Chapter Text
Bilbo awoke slowly, feeling grit in his eyes and throat. He groped around, pulling up fistfulls of sand. His first thought was that he was back on the beach in Besaid, carried back through time to the day he’d first met the dwarves, but as his vision cleared, he realized that he couldn’t be farther from the truth. Sand surrounded him in every direction, spreading on for miles and miles. The sun beat down heavily on his back, and he knew that wherever Sin had dropped him, it was far away from their hiding place under Macalania Temple.
Sitting up took some effort, but he was remarkably unhurt. A few cuts and scrapes here and there, but nothing was broken, and he wasn’t bleeding out, and those were both things to be thankful for. Likewise, he still had his sword and pack, and the book from Dís was still safe under his shirt. That said, there was no sign of the dwarves or Gandalf, or civilization at all for that matter.
He remembered his mother’s words, back from when he was small, and she’d take him to the market with her. “If you get lost, stay where you are,” she’d insist firmly. “If you try to find me, you’ll end up more lost, and we might never find each other again.” Sound advice in Hobbiton’s market, but it felt less applicable in the middle of the desert. The dwarves wouldn’t know where to begin looking, and if they all waited to be found, they’d die of thirst first.
A harsh gust of sandy wind decided him. Wrapping an extra shirt around his head so that only his eyes were exposed, Bilbo set off into the desert, sword held in front of him cautiously. He picked a random direction, and did his best to follow it in a straight line, deviating only when particularly tall sand dunes forced him to. Desert fiends appeared from time to time, but they mostly ignored him, probably finding more interesting prey elsewhere. Eventually, it occurred to him to follow one, and there he found Dwalin, sweating and swearing in another language.
“Do you know where we are?” Bilbo asked once the fiends were dealt with.
“Aye, that I do,” Dwalin admitted. “Roughly. Bikanel Island, where many of our kin settled after Sin took the mountain.”
“Here?” Bilbo couldn’t think of a less likely place for dwarves to live. “There are no mountains!”
“Save those we made ourselves,” Dwalin agreed. “We called it Ered Luin, or the Blue Mountains.”
“Why?” Had they painted their home blue, or something?
Dwalin laughed. “If ye look at the sky, with the dunes poking up into it, it kind of looks like mountains,” he admitted. “It was a bit of gallows humor, that they were the last mountains we were like to see.”
It did almost look like mountains, though he imagined that it must have been a very sad dwarf who first noticed that, and mentioned it to others. Gallows humor was right.
“By the way, you’re not to tell anyone where this is,” Dwalin continued more sharply. “If Yevon knew, well. They don’t much like us.”
It was probably the most talkative Dwalin had ever been with him, and Bilbo found himself agreeing easily. “I’m wanted by them too, remember?”
“Aye, but you might be tempted to sell us out for a lighter sentence,” Dwalin replied, though there wasn’t any judgment in it.
“I would never,” Bilbo practically shouted, indignant. “Besides, without a map, I could never find anything here. I’m not sure how you can. It all looks the same.”
“That’s true enough, but our home is at the far northern tip of the island, so wherever you are, it’s north from there,” Balin explained, appearing from behind a dune. “From there, it’s just a matter of using the sun and moon to navigate.”
There was a brief cheerful reunion, which ended when the brothers headbutted each other.
“Have ye seen the lads?” Dwalin asked, the business of reuniting taken care of.
“Not yet,” Balin replied shaking his head. “Hopefully one of them is with Gandalf, since they should know the way back.”
“What about Thorin?” Bilbo asked, wringing his hands in concern. It seemed strange that they would forget him.
“I don’t think he came with us,” Balin admitted grimly. “As we were pulled up by Sin, he managed to get a good grip. With luck, he’s still under the lake.”
“And without luck?” Bilbo didn’t really need to ask, but he hoped beyond hope that he was wrong.
“Arrested and standing trial in Bevelle,” Dwalin answered derisively. “Or dead.”
Despite the burning sun, it felt like ice chips were floating in Bilbo’s veins. “Well then, we need to hurry, don’t we? While we wander around in the desert, Thorin’s waiting for us.”
The brothers appraised him, identical grins settling on their faces. It was the first time Bilbo had thought they actually looked related.
“Well said, lad,” Dwalin said, clapping him heavily on the arm. Bilbo’s knees buckled, but he managed to keep his feet somehow.
“North is that way,” Balin indicated with one hand, shading his eyes with the other. “Let’s be off.”
They walked for hours, until Bilbo was sure that he would never find his way back to the start. The wind and sand obliterated all landmarks periodically, and their footprints never lasted very long. He might have found his way to the coast eventually, using the rising and setting sun as a guidepost, but the odds were against finding the dwarven outpost. Without knowing it was there in the first place, he wouldn’t have even known to look for it.
