Chapter Text
For Bilbo, Macalania Woods had always been a place of alien beauty, with dangers lurking around every corner. Now that they could handle the fiends without any trouble, he had expected to feel safer, but it wasn’t to be. Especially after nearly crash landing in the Thunder Plains after a particularly nasty lightning strike, with promises that the airship would be fixed by the next time they needed it. Probably. No, safety just wasn’t happening today.
“Do not speak unless you have to, and make no more noise than necessary,” Tauriel instructed as they entered the woods. “The longer we can go unnoticed, the less likely we are to be shot.”
“But we’re looking for your people,” Bilbo pointed out. “They’re going to know we’re here eventually.”
“And if we haven’t started a ruckus in the woods, they will be more willing to let us near Summoner Thranduil,” Tauriel explained. “This place is sacred to us, a wood that shines with it’s own inner light. It exists only because of the influence of the fayth at the temple, and so you were right to think that you must speak to us first. Without permission, they will try to protect the temple, especially now that they have fled the city.”
The elf-maid put a finger to her lips for silence, and set off deeper into the woods. Kili tried to follow close behind her, but without permission to speak he couldn’t be too much of a nuisance. At least Bilbo hoped so.
It wasn’t long before he was convinced they were lost. There were many clear paths through Macalania, and they had taken one last time, though Gandalf had eventually dragged them onto a less used one. Tauriel took them off the path almost immediately, forcing them to twist and turn into awkward positions to avoid being cut or stabbed by the sharp trees. They traveled at a snails pace, though at least the fiends kept their distance. Did they sense that they could only lose? Or did they perhaps have a habitual fear of the elves? Maybe they had been elves themselves once, and retained some memory of that life.
When Tauriel finally called a halt in a place where the path widened, most of the company was covered in tiny cuts from the crystalline trees, and all of them had tiny shards in their hair and beards. Bilbo couldn’t decide if it was comical or strangely beautiful, the way the half-light of the forest reflected off of them. But then, those same shards had been tearing at the thick soles of his feet all day, so his appreciation for their beauty was lessened somewhat.
They had not been given permission to speak, so they sat in tired silence, chewing on dry rations. Even if Tauriel had been willing to risk a fire, which Bilbo guessed she would not be, he remembered the trouble they’d had last time trying to find wood that would light. In many ways, it was a forest that protected itself from people looking to use it as fuel. A gift from Shiva, who hadn’t been able to protect anything while alive.
Silently, Thorin placed a hand on one of Bilbo’s feet, and he could feel the familiar rush of magic flowing through him as the cuts closed seemingly of their own accord. Had he been allowed to speak, Bilbo might have protested the necessity, as they were all cut to pieces in their own ways, but he did need his feet intact if they were going to be tromping about for much longer.
Unconsciously, feeling warm from the flow of magic, Bilbo reached forward and brushed some of the crystalline shards out of Thorin’s thick hair. The dwarf summoner was practiced at healing small wounds by now, so though he stiffened, there was no change in the flow of magic.
Would a day ever come where such a casual touch would be normal? The thought filled Bilbo with an unfamiliar yearning, even as he tried not to get his hopes up. Everything from the moment he had been dragged from the Shire had been more than any Baggins deserved, considering that none of them had ever been real. But was it wrong to hope that more might be possible? That there might really be a way for him to be real, or at least survive the disappearance of most of the fayth?
Thorin’s hand withdrew, Bilbo’s feet whole and hale again, Tauriel signalled that they should be off, and the moment was gone.
The path continued to widen, until they could walk two abreast. Kili tried to seize the opportunity to walk at Tauriel’s side, but she saw his bow and pointed to the back of the company. He went, eager to be useful, but Bilbo very much doubted he would be, staring longingly at the elf as he was. How had Thorin and Dís not noticed? At least Morwen, who had taken Kili’s vacated spot, wouldn’t trouble the elf-maid.
Bilbo glanced back at the siblings, who had unconsciously fallen in together while Bilbo stuck close to Gandalf. Judging by the smirk on Dís’ face, she had noticed, but her son being foolish apparently didn’t bother her. Perhaps she was just used to it. Thorin on the other hand met his eyes immediately, raising his eyebrows as if to ask if he needed something. Bilbo shook his head quickly and turned back around. Well, if Thorin really hadn’t noticed, he wasn’t going to be the one to bring it up.
It wasn’t long before Tauriel signalled for another halt, this time in front of the entrance to a clearing. Turning to face the company, she spoke in hushed tones. “Once we step into that clearing, we will be in their sights. I do not think they will shoot, as they ignored our passage through the woods, but make no sudden movements.”
Tauriel waited until they had all nodded their agreement before turning back to the clearing. She strode out confidently, but Bilbo could practically sense her tension as they followed. Her nerves were strung as tight as her bowstring, even if her face showed no sign of it.
Once they had all entered the clearing, Bilbo noticed that he heard no birds or other animals, and then arrows were pointed in their faces, the wood elves materializing seemingly out of nowhere. But no one fired, and that was something to be grateful for, even if their fingers were clearly itching on the bowstrings.
