Chapter Text
Seeing Zanarkand from a distance really didn’t do it justice. Far away, it was just a tumble-down ruin of white stone and glittering pyreflies. It looked beautiful and sad, though Bilbo felt that way about most ruins. There was nothing particularly unique about Zanarkand, no, Doriath, from far away.
The true beauty of the city was only visible up close. In the moonlight, the stone had an eerie glow, as if it had come from the moon itself. Above, the pyreflies clustered in thick streams, almost like a shining river in the sky. It wasn’t just beautiful and sad: it was tragic. Only the deaths of thousands of people could cause so many pyreflies to congregate, drawn to the strong emotions they would have felt as they died.
Hypnotized by the pyreflies, Bilbo wasn’t watching where he stepped. One large foot slipped from the broken pathway and into the stagnant water surrounding the city. The splash seemed to carry for miles over the still water, and he froze in place.
“Do not disturb the water,” Gandalf warned, tugging him back onto the road and into the center of the formation. “The flooding came after the city was sacked. It hides things that no one has known for thousands of years. Ancient fiends and worse. We do not want to attract their attention.”
Bilbo just nodded stiffly, doing his best not to show the fear those words evoked. He’d been trying to keep some distance from Thorin to avoid being smothered by the dwarf’s worry, but if that kept him safe from unnamed things under the water, he could learn to live with it. For a little while, anyway.
Luckily for all of them, there was no way to get lost in Zanarkand. Most of the city was rubble and half underwater, leaving only a cracked stone road leading inexorably onward. It meant that there was nowhere to run if they encountered particularly nasty fiends, but there was no point in running from them anymore. Thorin wouldn’t be able to defeat Sin if he had to run from common fiends.
As they walked, Bilbo noticed a tall building in the distance, which seemed to be their destination. It was a dome, not unlike the music hall in Luca. It seemed to be the only structure to have survived the ages largely intact. Muscular statues flanked the entrance, though one of them looked like it had been cleaved in two ages ago. The torso lay on the ground, strangely free of moss or other plant life. In fact, there didn’t seem to be much algae or anything like it. Considering the flooding, that seemed impossible.
“Gandalf,” Bilbo asked, his heart pounding. “Why does nothing grow here? When the sea flooded the city, there should have been something, shouldn’t there?”
“I haven’t seen any fish either,” Fili admitted. “Was hoping to find something for dinner, but there’s only fiends.”
“The water is poisoned,” Gandalf told them. “I should have warned you sooner, but no one tried to drink it so I forgot the danger. The battle with the ancient evil left it inhospitable to all life. Time should have cleansed it, but some wounds cannot be healed so easily.”
“You said the traps were why no one had come back to live here, but poisoned water sounds far more likely,” Thorin observed with raised eyebrows.
“When you get to be my age, sometimes these things slip your mind,” Gandalf said. “I would have thought it obvious now that you’ve been here that this is not a place where life thrives.”
It was easy to forget sometimes that fiends did not count as ‘life’. Fueled by resentment, they could endure far more than the living. Bilbo couldn’t help but wonder if the Unsent were the same, or if how much of their mind they had left was a factor. But it was a waste of time to think about it. What could that information do to help Thorin?
Thorin seemed to guess the turn of his thoughts. “There isn’t much time left. Have you found another way to defeat Sin?” he asked Bilbo, a single eyebrow raised as if he knew exactly what the answer would be.
“I haven’t,” Bilbo admitted. “But I want to talk to Lady Luthien before you go off and get yourself killed.”
Thorin and Bilbo looked at Gandalf for approval, and he nodded thoughtfully.
“If you mind your manners, I do not think she will be offended. As it is Bilbo asking, that should not be a problem,” Gandalf told them. “But after all this time, do you truly think she might know something that she hasn’t told others?”
“Probably not,” Bilbo allowed. “But how do we know that she hasn’t given them another way and they’ve just failed?”
No one could say anything to that, though Thorin’s expression was painfully fond. Bilbo couldn’t understand it. Had Thorin been prepared to die for so long that the thought no longer troubled him? How else could he look so terribly pleased that Bilbo stubbornly persisted in trying to save him? He should try harder to save his own neck!
“I don’t understand him,” Bilbo muttered as he stirred dinner. They had made camp outside the dome, and he’d offered to cook. He needed something to do with his hands that wasn’t stabbing fiends. Or stabbing stubborn dwarves.
“With his sister, as well as myself and my brother, his choice to become a summoner has long been a point of contention,” Balin reminded him sympathetically. “We’ve known him almost his entire life, and done everything we can to try and make that life longer. You appeared a few weeks ago.”
“I hadn’t forgotten,” Bilbo practically snapped, and immediately felt guilty. “I’m sorry Balin, I just-”
“Don’t worry about it,” Balin assured him. “Thorin knows how to handle us trying to stop him. But he doesn’t know how to handle someone he just met, relatively speaking, expressing that same concern. Old fool that he is, it makes him happy.”
