Actions

Work Header

Come Hold My Hand, Let's Change the World

Chapter 2: Beau Baggins and the Study of Dwarves

Summary:

Bilbo nodded, “I beg your pardon, Master Balin. It was not my intent to pry. But I am curious – you have been mining in the Blue Mountains for years. You must have obtained gold and precious metals and minerals enough for several generations? How much gold do you need?”
“Master Baggins, let us be open with each other. Are you saying we are greedy?”
Bilbo said calmly. “No, Master Balin. I’m not saying you’re greedy. I am asking if you are.”
“I suppose it was too much to expect the people of the Shire to understand,” Balin said sadly. “There is no point in continuing this discussion, then.” He got up, shoulders slumped in defeat.

Bilbo, your xenophobia is showing!

Notes:

Thanks to everyone who read/bookmarked/left kudos! Love you all!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Bag End

Bilbo leaned back in his comfortable chair. He felt supremely content. He was wearing his favourite slippers again, and Rose was sitting on the floor, going over the carefully arranged piles of fabrics at her feet, selecting combinations to merge into dresses that would astonish the Shire. There were silks and brocades for formal wear, cottons, taffeta and gauze for casual wear, lawn and calico for blouses, satin and cambric for innerwear, wool and camelhair for coats. There were also soft leathers for new shoes. Another unopened bag held shawls, purses and inexpensive jewellery. A third bag held exotic knick-knacks and other presents for their neighbours, family and friends that would be placed under the party tree on Yuleday.

But this comfortable quiet couldn’t last long. Bilbo would have to confront Rose about the Dwarf she was meeting. Bilbo would need all his tact for that conversation. Luckily he had plenty of practice. So he was quite prepared for it when Rose suddenly turned to him and said, “Uncle Bill, I need to talk to you.”

“Yes, my darling? What is it?”

Rose moved closer till she was sitting at Bilbo’s feet. “I have met someone.”

“Someone? You mean someone special?”

“Yes, Uncle. And I would very much like to marry him. So please say I may, like a good Uncle.”

Bilbo smiled and ruffled her hair. “Well, we’ll have to see, won’t we? I’ll need to meet him first. Where does he live?”

“In Bree. And his name is Durin. And he’s the bravest warrior ever! He told me all about the time he attacked Moria and killed so many orcs and wargs he couldn’t count them!”

“Moria? I’ve never heard of such a place, let alone a war.”

“Oh Uncle Bill! You don’t know anything! When the King of dwarves led an army to take back Moria, Durin was at his side, and he killed countless orcs. And wargs.”

“I’ve never heard of wargs in my life. What in Yavanna’s name are wargs?”

“Wargs are…” Rose stopped. “Well, I’m not entirely sure. I think they’re huge animals. You should ask Durin when you meet him.”

“Is that his name? Just Durin?”

“Oh dwarves don’t have two names.”

Bilbo shrugged. He knew nothing about dwarves. He had never met a Dwarf in his life. He had seen a few, going by in his travels, covered with hair and armour and weapons, stomping along on their huge boots. Ugly, unkempt creatures. Neither Men nor Elves had much good to say about dwarves. Grasping, greedy, uncouth, loud, secretive and unsociable toward other races, were some of the milder epithets used. None of which made him at all keen to meet them. He had never heard of any wars the dwarves had fought in. Bilbo felt puzzled and a little resentful. How could his delicate little Rose be in love with a Dwarf?

Bilbo took another look at Rose. Well, perhaps not so delicate. Rose took after her Took ancestor the Bullroarer rather than the Baggins side of the family – she was the tallest female in the Shire, and very few young Hobbit lads topped her height. Was that the reason? Did Rose seek someone taller than her?

But there would be time enough to find out about the lad. The central tenet of diplomacy was patience, and Bilbo was accustomed to waiting. He was deeply suspicious, but he would give the Dwarf a chance. But when the time came, if he found that the Dwarf was not all he should be, well, then he would have to decide what to do.

