Actions

Work Header

A Most Sensible Idea

Chapter Text

The news quickly spread throughout Erebor the next day. Apparently, a group of orcs had taken shelter in a cave on the south side of the mountain. The cave, where they had gathered, used to connect straight to Erebor, once having been used by a group of dwarf tanners as an airy place to stretch out their prepared animal hides. That was until a rock slide completely barred the passageway down into the cave, shutting it off from the rest of the mountain.

‘Do you really think they would try to break in through a wall of rocks? It must be quite impenetrable.’ Bilbo was having tea in Balin’s office. It was the only calm place in Erebor. Here you couldn’t hear the rattling of axe and armour as the King prepared a “welcome party” for these orcs.

Balin put down his quill. ‘Not quite impenetrable. With strong bodies and a leader who cares nothing for the loss of life among his group, they could drag the rocks away within a week.’ He sighed and rubbed his forehead. ‘The frost and the lack of food has driven them this far into Erebor. Once the hunger truly sets in, they will do anything. Even break their backs to go through stone. They are like rats in that way.’

‘I’ve never seen an orc in my life.’ Bilbo turned his cup back and forth in its saucer. ‘Are they very horrible?’

‘They ignore pain, they feel no love, and they have no remorse at killing. They are the very basest of creatures. Their bodies are strong but their minds are weak. They are able fighters but lack no direction in their strategy.’

Bilbo’s mouth felt dry. He forced himself to take a sip of his tea, but it did little to help. These were the creatures that King Thorin was going to fight. Strong warriors with no morals. Bilbo tried swallowing again but his throat just made a clicking sound.

Balin didn’t seem to notice that Bilbo had gone quiet. He kept talking as he picked up his quill. ‘I confess I do not know which kind of enemy I would prefer: A muscled idiot or a clever weakling.’ He chuckled lightly to himself.

Bilbo bit his lower lip. ‘Do you know how many there are in the cave?’

‘Our scouts say about thirty, no more than forty.’

Forty hungry orcs, desperate in the bitter cold, willing to do anything to survive. And King Thorin was going to look for them. Bilbo breathed in deeply and closed his eyes. He would be alright. He had to be alright. Please, let him be alright.

‘Are you ill, Master Baggins?’ Bilbo opened his eyes again to see Balin looking at him. He had wrinkled his brow in concern.

Bilbo pushed his chair back and stood up slowly. ‘Yes, I…I think I’ll go to my room for a little while.’

‘Very well.’ Balin stood up as well. ‘Can you find your way? Do you need me to go with you?’

Bilbo shook his head. ‘No, I’ll be fine.’ He said and closed the door behind him.

The hallways were tense with nervous excitement. Dwarves seemed to walk past him quicker, and most of them were wearing some sort of protective layer, from thick leather on the servants to decorated and gold-plated metal on the lords and ladies. Without thinking about it, Bilbo buttoned his coat and turned up the collar to cover his neck.

Every conversation around him seemed more hushed. Dwarves were usually loud and boisterous. Now they whispered together, grabbing each other’s hands or shoulders as they walked from here to there.

There was a piercing sound of metal hitting stone behind him, and he turned to see some young apprentice being berated by his superior for dropping three expensive-looking swords. The lad was nodding along to everything his master was saying, and Bilbo could see how his hands shook as he gathered the weapons in his arms again.

Bilbo walked on, trying to ignore the tightening in his throat. He didn’t know whether he was going to cry or be sick.

‘Uncle Bilbo!’

He looked up. Frodo, flanked by Fíli and Kíli, was walking towards him. They looked more serious than Bilbo had ever seen them.

‘Frodo,’ He stopped in front of the trio, surreptitiously moving them to stand in a small alcove, so as to not block the busy hallway. ‘Shouldn’t you be back in our rooms? They’ll be leaving soon—‘

‘You mean Uncle Thorin’s leaving soon.’ Kíli interrupted him while kicking an imaginary pebble.

