Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warning:
Categories:
Fandom:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Series:
Part 2 of the old ways vs the new ways
Stats:
Published:
2026-02-24
Words:
9,002
Chapters:
1/1
Kudos:
348
Hits:
0

before vs after

Summary:

Thrór, his wife, Thráin and his wife are brought back to life. how? no one knows I didn't think that far so valar magic.

the spoiled royalty of old react to new erebor

Thráin's trying but man didn't have it well

Notes:

so I've realized I write Dís a bit different from other fics I've read. most have her as this badass teasing little sister of thorin and she still kinda is but also I see her being a bit spoiled. I image thorin and her being raised spoiled and strict. now obviously the dragon comes and ruins this and they have to be poor for a long time. when the get erebor back I imagine her expecting everything to go back to how she remembers it because in her mind those were the good days. not having to worry about anything. so she doesn't understand why thorin is chill with fili and kili and the company not respecting him and him just not being kingly (I definitely imagine thorin as a peoples king) she eventually learns especially after thinking back to her late husband and DEFINITELY after seeing how her mother and grandmother act. she understand now but if you go back to some of my fics with her this is why shes a bit off.

(See the end of the work for more notes.)

Work Text:

The resurgence of the Line of Durin was not heralded by a trumpet's blast, but by a chilling, emerald mist that swirled through the throne room of Erebor. When the mist cleared, the living stood face-to-face with the long-buried past.

Thorin stood frozen at the foot of the dais. Beside him, Dís gasped, her hand flying to her throat.

Standing in the center of the hall was Thrór, his once-regal robes tattered, a jagged, silvered scar tracing the line where Azog’s blade had claimed his life at the Gates of Moria. Beside him stood Thráin, looking weary and dazed, his hands twitching as if still searching for the Ring that had been torn from him in the darkness of Dol Guldur. Behind them stood the queens: Hrefna, Thorin’s grandmother, and Vora, his mother, both smelling faintly of smoke and ancient mountain air.

"Thorin?" Thráin’s voice was a raspy whisper, his eyes unfocused. "Is the shadow gone? Is the Ring...?"

"The shadow is gone, Father," Thorin said, his voice thick. He stepped forward, but his gait was different than the one his father remembered. He didn't move with the stiff, arrogant grace of a prince in exile; he moved with the heavy, grounded stride of a smith who had spent decades swinging a hammer for his bread.

….
……….
…..

The initial shock of the reunion quickly gave way to a profound, jarring cultural chasm. To the resurrected elders, Erebor had been a place of gilded perfection, where servants moved like shadows and the King’s word was law whispered from behind silk curtains.

"Thorin, my boy," Thrór grumbled, his eyes scanning the Great Hall. His goldsickness had been purged by the halls of Mahal, leaving him lucid but still possessed by an insatiable Dwarven greed for splendor. "The hall is... clean. But where is the gold? Where are the tapestries of Durin’s day? And why are you dressed like a common laborer?"

Thorin looked down at his clothes. He wore a sturdy tunic of dark grey wool and a heavy leather apron cinched at his waist. His forearms were bare, dusted with soot and scarred from the forge. Around his neck, there was no heavy gold collar, only a simple silver chain holding the key to the mountain.

"I have been working the lower forges, Grandfather," Thorin said simply. "A water pipe burst in the Third Level. The commoners' quarters were flooding."

Thrór’s jaw dropped. "You? The King? Working on plumbing?"

"We have few master smiths left, and the work needed doing," Thorin replied.

Hrefna, the grandmother, stepped toward Dís, her eyes narrowed at her granddaughter’s calloused hands. "Dís, my darling, where are your attendants? Your hair is braided with simple leather, not even a single pearl? And you smell of... is that vegetable broth?"

Dís flushed, caught between the old world and the new. "I was helping in the kitchens, Grandmother. The winter stores are being organized, and I wanted to ensure the rationing was fair for the miners’ families."

Vora, Thorin’s mother, looked horrified. "Rationing? Miners’ families? Dís, a Princess does not concern herself with the bellies of the common folk. You oversee the Court, you host the Lords, and you let the stewards handle the... the people."

….
…………
……….
….

The tension reached a boiling point when Thrór reached out to touch the crown sitting on a velvet cushion near the throne. It was not the massive, golden monstrosity he had worn. It was a delicate, masterful work of Mithril and silver.

"Silver?" Thrór hissed, the word tasting like ash. "The King Under the Mountain wears the metal of the Moon? Where is the gold, Thorin? The hoard is returned, is it not?"

"The gold stays in the vaults, or it is traded for grain and stone," Thorin said firmly, his eyes meeting his grandfather's without blinking. The old Thorin would have bowed to Thrór’s whim, but the Thorin who had spent years as a wandering blacksmith in the Blue Mountains was a different beast. "I do not wear gold. It is a heavy metal, Grandfather. It... it carries a weight I no longer wish to bear."

Thorin didn't mention the sickness, but the phantom itch in his mind was a reminder enough. He preferred silver now. It was honest. It was the metal he had worked with when he was poor, and it kept him grounded.

Thráin wandered toward a window, looking out at the rebuilt city of Dale. "Everything is so... busy," he murmured. "There are no palanquins. I see Dwarves walking in the streets. Walking! Alongside Men!"

"We work together now, Father," Dís said, stepping to his side. She looked at Thorin, her expression a mix of confusion and dawning understanding. Even she, who had been raised in the old strict ways, had been changed by the years of struggle. She still missed the silk and the servants, and she sometimes wondered why Thorin insisted on sharpening his own sword, but she saw the way the people looked at him. They didn't look at him with fear; they looked at him with love.

…..
………..
……
..

"Where are the guards?" Thrór demanded, slamming his fist onto a stone table. "We have been back for an hour and not a single servant has offered us wine! Not a single lord has come to kiss my ring!"

"The Lords are in the counting houses or the mines," Thorin said. "And the servants are paid laborers now, Grandfather. They have their own homes and their own hours. If you want wine, there is a cellar down the hall. I will show you how to use the tap."

