Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

The end of the road lies ahead (will we walk it together?)

Summary:

Post "growing old isn't hard to do".

Bilbo has reached 104 years, but many things have changed. Age has taken its toll, his mind traps him in memories more often than not, and everyone knows that the end will, eventually, come. Fate will have its way in the end of all things.

Until a stranger arrives in the night and reveals that perhaps fate and the future can be changed one last time.

Notes:

PLEASE READ BEFORE READING THE STORY

Well, we're here at last. I don't know how it happened, but we're here.

This is the end of all things, save for an epilogue that grew a little out of control and will need to be posted on its own outside of this story. But this story marks the end of the series. Wow. I can't believe I just said that.

I held off on posting this first because I wasn't read to say goodbye myself. I thought I was, and then I just kept putting it off. Even now, posting it sends a frisson of excitement and terror through me. It's hard to say goodbye not just to the characters, but to my readers, who have been so faithful and caring and along for the ride as much as I have been.

The second reason I held on is because my life sort of fell into shambles and it kept falling into little bitty pieces but is now finally, finally righted. I thought I had it together when I posted the last letter, and it wasn't there yet. I have been nothing but crazy, a hodge podge of emotions. Life wasn't being completely cruel, but it certainly wasn't being kind, and it handed me not one, not two, not three of what most people would consider very stressful life events, but four all at once. But after Tuesday I will have finished with the last of the stress and should be looking to a brighter future. And I realized it was time.

Please don't let the first paragraph turn you away. I promise you that, despite the tag of major character death, despite knowing this is the end, this DOES end happily. I swear it. You've trusted me this far, trust me a little bit more.

A shout out goes to those who have recently found my series and have been tearing through it (y'all know who you are). You have reinvigorated me. Thank you.

Chapter 1: The beginning of the end

Chapter Text

It is said, amongst those in the Shire, that one day, a great and adventuring Baggins passed on, and that a mighty oak tree sprang from where he had been laid to rest. He had many a visitor come to his burial that day, and there was much mourning, for his friends and family were great in number.

But none mourned so great as his husband, left behind. He would remain in the Shire for only a year more, and then he was laid to rest beside his husband. And the oak tree grew between their graves, connecting them even in their eternal sleep.

That, however, is a story for another day. This is the story of the farewells before the oak tree came.

 

“I worry about him,” Bilbo said one day as he settled the tea kettle on the table. The sun was fine as it always was, and the heat wasn’t too stifling. It was a perfect day by hobbit standards, so it wasn’t a surprise that the smials were empty and everyone was outside enjoying the day.

Thorin began carefully pouring the tea, first to Bilbo, then to himself. “Who?”

“Frodo. He’s not going to handle the next few years well.”

It wasn’t a subject that he wanted to particularly broach with his husband. Thorin tended to get quiet whenever he brought it up, but it had to be spoken of. It wasn’t something that they could avoid. Eru knew Bilbo didn’t like speaking of it. It was hard to admit that he was getting older. It was harder still to think that he wouldn’t be there for Frodo and Elodie.

Thorin kept his gaze to his teacup and avoided Bilbo’s gaze. “Being married can be difficult, when first starting out and finding your way. I have no doubt, however, that he will do well at it.”

Bilbo snorted. “That wasn’t quite what I was aiming for, but well done at turning the topic.”

“I’m not quite certain what else I was supposed to say.”

With a sigh Bilbo moved the tea kettle back to over the fire. “Thorin, he’s going to need someone here-“

“He has Elodie. Bofur and Esmeralda will still be here.”

“You make it sound as if you’ll be right behind me when I go,” Bilbo said, and Thorin flinched at the words. “And you won’t be. You’ve years left.”

“Empty and hollow years, without you.”’

“Thorin-“

“It is said, in dwarf lore, that one can die from a broken heart,” Thorin said lowly. “I can only presume that I will find out if it’s true.”

Oh the melodramatics on that dwarf. “Listen here, you,” Bilbo murmured, and he came over to stand in front of Thorin. His husband’s hair was mostly silver, but there were still a few dark strands here and there to be found. Bilbo found one and twisted it around one of his fingers. Quite unlike his own hair, which was grey except for a few patches of white that were beginning to straighten out. Another sign that he was getting old, much too old for Thorin.

