Actions

Work Header

Made For Me

Chapter 3: 3

Summary:

Will plays his part

Chapter Text

“Will! Why are you here?”

Will glanced behind himself, as if he believed he might have been followed.

“I think you know why,” he said, glancing in another direction, “I would rather not talk about it out in the open.”

This was hardly “out in the open”, being the hall of an apartment building. In addition, Will knew the only ears Matthew should be worried about were Will’s own. Still, he intended to sell this charade, and by the look on Matthew’s face, he had succeeded. Hook, line, and sinker.

“Come in,” Matthew said, stepping out of the way so Will could enter the apartment.

It was basically what Will expected. Clean, organized, with police propaganda littered around. On the coffee table sat a few psychology books and books on predatory birds.

One thing that surprised him was a Ouija board, on top of a pile of books. It sat, so innocent and unassuming. Will’s gaze caught on it despite himself.

The moment the door closed behind him, Will dropped his shoulders and forced his body to visibly relax. He let go of all that faux anxiety, now that he was alone with the predator.

“So you finally heard,” Matthew said, “I was wondering how you would react.”

Will could hear how pleased he was. Surely, he had expected this to be one of the less likely outcomes of his actions. Or perhaps he was smugly satisfied because this was exactly what he had expected. Either way, his pride and desire were already blinding him.

Will watched as Matthew walked around the coffee table and plopped down onto the leather couch. He sprawled out grandly, like a primate preening before another of its kind. It was pageantry. Will could tell there was a tense anticipation still in his every muscle. A predator prepared to strike. Or perhaps prey ready to flee. Will wondered which one Matthew thought of himself, and which was the truth.

“How else would I react?” Will asked, keeping his tone even, though a bit breathy to keep up the facade of huge relief.

Matthew shrugged with a smile, gesturing for Will to take a seat in the lone armchair adjacent to the couch.

Will took a chance.

Rather than the offered seat, he came around the coffee table and sat next to Matthew. Very close, but not yet touching. As much as Will wanted to sell this act, he still had an aversion to physical contact.

By the way Matthew’s body reacted to his choice of seat, the message had been read and understood clearly.

“You could have been afraid of me,” Matthew said, and there was an edge to his voice now, something bordering on frayed restraint.

Will allowed his body to sink into the couch as far as it could, and closed his eyes. He didn’t smile, because he wanted to keep that for a better moment.

“Why would I be afraid of you, Matthew?” he asked, the picture of calm relaxation.

There was a long pause, and Will was tempted to open his eyes to see how his words were being taken. He thought he had a pretty good idea anyway.

He can’t believe his luck. This is better than what he could have imagined. His imagination is so limited.

“I killed a man. For you. Because of you. As a gift. That would scare most people. Even cops.”

Oh, definitely.

“But you knew I wouldn’t be scared,” Will said, “that’s why you did it.”

Another pause. Because that was true, but it wasn’t everything. Matthew had to choose what he would say.

“He deserved to die.”

Will opened his eyes and looked at Matthew, showing only innocent curiosity.

“And you deserved to kill him?” he asked.

Because this was the moment. That was the question.

Matthew held Will’s gaze, fascinated and just a touch bewildered.

He can’t believe his luck.

“No,” Matthew said at last, and he was a bit sharp, a drop of venom in his tone, “You deserved to. But you couldn’t. And you wouldn’t. So I did it for you.”

This was the moment.

Will smiled. Softly.

“You made me a killer.”

Matthew mirrored the smile.

“By proxy.”

“You didn’t ask me first. You didn’t tell me you were going to do it,” Will said.

Matthew scoffed.

“You would have said no. You would have tried to stop me. You didn’t trust me yet. I had to show you I was worth trusting.”

Will was careful not to show his anticipation on his face as he waited for the words he needed Matthew to say. He knew they were close. Seconds away.

“By killing the man who shot you.”

There it was.

