“Oh, you know,” he says, “I'm just curious. I'm sure he has a very exciting story.”

“No doubt, no doubt. All great seamen do. Shame he never thought to tell it to anyone.”

“Yes,” Bilbo chuckles, “shame.”

 

But once he's started investigating, there's no stopping – gently but diligently, he manages to discover the old doctor's address, and stops by his house while there's still time before Frodo's school day concludes.

He resides in a very peculiar hut a little ways away from the center of town, overlooking the harbor from its own little hill, sunken almost completely, not unlike Bilbo's house, in overgrown and unkempt greenery – he recognizes some remnants of flowerbeds, a herb garden even, perhaps, but it's all been left to its own devices, growing wild.

There is no bell to ring by the small crooked metal gate, surrendered almost completely to rust, and Bilbo doesn't really know whether he should be so bold as to invite himself further in and go knock on the door – all of that is decided for him soon enough fortunately, when he sees an old man limping up the hill, his cane taller than him by a long shot, startling when he sees Bilbo.

“Oh, hello, you're finally here!” he exclaims, hurrying the last couple of steps toward him, “a day late, but it doesn't matter! Your salve is ready, come in, come in!”

“No no no, I'm not here for any... um, salve,” Bilbo tries to correct him, but is forced to follow him nevertheless, as he limps with increased (and impressive vigor) to the house now, “I just... wondered if I could ask you something.”

“About a salve?” the alleged doctor giggles, concentrating on the key rattling in the lock – his smile is an honest one, his face round and pleasant, and yet there is something about the... distant, distracted manner of his movements that hints at the fact that his mind is, as Missus Took had so aptly described, not all there after all.

“No, no, not about any salve,” Bilbo shakes his head indulgently, “you see, me and my nephew recently moved in at the Oak Cottage, and I heard in town that you used to know the previous owner? A Captain Durin?”

“Oh, Oak Cottage!” the doctor exclaims happily, “oh, of course, a lovely house, isn't it? The Captain is such a strapping fellow, don't you think? How is he?”

“Um,” Bilbo peeps, but before he can remind the man of the unfortunate truth, the door finally opens, and the doctor limps inside without any regard whatsoever for his company – Bilbo, as is his nature, follows.

“He's dead now,” he announces, firmly believing that straightforward is the way to go, “has been for quite some time now, remember?”

“He's... oh. Of course he is,” doctor Brown babbles, rummaging through his numerous belongings for... something, “for quite some time now, yes. What salve did we agree upon, again?”

“No, no salves, doctor, at least not today, thank you,” Bilbo sighs, casting a curious look to the peculiar interior, dried tufts of herbs hanging from the ceiling, strange vials and jars full of spices and more ground herbs covering just about every available surface.

“Then were you the one who wanted the tea for his wife? Because let me tell you, there's only so much a tea can do in the ways of lovemaking-”

“No, I'm not here about... that, either,” Bilbo sputters, “I just wanted to ask you a question or two.”

“About the Captain,” the doctor mutters.

“Yes, about the Captain.”

“Strapping fellow, he was, yes, hmm,” the short man mumbles to himself while Bilbo attempts to avoid knocking anything over, “always bought lots of tea to help him sleep at night, he did. When he was in town, that is.”

“That's fascinating, yes. Though I've been wondering about his nephews. They tell me you were summoned there once, shortly before they stopped coming here? The boys with their mother, I mean?”

“Oh," the doctor says, then remains quiet for a moment, up to the point that Bilbo starts worrying he's forgotten his presence completely – when he speaks again, his voice is feeble, and sad: "Such a lovely lady. Her boys, too. Do you know if they're ever coming back?"

"I was actually hoping you might be able to tell me that, sir," Bilbo sighs, getting just a tad exasperated, "do you know what happened to them? The Captain's family?"

No more answers, just the old man's incomprehensible muttering.

"Sir?" Bilbo attempts.