Thorin still wouldn’t look at him, focused only on Bilbo’s vest. Bilbo tugged on the lock of hair and forced him to look up. “We’ve had a good lifetime together, you and me,” Bilbo said. “Over fifty years together. A hobbit couldn’t ask for more than that. And we knew this day would come. But we’ve got to start planning on the after. For Frodo’s sake and Elodie’s sake. They’ve already lost one pair of parents; they don’t need to lose the second set.”

“And what about me?” Thorin asked, and his voice cracked. He took Bilbo’s hands in his and pulled him forward until they were forehead to forehead. “What am I supposed to do when you’re…gone?”

And Bilbo didn’t have an answer for him. He had nothing. “You’ll go on,” he began, but Thorin shook his head.

“Not without you. Do not ask it of me. I cannot, will not, go on without you. I would rather give all my remaining years to you before I had to live without you.”

“Thorin,” Bilbo said, but Thorin hushed him and simply held him tightly. Bilbo kept his words to himself and simply let Thorin do as he wanted. There was nothing for it, after all. Because the years had been stacked against them since the beginning.

And there was nothing he could do.

 

Evening fell. The night was cool and filled with fireflies, and children ran amok trying to catch them in order to put them into lanterns.

From a distance, sharp eyes watched them all. Silent feet moved through the grass, eyes lighting on chimney after chimney until at last they found one particular chimney smoking from the top hill. A hill with a bright green door, visible even in the dark.

Lips curved upwards in triumph. Bilbo Baggins had been found.

Silently they descended.

 

Dinner had been solemn, more solemn than Bilbo had wanted. Elodie had stopped by with her little Prim on her hip, saying Hob had sent his regards but was still tending to the borders, and Frodo had come by with Reginard as well. Yet for all the cheer they’d continuously tried to instill, the mood had been somber and unshakeable. Bilbo knew that Frodo and Elodie had glanced more than once between their uncles, trying to figure out just what had happened when that morning there had been sunshine and smiles.

Bilbo could have told them, but he had a feeling Thorin was waiting with words to tear the conversation away from him. So somber and solemn would have to do.

Thorin had gone off with Elodie and Frodo while Bilbo had retired to do the dishes. All right, Elodie and Frodo had all but dragged Thorin out of the room to interrogate him because Thorin was easier to break than Bilbo. They’d learned that years and years ago. When Bilbo had met Thorin, that wouldn’t have been the case: not even Kili and Fili could have dragged words from the dwarf’s lips if they’d been so inclined. Thorin had been a stone force, fierce and unbreakable, before they’d taken Erebor. Before he’d married Bilbo.

Then the years and the crown had slowly been a comfort, brushing his harder edges and revealing the gem beneath. Bilbo snorted and set aside another clean dish. Thorin would enjoy that analogy, it was a very dwarvish sounding-

Something clattered behind him. Bilbo froze and turned around. The kitchen was empty. “Thorin?” he called, pitching his voice low. No one answered.

Now that he thought about it, it had been awhile since he’d last heard Elodie and Frodo’s voices, too. His heart jumped in his chest, and Bilbo fought to stay calm. They could have gone outside for a smoke. He ignored the fact that he hadn’t heard the door open. “Thorin?” he called again.

A harsh metal sound, like a blade against stone, left him frozen for only a second more. Then he grabbed the blade from the nearby drawer and held it in front of him, sudsy hands and all. Old he may be at 104, but he wasn’t going down without a fight. Not when the lives of those he loved were on the line.

A guttural laugh made him almost panic. It threw him back to a dark time over fifty years ago when he’d been caught in Mordor, hung like a plucked goose and nearly killed by orcs. No, it couldn’t be. There were no orcs in the Shire.

But the laugh rang again, and when he heard it say, “Tasty, juicy flesh,” Bilbo slowly began edging his way to the door. His heart was pounding in his chest, terrified that if he looked outside, he’d see the Shire burning, just as it had when they’d fought to take it back from the last orc invasion. He swore he could still feel the heat, and he shook himself. Not now, not now. One thing at a time.

And his first and foremost concern was for Elodie, little Prim, Frodo, Reginard. Thorin.

Heavy footsteps pounded outside in the hallway, and the growl of the orc was closer. “We’re not to touch ‘im! You wait for orders!”

