Chapter Text
Thorin’s wish of leaving Guadosalam without encountering trouble was not to be. This was Thranduil’s domain, and he wasn’t about to let Thorin’s presence go unnoticed, or so it seemed to Bilbo when a brown-haired elf appeared and said that they were requested at the Manse. It felt more like they were required at the Manse. There was some history there that Bilbo wondered about, remembering how Thorin and Thranduil spoke to each other. It was yet another thing that he didn’t think he could safely ask about. In any case, he was about to get an answer.
So Thorin grumbled, but in the end he let the elf lead them into the Manse. The elf brought them to a wide reception room, furnished only with tables stacked high with food. Bilbo’s hand was halfway to a particularly tempting fruit before he remembered that they had not been invited to eat anything, and it would be poor manners to just dig in. Of course, by Shire standards this display without an invitation was itself extremely poor manners, but the ways of Elves were surely different. Even after Fili and Kili decided that the food was clearly for them, he held himself back. Thorin’s behavior had to be his guide here, and Thorin wasn’t even looking at the food. Balin and Dwalin were similarly restrained, though Gandalf took the liberty of lighting his pipe in one of the wall torches.
When Thranduil finally appeared, he swept into the room with an almost alien grace. It took Bilbo a moment to register that his son was behind him, so focused was he on the eerie quality of Thranduil’s movements. Thranduil himself seemed to barely take notice of the boy, waving his hand at Legolas absently.
“Go entertain Summoner Thorin’s Guardians while we talk,” he instructed the younger elf, and Bilbo’s heart sank. If their conversation was going to be private, he couldn’t exactly surreptitiously overhear anything. Or so he thought.
Legolas seemed uncomfortable playing the host to a bunch of dwarves, though he was polite enough to Gandalf. As it happened, Legolas could not easily drown out what was happening on the other side of the room. Thranduil began quietly enough, and Thorin seemed content to listen to him, and when Thranduil finished, Thorin was silent for a moment. Then he erupted in shouts, some comprehensible and some less so, though it was obvious enough that he was being rather insulting, and elves started pouring out of doors Bilbo hadn’t even noticed, pointing weapons at them.
“Well, well,” Thranduil said, his eyebrows slightly raised in what passed for surprise. “To threaten another summoner goes against the teachings of Yevon. Surely you know the punishment for that?”
Thorin’s expression might as well have been carved from stone. “I made no threats that were not deserved given the provocation.”
“Deserved or not, this cannot go unreported to Yevon,” Thranduil told him. “Especially not when one of your Guardians has been heard profaning the sacred places. The validity of your pilgrimage is called into question by such behavior.”
Bilbo’s heart thudded painfully in his chest. The dwarves were in a precarious position already; had he made it worse? Had he given Thorin’s enemies an opening to attack him?
“I don’t know what you’re talking about,” Gandalf said suddenly, drawing all eyes to him. “Profaning the sacred places? I’ve certainly heard none of that. Bilbo here was merely afflicted by Sin’s toxin for a time, and asking necessary questions to reorient himself. And none of the others have been so careless, save in answering those entirely necessary questions.”
For the first time, Thranduil’s expression wavered, creating the impression that he was uncertain. “Mithrandir,” he said, addressing Gandalf. “Even if that is true, and certainly your word is not to be doubted, there is still the matter of the threats made against my person.”
“Perhaps the matter would be best overlooked, when one considers that we were brought here under guard, knowing full well that summoners have no authority over other summoners,” Gandalf replied, raising an eyebrow. “If you were a maester of Yevon, things might be different, but between you and Thorin, there is no difference in rank.”
Something flickered in Thranduil’s eyes, and Bilbo was briefly reminded of a viper preparing to strike. Then it was gone, so quickly that he must have imagined it. “Consider my offer, Summoner Thorin,” Thranduil finally said, turning back to Thorin.
“I will give it as much consideration as you gave my guardian who was attacked by Sin,” Thorin replied coldly, turning his back on the other summoner.
“You should not be so quick to spurn potential allies, the way your grandfather did,” Thranduil observed smoothly. Bilbo saw veins in Thorin’s neck popping out as he struggled to stay in control.
“My grandfather died an honorable death, fighting Sin,” Thorin spat. “You have no right to speak of him.”
Bilbo was honestly amazed when they emerged from the manse without further trouble. The guards eyed them warily, but didn’t impede their progress, so they fled Guadosalam as fast as they could. Fili and Kili didn’t even murmur complaints about not staying at the inn.
Gandalf led them into a tunnel, and when they emerged, Bilbo was ready to turn right back around. The wizard had made it sound like Guadosalam and Macalania woods were directly adjacent, but apparently a dark, stormy plain lay in between. As they lingered in the shelter of the tunnel, Bilbo saw lightning strike nearby several times, despite the tall towers littering the plain. With all of their weapons and armor, the dwarves would be walking lightning rods if those towers weren’t doing much to draw the lightning off.
“Stay close to the towers,” Gandalf advised. “Not too close, but they do still work at drawing off the lightning if you don’t stray too far. I will do what I can to lessen the damage, but it would be best if we avoided being struck altogether.”
