Actions

Work Header

Rice Wine

Chapter 3: Worried black raven.

Notes:

In case none of you have read any of my other stuff with Bard's family in it, Satomi is his wife (and she's alive, because I'm done with killing off women for the sake of men's stories), Sigrid is most definitely the oldest and his heir, and Tilda is trans. Bilbo is also intersex btw. I should have mentioned that earlier but forgot. Enjoy.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Tilda likes Mr. Baggins. Grand Master Gardener, Bain says she should call him now.

Mr. Baggins laughs when she tells him. “Just call me Bilbo,” he says.

“You call me Tilda then,” she says, “no Princess.”

They shake on it. It’s the first time they meet officially, after everything. Tilda decides she likes him. Her opinion doesn’t change later, which doesn’t surprise her. She won’t often change her mind about people.

“You have a way with the earth,” she says when they’re sitting in a small garden attached to the royal manse of Dale. The manse is bigger than any house she has ever known, even the Master’s back in Laketown. She loves the balconies best when she’s on her own, catching the wind and its secrets, walking barefoot over cool peach stone, watching the kites as they turn above her. But when Bilbo is here, she prefers the gardens. He looks like he belongs, even besides the deepening brown of his skin that speaks of days spent bent over shoots and fingernails dirty with earth. There’s something about how he knows the soil that’s amazing to be part of.

Bilbo smiles at her. “Do I now?”

“Yes. Do all hobbits? Are they all like you?”

He nods, humming contentedly. “Peace, and good green growing things. That’s what hobbits are best at.”

“Not all humans are like me, I think.”

“Oh?”

“Hm. I’ve never met someone else who could – you know.”

Bilbo’s grin can’t seem to contain itself. “We are unique, it seems.”

“It more ways than one.”

They laugh, and Tilda watches Bilbo coax a tulip to brightness.

“One of my gardeners, you know,” he says after a while, “zir like us.”

“Zir?” Tilda tries the word on her tongue.

“Yes, zir. Ze is neither male nor female. I’m told there’s a dwarven term, you know, how your folk have ‘man’ and ‘woman’. They have an awful lot more apparently. Which might sound very confusing at first but you soon get used to. Gender is rather different for dwarves than it is for humans, or even hobbits. Would that I had known that sooner. It would have made things a lot easier.”

Tilda sniggers. “Like going to the loo.”

“And talking about babies,” Bilbo adds, joining in the game.

“And husbands and wives – oh, what would your gardener call zir – wait, how would I say, um, self?”

“Zirself. You know, I’m not sure. I shall ask. Maybe partner.”

Partner. Dwarves think of everything. “It was funny, talking to a dwarf. Ma and da took years to get it. But the first dwarf I said it to, you know what they said?”

“What?”

“They said – they said ‘oh yes, we’ve got all sorts of words for that’. Ma and da didn’t have any words.”

“In the Shire,” Bilbo says just as the tulip quivers in his hands, “we still have a lot of words left over from our Wandering Years, but with the Big Folk we just say man or woman. They don’t much get it, you know. Some of the Bree folk aren’t so bad. But most can’t deal with how our bodies are. But for ourselves, well, we don’t much bother about it.”

“That seems sensible. Huh.”

Bilbo finishes with the tulip, and the rest of the garden flutters for his attention. Tilda pulls a wind down to rustle through the plants, wondering what it’s like to feel all the roots and the leaves they way she feels air.

“What do hobbits call this?” She asks, gesturing to where Bilbo is digging a finger into the soil around a lavender bush.

Bilbo shrugs. “We usually just say ‘green fingers’. ‘Earth-sense’ too, now I think on it.”

“We’d say magic. At least, that’s what ma says about my stuff.”

“Magic works too, yes. Though we associate that more with fairies and folk tales than actual living people.”

The rest of the day is spent thusly: Tilda following Bilbo around the garden as he coaxes the plants to their best and she pulls in the occasional stray breeze. The garden flourishes in his company. Tilda thinks he wouldn’t even need to do anything to make a change, just sit there and be. The plants drink up his presence. She remembers, after a long and difficult talk with her da and the dwarven King, Bilbo asking her to lead him somewhere green. He’d been so angry that the first footstep onto soil had made the plants cringe back. She’d never seen the like. She’d asked a servant to bring some very strong tea – Bilbo liked tea, she knew without asking – and had encouraged him to drink it while they walked around the garden’s edge, the flora shaking as they passed.

“Infuriating, infuriating man!” Bilbo had almost tossed his tea several times, insensible to what his hands were doing. Tilda was dancing about in anticipation of it flying her way.

“He was trying to help, wasn’t he?” She was certain she knew who they were talking about – it leaked from Bilbo’s skin like water through a sieve – but she was less sure why.

“Help! He’s obstructing me at every turn.” Finally he stilled, coming round to face her and taking a furious sip from his cup. “Don’t worry about it, it’s – it’s nothing, really.”

“But it’s not.” She liked Bilbo. She didn’t want him to be upset.

“Well, yes, fine. But it’s not for young ears.”

“My ears aren’t young!” She was nearly twelve, thank you.

“Young enough, little lady.”

“Fine. Go talk to an adult then. To my ma. She’ll listen”

Bilbo shuffled. “No, no. It would make things terribly awkward. She’s the Queen. She shouldn’t take sides.”

“She wouldn’t be Queen. She’d just be my ma.”

Bilbo resisted, but eventually, after spending an hour or more in the garden, he went to see her ma. She came to Tilda later, just before Tilda was going to bed.

“That was a good thing you did, darling.” Her ma smiled softly, tucking the covers gently around her.

“Yeah?”

“Yes. It is good, to unburden things. I am glad you sent the Grand Master to me.”

“He was sad,” she said, “I don’t want him to be sad. It hurts him.” She knew she wasn’t old enough for a lot of things, but the was Bilbo ached, the way the air down from the mountain’s terraces spoke of loneliness and pain and wounding conversations was enough for her to know something was very wrong.

Her ma sat on the edge of her bed and stroked her hair. “I know. But...darling, I know your heart. So big and loving. But do not try to fix this by yourself.”

“But he needs help. I want to help.”

“I know, Tilda. But sometimes we cannot fix things as we would wish. You cannot do all that you wish for people, as hard as it is to bear. Be a friend. But leave time and space to be his healers.”

She knew, and still knows, that her mother was right. She also knows Bilbo doesn’t have time or space. Not enough to heal. She knows of nothing that might help him, really. Save the gardens.

So she sits with him. Let’s the plants brighten him just as he brightens them.

“Bilbo,” she says, remembering what she’d hoped to share today, “there’s something I wanted to show you!”

Bilbo nods kindly, and stops his work on the lavender bush to look at her. She waves him over to a good spot, somewhere where the sun is shining best and he’ll be able to see.

“I’ve been learning earthy things,” she tells him. “Just a few. I’m not very good at it.”

“I’m sure you’ll be fine,” he says.

They’re kneeling in front of a small wildflower bush, leaves a soft green-grey and the flowers petite and blue. She’s practised with others like it the most, so she’s more confident her spell will work now with this plant than any other.

“Use your, um, earth-sense,” she says, “don’t do anything, just feel.”

Bilbo does as she bids, looking quite amused. “Okay, now what?”

“Have you felt it? The plant?”

“Yes.”

“Ok, then stop. I’m gonna do my bit now.”

He removes his fingers from the surrounding soil. Tilda pushes herself up onto her knees and lets the wind calm her for a second. She’s been practicing this for a while, during her midday break from tutors when her ma allows her to bring her lunch outside into the garden. Tauriel has given her a few pointers, broken down what she knows of Mirkwood’s own earth magics. It’s different, Tilda thinks, from what Bilbo does. But it’s very useful. Maybe she should bring Tauriel to the gardens with Bilbo, one day. It would be fun.

She tunes out the wind. Instead she tries to listen to the leaves and stems and roots of the plant. The plant doesn’t move for her like it does for Bilbo, but she thinks maybe she can hear it: a faint singing, or humming, she’s not sure. Maybe it’s just an echo. But it’s enough. Her hands settle either side of the bush, like a barrier.

She holds the word in her mind. Bronia.

She holds it on the tip of her tongue. Bronia.

She speaks it aloud. “Bronia.”

Instantly she feels a connection with the plant, feels the word touch it and change it, strengthen it. A shadow uncurls in her mind of roots stretching down and leaves uncurling thicker than before.

