Actions

Work Header

A Most Sensible Idea

Chapter Text

Bofur was still talking. Next to him, Bilbo was nodding politely though his gaze kept moving throughout the great hall. He wasn’t looking for anything or anyone in particular, but he kept being distracted from their conversation every time the large doors creaked open in front of him.

They had left Frodo in the kitchens with Bofur’s brother. Bombur was a… stout dwarf with a large braid hanging down his chest like a necklace. Whether it was part of his beard or his hair, Bilbo hadn’t been able to tell. The dwarf’s cheeks had been flushed and shiny from the heat of the stove, but he had greeted his brother’s friends with a gracious smile.

‘Very nice to meet you hobbits, very nice indeed.’ He had nodded his head vigorously, and slapped Bilbo on the back hard enough to almost make him fall face-first into a pot of hot beef stew. Well, thought Bilbo after righting himself, there could be worse ways to go. He sniffed the dish delicately. Is that sage or thyme…?

‘Yes, Bofur has certainly told me a lot about you two.’ Bombur turned to the stove behind him, completely missing the way his brother pursed his lips in annoyance.

‘Bombur?’ Bofur interrupted. ‘Are ye cookin’ anythin’ good for lunch?’ He pulled out two chairs for Frodo and Bilbo to sit on.

The other dwarf was affronted. ‘Am I cooking anything “good” for lunch? When is lunch ever anything less than “good”?’

‘I don’ know. Judgin’ from what gets sent down to us miners in the middle o’ the day, it’s usually heated scraps from last night’s supper.’ He wiggled his moustache teasingly at his brother. Bilbo knew that Bofur was not the most particular of dwarves when it came to food. As long as there was plenty of it and ale to wash it down, he was happy. Though they came from the same family, Bombur had obviously developed more refined tastes through his work in the royal kitchens.

Bombur ignored his brother’s antics, gave an order to an underling to check on the bread, and started plating up various meat dishes to be taken to the great hall.

Frodo watched all this activity with hungry eyes, wanting to take in all the dishes and their preparations.

‘Well,’ Bofur continued, as he stood up. ‘I’ve invited these two to eat lunch with me in the great hall. We need to go before the food’s gone.’

‘Oh, I did wonder, why your face was so clean in the middle of the day.’ Bombur raised his eyebrows at his brother. Bilbo had noticed some black dust behind Bofur’s left ear earlier, but the gentle-hobbit had made no mention of it.

Frodo had moved from the table to stand by the stove. ‘Uncle Bilbo, I want to stay down here.’ His uncle made to interrupt but he continued. ‘Besides, you can talk to Bofur a lot better without me around.’ His attention went back to the numerous pots in front of him.

‘Let ‘im stay.’ Bofur said. ‘Bombur’ll look after ‘im and maybe he can even work a little to earn his keep.’ The dwarf grinned at the younger hobbit who laughed at the his impertinence.

Bilbo was unsure. At home, he would have thought nothing of leaving Frodo alone with one of his neighbours for an entire day. But those were hobbits. These were dwarves.

Bilbo sighed. He needed to stop this way of thinking.

‘Alright, I’ll eat with Bofur alone. But I would like to have supper with my favourite nephew, if there aren’t any other suitors for your company tonight.’ Frodo nodded and returned to the stove.

Bilbo stood up. ‘It was nice to meet you, Master Bombur, and please give this one,’ nodding at Frodo, ‘something to eat. He hasn’t had anything since breakfast!’

Bofur brought Bilbo back up the stairs and into the hall. And that’s where they were now, with Bilbo keeping both eyes on the door and one ear on Bofur’s long-winded comparison between a mattock and an ordinary pickaxe, and why the former was obviously the superior choice.

Since their arrival in Erebor, winter had really grabbed hold of the land surrounding the mountain. Everything had slowed down. There was a crispness to the air when Bilbo opened the shutters in the morning, and he was sure that it would snow that night.

Erebor remained unchanged by the weather. Its thick walls insulated its inhabitants, though Bilbo still moved quickly from fire to fire when he had to walk through the halls.

The door creaked again. It had been almost two weeks since their tour of the mountain with the King, and neither Frodo nor Bilbo had seen him since that day. The golden flower had been placed in a vase on Frodo’s dresser, but the lad looked at it less and less with every passing day.