‘We have to stay behind while he and Dwalin get all the fun.’ Fíli added as he twirled the left braid in his moustache.

‘I’m sure your uncle has his reasons for making you stay.’ Bilbo gave them a sympathetic look. ‘After all, we can’t have all of the royal line out fighting orcs. Who’ll rule Erebor then?’

‘But Mum’ll stay as well,’ Fíli said, ‘And she’s far more capable than any of us.’ Kíli nodded eagerly in agreement.

Frodo slightly bumped his shoulders against each of the two dwarves and smiled up at them. ‘I think it’s good that you’re not going.’ He looked down at the floor. ‘That you’re staying here with me.’

Bilbo bit his lip, stopping whatever he wanted to say at seeing this display of affection between friends.

Fíli smiled down at the young hobbit. ‘I guess so.’

He spoke to Bilbo. ‘We’re taking Frodo to our chambers while Uncle is gone. You should come, too. They won’t be away for more than a night at most.’

Bilbo thought of being alone in his and Frodo’s large rooms, alone with his thoughts and his anxieties about the King. Not being able to sleep, not being able to read, and just waiting for any news. And nothing in the silence but the loud beating of his nervous heart.

‘Yes, I’ll stay with you.’ Bilbo said. ‘I just need to get some things from my room first.’

‘Great.’ Kíli smiled at him. ‘We’re going to eat dinner in the great hall. Meet us there when you’re done?’

‘Yes, alright.’ Bilbo gave a weak smile to the boys as they walked away.

He finally reached his chambers and silently pushed the door open. He stopped as he saw an armoured figure sitting by the desk in the living room.

It was King Thorin, and he was hunched over, writing something. He wore close fitted, plain metal plates on top of his usual blue surcoat.

Bilbo cleared his throat, and the King quickly looked up towards the door. He carefully put down the quill as his other hand went to the opening in his armour beneath his armpit and quickly stuffed a small, soft thing inside between the metal and his heart.

He stood up, and even from where Bilbo was standing, he could hear the metal of the armour moving noisily together.

‘Master Baggins.’ King Thorin breathed, his hands smoothing over the edge of the desk. Bilbo blushed at the sight of those fingers, remembering how he had embarrassed himself the night before, holding on to the King for dear life, whispering to him drunkenly in the dark.

‘Your Majesty.’ Bilbo averted his eyes as he closed the door behind him. ‘If you’re looking for Frodo, he’s in the great hall with your nephews.’

‘I know. I’ve already spoken with them.’ The King moved closer. ‘I was waiting for you. To say goodbye.’

‘Goodbye?’ Bilbo looked down at the King’s armour and only now noticed the large sword hanging from his side. ‘Are you leaving already?’ He could feel his brow knitting as he looked up at the dwarf.

‘As soon as possible. Dwalin is waiting with his group of soldiers as we speak.’

Bilbo couldn’t look at him. He moved to sit by the table in the middle of the room, staring down at the grain of the wood. ‘Why do you have to go with them? Can’t Dwalin lead them against the orcs?’

King Thorin followed, sitting down next to him, his hand almost touching Bilbo’s on the table. ‘He could. But I couldn’t call myself a leader and a king, if I sent warriors off to fight a battle, and hid behind thick walls until they came back.’

Bilbo looked up at him. ‘Are you coming back?’

The muscles around the King’s mouth twitched. ‘Do you want me to? Frodo would be released from his promise if I were to be pierced by an orc’s blade. And then you could go back to Bag End and your beloved garden.’

Bilbo rolled his eyes, but he couldn’t help a small smile breaking through. ‘Don’t be silly. Of course I don’t want you to be killed by an orc.’

‘That’s probably the highest compliment you’ve ever paid me.’ The King was smiling warmly now. ‘I think I shall have that engraved on a medal. It will say: King Thorin of Erebor, gentlehobbits don’t want him to die violently.’