“Tauriel,” one of the elves said before addressing her in their language. With a start, Bilbo recognized Legolas, Thranduil’s son and guardian. Their pilgrimage really had stalled.
“They say that they have a plan that will save all of the summoners, and for that they need to go to the temple,” Tauriel said, suddenly switching languages so that they could all understand. “I do not know the details, but surely your father owes them at least his ear.”
Legolas turned to look at them sharply, his gaze settling on Thorin. “Is this true? You don’t want revenge against my father?”
Thorin snorted. “If I did, a summoners battle would be more appropriate than a declaration of war, or an assassination attempt. But we are here on business, not pleasure.”
And Thorin could not lose such a battle. Not after seeking out every aeon Spira had to offer, while Thranduil hid in the forest. As summoners, they were leagues apart now, even if they had been close in the beginning.
Legolas said something to Tauriel again in their language, and she simply nodded.
“Very well,” Legolas said at last. “I will take you to my father. But you will be carefully watched, and we must take your weapons until the audience is over.”
That was a command the dwarves could not submit to without glares and purposefully forgetting to mention a few weapons, leaving it to the elves to find them. However, Summoner Morwen’s daughters were just as irked at the order, and Bilbo saw death in their eyes as they handed over their swords. Somehow, Gandalf convinced the elves to let him hold onto his staff, so at least they had a backup plan if things went wrong. Though that backup plan could be removed forever with a Sending, and they were going to a meeting with three summoners.
Once all of their weapons had been confiscated, they followed Legolas through another series of narrow, twisting paths. The elves navigated them without a scratch, without even disturbing the delicate crystalline branches, but Dwalin, for example, was going to have some new scars before this was over. Not that he would mind, most likely.
“Enter one at a time,” Legolas ordered, stopping in front of the entrance to another clearing. “I will go first, then the summoners, and the guardians after. Tauriel-”
“I will wait here,” Tauriel interrupted. “Your father will not want to see me, and I want this meeting to go well.”
Bilbo half expected them to start arguing in their native language again, but Legolas simply nodded, his expression tight with displeasure, and walked into the clearing. Morwen and Thorin followed, and then there was a tussle between the guardians for the honor of being the first to follow them.
Dís won, simply by pushing past the scuffle. And perhaps a bit of magic was involved as well, Bilbo observed wryly as he trailed after her, stepping carefully over flailing limbs.
Thranduil was waiting in the clearing, somehow managing to look both more regal and more threatening than he had in his manse in Guadosalam. Perhaps it was the way the light of the crystalline trees shone in his eyes, giving them an almost fey glow. This was his home environment, far more so than the dusty town of Guadosalam, though what that meant for this conversation, Bilbo couldn’t say. Was he more or less likely to kill them if he felt comfortable?
“Well. This is a surprise.”
It felt like the understatement of the century, and Bilbo’s heart clenched as the dwarves bristled. He couldn’t make this easy, could he?
“Tauriel brought them here,” Legolas told his father. “They say they have a way to save all of the summoners, and they wanted to talk to you.”
“And you believed them?” Thranduil cast his gaze over the group with clear skepticism. “Summoner Morwen, you support Thorin Oakenshield in this venture?”
“I do,” Morwen confirmed. “In the past, I might have thought another path to defeating Sin was a fool’s venture. But learning exactly what sacrifice summoners and guardians are expected to make made me want to believe in another way.”
“To defeat death itself, death is a reasonable price, I would think,” Thranduil observed, but he hadn’t summoned his guards, so at least he was willing to listen. “How can anyone become a summoner and be unwilling to make that sacrifice?”
“Do you include the death of your son in that estimation?” Morwen demanded. “The final aeon must be remade every time, with the life of a guardian. I could not do that to my daughters. I would never have let them be my guardians had I known that I would have to make a choice that no parent should have to in the end. It’s wrong, and why no one has stopped to question it before is a crime.”
Thranduil’s gaze shifted abruptly to Thorin, though when he spoke his tone was carefully measured. “Is this true?”
“We heard it from Lady Luthien herself,” Thorin confirmed. “But she also told us that there might be another way.” A generous description of that conversation, Bilbo thought, but without her, they never would have known that there was more to the ring than immediately appeared.
The elf summoner looked suddenly thoughtful, though Legolas had frozen in place. It wasn’t every day that your father was asked to weigh the value of your life in front of others. He didn’t seem to think that he would come out on top. No wonder Tauriel had left Thranduil’s service.
“That is all very well, but why are you here? After all that has passed, I would not expect you to ask for my help,” Thranduil pointed out.
“We don’t need your help. We just need to go to Macalania Temple without being shot by your guards,” Thorin replied a little more sharply than was probably wise. Bilbo put a warning hand on his arm, and though the dwarf didn’t look at him, some of the tension went out of his body.
“And you can guarantee that Sin won’t move on and attack the woods after you have tried whatever plan you have?” Thranduil’s gaze was piercing. “I saw the smoke rising from the Calm Lands, and I believed that you had finally done what I wanted to prevent, only to learn that it had been the Crusaders, and they only fought a Sinspawn.”
