Actions

Work Header

A Most Sensible Idea

Chapter Text

Bilbo was nothing if not a conscientious hobbit. And even if that raven had been intolerably rude, he would do what he had promised.

He had to seek out the King to give him the message.

This turned out to be more difficult than he had thought.

‘His Majesty is working in his office.’ A passing servant told him.

‘He’s gone off to a meeting with his council.’ A snobbish office scribe glanced at Bilbo shortly before returning to her work.

‘I’m sorry to say that his Majesty is not here.’ An advisor said, looking to his colleagues for confirmation.

Bilbo almost growled in frustration. ‘Do you know where he is then?’

‘I think you should ask Master Dwalin. It’s his job to know where the King is at all times.’

Bilbo rolled his eyes as he went out the door.

Dwalin wasn’t in the library with Ori or at the guards’ quarters. But a guard knew where Bilbo could find him.

‘He’s down in the Cave of Stars with the King.’ The guard moved closer to the hobbit, his hand touching the small of Bilbo’s back. ‘Do you need me to show you the way, little one?’

Bilbo moved away from his touch, forcing a polite smile, though he didn’t know why he was being nice to such a presumptuous dwarf.

‘No, thank you. I can manage to find my way.’

‘Pity.’ The guard’s smirking face disappeared from view as Bilbo shut the door behind him.

Now, the Cave of Stars. Bilbo could well remember that day down in the mines when he, Fíli, and Kíli had got lost on their way to that place. And, when he had finally found the cave, how bright those lights had shone on the dark ceiling above them, how close King Thorin had stood next to him, and how the visit had abruptly ended when the King’s mood had suddenly turned sour. Bilbo hoped to find him in a more convivial frame of mind today. At least enough to receive a short message from the hobbit who kissed him.

He found the stairs going down into the mines and started his slow descent, mindful of tilted and slippery steps. At the bottom, he took a torch and lit it in a nearby fireplace, knowing that he was going into the darkest parts of the mountain.

Sounds of miners working the stone echoed around him, and Bilbo found it a comfort to know that he was not alone down here in the dark. He thought of Bofur and his friends joking as they worked, their bodies steaming with sweat in this cold and stony hollow.

He came to the large underground lake and stopped to admire the black stillness of the water. He leant over the railing, reaching down with his torch to shine a light on the surface, wondering if there was anything alive down there.

BOOM

Bilbo started as the walls shook around him, and he felt his torch slip from his hand. He grabbed frantically for it, but could only watch as the small light fell down, finally extinguishing in the lake beneath him.

Darkness surrounded him. Bilbo had never been in total darkness before. Through force of habit, he waited for his eyes to adapt, waited for the surroundings to appear as murky silhouettes before him. But nothing changed. Everything was black. There was no source of light this far underground.

He tried to stay calm as he clenched his fingers around the railing. If he kept hold of this, he might be able to find his way back to the stairs. His usually nimble feet shuffled over the stony floor, feeling for any obstacles in his way. The lack of sight had heightened his sense of hearing, and the sounds of footsteps and voices echoed around him. Before he had found the noises comforting, but in his blindness they became spooky. He had no idea where they were coming from, and his body tensed in anticipation of what he might meet in the dark.

The sound of his heart was loud in his chest, and his breath seemed to race alongside it. He closed his eyes and opened them again. It made not difference. All around him was darkness, and he was alone.

But suddenly up ahead, he saw light moving towards him. He bowed his head over the railing and clenched his eyes shut. Oh, thank Yavanna, Eru and all the others. He would not be abandoned down here.

He moved slowly towards the source of the light, and he heard voices coming from the same place.

‘I thought they weren’t doing any major excavations today?’

Well, Bilbo thought, from the sound of that voice at least I’ve finally found King Thorin.

‘I’ll go and see what’s going on.’

And that brazen guard had been right: Dwalin was down here as well.

The light in the distance split into two, one moving quickly away from Bilbo while the other stayed still.

As he moved closer, his hand brushing against the stone wall to keep him grounded, he started to make out the details of the figure holding the torch. It was undoubtedly the King, the grey in his hair shining in the darkness.

He decided to call out to the dwarf instead of jumping out from the shadows and surprising him.

‘Your Majesty.’ His voice was weak from his earlier shock and the words faltered and faded in his mouth.

King Thorin whirled around, shining his torch in front of him. ‘Who’s there?’

Bilbo stepped into the reach of the light, shielding his sensitive eyes from the powerful glare.

The King breathed out heavily at the sight of him. ‘What are you doing down here?!’ His tone was brusque and loud, making Bilbo flinch away from him.

