Work Text:
The second swirling vortex of emerald mist did not descend upon the throne room, but rather materialized within the quiet, hallowed stillness of the Royal Tombs of the Kings, a place of cold marble and sleeping stone that had, until recently, been a site of mourning for a line thought broken.
When the vapor dissipated, the air in the crypt grew heavy with the scent of damp earth and the sudden, sharp warmth of living breath. Three figures stood amidst the sarcophagi, blinking against the dim light of the eternal lamps.
In the center stood Frerin. He looked exactly as Dís remembered him from the frantic, blood-soaked day at the Gates of Moria: his golden hair, a rarity among the Longbeards, was caught in a simple warrior’s braid that had come loose in the fray. His face, youthful and unlined by the years of wandering that had weathered his siblings, bore a confused, gentle expression. He looked down at his chest, expecting to find the terminal wound of an Orc’s axe, but found only the soft grey wool of his tunic, miraculously whole.
To his left stood a Dwarf of sturdier, more humble stock. This was Vili. He was dressed in the singed leather smock of a miner, his face dusted with the fine grey silt of the Blue Mountain tunnels. His hands, broad and calloused, were still curled as if gripping the handle of a pickaxe. He smelled of iron and wet stone, the scent of the life he had lived far from the gilded halls of his wife's ancestors.
The third figure, however, was the most out of place. He was younger than the others, perhaps only in his seventies, with a face that bore a striking resemblance to Thráin, yet lacked the heavy burden of kingship. His name was Borin, the youngest brother of Thráin, who had fallen in a border skirmish long before the shadow of Smaug had ever darkened the horizon. He adjusted the strap of a shield that was no longer there, his eyes darting around the magnificent masonry of the tombs.
"Frerin?" Vili rasped, his voice sounding like grinding gravel. He looked at the golden-haired prince, whom he knew only from the stories Dís told him during the long, cold nights in the Ered Luin. "Where... where is the mine? There was a collapse. The supports gave way..."
Frerin didn't answer. He was staring at a statue further down the hall, a depiction of his father, Thráin, looking old, haggard, and weary. "That isn't right," Frerin whispered, his voice light and melodic. "Father doesn't look like that. He’s... he’s supposed to be at the war council with Grandfather."
Borin stepped forward, his boots clicking on the polished floor. "This is Erebor," he murmured, his voice thick with awe. "But the carvings... they are different. More intricate. And why is it so quiet? Where is the herald? Where is the King’s guard?"
They began to walk, a trio of ghosts made flesh, moving upward from the depths of the mountain toward the living levels. As they ascended, the silence was replaced by the low, industrious hum of a kingdom in the midst of a great rebuilding.
The transition from the tombs to the Lower Forges was like stepping from a dream into a thunderstorm. Borin led the way, his confusion growing with every step. He expected to see the rigid, ceremonial patrols of the King’s Guard in their gold-dipped mail. Instead, he saw Dwarves in soot-stained tunics carrying heavy loads of timber and stone, talking loudly and laughing without the hushed reverence he remembered from the court of his youth.
"Everything is... so busy," Borin muttered, echoing the very words his brother Thráin had spoken only a day prior. "But where are the palanquins? Why are the nobles walking in the dirt alongside the laborers?"
Vili, however, felt a strange sense of homecoming. The grit, the smell of woodsmoke, and the honest sweat of the workers felt more like the Blue Mountains than the stories of the 'Gilded Erebor' ever had. "It looks like a mountain that’s alive," Vili said, a small smile touching his lips. "Not just a treasury."
They rounded a corner near the Third Level and stopped dead.
Standing over a burst water pipe, knee-deep in murky runoff and covered in more grease than a common apprentice, was a broad-shouldered Dwarf. He was shouting instructions to a team of engineers, his sleeves rolled up to reveal forearms scarred by the forge. Around his neck hung a simple silver chain with a heavy iron key.
Frerin gasped, his blue eyes widening. "Thorin?"
The Dwarf at the pipe froze. He slowly stood up, wiping a hand across a forehead smeared with coal dust. When he turned, the three newcomers saw a face that was decades older than the one they remembered. This Thorin had silver in his beard and deep lines of sorrow and triumph etched into the corners of his eyes.
"Frerin?" Thorin’s voice was a ragged sob.
He didn't move with the grace of the prince Frerin had once followed into battle. He moved with a heavy, grounded stride, his boots splashing through the water as he lunged forward. He pulled Frerin into a crushing embrace, burying his face in his brother’s golden hair.
Vili stood back, his heart hammering against his ribs. He recognized the man from the sketches Dís had kept, but more than that, he recognized the aura of a man who had carried the weight of a people on his back.
"Thorin," Vili said tentatively.
Thorin pulled back from Frerin, his eyes falling on Vili. The King Under the Mountain, a man who had faced Smaug and the armies of Bolg, actually stumbled. "Vili? By the Maker... Vili."
Thorin reached out, grabbing Vili’s shoulder with a grip of iron. "She... she is going to lose her mind. Dís... she’s in the upper kitchens. She’s... she’s right here."
But Borin stepped between them, his face a mask of utter bewilderment. He looked at Thorin’s leather apron, his soot-stained face, and the lack of a single scrap of gold on his person.
"Thráin?" Borin asked, his voice trembling. "Brother? What has happened to you? Why are you dressed like a smith? And where is the King? Where is Father?"
Thorin looked at the younger Dwarf, the realization hitting him like a physical blow. "I am not Thráin, Uncle. I am Thorin. Your nephew."
Borin recoiled as if he’d been struck. "Thorin? The lad who was barely out of his tweens? No... no, you look... you look like Thráin did after a decade in the mines, only worse. What year is this? Why is the mountain so... grey? Where is the gold-leaf on the pillars?"
Thorin’s expression darkened, the shadow of the past sixty years passing over his features. "The gold-leaf is gone, Borin. The dragon took it. And then we took the mountain back."
"Dragon?" Borin whispered, his knees buckling. "What dragon?"