“Well, if he deserves you, I will talk to your other guardians as well, and we will decide if he may court you. But Rose, he should have asked your guardians for permission before courting you.”

Rose looked crestfallen. “I don’t think he knows that. And I didn’t tell him.”

“Well, no harm done. But we can’t keep breaking the rules of propriety, you know. We are Bagginses of Bag End, and we have a reputation to maintain.”

Rose looked down, abashed. She knew what she had done wasn’t right, and she couldn’t bear it if the likes of Aunt Camellia hauled her beloved Uncle Bill over the coals for her shortcomings. Uncle Bill had always prided himself on doing the right thing, and his favourite niece would not be the cause of his embarrassment, at least.

“I promise I won’t break any more rules, Uncle. I won’t meet him anywhere alone till you give me leave. But can I send him a letter asking him to visit us?”

“No. You can write to him after you get permission to start courting, not before. Give me his address, and I will send him a letter. Time enough to think about what to do next after I meet him.”

“All right” Rose said trustingly and laid her head upon her Uncle’s knee.

Bilbo felt a little like a cruel uncle from a fairy tale, but ruffled her hair affectionately, then said, “After the Solstice, we go to Michel Delving – to the tailor’s shop!” and Rose’s smile widened.

 

*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^^*^*^*^*^*^*^

Two days later. Bywater

 

“Beau! Beau Baggins!”

Bilbo stopped his pony and turned around. A rather large Hobbit, also on a pony, was coming up behind him. He was decades older than Bilbo, with a wide grin, snow white hair and a pleasant face. “Gorbadoc! Good to see you again, sir! What are you doing in these parts?”

“Meetings, my dear boy, meetings. It’s some confounded dwarves this time.” Gorbadoc Brandybuck, Master of Buckland, wheezed a little as he pulled up alongside Bilbo. “Beau, m’boy. Where are you off to?”

“Just going over to Bywater to meet some friends. And then we’ll ride on to Tuckborough.”

“Good, good. I need your support, m’boy. Looked for you at Bag End but your little girl told me you were on the road.” Gorbadoc, although the Master of Buckland, was very plainly and comfortably dressed in dark brown breeches, a plain green shirt, and a thick woollen coat.

“Well, of course. Any help I can give. I don’t know anything about dwarves, though. Men and Elves, certainly, but I haven’t had much truck with dwarves.”

“You know how I hate talking to outsiders of any kind. The Rangers will be there too. They scare me to death, those tall people. It’s just all too much for me, m’boy. I just want to sit back and smoke my pipe, but people won’t leave me alone. It would help so much to have you there. You help me think.”

“I don’t like them much, but whatever you say, Gorbadoc.” Bilbo wasn’t particularly keen on attending a meeting when he could be having fun with his friends, but he never could say no to Gorbadoc.

“I don’t like it either, Bilbo. Too many dwarves going through the Shire as it is. I don’t want to see them across the table at meetings, too.”

“But what in the world do they want?”

“Mining, their letter said. When I was a young Hobbit I never heard of dwarves mining outside the Blue Mountains. Their letter said they were planning to prospect other mountains around Eriador as well.”

The horses were walking side by side down the path now. By common consent, they set the horses to a trot for a while, then slowed into a walk again.

“Getting greedy, are they?” Bilbo asked.

Gorbadoc said, “I don’t know. Are they rich? They don’t look very rich to me.”

Bilbo shook his head. “Let’s meet them and see.”

“Here, here’s the letter. I depend on you to help me say no to them.”

Bilbo reined in his horse to a slow walk and read the letter. It said the dwarven King-in-exile had heard of possible metals in Celeb Brill, about 20 miles beyond Brandywine Bridge. It was pretty much no-one’s-land, but the King wanted to smooth the path for his miners. Plus they would need support in terms of provisions and transport during the prospecting and after.

Hence they were meeting with the Master of Buckland, and representatives of the Shirrifs and the Rangers, at the Bywater Inn.

Bilbo shook his head. He couldn’t see Gorbadoc agreeing to any such thing. Or the Rangers either.