“I did it I did it I did it!” Practically squealing with delight, she leaps up to run about the garden to the sound of her own laughter. Bilbo chuckles as he watches her, and catches her deftly when she throws herself at him.

“I can’t believe it worked,” she says, sitting herself down again. “Check it! Check what I did.”

Bilbo does, digging his fingers into the soil once more. Tilda bobs in place, watching. She calls the wind back to her, giggling in its embrace.

“Good gracious,” Bilbo says, “good gracious me. What did you do?”

“Tauriel helped me. It’s something they use in Mirkwood, to help.”

“Bronia, you said? Is that a Sindarin word?”

“Yep,” she says, bouncing onto her knees, “it makes it last better. Endure, Bain said it meant.”

Bilbo laughs, and it turns hollow somewhere along the way. “Oh, if that isn’t my word of the moment. Maybe you should put that spell on me! I have been doing a lot of enduring lately.”

Tilda isn’t sure what he means. “It...doesn’t work on people.”

He touches a gentle hand to the bush, the other still in the surrounding soil. “I know. But a silly old hobbit is allowed to hope. Very well done, Tilda. Very well done indeed.”

“You could stay here, you know,” she says, and she hadn’t meant to say it, but now it’s out of her mouth she is determined that Bilbo knows it’s true. “You wouldn’t have to endure so much here. You could have a holiday from enduring.”

He looks at her, eyes wide. His mouth opens and shuts a few times. “That’s not a thing a child can promise,” he says eventually.

“Ask Bain, he’ll tell you,” she says, and before Bilbo can get a word in she’s pulling him up, her elation at the spell forgotten. “Come on, Bain will tell you I’m right.”

“I don’t think Bain can promise that either.” And does Bilbo ever look regretful of the fact.

“Could my ma?”

“Yes, I suppose. But I don’t think –”

“Come on,” she says, not really paying attention to his protests, “let’s go.” She pulls him around the manse until she finds her mother, sitting in her solar with Bain and some of their servants. Tilda doesn’t really think they’re normal servants – they’re much too sneaky, the winds tell her. She waits until they’ve sat her and Bilbo down and served them tea, her legs swinging impatiently all the while, before asking for some privacy. Only once the last servant has left does she answer her ma’s confused look. Twice. She may have tumbled over her words the first time.

“Tilda is right,” her ma says once Tilda’s talked herself dry. “And I know my husband is in agreement with me. You shall always have a room in this house.”

“Always,” Tilda says.

Bain gets Bilbo a tissue as he starts to cry.

It’s a week later – a Tuesday, and she’s been up since the first suggestions of dawn, careening around the balconies and generally worrying her servants silly – when Tauriel shows up in the manse griping about spiders and border patrols and spiders and how she’s desperate for a few fingers of whiskey.

“I know where we keep some,” Tilda says, hanging off the back of Tauriel’s shoulders, “do you want me to show you?”

Tauriel frowns, swirling Tilda about to make her giggle. “Are you not a little bit young to know such things, mellon? It is hard to tell age with the younger races.”

“I suppose, but it’s not like I drink it. Though I could. I’m nearly twelve.”

Tauriel mutters to herself. “Twelve!”

“That’s very old among humans. Honest.”

“No it isn’t,” Sigrid says, appearing in Tilda’s vision. She’s gone for dwarven fashions again today; thick boots up to her knees and light burgundy trousers, a grey coat buttoned close to her skin down to her waist, where it flutters outward, skimming her hips and stopping at her thighs. It’s a style she usually chooses when she wants to practise her spear work, and contrasts bluntly with Tilda’s yellow and rose coloured dress.

“Is.” Tilda retorts.

“Isn’t.”

“Is.”

“Isn’t.”

“Is is is and forever. I win.”

Sigrid rolls her eyes.

“After whiskey, can we go and see Bilbo?” Tilda asks. “I really want you to see his gardens. I want to see his gardens.”

Tauriel swings her once more, then places her down. “Have you not yet seen them? I confess myself surprised.”

“I’m allowed, anytime I want. But Bilbo’s just always come here instead.”

Tauriel thinks on it for a while, and in the meantime they wander towards the kitchens so she can get a drink – water, in the end, not whiskey – Sigrid two steps behind them. Tilda’s trying not to be pushy, but she really wants to see some of Bilbo’s terraces. To see his plants and his apprentices, to look at the hedges he has round the borders, to note the differences between his herb terraces and his vegetable ones, to find out what colours he’s conjured. But she also wants to see if what the winds tell her is true. If the soil tells the same story.

She’s worried it will.

Tauriel agrees, but insists that Tilda eats breakfast first and ask her parents. Ma and da are happy enough, though they are adamant that they send Sigrid too.

“I want to join the practise in the yard,” Sigrid objects.

Da frowns heavily in a way Tilda knows means he’s thought about this carefully. “You mean as you have been doing for the past five days?” He says.

Sigrid says nothing, but juts up her chin.

“What is it your weapons master says?”

“She says a lot of things, da.”

“Aye, and one of them, if I’m not mistaken, is that being a warrior is about more than swinging your weapon all clever like –”

Sigrid releases a blustery breath. “About more than the precision of your weapon, da, honestly.”

Her da grins. “Right, right, and what’s the rest of it?”

“It’s also about learning what you can from other spheres of knowledge,” she says, slowing her speech. She knows she’s been beaten. “It helps you appreciate what you’re fighting for.”

Her da raises a questioning brow.

“Fine, fine.” Sigrid says.

Tilda cheers. All to the good as far as she’s concerned.

When they arrive in the Gardener’s Halls, Tilda almost regrets knocking. The door is a breathtaking bit of art.

“Remind me,” she says to Sigrid, poking her, “to bring Bain and ma here.”

Sigrid grunts.

A dwarf who introduces herself as Gróa ushers them in and tries to announce them. Tries, because Tilda flings herself heedlessly out into the garden and barrels into Bilbo. Sigrid scolds her, but Tilda just blows a raspberry in retaliation. Bilbo chuckles.

“Welcome, welcome,” he says.

Tauriel is immediately interested in the hedging they are using to protect the gardens from the wind, as Tilda thought she would be. Sigrid predictably spends the entire time staring out over the garden and beyond. Tilda, though, spends her time much more productively.

“Is your apprentice here? You know the one. I want to meet – to meet zir, if that’s alright.”

Bilbo sighs in mock-suffering. “I suppose,” he says, grinning. “Halli! There’s someone here you should meet.”

 It’s as good as Tilda hoped it would be. Halli is very interesting, knowing a lot about how to treat vegetables right and the various moods of trees. Then they get talking in earnest about, well.

“Ma and da say I was always trying on Sigrid’s dresses,” Tilda says. “I don’t know if I ever really thought I was a boy.”

“The moment you could speak,” Sigrid adds in, still staring out into the blue, “you were demanding I brush and braid your hair. Wouldn’t let da cut it neither.”

Tilda nods. That sounds right. She nudges Halli a bit. She likes Halli.

“What clothing do you like best?” She asks.

“Well now,” Halli murmurs, scratching zir chin, “it changes on the day most times. Dwarves ain’t got much truck with making woman wear one thing and men another and then ignoring the rest – ‘the rest’, bah, I wish this tongue had the proper words. We let each to their own, so to speak. Don’t make no mind to one person what another wears, does it? Shouldn’t leastways.”

“So you wear whatever you want.”

“Course. Now there’s fashions and such, and you still get rich folk wearing things the rest of us can’t hope to buy, and some of the Guilds and families get very protective over certain motifs and braid patterns. But Mahal didn’t want us fussing over gender the way you humans do, beyond making sure you know what people want to be called and what-not.”

“I think,” Tilda says, thoughts whirling about her mind, “I’m going to have to get someone to write this all down. This is the kind of thing we should know.”

“You could make a book about it,” Bilbo says.

“Only if you tell me about hobbits too. About you. You could start now.”

“Right, well.” Bilbo squints into the sunlight a little and laughs. “Hobbits all look the same when we’re born, or near enough, and most only settle on their gender around thirty-three, which is when we come of age. I wore dresses for many years. They were pretty.”

Tilda nods, patting her own dress happily.

Sigrid snorts. “Dresses don’t make you a girl.”