He had been trying to protect his people from Sin’s wrath! Of course, if he like everyone else had truly believed that Sin lay sleeping inside Mt. Gagazet, he would want to avoid it moving from the Calm Lands to the next populated area. Which happened to be where his people lived. The elf summoner had probably thought that Thorin would be content to drive it out of Erebor, or would accidentally lead it into the path of innocents. Both were untrue, but it was easy to see how he had come to that conclusion.
“When it comes to Sin, there are no guarantees,” Gandalf said grimly. “But, if we are successful, no one will know the fear of Sin’s approach ever again. An eternal Calm, so to speak.”
“But if you fail, Sin will be enraged, and unleash its wrath upon the land,” Thranduil replied.
“Every summoner takes that risk,” Thorin shot back, his hackles up again. “You would take that risk, if you dared to leave your woods and actually fight like you swore to the fayth. Except that peace would be temporary, and your people would die again, this time without you to shepherd them into hiding!”
Thranduil reeled back as if struck, the first sign of genuine emotion Bilbo could remember seeing on his ageless face. Glancing at the guards, he noticed that some had lowered their bows, their expressions confused. None appeared to have particularly itchy trigger fingers anymore.
“Fine,” Thranduil said, surprising them all. “Go to your deaths. I won’t interfere, and neither will any of my men,” he added after Thorin opened his mouth to interrupt. “I would have expected you to have more sense, Summoner Morwen.”
“Sometimes a little daring is more important than sense,” she replied. “Still, if you change your mind, I’m sure your help would be welcomed.”
“Perhaps if your venture threatens my people.”
Bilbo blinked. Had he just asked them to give him an excuse to help, or was he just imagining it? He looked to Thorin for confirmation, but the dwarf’s rage was still boiling off. Gandalf winked when he met his eyes, and Bilbo felt a little safer as they left the clearing. One way or another, all of the current summoners were with them. How could they fail when they all put their power together?
“I think I understand why my brother doesn’t like him,” Dís admitted quietly as the elves returned their weapons. “I deal with more elves than most in my business, but he’s a different sort. I’m surprised he became a summoner in the first place.”
“It is common for elves to change when they lose their spouse,” Tauriel said, rejoining the group as they left the clearing. “Most do not survive the loss. In general, we are joined for life.”
“Dwarves are much the same,” Thorin told her, surprising Bilbo by deigning to speak to the elf maid. “Our hearts are like the stone we were born from. They do not change easily, and it does not even occur to us to stray.” He glanced quickly in Kili’s direction and Bilbo realized with a jolt that Thorin very much had noticed, and was commending Kili as a partner! What was even stranger, Tauriel followed his gaze, though she quickly looked away. How very odd.
“I didn’t expect that,” Bilbo admitted to Thorin as they made camp in the very same spot they had after fleeing Bevelle. “You hate elves.”
“If Kili wants to pine for an elf-maid, one who earned Thranduil’s ire is better than any other,” Thorin replied, glancing at the pair. Kili was chattering excitedly about something, using Fili to back up whatever story he was telling, and Tauriel was listening, the faint hint of a smile on her face. “Any of us could die at any time. That is Sin’s power. I can’t object to happiness, wherever it is found.”
Bilbo swallowed heavily, a lump developing in his throat. Should he tell Thorin the truth? Didn’t he deserve that much, even if it might make him unhappy? When would he get another chance, especially if they really did find Sin under the lake?
Their journey was almost over. His time with Thorin was also probably almost over. When had that happened? Had he really wasted their remaining time wondering about what he should do?
“I’ve been an idiot,” Bilbo muttered to himself. “A complete and utter fool.”
“Bilbo?”
“Do you remember what you said in these woods last time? What I said?” His voice was too loud and the dwarves were staring, but Bilbo didn’t care. He had one chance to say everything he needed to.
“Many things were said,” Thorin pointed out, suddenly looking away.
“You said that you wondered if you could carve one of these trees out of crystal,” Bilbo reminded him, and Thorin nodded, his expression relieved.
“But why that conversation?” Thorin raised an eyebrow, as if he had expected it to be about their rendezvous in by the spring. As if he would talk about that with an audience!
“I didn’t know that you were planning on dying at the time, so I said that I’d like to see it after the pilgrimage.” The memory still stung. How thoughtless he had been at the time, when the signs had all been there. In hindsight, it was so easy to see why they had shied away from discussing the end of the pilgrimage, and he had just blundered through it.
“Yes…” Thorin replied uncertainly, watching Bilbo as if he expected him to continue.
“I still want to see it,” Bilbo said. “Don’t think I forgot. So… take care of yourself. There’s no point if you let this kill you.”
“Bilbo…” Thorin’s eyes widened in surprise, his mouth slightly open. His warm, kissable mouth. No, that wasn’t at all helpful at the moment.
“You have to live, Thorin. Please.” For me, Bilbo could have added, but this would have to be enough. Thorin had to be able to live for himself.
“I will try,” Thorin replied, his piercing eyes searching Bilbo’s face for something. “And you must promise to do the same.”
“I promise,” Bilbo agreed, though it felt like a lie.