*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^

When they reached the Inn, Bilbo handed over his horse to the ostler and walked over to the pub next door, where his friends Gruffo and Jago Boffin were waiting. He excused himself to them and promised to return after the meeting. They weren’t at all surprised – everyone knew the Master of Buckland depended completely on Bilbo for major decisions.

The meeting was held in the Inn’s private dining hall. When Bilbo walked in, he saw a large oval table had been arranged in the centre, and several chairs around. Gorbadoc waved him over.

He walked over to stand next to the Master and looked around. There was only one Man at the table, dressed in the dark, worn leathers of the Rangers, seated on a stool designed for Hobbits and looking a bit uncomfortable. There were two senior Shirrifs, both well known to Bilbo. The rest of the table was filled with dwarves – six of them. They were all dressed, sadly, in leather armour, but were not armed, and Bilbo saw weapons carefully laid out in a corner of the room, including the Ranger’s sword and bow, and the Shirrifs’ shortstaffs.

Bilbo bowed and said, “Beau Baggins, Head of the Baggins clan of Hobbiton, at your service. I am here at the Master of Buckland’s invitation.”

The Shirrifs got up politely. They obviously didn’t need to introduce themselves, so they merely bowed. The older of them, Shirrif Underhill said, “Master Baggins, it’s good to see you again.”

Ranger Windstorm was known to him as well, and he merely smiled and inclined his head. At friendly meetings with Dwarrows and Hobbits, Men stayed seated as much as possible so as not to intimidate.

Then it was the turn of the dwarves. Bilbo tried not to let his distrust show on his face as he bowed to them.

The white haired Dwarf in the centre got up and bowed, “Balin, advisor to the King, at your service.” At least he looked pleasant enough, and the white beard would have been elegant if the Dwarf dressed better. The others introduced themselves in turn. Dwalin, Chief of the Guard, was bald, tattooed and fierce, a typical Dwarf, every inch a warrior, and intimidating. The next Dwarf was a surprise: Heir-in-Exile Fili, young and smiling with golden hair and a handsome face. Almost Elven in his beauty, and with a livelier dress sense than the rest. Miner Borin wore a forest of chestnut coloured braids and a scowl. Scribe Farin could almost pass for a Hobbit with his babyish face, but he bore a straggly beard. Prospector Frar was the shortest and slightest, with long slender hands, a pointed face, neatly braided hair and beard.

Bilbo tried to smile pleasantly at them all and sat down. So the King wasn’t present. He took an interested look at Fili – young, very handsome, clearly a warrior, with a well-defined jaw and burly arms, and of the royal family. The King’s son. Pity his name wasn’t Durin.

Balin resumed speaking, “Master Gorbadoc, Master Baggins, as you know, we are miners, and have been mining in the Blue Mountains for a very long time. The veins in the Blue Mountains are now running thin, and getting harder and harder to mine. Hence we are looking for new sources of metals around Eriador. Celeb Brill was part of Gondor once, but their kings have long forgotten this part of the world. It is also not part of the Shire or Buckland, but we would not wish to begin mining there without your approval. In the beginning we will start prospecting – if we decide to start mining, perhaps we could hold another meeting? We are prepared to offer reasonable terms.”

Gorbadoc said reluctantly, “I don’t know. We already have dwarves enough going through the Shire. But I’ll let Beau here speak for me.”

Bilbo turned to Balin, “Master Balin, we are simple folk. It is unlikely that we would need anything you could give us. Before we consider your proposal, I have a few questions I would like to ask you, if I may.”

Balin nodded gravely.

“What is prospecting? How many dwarves will it need?”

Frar replied softly, “Just 4-5 prospectors, with some assistants. Maybe 20-25 in all. Perhaps more to start with, and a couple extra to travel to the Shire every couple of weeks to replenish their stocks. It should take us about 2 months to study the rocks and check the veins. We’ll need to dig some holes into the mountain, of course.”

“And once you start mining?”

“About 100-200 Dwarrows, perhaps.” Balin answered.

“How badly will the mountain be affected?”