Will allowed himself to relax even more. He had gotten what he had come here for. Matthew hadn’t suspected him at all, or else he would have been looking for a wire. Will’s gadget wasn’t as sophisticated as a wire, but it was easier to conceal. He had a small voice recorder in the pocket of his shirt. Behind the notebook he always kept there. He had all the evidence he needed. Matthew had just confessed to him. All he had to do now was get out of here alive.

“He didn’t know who I was when he shot me. It was random chance.”

Matthew shook his head, and Will saw his eyes dart over to where the Ouija board sat.

“I don’t believe in chance. Not anymore,” Matthew said, “Not now that I met you. If coincidences happen, they don’t happen in your life. This is more like divine intervention.”

Divine intervention.

Will didn’t even believe in God, but if he did he thought he would find this idea just as absurd. The idea that a God cared enough about him and his life to give him information, to show favoritism to someone who had not worshiped one day in his life was ridiculous to consider. If a God existed, they would not love Will, nor would they give him even a small gift.

“Why was I shot, then?” Will asked, “If I somehow hold the power to see the future?”

Matthew leaned closer, and Will had to force himself not to pull away.

“So I would have the chance to prove myself to you.”

Will understood, now.

Matthew thought they were both a part of some grand plan. Whether that plan was orchestrated by God or the devil, Will thought it wouldn’t make much difference to Matthew.

“Do you really think you won’t be caught?” Will asked, because he had to sell the act, and if Matthew had been helped in any way he would like to get that information for the chief as well.

Matthew chuffed.

“How would they catch me?” he asked, “They would have already come for me if they had any evidence. Even if they suspect me, they can’t do anything about it. There is no evidence. I made sure of it. And loyalty in the department is strong.”

Will was starting to see that. Still, he couldn’t help but say at least part of what was on his mind.

“Not as strong as you think,” he said, and Matthew tensed, “you are going to be caught. Someone who knows what you did is already working on having you be punished.”

Matthew was frozen entirely, his eyes fixed on Will as his thoughts whirled behind his eyes. Will saw still no shred of suspicion towards him. Matthew believed with all his heart that this was one of Will’s miraculous predictions. One he could not know, yet would come to pass. That was what Will had expected, and why he had even dared to say it to the other man.

“When?” Matthew asked.

Will shook his head.

“Only when you are not prepared to face it,” he said, and now he really didn’t know where the words were coming from, “When you feel secure in your place, and as if you can never fail.”

Matthew pulled back a bit, thoughtful.

“Is there anything I can do to get away?” he asked.

Because of course, if there was a way then Will would know of it. And Matthew trusted him entirely that he would share such wisdom.

“Don’t fight it,” Will said, because he might as well make things all that much easier, “Comply. Confess. Tell them why you did it, and answer their questions honestly. You can’t escape by yourself. I will come for you.”

Because Will knew he had to promise something in return for this act of faith. If Matthew thought he was dead either way, he would resolve to go down fighting. He would kill at least one of the arresting officers. He fought with complete abandon, but not without calculation.

Matthew let out a long breath. It clearly hadn’t been what he wanted to hear. Still, Will believed he had not risked anything with his words. He felt no concern over what would happen because of this night. Matthew was not a danger to him. Other people, most definitely. But not Will. Not yet.

“How long?” Matthew asked, “how long will I have to wait for you?”

Will didn’t want to make that promise. When time ran out, Matthew would raise hell. But he knew he wouldn’t accept it if Will didn’t give an answer. A real, solid answer.

“Four months,” he said, “Wait that long, and I will come for you. Prove yourself one more time.”

Will hadn’t meant to say that, and he didn’t know why he had. Still, from the way Matthew’s eyes flashed and his jaw set with determination, Will knew it had been the right thing to say.

“I’ll do it,” Matthew said, “Because I know you don’t lie. I have never heard you lie to anyone. Not even in the interrogation room.”