“I never said they did. I just liked them. It’s only humans who think one kind of clothing makes you one kind of person, which is why I said it. Hobbits wear whatever is easiest, or nicest, or most comfortable. Course, when I was old enough to run about with my mother trousers were easier. It stuck. The Bounders, now, they all wear trousers when on duty, of course, but that’s more a job related matter.”

“What are Bounders?” Tilda says.

Bilbo describes hobbits tough as old briar with calloused hands and sharp eyes, who keep the peace of their little green corner of the world.

“We say they ‘beat the bounds’,” he tells them. Sigrid has sat with them now, curious about warriors among a people so peaceful.

“They sound like the guards,” she says.

Bilbo nods. “They are rather like that, though a bit less formal and a mite friendlier to their own, let me tell you.”

Sigrid asks a few more questions about the Bounders, and the Shirrifs, and the Mayor, and on and on until Tilda has almost stopped paying attention.

“We should write a book about that as well,” she mutters to herself. “We’ll need a lot of books.”

Twilight has come upon them by the time Tilda gets to really try and listen to the earth and plants on the terrace. She curls around a few flowers, breathing in their air and pushing the tips of her fingers into the ground around them. She lies there for what feels like forever as whispers and echoes come to her. By the time she reawakens to the rest of the world, she finds herself alone save Bilbo.

“Where is everyone?” Her mouth feels heavy.

Bilbo just smiles at her, making no move to get her up or usher her inside. “They went to get some tea. I thought I’d best wait.”

“Ta.”

“It’s no problem. What did you learn about my terrace then?”

She breathes deeply for a moment, and wonders what to tell him. It’s as the winds said. The rest of his terraces are probably much the same.

“I think the soil is tough,” she says eventually, “but sad.” It’s more than that, in truth, but by Bilbo’s face he knows. The very ground aches. It’s like it’s caught a hundred tears and stored them up to mourn over. “Your pain goes into it,” she says, “don’t ask me how.”

“It seems I poison all I touch,” he mutters.

Her heart pangs for him. She pulls herself up and presses herself to his side. “It’s not your fault you’re sad.”

“But I know not how to stop being sad.” She angles her face upward to look at him, to see his features slowly falling.

“Well, get away from the thing that’s making you sad.” It’s what her mother might say, she thinks. “Go to something that makes you happy.”

Bilbo’s face is an open wound. “Were it so easy. My happiness...I thought it would be here. It seems it lies back west instead.”

“You know,” she says, “I’m not so good with maps, but Bain told me the other day that it’s getting easier to go west every day.”

Bilbo does not look so certain.

“There are elven barges,” she tells him, “and caravans of people going to Bree.”

“Bree,” Bilbo says, something broken and wistful in his voice.

“You can go, Bilbo, if you want.”

He stares at her. A light grows upon his face.

“Go.”

The plants rustle without a breeze.


 

Her brother sits before the fireplace, collapsed in on himself as a sail with no air. Pitiful. Three times she has tried to move him today, and three times he has plodded around behind her for nary ten minutes before retreating back to his misery and his high backed chair. She is tempted to give up on him for today, but she knows if she does that she will have to watch as he declines and finally explodes, which shall not be of benefit to anyone. Least of all Thorin.

Dalla sweeps in through the front door, decadent in her blue tunic. She’s been doing her best to find out everything she can about her son’s beloved hobbit, and Dís hopes beyond hope she’s found something useful. She calls her mother over, and they confer in the corner of the room. A tapestry of Gimizhbuznâl rises behind them.

Dalla sighs. “Still no movement?”

“Little. He is determined to mope. I can get nothing from him save lamentations over his failed romance.”

Bright brown eyes fix her with a gaze of steel. “I hope you have been sympathetic.”

Dís says nothing. Her mother sighs again.

“Nothing is as we planned it, it seems.”

She is more right than Dís wishes. Nothing is as they had hoped. The mountain is but an echo of what they remember. All she knows of it, all the images in her head, are seen through rose tinted glasses. A golden era that, if it ever was a thing in truth, has long passed. Now she must see things as they are.

“I should have come along,” she whispers without intent.

Her mother stares at her. “Come along?”

“On the journey east.”

“What would that have changed?”

Her children flitter past her mind’s eye, changed beyond going back, for better and worse – sterner, wiser, more cynical. “Perhaps there would be some who remained the same.”

“No my child, do not put that burden on yourself.”

“If I had come –”

“They would still be as they are now. Bereft of childhood’s romance, heavy under the mountain’s weight. You could not have prevented that. It was always going to pass.”

“Maybe I could have softened it.”

Dalla places a hand upon her cheek, an immovable and grounding force. Dís’ breath is a prelude to a sob she hopes never to voice.

“Maybe I could have saved them from these people they have become.”

Dalla shakes her head. “Maybe we could save all of Erebor, hm? Save the heart-weary and the battle-burnt and all those Erebor has hurt, whether she willed it or not.”

“I would try.”

“You would fail. And it would consume you.”

In her heart she knows the truth of her mother’s words, but she is loath to accept them. Erebor toddles on unsteady feet, and as she tilts she throws her people around like pebbles down a scree hill. Dwarves come who never knew the halls, and crowd it with their dreams and desires beyond what the mountain can fulfil. Worse perhaps are those that did know the mountain, for as with her their hopes are as a dream, dim morning mist that dissipates in the heat of the sun. Fleeing shadows take away all she thought she knew in the visions of her past.

Thorin never had any dreams, save that Erebor would be restored to them. He believed, utterly, with a resignation that terrifies Dís even now, that the revival of the mountain would require his life. No soft-powder thoughts slipped through Thorin’s mind, no ideas of love or life, of days spent in the star sheen of the diamond mines, of moments upon a green terrace in the sun off the northern snows. The sum of his life extended as far as he believed his people needed him, and no further.

But something had happened between the Blue Mountains and this lone summit. A small khuhund had, somehow, been a catalyst to bring forth a version of Thorin Dís has not seen since their brother died and the shadow of the crown fell upon Thorin’s head. It is a feat that only her children have hinted at achieving.

Thorin now perceives the plethora of possibilities laid before him. His future did not fall shut. He did not pay for Erebor with a surfeit of blood. And he does not know what to do with that.

Her mother sniffs, and brushes invisible dust from Dís’ arms. “Come. We must see to him.”

It is a strange world when Dís is the one having to look after Thorin. Rarely has she had to do it. They approach him as a unit, and Dís stands to the chair’s side as Dalla goes and stands in front of it, her harsh edges softening as she regards her son.

“My child, come, it is time for you to move.”

Thorin grumbles and mutters, but makes no indication that he is going to do as she bids.

“If you come with me to the kitchen I shall make you some nettle tea.”

That perks his interest. Nettle tea is a favourite of his. Often it was the only flavoured drink they could make, when merchants sneered at them and the climate forbade anything else. How like Thorin, to fall in love with a thing born of necessity.

Her brother rises slowly and follows them, his slow steps reminiscent of Kíli as a child, doe eyed and hanging onto his mother’s trousers with one sticky hand. Looking at the same dark hair, Dís slips her hand into Thorin’s own, and they become a pair, shuffling behind Dalla’s regal tread. They wait idly while Dalla prepares the tea, swaying side to side, bumping gently from shoulder to shin. Dís only lets his hand go when they have to sit at the small table in the centre of the kitchen, their hands now occupied with the business of clasping small bone teacups. They sit in the low seats in silence for a while, the stillness of the air only disturbed by rising steam.

Thorin sighs over the rim of his teacup, empty now. “Thank you.”

Dalla smiles, and presses down on his forearm so he lowers his teacup. With a delicacy Dís sees her use in few other places she pours her son some more tea, lifting and dipping the pot to air the liquid, not a drop escaping onto the table’s top. “You are in dire need of it, my child.”

Thorin’s face pinches.

Dís ventures a measured statement. “You have had a trying few days.”

Thorin scowls. “Trying. Say it as it is, sister, or say it not at all.”

“Very well. You have had a near catastrophic few days, marked by awkwardness, rejection and doubt. Does that more closely hit the truth?”

“I do not know whether to be grateful or distraught at the way your honesty always seems to hurt.”

“If you did not want my opinion you shouldn’t have asked –”

“My children.” Dalla’s tone forbids a decent into pointless bickering. “Peace, or I shall hold you both by your ears until they are sore.”

How is it at one hundred and eighty two she is still able to be cowed by such a threat? “Ma, we are not children.”