It was Miner Borin who replied, “All our mining goes deep into the mountain. We do not disturb the surface. We are Dwarrows, Master Baggins – our prospectors are highly sensitive – they listen to rocks to find the richest veins anywhere in the mountain, and we dig directly to the veins. Once the rich veins run out, we stop and do not go any deeper. We do not turn over tons of soil and ruin the landscape for flecks of gold.”

“For how long would you mine?”

“Hard to tell, since we haven’t even started prospecting.” Balin was getting more restless as he felt the disinterest coming off both the Hobbits.

“And how much of precious metals and gems do you hope to mine?

The Dwarrows looked at each other. Then Balin spoke, “That will be clearer after prospecting. But that would be information we could not share.”

Bilbo nodded, “I beg your pardon, Master Balin. It was not my intent to pry. But I am curious – you have been mining in the Blue Mountains for years. You must have obtained gold and precious metals and minerals enough for several generations? How much gold do you need?”

The Dwarrows gasped and Dwalin rose threateningly. Bilbo stood his ground. He had decades of experience dealing with Aunt Camellia. These Dwarrows weren’t a patch on her. He did not even look at the other Dwarrows, but kept his gaze on Balin.

Balin lifted a hand and Dwalin sat down again. Bilbo felt the shirrifs and the Ranger subtly relax on either side of him.

“Master Baggins, let us be open with each other. Are you saying we are greedy?”

Bilbo said calmly. “No, Master Balin. I’m not saying you’re greedy. I am asking if you are.”

“I suppose it was too much to expect the people of the Shire to understand,” Balin said sadly. “There is no point in continuing this discussion, then.” He got up, shoulders slumped in defeat.

Bilbo shook his head, “Master Balin, please sit down. I’m afraid I phrased myself too bluntly. We are simple folk, Master Balin. We have no need for precious metals or stone. We have no knowledge of mining. But perhaps if you explained?”

Balin sat back down. “Master Baggins, with all due respect, when you say you have no use for gold and jewellery, you are wrong.”

“Enlighten me.”

“Your coinage is copper, silver and gold. Your cutlery is made of silver. I have seen several Hobbits wear gold and silver jewellery. That brocade waistcoat you are wearing has silver threads woven into it.”

Bilbo looked down at his waistcoat and smiled.

“Elves use jewellery sparsely, but the richer Elves have enough gold and silver thread in their clothing to make up for it. Men wear the most jewellery of all the races. Am I right, Master Ranger?”

Ranger Windstorm waved a hand casually in agreement.

“But Dwarrows do not merely mine precious metals or gems and crystals. Where do you think mercury, iron, zinc, copper, lead, tin, phosphorus, cobalt, and tungsten come from? I remember drinking with a young Hobbit who waxed enthusiastic about fireworks the other day – does he know where saltpetre and sulphur come from? Do you know where the chemicals used to dye the fabrics you’re wearing come from? From Dwarven mines. We seek and we find the deepest veins, the richest sources, so that we can supply the peoples of the earth while keeping the land untouched.”

Balin stopped for a few seconds, looking pensive. “Granted, when we lived in Erebor, such an accusation could have been levelled at us. Erebor was the richest mountain in the world, crisscrossed with thick veins of precious metals and stone – you almost could lift a hand and pick out nuggets of gold from the walls. The kingdom was the richest in the world, bar none. But since we lost Erebor, fortune has turned away from us.”

Fili placed a hand on Balin’s shoulder, comfortingly, and the older Dwarf covered it with his own.

Bilbo swallowed. He had known none of this, and Balin’s emotion made him feel like a monster.

“But today, such accusations are meaningless. We mine the Blue Mountain range, but not for gold or silver – we mine it for other metals. Mostly iron, but also copper, lead, tin, antimony, bismuth, zinc. Which brings in enough money to sustain our population and help it grow, but not enough to make us prosperous or ensure that the next generation will have enough to live on. What would you have us do, Master Baggins?”