It was all he could do to not fall back into the memories. Memories of the chains biting into his wrists, memories of hanging suspended in the air while the orcs fought over him. Cold stone amidst the hot Mordor air, so tired, so bruised and broken and caught, never to be released. He had one chance to get out, one chance to fight the orcs and get to Mount Doom-

-no, Bag-End, you have to get to Thorin-

-and all that stood between him were the chains around his wrists and the orcs waiting out in the other room. Bilbo tightened his grip on his blade and stopped just outside the door. The hardwood beneath his feet made him pause with a frown. He didn’t have chains around his wrists. He was in Bag-End. Bag-End, Bag-End, he was in Bag-End, and he had to focus. Why couldn’t he focus?

“Just one lil’ bite,” one of the orcs said, and Bilbo heard it stepping around, saw the shadow, and he wasn’t going to get another chance to save whomever they had. Eru, they could have Frodo or Thorin, if they had Thorin-

“Let him go!” Bilbo cried, and he swept around the corner with the blade. The orc caught it easily but didn’t throw him off. The blade was wrenched from his hands and he fought desperately to get through, to get to Thorin. “I’m the one you want, don’t you touch him-!”

“Bilbo!”

He shook his head at the familiar voice that was very close, and when he looked up, there was Thorin, hands tight around Bilbo’s arms. His husband kicked the kitchen blade away, and when Bilbo looked wildly around, there were no orcs. It was just Thorin in the empty hallway and the quiet house with no one else in it.

And the sinking realization that he’d done it again.

Bilbo didn’t even have a chance to loathe himself before Thorin had him in a tight hold. “You’re not,” Thorin growled. “Bilbo, you’re not.”

“I’m as mad as they say I am,” Bilbo whispered. “Thorin, you know I am. This is the third time-“

“Don’t you dare say that about my husband,” Thorin said furiously. “You are not, you are not.”

Helpless tears rose in his eyes, and Bilbo buried his face in Thorin’s chest, choking on a sob. It was like blowing out the candle: one minute, Thorin had burned with fury, and the next he was holding tight to Bilbo and whispering soft assurances, kindness that Bilbo didn’t deserve.

He was a danger to himself and to those around him. “I could’ve hurt you,” he gasped out, but Thorin shushed him and held him tighter still. “No, Thorin, I could’ve-“

“You wouldn’t have,” Thorin swore. “I promise you. All is well. Please do not let this tear at you. Beloved, please-“

Bilbo grasped his husband’s tunic and miserably wept. Thorin held him and rocked him, and it should have felt like safety, wrapped in his husband’s embrace. All Bilbo could feel was the damning knowledge that he was slipping, day by day. It wasn’t age taking him, it was madness.

And one of these days, he would slip away and never come back.

He never noticed the two pairs of eyes from the doorway to the den watching him, fear and grief in their eyes before they slipped away. Nor did he notice the eyes watching him from the window outside.

Not until the knock on the door, at any rate.

Thorin paused, but he didn’t let go. “Go,” Bilbo whispered, sniffling. “Thorin, the door-“

“Elodie,” Thorin called, and of course they were still here, had probably witnessed his humiliating descent into madness. “Stop it,” Thorin murmured, as if knowing his thoughts. “You’ll leave my husband alone.”

Quick feet darted across the floor, and Bilbo suddenly felt the fear from the ‘orc attack’ strike him again. Thorin had heard the door, so it wasn’t just him. But it was late, too late for any respectable visitors. “Elodie, take Sting,” he called, his throat hoarse from his tears.

“Or Orcrist,” Thorin agreed. Not condescending, never condescending, but in full agreement, despite Bilbo’s spectacular loss of mind not even five minutes before. It made him so thankful for his husband and so utterly at a loss because he did not deserve this dwarf, this man who had stood by him through all these years, who even now supported him and refused to let the madness take him.

It was gratifying to hear the unsheathing of the blade before the sound of the hinges squeaking. He’d have to fix that, tomorrow. For now, what mattered were the next words from Elodie’s mouth.

Silence. “Elodie?” Bilbo asked, perhaps a bit hysterically, but Thorin was already turning to head to the door, so it didn’t matter.