“It should make him sad,” Bilbo muttered.
“I imagine it does, but Thorin is used to managing sadness. He does it better than most,” Balin told him. “He has had too few causes for joy in his life. When he goes off alone like that, what do you suppose he is doing?”
“Brooding?” Bilbo guessed irritably.
“Well, I suppose technically that is true,” Balin allowed. “He only lets himself feel such things alone, so that no one will think less of him. The dual weights of king and summoner demand it.”
“None of us would think less of him though. Would you?” Bilbo asked.
Balin shook his head. “Of course not. But Thorin is, as you said, quite stubborn. And it may be too late for that to change. Why not let him go? This can only make you unhappier.”
He probably should do what Balin suggested. Whatever feelings he had, they were too young to mean anything. Certainly too young to mean anything to Thorin. It would only make his inevitable death more painful, to say nothing of having to live in Spira afterwards. But it wasn’t so easy to just turn off feelings, was it?
Without really knowing what he was doing, Bilbo strode over to where Thorin was brooding. The dwarf didn’t notice him at first, wrapped up in his own thoughts, but when he did, there was a warmth in his eyes that suggested that the interruption wasn’t unwelcome. Somehow, that just made it worse.
“Could you take this more seriously?” Bilbo hissed. “I’m wracking my brain trying to think of something, anything that could keep you alive, and it doesn’t bother you at all! Why should I waste that energy on someone who doesn’t care if he’s alive or dead?”
Thorin stared at him dumbfounded, and Bilbo realized that he finally understood what Shiva had been saying. She hadn’t wanted to give her power to someone who didn’t value his life. She wanted to give her power to someone who was doing this only because there was no other choice. Someone who would have lived a full life otherwise. After all, why waste time with someone who didn’t really care about the outcome?
“I do care,” Thorin replied, stung. “This has been my fate for so long, I cannot see it going any other way. And I am glad of the chance to protect my people, even if only for a short time. But you try so hard, fighting against something that everyone else accepts. I can’t help but admire that. I don’t have that kind of strength anymore.”
Arguments swam in Bilbo’s mind, but nothing seemed helpful. He couldn’t just nettle Thorin out of doing this, Dís had already tried that without success.
“I just…” Bilbo hesitated, and Thorin patted the ground beside him, inviting him to sit down. Feeling the anger leaving him, Bilbo sat, though a little further away from Thorin. “You will let me talk to Lady Luthien first, right?”
“I will,” Thorin swore. “You seem able to get answers out of people who wouldn’t normally give them. The dead in particular. Even if you do not hear what you want to, it will still be valuable.”
Bilbo’s conversation with Tar-Miriel jumped to the forefront of his mind, but he shoved it back down. It wasn’t something Thorin needed to know about. “None of you ever thought to ask, that’s all,” Bilbo assured him. “Even if your people never did like Yevon, their teachings and rules must have been a huge part of your lives. Breaking them wouldn’t come easily.”
“It was just the rules,” Thorin admitted. “We don’t believe in Yevon, but we’re still forced to live by their rules.”
“What do you believe in, then?” Bilbo asked, curious. Even reading the history book from Dís hadn’t yielded much of that information. Probably because of the trouble it would have gotten the author in.
The change in conversational topic seemed to relax Thorin, the tension going out of his body as he leaned forward and met Bilbo’s eyes. “It’s a secret kept from outsiders, as Yevon would have us all killed if they could prove we didn’t worship as they do.”
Bilbo’s face fell, interpreting this as a refusal. “I see. I shouldn’t have-”
“As you have earned your place among us, you have the right to know,” Thorin continued. “We should have told you some time ago, in fact.”
Bilbo’s disappointment was gone in an instant, and he scooted closer to Thorin. Thorin in turn opened his overcoat and wrapped the both of them in it, warding off the evening chill. Not what Bilbo had been expecting, but Thorin was as hot as a furnace, so it didn’t seem worth complaining about. He’d been trying to keep a safe distance, thinking it better for both of them, but if that wasn’t what Thorin wanted, who was he to stop him? Thorin was a dead man walking, after all. And so was he.
“When Glorfindel mentioned the Valar, it wasn’t the first time I’d heard of them,” Thorin admitted. Bilbo could feel his voice rumbling in his chest, and it wasn’t an unpleasant sensation. “The dwarves recognize one above all the others, because he is our creator.”
“Is that not true for the elves?” Bilbo asked curiously.
“I don’t know,” Thorin admitted. “If they still believe in beings other than Yevon, they don’t tell anyone.”
“I hadn’t thought of that,” Bilbo admitted. “I keep forgetting how long ago Glorfindel died.”
