Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

In our minds, in our letters, we are together.

Summary:

Will stepped into his home, expecting the regular. A kiss, he would accept with closed eyes. And then dinner, discussing how Washington was and how he missed her the entire weeks of time and how the case wasn't nearly as bad as he thought it would be. 

But it didn't happen.

The house was too quiet. 

He set his keys in the bowl by the door. 

"Molly? Wally?" 

No one responded.

He walked into the kitchen.

The vase was gone. The flowers he had sent to the house weren't there. The little dish where she kept her rings while doing dishes disappeared from the counter. Her favorite mug was missing from the drying rack.

---
Will was spending his life trying to replace the person Hannibal is. Molly finally learns the truth.

Work Text:

Molly swore she married right. A solid, standup guy. Sure, he had some troubles in the past- a case of bad friends. Or she guesses, a bad few friends, coworkers, and choices all unraveled by a bad case of strep throat.

Despite, what her friend Caroline insisted, he was good. Will was sweet, a good dad and a better lover. He was attentive. Bringing home fish to cook with, serving meals parred with expensive wine bought for her, buying her clothing for work. Insisting she needed new perfumes, and better skincare.

Sure he wasn't perfect. Savoring the taste of whiskey a little too much.. Sometimes looking at her with such distant, inexplainable sadness that she felt compelled to touch his face, just to make sure he was still there- still okay.

But he was a better one. And she loved him. Loved his brain, even if she didn't understand it.

She loved that he listened, deeply. Without interruption, each word savored. He also had impeccable memory. Remembering how she liked her coffee, which fish she didn't like the taste of, what town she grew up in. He made her feel special, and made her feel known. 

She knew that when he stared across the dinner table that peculiar sensation of being studied was because he cared. It was romantic. 

Each dinner a special occasion accompanied with a bottle of wine, and a special experience. Every outing made with a tailored dress he picked up because it brought out a particular color in her eyes. 

She remembered when he came into the bathroom last month, a soft smile as he saw her combing her hair. She remembered how his nose scrunched at the smell of her perfume. 

"You should wear something different."

It must have been causing him headaches because he insisted on something less floral. "Something with amber, or perhaps Sandalwood."

"Will, I don't know what sandalwood smells like."

"I'll find you something."

And he did. 

The first time, the perfume was too ferocious. The next time it was too mellow. By the fifth time he found one, that was perfect. And she thought it was perfect how much he cared. 

Plus he had excellent taste.

That was what she told herself when he replaced her winter sweaters with fitted blouses, when he suggested she try wine AFTER smelling it, when he began teaching her to appreciate new.. richer foods. 

"I don't like scallops, Will hon."

"Just try it. The spinach pomegranate salad should compliment the texture." 

So she did. And it was right. "It's good."

"Good." He repeated to himself, smiling faintly. Eyes heavy with age. "I'm glad."

He always looked relieved, as if she passed a test.

Molly was just glad Will was helping her discover new things. A delightful privilege of marriage.

To learn another taste and allow love to be the reason you change your own. 

She didn't know that Will had spent years learning one man's tastes by heart.

She didn't know that the perfume he liked on her was the perfume he remembered on another man's skin.

She didn't know that when he watched her lift a wineglass, his eyes sometimes went distant because he was comparing the angle of her wrist to the memory of elegant fingers curled around crystal.

She didn't know that he was teaching her how to become someone else.

Or, rather, that he was teaching her how to become someone he had lost.

She only knew that her husband loved her.

And that, she thought, was enough.

Until the letters.

The first one was dated a Tuesday. 

She had been looking for the receipt- Wally getting strep had lead to a week worth of antibiotics- insurance have finally gotten back on reimbursment. Will had insisted on keeping the paperwork in his study, organized perfectly. He liked things in their proper place. He liked his books arranged by subject and his tools organized ind rawers. He liked kitchen knives sharp and the pantry stocked with ingredients she couldn't pronounce.

He liked a great many things.

The receipt wasn't in the desk drawer. It was in a folder beneath a stack of papers. All covered in Will's handwriting.

She might have put them back.

She ought to have put them back. 

But Will's handwriting was all over the envelope, and she had spent enough years married to him to recognize the particular pressure of his pen. The paper had been nearly torn through in places. Some words were written so faintly they were almost invisible; others had been struck so hard into the page that the ink had bled.

There was no name on the envelope.

Only a date.

And beneath it, in smaller writing:

Do not send.

She opened it.

"Why am I here?

To imitate the shape of a thing I cannot become. To cultivate a garden in soil salted by your hands. To be the thorns and the white roses, the gardener and the rot beneath his fingernails. To watch the sky unbecome, the explosions and deaths of a million stars until there is nothing left above me but the dark I have mistaken for shelter.