“My lady,” Elodie breathed, and Bilbo frowned and hurried after his husband.

Frodo, Reginard, and little Prim stood in the hallway, staring with awe-filled eyes at the door. Even as Bilbo and Thorin arrived, Elodie stumbled backwards in order to let their visitor in. The cloak registered first – a long, white cloak clasped with mithril at the throat. Mithril Bilbo recognized.

When the hood fell back, it was to a face that he had not seen in some years. “Is she…is she an elf?” Frodo whispered.

Her smile was still like sunlight. “Hello Bilbo, Thorin,” Arwen said, and she gave a nod of her head. “It has been some time since last I saw you.”

“Good evening, your majesty,” Thorin said with a bow, and Bilbo watched the eyes of his heirs grow wider still. If it hadn’t been for the tears still drying on his face, he would’ve laughed in amusement. It would be awhile before he could feel proper amusement again.

But he could still feel the sheer happiness flooding through him at the sight of an old friend. Now that he could see her, he could also see three Gondorians behind her, and two elves besides that. They gave low bows when he met their eyes, and Bilbo gave a quick nod to them. “Please, come in,” he said. “The roof may be shorter than you’re used to, but I can assure you that you’ll be able to stand freely.”

“Thank you,” Arwen said. Her voice was still soft, sweet and kind, the same as Bilbo remembered it. When she moved, it was with the grace that all elves seemed beget with. It was in her movements and her smile that Bilbo could well see her grandmother. Another being he missed with a fervor, one he wished he could see again before the end.

Seemed maudlin was the mood for this evening, disturbing what should have been a joyful visit.

“I am late in reaching you,” Arwen said. “Well past traditional hours of visiting with friends. For that, I must apologize. My father kept me a good time longer than I expected.”

“I can’t blame you for that, nor your father,” Bilbo said, still trying to shrug off his mood. “It’s been some time since he’s seen you last, and I know I’d feel the same if I hadn’t seen Elodie or Frodo or their spouses or any of the other young hobbits that blast through our dwelling in a great long while.”

Merry and Pippin, Samwise and Rosie, Lotho and Everard any of the other hobbit children who’d seemingly grown up in Bag-End. Thorin and Bilbo had wanted children, and they’d been gifted many. So it was with a fair conviction that Bilbo felt he knew just how Elrond had felt, giving Arwen up again after having her stop by.

“Indeed, and as a mother, I understand as well,” Arwen said. She smiled. “He is doing well, you need not ask. Aragorn has hopes for him to take on further duties of the crown.”

“And the others? Denethor, Finduilas, Ivriniel?”

Arwen’s smile fell, just a little, but enough for Bilbo to know that whatever she said next would not end well. “Denethor is Steward,” she said quietly. “Ecthelion passed several years ago.”

Thorin rested a hand on his shoulder, a comfort and strength. “Come, sit by the fire, and bring to us the rest of the news,” he said. “For an Elven Queen wandering into the Shire has more purpose than visiting old friends.”

Frodo’s jaw nearly hit the floor, and Bilbo finally felt a grin tugging his lips up. Elodie shook herself first and scooped her awe-stricken child into her arms. “I’ll get tea,” she said. “If you’ll but step into the den, my lady.”

“My name is Arwen,” the Queen said. “You have no need to address me with lofty titles. Though you may not know it, young Elodie of the Shire, you and I are friends.”

Elodie smiled widely before she managed to tamp it back down. “And a friend will always bring tea to another. Please, come sit.” Then she was gone, little Prim staring with wide eyes over her shoulder.

Arwen let out a small laugh at the sight of the little one. “It has been many years since my Eldarion has been that small,” she said. “Or my daughters. They grow so swiftly, now.”

“They have a tendency to do that,” Bilbo said, and swiftly ruffled the heads of both Frodo and Reginard as he passed them. They grumbled at being tussled like children, but they were both his sons, as far as he was concerned, though Reginard was by marriage. They were still his.

They settled in the den, the Gondorian soldiers thanking Elodie appropriately for the tea. The elves, too, were unfailingly polite, but moved with the men to the kitchen with no prompting, leaving Arwen alone with Bilbo and Thorin.