Vora let out a faint cry of distress and sank into a chair. "How did this happen? How did my son, the pride of the House of Durin, become a... a-”

"The dragon took our gold, Mother," Thorin said softly, his voice echoing in the vast, stone hall. "But the poverty gave us back our souls. I will not go back to being a King who hides behind gold while his people starve."

Dís watched her mother and grandmother, feeling a strange sense of vertigo. She remembered the perfection they demanded, the way she had been taught to never raise her voice, to never touch dirt, to always be a silent, shimmering ornament of the line. She looked at her brother, who was currently wiping grease from his hands onto a rag, and realized that the "perfect" royalty of her youth had been a hollow shell.

But even she found herself wondering: Thorin, must you truly do everything? Surely a King can at least have someone else carry his tools?

…
…….
….

The emerald mist had retreated, leaving the air in the royal apartments heavy with the scent of damp stone and ancient history. While Thrór paced the halls, measuring the silver content of the new chandeliers, the three women of the House of Durin retreated to a private solar.

The room was functional, sturdy oak chairs and woolen rugs, a far cry from the velvet-draped sanctuaries the Queens remembered. Hrefna and Vora sat stiffly, their eyes scanning Dís as if she were a puzzle with missing pieces.

…
………..
…….
…

"Dís," Vora began, her voice trembling with the fragile authority of a mother who had lost everything to fire. "Explain your brother to us. He looks at the Lords as if they are hindrances and looks at the coal-porters as if they are brothers. He wears silver and works with his sleeves rolled up like a common apprentice. What has happened to the dignity of our line?"

Dís sat across from them, her hands resting on the table. Her palms were calloused, a sight that made Hrefna flinch.

"You did not see the aftermath of the fire," Dís said softly. "You died in the heat of the dragon’s breath. We survived in the cold of the world outside. When the dragon took the mountain, he took our status with it. To the Men of the North and the Elves of the Wood, we were not 'The Line of Durin.' We were just more beggars in the mud."

"But the Blue Mountains!" Hrefna insisted. "Surely, once you reached our kinsmen there, you were restored?"

"We were welcomed, but the Blue Mountains were poor," Dís replied, her gaze hardening. "There were no thrones waiting for us. Thorin... Thorin did not want me to see the worst of it. He took the heaviest burdens. He worked in human forges, pounding iron for farmers' plows just to buy a sack of grain. He sent every coin back to keep me in a house with a roof."

Dís paused, a flicker of guilt crossing her face. "He shielded me. Even in our poverty, Thorin ensured I had 'easy' jobs, overseeing the weaving guilds or managing the scrolls. I am a Princess of the Longbeards, and I can swing an axe with the best of them, but I admit... compared to Thorin, I have been spoiled. He did the work of ten men so I could still feel like a Lady, even if my 'palace' was a three-room cottage in the rain."

"But he is King now!" Vora cried. "The gold is back! Why does he persist in this... this humility?"

"Because he remembers the hunger," Dís snapped, her voice cracking. "He does not trust the gold anymore. He trusts the strength of his own hands and the loyalty of the people who bled with him when we had nothing. He cares more for the poor because he was the poor for sixty years."

The two Queens exchanged horrified looks. "And what of your own life, Dís?" Hrefna asked, leaning in. "Did Thorin find you a suitable match among the noble houses of the Ered Luin? Is there a Lord Consort we have yet to meet?"

Dís let out a short, bittersweet laugh. "There was no Lord. I married a smith. A commoner named Vili."

Vora gasped, clutching her silk-draped chest. "A commoner? Dís, you are the daughter of Kings! To dilute the bloodline with a-"

"He was the finest man I ever knew," Dís interrupted, her eyes flashing with a warning that made her mother recoil. "Thorin was furious at first, but Vili... Vili was the one who truly grounded me. While Thorin was busy being a martyr, Vili taught me that a Princess is only as good as the service she provides to her people. He taught me that there is more honor in a well-made horseshoe than in a stolen crown. He helped me lose the arrogance I was born with."

The Queens were silent for a long moment, processing the "degradation" of their royal standards.

"Is he... is he here?" Vora asked tentatively.

"He died in the mines years ago," Dís said, her voice softening. "But he left me with two sons."

The Queens sat bolt upright. "Sons?" Hrefna breathed. "Grandsons? The line continues through you?"

"Fíli and Kíli," Dís said, a proud smile finally touching her lips. "They are the Princes of Erebor. They are the heirs to the throne."

"And were they raised with the strictness of the court?" Vora asked, her hope returning. "Are they the perfect, calm examples of Dwarven royalty? Do they understand the weight of their names?"

Dís looked toward the door, hearing a distant sound that she recognized all too well, the sound of a bucket of water being precariously balanced over a doorway and the muffled, wheezing giggles of two young Dwarves.

"They are... unique," Dís said carefully. "They were raised in the Blue Mountains, in the dirt and the wind. They are chaotic, they are tricksters, and they have absolutely no regard for 'strict morals' or the 'dignity' of their station. They take after their father in spirit and Thorin in heart."

"We must see them," Hrefna declared, standing up. "We must begin their training at once. If Thorin has gone 'stray,' we shall fix the grandsons."

Dís stood as well, looking at her grandmother with a mix of pity and amusement. "I wish you luck, Grandmother.”

….
………….
…..
.
The halls of Erebor were usually a place of stoic industry, but today they echoed with the frantic, wet slapping of boots against stone and the high-pitched, wheezing laughter of two young Dwarves in full flight.

Balin appeared around the corner, his face a bright, alarming shade of crimson, waving a stack of parchment. "Return here this instant! You cannot skip the history of the Third Age simply because the sun is out!"

Fíli and Kíli did not return. They banked around the corner of the royal wing, nearly skidding into a group of Dwarves who looked as though they had been carved from a different era.

