Actions

Work Header

Acorns And Arrogance

Chapter 11: Conversations and Revelations

Summary:

Bilbo runs into a familiar face, but Thorin is full of surprises. Though not all necessarily good.

Notes:

So terribly sorry for the wait! I spent the weekend in New York, and fumbled through inspiration. But it is here. Also, don't despair about any concerns of my leaving this work eternally unfinished - the epilogue is completed. Mostly because I'm approaching the sad parts of the story, and I don't want to dwell on that. Also, for those who are interested, I've been planning the sequels to this. With luck, this will turn into a trilogy, where this story focuses on Bilbo's story as "Elizabeth". The second one will be Ori's story, and the third is Frodo's. Stay tuned to learn about what popular film I will take inspiration from for each.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Chapter 11

 

Balin brightened at seeing the other dwarrow, and walked over the greet him. Thorin gave his advisor a smile and returned the greeting. “How have you been?” Balin inquired. Thorin replied that he was doing well, and returned the question. “Much better.” Balin answered, “I feel as if I could do anything. Courting and spending time in the Shire will do that to you.” Thorin gave a wry grin (and it surprised Bilbo to see that kind of an emotion on Thorin’s face)

 “We didn’t think you’d come back.” The prince said to Balin.

“There’s a certain appeal to never wanting to leave the Shire.” His advisor confessed. “But Dori’s brother is getting married, so it was time to come back home.” Thorin seemed to stiffen, and he glanced at Ori over Balin’s shoulder. The other dwarrow followed the look and then laughed.

“Oh-heavens no! Nori, not Ori.” Thorin gave a nod, but it was more out of a polite inquiry then genuine interest. It annoyed Bilbo.

Thorin turned his gaze to Ori, and said a polite hello. It was returned softly – Ori was rattled by Dwalin’s disappearance and the news of a “lady friend.” Though Thorin didn’t know Ori well enough to read his expressions, and took the short responses to inquiries on his brother’s in good stride. Bilbo couldn’t hold his ignorance of Ori offensive – they had hardly spent anytime speaking back in Rivendell, and few could actually read Ori. It had taken him years, and they were best friends.  

“Hello, Bilbo Baggins.” Thorin said, looking at him finally. He politely asked about his parents and Frodo (but he did at least seem interested in hearing about the youngest brother being quite taken with his kingdom). “How are you finding Erebor?” Thorin continues. Bilbo was a little surprised that Thorin was continuing the conversation.

But maybe it was time to stop being so surprised by the Prince. Yes, Thorin had been incredibly rude when they first met, but that had been quite some time ago. They had talked several times since then both in Bree, and then to and in Rivendell. Thorin had made for a good conversationalist and even expressed interest in the hobbies that Bilbo kept. It was certainly more than what Smaug had done, with his flattery and one-sided conversations. Perhaps Thorin wanted to be his friend. Perhaps Bilbo could use a friend.

“It’s very… intense.” Bilbo said after a moment’s though. Thorin seemed to chuckle. That inspired Bilbo to keep speaking. “We went through the market-place to get here, and I got swallowed by your large crowds three times!” That comment made the other dwarrow laugh. It was a rather pleasant sound.

During the interaction, Balin and Ori kept quiet. It was hard to decipher Balin’s gaze.

“I’m going to take Ori to the Great Library.” He announced. “I received correspondence about a potential position just before we left.” Then he turned to Thorin. “You should show Bilbo more of the Kingdom.” Balin started to lead Ori away before he could reply. Thorin looked back at Bilbo, and seemed to smile at him.

“Perhaps I shall.”

--

“Erebor is a vast kingdom of riches, all in different parts of the mountain,” Thorin was saying as they strolled through mostly-empty corridors. The story about Bilbo being swallowed by the market-place had been amusing, but he seemed to have no real desire to attempt going back. They stayed mostly in near-empty hallways and what felt like hidden hallways, which Bilbo was quite thankful for.

“And you have miners that retrieve the gems for you then?” Thorin replied in the affirmative. “And do all dwarrow mine?”

“Some shall,” The prince said. Bilbo couldn’t exactly tell what the dwarrow was thinking, but he seemed to enjoy explaining more about his home. He considered it fair trade, for Thorin had been very keen on learning about the Shire. Also, Bilbo was interested in learning about Erebor. One day Ori would be living here permanently (he ignored the ache in his heart at the thought) and there was something about the way that Thorin’s eyes lit up when speaking of the kingdom.