I have built a house, Hannibal."

Molly paused, breath caught at the name. It was a name all too familiar. 

She knew who Hannibal Lecter was. Everyone knew, in one way or another. The papers had made sure of that. Plenty of photographs, interviews, accounts of the murders, and the endless, sensational retelling of the terrible manipulative things that he had done to Will Graham, the special agent with a mind too skilled. 

Will rarely spoke of him.

When he had, it was as if Hannibal was a long forgotten man. No not a man... He spoke of Hannibal as a tragedy, a mistake, and a monster. Never a man. 

Molly looked back down at the page. And then she continued to read.

"There are trees, like back in Wolf Trap. The windows face west. In the evenings the light comes through the kitchen and lays itself across the counters like sacrament. My wife likes it. She says the house feels warm at that hour.

I don't feel warm.

I tell her I chose the windows for the light.

I lied. 

I chose them because I remember how you looked in the dying sun. 

Who am I?

I am the clock unwound, forever arrested at 6:16. The neighbor children whisper about, the lonely man with too many dogs and a house that smells of wet earth. (I am lonely, and I am married. I have a son, Wally. He isn't Abigail.) I am a deer wearing human clothes, standing at the edge of the forest, wondering why the other animals recognize me as prey. (I am not a mongoose.) 

I am the lamb that learned to bare its teeth,

I am the wolf that cannot remember what it was like to hunt before it became pleasurable.

I am whatever you saw when you looked at me. (Me, did you see me?)

I have tried so desperate to be something else. Someone else. He looks like you.

How am I?

Poorly.

Bedelia says I should be more precise, about my emotions. She believes that if I name them correctly, it might keep them from devouring me.

So: I am not well.

I am not well when I wake. I am not well when I eat. I am not well when my wife lays her hand against my back and I must remind myself that I am in my house, in my bed, in my life. 

I have to remind myself that the hand is hers. That the warmth belongs to a living woman who loves me.

I am not well, I am a cruel man.

I am not well when I look at her and see, for one wretched second, the shape of your absence.

I am not well when I don't.

When am I?

Better? Whole? Forgiven?

Only with scotch in my greedy belly, when the whiskey burns away the edges of the world and leaves me somewhere soft and dark. Only when the warmth comes, artificial and fleeting, like sunlight through stained glass. (I remember the heart you gave me.) Only when I can pretend that the heat in my chest is yours and not the fever of something dying.

You are dying. In my head, you are dying. I have no more memories to relive. I have lived them all over and over and over. Till I can tell them as biblical scripture my Pa would hate.

I am only myself when I am drunk.

With you. On you.

I cannot remember which. 

I think of you as a stag. Always have. Beautiful, watchful, terrible in your stillness. A creature that has never needed to lower its head to prove it possesses antlers. You stand among the trees as though the forest were an extension of your body, as though every living thing has been placed there for your amusement.

I once didn't see what you are. I do now.

I approach you knowing what you are. I know you might gut me, again. I approach you anyway. 

You have always been so patient with my ruin. You turn my arm as though examining a broken instrument, find the places where my bones meet incorrectly, and tell me that I am beautiful in my disrepair. You call my madness a becoming. You make a religion of my ugliness until I begin to believe that there is something sacred in being seen by you.

I want to be consumed. 

For you to take my clothes off, and comb my fur. 

I want to be spared. 

The world aflame while we stand alive. 

I want to put my hands against your chest and feel something monstrous beating beneath it.

I want you to gut me, open me and look. Look at me again. 

I want you to find nothing you do not recognize.

Is that love?

Or is it merely the hunger of a starving parasite, mistaking the knife for the hand that feeds it. 

It isn't love.

I don't love you.

I have a wife. 

She is kind, patient, a lot like Alana. She wears the perfume I chose for her and smiles when I bring her wine. She lets me teach her things. Sometimes she looks at me with so much passion, I am sick. I am depraved. She thinks of me as a gift. 

I am not. I have not gifted her anything.

I have only been arranging flowers in the shape of a grave. 

I have been setting a place at the table for a man who is not there.

I have been so desperately trying to prove that a garden can grow in the absence of its gardener, that a house can be a home without walls or a roof. 

I see you laughing. Telling me my relationship with Molly is not dead, for it wasn't alive.

You would be right.

I hate you for being right.

I hate you for leaving me. (I know where you are. I can't visit you. I can't do it.)

I hate you for not making a home with me.

I hate you for teaching me to recognize beauty in the things that destroy me.

You destroyed me.

But I hate myself most of all, because if you stood in my doorway tomorrow, I would let you in."

Molly was sick. Vomit coming up. This wasn't her husband, it couldn't be. He wasn't this... person. 