The "Old Royalty" stood like statues. Thrór, Hrefna, and Vora were dressed in heavy silks and stiff, high-collared robes, looking down with icy disdain at the chaos before them. Only Thráin stood slightly apart, his eyes wide and curious.

Fíli skidded to a halt, nearly tripping over the hem of a tunic that was clearly three sizes too large for him. It was one of Thorin’s formal regal surcoats, midnight blue silk with silver embroidery, but it was currently stained with mud at the hem and grease on the sleeves.

"Easy, Kíli!" Fíli panted, grinning as he adjusted the oversized collar. "I think we lost the old badger."

"Whom," Hrefna whispered, her voice like a chilling wind, "are you calling a 'badger'?"

The boys froze. They looked at the four strangers. Kíli’s hair was a wild, chestnut mess, entirely loose and cascading over his shoulders without a single formal braid. Worse still, his face was practically smooth save for a light dusting of dark stubble, a "lack of beard" that in the old court would have been seen as a mark of illness or exile.

"Uh," Kíli said, his tail-end of laughter dying in his throat. "Hello. Are you... lost? The tour for the visiting dignitaries isn't until the afternoon."

…..
…………
…….
.

Vora, stepped forward, her face contorting in a mask of pure agony. She looked at Fíli, who was wearing the King’s sacred vestments as if they were a common rag.

"You," she breathed, pointing a trembling finger at Fíli. "You wear the royal sigils of Durin while covered in the filth of the training pits? And you," she turned to Kíli, looking as if she might faint, "your face is as bare as a stone-troll’s! Your hair is unbound! Where is your dignity? Where are your braids?"

"My hair gets caught in my bowstring if I braid it too tight," Kíli said, sounding genuinely confused. "And I’m a Prince. I don't need a beard to tell people who my uncle is."

"PRINCES?" Thrór roared, the sound echoing off the vaulted ceiling. "These... these urchins? These chaotic, disheveled children are the heirs to my throne?"

Balin finally caught up, leaning against the wall to catch his breath. "Ah... I see you’ve met the terrors of the mountain. Fíli, Kíli, these are... well, they are your Great-Grandparents. And your Grandfather, Thráin."

The boys went quiet, their eyes darting between the stiff, judgmental elders. For the first time, they looked small, not out of fear, but out of a sudden, sharp realization that these people represented the world their mother had described as a "golden cage."

Thorin and Dís arrived a moment later, having heard the commotion. Thorin’s face was set in a hard line, ready to defend his nephews, but he stopped when he saw his father, Thráin.

Thráin wasn't looking at the mud on Fíli’s stolen tunic. He wasn't looking at Kíli’s smooth chin. He was looking at their eyes. He saw the spark of mischief, the lack of fear, and the way they stood close to one another, not as a formal unit of state, but as brothers who genuinely liked each other.

Thráin stepped past the fuming Thrór and the sobbing Queens. He reached out a weathered, scarred hand and gently touched Fíli’s shoulder, then Kíli’s messy hair.

"Father, I can explain," Thorin began, his voice defensive. "They were raised in the Blue Mountains. We had no time for the 'correct' etiquette of-"

"No," Thráin interrupted, his voice thick with emotion. He turned to Thorin and Dís, a sad, beautiful smile breaking through his weary features. "They are magnificent."

Thrór scoffed. "Magnificent? Thráin, they are a disgrace to our customs!"

"They are what I wanted for you," Thráin said, looking directly at Thorin and Dís. "When we were in the height of our power, I was only a Prince. I wanted to let you run through the halls. I wanted to let you play in the dirt and learn the names of the commoners. But your Grandfather... the Court... the 'Correct Way' was a cold, hard master. I was pressured to turn you into statues before you were even men."

Thráin looked back at Fíli and Kíli, who were watching him with wide, soft eyes.

"You have raised them in the light, Thorin. Dís," Thráin whispered. "They know who they are because they have been allowed to be themselves, not just symbols of a crown. They are Princes of the people, not Princes of the counting-house. You have done what I was too weak to do."

Thorin exhaled a breath he seemed to have been holding for decades. He walked over, placing a hand on Kíli’s head and another on Fíli’s shoulder.

"They know their history, Grandfather," Thorin said, looking at Thrór with a steady, defiant gaze. "They know how to lead a charge, how to judge a trade dispute, and how to hold a line in the dark. But they also know how to laugh with a miner and how to fix a broken wagon. I have taught them that a crown is a heavy thing, so they must have light hearts to carry it."

Fíli stood a little taller, even in his stolen, muddy tunic. Kíli didn't try to hide his smooth face. They looked at the old royalty not with the "calm, perfect" masks of the past, but with the honest, rugged dignity of the present.

"Now," Thorin said, his voice dropping into a playful growl as he looked at Fíli. "Take off my surcoat before you ruin the silver-work entirely. And Balin?"

"Yes, Thorin?"

“Let them go, we both know your not catching them anyways. They will just have to suffer more tommorow”
…
………..
……

The following afternoon, Balin led the resurrected elders through the Lower Markets. To Thrór and the Queens, the market was supposed to be a place of quiet, orderly transactions where commoners bowed as the royal carriage passed. Instead, they found a riot of color, the smell of roasting meats, and a King’s kin walking on foot through the grime.

"Where is the herald?" Hrefna asked, lifting her silk skirts to avoid a stray puddle. "How are the people to know their betters are among them without a trumpet's call?"

"The people of Erebor know who we are, My Queen," Balin said, his voice patient but firm. "They simply have work to do."

As they rounded the corner into the Goldsmith’s Quarter, the old royalty stopped dead. There, standing amidst a crowd of cheering miners and laughing merchants, was a figure that finally looked like the royalty they remembered, and yet, he was entirely different.

Bilbo Baggins was a shimmering vision. Unlike Thorin, who dressed like a smith, or the Princes, who dressed like ruffians, Bilbo was draped in the wealth of a kingdom.