The walk to the royal solar was a tense, silent affair. Thorin led them through the back corridors, avoiding the main thoroughfares where the sight of three resurrected Dwarves would cause a riot. Borin walked with his head down, his hands twitching, unable to process the "degradation" of the halls he had once seen as the pinnacle of Dwarven civilization.
When they reached the private solar, the door was already open. Dís was inside, arguing with a ledger, her hair braided with simple leather and her hands stained with the ink of a bureaucrat.
She didn't hear them enter at first. "Thorin, if you tell me we’re out of grain for the winter stores one more time, I’m going to throw this inkwell at-"
She looked up. The ledger slipped from her fingers, hitting the stone floor with a dull thud.
"Vili?" her voice was a ghost of a sound.
Vili didn't wait for permission. He crossed the room in three long strides, catching his wife before she could collapse. He didn't care about the ink on her hands or the simple clothes she wore; he only cared about the warmth of her skin and the fact that she was real.
Frerin stood by the window, looking out at the city of Dale below. He saw Men and Dwarves working together on the ramparts, their voices carrying up on the wind. He saw the lack of palanquins and the presence of shared labor.
"It’s different," Frerin murmured, a sad, beautiful smile touching his lips. "It’s not the Erebor I died for. It’s... it’s better."
"It is honest, Frerin," Dís sobbed into Vili’s neck. "It’s honest and it’s ours. No more gold-sickness. No more hiding."
But Borin remained by the door, his eyes fixed on Thorin. "You said 'we' took it back. You and who else? Where is the army? Where are the Iron Hills? And why do you look at me with such pity, nephew?"
Thorin sighed, sitting in a sturdy oak chair that Thrór would have found insulting. "The army was thirteen Dwarves and a Hobbit, Borin. And my father... your brother... he is here. In the guest wing."
"Then take me to him," Borin demanded, his voice cracking with a sudden, sharp fear. "Take me to my brother. He will explain why the Princes are working and why the Princess smells of vegetable broth."
The guest wing was quiet, the air smelling of the honey-cakes Vora had made that morning. Thráin was sitting in a garden chair near the window, dressed in his charcoal-grey wool, his eyes following a butterfly that had fluttered in from the terrace. Vora sat beside him, her hand resting on his scarred forearm.
When the door opened, Thráin didn't turn. He was used to the quiet presence of his children.
"Thráin?" Borin’s voice was barely a whisper.
Thráin froze. That voice was a relic of a world before the shadow, before the Necromancer, and before the dragon. He slowly turned his head, his haunted eyes meeting the wide, terrified gaze of his younger brother.
Borin stumbled back, his hand flying to his mouth. "By the Maker... Thráin? What... what did they do to you?"
He looked at the map of scars on Thráin’s neck, the translucent skin, and the "slight crazy" that still flickered in the depths of his pupils. He looked at the humble wool his brother wore and the way he clung to Vora as if she were the only thing keeping him from drifting away.
"I was in the dark, Borin," Thráin rasped, his voice sounding like dry leaves. "I was in the dark for a very long time."
Borin fell to his knees beside his brother’s chair, grabbing Thráin’s hands. "But you’re the King! You are the heir of Durin! Where is your crown? Where is your dignity? Why are you sitting here in the clothes of a commoner while the mountain falls into... into this?"
Thráin looked down at his brother, a look of profound, weary peace settling over his features. He reached out with a trembling hand and touched Borin’s cheek.
"This isn't a fall, Borin," Thráin whispered. "It’s an awakening. I have spent my whole life being a symbol. I have spent my whole life in a golden cage." He looked at Thorin and Dís, who stood in the doorway with Frerin and Vili. "My son... he broke the cage. He let the gold stay in the dark so that we could live in the light."
Borin looked around the room, at the scarred King, the ink-stained Princess, the smith-son, and the golden-haired boy who should have been dead. He saw the love in their eyes, a love that was fierce and rugged and entirely lacking in the "correct" etiquette he had been raised to value.
"I don't understand," Borin sobbed, burying his face in Thráin’s lap. "I don't understand any of it."
"You don't have to," Frerin said softly, stepping forward and placing a hand on Borin’s shoulder. "You just have to be alive. That’s enough now. That’s all any of us have to be."
The afternoon sun began to dip behind the peaks, casting long, purple shadows across the gardens of Erebor. The group sat together in the wild, fragrant sprawl of herbs and Shire-flowers, a family reunited across the boundaries of death and time.
Vili sat next to Dís, his hand never leaving hers. He listened as she told him of their sons, of Fíli’s courage and Kíli’s mischief. He laughed when she described how they had been raised in the dirt and the wind of the Blue Mountains, far from the suffocating "perfection" of the old court.
"They sound magnificent," Vili whispered, using the same word Thráin had used for his grandsons.
"They are a handful," Dís corrected him, though her eyes shone with pride. "They take after you in spirit, Vili. They have absolutely no regard for their station."
Frerin sat with his mother, Vora, helping her snap the ends off a basket of green beans for the evening meal. He didn't mind the work; he found the rhythm of it soothing, a far cry from the rigid protocols of his youth.
"You look happy, Mother," Frerin noted, his voice light.
Vora smiled, a genuine, unforced expression. "I am a person, Frerin. For the first time in my life, I am allowed to be a person."
Borin remained near Thráin, still struggling to reconcile the broken man before him with the brother he had idolized. He looked at Thorin, who was currently sharpening a small knife with a whetstone, his movements methodical and calm.
"He isn't the King yet, is he?" Borin whispered to Thráin, gesturing to Thorin. "He’s still waiting for you to take the throne back?"
Thráin let out a soft, delighted chuckle. "Oh, Borin”
….
………
….
The garden of Erebor was a tapestry of contradictions. The smell of wild lavender and damp earth from the newly planted terraces competed with the distant, rhythmic clang-clang-clang of the Great Forge. It was a sound of industry, not of ceremony, and it seemed to set Borin’s teeth on edge.