Bilbo got up and went to the window, overwhelmed by the self-doubts brought upon by this simple retelling of facts. He looked outside. A carriage stood in the yard – gleaming wood and polished iron – did the iron come from the Blue Mountains? All the world was connected. Had his travels taught him nothing? Since when had he become so xenophobic? The dwarves, no - Dwarrows, were possibly some of the things the Men and Elves had called them, but who was he to judge them with no proof? And by what criteria? Did their huge beards make them less respectable merely because Hobbits did not grow beards?

The room was silent behind him. Waiting. It was in his hands now – Gorbadoc would follow his lead. He could reject the proposal and condemn this battered, proud nation to many more years of ill-paid slogging, or he could give them a chance at a better life. He knew very well that where the Master of Buckland led, the Shire followed. Reject this proposal, and the Dwarrows would get no entry anywhere around the Shire.

He returned to the table but remained standing. “Master Balin, I apologise. My questions were impertinent, but you have answered more fully than I could have hoped for. You have my support, and that of the Baggins family. I suggest a simple 100-year certificate giving your people rights to mine the mountain, signed by the Mayor, the Thain, and Master Gorbadoc, witnessed by a Ranger, in return for a trade agreement whereby you agree to buy a certain value of provisions in Buckland and the Shire every year. In addition, Master Balin, we are much in need of smiths, and I believe Dwarrows are good at metalwork? Perhaps you could set up a smithy in the Shire? What do you say, Master Gorbadoc?”

“Yes, yes. I completely agree.” Gorbadoc was touchingly happy to see an end to talks that he wasn’t particularly interested in. “Your mining won’t disturb us, except we will have more dwarves travelling along the East Road.”

Balin looked at Bilbo, apparently undecided on whether he should be relieved or not. “What kind of trade agreement did you have in mind, Master Baggins? Provisions do not cost very much.”

“True. Let’s say 100 silver coins a year? Like this one?” He reached into his pocket, took out his purse and rummaged within it, finding what he needed. He spun the silver coin over to Balin, who caught it. It was a 30g coin with Rohan’s seal on it.

Balin studied it for a bit, then handed it over to his scribe, who quickly weighed it with a pair of small scales, then took an etching of it with paper and pencil.

“Those terms are acceptable to us, Master Baggins. And we thank you.”

The main part over, the discussions moved over to the Shirrifs and the Rangers, and several minutes passed as they discussed road conditions, seasonal changes, rules of the road, and dangers. Bilbo was free to sit back and watch the Dwarrows. He was feeling a little disoriented. He had come to the meeting with an attitude of disdain. Now he didn’t know what he felt, except that judging people before meeting them was a really stupid thing to do. Balin was so dignified, the young prince so smiling and enthusiastic, and Dwalin certainly looked like a warrior who could kill orcs and wargs. Elves they were not, but in their earthiness perhaps closer to Hobbits than to Elves.

*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^

Bilbo sensed the meeting was drawing to a close. He stepped out and asked the innkeeper to bring over ale and snacks to toast their successful discussions. The mood of the meeting had already changed, after Bilbo supported the Dwarrows. Now the room was livelier, and the individual groups had mixed – Dwalin in a huddle with the Shirrifs, Fili sitting up on the table and laughing with – or more likely at – the Ranger, who seemed to be indulging him. Balin, Borin and Frar were deep in discussions with Gorbadoc, who seemed quite satisfied. Bilbo homed in on the scribe, sitting alone. Scribes knew everything.

“Master Farin?”

The scribe turned around, looking flustered. “Master Baggins!”

Bilbo sat down in the chair next to the Dwarf and held out his hand, “Master Farin, I’m very pleased to meet you. I do some writing as well, in a small way, but I’m honoured to meet someone for whom writing is a profession.”

Farin looked puzzled, but rather pleased. “Thank you for the kind words, Master Baggins. I do love to write and read.”

Bilbo looked at the text on the papers. “That’s not a script I’m familiar with.”

“Oh it wouldn’t be. Khuzdul is a secret language, you know. We don’t share it with outsiders.”

“Ah yes. But you do use the common tongue as well?