He wore a velvet coat of deep emerald, but it was nearly obscured by the sheer amount of jewelry pinned to it. Diamonds glittered in his auburn-gold curls, which had grown long and lush; sapphires hung from his ears, and silver chains draped across his chest. Even his long, tufted tail was adorned with small, braided gold rings and a dangling ruby at the tip.

"Finally!" Vora exhaled, clutching her chest. "A true royal. Look at the poise! Look at the wealth! Who is this lord? An Elven prince? A Southron ambassador?"

"That," Balin said, a proud smile tugging at his beard, "is Bilbo Baggins. The Consort of the Mountain. Thorin’s husband."

The silence from the elders was deafening. Thrór looked as if he’d swallowed a piece of coal. Thráin, however, let out a soft, delighted chuckle. "Thorin? Married? My son, who claimed his only bride would be his forge? He has done well. The lad has a spark about him."

Bilbo noticed them and began to weave through the crowd. He didn't glide; he marched with the purposeful stride of a Hobbit who had a very long to-do list.

"Balin! There you are," Bilbo chirped, ignoring the stunned stares of the ancient Kings. "Tell the Quartermaster if I see one more shipment of stale flour, I shall personally toss him into the running stream. It’s an insult to the Baker’s Guild!"

He turned his vast blue eyes toward the elders. "And who are these? More relatives? Honestly, Thorin’s family tree is starting to look like an overgrown bramble."

"Bilbo," Balin coughed, "these are Thorin’s grandparents and his parents."

Bilbo didn't bow. He didn't even pause. "Right, the ones from the green mist. Lovely. I’m Bilbo. Don't mind the rocks," he gestured vaguely to the thousands of gold coins worth of gems on his person. "I’m currently a walking treasury because your grandsons and half the city can't stop 'gifting' things to me, and apparently, it’s 'rude' to say no."

"You... you are the Consort?" Hrefna asked, her voice trembling. She looked at his magnificent clothes. "At least you understand the necessity of the station. It must be exhausting, having to endure the commoners without your servants to buffer the smell."

Bilbo’s expression shifted from casual annoyance to genuine disgust. "Servants? To buffer the people? My dear lady, I am a member of the Baker’s Guild and the Scribe’s Circle. I spend half my morning elbow-deep in dough and the other half covered in ink. If I had a servant to do my work, I’d die of boredom or sheer uselessness."

The Queens gasped. They had assumed the jewels were a sign of his superiority.

"He wears the gems because he’s too polite to refuse a gift from a child or a lonely miner," Balin whispered to them. "He’d give it all back in a heartbeat if it wouldn't break the givers' hearts."

The elders watched in stunned silence as Bilbo continued through the market. He had no guards. He walked right up to a soot-covered charcoal burner and asked after his daughter’s fever. He handed a small, honey-glazed cake to a street urchin, ruffling the boy’s hair. He knew names. He knew who was struggling with rent and who had a new litter of puppies.

The citizens didn't bow in fear; they brightened. They reached out to touch his sleeve, offering him small trinkets or words of thanks.

"They... they love him," Thráin whispered, watching a group of hardened warriors melt into smiles as Bilbo scolded them for not wearing their scarves in the drafty tunnels. "I have never seen a people love a consort like this. Not in all the days of the old gold."

Suddenly, a dark, broad-shouldered figure appeared from the shadows of a nearby pillar, moving with a suspicious lack of regal dignity.

Thorin was sneaking. He had his hood up, trying to bypass a group of councilors, but the moment he spotted the shimmering, jeweled Hobbit, his entire demeanor changed. He abandoned his "stealth" and practically lunged for Bilbo, wrapping his arms around the Hobbit’s waist from behind and burying his face in the crook of Bilbo’s neck.

"Found you," Thorin rumbled, sounding entirely too pleased for a King who was supposed to be at a budget meeting.

"Thorin! Let go, you big oaf, you’re squashing the brooch the stonemasons gave me!" Bilbo huffed, though he leaned back into the embrace, his tail coiling affectionately around Thorin’s leg.

"I have three lords waiting to argue about bridge tolls," Thorin muffled into Bilbo’s curls. "I’m staying here. You smell like cinnamon and sanity."

The old royalty stared. Thrór looked horrified by the "clinging" nature of his grandson, but Thráin looked at the way Thorin’s hands held Bilbo, not as a possession, but as a lifeline.

"He isn't just a consort, is he?" Thráin asked Balin.

"No, My King," Balin replied softly. "He is the heart of the mountain. And as you can see, our Thorin is quite helpless against him."

Bilbo patted Thorin’s cheek. "If you stay, you have to help me hand out these meat pies. And if I see you scowl at a single merchant, you’re sleeping in the guest wing."

The King Under the Mountain, the man who had faced a dragon and a war, simply nodded, took a basket of pies, and followed his Hobbit into the crowd.

…..
……………
………….
……

The atmosphere in the royal wing was thick enough to choke a dragon. Thrór and the two Queens, Hrefna and Vora, marched toward the dining hall with a stiffness that suggested they were trying to hold the very walls of the mountain together by sheer force of will.

"Public displays of affection in the marketplace," Hrefna hissed, her hands tucked sharply into her silk sleeves. "A Consort who smells of yeast and speaks like a tavern-keep. Thráin, say something!"

Thráin did not say something. He walked a few paces behind them, looking profoundly tired. His eyes were not on the stone ceiling or the lack of gold-leaf; they were distant, haunted by the memories of the pits of Dol Guldur. He looked like a man who had seen the end of the world and found the current complaints about "decorum" to be remarkably small.

"We shall set the standard at dinner," Thrór declared, his scar-lined neck flushing red. "A formal meal. Dignity. Order."

They pushed open the heavy oak doors to the dining hall, expecting a silent, candle-lit room with servants waiting in the shadows. Instead, they walked into a riot.

The long stone table was crowded. The Company of Thorin Oakenshield was already there, and they weren't waiting for a royal decree to start. Bofur was mid-song, Glóin was arguing with Nori over a plate of sausages, and Bombur was effectively a one-man whirlwind of consumption.