"Ah-ha! I knew it was here somewhere!" he exclaims out of the blue, startling Bilbo, turning to him with a grin truly victorious, "lavender drops, my very last batch! One drop in your boy's tea in the morning and before bed again, and he'll be alright in no time!"

"No, I – huh?" Bilbo inclines his head helplessly.

"Now, remember to store the vial somewhere dark, or they get bitter mighty fast, oh yes..."

"Doctor," Bilbo speaks louder now, "I don't want any drops! I was asking you about the family of Captain Durin, remember? The one from Oak Cottage?"

"That, yes. Terribly sad, it was. Poor boys."

"But what happened to the boys?" Bilbo is desperate now.

The old doctor looks at him curiously, as if it's the first time he's really paying attention to him, and Bilbo nods hopefully... But it's gone faster than it came, the man giggling to himself and turning away, another fleeting thought capturing and distracting him, and Bilbo realizes it's no use - he won't be getting any coherent information out of him any time soon.

"What do I owe you for this?" he sighs, resigned, taking the vial of the mysterious drops in his hand and inspecting its dark contents.

"Oh, nothing of course, free of charge for you and your boy," doctor Brown babbles happily, fluently switching back to his muttering only he can clearly understand. Bilbo opens his mouth to try and ask him how he knows about Frodo, but then it occurs to him the man might not even know who he is talking to, come to think of it.

"Well then, uh... thank you, that's very generous of you," he says, clutching the vial in his hand, though he's not entirely sure why he's decided to take it in the first place.

"Yes, yes, yes, absolutely, now send the next one in, if you would be so kind..." the doctor babbles on, and having exhausted his share of questions and patience, Bilbo leaves him to it and backs out of the strange small house into the blinding afternoon sun.

The odd encounter stays with him for the rest of the day – he’s lost in thought their entire walk back to the house, letting Frodo (and Sam this time, whose father has promised to stop by for him later) run ahead and laugh without a care in the world. Since the Gamgee's boy is visiting, Bilbo doesn't get a chance to ask the Captain about the peculiar doctor until later that evening, and when first he mentions the man's name and asks about the Captain's mysterious sister and nephews, the ghost disappears without a trace or a word of explanation and doesn’t speak to him for the rest of the night.

"Fine, have it your way, it's your book, not mine," Bilbo sighs and shrugs, and the house lulls him to sleep with the rafters creaking gently in a discordant melody that is strangely familiar to him now, and the distant plucking of a harp that might as well be the beginnings of one of his dreams already.



In fact, the Captain refuses to communicate for entirely longer than is usual for him. He doesn't see fit to comment on Bilbo's decision to rearrange the dining room the next day, and doesn’t even bother helping him by blowing out the lamps lining the staircase in the evening, as has become a habit for them both – he doesn't complain when Bilbo uproots a good half of the drying rose hip bushes by the road, and offers no explanation when an old unused well is uncovered in the back of the garden, its mouth barred by rotting but solid wooden planks.

Even when Bilbo makes an attempt at writing more of his story on his own, Captain Durin keeps his distance, though Bilbo is certain that reading his notes out loud to him and speculating in the most ridiculous manner about his actual achievements must drive the ghost insane .

But no, nothing, no response for two whole days – it is only when Bilbo starts baking and preparing for having more of Frodo's classmates over (the boy's own idea, which he was happy to go along with, especially since Frodo bravely brought it up on his own) that the cantankerous Captain's interest is spiked once more.

"Are you expecting to feed a battalion with that?"

His voice is hoarser than Bilbo remembers it, quieter too, and yet, despite yelping in shock and mushing the cookie he's been shaping into a useless ball, he's glad to hear it.

"What did I tell you about that collar with a bell on it?" he scolds, his own voice fortunately only wavering a little bit.

"I'm not your dog," the ghost grumbles, moving to inspect the tray of cookies already baked, as if they're in need of a thorough scrutiny.

"No, you're right," Bilbo sighs, "dogs are much more polite. In answer to your question, those are supposed to feed four hungry boys, so I suppose a battalion is an apt comparison. Keep your hands off."