Frodo cleared his throat. “Shall I help them find tea cakes?” he finally asked. He still couldn’t seem to take his eyes off of Arwen. Reginard, either, and Bilbo wondered at it. They’d met elves before, having seeing Legolas and Tauriel more than once as they’d grown.

Of course, the sight of Galadriel still left Gimli and Bofur both struck to the bone with awe, so he supposed it didn’t really matter how many elves there were to see. Some were just blessed with a grace that would always enchant those around them.

Arwen didn’t seem to mind. If anything, she smiled and gestured to the nearby chairs. “You are welcome to stay; my guards will not mind a moment by themselves. Of this I can assure you.”

Elodie returned once more, this time with tea destined for the Queen. Prim toddled behind her, little thumb in her mouth. “You are blessed,” Arwen said, nodding to the little one. Prim’s face split into that wide grin of hers, even with her thumb still between her lips. It made Arwen chuckle at the sight.

“More days than others,” Elodie agreed. “But I imagine you know what that’s like. I’m grateful for Hob, I can assure you of that.”

“Hob Hayward is a Shirrif,” Bilbo explained to Arwen. “He’s patrolling the borders to keep the Shire safe. And when he’s not out there, Elodie is.” Adventurers, the lot of them. Some of the more grumbling types of hobbits would say that Bilbo and Thorin had corrupted the younger generation. It was quite a proud achievement, if Bilbo said so himself, and he smiled into his tea at the thought.

Arwen smiled. “This sounds a great deal like my husband. He is King, and yet he still insists on riding the fields with his men. Denethor, too, goes with him more often than not, now that he is in Minas Tirith.”

“And left Finduilas behind?” Bilbo asked with a frown. “In Dol Amroth, with their children?”

“No. She came to Minas Tirith with both of her children, and there she stays.”

Bilbo paused, teacup almost to his lips. Thorin set his down on the table without hesitation. “She would not leave the sea,” he said. “Finduilas would perish without it.”

“She nearly perished beside it,” Arwen said quietly. “The birth of her first son, Boromir, was difficult. The bearing of her second nearly ended her. You know how ill she was at Faramir’s blessing. Denethor brought her to Minas Tirith many years ago and begged for my aid to save her. Had I not been there and able to help her, I do not know what would have happened.”

“But she’s alive,” Bilbo pressed, forgetting completely the wide eyes of his children seated around him. No, all he could think of was the sweet smile of Finduilas and her constant longing for the sea. Always for her home at the sea…and Denethor. “She is, isn’t she?”

“And doing well,” Arwen assured him. “Her sons Boromir and Faramir are growing tall and strong, and Denethor is proud of them both. Faramir takes after his mother, more often than not, while Boromir would climb into a sack if it meant he could travel with his father and Aragorn.” She chuckled a little at the image, as if remembering a time when the lad had actually done so. “But they are happy and healthy, and soon Finduilas will go back to the sea.”

“Did they ever reconcile?” Thorin asked quietly. “Denethor and Ecthelion.”

It was some time before Arwen answered, and there was a sadness in her eyes. “They did, but it was brief in time, even for men. Both had longed for it, but neither would make the first step until Ecthelion’s life was near its end. Only then did they speak truths to one another, deep and harsh truths that had been denied to them both for many years. Now Denethor sits where his father did, and his reconciliation has left him calmer and more full of peace. He also cherishes his sons, which I have no doubt is due in part to how his father never cherished him.”

She sighed and gazed off into the distance for a long moment, as if watching something else happen. “It will make all the difference,” she murmured. “For more than one of their lives.”

She turned back to her tea, then, and Bilbo turned to his, though his thoughts ran about in his mind. Ecthelion gone after so long, and Finduilas ill, unable to see her beloved waters. Another face came to mind, and he asked, “And Ivriniel?”

Arwen’s smile slowly rose to her face once more. “She travels, wanders, and writes of the lands she sees. More often than not, I hear that her companion is a dwarf with fine braids in his hair and a gleam in his eye.”

“I would expect nothing less, after all these years,” Thorin muttered. Still, his husband shook his head with a rueful smile, and Bilbo chuckled. Good. The last he’d heard from Dori, Nori had been off again somewhere else, but it was always good to hear from the other side that he wasn’t alone, and neither was Ivriniel.