Bilbo chuckled. ‘One gentlehobbit. I can’t speak for all of us.’ They shared a quiet laugh until Bilbo sobered again.

‘We shouldn’t be laughing.’ He looked down. ‘Not when you’re leaving. Not when you’re going off to fight.’

‘Are you worried for me, Master Baggins?’ King Thorin murmured as he brushed his hand back and forth on the table, each pass bringing it closer and closer to Bilbo’s smaller one.

‘Do I need to be worried?’ Bilbo whispered, his eyes following the movements of that broad hand.

‘I don’t think so.’ The hand stopped. ‘It’s a small group of starved orcs hiding out for winter. And I have a group of trained dwarves behind me. I’m sure we’ll succeed.’

‘But not certain?’ Bilbo could hear the armour clinking against the wooden back of the chair. It made King Thorin move differently, made him seem larger and slower. A proper target.

‘Nothing’s certain in life.’

‘Except death.’ There was a small irregularity in the surface of the table, and Bilbo couldn’t stop scratching at it.

‘Master Baggins?’ The King’s voice was soft, so soft that it made Bilbo raise his head to look into that serious face.

‘I will do everything in my power to come back to– To come back.’ The King held eye contact, then quickly licked his lips and looked away.

‘I wish I could fight,’ Bilbo suddenly said. ‘Anything must be better than having to sit here, listening for signs of intruders, and waiting for any news about the ones fighting to protect you.’

‘I’m glad you can’t fight.’ The King murmured. ‘But maybe you should learn to defend yourself, which reminds me…’ He stood up and walked back to the desk.

Bilbo must have been distracted by the presence of the King in his rooms earlier, for how could he otherwise have the missed that good-sized brown parcel placed on the edge of the desk.

King Thorin brought it back to the table and laid it down in front of Bilbo. ‘For you.’

Bilbo’s mouth fell slightly open. ‘Oh…Oh, thank you.’ He unwound the string and parted the brown cloth, revealing what seemed to be a silvery, knitted shirt.

He took removed it from its covering and spread it out in front of him on the table. It soon became apparent that it wasn’t knitting, but hard rings of what appeared to be silver woven tightly together to create impenetrable armour. It looked to be Bilbo’s size.

He held it up and could see tiny white gems shining among the metal, catching the light merrily.

‘It’s beautiful.’ He breathed. Even a hobbit would notice the other-worldly shine of the metal and the impeccable craft that had gone into making the entire shirt.

‘It’s not only beautiful, but incredibly useful.’ King Thorin said. ‘Put it on and it will protect you against most attacks. No sword or arrow will pierce this shirt.’

‘And you want me to have it?’ Bilbo tore his eyes away from the glimmering metal to look at the King.

‘Yes,’ King Thorin nodded seriously. ‘Would you- Would you please wear it? Always? Not just when we’re threatened by orcs. Not just when you’re here in Erebor. But always. Please?’

Bilbo draped the shirt over his hand, feeling its surprisingly light weight. ‘I don’t think I’ll have much use for it back in the Shire. I don’t think I’ll need such fine protection against tripping over rakes in my garden or being butted by an ill-tempered goat.’ He looked up, smiling but it fell from his face when he saw how sombre the King still looked. ‘But I will wear it.’

‘Good,’ King Thorin gave a relieved sigh. ‘Put it on immediately after I leave.’

Bilbo placed the shirt gently back on the table, listening to the tinkling sounds as the metal circles hit the wood.

He looked out the window, taking note of the darkening sky. ‘Will you attack after dark?’

‘Yes.’ King Thorin went back to brushing his hand back and forth on the table, settling into his seat.

Bilbo thought of Dwalin and his men waiting for their king, shuffling in their heavy armour, their arms getting tired from carrying large weapons.