"I would pour you wine,

I would show you the garden.

I see it clear as day, watching your face for a verdict on the house, on the light, on the cruel forgiveness I am waiting to give you.

I miss you.

There. I have written it plainly, without the garden, without the stag, without the elaborate little disguises I have learned from you. 

I miss you.

I miss you so much that I have begun to mistake the wound for the organs that keep me alive.

I don't want you free.

Rot in prison.

I do not want you back.

I do not want you back.

I do not-"

The rest of the page is torn away.

The words ended there, severed so violently that the paper had split beneath the ink. She sat very still. Still nauseous.

But despite what she thought, she wasn't angry. She expected grief, some terrible, humiliating admission that would make her feel foolish for ever having believed in him. But this was worse. This was a man arguing with himself in the privacy of his own home, trying to convince himself that he did not want something he had already given himself to.

She looked at the other pages again.


I don't want you free.
Rot in prison.
I do not want you back.
The repetition was almost childish. A foot stamping against the floor. A little boy insisting he did not want the toy he had been crying for, even as he clutched it to his chest.


Molly had seen Will lie before. She had watched him hide pain behind a crooked smile, dismiss a nightmare with a shrug, and insist he was fine while his hands shook around a coffee mug.


But she had never understood that his lies could be so beautiful.


That he could make a cathedral out of denial and kneel inside it for years.


She set the letter down.


Then she picked it up again.


At the bottom of the stack, there were more. The next dated eleven days later. 

It was shorter than the first, but the handwriting was worse. Words wandered down the page until they crowded at the bottom. Where a sentence had been written over itself until Molly could barely make it out. "I am trying to be precise, to tell the truth. I am trying to stop,"

She turned the page to the beginning. 

"Dear Hannibal,

I have been thinking about the difference between wanting something and deserving it.


You would say there is no difference worth discussing. Desire is an appetite, and appetite is not a moral failing. It is what one does to satisfy it that reveals the nature of the beast.

I have always hated how easily you make wickedness sound like wisdom.

I have been trying to be a husband.

This morning, Molly kissed my cheek before leaving for work. She smelled of the perfume I bought her. She told me she loved me. I told her I loved her, too.

I did not lie.

That is the terrible thing. I did not lie, and still I betrayed her.

I love her as one might love a garden that has grown over a grave. I appreciate the flowers. I am grateful for the shade. I tend the soil and watch the seasons pass, and every so often I remember what lies beneath my feet.

I cannot tell her.

I cannot tell her that I have spent our marriage measuring the distance between her and a ghost. I cannot tell her that I have watched her learn to like the things I like, and that every time she smiles at something I have taught her to appreciate, I feel a momentary, despicable triumph.

You would understand that triumph.

You would recognize it for what it is: the satisfaction of having made another person resemble the object of one's desire.

I wonder whether you would be disgusted with me.

I wonder whether you would be proud.

I wonder which possibility would hurt more.

I have started dreaming about the prison.

Not your cell. I have never seen your cell. I imagine it differently each night. Sometimes it is a dark room with a narrow bed and a little window through which no sunlight ever enters. Sometimes it is an enormous, beautiful room, furnished with everything you could possibly want, except a door. Sometimes I am standing outside it, and you are on the other side of the glass, watching me with that unbearable patience of yours.
In the dreams, I am always the one who cannot leave.

I wake up with my hands clenched.

I wake up reaching for you.

I have started sleeping on my side of the bed, as close to the edge as I can manage without falling. There is a ridiculous comfort in the empty space beside me. I can pretend it is waiting to be occupied.

I know you are not coming.

I know you cannot come.

I know these things with the reasonable part of my mind, the part that recognizes a prison for what it is and understands that locked doors are not metaphors. I know them as certainly as I know my own name.

But there is another part of me.

You know the part.

The part that has never believed a locked door to be the same thing as an ending.

I am trying to be precise, Bedelia says.

I am trying to tell the truth.

I am trying to stop.

I want you.

Will. "

Molly lowered the page.

She pressed her lips together until they hurt.

It was the casualness of it that undid her. The way he could describe kissing her, telling her he loved her, lying beside her at night, and then turn immediately to Hannibal as though the other man were the only person capable of understanding the significance of any of it.

She thought of all the mornings she had kissed Will goodbye. All the evenings she had come home and asked about his day. All the nights she had lain awake beside him, watching the shadows move across the ceiling, wondering what terrible thing had happened to him that he couldn't tell her.

She had thought he was afraid to let her in.

He had been afraid she would discover there was someone else already inside.

And the worst of it was that Hannibal wasn't even there.