“Then don’t act like bairns of barely thirty.”

“And here I was,” Thorin says, “anticipating a peaceful moment with family.”

Before Dís can start the argument all over again, a voice behind her cuts her off. It’s full of laughter and confusion, and puts Dís immediately at ease.

“What are you all squabbling about?” Fíli asks.

Dís turns to beckon her daughter to the table, and she takes the low chair on Dís’ left, her golden braids swaying with the movement. “We’re bickering about the last few days, and having nettle tea while we’re about it.”

Fíli laughs outright, but it sounds a bit cracked. “I’ll have one but not the other, if you please.”

If you please. It strikes Dís at that moment how much influence the khuhund has had on her kin. She does not think Fíli ever uttered such a phrase in her life until she met Bilbo Baggins. It is so utterly... khuhundul. Hobbitish.

“Presumably you mean to have the nettle tea,” Dís says, and Fíli dashes to get another teacup. She waits patiently by her grandmother’s shoulder while it is filled.

Dís waits until Fíli is seated again before she speaks. “We do need to speak of the other.”

Thorin, predictably, groans, downs his tea with aplomb and makes to escape his chair. Dís secures him with a firm grip on his arm.

“We must.” She tells him.

Her brother leans so his hair falls about his face. “It is done, and I am done with it. Leave me be.”

“Uncle, she has a point.”

“What point?”

She must say it now, or she shall perhaps never say it at all. “It was never going to work.”

“Thank you, dear sister, for your input. Your words always cheer me.”

“You are too different! And too divided. How could he have looked upon you with love when you are so strange to him, and he to you?”

He snarls at her now, her words stinging. She snarls right back. Dalla rolls her eyes and retrieves their teacups to prevent their damage.

“I gave him the necklace, did I not?” Thorin’s words bite through the air like steel. “I made my intentions clear.”

Fíli shakes her head. “Hobbits do things differently, uncle. Bilbo may not even have known what the necklace meant.”

“Nonsense. He accepted it gladly – for a moment, he was glad of it. Of me.”

“I’ve half a mind to get Ser Amina in here and see if she verifies your tale.” Dís says.

“Don’t bother.” Fíli shrugs when Dís looks at her. “I know for a fact that Amina was too smitten with one of Bilbo’s apprentices to pay much attention beyond her duty. Haruna.”

There is a thud as Thorin’s fist strikes the table, and all the cups and saucers tremble. “Do not say that name to me. I will suffer his choice, but I will not suffer her name.”

Dalla waves to Fíli, who begins to collect the rest of the bone crockery with a wary eye on her uncle. Dalla’s eyes swivel slowly to rest on Thorin, who looks suitably abashed.

“It is not her fault,” Dalla says quietly, “you would do well to recall that in your pain.”

“I know, mother, and I hold her no ill will, but her name burns in my ears.”

“Does his?”

Thorin’s hand tightens until his knuckles are white. “Aye. And it sings. Like staring overlong at the sun.”

Dís remembers golden hair, laughter like a bubbling brook, a hand of flesh and a hand of brass. She remembers gentle eyes and the way their gaze burnt upon her in such exquisite agony. These are all things she shall know again one day, in their Maker’s halls. But for now she sighs, bereft, and her mother sighs with her, and they let Thorin’s words hit their own memories with a painful precision.

“Mahal be blessed,” Fíli mutters, “listen to you all. If I should ever fall in love, someone hit me until I stop.”

She swipes gently at her daughter, cuffing her about the back of the head. “If you should ever fall in love I hope others are a great deal more sympathetic than you are currently being.”

“Yes yes, ‘have some thought for the poor afflicted’, I know.” Fíli shrugs and ducks a second swipe with a grin just this side of caustic. “You all just seem to be making mountains out of molehills is all –”

“What an odd turn of phrase,” Dalla says, and Fíli scowls at the interruption.

“Khuhundul,” Dís tells her.

“Ah.”

“If you would just talk to him,” Fíli says, loudly, “instead of all sitting in here like conspirators –”

Next to Dís, her brother scowls. “I resent that.”

“You mean you resemble it,” Dís tells him, and his scowl deepens.

Fíli has her hands flat on the table, head thrown back and eyes closed in a picture of great strain. “Sometimes I wonder where Kíli gets it from, you know, and then moments like this occur and I wonder why I ever wondered at all.”

They bicker for a while longer, Fíli and Thorin both frowning in remarkably similar fashions across the table. Dalla twice has to strategically intervene so that her son and granddaughter don’t reach across the table to start a true brawl, and once kicks Dís very pointedly in the shins when Dís is thinking of putting her brother in a headlock and holding him there until she feels better. Dís obviously needs to work on not broadcasting her emotions. Her mother is far too astute.

“Look,” Fíli says, half her body suspended above the table by one clenched fist pressed into its top, “forget everything else – no, shut up Thorin, I’m serious – forget the bloody dinner, forget the bloody dance, forget it. Did he ever actually, verbally, clearly, turn you down?”

It’s only the fury in Dalla’s eyes and her quick hand that stalls Thorin’s attempt to kick his chair behind him. Those chairs are from Dale, and their mother is possessive. Instead he stands up and shouts wordlessly, twists out of his mother’s grip and paces back and forth between the table and the pantry.

Fíli isn’t letting this go. “Thorin. Did he?”

Thorin’s shoulders are drawn up high, like a ram backed into a corner that’s thinking about running. “He kissed her. Haruna. He kissed her and gave her the necklace, and she placed it about her neck. They laughed and drank and did not spare me a glance.”

Dís’ teeth ache. If Amundi had done that, when she had courted him over a century ago...if her love had done that...Mahal be good. She would have disappeared into the wilds and not returned till her heart had scabbed over and she could no longer feel the pull of the scar when she breathed. No wonder Thorin is holed away in their mother’s rooms. A King cannot disappear, but he can hide as well as any other.

Fíli’s face settles into a careful neutrality. “And?”

Thorin is not alone in his shock. Dís stares at her own daughter in a strange state of horror.

“He kissed her,” she says, and Fíli shrugs. “Fíli, I know you are not over fond of romance, but even you know what that means.”

“To us,” Fíli says. “To us, ma, but not to him I’d wager.”

Thorin is shaking, like light caught in a multifaceted gem. Dís stands and gently ushers him back to his seat. Her daughter’s words are dust to her, without meaning. “Fíli –”

Fíli interrupts her recklessly. “The necklace is the same. I’ll bet my viola he took the thing off on the first day, put it on a side table as he went to bed.” Mahal, such blasphemy. “And even if he didn’t, he certainly isn’t wearing it now, but what you all seem to be ignoring is that we don’t know why.”

“We know why,” Dís says quietly, her hands firm upon her brother’s shoulders.

Fíli shakes her head. “No, we don’t. You’re assuming you know, but all you have is half-cooked ideas based on the few glimpses we got at a feast and Thorin’s own already worrisome interactions.”

Dalla shifts her glance from her children to her granddaughter. “Worrisome?”

Dís feels Thorin curl up all over again, and digs her fingers into his muscle in the only show of solidarity she can manage right now. She cannot quiet Fíli. Fíli’s eyes are the sharpest, her mind the clearest, and they need her insight more than they want her silence.

Fíli looks at her uncle, her eyes like flint. “Did either of you ever make reparations? One word of sorrow, one word of regret?”

She has heard the accounts of what happened that day at Erebor’s gate. Already their sages have begun to immortalise those chaotic weeks and months that her kith and kin went east, in song and chronicle and cultural memory. But upon the topic of that singular, blasphemous theft they have so far remained silent. What are they to say, when even those who were there cannot give clear telling? When the thief is now the Grand Master of a trade? When he was not given punishment? When he is beloved of the King? Dís has more advantage than most, having ample opportunity to interrogate all of the company who will sit still long enough for her to talk to them. But still she does not understand what happened, that day or after. She is not sure Thorin understands either.

Thorin seems to shift downward, grow smaller as if this tale physically alters him.

“Thorin,” Dalla says, “speak.”

Her son sighs, and obeys. “I was going to kill him.” He stops, and Dís increases her grip. “Everything in me was bent in fury and greed towards all our people’s treasures and towards him, and in one fell swoop I lost both. Or so it felt in my fevered mind.”

Dalla places a hand on her son’s arm. “You are not to blame for your mind’s concoctions.”