Borin clung to Thráin’s hand, his knuckles white. He looked at the scarred, weary Dwarf in the wool tunic and then at the younger, silver-bearded Dwarf, Thorin, who was still casually honing a blade.
"You say father is not king?," Borin whispered, his voice trembling with a mix of awe and burgeoning horror. "And you say Thorin is? look at him, Thráin! He has coal dust under his fingernails. He has no crown. He has no guards standing at attention. If he is the King, where is the King’s dignity? And if he is the King... then what are you? Why are you not on the throne?"
Thráin’s expression didn't flicker toward anger. Instead, a profound sadness washed over him, making him look even older. "I am a man who was lost in the dark, Borin. I am a man who was broken by a Ring and a Necromancer. I do not want a throne. I want the sun on my face and my family whole."
Borin shook his head violently. "It is not right. The Line of Durin does not... we do not sit in gardens like common shepherds! Father would never allow this. Where is he? Where is King Thrór? He will set this straight. He will explain why you are dressed in rags and why my nephew is acting like a village blacksmith."
As if summoned by the mention of his name, the heavy oak doors leading to the royal apartments creaked open.
Thrór stepped out onto the terrace, his tattered but gold-trimmed robes trailing behind him. Beside him walked Hrefna, her silver hair coiled in the intricate, tight braids of a Queen of the Old Way. They both stopped, the air leaving their lungs in a simultaneous gasp.
"Frerin?" Hrefna cried out, her voice cracking.
The golden-haired Prince stood up from his task with the beans. He wiped his hands on his trousers, a gesture that would have earned him a week of lectures in the old days, and offered a brilliant, sunny smile. "Grandmother. Grandfather."
Thrór ignored the lack of a formal bow. He lunged forward with a speed surprising for his age, pulling Frerin into a fierce embrace. "My boy. My golden boy. The Raven told us you fell at Azanulbizar. I saw the fires... I thought you were ash."
"I was," Frerin said softly, leaning into the scent of old parchment and expensive oils that always followed Thrór. "But I’m not anymore."
Hrefna’s eyes, however, moved past Frerin to the Dwarf standing beside Dís. Vili stood tall, his shoulders square, looking every bit the commoner he was. He didn't look down; he looked at the Queen with a kind, steady gaze that spoke of a man who had worked for every scrap of bread he’d ever eaten.
"And who is this?" Thrór asked, pulling back from Frerin, his eyes narrowing as they landed on Vili’s singed leather smock.
"This is Vili," Dís said, her voice ringing with a sharp, defensive edge. "My husband. The father of my sons."
Thrór stiffened. He looked at Vili’s rough hands and the lack of a noble house-sigil. "A miner? You married a laborer of the Ered Luin?"
"I married a King among men," Dís snapped, stepping closer to Vili. "And if you insult him, Grandfather, you can find your own way back to the silence."
The tension was a physical weight, but it was broken by a sudden, strangled sob from the garden floor.
Borin had stood up, his eyes darting between Thrór and Thráin. He looked at Thrór, who still looked like a King of Legend, despite the scars, and then at Thráin, who looked like a refugee.
"Father!" Borin cried, rushing to Thrór’s side. "Father, thank the Maker. Tell them. Tell Thráin he must take his place. Tell Thorin to put on a crown and stop acting like a commoner. They are making a mockery of our House! They work in the dirt, Father. They speak to Men and Elves as equals!"
Thrór looked down at his youngest son, his brow furrowing. "Borin... you were always the most traditional of us."
"Because it is the Way!" Borin insisted, gesturing wildly at the garden. "Why is Thráin so angry with you? Why does he look at you as if you are a stranger? He is sitting here with Vora like a peasant at a harvest festival!"
Thráin’s eyes snapped to his father. The gentle peace he had found minutes ago vanished, replaced by a cold, hard fire. "He is 'mad' at our father, Borin, because our father followed a golden idol into a dragon’s mouth. I am 'mad' because our father cared more for the gems in the deep than the blood of his kin."
"How can you say that?" Borin whispered, looking horrified. "He is the King! The gold is our life! Without the Arkenstone, we are nothing!"
Thorin finally stepped forward. He moved with a quiet, terrifying authority that had nothing to do with silk or gold. He dropped his whetstone into a pocket and looked his uncle in the eye.
"Uncle Borin," Thorin said, his voice low and grounding. "Look at me."
Borin looked. He saw the scars from the Orcrist. He saw the weary weight of the crown of kingship that Thorin wasn't even wearing.
"I am the King Under the Mountain," Thorin stated. It wasn't a boast; it was a heavy fact. "I do not wear a crown because a crown did not lead us through the Mirkwood. I do not sit on a throne because a throne did not kill the Pale Orc. I work with my hands because my people are hungry and cold, and a King who will not bleed with his people is no King at all."
Borin staggered back, his breath coming in short, panicked hitches. "But the protocol... the lineage... the majesty..."
"The majesty is in the survival, Borin," Dís said, her voice softening as she saw the genuine distress in her uncle’s eyes. She walked over, taking Borin’s arm. "You have been gone a long time. You died when the world was bright and the halls were full of song. You didn't see the fire. You didn't see the decades of wandering where we had to choose between our pride and our lives."
Frerin stepped up on Borin's other side, his presence a cooling balm. "It’s alright to be confused, Uncle. I am confused, too. I expected to wake up in a war camp, not a garden." He tilted his head, smiling. "But look at Father. Look at Thráin. Do you see how he holds Mother’s hand? He never did that in the old city. He was always too busy being a Prince."
Borin looked at Thráin and Vora. For the first time, he noticed that Thráin wasn't just sitting; he was resting. The frantic, twitching energy Borin remembered from his older brother, the constant pressure to be the perfect heir, was gone.
"He looks... quiet," Borin noted, his voice small.
"He is finally at peace," Vora said, reaching out to touch Borin’s hand. "And you can be, too, Borin. You don't have to be a soldier of the line today. You just have to be my brother-in-law."