He was in prison. Behind locks and glass and walls thick enough to separate a man from the world. Will had built an entire relationship around someone who could not come to him, then used the impossibility of that relationship to excuse himself from the one he already had.

Molly wanted to hate Hannibal.

It would have been easier if she could.

She wanted to blame him for the perfume, the wine, the clothes. For the way Will's face changed when she wore red. For the way his eyes sometimes lingered on her mouth as though he were waiting for a different voice to come out of it.

But Hannibal had not chosen her perfume.

Will had.

Hannibal had not stood in their kitchen and watched her learn to enjoy a meal she had once disliked.

Will had.

Hannibal had not kissed her goodnight and then sat in his study writing letters about how he wished he could come home to another man.

Will had done all of that himself.

She gathered the pages into a neat stack.

There were more.

The third letter had no date.

It began with a single sentence.

"I think I am beginning to understand why you liked the stag."

Beneath it, Will had written:

"It is not because the stag is beautiful, though it is. It is not because it is dangerous, though it can be. It is because the stag stands in the forest and belongs to it without ever having to ask permission.

You have always been like that.

You walk into a room and the room becomes yours. You sit at a table and the table seems to have been built for you. You look at a man and he begins to wonder whether he has been waiting his entire life to be looked at.
I have spent years trying to convince myself that this is a kind of manipulation.

Perhaps it is.

But I have been manipulated by many people. I have been lied to, used, studied, and made into an instrument. I have been treated as a means to an end by people who believed their ends justified whatever they did to me.

You were the only one who ever made me feel as though the end might be worth reaching.

I do not know what that says about either of us. I only know that when I think of you, I do not think of the things you did to me first. I think of the things you saw.

I think of your attention.

I think of the terrible, exquisite sensation of being understood by a person who had no intention of making me easier to love.

You did not ask me to be harmless.

You asked me to be honest.

I have been neither.

I have tried to make myself into a good man, Hannibal. I have tried to become the sort of man who can be loved without consequence. I have tried to be gentle, patient, forgiving. I have tried to believe that goodness is a destination rather than a performance.

And then I remember you.

I remember the way you watched me, the way you waited for me to arrive at a conclusion you had reached long before I had the courage to begin. I remember how infuriating it was to discover that you knew me. How much I wanted to prove you wrong. How much I wanted you to be right.

I wanted you to see me.

I wanted you to see me and hate what you found.

I wanted you to see me and love it.

I wanted so many contradictory things from you that I have begun to suspect contradiction is the only honest language I possess.

I do not know whether I love you.

I know that I have spent years trying to find a word that would make wanting you less shameful.

Obsession. Dependency. Trauma. Grief.

I have tried every word I can find.

None of them has your name.

Perhaps that is the problem.

Perhaps I have been trying to name the ocean without admitting that I am drowning.

I miss you.

I miss you.

I miss you.

Will."

The final three lines were in a different pen. The ink was darker, the pressure harder. Beneath them, Will had added. "I will not send this."

Molly let out a breath she hadn't known she was holding. She thought of her memories with Will. The way he watched her taste something and wait for her response with a concentration that had made her feel adored. 

But the truth hit.

He hadn't been waiting for her to like it.

He was waiting for her to become someone else.

And she had been so happy to please him.

She felt humiliated by that happiness. By the memory of showing Caroline the perfume, telling her how thoughtful Will was, how he'd insisted on finding the right one. By the way she'd turned her wrist beneath Caroline's nose and laughed when her friend called her spoiled.

The fourth letter was a single paragraph. 

"I dreamed you were home. You were standing in the kitchen, reading a book, and the light from the window fell across your hands. You looked up when I entered, as though you had been expecting me. You asked if I had eaten. I said no. You told me there was food in the refrigerator. It was the most ordinary thing in the world. I woke up crying. I have never been so ashamed of wanting something."

Molly set the final page down.

She looked at the stack. She couldn't force herself to read them anymore. 


There was no grand confession to be found among them. No sudden realization that would turn Will into a different man, no secret explanation that would make the hurt less real. There was only the same truth repeated in a hundred different ways.
Will wanted Hannibal.


Will had always wanted Hannibal.


And Molly had been the person he chose to hurt while he tried to pretend otherwise.


She stood, gathered the letters, and carried them downstairs.

She did not burn them.

She did not tear them up.

She found an envelope, placed the pages inside, and sealed it.

Then she wrote the name on the front.

Dr. Hannibal Lecter.

She knew where he was being held. The address was public knowledge. It had appeared in the newspapers often enough that she could have written it from memory.

For a moment, she considered adding a note.

Something sharp. Something cruel. Something that would make Hannibal understand that she knew what he had done to Will, that she understood what Will had done to her, that she refused to be the only person left carrying the weight of this grotesque little love story.