But he wouldn’t be the one to remind the King of his duties, to give him an excuse to leave. He sat back in his chair and gave his companion furtive glances, trying to memorise that handsome face, the grey in his hair and the strength of his arms. Bilbo would need that memory if… If King Thorin didn’t return.

‘Are you staying here tonight? Alone?’ The King looked up at Bilbo.

‘No, Frodo and I are going to stay in Fíli and Kíli’s chambers.’

‘Good. That’s good. They’ll protect you if…’ He trailed off.

It had now become so dark that Bilbo felt the need to bring some more light into the room. He picked up a candle from the table, lit it in the fireplace and brought it around the room, lighting lamps on sideboards and tables.

He could hear the armour clanking as King Thorin turned in his seat to follow his slow movements throughout the room.

‘I have to go.’

Bilbo turned to face him, the candle still in his hand. ‘Yes.’

The King stood up and walked over towards him. ‘Wear your armour.’

‘Yes.’

‘And I will be back before morning.’

‘Yes.’

The King glanced down at the floor. ‘You’re dripping wax on the rug.’

‘Yes- Oh, am I? Bilbo looked down and quickly placed the candle on a nearby shelf to prevent further damage.

‘Sorry.’ He muttered.

‘Don’t be.’ King Thorin was close to him now. ‘Shall we shake hands before I go?’

Bilbo looked up into those blue eyes. He couldn’t say anything so he raised his right hand and offered it to the dwarf.

The corners of King Thorin’s mouth lifted slightly as he slowly let his hand slide into a close fit with Bilbo’s. The rough, warm texture of the skin set small shocks up Bilbo’s arm. They seemed to settle in his chest, heating him from within. The King didn’t squeeze his hand, nor did he shake it. He just held it for a long while.

As he finally let go, he murmured, ‘I will see you again, Bilbo Baggins.’

What could Bilbo say but, ‘Yes.’

He could hear the rattle of metal as King Thorin left him, leaving the door open behind him. Bilbo could feel a cold draught coming from the stony hallway, and the candles flickered and smoked, casting shadows in the silent room.

Bilbo couldn’t stay here any longer. He gathered his ringed shirt and his book and made to leave. He paused before going out the door. He would need a candle for these dark passageways.

As he went to the desk to collect the large candle there, his eye was caught by a piece of parchment lying on top of the pile. That was neither his nor Frodo’s flowing, rounded handwriting. It was a good deal more spiky and angular, and Bilbo recognized it from the letter he had read from King Thorin to Fortinbras the Thain.

The King must have been writing this while waiting for Bilbo to return. The page had several spots of ink splattered across it. King Thorin must have paused a lot while writing this. He must have sat in thought with the quill poised above the parchment, not noticing the dripping ink.

He let the book and the shirt drop to the floor as he sat down to read what was written.

 

Master Baggins,

I have been waiting for your return but am unable to wait any longer. And so this letter will serve as a poor substitute for a meeting between us.

My patrol is waiting for me as I write this, and I will be leaving soon. I do not know when I will return.

Please accept this present as a sign that you and yours are under the protection of Erebor and its king. It has long been among the treasures of the line of Durin, and I hope it will suit you.

I wish

 

And there the letter ended.

Bilbo traced a finger over the writing as he thought. What if this will be last thing I have of him? What if these polite words will be the only evidence of my friendship with King Thorin of Erebor?

He carefully folded the parchment twice and stuck it between the pages of his book.

Bilbo bundled up his armoured shirt in its packaging, picked up the candle and the book, and quickly made his way to the great hall to meet up with the three lads.

 

X—X

 

Lady Dís was waiting for them when Bilbo and the boys arrived at their chambers. She would spend the night with her sons, waiting for news of her brother and his patrol.

They all gathered in front of the fire place. The Lady offered Bilbo a small drink of some strong liquor, but he politely declined. He needed to stay alert this night while the group kept a vigil together.

He let the package on his lap slide down, and the metal clinked as it hit the stone floor.