Frodo finally plucked up the courage to ask her a question, and her voice was sweet in replying. After that, nothing was held back, and Arwen was dutiful in answering all of their questions, whether simple ones from Reginard about Gondor or more complex ones from Elodie about the healing herbs that grew better in Arwen’s garden. The candles burned down until Bilbo realized at last that little Prim was fast asleep in her mother’s arms, and Elodie blearily blinking to stay awake. Reginard had long since fallen asleep against Frodo’s shoulder, and Frodo had simply wrapped an arm around his husband to keep him there.

For an evening that had started with such utter catastrophe and madness, Bilbo had never expected this kind of peace to come. He glanced at his husband and found Thorin already watching him with soft eyes. He gave a small smile and watched as one began to bloom on his husband’s face.

“So why do you venture this far west?” Thorin asked Arwen at last, when she had finished her tea. Arwen settled her teacup between her hands and met their gazes with surety.

“The last of the elves are leaving Arda. The ships will bear them henceforth to Aman.”

Bilbo stared. “The last of-?”

“My father and those in Rivendell. My grandmother, too, with those who have stayed behind with her.” Arwen took a long and deep breath. “I will not be going with them. And, to the best of my knowledge, neither will Legolas or Tauriel.”

“What of Haldir?” Thorin asked. “He still travels between Lorien and Erebor more often than not, or so I have heard in letters from the Mountain.”

“I do not know. I expect it will be a difficult decision for him, for he is a Captain under Galadriel’s hand, and he loves her fiercely. But he is also loyal to Tauriel and Gimli, two of his dearest friends. I, too, have heard much about Haldir’s journeys to Erebor from my grandmother. He is also quite fond of Kili, and of Fili’s children.” She shook her head. “I do not know what he will do. Most everyone has already left.”

“But…but what happens when the elves leave Middle-Earth?” Frodo said, staring in horror. Elodie’s eyes were filling with tears at the very thought, and it was an incredibly terrible and horrific idea to imagine: their world without any elves there to tend to the forests, to guide with their long-earned wisdom and knowledge. If they all left, it would be down to three elves: Arwen, Tauriel, and Legolas. All three doomed to stay from mortal love.

Perhaps it would be better if Haldir left the shores of the mortals.

“The world is moving to the age of Men and Dwarves,” Arwen said. “And their children, bearing mixed blood from dwarves and elves alike. And the world will continue in such a fashion.”

She set aside her cup, more solemn than Bilbo had ever seen her. “I travel west to say goodbye to my kin. Aragorn will be there as well, in two months’ time, when they depart. I also had the chance to stop here, in the Shire, and see friends I have not seen in many years.”

The way she gazed at him, however, left Bilbo unsure if that was all there was to it. There was a deep and knowing look in her eyes, as if she knew the madness that was taking him, the age that was wearing at his bones. Galadriel had gazed at him with that knowing look once, too. Right before she’d told him that he’d changed Fate and altered forever the course of the future.

He wasn’t keen on that look now.

“Elodie, Frodo, let’s get you both tucked away,” Bilbo said, putting his teacup to the side and standing as briskly as he could. It wasn’t very brisk, but brisk enough. Elodie yawned but nodded, and Bilbo knew Hob would be by in the morning to find them. Frodo and Reginard also gave brief nods and began stumbling back to the rooms they knew were theirs. They didn’t live far, but far enough that Bilbo wasn’t sending them out into the Shire.

Especially not when he could still feel the crawl of orcs under his skin, burning through him. He flexed his hands and fought to send those terrible thoughts away. They had no place on a night like this.

“I’ll get more tea, or perhaps something stiffer,” he said. “And I’ll check in on your guards. You’ll be staying here, won’t you? I can assure you that I do have a bed fit for elves and men and very tall wizards. I have multiple, in fact.” Guests through the years had necessitated that.

Arwen gave him a bright smile. “If it’s no trouble to you, then yes, I would enjoy more of your company than past this evening.”

“Good,” Bilbo said decisively, and he left before the crawling feeling could get any worse. Wine would help soothe the last of his nerves, and he shrugged off the last of his worries before greeting the guards in the kitchen.

 

Thorin watched his husband go, hating that Bilbo was still flexing his hands like he did when he was fearful or nervous, rolling his shoulders in the same manner. But there was nothing he could do against the creatures in his mind.