But what could she say that the letters hadn't already said?

She had no wish to beg Hannibal to return Will to her. No wish to ask a man in prison to repair the damage his absence had done.

She wanted him to know.

She wanted him to read every word Will had written and understand that somewhere, in a house he had never entered, there had been a woman who loved Will Graham and had been made to feel like a substitute for a man she had never met.

She wanted Hannibal to know that Will had tried to forget him.

And that he had failed.

Molly put on her coat and took the envelope to the post office.

She sent it with a return address.

An address she wouldn't be at.


Will stepped into his home, expecting the regular. A kiss, he would accept with closed eyes. And then dinner, discussing how Washington was and how he missed her the entire weeks of time and how the case wasn't nearly as bad as he thought it would be. 

But it didn't happen.

The house was too quiet. 

He set his keys in the bowl by the door. 

"Molly? Wally?" 

No one responded.

He walked into the kitchen.

The vase was gone. The flowers he had sent to the house weren't there. The little dish where she kept her rings while doing dishes disappeared from the counter. Her favorite mug was missing from the drying rack.

He stood in the middle of the room, staring at the empty spaces.

Then he went upstairs,.

The perfume bottles were still there. The blouses were still there. The expensive watch was also still there.

But the framed photograph of the two of them at the beach had been taken from the bedside table.

He opened the wardrobe, and just as he expected. All that was left was his clothes, and the "gifts" he had given.

Will sat down on the edge of the bed. Winston whining by the door. 

He did not cry.

He thought he might. He waited for it, sitting very still, his hands resting on his knees. He willed for the tears to pour, hoped they would. 

Instead, he felt a terrible, hollow clarity.

Molly was gone. 

He had hurt her. He had used her kindness as a place to hide, and he had made her complicit in a fantasy she had never agreed to inhabit. He had let her love him while he spent his days longing for someone else. 

There was no excuse for it. 

He knew that.

He knew that he should be devastated, that the loss of his marriage should be the only thing he could feel. But beneath the guilt, beneath the shame, beneath the knowledge that he had done something cruel to a woman who had loved him, there was another feeling.

A quietness.

A loosening.

For the first time in years, he did not have to pretend that he was waiting for his life to begin.

He was waiting for Hannibal.

He had always been waiting for Hannibal.

Will pressed his hands against his face.

“Oh, God,” he whispered.

He did not know whether he was praying for forgiveness or asking to be punished.

Perhaps both.

After a while, he went to his office. 

A sick depraved desire to see the letters. 

He had left them in his study, stacked. He had told himself he would destroy them eventually. He had told himself that they were only words, only an exercise, only a way of making his thoughts less dangerous by giving them somewhere to go.

He opened the drawer.
It was no stack. Just a single envelope.

Will stared at it.

For several seconds, he could not understand what he was seeing. Then he began to search. He pulled open the other drawers, lifted the papers on his desk, checked the shelves and the wastebasket. He went through the room twice, moving faster each time.

The letters were gone.

His stomach tightened.

Molly had found them.

Of course she had found them.

He sat down hard in the desk chair and looked at the empty drawer.

He imagined her reading them. Her face changing as she moved from one page to the next. The hurt, the confusion, the humiliation. He imagined her understanding exactly what he had done.

He imagined her hating him.

He deserved it.

He wanted to call her. He wanted to tell her that he was sorry, that he had never meant for her to become part of something so ugly. He wanted to tell her that he had loved her, in whatever broken, inadequate way he had been capable of loving anyone.

But he knew what she would say.

"Then why wasn't I enough?"

Will closed his eyes.

Because she had never been the question.

He had made her one. He had spent years trying to convince himself that if he could build a life with her, if he could be good to her, if he could love her enough, then the past would loosen its hold on him.

But Hannibal had never been the past.

Hannibal was the part of him that had never stopped looking forward.

Will opened the drawer again.

He glared at the singular letter, wondering what fucked up one Molly left for him to relive. 

But he paused, seeing his name written across the front in an elegant, unmistakable hand. 

Will forgot how to breathe.

He reached for it, then stopped.

For a moment, he simply stared at the writing.

He knew that hand. He knew the long, graceful strokes, the measured pressure, the way the letters seemed to possess an almost infuriating certainty.

Hannibal.

Will picked up the envelope.

It was sealed.

There was no date on the front, no return address, no indication of how it had come to be there. He turned it over in his hands, searching for an explanation that did not exist.

Then he opened it.

Inside was a single sheet of cream-colored paper.


"Will,

I have imagined your life without me so many times that I have, on occasion, mistaken these imaginings for memories.