A familiar cry reunited them with Fili, Kili and Gandalf after a few hours, along with most of their rations, but the news wasn’t all good. Being tossed about by Sin and thrown in the desert had destroyed much of their food stores, and Fili and Kili had not rationed the water, so they didn’t have long before wandering the desert became a lot less coherent, and a lot more potentially fatal.
In the end, bruised, foot sore, hungry and thirsty, the company was picked up by a random patrol on a hover, who thankfully recognized the dwarves before arming weapons. Bilbo and Gandalf spent the last few miles blindfolded, for which the company apologized profusely, but there was nothing to be done. Bilbo was beyond caring. They needed to go after Thorin. Delaying by arguing about procedure would just waste time they didn’t have.
There being no natural mountains, Ered Luin was a mountain of metal, constructed entirely by skilled dwarven hands. Bilbo could barely believe his eyes when they took his blindfold off. Most of the buildings in Spira seemed to fit their environment, but Ered Luin was a fortress, built to keep the dwarven race alive at all costs. He was surprised on the one hand that Thorin seemed obsessed with getting back his ancestral home, when they had a home already. On the other hand, dwarves were meant to live in mountains, carving their fortunes from the bounty of the rocks. The only bountiful thing here was sand. Even the metal of the fortress had probably been brought from somewhere else, or salvaged from beneath the desert sands. How they ate, he was sure he would never know. There had to be facilities deeper inside the fortress that accomplished that, but they were definitely too secret for an outsider.
It was here that Bilbo met Thorin’s dismissed guardians.
They were undeniably a motley crew, and there were also quite a lot of them. He remembered Thranduil’s jibe about Thorin’s guardians, and wondered how much worse it would have been if he hadn’t sent the rest home. When they saw Bilbo, and were made to understand that he was a guardian, to say that they were curious was an understatement.
“Why did he agree to it? Surely a halfling can’t offer superior protection to hardened dwarvish warriors!” The red-headed Gloin insisted, earning some agreement from his fellows.
“What?” Oin turned his ear-trumpet toward his brother.
Thereafter followed a confused mass of dwarves shouting in Oin’s general direction, and Bilbo began to understand why Thorin had decided to keep things more manageable. The traveling expenses alone for such a large group! There was probably more to it than that, but it didn’t really matter. His existence was an insult to this group, at least until Balin got them calm enough to explain the circumstances, and they didn’t really have time for that.
“Gentlemen, please!” Balin insisted. “Thorin has been taken by Yevon, and we cannot waste time.”
“You’ve got a plan then?” Bofur asked, the other dwarves quieting.
“If they have their minds set on execution, they’ll make it as public as possible,” Dori observed, cupping his chin. “A normal summoner might face the Via Purifico, but…”
“They won’t make it easy to get in undetected,” Nori agreed.
“Then we’ll just ram our way in!” Ori insisted, sounding much more confident about the idea than his appearance suggested was a good idea.
“And die in the attempt,” Balin disagreed, shaking his head. “Bevelle is protected by stone giants. They would swat us out of the sky.”
“But wait, why would they publicly execute Thorin?” Bilbo had been pondering that over, and so missed the fact that the conversation had moved on. “Wouldn’t they want to cover up the fact that a summoner had supposedly strayed?”
The dwarves all turned to look at him, and he recognized the look in their eyes as pity.
“You must remember, the dwarves and Yevon have a difficult relationship,” Gandalf reminded him, breaking a long silence. The dwarves all blinked, as if they’d forgotten he was there. Bilbo couldn’t help but wonder if there had been some magic involved. “In cases like these, they would rather make an example of Thorin than take care of him quietly. That is why we must act quickly.”
“What do you suggest, then?” Nori asked, watching Gandalf with narrowed eyes.
“I believe young Ori had the right idea,” Gandalf admitted. “A direct assault on the citadel when they are preparing to execute Thorin would be extremely public. Seeing him rescued by his guardians, people might question if Yevon was in the right, for how could guardians be loyal to an unworthy summoner? Even if we were caught, a shift in public sentiment would caude them to send us to the Via Purifico, and contrary to popular belief, there is a way out.”
Fili and Kili’s eyes were shining with excitement, and the older dwarves were scarcely less eager.
“Never would have expected such a plan from you,” Dwalin admitted with grudging respect.
“It is not without risk,” Gandalf admitted. “But Yevon’s only weakness is public opinion. Maester Saruman has not remained Head Maester by ignoring it.”
“But how are we going to get there in time?” Bilbo asked. “The warrior monks won’t have had far to go to get Thorin to Bevelle.”
“Oh, don’t you worry about that,” Bofur assured him. “We’ve got just the ticket.”
“The salvaged ship?” Kili asked, nearly bouncing with excitement.
“You got it fixed up?” Fili looked barely less eager.
“Oh, sure,” Bofur agreed, making his way toward the ship, leaving everyone else to follow. “Bifur has a way with these old machines. He got it purring in no time at all.”
When they reached the hanger, Bilbo’s mouth fell open. This was an old machine? It was hovering above the ground, seemingly without assistance! “How is it doing that?” he asked Balin quietly.
“That, my lad, is an airship,” Balin replied proudly. “They fly, you know. Reached their peak a few thousand years ago, before Sin sunk most of them and destroyed the mine where we found their power sources. Now, salvage is the only way to go, at least until we find another power source.”
“But how does it work?” he asked again, only to be met with a shrug.
“We haven’t built one in generations,” Balin reminded him. “Durin would know, but he hasn’t been reborn in a thousand years, and Thorin had more important matters to attend to than interrogating his shade about the inner workings of ancient technology.”
The dwarves assured Bilbo that they could complete the necessary preparations more quickly without his inexperienced help, so he found a nice, quiet corner on the airship to continue reading his history book. The more he read, the more something stuck out as strange. Durin II was the first dwarf to defeat Sin, and become High Summoner. Yet, there was no more mention made of him after that. The next reference to Durin was Durin III, and the pattern was the same with him. His achievements all came to end after his defeat of Sin, and he was never mentioned again. Durin IV was the same. The only deviations were Durin I, who didn’t fight Sin at all, and Durin V, who became a fayth.
Bilbo scratched his head. He felt like he was trying to look directly at something that was hiding from him. This new information was like the last piece of a puzzle that he’d been assembling since he arrived on the beach, except he still didn’t know what the picture looked like. He wanted to ask someone, demand some answers, but that would have to wait until they were underway.
He waited until he felt the deck shift under him, and no longer. Bilbo set off for the bridge, hoping to find Balin or Gandalf. It was a bit of a relief that Gandalf was right outside. Something told him that this wasn’t a conversation that he wanted to be public.
“Oh, there you are Bilbo!” Gandalf clapped him on the shoulder. “I was beginning to worry that you never made it on the ship.”
“I just found somewhere to be out of the way,” Bilbo replied impatiently. “Gandalf, I need to ask you something. Something important.”
Gandalf peered at him intently, as if reading his thoughts. “Are you sure you want to know?” he asked simply.
“Yes. I think I already know the answer, but I want to hear it from you,” Bilbo admitted. “Everyone has been… well, dancing around what happens when you defeat Sin. Dís gave me a book on the line of Durin, and none of them get mentioned again after they defeat Sin. They just vanish.”
“That is a good word for it,” Gandalf told him. “Whether a pilgrimage succeeds or fails, for the summoner the result is the same. They die unsent.”
His comment in Macalania woods about ‘after the pilgrimage’ felt terribly insensitive in hindsight. Still, he couldn’t bring himself to scream and cry, or respond emotionally at all. He was in shock, even though he had guessed at the truth before this. Knowing it for a certainty was different. How could his mother done this? How could Thorin do this, risking Fili and Kili’s lives as well? No wonder Dís was so unhappy with his choice. She only had her sons and her brother left, and her brother was knowingly walking toward his own doom.
“But why? If they kill Sin-”
“The final aeon,” Gandalf said simply. “It is too powerful to fully control, and the summoner has no time to bond with it. After killing Sin, it turns on the summoner. The guardians too, if they are unlucky.”
“I don’t understand,” Bilbo admitted heavily. “If Sin always comes back, why do people willingly accept dying to defeat it? They die, but Sin doesn’t!”
By now this conversation was starting to attract the attention of passing dwarves, but Bilbo couldn’t bring himself to lower his voice. They were all okay with this? They just accepted this as necessary?
“Every summoner has the same hope: that when they defeat Sin, its defeat will be permanent,” Gandalf explained wistfully. “Even though in thousands of years, it never has been.”
“Then why don’t they try something else?” Bilbo demanded. “I seem to recall something about the definition of madness: doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result.”
“This world is mad,” Gandalf replied simply. “But the summoners are not the only ones who fight Sin. The Crusaders, under the initial direction of Lord Mi’ihen, have fought against Yevon’s dictates that only the final aeon can defeat Sin for thousands of years. You know as well as I how that has gone for them. Sin remains. The summoners die. Can you change that, Bilbo Baggins?”
Currently? No. He had no idea where to even start. But there had to be something he could do. Why else had Gandalf brought him to this twisted world?
Bilbo paused. It couldn’t have been just to help Thorin on his way to a heroic death, could it? Something felt off about that. Especially if there really was no Shire, and he had to make his way in this world when it was done.
“I’m sure I can figure something out,” he finally said with a shrug, projecting far more confidence than he felt.
Gandalf’s eyes had an amused twinkle as he started walking toward the bridge, though he didn’t reply. After all, first they needed to rescue Thorin. Then they could worry about keeping him alive.