“No, perhaps not. But that does not stop it from weighing heavily upon me. It does not erase my grip about his neck. Can my illness excuse my violence? Could my anger have excused his death?”

“No. It could not. But such things have the potential to be reconciled. Did you try?”

“We exchanged words...we said sorry, while I was lying in a tent thinking I was going to die. We did not speak of it again. It seemed enough.”

“Well,” Fíli says, “you thought you were dying.”

Dalla nods, as if in agreement. “A first step is not a completion. It was not enough, my child, though it may pain you to hear. These things take time and effort beyond the blown air of a few words.”

“A dwarf is their word,” Thorin says, a proverb he has always tried to follow.

Dalla answers with a proverb of her own. “But words cannot change ones feelings, as a dam changes a river.”

“Feelings should not rule a soul.”

“One should master their own emotions, aye, but that mastery does not come in a single moment of will, but in a slow process of seeking truth and calm. A hasty, blood drenched exchange upon the remains of a battlefield is not seeking truth and calm. It is to make things as right as you can before you part forever. But you did not part, and so you are now stuck with the consequences of your inadequate reconciliation.”

A breath rattles out of Thorin in a way that tells Dís he is trying not to weep. “I should not hate him. I love him.”

“Let us not bandy about should not. As if emotions are so cheap.”

“Uncle,” Fíli says, “you need to do something. What are you going to do?”

They wait. Thorin is long in giving an answer. So long that Dís retakes her seat, desiring to parse her brother’s emotion from the features of his face. Eventually he clears his throat.

“I...am going to do...nothing?”

There is a beat of incredulous silence, and then a harsh scrape of wood on stone as Dalla rises with abrupt haste out of her chair.

“I am overfull, over full with many things,” she says, pacing in an unwitting mimic of her son, “not least my children’s love lives. You shall think on this Thorin, on this – this calamity, and then you shall talk to young Master Baggins or Mahal strengthen me, I shall talk to him.”

The room is full of quiet again, save the thud-thud-thud of Dalla’s pacing. Thorin’s face is swinging between horror and hope.

“Very well,” he says at last, “I will talk to him.”

“Good,” says Fíli, suddenly bright, “you can start by digging through what you want  to be versus what actually is, and then move on to telling Bilbo that you asked him to marry you without actually using the words you or marry –”

“Would it not be best to start with a nice cluster of diamonds?” Thorin says.

Dís shakes her head. “No, he would prefer rubies, surely? His Gardeners are always wearing those red coats, you could find some to match –”

“NO,” Dalla shouts, and Fíli groans and gets up to make some more tea.

Thorin turns to look at her. “Do you think another jewel would be more appropriate?”

“I think, my son, that talking to him would be more appropriate.”

“But –”

“No. No diamonds, not rubies, no gifts of any kind. You will speak. You will stop hiding behind things to avoid your fears.”

“If wishes were pennies,” Fíli mutters, setting a new pot above the fire to boil, and Dís is sure that’s another khuhundul phrase –

There is a squawk, and if Dís were given to interpreting squawks she would mark this one as worried. The noise resolves itself into a raven, which comes down out of a skyshaft and lands apologetically on the tabletop.

“Message for His Majesty?” The raven does not sound sure that there should be a message at all.

Thorin frowns to hide a brief and guilty smile. “Who bears it?”

“Shorëc, daughter of Korëc.”

“And whom is it from?”

“Grand Master Baggins, in the Gardener’s Halls, with top priority level –”

“Yes, yes,” Thorin says, earlier apathy usurped by impatience, “you may recite it.”

The raven hesitates, and begins to speak.


 

He sits on their highest terrace, the one reserved for root vegetables and winter berries. His apprentices are scattered about on the others. They can feel something is off, and have left him to himself. So he sits in the quiet of the morning, breathing deep of the cool air and absorbing the piercing sun as it slides around the clouds and bounces off the snow. He sits, and tries not to cry.

He loves Erebor as much as he has ever loved the Shire. Its high walkways, the careful geometry of everything, the layer upon layer upon layer of cloth and stone and paint that make up its beauty. The people – who ever thought he’d grow to love dwarves, rough and rude as he once thought them? Even come to call them family? But here he is, consumed with love for his apprentices, for the Company, for dozens upon dozens of others, for...for...

He wakes with a happy expectation each morning for what he’s going to do on the terraces that day, takes delight in the progress of his apprentices, the joy they find in the earth. The cool mountain wind vitalises him. His work fulfils him. But Tilda is right.

The mountain is also suffocating him.

The air is not enough, not enough, a sob is pushing its way brutally up his throat and he can’t breathe. He throws himself up with a cry and flings himself toward the curtain wall, to the hedge, swatting at it as it parts before him with tremulous fluttering. He only stops when the wall pulls him up short. It presses at his waist and thighs, while the hedge pushes gently at his back. But now he can see west.

West.

Spirits, but he is a broken man.

The wind pulls at his hair, and he hears a quiet call from the terrace entrance behind him. He takes one last breath – one last look west – and turns back through the hedge to see to the caller.

It’s Haruna. “Master,” she says, “I – tea?”

She sounds so uncertain. “Tea?”

“Yes, tea. Terraces down – down –”

“The lower terraces?”

“Yes, lower terraces are...” and she stops, eyeing the hedge and the berry bushes warily.

Oh dear. “The lower terraces are what, Haruna?”

“Are...not good. Shaking, like storm is here. But sky – no storm in sky.”

“Oh.” When he looks at himself, he notes his own tremors. And when he listens he can hear an unnatural susurrus. A glance about him shows every bit of greenery above the soil is rustling without a breeze. He suspects if they dug downward they’d find it extends through every bulb and root.

“No,” he says, “there is no storm in the sky.”

Haruna is silent. She looks around the terrace and shakes her head.

West. West. It’s getting easier to go west every day.

He’s made up his mind. “Haruna.”

“Yes, master?”

“Down in my room, in my study, on my desk – and in it, mind, and all about it as well, I’m not the most terribly organised person – my desk, has all you’ll need to see these terraces blossom. Schematics and plans and crop rotations and lists of materials and thoughts, goodness, whole pages of thoughts on what to plant where when. And not a few very stern letters about that stupid glass roof on the southward terrace. The one we were on when Kíli visited.”

“Master?”

“And of course there’s the outstanding bills and orders and such with Dale, you’ll need to deal with those. No helping that. Get Ase to aid you. And I’ll need to edit the royal mandate, put your name on it instead of mine, but that can be done easily enough. Fíli will make sure it gets through all the blasted bureaucracy.”

“Master.”

“And you can have my rooms, of course. And probably a good lot of my other things. I’ll not be able to take much, though I suppose I can get some things sent after me –”

“Master! Please, be stopping. Please. I do not understand. Master I do not –” she pauses to draw in a breath, and for the first time since he started babbling Bilbo looks at her, and sees that she is crying, “– I do not – you go? Why say – why say this if you not go? Go where?”

“West,” he says, and can say no more.

He is sat on a low bench at the edge of the terrace when she returns a few minutes later, a tray of tea held delicately in her hands, tears still drying on her face. The tray is put slowly on a small table next to the bench, the wood clacking softly against the table’s glass top. Haruna pours two cups, one with red flowers and one with blue birds. A cube of sugar in one, a slice of lemon in the other. Bilbo takes the one with sugar, the red flowers matching his waistcoat nicely. She sits beside him, and for a while there is nothing but the glint of sun off snow, the steam of hot tea, the smell of soil.

At last, as she cradles her empty cup, Haruna speaks. “You are going back to Shire.” She cannot quite look at him.

“Yes,” he says, but that is wholly insufficient, “the storm, Haruna, the storm.”

“There is no storm.”

“Yes there is. It is me. It is Erebor. It is...Thorin Oakenshield, son of Thrain. Thorin Oakenshield, King under the Mountain. Thorin.”

She looks up at him now. “The King.”

He laughs, bitter. “Yes, Thorin. My King, and isn’t that a joke.” Albeit not a very funny one.

Haruna then decides to set off on what seems a complete tangent. “I was, this morn, before plants are shake and air is tight, I was to ask Master of love.”

“Love?” He stares at her and feels his face crumple. “You were going to ask me of love?”

“Yes –”

“What on this good green earth do you think I know of love?”

“Much. Much, Master.”

The pain in the soil, the tense feasts, his foolish, foolish plan with the Arkenstone...