“As I was saying,” Thorin continued. “Before the world was fully formed, long before the elves awoke or Sin was born, Mahal the smith forged the first dwarves in secret. He made them in his image, desiring as a craftsman to bring more great craftsmen into the world.”
“So dwarves were the first race to be born?” Somehow he could understand why Yevon wouldn’t approve of this being spread around. And with that in mind, the enmity between the dwarves and Yevon made a lot more sense.
“No,” Thorin admitted. “And yes. Mahal was forced to put the dwarf fathers and mothers back to sleep until the world was ready and the elves had awakened.”
“Are these the seven dwarf fathers that came up before? The ones who reincarnate among their people every so often?” Bilbo asked, remembering their conversation at the Macalania Travel Agency.
Thorin nodded. “Because of how we were made, there was no afterlife planned for the dwarves,” he explained. “So we believe that when we die and are Sent, we return to the stone of the Farplane, there to wait for the world to end.”
Not for the first time, Bilbo wondered what would happen to him when he died, or faded, or did whatever dream-hobbits did. Could he reach the Farplane if he didn’t really exist? He certainly wouldn’t reach whatever part of the Farplane the dead dwarves were stored in.
“Is that why you prefer to bury your dead in stone tombs?” It had seemed like such a luxury in this world before, but it wasn’t about luxury at all.
“We believe it eases their passage to the Farplane,” Thorin told him. “My brother, father, and grandfather… None of them were buried in stone tombs. My brother and grandfather were burned on the Djose shore, and my father…” Thorin couldn’t continue, and Bilbo put his hand on his gently. The wound was too raw.
“The same won’t happen to you,” Bilbo found himself saying. “Whether you defeat Sin or not, none of us will let that happen.” He could see how important it was to Thorin, even if he found the subject rather morbid.
“If we fail, there will be no one left to carry out that promise,” Thorin observed, though he turned his hand over so that he could take Bilbo’s.
“Then we had better not fail, hadn’t we?” Bilbo said with more determination than he felt. “You said some time ago that only reincarnations of the seven dwarf fathers have ever succeeded. But Durin’s soul is trapped in stone. Who’s to say you didn’t inherit some of it?”
Thorin shook his head slowly. “Reincarnations of Durin know who they are. They carry the memories of every lifetime with them to the next. I don’t have that.”
But there was a faint note of doubt in Thorin’s voice, and that would have to be enough for now. Bilbo felt like he was always settling since coming to Spira, but what else could he do? He could hear the whispers of pyreflies inside the dome, like sirens trying to call the soul out of his body, and he leaned back into Thorin. With the shadow of death so hanging over this world, how could anyone ever get exactly what they wanted?
The inside of the dome was even worse than any of them had expected. Aside from having to navigate a broken hodgepodge of a road, assembled from what hadn’t completely crumbled over the ages, and of course the fiends, there were also the shades to contend with. Only a few steps into the dome, an apparition had flown out of Thorin’s body, wreathed in pyreflies, and talked to another apparition, which stepped through Kili and made him shudder.
“The pyreflies trapped in the dome over the ages accumulated to the point where they create an effect like a sphere,” Gandalf explained grimly. “The memories of the summoners who come here are preserved by the pyreflies, so that even those who fail are not forgotten, even if the city itself is all that remembers them.”
Encountering ghosts made of pyreflies was extremely unsettling. Even if they weren’t ghosts in the strictest sense, just clusters of memories, that didn’t change the fact that they were looking at people who were long dead.
“This is for the best,” a woman insisted calmly. “There is no one better suited for it.”
“That doesn’t make it right!” a man replied, and Bilbo started when he recognized a younger version of Captain Bard. Perhaps they weren’t all dead after all. “What about our children?”
“I feel like an intruder,” Bilbo admitted, turning away from the scene. “This was supposed to be a private moment.” Though he couldn’t say he understood what exactly they were talking about. Wasn’t Bard the summoner?
“For me it is a little different,” Gandalf admitted, gesturing toward a distant scene, and a pyrefly version of himself. “Nowhere else are my memories so well preserved, though it is a difficult journey just to see them again.”
“Do our memories affect what we see here?” Balin asked curiously. “I imagine they would, like normal pyreflies.”
“To some extent,” Gandalf said. “It is likely that Captain Bard appeared because someone’s mind is distracted by thoughts of what he intends to do to the mountain. You could probably summon up any high summoner you might want to. But, the dome also has a way of showing you what you need to see.”
Bilbo wondered about that as they proceeded through the dome. Many summoners and guardians passed by them, but the scenes were almost all the same: a summoner expressing doubt, and a guardian insisting that this was the way things had to be. They were always vague, but the message was clear enough. He couldn’t help but suspect Lady Luthien had her eyes on him. But what could she have to tell them that would throw this many summoners into doubt?