‘Are you hoarding jewellery, Bilbo?’ Kíli grinned at him.

‘Don’t be silly,’ Frodo said, ‘Uncle Bilbo never wears trinkets.’

‘Maybe he’s stolen it from the treasury, thinking he’ll use it to buy his way out when the orcs come for us all.’ Fíli shared a smile with his brother.

‘Behave yourselves, boys.’ Lady Dís sat forward in her chair. ‘What have you got there, Master Baggins?’

‘Well, I…’ Bilbo couldn’t find the words to describe the gift so he merely pushed the cloth aside, revealing the shiny metal to the dwarves.

‘Mithril…’ Fíli whispered.

‘Look at how many rings it’s made off, and how closely they are woven together,’ Kíli added, ‘Not even the smallest arrowhead would pierce this armour.’

Bilbo could feel his cheeks warm at their obvious admiration for the object. It must be something quite special.

‘I haven’t seen that for years,’ The Lady said, as she held out her hands to receive it from Bilbo. He handed it over. ‘Where did you get it?’

‘King Thorin--,’ Bilbo cleared his throat. ‘His Majesty gave it to me.’

‘Did he?’ She said quietly, as she brushed her fingers over a row of gemstones.

Lady Dís gave him a strange look as she handed the shirt back to him. ‘You better put it on then. I’m sure that was my brother’s wish.’

Bilbo stood up and removed his jacket and waistcoat. It still surprised him how light the thing was, as he pulled it over his shirt, adjusting it slightly to lie flat over his arms.

‘It fits you perfectly, Uncle Bilbo.’ Frodo stood up and inspected the ends of the sleeves.

‘Very rare thing, Mithril.’ Lady Dís said. ‘Can only be found in the mines of Khazad-dûm.’

‘Mum only has a small dagger with a Mithril handle.’ Kíli said. ‘She’s promised Fíli can have it when he becomes king.’

‘Oh, I didn’t know…’ Bilbo felt like taking the shirt off, the value of it suddenly weighing down on his shoulders.

Their chat was interrupted by a loud sound from outside the door. The company froze.

Bilbo noticed how Fíli’s right hand went to the dagger by his side, while Lady Dís brushed past the two hobbits to take a longsword from a holder on the wall.

Kíli stood up as well, silently standing in front of Bilbo and Frodo and moving them back towards a curtain in the corner of the room.

They could hear shuffling coming from the hall outside.

Kíli kept his eyes on the door, but whispered to the hobbits over his shoulder. ‘There’s a way out. Behind that,’ He gestured to the curtain. ‘It will take you to a hidden path down to the kitchens. From there you can get out of the mountain.’

Frodo’s eyes widened. ‘Why are you telling us this?’

Kíli didn’t answer. ‘Have you got your dagger, Frodo?’

‘Yes, but--,’

‘Good. Stay behind Bilbo and his armour. Only use your weapon as a last resort.’

Bilbo could feel his hands starting to shake, and his eyes travelled back to the chair in which he had been sitting. His book with the letter tucked inside had been left there. Could he retrieve it before they had to…

‘Kíli!’ Lady Dís whispered close by. ‘Don’t scare the hobbits. We don’t yet know what’s going on outside.’

‘It’s best to be prepared.’ Fíli said next to her.

Bilbo drew a deep breath. ‘Why don’t we all go out the hidden door?’

‘The Line of Durin doesn’t run away.’ Kíli muttered.

‘And you think a Baggins does?’ Bilbo huffed, though he couldn’t exactly deny it. He had been running away from a lot in his life.

There was a brief knock at the door.

The group seemed to jump slightly as one before glancing nervously at each other.

‘Well,’ Lady Dís finally said. ‘I don’t think an invading horde of orcs would knock politely before an attack.’

She went slowly to the door, still holding her sword firmly in one hand. Fíli and Kíli stood shoulder to shoulder in front of the hobbits, their hands on their daggers.