"Couldn't eat them if I wanted to," the ghost chuckles dryly, “and I didn’t agree to inviting the entire town here."

"Four small children is what I said, I believe. You'll barely notice them. Certainly I hope they'll barely notice you ."

"I can make no such promises," the Captain declares simply, the wickedly teasing undertone still apparent to Bilbo, though.

"Stop mucking about," he wags a finger at him, "remember our deal."

"Yes, that has been going splendidly , hasn't it," the ghost says tersely, moving on to brood by the window, clasping his hands behind his back and gazing out onto the expanse of the sea, just another one of the shadows in the dim kitchen, in his black ensemble, heavy boots and oiled trousers with an old sweater that Bilbo still thinks is a bit too much for the weather this time of the year (and he sometimes wonders if a ghost's clothes can change, or if they are, in fact, the ones the Captain died in...).

"And whose fault is that exactly?" he reminds him, "I have been trying, I'm perfectly willing to work on this story if only you extend me the courtesy of actually telling me anything that is even remotely true! How long do you think we can keep tiptoeing around certain topics? And how excited do you think people will be to read a story that hides more than it tells? What did happen to your sister and nephews?"

"Too many questions!" the Captain booms, and the stove, simmering happily and calmly up until then, sizzles threateningly.

"Oh but you are impossible!" Bilbo exclaims, "don't blame me for not holding up my end of the bargain, if you won’t even consider being truthful with me! Now shoo, the boys are coming. Off you go!"

"You don't shoo me in my own house!"

"Oh, really? That's strange, because I think I just did!" Bilbo hisses, dusting off his hands and setting the uncooked batter aside so that he may welcome the visitors.

"I don't want to hear another peep out of you!" he remembers to scold the ghost, who has deserted the kitchen without a word, and can now be heard complaining up in the master bedroom – Bilbo expects to come back to his neat stacks of fresh laundry tossed up all over the place, and perhaps a haphazardly unlatched window or two, but for now, he hasn't the time to worry about that.

It was Missus Gamgee's truly enlightened idea to let the other mothers of her little gossip group know just how much fun her son has been having over at the feared Oak Cottage – Bilbo is all for changing the house's grim reputation, of course (despite the fact that it is, well, true), but he’s obviously miscalculated, expecting the ladies to be firmly against letting their offspring spend time alone so far from home. As it is, the parents of both little Merry Brandybuck and Pippin Took jumped at the chance to commit their children to Bilbo's care for one lazy afternoon.

Both boys are somewhat endearingly scrawny, and Bilbo has often seen them running around town without any supervision whatsoever, following this or that group of older children or trying their luck looking inconspicuous by the docks and snatching a fish for themselves or playing hide and seek between the crates and boats. But all that matters is that Frodo considers them his friends now, and Bilbo is prepared to extend his hospitality to anyone who is nice to his nephew, really.

He is only one man, of course, and past feeding them all, he can’t hope to herd them much beyond the point of forbidding them from leaving the garden to dash off to play with Beorn’s sheep, and absolutely no trying to pry the lid of the old well open.

Frodo is so much livelier around them, smiles brighter and occasionally even has something to say, and Bilbo stands on the back porch, munching on the last leftover cookie, and wishes the boy's mother were here to see it.

He misses his cousin Primula so much he aches with it sometimes, and he's not entirely sure what she would have to say about his decision to bring Frodo with – then again, he's not entirely sure what she'd say about anything. It was all a bit too sudden for everyone, and all that Bilbo is really sure of is that she would want the boy to be taken care of properly, with love. He can provide that much, he sincerely hopes.

“This is outrageous.”

“Oh, don't you start,” Bilbo sighs, managing to flinch only a little bit when the Captain suddenly stands by his side, watching the four boys kicking around a ball that little Sam had brought with him, all loud laughter and muddy knees and tousled hair, with a look of detached disapproval.