Bilbo enjoyed his cup of tea every night, but he had the urge to squirrel the rest of the packet away in his travelling trunk. He felt that he would somehow need it more, once he had returned to the Shire.

There was a creaking sound in front of him. Bilbo looked up.

Lady Dís walked into the great hall, flanked by her two sons. Again, the hobbit was impressed by the great presence of the Lady.

She stopped in front of him and Bofur, who quickly removed his hat.

‘Oh,’ she said. ‘I had hoped to find Frodo with you.’

Bilbo nodded in understanding. He was used to this by now. Dwarves still turned and looked at Frodo, when the two hobbits moved through the halls, and he heard whispers of ‘The King’s intended’ following their footsteps. Frodo was the more important of the two now, and he had to get used to that. Back in the Shire, there was no Frodo without Bilbo. Here in Erebor, Bilbo seemed to fade into the background next to the youth and beauty of his nephew.

‘I wanted to invite both of you for supper in my chambers tonight. My sons will be there as well.’ She spread her arms slightly to encompass the lads standing on either side of her. They each gave the hobbit a perfunctory smile, but looked like they wanted to be somewhere else.

‘And the King?’ Bilbo couldn’t help himself.

Lady Dís’s eyes softened. ‘My brother will not be joining us. He has some business with his advisors and will probably work late into the night.’

Bilbo ducked his head. He knew he couldn’t refuse this great dwarrowdam. ‘We will be delighted, my Lady.’

She nodded briskly. ‘Good. I’ll send someone to escort you. Probably one of these two blockheads.’ as she gestured to her sons with lazy wave of her hand. The Lady walked away, her sons ambling after her.

Bilbo suddenly remembered the dwarf next to him. ‘Oh, I’m sorry, Master Bofur! I should have introduced you!’ He blushed. Being away from the Shire was having a bad effect on his manners.

‘Wasn’t ‘specting ye to.’ Bofur calmed his friend. ‘The grand ‘n’ mighty don’t talk to lowly miners like me, other than to give ‘em orders. I rarely see lords and ladies outside of the Durin’s Day celebrations, and even then all I get is a short nod.’ He took a sip from his cup.

‘Isn’t it like that in the Shire?’ Bofur asked.

Bilbo thought about it. Of course, the Tooks, the Brandybucks and even the Baggins were considered important families in the Shire. But that was mainly because they kept track of their family tree, took pride in their name, and had never moved an inch since first settling on their land. And the Browns and the Greenhands were considered to be more…salt of the earth types, but was never treated as less than any other. Why, Bilbo drank tea with his gardener, and danced with the daughter of his butcher at the village fetes.

‘No,’ he said. ‘There isn’t such a large difference between hobbits.’

‘Thought as much.’ Bofur drummed his fingers on the table. He looked away from Bilbo. ‘It makes sense now. Why a nicely dressed hobbit, such as yerself, spent so much time talking with a grubby miner.’ He drained his cup and pushed away from the table. ‘Enjoy your supper with the Lady.’

‘Master Bofur?’ Bilbo grabbed his hand and had to think quickly. ‘Will you have supper with Frodo and me tomorrow evening?’

Bofur was a jolly dwarf by nature, but Bilbo thought that he had never seen such a large and genuine smile on his friend’s face before. The dwarf nodded so quickly, that his hat was in danger of falling off.

‘Yes, I would like that very much, Mr. Baggins.’

‘Please,’ the gentle-hobbit said. ‘Call me Bilbo.’

Before the large doors closed behind Bofur, he turned around, and even at a distance Bilbo could still see his wide, happy eyes.

 

X—X

 

Lady Dís was an accomplished hostess. She welcomed her guests with a smile, introducing her sons, Fíli and Kíli, properly to the two hobbits, and then led them to a table packed with food and drink, inviting them to feel at home. Yes, everything was quite correct.

Only, once Bilbo and Frodo had finished exclaiming about the food, remarking on the comfortable size of the room, and complimenting the Lady’s choice of furnishings, conversation seemed to dry up.

Frodo kept pushing a piece of potato around his plate, while Bilbo took several small sips of his wine in quick succession.

Surprisingly, it was the Lady’s youngest son, Kíli, who made the next effort into a subject.