“When a dwarf reaches near-adulthood, they develop certain talents for a trade or craft. Their family will then arrange an apprenticeship for the dwarf to a guild that specializes in the field. Most of us will go to the mines though, because it is the most profitable of ventures, and every dwarrow can hear the calling of the mountain, the allure of different gems.”

Bilbo smiled. “It must sound lovely, I’m sure to a dwarrow. Hobbits are more inclined to work with the Earth, as opposed to under it.” Thorin nodded.

“Of course. You hobbits prefer your homes, armchairs, fires, pipes, and planting.” Bilbo was glad Thorin couldn’t see his face, for his eyes had widened in shock. How in the Valar had Thorin remembered that?

Thorin seemed uncomfortable in his silence. “I apologize.” His earlier ease of conversation had vanished. “I just… my memory is near-perfect, and that conversation in particular seemed to resonate.”

“It’s no problem at all.” Bilbo recovered. He felt guilty to see Thorin so uncomfortable. But for once in his life, he couldn’t think of anything to say that could smooth over the silence. Thorin seemed to have an answer.

The dwarf stopped them in the middle of a hallway. “If you’ll follow me,” he said, turning left. Bilbo followed him through an alcove, and couldn’t help but gasp.

It was a garden.

“My mother kept a garden, when she was alive.” Thorin was explaining, while Bilbo slowly, methodically, walked along the perimeter. His eyes drank in every different bush and flowerbed. “She always liked flowers, and the different shades of green things.”

It took Bilbo a few moments, but he finally managed to look at Thorin. “Thank you for showing me this.” He whispered. The dwarf smiled, looking pleased with himself.

“It’s no problem. My sister, brother and I took turns keeping it up after she passed.”

“I’m sorry for your loss.” Thorin’s eyes looked pained to speak of his mother, but he shook away Bilbo’s condolences. “It is alright, it was many years ago. Keeping after her garden helped the three of us move on. It was a closure our father did not receive. He passed shortly after of a broken heart.”

Bilbo repeated a condolence, and Thorin told him not to worry, though his words were kind. “My grandfather is currently ruling.” He continued, sitting on the only bench at the garden’s center. Bilbo joined him.

“I didn’t know you were a gardener.”

“’Gardner’ is too generous of a word.” Thorin replied, “I could never manage something as nice as your garden back home.” It wasn’t fair, the way a statement uttered so matter-of-factly could turn his stomach in circles.

“Oh – I almost forgot.” The dwarf reach on his other side, opposite of Bilbo, and then sat straight.

“Here is an acorn, for your collection.”

It seemed that Thorin was full of surprises.

“I shouldn’t be surprised that you’d remember this too.” Bilbo carefully fingered the acorn in his hands. “This is perfectly lovely, thank you very much.”

“You’re welcome.” Thorin answered. A now-comfortable silence fell, and Bilbo took in the beauty of the small garden before him.

Thorin spoke after a few moments. “It you like, I am supposed to meet my sister for dinner. If you are uncommitted to any plans, perhaps you’d like to join us.”

Thorin’s sister. The Lady Dis. The Princess Under The Mountain. Dori had worked for her for years. Bilbo swallowed, but could think of no reason to refuse. Besides, they had just had a wonderful conversation and walk. Maybe Thorin wasn’t nearly as arrogant as their first meeting had suggested. Bilbo was big enough to admit when he was wrong.

“I would love to.”

--

Thorin helped Bilbo pull one of his servants to send word to the Ri residence that he would not be there.

“It’ll be for the best.” Bilbo remarked to Thorin as he watched the dwarf turn the corner. “The Ri family is supposed to meet with the Ur family for the wedding, and I was not sure where we would be finding ourselves.”

“You haven’t seen a dwarf wedding, have you?” Thorin asked. Bilbo shook his head as Thorin led him in a different direction.

“No matter how grand or small, they have the same sequence of events. One partner is led down a procession by the head of the family, to be married by a member of either the judiciary guild or of the Royal Family. They swear to honor and love one another. After there is a celebration, usually lasting three hours.”

“That’s not too different from a hobbit’s.” Bilbo remarked, “Though members of both families wear flowers in their hair. And it’s the one celebration where the couple will receive gifts rather than give them. And our celebration focuses on eating and dancing. Depending on the couple, it can go on and on. I once went to a wedding that lasted an entire day!”

The prince began to laugh, loudly. Those they passed by openly gaped – it was a rare occurrence to see Prince Thorin, usually so stone-faced, laugh as if he had no care in the world.

They continued to compare hobbit traditions to dwarf ones as Thorin showed Bilbo deeper and deeper into the mountain. It was the quarters of the royal family.   