“They're too loud,” the ghost announces, like a grouchy old man roused from his afternoon kip far too early, “too careless around the glass displays, you saw them, they almost broke that tea set I'd gotten in Paris! Too careless. Too loud, too...”

“Too...?” Bilbo imitates him sardonically, adding lightly, “you're running out of adjectives. They're children. They're supposed to be loud and careless. Or did you not learn that with your nephews?”

“Enough about my nephews,” the Captain utters, a vague threat lingering behind those words, “you know nothing about them.”

“Only because you won't tell me,” Bilbo shrugs.

The boys' laughter carries, and the ghost doesn't respond, but he doesn't disappear either – Bilbo watches him for a change, for as long as he's allowed to do so, and sees him following the boys' every movement with a care that can only mean one thing. His suspicions are confirmed when, entirely out of the blue, Merry decides to scale the ancient briar bush crawling its way up the far wall of the house, and before Bilbo can register it, his foot slips and he tumbles backward – it is not a long fall, he's barely lifted himself above ground, and yet, as Bilbo calls after him to be careful, that call echoes in the Captain's own, less a voice and more the wind picking up and rustling in the leaves of the elms and the tall grass, urgent and worried, before the man realizes, realizes it's no good and draws back, turning away.

“We're alright, Mister Bilbo!” the boys call, Merry dusting off his trousers and dashing off someplace else again, completely unscathed, and after making sure to forbid them from any more dangerous antics, Bilbo finally says to the ghost what he's been thinking all this time: “You love them.”

“What now?” the Captain grumbles, striding away to the far side of the veranda, to look away and off to the sea, as is his habit when he broods.

“The children,” Bilbo follows him mercilessly, “you like having them around, because you used to have them around all the time, isn't that right?”

“Don't be ridiculous.”

“Oh, that's rich, coming from you,” Bilbo annoys him further, “you're very good at acting all cold, very good indeed, but it's obvious.”

“What is?” the ghost sighs, still stubbornly glaring at the horizon, the clouds gathering slowly but surely like water beginning to boil, a promise of a rainy night. Bilbo steps closer, far too intrigued now to stop.

“Whatever happened to your nephews,” he says much more gently, less teasing, “it's long gone now. You are long gone, as well, and yet, by some cruel trick of fate, you're... well, still here. You've no one to make amends to but yourself. Telling your story is a good way to do that, but not unless we tell it in its entirety.”

The man stands there motionless for the longest time, staring ahead, and Bilbo notes how real he looks – the sharp afternoon sun pronounces his terse features, bleaches his eyes an even lighter blue... specks of dust glitter around him like the tiniest golden sparks, but if Bilbo watches close, they never settle, simply swirl lazily, as if they naturally know to avoid him – he wonders, heedlessly, if the ghost can feel, can smell the fresh scent of brine carried here on the breeze, yet warm, or the smooth wooden railing of the porch, or the sun on his face.

His eyes turn to Bilbo, and he really is his own painting come to life (well, figuratively speaking, anyway), stunning and intimidating, always leaving him a bit breathless.

“If – if you don't want to say, I understand,” Bilbo tries yet again, not entirely sure himself why he's doing it, “but you want this story told, don't you?”

“Not every detail,” the Captain says, his voice rough, as if even admitting that much pains him.

“Understandable,” Bilbo smiles in what he hopes might be at least a somewhat encouraging manner, “no one says all of it has to go in the actual book itself, you know.”

“Meaning...?” the ghost quirks one impressive eyebrow.

“Meaning... well,” Bilbo chuckles, “I think it would be a shame, not telling the whole story to someone.”

“You,” the Captain scoffs.

“At least you'll tell it,” Bilbo points out, “how much of it actually goes in the book for the rest of the world to know, we shall decide together, after all. But telling it in its entirety? That is really what you want, isn't it? Even if it's to just one person.”