“No. I know nothing. Nothing worth the telling.” Haruna looks set to speak again, perhaps to explain what she thinks love has to do with the current conversation, but Bilbo has other things that need doing. “Go and get the others,” he tells her, and her mouth snaps shut, “go and get all of them and bring them up here. And bring something to drink with a bit of a kick, if you please.”

She does, without complaint. His apprentices find him – bench abandoned, tea carelessly left half finished – sat in amongst a collection of berry bushes. He’s cross-legged, facing west, with his face lifted to catch the breeze and his fingers buried in the soil.

“Sit,” he says. They arrange themselves so they make a perfect circle. To his left, Haruna holds another tray. This one bears seven small clear glasses, and a pitcher of strong rice wine. She places it down on the earth and waits. All of them look to him.

“Hobbits are terrible at big goodbyes,” he says, and says no more until the panicked whispering that it generates has died down, from plants and dwarves both. “Terrible at them. Mainly because we never get practice; when you all live just a day or so walk away from everyone you care about, goodbye is generally only a temporary, casual thing. We make a big fuss of it, of course, because as you know hobbits are good at making fusses of things. But we know that in a little while we shall see each other again. For tea, or a walk, or someone’s birthday. So we’re rather bad at big goodbyes. So I’m rather bad at them.”

“Grand Master,” Ase says, but Bilbo hushes her.

“Give me a moment,” he says, “just a moment, to work things out, and then you can speak.” Pushing himself to his feet is harder than normal, because he’s still shaking, and he has to take hold of Haruna’s shoulder to stabilise himself. Her face is crumpled, and she can’t meet his eye.

I was to ask Master of love.

He takes a breath. “I love you all, very dearly. More than I can express, in truth, and if I say so myself I’m usually not half bad at expressing things.” Sólveig laughs quietly. “You are, without peer, the best bunch of green-fingered fellows I’ve ever had the joy of working with. Teaching you has been the utmost pleasure, and privilege, and, well...” He shuffles, and clears his throat. “This mountain has not been an easy place to be, for reasons you all know – and it’s for those reasons, and more, that you’ve probably all guessed because you’re a bunch of gossipy busy-bodies, bless your souls, that I’m leaving – but despite those hardships, the time this mountain has given me with you is something I’d not wish trade for all the peace the Shire has to offer. And that’s a great deal of peace, I’ll have you know.”

Ebbe, sat to his right, presses a rough palm to his hip. “You’re leaving us.”

Bilbo swallows, and opens his mouth, and closes it, and has to force the words out through a barricade of tears. “Yes. You are all a blessing, you are all – good gracious I am so very proud of all of you. But Erebor is hollowing me out. So I must sacrifice this joy for some peace, or I do not know what shall be left of me.”

The hand he still has on Haruna’s shoulder is covered by her own. “You must go west.”

“You all mean the world to me,” he says, “but I cannot stay.”

Quietly, Halli starts to cry.

In the end, once their grief has settled, he is sent off with a blessing and a glass of rice wine.

“May Mahal and Gimizhbuznâl watch your path.” Halli says, lifting zir own glass to the sky in salutation. “May your garden never wither, may your hearth never grow cold.”

There is a chorus of soft, heartfelt ‘aye’s. The terrace seems to dim as he steps off of soil onto stone.

They help him pack; two bags, small and easy to carry. Other things are set aside to be sent by the slow and safe caravans that head south through Rohan. Everything else, he leaves to them.

“Haruna is your Grand Master now,” he tells them as his last shirt is folded away. “But you must all help each other. Get some tips from those Gardeners in the Iron Hills and beyond, if you can, and make sure you bully the other guilds enough that they pay you heed.”

Ase laughs and shakes her head. “We’ll be fine, Grand Master.”

“None of that now. I’m just Bilbo.”

“Bilbo. We’ll be fine.”

Looking at them all, he knows she’s right. He’s trained them well. They are ready.

“Just...make sure Fíli gets the relevant paperwork, alright? I’d hate for a bit of bureaucratic nonsense to be what I leave you with.”

There’s a shout, and the two of them turn to see Sólveig waving hairbrushes about and Ebbe scowling at her. Halli is in a corner, debating the merits of moving a cabinet, and Gróa is making a valiant effort at finding his handkerchief. Haruna is at the window, thumbs tucked in the pockets of her waistcoat.

“No,” says Ase, “this is what you leave us with.”

“Chaos?”

The look she gives him dismisses his attempt at humour with a gentle grace. She can see right through him. “Family.”

Family. Isn’t that a thought.

“Well,” he says, “well. Gather round everyone! Come on now, gather round! There’s one last thing this old hobbit has to teach you before he goes a-wandering on the road.”

They come, each of them in their red waistcoats, hidden under work robes and muddy shawls and braided hair.

He hasn’t got any notion of what he’s going to tell them until he opens his mouth. “Love,” he begins, “is a strange thing. It comes in all kinds of forms, and in all kind of packages. It hurts, because there are people involved, and people are notoriously dangerous for one’s emotional state. And sometimes it’s not healthy, not healthy at all. But if it’s a good love, if it’s joyful and trusting and it builds you up, then it’s worth hanging on to. Hear me, all of you? Good love is worth hanging on to.”

Across from him, Haruna’s eyes focus, and she nods like he has just said something very wise. He hopes he has.

He clears his throat. “Right, that raven sent off? Good. Who wants to see me down to Dale?”

They all do, and he parts with them, finally, painfully, in a side room of the royal manse. He watches them walk away down winding stairs until he can’t bear it anymore. Satomi holds him as he cries, and Bard sends the servants away, and Tilda whispers so a warm breeze curls around him.

“After the rain, earth hardens,” Satomi says to him, her words soothing him as he hiccups into her sleeve. “So shall you grow taller, Bilbo of the Shire.”

He feels the peace of it upon him, and knows it for what it is; a blessing, a hope. Pulling himself from the safety of her hold is not so hard with those words in his ears. It is made easier by catching glimpses of all their faces, worried and calm and glad.

“We’ll see you again,” Tilda says, “with your roots down deep.” The wind picks up speed.

Satomi smiles, and wipes his face with a cotton cloth. “And when we do, your welcome here will be undiminished.”

They all take a boat down the canals to Laketown, Bard keeping up an amicable chatter with the boaters and fishers and everyone else who will listen to him. Tilda stays pressed to Bilbo’s side. When Satomi starts her haggling in the harbour with a tall elven barge captain, Tilda digs into her pockets and presses something into Bilbo’s hand. Upon inspection Bilbo finds that it’s a sunflower seed, small and striped.

“They grow tall,” she says, “like you will, one day. Maybe not today or tomorrow, and maybe never as tall as you think you should be. But you’ll grow. You’ll be ok.”

He can’t help but stare at her.

“It’s a story,” she says at his look, “I don’t mean you’re actually going to grow.”

“I know,” he whispers, “I know. I’m just...touched is all.”

Tilda blinks. “Oh. Good.”

Satomi secures him a place on a trading barge to take him through the woodland waterways, and a caravan to take him onward to Rivendell once the barge can go no further. After Rivendell he shall have to find his own way, but that shall not be so hard. Lord Elrond shall no doubt know of safe ways to get to Bree, and then the Shire, and then...and then, upon the eastern borders of Buckland, he shall be able to find his way home with his eyes closed and his hands tied fast together.

Once negotiations are finished he is gifted with five kisses and five hugs, and he leaves the last of his friends behind in the harbour. They turn north, for home, and he contents himself with seeking out a quiet inn to await the morning. It is only midafternoon, just over half a day from his goodbye on the terrace. It feels like a lifetime ago.

The inn he finds is small and out of the way. Cheap and cheerful. He arranges things with the landlady and sets his bags in his room, and then settles himself on a solitary bench a few feet from the front door, high up above the walkways of Laketown on a small porch before the inn’s entrance. It allows him a breeze and a moment of quiet. Fire catches slowly in his pipe as he lights it, and the smoke winds gently up above the rooftops. He sighs, and smokes, and sets himself to wait the hours out.

Just as he has at last tricked himself into a modicum of calm, a raven arrives. They perch on the end of the bench, looking rather worse for wear; feathers are bent out of alignment, dust caught on several of them, and the poor creature cannot seem to stop shifting from foot to foot.

“Mister Baggins?” They ask.