‘I--,’ Bilbo started.

‘And where’s your torch? How can you even think of going down here without a torch?’ The King strode to where Bilbo was standing, shining all around, seemingly looking for something else.

‘I had a torch, but--,’

‘Did someone leave you down here alone? Was it one of your miner friends?’

Bilbo made a frustrated sound, his hands going to his hair. ‘Will you listen to me?’

‘No, you listen to me. I can’t have you doing something like this; like going down to the mines alone. Not now.’ King Thorin stared into Bilbo’s eyes. ‘Not ever.’

Bilbo crossed his arms and stood straighter, refusing to be cowed by the King’s imposing presence. ‘First of all, I could go and jump off the side of the mountain and you wouldn’t be able to stop me. You have no say in what I do.’

‘And don’t I know it.’ King Thorin mumbled.

‘Second of all,’ Bilbo continued, ignoring the King’s mutterings. ‘I wouldn’t even be down here in this dank and horrible place, if I didn’t have to give you a message.’

‘A message?’ The King frowned, stepping closer. ‘From you?’

‘N-no.’ Bilbo stammered. ‘From Fortinbras Took. From the Shire.’

The King’s hand, which was holding the torch aloft, dropped a bit. King Thorin looked away, taking a deep breath as he squared his shoulders. ‘What’s the message?’

‘”It’s a deal.”’ Bilbo waited for some kind of reaction but none came. ‘I’m sorry, but that’s all the raven told me. I don’t know what it means, but--,’

‘No, it’s fine.’ King Thorin closed his eyes briefly. ‘It’s good.’

Bilbo studied the flickering shadows on the cave wall as they stood in silence for a moment. He finally cleared his throat to speak.

‘Are you going to tell me what this is all about?’

‘Not right now. Later, perhaps.’

Bilbo swallowed. ‘At least tell me if it’s about Frodo?’

‘No.’ King Thorin looked back into Bilbo’s eyes. ‘It’s not about Frodo.’

 

X—X

 

The snow kept thawing the following days after that moment in the lower mines.

Bilbo looked up from his book in the library to stare at the melting icicles. They gleamed in the sun, and sweated heavy drops down past the open window. These were quickly followed by a heavy slush of snow, falling from somewhere further up the mountain.

He was interrupted in his thoughts by Ori, who laid that silly book on hobbits on the table in front of him.

‘Do you have the time to continue this?’ He asked Bilbo, not waiting for an answer before finding pieces of parchment and a quill.

Bilbo blinked at the sudden intrusion. Ori mostly slipped around silently in the library, often only greeting Bilbo with a warm smile when he arrived and a friendly wave when he left. He knew that Bilbo prized this place as a sanctuary and only talked when Bilbo instigated a conversation.

‘Yes, of course. But what’s the rush? We’re more than halfway through already.’ Bilbo smiled. ‘Didn’t we finish “Seasons and Holidays” last time?’

‘Yes, and we have to get through the entire book before the passage down the mountain clears.’ Ori opened the book to find the next chapter, not noticing how still Bilbo had become next to him.

‘Why would that matter?’ Bilbo said slowly.

Did Ori know something? Bilbo hadn’t shared his desire to leave Erebor with anybody else but Frodo. And that was before the snows had imprisoned him for the winter. He had longed for spring to come, but didn’t think his longing had been so intense as to show on his face for anyone who cared to look.

Ori looked up and smiled at him. ‘Oh, it isn’t true then?’

Bilbo frowned. ‘What is?’

‘I said to Dori that it didn’t make sense. Dori, that’s my brother.’ Ori straightened the parchments and opened a pot of ink. ‘But he was so adamant, and they hadn’t been seen together in such a long time, and then that scribe told me--,’

‘Ori!’ Bilbo interrupted him loudly. ‘You’re not making any sense. What has your brother got to do with the snow thawing on the mountain?’

Ori slowly replaced the quill in the inkpot. ‘Well, my brother has a tea stall in the market place. Do you know it?’

‘Yes, I know it. Just get on with the story.’

‘Right. And of course, he gets a lot of talkative customers. One of his frequent customers is a royal guard, who told him what he had heard from a chambermaid, who regularly lights the fires in the room where the King’s council meets.’

Bilbo blinked rapidly. ‘So a maid told a royal guard, who told your brother, and now you’re telling me?’

Ori smiled and gave a relieved nod. ‘Yes.’

Bilbo raised his eyebrows expectantly when the librarian didn’t continue. ‘Told me what?’

‘Oh! That the courtship between Frodo and the King is finished.’