Thrór watched this exchange, his jaw tight. He looked at Vili, the commoner, who was now helping Hrefna to a stone bench with more genuine grace than any courtier had ever shown her. He looked at Thorin, the King who smelled of iron and smoke.
Borin sank onto the grass, his fine silk tunics getting stained by the green clover. He looked up at Thorin, who was watching him with a patient, tired sort of love.
"You really are the King?" Borin asked.
"I am," Thorin said.
Borin let out a shaky, hysterical laugh, burying his face in his hands. "The world has gone mad. Im so confused”
Thráin patted his little brother on the shoulder “thats okay borin. Its alright to be confused”
The fragile peace of the royal garden was not shattered by a dragon’s roar or an Orc’s cry, but by something far more chaotic: the high-pitched, frantic laughter of two young Dwarves who were running for their lives.
The garden doors didn't just open; they were kicked off their latch as Fíli and Kíli burst through, stumbling over their own feet. They were covered in a suspicious layer of blue dye and feathers, their braids sticking out at wild angles.
"He’s gaining on us!" Kíli wheezed, doubling over and clutching his sides. "I told you the bucket was too heavy!"
"It was the perfect weight," Fíli gasped, his face flushed bright red from the exertion. "You just didn't trip the wire fast enough!"
Before they could find a hiding spot behind a topiary bush, a shadow loomed in the doorway that could only belong to one Dwarf. Dwalin, son of Fundin, marched into the sunlight. His bald head was smeared with a streak of vibrant azure, and his beard, usually kept in terrifyingly neat braids, was dusted with chicken down. He looked like a very disgruntled, very blue mountain.
"I’m going to shave your heads!" Dwalin roared, though the familiar glint of amusement in his eyes betrayed him. "I’m going to-"
The roar died in his throat. His heavy boots skidded to a halt on the stone path. Dwalin’s gaze, which had been locked on the two mischievous princes, drifted upward. He saw Thorin, then Dís, and finally, the figures sitting in the grass.
The blue-stained warrior dropped his axe. It clattered loudly against the marble.
"Frerin?" Dwalin’s voice, usually a deep rumble that could shake the foundations of the mountain, was suddenly thin and fragile.
Frerin stood up, his golden hair catching the light, his gentle smile widening. "You’ve grown a bit grumpy in your old age, Dwalin. And blue isn't really your color."
Dwalin didn't say a word. He surged forward, ignoring everyone else, and caught Frerin in a hug that looked like it might snap the younger prince’s ribs. The two had been inseparable in their youth, Dwalin the shield, Frerin the light. For a long moment, the only sound was the heavy, wet thud of Dwalin’s hand patting Frerin’s back, over and over, as if making sure he wouldn't vanish into mist again.
"And Vili?" Dwalin asked, pulling back and looking at the miner. He reached out a hand, clasping Vili’s forearm with a grip of iron. "You owe me a keg of ale for leaving me alone with these two terrors for so long."
Vili laughed, a warm, grounded sound. "I think the ale is on you, Dwalin. You’re the one with the royal treasury now."
Fíli and Kíli stood frozen, their pranks entirely forgotten. They looked at the golden-haired Dwarf who looked so much like Fíli it was unsettling, and then at the miner who was looking at them with a gaze of such raw, fatherly hunger that it made their chests ache.
"Boys," Dís said, her voice trembling as she beckoned them forward. "This is your Uncle Frerin. And this..." She took a breath, her hand finding Vili’s. "This is your father."
Kíli was the first to move, his usual impulsiveness driving him forward until he was standing right in front of Vili. He looked at the man he had only ever known through stories and the faded smell of a leather coat. Vili reached out, his calloused thumb wiping a smudge of blue dye from Kíli’s cheek.
"You have your mother's eyes," Vili whispered. "But the rest of you... you're all mine."
Fíli, however, was staring at Frerin. It was like looking into a mirror that showed a kinder, softer version of himself. He had the same golden hair, the same sharp nose, the same tilt to his head.
Frerin stepped toward Fíli, his eyes bright with a smug sort of delight. He circled his nephew, taking in the intricate braids and the fine fur-lined coat.
"Dís," Frerin called out, his voice full of mischief. "You didn't tell me you had such good taste! He’s the image of me. Truly, the handsomest Dwarf in the mountain." He leaned in closer to Fíli, whispering loud enough for everyone to hear. "I hear you’re the Crown Prince. It’s a good thing you look like me; the people need something pretty to look at after sixty years of Thorin’s scowling."
Thorin let out a huff, though he couldn't hide his grin. "Be careful, Fíli. He was always the vain one."
"It’s not vanity if it’s true," Frerin shot back, throwing an arm around Fíli’s shoulders. "See? We even stand the same way."
In the midst of this emotional whirlwind, Borin was sitting on the grass, looking utterly lost. He looked at Fíli and Kíli, who were clearly grown men, warriors with beards and scars, and then at himself.
"Wait," Borin said, his voice high and confused. "Thráin... if those are Dís’s sons... and I am Dís’s uncle... does that mean they are my grand-nephews?"
"That’s right, Uncle," Thorin said, suppressing a laugh.
Borin stood up, dusting off his silks. He walked over to the two 'boys,' who towered over him by a good few inches. "But... they are older than me! I am only seventy-two. They look... they look like they’ve seen a hundred winters!"
"Eighty-two and seventy-seven," Kíli supplied helpfully, still leaning against Vili’s side. He looked down at Borin, his brow furrowing. "So... you’re our... Great-Uncle? But you’re shorter than us."
"And younger," Fíli added, poking Borin’s arm. "This is very strange. Do we have to listen to you? You look like you should be our younger brother."
Borin puffed out his chest, trying to reclaim some shred of his dignity. "I am the son of Thrór! I am a Prince of the Line! Of course you have to listen to-" He stopped, looking at Fíli’s golden hair and then back at Frerin. "........This is a chronological disaster!"