"What is the meaning of this?" Thrór thundered, his voice echoing off the vaulted ceiling. "Why are these... these miners at the High Table?"

Kíli, who was sitting next to Fíli, let out a loud snort. "We're not miners today, Grandfather! We're the guys who didn't get eaten by Trolls. Pass the gravy, Bofur!"

"Kíli, you’ve got sauce on your ear," Fíli remarked.

"Your face is sauce!" Kíli shot back.

Bifur, sitting across from them, didn't say a word. He simply reached out with a heavy, calloused hand and delivered a sharp, echoing smack to the back of Kíli’s head. The Prince yelped, nearly face-planting into his mashed parsnips, while Bifur grunted a series of ancient Khuzdul curses and went back to his soup.

Thrór’s eyes landed on the older members of the group, the ones who had been alive when he reigned. Dori, Óin, Bifur, and Balin. He straightened his back, expecting them to lead the others in a formal bow.

Instead, Dori looked up from his tea, gave Thrór a look of profound annoyance, and went back to straightening Ori’s collar. Óin didn't even look up; he was busy poking at a piece of chicken with a medicinal probe, muttering about its protein content.

They remembered. They remembered the King who had sat upon a throne of gold while the shadow grew. They remembered the pride that had invited the fire.

"Dori!" Thrór barked. "You were of the House of Ori. You knew the protocols! Command these boys to stand!"

Dori set his cup down with a deliberate clink. "My King," he said, the title sounding more like a weary acknowledgement than an honorific. "I spent sixty years in the Blue Mountains knitting wool and carrying charcoal. I saw your grandson work himself to the bone to keep us from starving while your 'protocols' lay buried in a dragon’s belly. I’m quite comfortable sitting, thank you."

"He’s gotten grumpier with age, hasn't he?" Óin yelled into his ear-trumpet, pointing it directly at Thrór. "Must be the scar! Does it itch? I’ve got a salve for that, though it smells like wet dog!"

Dís walked in, looking like she wanted to turn around and walk right back out. She slumped into her chair at the head of the table, not waiting for a servant to pull it out for her.

"Dís!" Vora whispered, leaning in. "This is anarchy! These commoners are laying hands on the Princes! They are insulting your Grandfather!"

"They aren't commoners, Mother," Dís sighed, rubbing her temples. "They are the Company. They saw Thorin covered in Orc blood and pine-sap. They saw him at his absolute lowest, crying over a map in the dirt. You cannot demand 'royal respect' from people who have seen the King vomit from exhaustion. I was outraged for the first year, too, but eventually, you realize that a bow doesn't keep the cold out. These Dwarves would die for Thorin, but they won't stand for his Grandfather just because he’s wearing a fancy robe."

Only Thráin received a different treatment. As he took his seat, the table grew marginally quieter. Balin offered him a respectful nod, and even Bifur stopped his aggressive soup-eating to incline his head.

They didn't respect the Crown he wore; they respected the man who had been broken by a Necromancer and had still tried to find his way home.

Thráin looked at Thorin, who was currently sitting at the center of the chaos, laughing as Bilbo (still draped in his jewels) tried to prevent Fíli from stealing a whole loaf of bread. Thorin looked... happy. He looked like a man who didn't have to pretend to be a god.

Thráin reached out and patted Dís’s hand. "They raised them well, Dís," he murmured, loud enough for the old Queens to hear. "They are loud, and they are messy, and they are entirely lacking in the 'correct' virtues. But they are alive. We were never this alive, were we?"

Thrór let out a huff of indignation, but he found himself silenced when Dori leaned over and aggressively offered him a plate of broccoli.

"Eat your greens, Thrór," Dori grumbled. "You look peaky. And don't look at me like that—I’ve raised three brothers and two Princes; a resurrected King doesn't scare me one bit."

….
………..
………………
………
…..

The lanterns in the royal guest wing flickered with a low, blue flame, casting long shadows against the cold stone walls. The air here was silent, a stark contrast to the boisterous, chaotic dinner they had just endured. Thrór and Hrefna had already retired to their chambers, their muffled grumbling about "disrespectful bakers" and "shameless hobbits" finally fading behind a heavy oak door.

In the adjoining room, Vora stood by the window, her silk robes whispering against the floor. Her mind was a whirlwind of indignation. She had expected to return to a world of gold and reverence; instead, she had found a son who smelled of soot and a kingdom that felt more like a rowdy tavern than a seat of power.

She turned to speak to her husband, but the words died in her throat.

Thráin was standing by the bed, his back turned to her as he removed his heavy traveling tunic. For the first time since their resurrection, the flickering light hit him clearly. Vora gasped, her hand flying to her mouth.

His back was a map of agony. Great, jagged puckers of scar tissue ran from his shoulders to his waist, the marks of the whip, the brand, and things far worse. The skin was translucent and tight, a ghostly reminder of the dungeons of Dol Guldur. When he turned slightly, she saw the "slight crazy" in his eyes, a distant, fractured look that suggested he was seeing a world she could not perceive.

"Thráin," she whispered, her voice trembling. "My love... what did they do to you?"

He didn't answer at first. He simply climbed into the bed, his movements slow and mechanical. He stared at the ceiling with those haunted eyes, his jaw set in a rigid line.

For hours, they lay in the dark. Vora could hear the grandfather's rhythmic snoring through the wall, but beside her, Thráin was as still as a tomb.

"Talk to me," Vora pleaded, turning on her side to face him. "Since we returned, you have been a ghost in your own skin. Thorin and Dís... they have changed, yes. But you... you are hollowed out. Tell me what happened after the dragon. Tell me what happened in the dark."

Thráin’s breath hitched. He had been trained from the cradle to be a Prince of the Longbeards, to be a mountain of stone that never cracked. Silence was his armor; dignity was his shield.

"I was a King in a cage, Vora," he finally rasped, the words sounding like grinding gravel. "And before that, I was a Prince in a golden cage."