Bilbo’s jaw dropped and he gawped at the dwarf sitting next to him. ‘I don’t… I don’t think that’s true.’

‘No, it obviously isn’t, or you would know about it.’ Ori took up his quill again. ‘I’m so glad it isn’t true! I was afraid the two of you would leave Erebor as soon as possible, and at the rate the snow was thawing, we would have no time at all to finish this project.’ He pushed the book on hobbits closer to Bilbo.

Bilbo stared down at the words on the page, but the shapes made no sense to him. He looked back up at Ori. ‘You mentioned something about a scribe earlier..?’

‘He was working here in the library and overheard Frodo complaining about the King, about how tiresome this courtship was?’ Ori looked expectantly at Bilbo for either a confirmation or a denial.

Bilbo thought about the royal guard, and the maid, and the scribe, and Ori’s brother with the talkative customers. Every one of them was obviously willing to share their bits of gossip with someone else. He closed his eyes. What were the chances that the news of Frodo’s discontentment hadn’t travelled all around Erebor and back again? And it must have reached King Thorin’s ears as well.

He needed to fix this.

Without thinking, Bilbo stood up, his chair scraping against the rough floor.

Ori looked up at him. ‘Are you alright, Bilbo?’

‘No. I need to speak with the King.’ He moved away from the table, buttoning his jacket as he went. ‘Do you know where I can find him now?’

‘Yes, he must be holding court in the throne room right about now.’ Ori stood and followed Bilbo. ‘But I don’t think they’ll take kindly to interruptions. Can’t it wait? Come and sit back down.’

‘No, it can’t wait.’ Bilbo threw open the door. ‘I have to go.’

 

X—X

 

His steps slowed as he neared the throne room. Bilbo stopped completely, contemplating the closed door and the two guards placed on either side of it.

One of the guards glanced at Bilbo hovering in the hallway, but turned his head back to gaze at the empty space in front of him.

Bilbo took a deep breath and went up to the two dwarves. ‘Could you please let me into the throne room?’

‘No admittance.’ One of the guards said shortly, looking above Bilbo’s head to the wall behind him.

‘But surely--,’ Bilbo started before he was interrupted by the other guard.

‘His Majesty and his council are working.’

Bilbo pressed his lips together in annoyance, expelling a short burst of air through his nose. Impossible dwarves! He moved away from the door, walking a couple of steps down the hallway.

Just as he was about to turn back and abandon his mission, something lit up inside him. No, he wasn’t going to give up now. Not while he still had his wits about him. Maybe he could use this unfortunate situation between Frodo and the King to his advantage.

He went back to the guards, smiling politely. ‘But I have a message from his Majesty’s intended.’

He saw the guards glancing at each other. The one on the left hesitated before he addressed Bilbo.

‘You can leave the message with us.’ He paused, nodding to his partner. ‘We’ll make sure his Majesty receives it when he’s not busy.’

‘Oh, no, I couldn’t do that.’ Bilbo rocked back and forth on his feet.

The guards stood straighter. ‘Why not?’ One of them said. ‘You can rely on us. We won’t tell anyone but the King.’

‘It’s not that.’ Bilbo smiled charmingly. ‘I know that the guards of Erebor are known for their discretion. But this is a… personal matter between the King and his intended.’ He raised his eyebrows meaningfully.

The guards shifted slightly and shared a look between them. ‘I don’t know…’ the one on the right said.

Bilbo straightened and put his hands behind his back, ready to walk away. ‘Right! I’ll just let the King know that it was you two who hindered his longed-for reunion with his beloved.’

‘Master Baggins?’ One of them called out to him as he turned down the hallway. ‘It’s not a complicated message? It won’t take long?’

Bilbo looked down at the floor to hide his smile. ‘No, I just need a quick visit.’

The guard on the right put his ear to the wooden door, his face set in concentration. ‘Alright.’ He pulled back. ‘Go on in now.’

Bilbo smiled brightly. ‘Thank you! I’ll be sure to tell the King how helpful you were.’

The guards cracked the door open and Bilbo slipped inside.

As the door shut behind him, the sound of it echoed through the large and sparsely furnished room. The cold stone lay before his feet, no carpet to muffle his step as he proceeded through the wide expanse of the throne room. On both sides of him he could see groups of advisors and scribes working by tables or conversing in the corners. Most of them stopped whatever they were doing to follow his progress towards the throne at the top of the room.

Bilbo looked straight ahead, his eyes on the two dwarves directly in front of him. King Thorin was sitting on the ostentatious throne while Balin was bending over him, a quiet discussion going on between them.