The dwarves all nodded solemnly, much to Bilbo’s astonishment. “Wait a second,” he protested. “We’re just going to go out there and hope we don’t get hit? Why not wait until the storm passes?”
“The storms of the Thunder Plains never cease,” Balin advised him. “They are the only way forward, so we must press on and hope for the best. It is as much a trial for a summoner as the temples.”
Bilbo pursed his lips, but Thorin had already stepped out of the tunnel and onto the plain, so he knew there was no point in arguing. Still, he stuck close to Gandalf and the lightning rod towers. He felt a little ashamed of his cowardice, but lightning was not a trivial enemy. There were two main causes of fire in the Shire: careless hobbits and their cook fires, and lightning strikes. A little caution was justified, he felt. At least Kili looked a little less reckless than usual, jumping whenever lightning struck nearby. He was the dwarf Bilbo would have been worried about wandering off and getting struck, but he kept close to his brother.
“Our mother has an agency here,” Fili admitted to Bilbo. “Kili never did like this one.”
“At least it’s safer in there than it is out here,” Kili grumbled. “How do the fiends survive here? Dodging lightning bolts while fighting fiends has got to be against some kind of rule.”
“What kind of rule would that be?” Thorin asked, eyebrow raised in amusement. “The pilgrimage is supposed to test the summoner and their guardians.”
Kili mumbled something unintelligible.
“Putting that aside for the moment,” Balin interjected. “What did Thranduil say?”
Thorin’s expression clouded over. “He proposed quitting his own pilgrimage and putting his resources toward aiding mine, in exchange for some treasure that Sin trapped in the mountain,” he practically growled. “If I passed his words on to the Maesters, it would be he getting dragged in for questioning.”
“Really?” Bilbo asked. “Why? Helping another summoner can’t be a bad thing, can it?”
“It’s not that,” Dwalin answered roughly. “Giving up a pilgrimage in exchange for wealth-”
“Very strongly frowned upon,” Balin agreed. “It’s like bribing your fellow summoners to quit. What if you then fail to defeat Sin? The consequences could be dire.”
“Summoners who have quit cannot journey again,” Thorin said grimly. “Quitting means excommunication. Accepting a bribe is the same. There would be no summoners left to fight Sin.” His eyes never left Bilbo’s face during this explanation. This happened so often, as if he was gauging Bilbo’s reaction, that he was almost used to it. By now, it was just the cold rain that made it seem like his cheeks were warm.
“So what he suggested could have jeopardized both of your pilgrimages,” Bilbo observed, determinedly not breaking eye contact. “No wonder you were so angry.”
Some of the tension seemed to leak out of Thorin at these words, though it was back when Balin clucked his tongue. “You let him goad you into that,” he scolded. “Now, if he retaliates, he will have Yevon’s support.”
“He will lose it the second I tell them what he proposed,” Thorin insisted, though he sounded less sure of himself now.
A bolt of lightning striking near enough to make their hair stand up put an end to that conversation, as they found that maybe moving a little faster would be in their best interests. The fiends themselves provided an answer to Kili’s earlier question, when one was struck by lightning and went into a berserk rage. Only a well-placed strike from Dwalin on the back of its’ neck prevented the fiend from goring Bilbo as he tried to steal from it.
It was with visible relief that they reached the Travel Agency, nestled at roughly the halfway point between Guadosalam and Macalania Woods, or so Fili assured them. Thorin was in favor of pushing on without stopping at the Agency, as there was still daylight left (though how he knew with the permanent darkness of the storm, Bilbo couldn’t tell), but Gandalf pointed out that that would leave them camping on the plains, or walking through the night to reach the safety of the woods.
“Would it be safe, do you think, to camp on the plains?” Bilbo asked, hoping he didn’t sound like he was whining.
“Standing still on the plains is always a bad idea,” Balin replied, shaking his head. “We would not be very tall targets, but we would be immobile ones.”
“Bad idea,” Dwalin agreed, with an apologetic shrug at Thorin.
Thorin didn’t push the issue, though there was a noticeable tightness to his jaw when they entered the agency. Dís wasn’t there, which did a lot for loosening Thorin’s jaw back up, though the dwarf working the counter assured them that she would probably still be at the Macalania Lake agency when they made it up there.
Fili and Kili retired to bed first, Kili’s usual boundless energy exhausted by being in a place he hated. Gandalf went next, claiming that an old man needs all the sleep he can get, not that anyone questioned him. Balin made a similar excuse not long after, and Dwalin made no excuse, though he and Thorin exchanged a look before he left. That left Bilbo and Thorin, sipping warm drinks in silence. There was no point to this, Bilbo knew. Their silence was hardly companionable, as Thorin’s demeanor still strongly resembled the thunder clouds overhead. He should just go to sleep, even if he didn’t feel up to it yet.