Bilbo is hesitant to answer, but it’s not like being the only hobbit in the whole of Rhovanion isn’t a giveaway. “Yes, that’s me.”

“Brön daughter of Crön. A message.” Brön clears her throat. “‘Baggins, come back right now. Your Halls are a calamity. Your apprentices are a wreck. What are you doing? Come back right now.’” It must be from Dís, he can tell. She always is rather blunt.

Before Bilbo can even formulate a word of reply a second raven comes careening in, crashing into the first and sending them both flying and squawking indignantly. They circle each other before settling beside each other. Bilbo looks at them and feels a pool of dread grow in his belly.

The second raven looks at him. “Eärn, child of Bërna, with a message from her royal Highness Princess Fíli for Grand Master Baggins.”

“It’s not Grand Master anymore. I quit.”

The protest only makes the raven look uncomfortable before they continue. “‘I’m so sorry Bilbo, I am. Please don’t leave like this. Let us heal things before you go home.’”

The dread swells into a dull kind of fury as more ravens appear, in pairs and alone, all fluttering about him and one another in a contained calamity. So this is to be his goodbye. Any pretence he had has vanished. Now he feels reduced to the thief he once was in truth, disappearing in the night. Perhaps he shall always be a thief. Perhaps the ending shall always be in chaos.

“‘We shake off the dust and clasp hands again,’” one from Dalla recites to him, and with that he stands and flees inside, leaving a cacophony of ravens and the landlady’s bewilderment in his wake.

The door to his room bolts closed with a satisfying thunk, and he secures a chair under it for good measure. The window is a bit more of a problem, but in the end he ties it shut with his neckerchief. The cawing of the half-dozen ravens outside continues for a good while, but eventually the sounds fade and Bilbo hopes they’ve gone away. He crawls beneath the covers of his low bed and hopes his journey tomorrow shall not have to become another escape.

In the morning he settles the breakfast bill with the landlady and tries to ignore her suspicious looks, covering himself with his cloak and hurrying out the door. A glance upward and about reveals an utter lack of ravens. Thank goodness. The walkway towards the southern docks is crowded with humans and a few elves but no dwarves, and with such auspicious tidings he sets off. Once he is in Rivendell perhaps he shall write a letter to Haruna to see what on earth happened with the line of Durin, but for now he is merely happy to be on his way. The tall press of bodies makes him near invisible, and he takes comfort in it. Salty fishers and dock workers pass by, laugher load, exchanging the morning’s gossip.

“Something a bit off about it all, is all I’m saying.” Says one rough looking woman.

“What would you know about it eh?”

“I’ve been involved in a few barneys down that end of the harbour. Know the feel of them. And this group was on the brink, I tell ya.”

“I don’t know...”

The rest is lost to the growing crowd, and Bilbo tries to ignore what little he heard. It won’t be his end of the harbour. A well seasoned traveller like the captain wouldn’t be within a mile of it. Satomi knows her people well.

All his attempts at diverting his fear are abandoned when he spots Haruna and Sigrid hovering about the dock entrance. Their gazes are scanning the crowds, and with her height Sigrid spots him first, her eyes widening and her lips moving around a word Bilbo can’t catch. Haruna turns, and they move, two red figures pushing through the crowd towards him.

“What’s gone wrong?” He says as they reach him. There’s no other reason they would be here. They’ve said their goodbyes; to loiter would only drag out the pain.

“Perhaps you should –”

“Come back master –”

Bilbo cuts them off with a slash of his hand, and moves past them onward to the docks. Maybe they realise their folly, as they follow him in silence along wooden walkways and into the open space beyond. Masts fill the air like skinny trees in winter, sails snapping in the wind and wood creaking. It stinks more than the rest of the town, if that’s possible; fish and oil and dried water weeds. As they move towards the end of the dock where Bilbo’s ride waits, a hobbit and his two taller tails, Bilbo begins to hear the echoes of shouts.

“I knew I wasn’t going to be able to leave in peace,” Bilbo mutters.

Haruna sighs behind him. “Maybe we go back little bit –”

“No. I’ve come this far, I’ll not be turned back by some – some soft-footed dwarf, some fool, some – oh dear.”

They turn a corner and emerge into a scene that would not look out of place in a comedic play, or a hobbit’s extended family dinner. The rest of the Dalish royal family has come down again, as well as the Company, and the Ereborean royal family, and his very own Gardeners. Kíli is off to one side, chewing on his fingernails and talking to Bofur and Ebbe, who for some reason has decided that bringing a spade to an occasion like this is an absolute must. Satomi is trying to keep dwarves off of the elven captain’s boat, and Dís is trying to get them on, and Dalla, for all Bilbo knows, is keeping score. Tilda has found a perch on Dwalin’s shoulders, Fíli is consulting what is presumably a map of Laketown, Halli is leading the rest of the Gardeners in distracting the dwarven guards from the elven boaters, and Ori is, typically, chronicling the entire thing.

Ase, Bard and Thorin are arguing. Loudly. Bard looks painfully comical, glaring down at two dwarves near half his height but with enough strength between them to throw him a good way out into the lake. Ase has a large handful of paper and is almost hitting Thorin with it, shouting about procedure and ethics and common cross-cultural practices.

“They haven’t seen us yet,” Sigrid says after a moment, “we can still leave.”

Bilbo sighs. And then, with a deep reluctance, steps forward and tries to catch someone’s attention. His wave is a small thing, half-hearted and feeble, but Tilda’s eyes swivel to fix upon him. Her hands flap and she makes Dwalin turn and come towards him. The dwarf’s eyes grow large in his face, and once they are clear of the crowd he shouts, wordless. Tilda slides off of him and rushes forward. She barrels into Bilbo, burying her face in the sleeve of his travelling jacket.

“Bilbo, Bilbo,” she says into rough cloth, “if the mountain could shake, it would be.”

It’s an utterly opaque statement, but before Bilbo can think of anything to reply with, let along voice it, they are overrun by dwarves and humans and the shadows of irate elves. Bilbo pulls in a deep breath, and sets his eyes on the dwarven king.

Thorin looks wretched, and the first thing out of his mouth, before Bilbo can even begin yelling at him, is “I will not stop you from going, but I beg for leave to speak before you do.”

Bilbo’s teeth click shut around the beginning of a broken sound, and he nods at Thorin in lieu of speaking.

“I’m sorry,” Thorin says, and bows forwards like he has been struck, his greying hair falling about his face.

Bilbo blinks, and processes the words, and decides this is not at all what he thought was going to happen. “Sorry for what?”

“Everything.”

Bilbo clears his throat. “Well, that’s...that’s not very clear at all –”

“If my ancestors could see me, khathuzmi e, they would be ashamed.”

Bilbo is shocked, for dwarves do not often, even now, speak their cradle tongue about him. His words are stolen from him, and all he can do is stare at the sway of Thorin’s braids in the winds off the lake. Bard takes the opportunity the silence provides to suggest a relocation from the dock to a private garden nearby, lest they become ‘gossip for fishers and bargefolk from Rivendell to Rhun’, and with little objection they all comply. Haruna finds him, and her hand slips into his, and the rest of his Gardeners form a circle around him as they move. It grants him some time to think, but he finds it wasted; his mind is fixed on Thorin saying ‘I’m sorry’, impossible, incongruous, and against everything he expected. So he finds himself, no greater in thought, sat upon a wooden bench enclosed within high red wooden fences, amidst a garden full of overflowing greenery that twists and turns as it will. Even if it doesn’t grant actual privacy – those fences may be high but they are also thin – at least it grants the pretence of such. Bilbo accepts a cup of cool water. Haruna moves to him as he stands, but he waves off all of the Gardeners as he makes his way over to Thorin. The dwarf sits in a wicker chair, one of a pair, each a reasonable distance from the other. Thorin holds his own cup and naught else. At his signal his own folk move away, Fíli and Dís and Dalla ushering them off.

Perhaps there is some kind of sensitivity to this, and not a mere panic. Bilbo sits down in the second chair and waits. All others drift off, hidden behind foliage and short wooden dividers, until if Bilbo focuses himself on these two wicker chairs he can fool himself that they are the only two people for miles.

“I am sorry,” Thorin says finally, and Bilbo makes himself keep waiting, because he does not know what this is. “I am sorry, for I was a fool. I thought things were clear between us –” Thorin cuts himself off, murmuring and shaking his head, “no, I pretended things were clear, because to think otherwise was to admit to a depth of complication I did not wish to delve into.”