‘Do you spar, Master Frodo?’ he said.

Frodo stopped bothering that poor potato. ‘Spar?’

‘Yes, you know, with swords, spears or axes?’

The oldest, Fíli, was suddenly interested in the conversation.

‘Kíli prefers the bow and arrow,’ he said ‘while I am handy with two single-handed swords.’ He looked at his brother. ‘Though both of us know our way around a two-handed broadsword as well.’

They looked at Frodo. ‘What’s your weapon of choice?’

Frodo kept opening and closing his mouth like a fish but little sound came out. At last he gathered himself. ‘I don’t! Have a weapon, that is. Or spar, for that matter.’

Bilbo took up the subject. ‘We don’t do a lot of fighting in the Shire. We are a peaceful sort.’ He smiled at Lady Dís, who didn’t return the courtesy,

‘But,’ she said, ‘what do you do if you encounter a “non-peaceful sort”?’ The Lady looked at Bilbo searchingly.

‘We don’t.’ He gave a helpless smile. ‘We never have.’

The three dwarves stared at him, and he gave a slight shrug, as if that were any answer.

‘I haven’t seen any danger inside Erebor, either, in the time I’ve been here.’ He continued. ‘But Master Dwalin still carries huge axes on his back, and most dwarves will at least wear a good sized knife in their belt.’

The dwarves all made an almost reflexive movement of their right hand to their waist.

‘But weapons are part of our culture!’ Fíli exclaimed. ‘I carry our mother’s swords, while Kíli uses our father’s bow. They are as important as our braids.’ The two small braids next to his mouth shook with his agitation.

‘The life and family of dwarves are inscribed on their weapons, Master Baggins.’ Lady Dís said and stood up. She went to a chest in the corner of the room, where she pulled out a huge axe, one that almost measured the length of Frodo. Bilbo could feel the lad suddenly tremble beside him. He placed his hand gently next to his nephew’s on the table.

She pushed the half-empty dishes out of the way and placed the axe with a clang.

‘Look here,’ she said, pointing at clusters of runes on the blade of the weapon. ‘These mark important events in my family’s life.

She started listing while her finger glided over the indentations in the metal, ‘My parent’s marriage, my birth, my first kill, when I began courting the boys’ father, my marriage, and my greatest victory in battle.’ Her eyes had a far-way look, as if the cold iron was telling her something.

Kíli took over from his mother. ‘Uncle Thorin has something similar. A longsword with an emerald at the end of the handle. It has names going back to Náin the Second!’

Fíli nodded. ‘Yes, and Frodo’s name will be on there soon enough.’ The two lads smiled at the young hobbit.

Bilbo could feel his nephew’s hand forming a fist next to his on the table. ‘What?’ Frodo said.

‘When you start your courtship.’ Fíli scraped his plate for any last remnants of food. ‘We’ve all been wondering why Uncle hasn’t announced anything yet.’

‘Yes,’ Kíli said. ‘You’ve already been here for more than two weeks.’ He smiled at Frodo. ‘What are you waiting for?’

‘Frodo is still young…’ Bilbo started.

‘He can’t be much younger than Fíli or me!’ Kíli grinned at his brother.

‘And as Balin has so often reminded us, we’re both plenty past marrying age!’ Fíli grabbed another piece of bread.

Bilbo kept silent. He was not prepared to get into another discussion filled with misunderstandings about dwarves and their strange version of age and growth.

The words burst out of Frodo, though. ‘But I’m not ready to be put on a sword!’

The room was quiet but for Frodo’s loud breathing. Lady Dís placed a hand on his shoulder.

‘Are you not sure about your courtship with the King, Frodo?’ Her voice was gentle, gentler than Bilbo had heard before.

Frodo’s breathing had sped up. ‘I don’t know.’ He licked his lips. ‘I mean, I’ve hardly seen King Thorin. He’s been, you know, alright but not…’ He trailed off.

Lady Dís ruffled his hair. ‘Don’t listen to these two fools. There’s no rush. You’re young, and my brother is in the prime of his life.’

She sat back down. ‘You’ll find each other eventually.’

Bilbo exhaled. This entire thing still felt wrong.

 

X—X

 

They had bid their goodnights and left the table. Fíli and Kíli intercepted the hobbits by the door.