Somewhere in the room, something dropped heavily down, making a loud, blunt noise. The King instinctively looked up from his talk with his advisor and finally noticed Bilbo making his way towards him. He sat straighter in his seat, his hands gripping the sturdy armrests of the throne. Balin looked up as well, a small smile growing on his face as he spotted the hobbit.

The room was completely silent when Bilbo finally came to a stop in front of the throne. He swallowed, trying to clear his throat silently, and stood straighter with his feet apart to address King Thorin on his throne.

‘Your Majesty.’ Bilbo sketched a bow, hearing a slight echo of his voice going around the room. ‘I would speak with you.’

The King sat forward in his seat. ‘Yes?’

Bilbo glanced at the many dwarves milling around the room. They all had eyes and ears, and he would prefer it if no more dwarves learnt about that false rumour concerning Frodo and the King ending their courtship. Even if it was denounced thoroughly, remnants of it would always linger in the minds of the inhabitants of Erebor. It would be better to limit its reach now.

He moved closer to the King and lowered his voice. ‘Could- could we talk privately, your Majesty?’

King Thorin was silent, studying the hobbit’s face. Bilbo didn’t think he was asking for a lot. Maybe there was some small room close by that they could quickly go to and—

‘Right. Everybody leave.’ The King’s voiced boomed throughout the room, followed by the noises of advisors, scribes and guards scuttling through various doors. Balin passed Bilbo on his way out, putting a reassuring hand on his shoulder.

Bilbo turned in a circle to see the abandoned and silent room surrounding him. His gaze returned to the King who stood up from his throne and ambled down to Bilbo.

‘Well, Master Baggins,’ he murmured, standing quite close. ‘What could be so important that you had to interrupt the work of my council?’

Bilbo took a step back, needing to be further away from King Thorin’s intoxicating presence. ‘I had to talk to you.’

A small smile twitched around the King’s lips. ‘Yes, so I gathered.’ He kept staring at Bilbo’s face, shifting his gaze between his eyes and his mouth.

‘It’s about Frodo.’

‘Oh.’ The King turned back towards his throne. ‘I see.’

Bilbo breathed out slowly as the heat of the King moved away. ‘I heard a most disturbing rumour today.’ He said as he followed King Thorin with his eyes.

The King sat back down on his throne, slumping slightly in his seat. ‘Really? About Frodo?’

Bilbo moved a bit closer. ‘And about you.’

King Thorin tapped some indefinable rhythm on the arm of his throne, humming indifferently. ‘Well, I wouldn’t let it bother you. There’ll always be stories going around about the King and those closest to him.’

Bilbo frowned and looked down at his feet.

‘Though,’ the King said, ‘From the look on your face, it must be something more serious than the usual gossip.’ He sat forward in his seat. ‘Please…tell me?’

‘I’m surprised you don’t know already. The stories seem to have been circling around all of Erebor for the last day or two.’ Bilbo took a deep breath. ‘It’s being said that Frodo has been complaining about you in public, and that you’ve halted your courtship with him. But it isn’t true!’ Bilbo didn’t feel one ounce of remorse at lying to the King, not when it came to protecting his nephew’s reputation.

‘Oh.’ King Thorin looked away.

‘You believe me, don’t you? What they’re saying about Frodo... I mean, his words must have been misunderstood.’

‘I hadn’t heard that rumour.’ A muscle tightened along the King’s jaw. ‘But I believe you when you say it isn’t true.’

Bilbo felt tension leaving his body. ‘Thank you.’

‘Is that all?’ King Thorin sat up straighter.

‘No…’ Bilbo hesitated. ‘If I could ask for one favour?’

The King nodded, but he still wasn’t looking at Bilbo.

‘I think the two of you should make some sort of appearance together in public.’ He said, trying to catch King Thorin’s gaze. ‘Just to put the rumours to rest. To show that your courtship is still happening. And that Frodo has done nothing wrong.’

The King sat in silence for a moment, his hand moving restlessly. ‘I can’t do that.’ He looked back into Bilbo’s eyes for a moment. ‘I’m so sorry.’ He closed his eyes against the sight of Bilbo’s confused face. ‘I wish I could have been the first to tell you.’

‘What are you saying?’ Bilbo held his breath.

The restless hand clenched into a fist, and the King made an aborted strike against the side of the throne. ‘It shouldn’t have left this room! Not yet, anyway.’ He made a frustrated growl. ‘I should have known that it would be difficult to keep such a secret within the council.’

Bilbo started to suspect, but he could barely believe it. ‘Tell me. Please.’

King Thorin brushed his long hair out of his face with an abrupt gesture and finally looked into Bilbo’s eyes.

‘I’m stopping the courtship.’