Fíli and Kíli shared a look. They turned to their mother, then to Thorin, and finally back to Borin.
"What do we call him?" Kíli asked. "Uncle-Lad? Little-Great-Uncle?"
"Prince-Child?" Fíli suggested, grinning as Borin grew redder.
"You will call me Lord Borin!" the younger Dwarf squeaked, though his heart wasn't in it.
Frerin laughed, a clear, ringing sound that seemed to chase away the last of the gloom in the garden. He ruffled Fíli’s hair, messing up the royal braids even further. "Let them call you whatever they like, Borin. In this Erebor, it seems the titles don't matter as much as the trouble you can cause."
He looked at Dwalin, then at his nephews, and finally at the blue dye still dripping off the walls. "Now, tell me about this prank. If we’re going to live here, I need to know if the quality of mischief has improved since my day."
Vili pulled his sons close, one under each arm, looking at the chaotic, beautiful, mismatched family that had been gathered from the halls of the dead and the struggles of the living. "I think," Vili said, his voice thick with contentment, "that the mischief is in very capable hands."
Borin sat back down, watching Fíli and Frerin stand side-by-side, two golden princes of two different eras, and finally let out a long sigh. "Fine. But you're not calling me 'Uncle-Lad.' It’s undignified."
"We'll see about that, Uncle-Lad," Kíli chirped.
…
……..
…….
..
The march from the garden to the Great Hall was a trial in itself for Borin. He walked with his head swivelling like an owl's, taking in the sight of the Great Forge where Dwarves of all ranks shared water skins, and the lack of silk tapestries on the walls. Frerin, however, seemed to find it all enchanting. He walked beside Fíli, his twin in golden hair and mischievous spirit, whispering questions about how many Orcs Fíli had slain and if the "pretty" hair beads Fíli wore were a new fashion or a necessity for keeping his head on straight.
"It’s for the girls," Fíli winked, bumping shoulders with his uncle.
Frerin grinned, a smug glint in his eye. "Good lad. Always keep them looking at the face. It distracts from the clumsy footwork."
Vili, meanwhile, walked in a daze of quiet joy. He had Kíli on his left and Dís on his right, his hands resting on their shoulders as if to anchor himself to this impossible reality. He didn't care about the architecture or the missing gold; he cared about the heat of his son's shoulder and the familiar, sharp scent of Dís’s perfume, a blend of mountain heather and forge smoke.
As they entered the Great Hall, the three newcomers stopped dead.
The royal table was not on a high, secluded dais. It was a massive, scarred wooden slab set right in the middle of the floor, surrounded by heavy benches. And it was currently being assaulted by a whirlwind of floral silk, gold waistcoats, and a truly staggering amount of jewelry.
A creature no taller than a Dwarf child, but with much larger, hairier feet and a face that radiated a blend of maternal fussiness and absolute authority, was scurrying around the table. He was draped in more gold than Borin had seen since waking up: rings on his fingers, a heavy Mithril-and-gold chain around his neck, and a waistcoat embroidered with threads of pure silver.
Beside him, the formidable Bombur was carrying a tray of roasted meats that could have fed a small army.
"Thorin II Oakenshield!" the small creature shouted, his voice ringing through the rafters. He didn't even look up as he slammed a bowl of mashed parsnips onto the table. "I have half a mind to let you eat the decorative garnishes and nothing else! Thirteen! I was told there were thirteen for dinner! And then your mother mentions in passing, in passing, mind you, that three more have popped out of the ether!"
Thorin, the King Under the Mountain, the slayer of beasts and reclaimers of realms, actually flinched. He sat down at the table with his head slightly bowed, his hands folded like a schoolboy.
"Bilbo, I intended to tell you," Thorin began, his voice uncharacteristically soft.
"Intended! Intended doesn't peel extra potatoes, Thorin! It doesn't stretch the gravy!" The hobbit, Bilbo, turned on his heel, his many rings catching the light. He finally noticed the three strangers standing there. His expression shifted from fury to a soft, inquisitive warmth in a heartbeat. "Oh. Well. I suppose you must be the new ones. Do come in, don't just stand there catching flies. I’m Bilbo Baggins. Sit. Eat. You look like you haven't had a decent meal in an age, which, considering you were dead, is probably a fair assessment."
Borin gaped. He looked at Thrór and Hrefna, expecting them to roar at the "halfling" for his insolence. Instead, the former King and Queen of Erebor were sitting quietly, Hrefna even going so far as to tuck her napkin into her collar with a look of wary respect. They had learned the hard way: you do not cross the Hobbit. If you did, the kitchen went cold, the tea disappeared, and every Dwarf in the mountain, from the lowest miner to the fiercest guard, would give you the "disappointed stare" for upsetting their favorite Burglar.
"What... what is it?" Borin whispered to Frerin. "Is it a very small, very wealthy child?"
"It’s a Hobbit, Uncle," Frerin murmured, his blue eyes wide with fascination. "I’ve heard of them in the old songs, but I thought they were just... stories. Why is he wearing a King's ransom in buttons?"
"Because he can," Dwalin grunted, sitting down and reaching for a leg of mutton. "And because if he doesn't wear it, Thorin keeps buying him more until he does."
Vili sat down, his eyes fixed on Bilbo. He had seen Hobbits in the Shire during his travels in the Blue Mountains, but they were usually dressed in muddy browns and greens. This one looked like he had looted a treasury and decided to wear it all at once to a tea party.
"Bilbo," Thorin said, reaching out a hand as the Hobbit bustled past him with a basket of bread.
Thorin’s hand caught Bilbo’s silk-clad waist, and the King pulled him close. The transformation was instantaneous. The hardness in Thorin’s face melted into something so tender, so utterly vulnerable, that Frerin nearly choked on his ale. Thorin pressed his forehead against Bilbo’s, his eyes closing in a moment of pure devotion.
"Thank you, ghivashel," Thorin whispered.