The dam broke. Perhaps it was the sight of Thorin’s happiness, or the freedom he saw in his grandsons, but the words began to pour out of him in a desperate, weeping torrent.

"I was a puppet, Vora," he choked out, the first tear tracing a path through the grime of his soul. "My entire life... a scripted play. Every word I spoke, every braid in my hair, every law I signed, it was all for the 'Dignity of the Line.' My father’s shadow was so long I never felt the sun."

He began to sob, his chest heaving. "I am weak. I have always been weak. I did nothing the way I truly wanted. I wanted to be a builder, not a King. I wanted to walk the low roads, but I was kept on a dais."

He looked at her with a raw, heartbreaking intensity. "The only thing... the only choice I ever truly made for myself was you. I loved you before I knew what duty was." His voice cracked.

Vora reached out to touch his face, her heart breaking. "Thráin..."

"But even you changed," he whispered, a fresh wave of grief hitting him. "After the wedding... the court took you. You became just another jewel in the hoard. You became a Queen of rules and cold perfection, and I lost my wife to the very crown I hated."

Vora felt the words like physical blows, but it was his next admission that froze the blood in her veins.

Thráin looked toward the adjoining wall where his father, Thrór, slept. His face twisted into a mask of pure, unadulterated loathing.

"I cannot look at him," Thráin hissed, his eyes wide and wild. "I look at my father and I see the death of my heart. He calls for respect, but he gave none to his own blood. Do you know why Frerin is not here, Vora? Do you know why our middle son did not survive the gates of Moria?"

Vora went pale. "He... he fell in battle. Thorin said the fighting was fierce-"

"He fell because my father was obsessed!" Thráin shrieked in a hushed, jagged whisper. "Thrór’s pride, his madness for Moria... he threw our boy into the vanguard. Frerin wasn't a warrior; he was a dreamer. But my father demanded 'glory' for the line. He sent Frerin to a slaughter he didn't understand, and for what? For a pile of old rocks and a crown he couldn't even keep. My father killed our son, Vora. He killed him as surely as if he’d put the axe to his neck himself."

Vora sat back on her heels, the world spinning. Her second son. Her gentle, quiet Frerin. She had spent decades believing it was a tragic necessity of war, only to find it was a sacrifice on the altar of her father-in-law's ego.

…

Vora sat in the silence that followed, her world tilting on its axis. She had spent the day mourning the loss of "dignity" and "respect," while her husband had been mourning the loss of a son she hadn't even known was sacrificed to his grandfather's ego.

Thráin’s energy vanished as quickly as it had come. He collapsed back against the pillows, the fire in his eyes fading into a dull, exhausted ache. He talked until his voice failed, mourning the life he never led and the children he hadn't known how to protect.

Eventually, the weight of the confession and the lingering trauma of his death pulled him into a deep, heavy sleep.

Vora remained awake. She sat in the darkness, listening to the steady breathing of the man beside her and the distant, arrogant snoring of Thrór in the next room. For the first time, she looked at the heavy silks she wore and felt as though she were dressed in lead.

She thought of Thorin, who wore silver and worked with the poor. She thought of Fíli and Kíli, who laughed and played pranks. She finally understood. They weren't "disgraceful", they were free. They were everything Thráin had been denied.

Slowly, Vora crawled into the bed. She didn't maintain the "proper" distance expected of a Royal Consort. She reached out and pulled Thráin close, tucking his head against her shoulder and wrapping her arms around his scarred torso.

She held him with the fierce, protective grip of the girl she had been when they were courting in the gardens of the old Erebor, before the gold, before the dragon, and before the "Correct Way" had nearly unmade them both.

….
……….
……………………
………………
…..

The morning light filtered through the stone carvings of the guest wing, but the Queen who emerged was not the same woman who had entered the night before. Vora moved with a quiet, sharp-eyed determination. She didn't seek out a servant; she didn't wait for a herald. She walked straight to the quarters of the House of Ori, looking for the one Dwarf who seemed to understand the fabric of a person as well as the fabric of a coat.

She found Dori in a small sun-lit room, surrounded by spools of fine wool and silk, meticulously mending a pair of Kíli’s trousers. He looked up, his spectacles sliding down his nose, surprised to see the Old Queen standing in his doorway without an entourage.

"My Queen," Dori began, starting to rise. "If you require a fitting, I can come to your-"

"Sit, Master Dori," Vora said, her voice softer than it had ever been. She stepped into the room and closed the door. "I am not here for a royal gown. I am here for my husband."

Dori paused, his needle hovering in the air. "King Thráin? What does he require?"

"Freedom," Vora whispered. She took a breath, her fingers twisting in the expensive, stifling silk of her own sleeve. "He spent his life in stiff velvet and heavy gold collars. Last night... last night I saw the cost of that weight. I want you to make him clothes like a master builder would wear. Sturdy linens, soft wool that doesn't scratch, and breeches that allow him to move. He once told me, long ago, that he hated the feel of silk against his skin. I want him to never have to wear it again."

Dori watched her closely, his sharp eyes softening. "And for yourself, My Lady?"

Vora looked down at her hands. "I was the daughter of a minor Lord of the Iron Hills before I married. I used to wear simple tunics and sturdy boots for riding. I want something... something like that. No corsets. No trailing skirts. I want to be able to walk beside my husband, not six paces behind him."

Dori set his work aside. "That is a sudden shift in tune, if I may say so, My Queen. Your father-in-law will have much to say about 'lowering' the royal standards."

Vora looked back toward the hallway where Thráin was still sleeping, likely the first peaceful sleep he’d had in a century. "I’ve been thinking, Master Dori. I’ve been thinking about what it means to be a Queen of a graveyard versus a wife to a living man. I choose the latter."

..
……..
….

After leaving Dori with a list of measurements and a sense of purpose, Vora made her way to the royal gardens. She found Bilbo there, sitting on a bench with his jeweled tail tucked neatly beside him, writing in a large leather-bound book.