“Yes. And Sindarin. The others don’t approve of my learning an elven language, but it comes in very handy while travelling.”

“Indeed it does. I have learnt Sindarin as well, but am not at all fluent. Do you travel a lot?”

“Oh yes. I go wherever there are negotiations to be done. It’s in the family. My grandfather was the Royal Scribe at Erebor, and he continued to serve King Thror in exile. He died a hero’s death at the battle of Khazad-dum.”

“Khazad-dum?”

“Our ancient city in the Misty Mountains. It’s called Moria now. But to us Dwarrows it will always be Khazad-dum.”

Bilbo’s ears perked up. “Your grandfather died in battle? That must have been quite a shock.”

“Nay, I wasn’t even born then. Even my father was but a lad.”

Bilbo felt disoriented. He tried to remember Rose’s words. She had clearly said her lover was a veteran of Khazad-dum. That would make him much older, he guessed. “How many years ago was the war?”

“Oh about 150 years.”

Too long ago. Something didn’t add up. “You still remember the tales, then.”

“We can never forget. That was the day both King Thror and Prince Thrain were killed by the Pale Orc.”

“So, your people lost the war?”

“We did lose the war, eventually, but we won that battle. The soldiers rallied behind Prince Thorin, who pushed back the orcs using an oaken branch as a shield, and killed Azog. He’s called Thorin Oakenshield, now.”

“He sounds like a brave warrior.”

“Yes, and at the time he was even younger than my father, who was considered too young to fight.”

“You say you lost the war. How was that?”

Before Farin could reply, Gorbadoc called Bilbo over and he excused himself and went over.

He pulled up a chair next to Balin, who gave him a friendly smile.

“Beau, could I ask you for a favour?”

“Yes, of course. Anything.”

“Could you be the liaison with Master Balin’s people? Bag End is a few days closer to the Blue Mountains than Brandybuck Hall. And since you’re already our liaison with the Men and Elves…”

Balin said dryly, “The Elves are not our friends, Master Baggins.”

“Hobbits have no enemies, Master Balin.”

Balin pursed his lips, “There are those out in the world who are enemies of all of Eru’s peoples.”

“Yes, but I was not speaking of the Enemy’s minions.”

Balin nodded appreciatively. “Master Baggins. Forgive me for my curiosity, but you have a knowledge of the world I have not seen in other Hobbits. Begging your pardon, Master Brandybuck.”

“No need to beg my pardon, Master Balin. Beau here is a wonder – travels abroad regularly, takes after his pretty mom that way. But he’s still a Baggins through and through – as high a stickler as they come. You cannot have a better guide to Hobbit etiquette than Beau if you mean to socialise. So you don’t tread on any toes, you know.”

Balin smiled and nodded. Bilbo grinned back, rather charmed by the elderly Dwarf. “I’ll be happy to be your liaison, Master Balin. And meet you for drinks and a discussion of Hobbit and Dwarf customs any time you’re passing this area.”

*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^*^

Three days later. The Green Hobbit inn. Michel Delving

Fili knocked at the door of a room at The Green Hobbit. It was thrown open, Kili almost flew out at his older brother and knocked their foreheads together. Balin watched them indulgently.

“Mahal, it’s good to see you! How did it go?”

“Well, quite well. Where’s Uncle?”

“Next door.”

Balin knocked on the door and Thorin opened it. He looked drawn and tired, as if he’d spent a sleepless night.

He smiled, though and hugged Fili. They all squeezed inside and sat down, Thorin on a chair, the others on the bed.

“Where are the others?”

“On the way to Celeb Brill.”

Thorin smiled, a smidgen of hope showing in his eyes. “So, did they agree? What did we need to promise them? Not my firstborn, I hope.”

“Hardly anything. I’ve signed a 100-year agreement with the three Hobbit power centres – the Mayor, the Thain, and the Master of Buckland. All we have done is promise to spend 100 silver coins every year in the Shire. Oh, and set up a smithy, which would be to our benefit, anyway.”