I know the house you might have chosen. I know where the afternoon light would fall across the kitchen floor, which chair you would claim as your own, and how you would complain about the garden while secretly taking pride in its unruliness. I know that you would leave books open facedown upon the furniture and insist that the dogs are permitted on the sofa because they have nowhere else to go. I know you would dislike the curtains I selected and eventually grow accustomed to them. I know that you would find some fault with the wine I served, even when you enjoyed it.

I know all of this because I have spent years imagining a life with you.

Not a life of grand gestures or dramatic declarations. Those are the fantasies of men who have never understood the intimacy of being known. I have imagined the unremarkable things. Your coat abandoned over the back of a chair. Your hand resting on my wrist as you reach past me for something on the table. The sound of your footsteps approaching a room in which I have been waiting for you. The quiet certainty of knowing that when the day has exhausted you, you will come to me—not because there is nowhere else to go, but because there is nowhere else you would rather be.

I have imagined waking beside you.

I have imagined watching you sleep, your face stripped of the careful suspicion with which you meet the waking world. I have wondered whether you would permit yourself that softness in my presence, or whether even in our bed you would insist upon keeping one eye open, one hand near a weapon, some small part of yourself prepared to flee.

I suspect you would.

I would love you for it.

I have imagined our conversations, too. The arguments. The silences. The things we would never need to explain because explanation would be an unnecessary insult to the understanding between us. I have imagined you looking at me across a dinner table, a knife in your hand, and recognizing that I have given you something far more intimate than a meal.

I have imagined you knowing precisely what I am.

And remaining.

That is the life I have wanted, Will. Not your innocence. Not your salvation. Not the domesticated version of you that the world might tolerate, provided you kept your teeth hidden and your hands clean.

You have never needed to be made good for me.

I know the shape of the darkness in you. I have seen the terrible grace with which you approach it, the revulsion with which you turn away, and the longing with which you look back. I know that you have spent much of your life believing these contradictions make you monstrous in some singular, unforgivable way.

They do not.

Or, if they do, then you are not alone.

There is a particular loneliness in being recognized only in fragments. The world has always been willing to admire my intelligence, my manners, my accomplishments. It has been willing to sit at my table, to enjoy the fruits of my labor, to call me cultured and refined. It has not been willing to see what these things conceal. It prefers the mask, and I have worn it so well that I have sometimes wondered whether anyone would recognize me without it.

You did.

Not immediately. Not without resistance. You saw me and recoiled, then returned. You called me a monster as though the word might create sufficient distance between us. You sought to expose me, to punish me, to destroy me. And through it all, you continued to look.

You saw me because some part of you understood me.

I saw you for the same reason.

Perhaps this is what I have meant all along when I have spoken of becoming. You were never intended to become me, Will. Nor I you. What I recognized was not a reflection but a complement: the part of the world that had always been missing from my own, the answering note to a sound I had believed complete.

You possess a capacity for violence that frightens you because you have mistaken your horror of it for proof that it does not belong to you. I possess no such convenient illusion. Yet neither of us is made only of the things we fear. There is tenderness in you that does not diminish your darkness. There is darkness in me that does not render tenderness impossible.

Together, we might have been something neither of us could have become alone.

I do not mean that we would have made one another better.

I have never thought you needed to be better in the way the world means it. I have wondered, instead, what we might have become if neither of us had been required to pretend.

A terrible thing, perhaps.

A beautiful one.

Almost certainly both.

I have spent years imagining the life we might have had, and I have spent nearly as many convincing myself that you were better without me.

It was not a difficult argument to make. You had a wife. A son. A house in which your name was spoken without fear. You had the opportunity to become a man whose days were measured by ordinary concerns: the weather, the garden, the health of a child, the small and tedious negotiations of a marriage. You had people who loved you without requiring you to explain the worst things you had done. You had a chance at peace.

I knew what I had offered you.

I knew what I had taken from you.

And so I told myself that your absence was a kindness. That the distance between us was a mercy you had earned. That if I loved you—and I did, though I had not yet found a word that could contain it without diminishing it—then I would accept the life you chose, even if that life did not include me.

I would not reach for you merely because I wanted you.

I would not make a prison of your affection and call it devotion.

I would let you go.

I have repeated these convictions to myself with the diligence of a man tending a grave. I have maintained them through the long days and longer nights. I have sat in this cell and imagined you happy, and I have tried to make my happiness for you something more than a performance.

Sometimes I have succeeded.

I have imagined you laughing with your son. I have imagined you holding your wife while she sleeps. I have imagined you coming home to her, setting aside the burdens of the day, allowing yourself to be comforted by a life that asks nothing extraordinary of you.

I have imagined all of this, and I have wanted it for you.

I want you to understand that.

I have wanted you safe, Will. I have wanted you free of me. I have wanted you to find some peace in a world that has so rarely permitted you any.