Bilbo sighed, his posture softening as he leaned into the King. He reached up, his small hand patting Thorin’s scarred cheek. "Yes, yes. You’re a menace and I love you. Now let go, the roast is getting cold."
The silence at the table from the newcomers was deafening.
"Wait," Frerin said, his smug grin finally faltering in sheer shock. "Thorin? Our Thorin? The one who used to practice sword forms for eighteen hours a day and refused to go to the spring festivals because 'dancing was a waste of stamina'?"
"He’s the King’s Consort," Dís said, her voice full of suppressed laughter at her brother's face. "And Thorin’s husband. They’ve been married since the reclamation."
Vili stared at his brother-in-law. He remembered Thorin as a man of stone and iron, a prince who seemed to have no room in his heart for anything but duty and vengeance. Seeing him now, looking at the Hobbit with a gaze of such raw, unshielded love, was more shocking than the dragon or the mountain's restoration.
"He found his heart," Vili whispered, a slow, kind smile spreading across his face. "In a gardener from the Shire. Well done, Thorin."
Borin, however, was still stuck on the logistics. "But... he’s so small! And he’s not a Dwarf! And he just told the King of the Longbeards that he was a 'menace'! How are we not in the middle of an execution?"
"Because Bilbo is the one who saved his life," Thráin said from his seat, his voice raspy but firm. "And ours. He is the glue that holds this madhouse together, Borin. If Thorin is the mountain’s head, Master Baggins is its heart. And you don't argue with a heart that can cook like that."
Frerin watched as Bilbo finally sat down next to Thorin, the King immediately moving to pile the best cuts of meat onto the Hobbit’s plate. Thorin didn't even notice the rest of the room; he was too busy making sure Bilbo had enough butter for his bread.
"I like him," Frerin decided, his smugness returning as he nudged Fíli. "He’s got spirit. And he’s clearly the only one who can make Thorin behave. We’re going to get along just fine."
Bilbo looked up, catching Frerin’s eye. He pointed a fork at the golden-haired prince. "And don't you think your 'pretty face' gets you out of the dishes, young man. I don't care if you just got back from the Halls of Mandos; in this house, everyone helps with the cleanup."
Frerin’s jaw dropped. He looked at Thorin, expecting a defense.
Thorin just took a sip of his ale and shrugged. "Better do what he says, Frerin. I tried to argue once. I ended up sleeping in the armory for three days."
Borin looked at the Hobbit, then at the doting King, and finally at the mountain of food. He picked up a fork, his head spinning. "I think," Borin muttered, "I’m going to need a lot more ale to understand this century."
…..
………
…..
The Great Hall was finally succumbing to the low, amber glow of dying embers. The boisterous clatter of the "reunion feast" had faded into the soft shuffling of boots on stone as the family began to drift toward the royal sleeping quarters.
Borin walked several paces behind Thráin, his head still spinning from a dinner where a Hobbit had successfully argued with a King over the proper way to zest a lemon. Vili had his arm draped firmly around Kíli’s shoulders, the two of them speaking in low, eager tones about the mechanical pulleys in the lower mines, as if trying to bridge twenty years of silence in a single night.
Frerin, however, lingered.
He watched Thorin and Bilbo at the head of the procession. Thorin walked with a slight, almost imperceptible hitch in his gait, a remnant of the pine-forest fire or perhaps the ice of Ravenhill. The King’s hand was resting on the small of Bilbo’s back, not as a gesture of possession, but as if the Hobbit were the only thing tethering him to the earth.
As they reached the junction of the main corridor, Frerin reached out and caught the sleeve of Dís’s tunic.
"Dís," he whispered, his voice uncharacteristically somber. "A moment?"
Dís stopped, signaled to Vili that she would be right behind him, and stepped into the shadow of a massive carven pillar. She looked at her younger brother, the golden prince who had died with a smile on his face at the gates of Moria. To her, he was a miracle; to him, she was a stranger wearing his sister's face.
"You’ve been quiet since we left the table, Frerin," Dís said, her voice softening. "Is it the Hobbit? I know it’s a shock, but Bilbo is-"
"It’s not the Hobbit," Frerin interrupted, shaking his head. His blue eyes searched hers, looking for the girl who used to chase him through the High Gallery. "It’s Thorin. And you. And Father."
He leaned back against the cold stone, crossing his arms. "I died at the gates, Dís. I remember the sun hitting the axe-heads. I remember the war-cries. I thought... I thought if we won, we’d go home. If we lost, we’d be honored dead." He paused, his gaze drifting to the far end of the hall where Thorin’s silhouette was disappearing into the shadows. "I didn't realize there was a third option. That you would all just... wander."
Dís felt a familiar, sharp ache in her chest. "We didn't have a choice, Frerin. Erebor was a tomb of gold and dragon fire. Moria was a graveyard. There was nowhere else to go but West."
"He looks like he’s lived three lifetimes, Dís," Frerin said, his voice cracking slightly. "I saw him at dinner. When the door slammed too hard, he didn't just look up, he reached for a sword that wasn't there. His hands... they aren't the hands of a Prince who spent his days at the harp. They’re scarred, burnt, and calloused. And the way he looks at that Hobbit... it’s like he’s afraid the world will stop existing if he blinks."
Frerin stepped closer, his youthful face twisted in a pained sort of confusion. "What happened to my brother? What happened to the Thorin who was too proud to even look at a commoner’s forge? I see a King, yes, but I see a man who has been broken and glued back together more times than I can count."
Dís sighed, reaching out to take Frerin’s hands. Her skin was rougher than his now,a testament to the decades she had spent managing a refugee camp in the Blue Mountains while Thorin worked the charcoal fires.
"The Thorin you knew died a long time ago, Frerin," she said gently. "He died in the cold of the Ered Luin. He died when he had to sell his mother’s jewelry just to buy grain so the children wouldn't starve. He died when he realized that Grandfather’s gold wasn't coming to save us."