Thorin stared, “Balin, that’s unbelievable. 100 silver coins is only about double what we already spend here. How did you manage it? I did not expect such a treaty to be signed at all, let alone on such easy terms!”

Fili said with a big grin, “Balin’s magical oratory did it, Uncle! You should have heard him – he was brilliant!”

Thorin smiled at his nephew, and the lines of worry smoothed out a little. “Do tell.”

“May I?” Fili asked. Balin smiled and nodded.

“So uncle, there we were in this meeting room, with the head Hobbit, the Master of Buckland. And there were the Shirrifs and a Ranger. And not one of them seemed friendly. Not hateful, mind you, just indifferent. Which was fine, I guess, because why would they care? We were prepared to offer reasonable terms – it was up to them to accept it. So Balin started speaking and the head Hobbit was shaking his head, and you know what that means. So we were prepared for failure from the start.”

Thorin nodded, a deep abiding pain in his eyes.

“And then this younger Hobbit walks in. You should have seen him, Uncle. Golden hair, and blue eyes, and dressed in brocades and silks like, like… an Elf! With pointy ears as well. Pretty much bosom buddies with everyone else at the table – you should have seen them light up when he came in, even the Ranger. And he stood there absolutely radiating distrust at us. I took one look at him and I said to myself, this is a Hobbit who’s been cohabiting with those… tree-shaggers!”

Thorin shot Fili a sharp look, “Well, go on!”

“The head Hobbit asked the younger Hobbit to take over the discussions, which he did. And asked Balin a whole lot of impertinent questions. Even Balin gave up after a while and got up to leave. Didn’t you, Balin? But as we were getting up, the Hobbit suddenly said he wasn’t trying to be impertinent, but trying to understand why prospecting at Celeb Brill was important to us. And Balin sat back down and completely floored him with the answer. Totally. You’ve never seen anyone as flummoxed as that Hobbit was. He actually had to walk off to have a think about it.”

“And then?” Kili asked impatiently.

“When he came back, he did a complete about-face. Said he supported us, and suggested this agreement. The old Hobbit immediately went along with it. He obviously didn’t want to think too much. And the Shirrifs and Ranger agreed as well, and there we were. And the young Hobbit ordered food and drink for everyone, and sat and talked to all of us, and all of the distrust had gone, completely. When I am 200 years old, I want to be like Balin. He’s brilliant.” Fili finished with a broad grin.

Thorin smiled, “Is that pretty much what happened, Balin?”

Balin laughed. “Somewhat, yes. But I don’t think it was my oratory. The Hobbit lad obviously wanted to do the right thing, despite his prejudice, and was prepared to put in the effort. And he was a Hobbit with a spine. He said something a bit off, and you know my brother – he was on his feet in a moment. The Hobbit didn’t even flinch, just looked at me steadily as if to say – that’s your chap, keep him in line.”

“I liked him, too,” said Fili. “You know he’s our liaison with the Shire now. We chatted after the meeting and he was really nice. Invited us to his house for tea. That was a first.”

Thorin looked up. “Really? Invited you for tea?”

“And all our friends. Tea is at 4, he said, and there’s always plenty of it. He was nice, Uncle Thorin. Nicer than any Hobbit I’ve met.”

Balin nodded gravely, “Yes. For all the distrust he came with, he proved to be unusually open-minded. A bit of a scholar and a linguist, well-travelled, well-respected, but under all that respectability I saw a craving for adventure, a recklessness. An interesting young Hobbit, and one I would be happy to meet again.”

Thorin looked wistful. “A craving for adventure? I wonder, if he really knew what adventures consisted of, would he crave them? If he knew that adventures did not always bring us back home again?”

Balin shook his head sadly, “I hope experience never teaches him that, as it taught us.”

“What was he called, this admirable young Hobbit?”

“Baggins. Beau Baggins.”

Notes:

For everyone who noticed that Bilbo calls Fili the King's son, that's simply because he doesn't know Fili is Thorin's nephew. Also, you may have noticed he starts off calling them Dwarves, but changes to calling them Dwarrows after he realises that's what they call themselves.