But wanting these things for you has never prevented me from wanting other things for myself.

And I am not as noble as I have tried to appear.

I am jealous of your wife.

There. It is an ugly sentence, and I will not dress it in finer language merely to make it easier to endure.

I am jealous that she knows the sound of your footsteps in the hall. I am jealous that she has heard your voice before you have fully awakened, that she has seen you tired and unguarded, that she has been permitted to occupy the ordinary spaces of your life. I am jealous that she can reach for you without first crossing the distance of an ocean, a prison, a history of bloodshed, and all the terrible things we have done to one another.

I am jealous of the chair she sits in at your table.

I am jealous of the bed in which you sleep.

I am jealous of the mornings.

It is a humiliating thing, to envy the ordinary. I have never wanted a life merely because it was conventional, and I have never believed marriage to be a sacred institution simply because other people have agreed to call it one. Yet I find myself imagining her beside you, and I feel something in me turn its face away.

She has been given what I have spent years imagining.

Not because she has stolen it from me. Not because she has done anything wrong. She may love you sincerely. She may be good to you. She may have offered you a gentleness that I could never have offered without first learning how to trust it.

I do not know her well enough to condemn her.

I resent her all the same.

I resent the fact that she can love you without understanding the entirety of you and still be permitted to call that love a life. I resent that she can stand beside you in the daylight while I have been relegated to the dark corners of your memory. I resent that she can touch your face and not have to wonder whether the tenderness between you is another form of violence.

And I resent, most of all, that you may have learned to be happy there.

I have tried to make peace with that possibility. I have told myself that if you are happy, then I should be content. That the shape of your happiness is immaterial so long as it is yours.

I have told myself that you have chosen a life in which you do not have to look too closely at what you are.

But I know you, Will.

I know that you can love your wife and still be lonely. I know that you can hold your son and feel the full, overwhelming tenderness of being his father, and still encounter something in yourself that neither domesticity nor devotion can quiet. I know that you can be grateful for your life and wonder whether gratitude is the same thing as belonging.

I know because I have wondered these things for you.

And because I have wondered them for myself.

I have been alone for so long that I have learned to make an art of it. I have cultivated the rituals, the books, the meals prepared for one. I have learned to turn deprivation into an exercise of the mind. There is very little a man cannot convince himself he does not need when the alternative is admitting how desperately he wants it.

I have told myself that I do not need you.

I have told myself that imagination is sufficient.

It is not.

For years, I could survive on the life I made for us in my mind. I could place you across from me at dinner and listen to the arguments we might have had. I could imagine your displeasure at my choices, your reluctant amusement, the way you might look at me when you believed I had said something particularly unforgivable. I could imagine you beside me in the garden, your hands in the soil, your attention fixed upon some small, living thing you would insist was worth saving.

I could imagine you staying.

But imagination has become a room without a door.

I have lived in it for so long that I have begun to mistake its walls for the boundaries of the world. Every imagined morning ends when I open my eyes. Every conversation concludes in silence. Every time I reach for you, I find only the space where you ought to be.

I am tired, Will.

Not of waiting. Waiting is merely time, and I have always been patient with time.

I am tired of loving you in a world where I cannot hear you answer.

I want the life beyond the one I have made in my mind. I want the irritating, imperfect, astonishing reality of you. I want to know what you would say to me now, knowing everything you know. I want to sit across from you and watch you decide whether to hate me. I want to hear you tell me that I am wrong. I want you to look at me with that terrible understanding of yours and make me answer for every moment I have spent imagining a future in which you forgave me.

I do not even require forgiveness.

I would take your anger. I would take your contempt. I would take the truth, however cruelly you chose to give it to me.

I would take the opportunity to stand in front of you and discover whether the man I have loved for so long still exists beyond the confines of my own longing.

And if he does, I want him to have the choice I was once so certain I should deny him.

I want you to choose me.

Not because I have decided that you belong to me. Not because the things we have done to one another have bound you to me beyond your will. Not because I believe that our shared darkness constitutes a claim upon your future.

I want you to choose me because you know what I am, and I know what you are, and neither of us must become less monstrous to be loved by the other.

I want you to look at the worst of me and recognize something that does not frighten you into retreat.

I want to do the same for you.

Perhaps that is what I have been trying to say all these years. Perhaps this is what I knew before either of us was willing to acknowledge it: that there are parts of us which, left alone, become unbearable, and that recognition does not cure them, but gives them somewhere to go.

We were never going to save one another.

I think we might have been able to live.

There is a difference.

I have imagined a thousand lives with you, Will. In some, you come to me willingly. In others, you arrive furious, armed with all the reasons I do not deserve you. In some, we are gentle with one another. In others, we spend years learning the difficult distinction between hurting someone and being hurt by them. I have imagined a life in which you never forgive me, and one in which I never ask you to.