She squeezed his hands, her eyes glistening. "He became a smith because he had to. He became a wanderer because he was looking for a home he thought was lost forever. He carried the weight of every single Dwarf who died in the wilderness on his back. By the time he reached this mountain, he wasn't just a King, he was a man who had lost everything but his honor."
Frerin looked away, his throat tight. "And the Hobbit?"
"Bilbo gave him back the things honor couldn't provide," Dís whispered. "Mercy. Laughter. The realization that a life spent only for duty is no life at all. Thorin is 'happier' now, as you say, because for sixty years, he didn't think he was allowed to be. He thought he only existed to be a shield for us."
Frerin looked down at his own hands, smooth, unscarred, the hands of a Prince who had died before the world turned grey. "I feel like a ghost, Dís. Not because I was dead, but because I don't know the man my brother has become. I don't know the sister who looks at me with so much pity."
"It isn't pity, Frerin," Dís said, stepping forward to pull him into a fierce, grounding hug. "It’s love. And you don't have to understand the many years tonight. You just have to be here. Thorin needs his brother. Not the Prince of the Golden Age, but you. He needs someone who remembers him before the world broke him."
Frerin buried his face in her shoulder, the smell of the mountain finally starting to feel like home. "I’ll try," he whispered. "But I’m still not helping with the dishes."
Dís let out a watery laugh, swiping at her eyes. "Oh, you’ll help. Bilbo will have you elbow-deep in soap suds by breakfast. Just watch."
As they broke apart and headed toward their rooms, Frerin looked one last time toward the King’s chambers. He saw a flicker of light under the door and heard the low, muffled sound of Thorin’s laughter followed by a Hobbit’s indignant huff.
The "signs of hardship" were there, in the scars, the limp, and the shadows in Thorin’s eyes, but as Frerin walked away, he realized that for the first time in his memory, the King Under the Mountain wasn't standing guard. He was simply going to sleep.
…..
………..
…….
The royal guest wing was a place of deep shadows and soft torchlight, yet to Borin, it felt like a labyrinth of ghosts. Every carving on the walls seemed too sharp, every hallway too quiet. He walked with a frantic, uneven pace until he reached the heavy oak doors assigned to Thráin and Vora.
He didn't knock. In his mind, he was still the youngest prince, and this was still the brother who had taught him how to hold a wooden training sword. He pushed the door open, his voice already forming a question. "Thráin, I’ve been thinking and-"
The words died in his throat.
The room was bathed in the low, flickering orange of a hearth fire. Thráin wasn't sitting at a desk or standing tall by a window. He was tucked into a heavy armchair, his head resting against Vora’s shoulder. Vora sat on the arm of the chair, her arms wrapped around him, her fingers tracing the jagged, pale scars on Thráin’s neck with a tenderness that looked like she was trying to knit his skin back together.
Thráin’s eyes were closed, his breathing shallow and hitching, as if even in sleep he was running from something.
Borin recoiled, his back hitting the doorframe. "Is he... is he ill? Vora, what is wrong with him? Why is he trembling?"
Vora looked up, her expression calm but weighted with a mountain of sorrow. She didn't move away from Thráin; she only pulled him closer. "He is not ill, Borin. He is remembering."
"Remembering what?" Borin stepped into the room, his hands shaking. "The battle? The skirmish where I fell? Surely that wasn't enough to... to do this to him."
Vora gestured to a stool near the fire. "Sit, Borin. You have been asking why the gold is gone and why your brother looks at the King’s crown with fear instead of pride. It is time you knew."
For the next hour, the silence of the room was broken only by Vora’s soft, steady voice and the occasional crackle of the logs. Borin sat paralyzed as she spoke of things that sounded like nightmares from the deepest pits of the world. She told him of the day the sky turned to fire, of Smaug, the Dragon, who had turned their home into a furnace.
"Erebor fell?" Borin whispered, his face ashen. "The Great Gates... the Treasury... all gone?"
"In a single afternoon," Vora replied.
But it didn't stop there. She told him of the long, starving years in the wild. She told him of the madness that took Thrór, and how Thráin had inherited a crown of nothing but dust and wandering. She told him of the Ring, the last of the Seven, and how it had gnawed at Thráin’s mind until he wandered into the shadow of Dol Guldur.
"They took him," Vora said, her voice dropping to a jagged whisper. "The Necromancer. They took his Ring, they took his mind, and they took his light. He was in the dark for decades, Borin. While you were at peace in the Halls of Mandos, your brother was a prisoner in a place where the sun never shines."
Borin looked at Thráin, his big brother, the one who was supposed to be invincible, and saw the truth in the way Thráin’s hand clutched Vora’s sleeve even in his stupor.
"And Thorin?" Borin asked, his voice a mere thread. "He... he lived through all of this?"
"He led them," Vora said. "He worked as a common smith in the Blue Mountains to keep us fed. He traded his royal pride for the life of a laborer. He watched his father disappear and his grandfather die, and then he marched back here with nothing but twelve companions and a Hobbit to face the dragon alone."
Borin felt a wave of nausea. He looked down at his own pristine, silken sleeves. He had died in a simple border skirmish, a "hero’s death" in a time of plenty. He had never known hunger. He had never known the shame of begging for work in the cities of Men. He had never known what it was like to see his King covered in soot and grease because there was no one else to do the work.
"I called him a-," Borin choked out, a sob finally breaking through. "I told him he lacked dignity. I told Thráin he was acting like a peasant."
Thráin’s eyes fluttered open then. They were cloudy, but they found Borin in the firelight. He reached out a hand, his fingers grazing Borin’s knee.
"It’s... it’s alright, little brother," Thráin rasped, his voice sounding like stone grinding on stone. "You didn't know. You are a piece of the world that was... and I am glad you are here. You remind me that there was once a time when we didn't have to be afraid."
"But everything is wrong!" Borin wailed, falling to his knees by the chair. "The gold is gone, the King is a smith, the Princess is a ledger-keeper, and the world is full of Hobbits and scars! How can you stand it? How can you look at what we’ve become and not weep?"