The ghost opens his mouth and appears almost offended – for his part, Bilbo doesn't really blame him, sometimes his silly curiosity and cheekiness get the better of him – but before either of them can say more, the boys come barreling onto the back porch, trailing mud everywhere, announcing what neither Bilbo nor the Captain have noticed yet, too engrossed in their strange conversation: it's started raining, earlier than anticipated, nothing but a quiet pitter-patter on the wooden roof.

“Mister Bilbo, can we have more cookies now?” Pippin asks with a disarming grin, probably the dirtiest one of them all, covered head to toe in twigs and grass and dust, more than befitting the leader of the boys' expedition through the unexplored parts of the garden.

“I, oh... of course,” Bilbo looks from the ghost to them, a bit startled and blindsided, “well, oh – there are actually no cookies left, I'm afraid you ate them all, boys, but go on, get inside, get washed up, all of you! And I'll... yes, I'll go see about making us all something quick to bite... Go on, inside, hurry!”

They obey, dashing inside with squeals of delight, loud as ever, and Bilbo sighs, turning back to the Captain – who stands there still, a somewhat forlorn look in his eyes.

“Thank you for staying out of sight,” Bilbo says a bit pointlessly, “though I must say, it's very distracting when I'm the only one who can see you and I'm forced to carry a conversation anyway...”
“A storm is coming,” the ghost announces, as if he hasn't heard a single word Bilbo just said, and before he can point that out, there is no more Captain Durin on the back porch, and the rain begins to fall ever harder.

“...Of course,” Bilbo shakes his head, not even attempting to understand a dead man's whims at this point, and heads back inside himself.

Once again, the ghost keeps his distance, but this time, Bilbo doesn’t feel like he's offended him in any particular way – hopefully just made him think, which, he admits, can be equally as annoying an outcome.

His suspicions are proven completely right the very next morning – he doesn't even notice it at first, almost walks past it on his way to wake up Frodo, but then his thinking finally catches up with his vision, and he stops, and stares.

The door to the attic is open, casually half ajar as if he just forgot it to close it last night, and Bilbo scratches his head, deep in thought, because... did he?

"Does this mean I can go have a look now?" he asks cautiously.

The house is utterly silent.

He takes a step closer, and meets with no resistance whatsoever. He makes himself control the sudden excitement.

"You're not going to shut the door behind me and lock me in there forever?" he speculates.

The house doesn't have a response for that, either.

"Well then," Bilbo gulps, "here goes, I suppose."

The door is narrow and the stairway beyond dark and dangerously crooked, and Bilbo returns to the house's main staircase to light on if the oil lamps there and take it with him. It's only a couple of creaking wooden steps up to the attic, but it's like stepping into a whole another world – ahead he sees the faintest glow from what must be some sort of skylight, and he steps forth only with the utmost care, sensing the shapes of things he cannot name ahead in the darkness, scattered about in a pattern that is probably haphazard at best. It wouldn't do to break his leg tripping over a stray shelf right now.

He stops and tries to make his eyes adjust to the lack of light, his lamp doing very little to illuminate anything – he thinks he sees an uneven shape up ahead, something taller than him, an old cloth draped over it, but he’s more concerned about the distant scurrying he hears, like frantic mice, and what might be the plucking of strings, just like he's been hearing in his dreams every now and then, quiet and somehow hollow...

"Ahh!" he cries out in a sudden nasty surprise when something brushes at his wrist, and jumps back, hitting his shin on what might be a toppled shelf or a beam, or simply just a torture device designed to bring him to pained tears.

"Uncle!" Frodo exclaims, and sounds equally as frightened, large eyes shining bright in the dancing light of Bilbo's lamp.

"Oh, it's only you," Bilbo lets out a shuddering sigh, "wait outside for me lad, this is no place to wander."

But Frodo merely shakes his head furiously, clutching onto Bilbo's sleeve and standing close by him, scanning the darkness surrounding them with equal parts worry and curiosity.

"Well, alright, just tread lightly," Bilbo tells him.

They proceed further until they come by the actual large space of the attic, the skylight finally offering some more light – directly below it stands... something, tall and broad, smooth curved shapes Bilbo doesn't recognize.