‘We’re sorry about earlier.’ They looked at Frodo.

‘We didn’t mean to pressure you.’ Kíli said. ‘I guess we’re just excited that Uncle’s finally found someone.’

‘And we want to invite you to spar with us whenever you want.’ Fíli continued. ‘We train most mornings.’

‘But I can’t fight.’ Frodo protested.

‘We’ll teach you!’ Kíli said. ‘We’re excellent teachers!’ Fíli nodded his head.

Frodo hesitated. Bilbo said nothing. This was the lad’s decision.

‘Alright.’ Frodo said. ‘Where do you train?’

‘We’ll show you! Right now!’

The dwarves bustled the small hobbit out the door.

“Are you going to be alright, Frodo?’ Bilbo called after them.

‘Don’t worry, Master Boggins. We’ll look after him!’ came the cry back, though he couldn’t tell whether that was Fíli or Kíli.

Bilbo sighed. It would be alright, he told himself. He started down the hallway in the direction of his rooms.

Or what he thought was the direction. The dark corridors all looked the same to the hobbit. Damn this windowless mountain, he thought, as he passed the same statue for the third time.

After shuffling aimlessly through abandoned passages, he finally swallowed his pride and looked for someone to ask for help. He turned around once more.

There! He could see a doorway up ahead with light flooding out from beneath it. He hurried to it.

His hobbit manners made him softly push the door slightly open. He didn’t want to disturb anymore than he had to, and if he saw something he shouldn’t, then he could quickly make his escape. He heard muffled voices and the tail end of a sentence.

‘…very young. Too young, even.’ That voice sounded familiar, Bilbo thought.

‘You’re not making any sense. I thought we agreed on this?’ There was a second voice.

‘I know why I have to do it. I’m just not sure anymore.’

The second person sighed. ‘This isn’t like you. You never had these kinds of ideas before.’

‘Maybe now’s the right time for them.’

The room was silent, and Bilbo was ready to make his presence known.

‘Wait…’ the first voice said. ‘There’s someone at the door.’

Blast it! Bilbo turned on his feet and moved down the hall. There was the sound of the door swinging open behind him, and then light flooded the floor in front of him. He heard a deep voice.

‘Bilbo?!’

He flinched. Of course it was the King. The only thing that could make his humiliation more complete was if both his parents came back to life to see their only son scrambling around a deserted hallway like a common thief.

Bilbo turned around. There was an urge to smooth his jacket and check his hair, but he suppressed it.

‘Good evening, your Majesty.’ He bowed.

‘What are you doing out here?’ The King closed the door behind him and moved towards Bilbo.

In the cold and dimly lit hallway, King Thorin’s voice seemed to envelop Bilbo. He felt warm. Why did he feel warm?

The King was now next to him. Too close, Bilbo thought.

‘I…’ he started. King Thorin looked at him attentively. ‘I got lost, coming back from supper.’

The King’s lips quirked upwards. ‘Really?’

‘Yes, really.’ He would like to see his Majesty try to find his way round the circular paths of Hobbiton!

‘Then allow me to escort our esteemed guest to his rooms.’ King Thorin presented his right arm with a flourish.

Bilbo rolled his eyes and placed his hand on the other’s arm. He could survive this ridicule; he just wanted to find his bed before morning.

King Thorin started off with purpose, and Bilbo followed.

The King had removed his usual leather vambraces and his surcoat, and there was nothing between the hobbit and the dwarf but the soft material of King Thorin’s tunic. Bilbo flexed his fingers on his forearm. He could feel the hard muscles jumping beneath his touch.

The King cleared his throat. ‘Why were you having supper in the East wing?’

‘Lady Dís invited me.’

‘Ah.’

They walked in silence. Bilbo’s ingrained manners urged him to find some topic of conversation, but his new-found obstinacy when it came to this king kept him quiet.

‘How is Frodo?’ King Thorin asked.

‘Good.’

Bilbo sighed. As much as he tried, he couldn’t be impolite. ‘The inhabitants of Erebor have been very welcoming to him, and try to keep him busy and entertained.’ Bilbo hesitated. ‘Your nephews are going to teach him how to spar.’ He said the last word as if it were foreign to him.