“My sister’s place is not far from here.” Bilbo smiled at him. He hoped Thorin could not tell how the statement made him so very nervous.

--

Bilbo didn’t know what he had expected of the Lady Dis, but he knew the dwarrowdam before him was not what he had imagined.

She was perfectly lovely. Dis looked nearly identical to her brother, the only difference really being that her hair was slightly longer, and her build was slightly slimmer.

When Bilbo entered, Thorin introduced them. Dis gave him a warm hug, and then introduced him to her son’s (Thorin’s heirs) Fili and Kili. They were young, probably a year or two younger then Frodo. It was apparent that Dori had had a hand in teaching them manners, and their actions were also similar to Balin’s in the way they greeted Bilbo. But Bilbo knew young hobbits around Frodo’s age, and it was plainer then day that the princes had a mischievous streak to them. It was then that he silently decided that they would not meet Frodo if he could help it.

Dinner had been a pleasant affair. Dis was a perfectly gracious host, and everyone was remarkably friendly. Vili, her husband, was very amiable, and was curious about the different habits of hobbits. Thorin had a relaxed air about him that Bilbo had never seemed, and Bilbo was entertained by watching him speak in such an animated fashion to his sisters and nephews. In the midst of the dinner, a knock had sounded at the entrance to her rooms. Vili went to answer, and returned a moment later to tell Thorin that it was for him.

“I’m sorry about this.” Thorin reappeared a moment later. “It seems that the King needs his Heir.” It was said lightly, but with a slight scowl. Bilbo suspected he didn’t want to leave such a pleasant affair.

“Well, duty calls.” Dis remarked, while Thorin clasped Vili, and gave his nephews hugs good-bye. He then faced Bilbo. “I’m sorry to leave you like this.” His gaze was truly regretful.”

“It’s alright – I’ll see you around, yes?” Bilbo asked. Thorin nodded, and smiled at him. He then left.

After that, the topics of conversation drifted. Bilbo updated Dis on how Dori was doing – she was happy for him and Balin. Dis told him a little more about the history of the Mountain, and even had a few anecdotes of her two brothers growing up. These appeared to be stories that not even Fili and Kili knew, for they began to listen in earnest.

“Oh, the trouble Thorin, Frerin, and Dwalin would get in!” Dis was saying. Bilbo had been laughing, when he heard Dwalin’s name. The hobbit fell silent. “Have you heard from Dwalin?” Bilbo asked, “I had met him when I first met Thorin and Balin, and I was wondering where he was.”

“Well, that’s an interesting story.” Dis said, with a twinkle in her eye. Bilbo learned forward, “It turned out that Dwalin became rather besotted with someone out west.” Bilbo stilled. “But really,” she continued, not noticing his posture, “The other didn’t seem to keen. Actually, he didn’t seem interested at all. His mother was pushing for him to even speak to Dwalin!”

A pit was forming in Bilbo’s stomach.

“Plus, it became obvious that they only wanted Dwalin to be interested so the lad would have access to his money.”

Numbness took over now.

“So when Thorin and Dwalin headed back, Thorin of course had to talk some sense into our cousin. But Dwalin needed some time to think, so he agreed to escort Frerin to the Iron Hills to stay with our cousin Lord Dain. A shame they won’t be back until after the wedding – Frerin would have loved you.”

What was the proper decorum one kept, when one discovered that the happiness of one’s brother was ruined forever? Bilbo doubted his father would have an answer.

“Is everything alright?” This was Fili who spoke up now. “You look different.” Kili tilted his head to the side and nodded in agreement.

“Oh, I’m perfectly fine.” Bilbo lied, “But I’m feeling a little overwhelmed after today.” He turned toward Dis and Vili. “I’m terribly sorry, but might I excuse myself? I hadn’t imagined staying this long from my family today.”

Dis and Vili told him it would be no problem at all. Bilbo politely yet firmly warded off their offers to guide him back. After a few light-hearted good-byes, Bilbo left the residence.

It was unbelievable. That Thorin had spent as much time with him as he did – the man gave him an acorn! Only to have those opinions of his Ori, his family? The nerve! Bilbo felt lied too. It was his fault that his brother was so miserable. And Bilbo had spent the entire day with him!

Fondness had been growing in Bilbo’s heart for the awkward but appealing dwarf.

It was replaced by fury. 

Notes:

At last we have found some drama.

Comments? Questions? Advice? Want to know why I always mention something random in the last question? Leave a comment or a message. I like to reply to them - I get terribly lonely here, where I am.