He looked up as the Queen approached. He didn't stand, but he did offer a small, polite nod. "Morning, Vora. If you’re here to complain about the breakfast sausages again, you’ll have to take it up with Bombur."

Vora didn't snap back. Instead, she sat on the edge of the bench, looking remarkably small in her heavy, golden-era robes.

"I am not here to complain about the sausages, Master Baggins," she said. She looked at him, really looked at him,and saw the way he sat so comfortably in his own skin, despite being draped in enough gems to buy a small city. "I am here because... I do not know how to help him."

Bilbo closed his book, his expression shifting to one of genuine curiosity. "Help who? Thráin?"

"He is broken," Vora said, her voice cracking. "The Necromancer... the loss of his son... the shadow of his father. He has spent his whole life trying to be 'Perfect,' and it has left him with nothing but scars. I saw the way Thorin looks at you. I saw the way the people look at you. You helped Thorin find peace when he was just as broken. How? How do I help a man who has forgotten how to choose for himself?"

…..
…………
…….

Bilbo leaned back, his auburn-gold curls catching the light. He reached out and gently patted Vora’s hand, a gesture that would have been a scandal twenty-four hours ago.

"You’ve already started," Bilbo said softly. "You’re asking. That’s more than anyone ever did for Thráin in the old days, I’ll wager."

"But what do I do?"

"You stop being a Queen," Bilbo said bluntly. "Thorin didn't need a Consort who sat on a throne and told him how grand he was. He needed someone who would tell him when he was being a stubborn idiot. He needed someone to make him tea and remind him that the world doesn't end if a braid is crooked."

Bilbo looked out at the mountain peaks. "Thráin has spent his life being a symbol. He doesn't need a symbol for a wife. He needs a partner. Take him to the lower levels. Show him the forges, not the royal ones, the busy ones. Let him get soot on his face. And most importantly..." Bilbo smiled, a mischievous glint in his eye. "When Thrór starts shouting about 'dignity' and 'tradition,' you stand in front of your husband and tell the old King to go sit in a corner."

Vora let out a startled, watery laugh. "I don't think I’ve ever told Thrór to sit in a corner."

"Well," Bilbo shrugged, "there’s a first time for everything. It’s remarkably cathartic. If you’re going to help Thráin find his voice, you have to find yours first."

Vora stood up, squaring her shoulders. The weight of the silk still felt heavy, but the weight in her chest felt lighter. "Thank you, Master Baggins. I believe I understand why my son chose you."

"Oh, he didn't choose me," Bilbo joked, picking up his pen again. "I’m just the only one who doesn't get intimidated when he grumps. Now, go see Dori. I think I saw him pulling out some very nice, un-royal charcoal-grey linen just for you."
….
………..
……..
….

The royal kitchens were usually a sanctuary of controlled chaos under Bombur’s command, but this morning, a strange silence had fallen over the prep stations. The sous-chefs stood back, whispering, as they watched a figure who looked nothing like the Queen of the Golden Age.

Thorin and Dís entered the room, both dressed in their usual practical gear, stopping dead at the sight.

Standing by the central wooden table was Vora. She had shed the stifling, gold-threaded silks of her youth. In their place, she wore a simple, sturdy tunic of dusty pink linen and dark trousers, clothes Dori must have worked through the night to finish. Her sleeves were rolled up past her elbows, and her hair was tied back in a messy, functional knot.

Most shocking of all, her hands were covered in flour.

"Mother?" Thorin asked, his voice cracking with a vulnerability he usually reserved only for Bilbo.

Vora looked up, a smudge of white powder on her cheek. She looked younger, somehow, fresher, despite the fatigue under her eyes. "Thorin. Dís. I... I am trying to remember the recipe for honeyed oat-cakes. The ones with the wild berries from the Iron Hills. Your father used to love them before... before the world became so heavy."

Dís stepped forward, her eyes shimmering. "You’ve never cooked, Mother. Not once in our lifetimes. There were always twenty servants between you and a stove."

"I know," Vora said, her voice small as she looked down at the sticky dough. "The crown changed me before you were even born. I forgot that I used to like the smell of yeast. I forgot that I used to be a person who could do things for herself." She looked at her children, her expression raw. "I want to be a wife today. Just a wife."

Thorin moved to her side, his large, calloused hand reaching out to steady the bowl she was struggling with. He didn't mock her; he simply adjusted her grip. "Add a bit more milk, Mother. It’s too dry. Like the clay in the Ered Luin."

For a moment, the three of them stood in the flour-dusted light, not a King, a Princess, and a Queen, but a family.

An hour later, the dusty pink tunic was dusted with flour and a few berry stains, but Vora didn't care. She carried a tray into the guest suite, where the heavy curtains were still drawn.

Thráin stirred as the scent of warm honey and toasted oats hit his senses. He blinked, squinting at the figure sitting on the edge of the bed. For a moment, his mind, still fractured by the darkness of the dungeons, thought he was dreaming of his youth.

"Vora?" he croaked, sitting up.

"I made you breakfast," she said softly.

Thráin’s eyes trailed down. He saw the simple pink linen. He saw the flour on her arms. He saw that she wasn't wearing a single jewel, not even a ring. She looked like the girl he had met in the mountain gardens, the one who wasn't afraid to get dirt under her fingernails.

"Your clothes..." he whispered, reaching out to touch the soft, humble fabric of her sleeve. "You look... like yourself."

"I got them made," she replied, her voice thick with emotion. "And I got these for you."

She gestured to the foot of the bed. Dori had delivered. No more stiff velvet or ceremonial robes. There sat a tunic of soft, charcoal-grey wool, sturdy trousers, and a pair of boots that didn't have gold buckles. They were clothes for a man who wanted to walk, to build, to live.

Thráin looked at the clothes, then back at his wife. A sob escaped his chest, not one of pain, but of a man finally being allowed to breathe.