Bilbo thinks carefully about his breathing, about how he’s holding his glass of water. “What did you think was between us that was so clear?”

Two blue eyes rise to meet his gaze, and then flick away. “If I say it I will seem a fool.”

“Then say it, and be a fool. We are already here.”

“I had thought us in love.” His voice catches, and Bilbo looks in wonder as the dwarf opposite him must compose himself.

Love. Love? Can it be so? But it must be, because Thorin is not given to lying, and is terrible at it besides. Air leaves Bilbo’s lungs in a great gust. “I thought the same. But then...”

There is quiet about them, only the wind through leaves and the creak of their chairs.

“Then I tried to kill you,” Thorin says.

Bilbo well remembers the feel of the Arkenstone in his palm, in his pocket, nestled next to his ring and his heart. He remembers the vice of a strong hand about his neck, and the coolness of the air beneath his feet. Death had found him, he had thought, in the arms of a man he had killed for.

“I hated you,” Thorin says, “in that moment I hated you. Your betrayal had torn me asunder, and in my rage I though...I could not see any other options.”

“You were ill,” Bilbo makes himself say, because it’s true.

Thorin jerks upwards, his eyes wet and his lips thin. “That does not excuse me. My mind was a fog, but it does not excuse me.”

That loosens something in Bilbo, and in a rush he releases long held thoughts to Thorin. “I was so afraid. I thought I was going to die. I thought you were going to throw me. I’d been so stupid, thinking I was helping, I had no notion of what I had given away. Of what the Arkenstone truly was. I thought it a bauble.”

“I know.”

“A bauble. But it is the mountains heart, and I’d given it away like a common jewel. And going down that wall, with your eyes upon my back – I thought I was going to be sick while still climbing down. And in the tent! I’d wanted – I’d wanted to scream, to tear at you. I hated you so.”

Thorin nods, utterly understanding.

Bilbo laughs. “I was a fool. I would undo it all.”

“As would I.”

“Why did you keep me around? After all I did, I thought myself merely a placeholder, someone to get you all on your feet until a dwarven Gardener was willing to come from the Iron Hills.”

Thorin nods again, then shakes his head, then aborts a motion to place his hand over Bilbo’s own. “No, that is not so. I love you, and I wanted you near, and you were – are – thoroughly qualified for the position of Grand Master Gardener. You were not a tool. You were...” He stops, and cannot seem to go on.

They watch as a leaf comes away from its branch and drifts down to rest on the loam. Bilbo finishes his water, and looks at Thorin out of his periphery.

“Why did we not say any of this before?” He wonders.

With a clink Thorin sets his cup down on a wooden table beside him. “Because – for my part at least – I desired to think dwarves and hobbits similar in all things, and so ignored all differences. If I had not, perhaps I would have looked also at our own, personal differences.”

“I don’t know,” Bilbo chuckles, “I thought you all terribly different, but I paid no more attention to these details than you.” Thorin winces, and when Bilbo frowns at him he shifts uncomfortably in his chair.

“I proposed to you.”

Bilbo blinks. “When?”

“A week past, just before the dinner. The necklace.”

“You didn’t say anything! You can’t just give a fellow a necklace. I mean, hobbits just use ribbon, but we hardly wear it all the time.”

“Yes, one of those...cultural differences. Fíli had much your reaction.”

“Trust Fíli to be the only one of us to think things through.” Wait. “I took the necklace off. Did that mean something?”

Thorin winces again. “Aye, that and the kiss, with your apprentice.” Haruna, he must mean. “They were a rejection of my affections and an acceptance of hers.”

Bilbo can do naught but stare at him for a while. The height of their own folly rears before him. “You do know she is utterly smitten with one of your personal guards?”

“Fíli made mention of that as well.”

There is a pause, and then Bilbo says, slowly. “Thorin, I cannot accept your proposal. I would not have accepted it then.”

His face does not fall, nor his shoulders slump, but Bilbo suspects that is because he is prepared rather than unaffected. “I know.”

“I am sorry. For this. For everything.”

“As I am. We have each done the other much wrong.”

More, Bilbo realises, than can be fixed within half an hour in a secluded garden. They cannot finish this now – it would be as much a lie as their earlier, false reconciliations were. They must take time. They must still part.

“We need more time than this.” He says.

A laugh, high and sweet, comes from among the greenery. Thorin looks for it briefly, then looks at Bilbo, and sighs. Bilbo drains the last of his water, now made too warm by his hands.

“If you go,” Thorin says, voice quiet and reserved, “I would ask that you allow me to write to you. Words on paper are naught compared to words aloud to a hobbit perhaps, but for a dwarf...” his words fade.

“I know. I remember the contract. Words have power. And, yes, you may write me. And yes, I am going. I cannot – we are too close here.”

Thorin nods. “The mountain did tangle us up together. Needs must we have space to breath. To heal.”

“Yes, exactly.”

“Will you come back?”

It’s a valid question. Bilbo had though he was leaving forever, that he would only ever see dwarves again in the gentle confines of the Shire. But now?

“Perhaps. To Dale, I think. Not to the mountain. Maybe. Probably. I cannot say. But to Dale, I will. I have the promise of a room in the royal manse.”

They murmur to each other for a while longer, and Bilbo tentatively reaches out to brush Thorin’s fingers with his own, and it is enough. For now. Perhaps one day he shall need, and shall have, more. Or perhaps not. But here, there is a peace growing between them, and he is content.

When she returns, alone but with the shadows of the others not far behind her, Haruna gives Bilbo his necklace. Thorin shows them both the minute Khuzdul inscribed on the fine links, and then, gently, Bilbo places it back in Thorin’s hands. Haruna retreats again with a sad smile upon her face.

“I don’t know what you would normally do with something like this, or if this is even a thing that normally happens, but if you can, if you will, I would like you to keep it,” he says to Thorin. “It is not a promise, for I think neither of us can safely make those anymore. But it is a hope.”

“Hope,” Thorin says, smiling and clinging to the chain, “is more than enough.”

“I – hah – I hope so. I hope we can endure this.”

“We will not endure, Bilbo. We will heal.”

And Bilbo thinks they just might, at that.

When at last they return to the dock, their goodbyes have to be repeated all over again. Save this time he is able to say goodbye to the line of Durin with more than a bureaucratic letter. It is better than he wished. Upon the deck of the slow moving boat, the captain gives him permission to stand by the rail nearest the dock while they push off. Bilbo lifts his voice in a song of home and rest, a hobbitish kind of blessing. Haruna and Amina are stood together, all the apprentices about them. Thorin’s company shouts and waves and weeps by turns, and Fíli runs along the pier with laughter in her mouth, following the barge for a ways. And Thorin – Thorin smiles, and grips his sister’s hand. Dís nods at Bilbo. Then she raises her voice with his in the chorus, and Bilbo didn’t know she’d ever learnt the song, but she sings perfectly. Quieter voices join her – Óin and Halli and Fíli carry them, and the rest follow in their own way. And as the barge drifts into some fog and the docks slips out of sight, Bilbo is suddenly struck again by how much he loves all these folk. How much they have changed one another. He is leaving family behind. Temporarily, he hopes. They are not so far away, even if it’s more than a day’s walk.

The fog shifts for an instant, and he is blessed with a last view of the crowd on the docks.

“May your roots grow deep!” He calls, a benediction both hobbits and dwarves can understand, and he fancies he can see them all smile.

Notes:

Khuzdul:
'Gimizhbuznâl' means '
'Khuhund' means 'hobbit', and 'khuhundul' means hobbitish.
'khathuzmi e' means 'let me endure'. I wanted 'preserve me', but the dwarrowscholar didn't have that, so this seemed an appropriate alternative.

Sindarin:
'Bronia' means 'endure'.

'After the rain, earth hardens' is a Japanese proverb meaning adversity builds character. It seemed right for Satomi, a woman of Rhunish descent who I've fancast as Rinko Kikuchi.
'We shake off the dust and clasp hands again' is a Longbeard proverb I made up, with the basic meaning of coming to an understanding after a disagreement or traumatic event of some sort.

EDIT: This chap was experimental in a lot of ways, so please feel free to give feedback. I especially want to know how people felt about the Halli/Bilbo/Tilda interaction, and the moment in the garden in the final section.