The King laughed. ‘I’d like to see that! Knowing their impatience, they won’t even teach him how to hold a sword properly before swinging at him!’

Bilbo swallowed drily and grabbed King Thorin’s arm tighter. He suddenly felt a large, warm hand on top of his own. They had stopped walking.

‘I’m joking, Master Baggins.’ The King looked earnestly into his eyes. ‘The lads may be a little…impetuous, but they’re not cruel. Besides, Dwalin will be there. He always oversees my sister-sons’ training.’

Bilbo nodded. They stood in silence for a moment, the King’s hand still holding onto Bilbo’s smaller one. He thought he could feel it move over his knuckles slightly.

‘It’s odd.’ King Thorin murmured, seemingly far away. ‘You have so much hair on your feet, but your hands…They’re quite smooth.’

Bilbo didn’t know what to say to that, and he wasn’t entirely sure that the King knew what he was saying.

He gently disentangled his hand from his Majesty’s grip. He looked away from the dwarf in front of him.

‘Yes,’ The King swallowed. ‘I was taking you back to your rooms.’

He moved on ahead, and Bilbo followed. There was no more talking and no more touching. Bilbo was relieved, though his fingers still prickled with the remembered warmth of the King’s arm.

As they walked through the passages, Bilbo could gradually recognize more and more of his surroundings. They must be close, thank Yavanna.

King Thorin stopped in front of a familiar door. Bilbo sighed. Finally.

He made to open the door.

‘Master Baggins?’

He closed his eyes shortly and turned around. ‘Yes?’

‘I asked about Frodo earlier, but I didn’t inquire about you.’ The King straightened slightly. ‘Are you enjoying your stay in Erebor?’

What could Bilbo say? That the cold walls of the mountain still seemed to close in around him? That a lot of the dwarves ignored him in favour of Frodo? That he dreaded every meeting with his nephew’s intended, because the dwarf unsettled him in a way that he couldn’t explain?

‘I’m fine.’

‘And have you been enjoying the library?’ The King moved closer.

Bilbo tightened his grip on the door handle. ‘I haven’t been back yet.’

‘Oh.’

Bilbo sighed. ‘Thank you for leading me back to my chambers, your Majesty.’

The King nodded briskly, and looked away.

Bilbo would regret this. ‘And thank you for the tea.’ It felt dangerous to even acknowledge the gift.

King Thorin’s eyes, which had been shuttered, quickly found Bilbo. He looked incredibly grateful for the hobbit’s words. ‘You’re welcome.’ He smiled.

Bilbo’s hand tingled once again.

‘Bilbo?’ That was the second time the King had used his first name in one evening. The gentle-hobbit was not quite comfortable with it. But Kings were the makers of customs and could not be gainsaid.

‘What is it?’ Bilbo felt tired.

‘Will you dine with me tomorrow night? You and Frodo, I mean.’ King Thorin leant slightly towards him.

Bilbo remembered Bofur’s happy eyes. ‘I’m sorry, your Majesty. We’re having supper with a friend.’ After what he had learnt at lunch, he suddenly felt like provoking the King. ‘He’s one of the miners currently digging out your Majesty’s gold.’

‘The one you went away with during the Durin’s Day celebrations?’ King Thorin’s gaze was intent.

Bilbo was surprised that the King remembered. Maybe it had been a total breach of propriety for the uncle of the King’s intended to enjoy the company of labourers.

‘Yes. His name is Bofur, if your Majesty didn’t know.’

‘Is he…?’ The King hesitated. ‘No, it’s not my place to ask.’

Bilbo rubbed his eyes. It was too late for mysterious dwarves. He gave a quick ‘Goodnight.’ to the King and shut the door behind him.

There was a light coming from Frodo’s bedroom. He’s back then, Bilbo thought as his shoulders slumped. He went to his own bedroom and sat on the edge of the bed.

In the quiet darkness of the room, he could hear the beat of his heart slowing.

When had it sped up? Was it when he had been alone and lost in the dark hallways? When he had been discovered spying on the King of Erebor? When he had openly flaunted his friendship with a miner in the King’s face?

Or was it when he had stood silently in the dim light from a flickering torch, feeling the warm, rough touch of a large hand on his own, and looked up into blue eyes that no longer felt like ice.