Bilbo held his breath as the Lady gradually opened the door, and felt his entire body sag with relief as he saw the red hair of the small dwarf standing outside.

‘Master Ori!’ Lady Dís let her sword fall down to her side.

‘My Lady.’ Ori made a short, nervous bow. ‘May I come in?’

‘Yes, of course.’ She stood aside, letting the librarian enter the room.

Bilbo pressed himself out between Fíli and Kíli to greet his friend. ‘Ori, what are you doing here?’ His gaze dropped to Ori’s hands. He was holding at large leather bound book with a tear going down the spine. It looked fresh, and Ori’s right hand kept going over it, as if trying to repair it with touch alone.

‘Well, you see--,’ His voice shook a bit, as he glanced at the royal dwarves gathering around him. ‘It was really Mr. Dwalin’s idea, and I said it would be silly, but he wouldn’t take no for an answer, and then he brushed my cheek like that, and I really, really...’ Ori trailed off, almost dropping the book before holding it tighter once again in his arms.

‘Won’t you sit down, Master Ori?’ Lady Dís smiled gently at him and led him to a soft chair by the fire. Bilbo sat down next to him after he had redressed in his waistcoat and jacket. Soon they were all gathered again, though the weapons were within easier reach this time.

‘What did Master Dwalin say?’ Bilbo asked.

‘That he wanted me to be safe. That he wanted me to go to the princes. That they would protect me if…if he doesn’t come back.’ He swallowed loudly and clenched his fingers around his book.

‘Let me take that.’ Bilbo murmured as he lifted the tome from Ori’s tight grip.

‘You’re welcome to stay, Master Ori.’ Fíli smiled at the small librarian.

‘Yes, we have enough food, warmth, and company to go around.’ Kíli nodded beside his brother.

Frodo stood up. ‘Let me get you something to eat and drink, Master Ori.’ He clapped his hand on the dwarf’s shoulder and went to the table laden with food. Fíli and Kíli followed him.

Bilbo noticed that Ori’s hands were still trembling, now that he had nothing with which to occupy them. He glanced between the fresh tear in the book and Ori’s nervous movements, and thought that he could guess where that loud sound had come from earlier. Heavy leather hitting stone did create something of a bang.

He looked up into the small dwarf’s eyes. ‘You’re safe, Master Ori. It’s alright now.’

‘But it isn’t, is it?’ He held eye contact. ‘He’s out there now, and-- And I knew I would have to deal with this, when I started courting a captain of the guard. I just didn’t think it would happen so soon. I thought we would be safe and together all through winter.’ He clasped his hands together, trying to keep them calm.

Bilbo nodded slowly. ‘Yes. I know.’

‘He’ll come back to you, Master Ori. You can depend on Dwalin. He has never let anyone down in his life.’ Lady Dís smiled at the librarian as she stood up and went to join Frodo and her sons by the table.

‘And Lady Dís has known your Master Dwalin longer than any of us,’ Bilbo said, trying to fake confidence for Ori’s sake. ‘Even though I have only known him a little while, I am fully convinced Master Dwalin would defy Eru himself just to return to you.’

Ori wiped his eyes. ‘Thank you.’ He said with a thick voice.

Bilbo turned the book over in his hands. It had no title or any other marks to distinguish it.

‘What is this that you’ve brought with you?’

‘Oh,’ Ori sniffed slightly, though Bilbo pretended not to have heard. ‘Do you remember me telling you that we have very little information about hobbits in the library of Erebor?’

‘Yes?’

‘Well, that’s our only volume on the subject. It was written by a travelling tradesman, and is considered to be a comprehensive study of the hobbit race.’

‘Really?’ Bilbo was curious to know how these dwarves described the Shire and its inhabitants.

‘Yes, and I was wondering if you would read it and tell me if anything’s incorrect.’ Ori paused. ‘It would give us something to do this night while…while we wait.’