"Can we...?" he peeps, and when the house doesn't have an answer, and Frodo merely shrugs, Bilbo sets the lantern down on the nearest flat surface, tells his nephew not to move an inch, and steps valiantly closer.

The cloth is heavy but silky smooth, age and a steady layer of dust rendering its original color almost unrecognizable – Bilbo drags it off the mysterious object only carefully and with some hardship, and all that dust rises in puffs and clouds as the fabric pools on the ground.

"Oh, my," Bilbo exhales, coughing away the dust.

"What is it?" Frodo asks timidly.

"That is a harp, my lad," Bilbo sighs reverently, fingertips ghosting over the majestic curve of it, the carved wood still gleaming as if it was only made yesterday, honey-brown and smooth.

"Is it the Captain's, I wonder...?" Bilbo murmurs, resisting the temptation to run his fingers through the translucent strings, hear its sound as more than an echo on the precipice of his dreams.

My sister's , the dark corners whisper, do cover it back up when you're done here.

"Yes, of course I will..." Bilbo mutters absentmindedly.

"Uncle, look!"

Frodo sounds tense, and so Bilbo turns to him immediately, but fortunately he's alright, only crouching by a large chest by the wall – the look of it doesn’t fill Bilbo with much confidence, but the lad is already struggling to unlatch the lid, and there are no complaints from the house yet, so he figures they might as well see what is inside.

Toys. Countless toys, an old soft teddy bear with eyes of brass buttons, a wooden whipping-top, scratched and beaten, colors fading; an abacus and a skipping rope, too, a music box with a dancing ballerina on top... An entire painted box full of tin toy soldiers, complete with muskets and their horses. Frodo's eyes blaze with excitement, but he barely dares touch, only watches, and fidgets.

"Oh, these are gorgeous," Bilbo sighs, then, kindly, "can we bring them downstairs, do you think?"

The house is utterly silent for one hesitant moment.

...You may.

 

They discover the rest with time – despite his excitement about the new toys, Frodo does have to go to school, and Bilbo spends an eventful, and dusty, afternoon cleaning everything up and returning to the attic time and time again, to unearth more and more mathoms from a time long gone.

The pictures, he only finds by accident, really, while sifting his way through the abandoned drawer of letters the Captain had made him promise not to read.

A woman and a man and their two children, every miniscule detail of their faces captured masterfully, a young, happy family, one of the boys a newborn still in his mother's arms. Bilbo doesn't have to ask to know exactly who they are, the woman's eyes gazing at him with a familiar intensity, her dark hair and sharp, almost regal nose a perfect likeness of her brother.

He is allowed to carry that downstairs as well, and sits with it at the kitchen table, brushing the thin layer of the ubiquitous dust off it gently with a soft cloth, the ghost lingering nearby, the silence of the tense, anticipatory kind.

"I suppose you're really not going to tell me what happened to them, are you?" he murmurs, thinking of the rough letters carved into the log on the beach below the house, and the quiet mass of the musical instrument waiting up below the roof, untouched for years and years – he longs so much to know the story behind it all, to hear what it was like when an actual family lived in this house, and find out where the harp stood – the dining room? or maybe Frodo's bedroom? - but as it is, getting answers out of someone who is reluctant to give them is difficult enough when they are alive, much less... this.

All in due time , the house whispers to him, and Bilbo sighs, fingertips barely touching the old, fraying paper of the bundle of letters that no doubt hold some of the answers he's looking for, and agrees: "All in due time."

 

Notes:

And so we learn a bit more about Dis, though yes, all in due time. And don't ask me how the names work, I just needed a colorful flock of townsfolk, and I know they're all originally related to Bilbo and/or Frodo in one way or another, but let's just go with it for the time being :D Hope you guys enjoyed it! I shuffled the posting schedule a bit, because I realized I didn't want to post the last two chapters together, but yeah, all is well otherwise :)