Bilbo sighed and took another sip of his tea. He should go to bed, but there was something about the way Thorin was sitting, shoulders high and tight, his arms folded in and his cup of tea held close, that made him want to stay. Perhaps he sensed another rare moment of vulnerability coming on, if only he could outlast Thorin’s stubbornness. Perhaps it felt like the time to actually do what Dís had asked him to do, if he could just work up the courage. Ultimately, it didn’t matter. He was here, in a contest of who could stay awake longer with a dwarf who seemed to be fueled by pure pig-headedness. If defeating Sin were merely a contest of wills, Thorin would be High Summoner without any trouble.
Bilbo set down his cup. Maybe now would be a good time to ask about something innocuous, just to get Thorin talking. If not, he could always just go to bed, and save himself more waiting.
“I’ve been wondering,” he began, and Thorin’s eyes immediately snapped in his direction.
“What?”
It was like he’d been waiting as impatiently as Bilbo. He could almost laugh. Did he look like he needed to talk too?
“Well, I guess I just wondered about your healing magic,” he finished lamely. He had wondered, but it was hardly the most burning question in his mind. “From what I’ve seen so far, it looks like most people specialize in something, but you heal, fight with a sword, and summon.”
Thorin’s shoulders relaxed, and his mouth twisted in a wry smile, as if to say, ‘this is what you wanted to ask?’ “It is unusual,” he agreed. “Summoners generally practice magic to build their reserves for summoning. Useless in the end, but it’s encouraged. I thought if I learned offensive magic, I would neglect my sword training and become dependant on the magic.”
It was a very Thorinish reason, somehow. He had high standards for everyone, including himself. If learning offensive magic would cause him to fall below those standards, then that magic was unnecessary. With that in mind, it seemed strange that he hadn’t tried to send Bilbo away yet. True, his stealing had proven useful, and he did his best not to hold them all back in battle, but he just didn’t have the arm strength to do real harm. He was getting there, but he’d certainly never stack up even to Kili.
Those thoughts depressed him, and he found himself gazing into the dregs of his tea, grasping the sides of the cup loosely.
“Are you tired?” Thorin asked, his forehead wrinkled in concern.
“No, I-” Bilbo sighed irritably. “I just feel bad. I’m not a fighter, never have been. I’m slowing you down.”
Thorin’s eyes narrowed as he studied Bilbo’s face. “You are not a warrior,” he said, taking a sip of his tea. “And you have been lost ever since Sin ripped you from your home. But your aim is good. You render Fili’s cooking palatable. We don’t have to waste gil on potions. It may not be wise to take you to Zanarkand, but…” Thorin looked away for a moment, apparently thinking better of what he was going to say.
Bilbo opened his mouth to protest, but Thorin silenced him by raising a hand.
“I considered sending you home once, but your home is the Calm Lands,” Thorin pointed out. “If you wish to leave when we get there, no one will stop you. My offer from Luca still stands.”
“It’s not that I want to leave,” Bilbo protested. “You… do you still believe that I’m really from the Shire?”
“Yes,” Thorin said, his eyes never leaving Bilbo’s face.
“Why?” Bilbo asked. “Even saying so is apparently heresy.”
Thorin didn’t answer, and they sat in silence until Bilbo decided to give up the battle of wills, and go to bed. Realistically, he knew the answer. Thorin was a summoner. He, more than anyone, saw the destruction caused by Sin. He, more than anyone, would want to believe that maybe there was more to that destruction, even if all the evidence pointed against it. Because Thorin was pig-headed to a fault. An optimist, in a world that didn’t reward optimism in the slightest.
Still, it was nice to be believed, and to have a place in this increasingly familiar world. It was nice that even if the dwarves didn’t necessarily need him, whatever Gandalf might claim, at least their leader had decided he was welcome. It felt so long ago now that Thorin had told him on the boat ride to Luca that as long as he made himself useful, he could stay.
Bilbo reached his bed, but found that he couldn’t fall asleep. New questions arose in his mind, questions that he had no business thinking. What if he did have a home? What if the Shire wasn’t destroyed? Would the dwarves make him leave then? Would he still be welcome if his warm hearth was in fact waiting for him? How different would circumstances have been if they had believed the Shire was intact in the first place? Would he have come on this journey at all, or been left to get home for himself?
He shook his head irritably, and rolled over. There was no point in ‘what ifs.’ He was here now, and that was how it was going to stay for now. When they got to the Calm Lands, there would be decisions to make, that was all. And, if Thorin decided that Bilbo was no longer welcome, well, he would just have to deal with that, wouldn’t he? It wasn’t as if he enjoyed risking his life on a daily basis. The adrenaline rush was nice enough he supposed, but what use was an adventure if you didn’t live to tell anyone about it? Then you were just a cautionary tale, like the failed summoners.
Or his mother.
Bilbo drew his blanket around himself tightly. He’d been saved by Thorin and his Guardians, whatever they secretly felt about having a hobbit in tow. So if there really was no home or family waiting for him, he owed it to them to help save their home from Sin, so at least they would have one. Gandalf and Dís both seemed to think he could do something, so maybe he really could.
It still took him a long time to fall asleep, piercing blue eyes haunting him, and he couldn’t say who they belonged to.
