Work Text:
The city of Esgaroth was close enough that they could hear the screams of its people. They could hear the fire burning up houses, boats, and lives. It awoke guilt in them all as they sat on the flanks of Erebor looking at the distant flames. How many lives was this treasure worth? What right did they have?
Bilbo has changed a lot since leaving home, but nothing could have prepared him for this. He turned away in horror. It was only when he saw Balin’s face did he realise that some of their company had been familiar with this destruction. Too familiar. Bilbo couldn’t imagine what memories this must have brought back.
The hobbit’s eyes searched for Thorin until he saw the prince a few steps down. Deaf to the pain and grief of humans. With his back turned on the world, his mind focused solely on one thing - Erebor.
***
The next few days had been strange. He had never heard the dwarves so quiet before. The halls of Erebor were filled with the murmur of gold coins slipping and shifting as everyone searched for the Archenstone.
Thorin snarled commands, demanded answers, or whispered of treason within their ranks. Hasn’t Bilbo noticed the way others look at him? Hasn’t he heard his men conspiring to overthrow him?
Every time, Bilbo reassured him. They have completed the quest. They have reclaimed Erebor. They were safe.
Sometimes after they spoke, he saw clarity return to Thorin’s eyes; other times his gaze remained dark and full of hate. A dragon’s gaze.
Bilbo wanted to look at Thorin and see the prince he started this journey with. All he wanted was to look at him and feel hope again. And yet, all he felt was a dull pain on his chest where Thorin’s sword left a mark.
The solution was simple. Bilbo just had to bide their time until Gandalf returned and dispelled whatever madness had taken over the king. He just didn’t know how much longer he could keep this up before tragedy struck.
When Thorin accused Kili of stealing the Archenstone, Bilbo managed to calm the king down, leaving the young dwarf with only a red gash on his arm, but what if he accused any of them of treason? Bilbo hoped not to put his persuasion skills to the test. Together with Balin, they divided the work in a way to keep the young dwarves as far away from their king as possible. To bide their time. To delay. To wait for some sort of help.
That was the plan, until they woke up one morning to find an army at the gates. They ran out of time.
***
He had hope, even though a part of him already knew that Thorin would refuse. Thirteen dwarves versus an army of Mirkwood, their armours golden and arrows sharp.
Oakenshield has weighed the value of your life and found it worth nothing.
Once, they would have all died for him without a second thought. Bilbo tried to pinpoint what changed but he struggled to find something that hadn’t. At the start of this journey, Thorin asked them to follow him, to trust him. When he refused the elves, it was a sentence. An order to die - and what for? Pride? He worried that the dwarves might have been loyal enough to fulfil that order. It was a startling thought when he realised he wasn’t. He wasn’t prepared to die. He wasn’t prepared to let the madness and ego of a king kill all of his friends.
Bilbo was not a killer. Although he thought he wasn’t a burglar and a thief either, he sneaked through the elven halls and goblin tunnels. He stole from his friends and his enemies. The ring weighed on him nowadays. The Archenstone burned in his pocket each time another accusation was made, another strike of the king landed on his own kin.
Bilbo Baggins was a burglar. Bilbo Baggins was a thief. But Bilbo Baggins wasn’t a killer. At least not yet. He cursed himself for not seeing another solution. Maybe a hobbit who has just left the Shire would see things differently, maybe there would be another way out for him. Bulbo Baggins have lived in the realms of wars and dangers for too long now. It got to him. He has seen more blood and death than most of his people. With an army at the door, Bilbo was running out of options. With an army at their door, Bilbo was running out of time.
And yet, he allowed himself to linger one more day, hoping foolishly for salvation to arrive. He took his time preparing for the deed. The Sting didn’t seem like the right tool; it was made for killing monsters, and so he looked around the halls until he found a dagger. Sleek and elegant. At night, unable to sleep, he hugged it tightly, damning the elves and their armies. Damning the dwarves and their pride. Damning the dragon and its gold. Daming himself for being too cowardly to let them all die, not smart enough to find another way. But most often, he cursed Gandalf. Gandalf, who introduced them, who led them here. Gandalf, who was supposed to meet them days ago. Gandalf, who surely would find another way, one that Bilbo couldn’t see.
Gandalf, who was still not there when the sun came up.
***
When Bilbo found Thorin, the king was alone, pacing the throne room, fists full of coins. It took one look to see the madness had taken over. His eyes were as cold as the gold in his hands.
‘I heard them whisper last night.’ Thorin spat the words out in anger.
‘They’re afraid.’ Bilbo whispered softly, unsure if the king heard him. Unsure if it even mattered. He stopped a few steps away, underneath a nearby arch. He leaned against the wall, hoping it would hide his arm twisted behind his back, the dagger growing heavier by the minute.
‘If they’re afraid, they don’t have a place among us. If they want to flee, they’re welcome to fly off the keep’s walls. Cowards and traitors. They’ve stopped their work. They’re not looking for it!’ His sentences grew louder and sharper.
‘Thorin, the Archenstone is gone. We’ve searched for days.’ Bilbo worried that if he took another step in Thorin’s direction, his knees might give out.
‘Have you noticed my dear nephews hiding in the northern tunnels? What could they be doing so far away from me, but conspiring in the shadows? I’m tempted to open the gates of Erebor just to see them slaughtered.’
‘You don’t mean that.’ His vision blurred with tears as their eyes met. He searched so long for anything, any sign of clarity in Thorin’s eyes. His damned, beautiful eyes. He found only cruelty.
‘Don’t I, Master Burglar? Do you doubt the words of your king?’
Bilbo swallowed as he took a step towards Thorin. And then another one.
He would have followed Thorin everywhere; whoever the person before him was, he wasn't him.
‘Forgive me, my prince. I didn't know what else to do.’
Thorin’s eyes narrowed. Bilbo’s blade struck out.
There was a world in which the blade easily slipped between Thorin’s ribs. Bilbo held him, fresh, warm blood on his hands. He sobbed and screamed himself hoarse over the body of his dearest friend.
That was not what happened.
The hobbit was quiet. He was dextrous, he was quick, and he was brave; however, Thorin was a warrior. The dwarf’s hand caught his own before the blade even managed to make contact with the skin. He twisted Bilbo’s arm painfully. The dagger hit the stone floor with a ring.
Thorin shoved him to the floor roughly, the impact knocking the wind out of Bilbo's lungs. He couldn’t breathe. The world was spinning. Through tears, he saw a glimmer of the knife, and he reached out towards it, only for Thorin to step on his outstretched hand, pinning him in place.
Bilbo wept with pain and grief. Thorin was so much stronger than him. He didn’t stand a chance.
It was true and as good an excuse as any. Deep down, he knew as soon as he struck that he never intended for that blade to land true. He just didn’t have it in him to do what needed to be done, and now they were all going to die. Bilbo was going to die having betrayed the only person he truly cared for. The only person he-
Thorin grabbed him by the collar and lifted him up as if he weighed nothing. Thorin slammed him into the wall and pinned him with one of his arms. For a moment, Bilbo couldn’t hear anything over the rush of blood in his ears. Then the sound of his own sobs finally caught up to him.
‘Thorin, I’m so sorry,’ he whispered his apologies frantically, more to himself than anyone else. ‘Forgive me, Thorin. I’m so sorry. I’m so sorry I couldn’t do it.’