Thráin looked at Vora, and then back at Borin. A small, tired smile touched his lips.
"Because we are alive, Borin," Thráin said. "The gold was a weight. The pride was a cage. I would trade every gem in the Mountain's heart just to sit in this chair, with my wife's hand in mine, and hear my grandsons laughing in the hall."
Borin leaned his head against the arm of the chair, his shoulders shaking with the weight of sixty years of history he had never asked for. He realized now that he wasn't the "Prince" anymore, he was a relic. But as Vora placed a hand on his head, he felt a strange, terrifying sense of relief.
The world was broken, yes. It was messy, and poor, and strange. But as he looked at his brother, he saw that while the Prince had been destroyed, the man had finally been found.
"I don't understand it yet," Borin whispered into the fabric of the chair. "I don't think I ever will."
…
……
…
The heavy door to Thráin’s chamber clicked shut, leaving Borin alone in the flickering torchlight of the corridor. The silence of the mountain, which had once felt like a majestic velvet cloak, now felt like the weight of a cave-in. His mind was a frantic kaleidoscope of images: Thráin’s haunted eyes, the smell of the Hobbit’s strange floral tobacco, the sight of a King, his nephew, with the scarred hands of a laborer.
He felt small. For the first time since he had opened his eyes in the emerald mist, Borin didn’t feel like a Prince of the Line. He felt like a child lost in a forest where all the trees had grown tall and twisted while he slept.
Without consciously deciding where to go, his feet led him toward the larger, more ornate suite assigned to Thrór and Hrefna. In the old days, he would have straightened his tunic and practiced a formal greeting before entering. Tonight, he simply pushed the doors open and stumbled inside.
The room was vast, filled with the finery that Thorin had painstakingly recovered from the lower treasuries to appease his grandfather’s pride, but the atmosphere was brittle. Thrór was standing by a balcony, staring out at the distant lights of Dale with a look of profound displacement. Hrefna sat at a vanity, her fingers idly tangling in the long, silver strands of her hair.
"Father?" Borin’s voice cracked.
Thrór turned. The hardness in his jaw, the iron-willed King who had once demanded absolute perfection from his sons, softened just a fraction. He saw the way Borin was trembling, the way his fine silk robes seemed to swallow his slight frame.
"Borin," Thrór said, his voice unusually quiet. "You should be resting. The healers said the transition from the Halls is taxing on the spirit."
"I can't rest," Borin whispered, stepping further into the room. He looked at Hrefna, who had turned from her mirror. "I went to see Thráin. He... he told me. Or Vora did. About the dragon. About the years of begging for scraps in the mud. About the dark place where they kept him."
Hrefna stood up, the silk of her nightgown hissing against the floor. She had never been a mother of soft touches; she was a Queen who raised warriors. But seeing her youngest son looking so utterly shattered pierced through the layers of her royal armor. She reached out, taking his cold hands in hers.
"It is a heavy burden to wake up to a world that has burned, my son," she said.
"Why is Thráin so broken?" Borin asked, a tear finally escaping and tracking through the dust on his cheek. "He’s the Crown Prince. He’s supposed to be the strongest of us. But he looks at the shadows as if they’re going to reach out and grab him. And Thorin... Thorin is the King, but he acts like he’s just a guest here. He treats that Hobbit like a treasure more precious than the Arkenstone."
Thrór walked over, his heavy boots silent on the thick rugs. He placed a hand on Borin’s shoulder. It wasn't the steady, reassuring grip of a father who knew how to fix things. It was the grip of a man who was just as lost as his son.
"I do not understand it either, Borin," Thrór admitted, his voice rough with a rare honesty. "I look at this 'New Erebor' and I see a kingdom of ghosts and commoners. I see my grandson, a boy I remember playing with wooden goats, ruling with a Hobbit at his side and the dirt of the forges on his brow. It is... it is a bitter brew to swallow."
"But they seem... they seem happy," Borin sobbed, finally letting the weight of his confusion pull him down. He sank onto the edge of his parents' massive bed, burying his face in his hands. "Vora looks at Thráin like he’s a miracle, even if he can’t stand up straight. Dís looks at that miner, Vili, like he’s a god of the hearth. And Frerin... Frerin is laughing with those boys as if the world never ended."
He looked up at Thrór, his eyes red-rimmed. "Am I the only one who misses the way it was? Am I the only one who thinks we’ve lost our dignity?"
Thrór sat down beside him. The old King looked at his hands, hands that had once clutched the Arkenstone with a fever that destroyed a people. "No, Borin. You are not the only one. My heart screams for the gold-leaf and the silence of the old court. It screams for the respect that was owed to our blood."
He paused, looking toward the door where he knew his other son and grandsons were likely settled for the night.
"But then I look at Thráin," Thrór continued, his voice dropping to a whisper. "I see what my pride cost him. I see the scars on his soul that I put there by dragging him into my madness. And I realize... the 'dignity' we had was a mask. This... this chaos Thorin has built... it is honest. It is terrifyingly honest."
Hrefna sat on Borin’s other side, drawing his head down onto her shoulder. It was a gesture she hadn't made since he was a small lad in the nursery. "We are all struggling, Borin. To us, it has been only a day since we were in the old halls. To them, it has been a lifetime of agony. We are the ones who are out of step."
"I don't know how to be a Prince in this world," Borin muffled into her shoulder.
"Then do not be a Prince tonight," Hrefna whispered, stroking his hair. "Just be Borin. Be our son. We will find our way through this fog together, even if we have to learn it from a Hobbit and a smith."
Thrór didn't say anything more. He simply leaned his weight against Borin’s side, a silent acknowledgment of the fear they all shared. For a long time, the three of them sat in the dim light, the King, the Queen, and the Youngest Son, clinging to each other in a mountain that was theirs, yet felt entirely foreign.
The glory of the old world was gone, and while they didn't know how to live in the new one yet, they were, for the first time in their long lives, simply a family in the dark.