‘Of course, Master Ori.’ He smiled. ‘I’d be glad to.’

‘Thank you. And just Ori, please.’ The young dwarf gave him a shy smile, though Bilbo could still see tracks of tears down his cheeks.

He carefully opened the volume, mindful of not disturbing the tear along the spine anymore than he had to, and started reading from the first page.

Lady Dís, Fíli, Kíli, and Frodo rejoined them by the fire, carrying plates of food and drinks. Bilbo glanced up to see Ori gratefully accepting a small drink of that strong liquor from the Lady. Frodo had sat on the floor between his two seated friends, laughingly fending off slices of ham being placed on his head by the lads.

Ori relaxed into his chair, smiling at the warm company surrounding him. ‘Though there are some strange facts in that book,’ he said, ‘For example, it says that hobbits don’t get children, you know, the usual way.’ Bilbo smiled at seeing the librarian’s ears reddening slightly.

‘Really?’ Fíli said, chewing on a piece of ham he had taken from behind Frodo’s ear.

‘Yes,’ Ori nodded. ‘Apparently, they cut the hair off their feet and plant it in fertile soil. And within a year: Hobbit babies, ready to harvest!’

‘Yeah, I’ve heard that as well.’ Kíli said seriously while gesturing with a chicken drumstick.

‘Nonsense!’ Frodo laughed as he turned to look up at his friends. ‘You don’t really believe that, do you?’

‘If it says so in a book, Frodo,’ Kíli grinned, ‘Then it must be true.’

‘You must forgive my sons, Frodo.’ Lady Dís smiled, ‘But they have always been complete idiots.’

‘Hey!’ Fíli said while Kíli placed his hand on his chest, soothing an imaginary injury. Frodo and Ori giggled while Bilbo chuckled quietly to himself.

‘Well,’ Bilbo said, ‘That’s the first misapprehension that needs to be corrected. Where does it say that thing about planting hobbit children, Ori?’

‘Under “Mating Rituals and Fertility”.’

‘I don’t like that book,’ Frodo said sourly. ‘It makes us hobbits sound like strange, mythical beasts.’

‘Well, before I met the two of you, I did rather think a hobbit would be half a rabbit, half something else.’ Kíli said while Fíli nodded next to him.

‘As I said,’ Lady Dís said drily, ‘Idiots.’

A short laugh moved about the group but died down again. They sat quietly, listening to the wind howling outside and the hiss of the fireplace. Once in a while, the silence would be broken by Bilbo turning a heavy page or the sound of a cup being placed on a table.

‘Do you think they’ll have reached the cave by now?’ Ori whispered into the dark, silent room.

‘Probably.’ Fíli murmured.

Bilbo stopped reading and thought about King Thorin’s sword and how it had clanked against his heavy armour. Both parts had looked sturdy and well-made, and the King wore them with confidence, as if he was used to them. Would they protect him or slow him down in battle?

‘It seems very cold tonight,’ Frodo drew his knees up to his chest, hugging his legs with his arms.

‘That’s the sound of the wind tricking you.’ Lady Dís said as she stared into the flames.

A chair creaked as someone put down a used plate on a table.

‘I knitted Mr. Dwalin a thick scarf to wear above his armour.’ Ori whispered. ‘I didn’t even check to see if he had it on when I said goodbye to him. What if he’s forgotten it?’

‘I’m sure he didn’t, Ori.’ Bilbo leaned forward and put his hand on the dwarf’s knee, squeezing slightly.

Silence surrounded them. It was as if the mountain itself held its breath while it awaited its fate.

‘How long until morning?’ Kíli asked.

‘It’ll be hours yet.’ Lady Dís said. ‘I’d better put another log on the fire.’

But she didn’t move. None of them did. They just sat quietly, listening for unfamiliar noises, and thinking about the absent ones out there in the darkness.