"I don't have to be the Prince today?" he asked, his voice trembling.

"No," Vora said, leaning forward and pressing her forehead against his. "Today, you are just Thráin. And I am just Vora. And we are going to go for a walk in the gardens, and if your father has anything to say about it, I shall tell him exactly where he can put his 'Correct Way'."

Thráin let out a wet, shaky laugh, the first sound of real joy Vora had heard from him since the dragon came. He reached for a honey-cake, his scarred fingers trembling, and as he took a bite, the ghosts of Dol Guldur seemed to recede just a little further into the light.

..
…….
…
The gardens of Erebor had been transformed since the reclamation. No longer were they the stiff, manicured terraces of the old days; they were now a wild, fragrant sprawl of herbs, Shire-flowers brought by Bilbo, and sturdy mountain shrubs.

In a secluded corner, bathed in the soft morning sun, Thráin and Vora sat on a stone bench. Thráin was dressed in his new, soft charcoal wool, his head resting heavily on Vora’s shoulder. Vora, in her dusty pink linen, held him with a fierce, unyielding tenderness, her hand stroking his hair—not with the practiced grace of a Queen, but with the desperate love of a wife who had found her husband again in the dark.

..
…..
…

 

The peace was shattered by the sound of clicking heels and a sharp, indrawn breath. Thrór and Hrefna appeared at the end of the gravel path, both dressed in their heavy, suffocating gold-and-crimson robes.

Thrór stopped so abruptly he nearly tripped. His eyes bulged as he looked at his son, the heir to Durin’s line, dressed like a commoner and clinging to his wife in a public space.

"Thráin!" Thrór’s voice boomed, echoing off the garden walls. "Vora! What is the meaning of this... this dishevelment? And have you no shame? Cuddling like tavern-folk in the open air?"

Hrefna looked as though she might faint. Her hands flew to her throat, clutching her heavy emerald necklace. "Vora, your dress... it’s pink. Plain, dusty pink. And you have smudges on your face. Where are your attendants? Where is your dignity?"

Vora didn't move. She didn't pull away. In fact, she tightened her hold on Thráin, feeling him flinch at his father’s voice. She looked up at the old King and Queen with a cold, clear gaze that silenced them both.

"Our dignity is right here, Hrefna," Vora said, her voice steady. "It’s in the fact that my husband is breathing. It’s in the fact that for the first time in a hundred years, he isn't trying to hide his pain behind a silk mask. If you find the sight of a husband and wife loving one another to be shameful, then perhaps it is you who have forgotten what it means to be a Dwarf."

Thrór’s face turned a dangerous shade of purple. "You forget yourself, woman! Thráin, stand up! Straighten your back! You are the King in waiting, not a-"

"He is a man who has been through hell, Father," Thorin’s voice rang out.

Thorin, Dís, and Bilbo had followed the shouting. Thorin stepped to the front, his arms crossed, looking at his grandfather with a weary kind of pity.

"Let them be," Thorin commanded. "In this mountain, we do not measure a Dwarf’s worth by the stiffness of his collar. If they wish to sit in the sun, they shall sit in the sun."

…..
……..
….

 

The argument was cut short by a sound that made everyone, even Thrór, jump. It was the sharp clack-clack of a wooden staff against the stone and a low, rumbling hum of a song.

Out of the shadow of a great stone arch stepped a tall figure in a grey cloak and a pointed blue hat. Gandalf the Grey leaned on his staff, his eyes twinkling under his bushy eyebrows as he took in the fractured royal family.

"A bit early for a shouting match, isn't it?" Gandalf remarked, blowing a small, smoke-ring that took the shape of a butterfly before fluttering away.

"Mithrandir!" Thorin exhaled, stepping forward. "What is this? This magic... how are they here? Is it a trick of the mind? A temporary shadow?"

Gandalf looked at Thráin and Vora, his expression softening into something profoundly kind. He looked at Thrór’s scar and the Queens' bewilderment.

"No trick, Thorin Oakenshield," Gandalf said, his voice dropping into a resonant, serious tone. "The world is changing, and sometimes, the Valar see fit to balance the scales. Those who were lost to the shadow of the dragon and the darkness of the Necromancer have been returned. It is not a fleeting gift."

Thrór stepped forward, his eyes narrowed. "You mean to say we are... permanent?"

"As permanent as any Dwarf can be," Gandalf replied with a small smile. "You are not ghosts, nor are you memories. You are flesh and blood. You are here to stay, to see the kingdom rebuilt, and perhaps, if you are wise, to learn that a mountain is made of more than just gold."

….
……….
……

 

Silence fell over the garden. The weight of the word permanently settled over them all.

Thrór looked at the mountain he had lost. Hrefna looked at the grandchildren she barely knew. Thráin, still tucked against Vora’s side, let out a long, shaky breath. He wasn't going back to the dark. He wasn't going back to the silence.

Vora looked at Gandalf and nodded her thanks. She then looked back at Thrór, who was still fuming but looked suddenly very small against the vastness of the wizard’s words.

"You heard him," Vora said quietly. "We are here to stay. And if we are to live in this new Erebor, we are going to do it as we choose. No more cages, Thrór. Not for Thráin, and not for me."

Thorin walked over to his parents, placing a hand on Thráin’s shoulder. Thráin reached up, his scarred hand covering his son’s.

"Well," Bilbo chirped, breaking the heavy tension as only a Hobbit could. "Since everyone is officially alive and staying for tea, I suppose I should go tell Bombur to double the scone order. It’s going to be a very long afternoon."

Gandalf chuckled, his staff glowing faintly in the morning light. "Indeed, Master Baggins. Indeed it is."

Notes:

so originally this ended at them meeting the company but I felt soooo bad for Thráin so I made his wife see the damage done to him and she very much loves him so she does change. the (great) grandparents on the other hannnddddd their in too deep and probably wont change. but I hope you guys like this ending better then what I had planned. also this came out way longer then I meant it too.

Series this work belongs to: