Chapter Text
With the Cavern of the Stolen Fayth behind them, there were no more excuses for delay. They had to climb the mountain once Kili was healed, even though Thorin gazed at it like the sight would break his heart. Healing Kili took longer than usual as a result, but as much as Bilbo might want it to take forever to put off the inevitable, he knew it wasn’t possible.
“Is it safe to climb it?” Bilbo asked as they stood at the base of the mountain. A crumbling stone gate waited for them in the distance, the only evidence he’d seen that anyone had lived here at some point. “Is Sin likely to hear us?”
“Sin is no likelier to find and kill us here than anywhere else in Spira,” Balin assured him, though it wasn’t a very comforting thought. “As long as we do not go inside the mountain, it probably won’t even know we were here. The mountain isn’t paper-thin, you know.”
That seemed to be enough for the dwarves, as they started their ascent without another word. It wasn’t quite enough for Bilbo, though he hurried after them. His feet slipped and slid in the snow, but at least he wasn’t cold.
“‘Probably?’” he prompted Balin.
“Well, it is Sin, after all,” Balin allowed. “The living embodiment of chaos and death. No one can ever really predict what such a creature will do. But previous attempts to retake the mountain have shown that it is fiercely territorial, and unlikely to move from inside unless it is threatened. Again, from inside.”
Bilbo remembered the senseless way the people at Kilika Port had died, and doubted there was really any rhyme or reason to it. But as Balin only seemed capable of making him feel worse about the whole thing, he decided to keep his mouth shut and climb. He had a feeling he was going to need all the energy he could muster.
It was a long, treacherous climb. There were paths carved into the mountain, either by wind and time, or the hands of dwarves, but it was obvious that only summoners had been on the mountain in centuries. The paths were narrow and ice-covered, the rock was crumbling, and here and there they found the frozen and half-eaten bodies of those summoners and guardians who had died there, but had apparently accepted death and not become Unsent. They knew what had happened to the rest, and they presented an equal problem in navigating the mountain safely. Wolf-fiends would charge down paths heedless of the possibility of falling, and it was only a few well-placed strikes from Dwalin, knocking the fiends off the path, that kept the rest of them on it.
Thorin unexpectedly called an immediate halt when they reached a relatively wide overhang, though it was only just sunset. Normally he would have insisted that they march until it was dark.
“The wind is picking up,” he said simply when Bilbo asked, with a look at Fili to set up dinner. “In the dark, we all risk being blown off the path, you most of all. If the snow fall thickens, we’ll simply walk off and fall to our deaths.”
“So the mountain itself is a test,” Bilbo mused, letting Fili drag him off to help. Dís had given them more than enough supplies, and now it was obvious why. Nothing could grow on the mountain, and only fiends could live there for long. Foraging would have been fruitless and even dangerous, and there wouldn’t be any more towns or Travel Agencies waiting on the other side.
“It is considered a sacred mountain, you know,” Gandalf told him, his pipe already out. “They say that when an army came to attack Doriath, a fierce snowstorm came upon them, decimating the army. Those who survived immediately turned back, and told their masters of the mountain’s fury. It did not save Doriath in the end, but people believed that they had prayed to the spirits of the mountain, and it answered to protect them. Over the millennia, that belief is one of the few things to survive Sin’s destruction.”
“That’s why Yevon doesn’t like that we lived underneath it, right?” Fili asked, as if he’d heard the story a thousand times. Maybe he had, if it was the reason Yevon gave for their dislike of dwarves.
“That’s part of it,” Balin agreed with a look at Thorin. “They say it is our fault that Sin dwells here now, that only our defiling of it made such a thing possible.” He shook his head sadly. “Even though they must know it’s impossible to ascribe motives to Sin. They simply wanted an example to show why it is dangerous to accumulate more wealth than they.”
“They don’t care what Sin really wants, if it even thinks or feels,” Thorin replied grimly. “There must always be someone to hate. It’s how they keep control. They give people a common enemy that they can actually hope to defeat.”
“And if you defeat Sin?” Bilbo asked, looking back at where Thorin leaned against the wall. “What will they do then?”
Thorin shrugged, though he didn’t look away. “At best, they will call me the finest of dwarves and my sins will be forgotten. Then they will find someone else to hate, or hold all dwarves to my standard, and keep hating them for not having the strength to put their lives at risk. More dwarves will follow in my footsteps, trying to protect their people from Yevon’s wrath, until there are none left.”
“It never ends,” Dwalin observed irritably.
“Everyone is a sinner until they defeat Sin,” Gandalf said. “Then they are a Champion of Yevon, defender of the people. Whatever else they might have done is erased, and added to Yevon’s long list of secrets. So it has always been. But that does not necessarily mean that is how it will always be.”
“As long as Sin regenerates, the High Summoners cannot speak for themselves,” Thorin pointed out. “They are dead, and their guardians lack the strength to argue in light of what they’ve faced. Those that make it back from the final confrontation always refuse to speak of it, except to say whether or not they won.”
All Bilbo could think was, “as long as Sin regenerates,” and he could tell by the distant look in Gandalf’s eyes that he was stuck on the same words. How many summoners had Gandalf accompanied to their deaths? It had to have been a lot, to earn the title of legendary guardian, but all of those pilgrimages had ended with the summoner’s death. After all of those deaths, it was no wonder Gandalf kept all of what he knew to himself. If he couldn’t find another way after all this time, after so many pilgrimages, how was Bilbo supposed to?
Unconsciously, his hand found the ring in his pocket, and he turned it over slowly, as if somehow it would help him think of something.
----
Far too soon, they reached the summit of the mountain, and got their first look at Doriath, now the ruined city of Zanarkand. From that distance, there wasn’t much to see except crumbling white stone and a glittering trail of pyreflies above it all, but the sight still had an impact. Even Fili and Kili’s usual relaxed chatter was silenced in an instant as the reality of the situation set in. The end of Thorin’s journey was just ahead, and they were no closer to finding another way.
“Proceed cautiously,” Gandalf advised. “Lady Luthien may send us a giant fiend to defeat as a test, and there are other things on this side of the mountain that we might wish to avoid.”
Bilbo nodded absently at the warning, knowing it was meant for him more than the others, but he wasn’t really paying attention. If he had, he would have noticed Gandalf’s casual reference to someone who should have been dead. His chest hurt as he watched Thorin gaze down at the ruined city, yet he couldn’t look away. He felt like he had to take this opportunity to memorize every line of that face, because he was almost out of time.
“I don’t want you to die,” Bilbo said, the words coming out in a rush. The others had moved on a little way to give Thorin some privacy, and he felt like this was also his last chance to say what he needed to. When would they be alone again?
“This is how it has to be,” Thorin replied firmly, though he didn’t look away from the city. Bilbo knew now what that meant. When Thorin, who had stared so intently at him from the first wouldn’t look at him, it meant that he couldn’t. It meant that he didn’t believe what he was saying as strongly as he might like. It was an opening if Bilbo had ever heard one.
“No, it isn’t!” He insisted fiercely. “No one expects it of you! In fact, unless I’m very much mistaken, your entire family has been rallying for you to quit being a summoner for years! You said you were going to die for them, but they don’t want that sacrifice from you! That means you’re not really doing it for them at all.”
That was enough to get Thorin’s full attention, and he turned on Bilbo, his sharp eyes blazing. “Everything I’ve done, I’ve done for them. Someday, perhaps they will appreciate that fact, but even if they don’t, it doesn’t change my resolve.”
It was very hard not to wince. Thorin was referring to Fili and Kili, and probably Dís as well, but Bilbo also felt like it was meant for him too. He had promised not to try and stop Thorin without some other idea, but here he was nettling him again. But what else could he do at this point? He was overwhelmed by his own helplessness.
Bilbo opened his mouth to say something, anything, but a shout from the company further down the path utterly derailed his chain of thought.
“What in-”
“Are these bodies?”
“Gandalf, explain this!”
Bilbo and Thorin exchanged a look, each giving a slight nod. This argument wasn’t over, just postponed. Then they took off down the path.
The company hadn’t gone far, halting in front of a strange carving in the side of the mountain. From his current distance, it looked to Bilbo like a sculpture of many people, fused together and also with the mountain. When he got closer, it was sickeningly obvious that he was wrong.
“It’s a fayth,” Gandalf told them grimly. “The last survivors of Doriath banded together to get their revenge on the ones who killed their families and destroyed their city.”
Nausea bubbled up in Bilbo’s throat. “But… so many of them! What could they possibly be summoning?” Even as he said it, the answer was obvious. Sin wasn’t a fiend, born from the resentment of the unhappy dead. Sin was an aeon, a product of the frustrated rage of the living. How he knew it, he couldn’t be sure. But he felt certain it was true, with all of his being.
“Bilbo?”
He heard voices calling his name, but they felt so distant. He could see them nearby, but it was like being trapped in a bubble. His limbs were so heavy, and the world tipped beneath him, until he could see nothing but blackness.
“So you made it here at last.”
The high, crisp voice startled him into opening his eyes. His cheek was pressed into soft green grass, and that immediately told him something was wrong. There was no grass on the mountain. Forcing himself to his feet, Bilbo took in his new surroundings, and the shock drove the breath from his lungs.
He was standing on a hill, in the middle of Hobbiton. There was something a little off about the colors of things, suggesting the onset of autumn, but it was undeniably the Shire as he remembered it.
“How… What is this place?” he asked, simply unable to believe the sight. It was impossible. “This has to be a dream.”
“It is a dream,” the voice agreed, and Bilbo turned in the direction of the sound.
“Shiva! No, Tar-Miriel,” he corrected himself, seeing that she appeared before him as a fayth, not an aeon. “I don’t understand.”
“You don’t understand dreams?” she asked him, a twinkle of amusement in her eyes.
“Well, does anyone really?” He pointed out with a touch of asperity. “But that’s not the point. I passed out, didn’t I?”
“When you saw the fayth,” Tar-Miriel agreed. “It was too much for you, getting so close to the source of your existence.”
“The source of my- what are you talking about?” Bilbo demanded.
“You’ve known for some time that Gandalf didn’t pull you into the future,” she reminded him. “But you couldn’t explain how the Shire would be safe after Sin attacked otherwise. Sin attacked the Shire looking for Gandalf, I think is what he told you.”
“Yes, that sounds right,” Bilbo admitted, though he could barely remember that conversation now.
“But does that sound like the Sin you’ve seen? Leaving as soon as it gets what it wants? Sin is an indiscriminate killer, isn’t it? Why would it track down a specific person?”
Bilbo furrowed his brow. “No, that doesn’t sound like Sin at all,” he agreed. “Why would Sin leave the Shire alone once it had Gandalf?”
Tar-Miriel smiled sadly. “Because your Shire is one of the places Sin protects from the intrusions of the outside world. Every time a city is destroyed, turned into an unsalvageable ruin, the people who manage to survive find themselves in despair. They beseech Yevon to bring back the people they lost, and are given a choice.”
“What choice?” Bilbo demanded when Tar-Miriel hesitated. “What choice could Yevon be giving them?”
“The choice to live and die alone, living with their grief, or to become fayth, and add their memories to the vast dream of the fayth. They are asked to help build dream Spira, a world that death does not touch, and which grows more vibrant as Sin destroys the world of the waking.”
Bilbo’s breath caught, and he felt the nausea returning. “Then I’m-” He stopped himself. He wasn’t ready to say those words yet. “Numenor?” He asked instead, and Tar-Miriel nodded.
“I too was given that choice,” she told him. “I begged Yevon to save my people, and was told that it was impossible. But, I could bring back their golden age and hold onto it forever if I became a fayth, and dreamed alongside the others. My memories, given shape.”
“But how-” Bilbo stopped himself again, this time to collect his thoughts. “Glorfindel told me that in the past, only elves could become fayth. What was it about the destruction of Doriath that changed that?” Even now, with his own existence thoroughly questionable, he needed more information. Something, anything that could help Thorin!
“I will let someone who was there tell you that,” Tar-Miriel said apologetically. “If you can get Luthien to tell you.”
“She’s alive?” Bilbo asked in disbelief, remembering Gandalf mentioning her sending fiends to test them. “I thought she was the first summoner to defeat Sin.”
“Gandalf may not have mentioned it, but she is as alive as Thorin’s father Thrain was, when you found him in Isildur’s cave,” Tar Miriel replied. “She may talk to you, or she may not. She’s been dead for a very long time, after all. It is hard to remain as you were when you are Unsent for so long.”
Probably a dead end then, but he filed the information away for later. Distantly, he could hear the company calling his name, and realizing that he had little time left, he knew there was no more putting off the important questions.
“Then, the Shire…”
“Was destroyed by Sin, and the survivors became fayth, remembering the people who had died, and letting their dream versions continue where their lives had left off,” Tar-Miriel confirmed. “Their dream neighbors married and bore children, and those children did the same, until the people of the Shire they had known were long dead, and they were dreaming of their distant descendants.”
Truthfully, he had been afraid of that.
“So, if Sin were permanently defeated, what would happen to me? How can I even exist outside of the dream?” Bilbo asked, the voices louder in his ears.
“We don’t really know any of that,” she admitted. “Gandalf made his way into the dream somehow, and started bringing hobbits out of it, and we don’t know how he managed it. You were taken out of the dream by Sin, and perhaps that made you a little more real. Then there are other circumstances that make your existence unique, though that too isn’t my story to tell. But, even if you knew that destroying Sin would end your life, would that stop you? For a chance to prevent more summoners like Thorin from wasting their lives, would you refuse to act?”
It was truly alarming to realize that no, he wouldn’t. He had just been chastising Thorin for throwing away his life, but if he did find a way to keep Thorin alive, his own life might be forfeit! And he didn’t care. Thorin belonged in this world. He didn’t.
“I was never meant to exist in the first place,” Bilbo pointed out, though it stung.
“That’s not true!” Tar-Miriel insisted, unusually passionate. “It was the love of the fayth that gave you life, the longing of those who missed their friends and families! Those feelings are real, and with those feelings they nurtured you and everyone you ever knew. They intended for you to exist, and… we’ll be sad if we lose you. You were meant to exist. It was just always on borrowed time.”
The Shire was fading all around him, and as Bilbo’s consciousness returned, his head cradled in Thorin’s lap, he understood why Gandalf had brought him to Spira. It was a gamble, an attempt to improve Thorin’s chances with the fayth by bringing along someone who was beloved of the fayth. Nothing more or less than that. But, as he looked into Thorin’s eyes, so full of relief now that he was awake, Bilbo was determined to do more. If one of them had to die, it wasn’t going to be Thorin.