“He has aged so much.”

Arwen’s soft voice only brought back memories of his arguing with Bilbo just earlier that day. “104,” Thorin said quietly. “Hobbits don’t tend to live that long. Some do, but most don’t.”

“His mind, too, has aged,” Arwen said, and she sounded as grieved as Thorin felt. “He falls into the memories of yesteryear more often than not, or so my father said from your last letter.”

Thorin shut his eyes tight. “There’s nothing anyone can do,” he said lowly, and each word felt like poison to him. “The Ring took its toll, and the years that followed did the rest. Your father tried, but there was nothing to be done.” Mahal knew Elrond had tried. The elf had been nearly as desperate as he to find some way to aid Bilbo.

“I do not think he would have made it this long without you,” Arwen said. “You have soothed more than you can know.”

It was a kindness, one that was unfortunately not strong enough to combat the terror seizing his soul. The terror of losing Bilbo once and for all. He could only nod, words beyond him.

“I am not going to Aman. But I still have a place on the ship.”

It took a moment for her words to register, but when they did, he raised his head, slowly meeting her gaze. Her eyes were knowing, but there was a peace about them, a peace she was offering him. “It is mine to give to whomever I wish,” she continued. “They need not be an elf. The place may go instead to an old friend, one who deserves a life of tranquility they will not find on these shores.”

Thorin stared until tears began to roll down his face. “Truly?” he rasped.

Arwen only smiled, and Thorin could have fallen to his knees and thanked her, could have worshipped her at her throne, could have done anything for this wonderful being who would let Bilbo take her place. She would let Bilbo go to Aman, to remain for years and years in peace, health, and happiness. No more madness, no more distress, no more fear. Just peace. “Thank you,” he whispered. “Arwen, thank you.”

“No.”

Thorin and Arwen both turned at the sound of Bilbo’s voice. The hobbit stood before them, fury in his gaze, and Thorin watched as he set the tray with wine and wine glasses down before striding over to them, age not even hampering him in this moment. “Thank you, but no,” Bilbo said firmly. “I’m staying here.”

Thorin stared, then slowly began shaking his head. “No,” he said, and watched Bilbo’s eyes narrow. He didn’t care, he absolutely didn’t care, because for this one time, this one time, Bilbo was going to go. “You have a chance, and I will not see it wasted.”

“I’m not leaving you,” Bilbo said, and Thorin had been afraid that was what would keep him. “So you can think up as many preposterous ideas as you like, but I will not leave you. I will be right beside you until my last breath.”

“You would make me watch you die?” Thorin said desperately. “You would really be that cruel?”

“You would make me leave, knowing that you were left here to die, and I’d never even know when?” Bilbo retaliated, and even with as furious as he was, there were tears in his eyes. “You would be that cruel?”

“Bilbo,” Arwen said softly, and Bilbo turned to face her, looking hurt and worse than that, betrayed. But Arwen shook her head before he could speak. “I cannot give you my place on the ship.”

Thorin froze. “But, you,” he began, and Arwen spoke once more.

“I cannot give it because the Ringbearers have their own places already. You already have a seat, Bilbo. I am giving my place to Thorin.”

For a long moment, no one said anything. “You,” Bilbo began, and then he couldn’t say anything more, so he hurried instead to her and wrapped his arms tightly around her before he fell into tears. Thorin himself could not do anything except grasp the back of his chair and try to remain standing.

Him. Arwen was giving her place to him. A dwarf, and it did not matter that he had been her friend. No dwarf went to Aman, it was not open to them. But Arwen was giving him her place.

She stood, Bilbo still in her grasp, and opened her other arm to him. Thorin stumbled into the embrace, his free hand reaching to clutch at his husband. In that moment, eyes wide and full of wonder, Bilbo looked as he once when Thorin had first met him. He’d been blessed to watch the laugh lines crease Bilbo’s brow, watch the hair go grey and silver in turn. Over fifty years with this incredible being, with Thorin’s hand in his.

And he would be blessed to continue holding that hand instead of forced to let it go.

Like the mother that she was Arwen wrapped her arms around them and held them close, sheltering them from the world around them. Thorin’s hand tightened on Bilbo’s, and the three friends stood together for some time.