That struck Will. He supposed it was true. He certainly didn’t make a habit of lying. He preferred the truth always, and if he could get what he wanted using the truth he was happy with that.

But had he really never lied once with Matthew as witness?

Nevermind that he had denied his own possession of supernatural powers. Surely, Matthew would have some excuse for why he could say such things and not be lying.

Tonight, Will hadn’t lied. He had used questions to make Matthew say things he didn’t believe, and everything else he had spoken he had believed with every fiber of his being.

Matthew had been obsessed with him from the beginning, he realized. Not just since the day he was shot. Matthew had been watching him closely from the very start, and had been making all these secret observations. He should have seen it sooner.

He wanted to leave. He had everything he needed, and he wanted to get away from Matthew as quickly as possible. He just had to do it he right way, so Matthew would keep buying what he had told him to do.

Will checked his watch and glanced to the door, hoping he was transmitting a reluctance to leave, even though that wasn’t what he was feeling.

Matthew caught it.

“Do you have to leave?” he asked, and it was clear he didn’t like that thought, but believed he understood it.

Will sighed and nodded.

“I wish I could stay,” he lied, and this one really was a lie, like his promise to come for Matthew after four months, “but I’ve already been here for too long. If anyone is watching me or you, this was a bad idea.”

Matthew considered that.

“You came, so it’s probably safe, but if you feel you need to leave then you probably do,” he said, his faith unshakable. It made Will even more uncomfortable. “Do you have time for one more thing?”

Will knew his curiosity would be the death of him someday.

“What is it?” he asked.

Matthew jumped up and took hold of the Ouija board, making Will tense before he could think to hide his reaction.

“Don’t worry,” Matthew said, bringing it over, “It’s just a tool. For people like you. It helps get more clear answers. At least, it’s supposed to. I haven’t gotten it to work. I don’t have a gift.”

He wants me to try it, Will thought in a panic, to see if it works when someone with an actual gift tries it. But I don’t have a gift. It won’t work. And even if it does, it’s evil. Nothing but evil.

Will stood up.

“I’m sorry, Matthew,” he said, another lie, “but no. I don’t have time for that. I really have to go. Something bad is going to happen if I stay.”

Another prediction.

At least Matthew believed in them.

Matthew frowned, but nodded.

“Okay. Go. This is the last time we’ll see each other for a while, isn’t it?”

Will nodded, making his way to the door.

“It has to be,” he said, “don’t try to contact me. I’ll come for you. Just be patient.”

Just as Will’s hand was on the door, his wrist was caught. Matthew was faster than he should be. And that dangerous thing was in his eyes.

Before Will could react to his close proximity, Matthew had leaned in and kissed him. Will was frozen, torn between his act and his honest reaction. He just held still and let it happen, afraid of throwing away everything he had accomplished this night.

Matthew pulled away, and Will let out the breath he had been holding in. That made Matthew smile, and Will was glad he would be behind bars soon, and far away from him.

“It was my last chance,” Matthew said smugly, “I can’t do that again for four months.”

Will was glad that was all he was trying to do. There was a limit to what he was willing to go through to put criminals behind bars. He would gladly get shot before he did anything like this with Matthew.

“I really have to go,” Will said, yanking the door open and stepping out into the night, “goodbye, Matthew.”

Matthew stood in the doorway for only a second as Will stepped away from him, clearly too cautious to do anything more than that.

When the door closed, Will wanted to let his guard down. But he knew better. He waited until he was in his car, and had driven halfway home before he stopped and took the recording device from his pocket.

He knew better than to try to alter the recording. He had to hand it over whole to the chief and the investigating team. As much as he wanted to keep anyone else from hearing what had happened, he knew it was his job.

At least he would never have to see Matthew again after he went away. Best case scenario was that someone managed to kill Matthew while he was in prison, and Will hoped he could count on that so he would never have to know what Matthew would do when the time ran out on his promise.