In every version, you are there.

I have tried to imagine a future in which you are not, and I have never managed to make it convincing.

I thought I could accept that you were better without me. I still hope, in some distant and increasingly difficult part of myself, that you have found happiness beyond my reach.

But I no longer wish to spend the rest of my life loving you only in the conditional tense.

I do not want another imagined dinner. I do not want another conversation conducted in the silence of my cell. I do not want to spend the remaining years of my life constructing a home for you in my mind while another man, another life, another set of circumstances decides what you are permitted to become.

I want to be there.

I want to be there when you are cruel. I want to be there when you are kind. I want to see what you do with the parts of yourself you have spent so long trying to bury. I want to know whether we can make something of the terrible recognition between us, something that exists beyond the hunt, beyond the blood, beyond the necessity of losing one another in order to prove that we cannot bear to be apart.

I want to know what happens when we stop making a tragedy of our love and begin, however imperfectly, to live with it.

I am afraid, Will.

Not that you will hate me. I have given you sufficient reason.

Not that you will refuse me. I have imagined that refusal so often that I know its every expression.

I am afraid that you will come to me and discover that the life I have built around you is only another beautiful prison. I am afraid that the man you remember is not the man who will stand before you. I am afraid that we will look at one another, at last, and find that recognition is not enough.

But I am more afraid of reaching the end of my life without ever having asked you to choose.

I have spent years imagining the man you might have become beside me. It is time, I think, to discover whether he exists.

And whether I might become someone who deserves to stand beside him.

I love you, Will.

I have loved you through every silence, every absence, every careful argument I have made in favor of your happiness without me. I have loved you while teaching myself not to reach for you. I have loved you while convincing myself that restraint was the final kindness I could offer you.

Perhaps it was.

Perhaps I was wrong.

I cannot continue to make a virtue of my own loneliness and call it love.

If you are happy, I will have to face that truth. If you do not want me, I will have to learn to live with it. If the life I have imagined for us exists only in my mind, then I will mourn it, as I have mourned it a thousand times before.

But I want the chance to discover whether it might be real.

I want a life with you, Will.

Not the life I have imagined.

Not the man I have made of you in my solitude.

You.

And if there is nothing left for us beyond what we have already done to one another, then I would rather hear you tell me so than spend another day pretending I have ceased to hope.

Yours, in every way that matters,

Hannibal."

Will read the final line twice.

Yours, in every way that matters.

He stared at it until the words lost their meaning, until the ink became nothing more than dark impressions upon cream-colored paper. His thumb rested against the edge of the page, rubbing at it absently, as though he might wear through the words if he worried at them long enough.

Hannibal loved him.

Will had known. God, he had known.

He had known it in the way Hannibal watched him across a room, in the patience with which he waited for Will to arrive at truths he had already understood. He had known it in the terrible intimacy of being seen, in the way Hannibal could take the ugliest thing Will had ever done and hold it between them as though it were a gift.

He had known it when Hannibal had left him.

He had known it when he had watched Hannibal being taken away, when he had stood at the edge of an ending and discovered that all he wanted was to follow.

But knowing was not the same as hearing it.

And hearing it was not the same as being asked.

I want you to choose me.

Will's throat tightened.

He had spent years imagining what Hannibal might say if he ever had the opportunity to speak without the interference of prison walls, legal proceedings, blood, or the terrible, complicated history between them. He had imagined apologies. Accusations. Another carefully constructed argument about becoming. He had imagined Hannibal telling him that everything between them had been inevitable, that Will had never possessed the freedom to choose otherwise.

He had even imagined Hannibal telling him he was a disappointment.

He had not imagined this.

Hannibal had left the choice in his hands.

It was an appalling thing to do to a man who had spent his entire life trying to convince himself that his hands were clean.

Will lowered the letter to his lap.

The house was silent around him. Somewhere beyond the study, the refrigerator hummed. A dog shifted in the next room, claws clicking softly against the floor. Ordinary sounds. The remnants of an ordinary life.

Molly was gone.

The thought came without the force he expected. It was not that he did not understand what he had done. He understood it with a clarity that made him feel ill. Molly had loved him. She had trusted him. She had stood beside him and mistaken his attention for intimacy, his careful observations for understanding, his gifts for evidence that he had been thinking of her.

He had been thinking of someone else.

He had taken her kindness and made it useful to him. He had watched her learn his preferences and congratulated himself when she acquired them. He had let her believe that every small adjustment was a discovery they were making together, when he had been leading her toward a man she had never met.

He had made a home out of her love and then spent every night longing for someone who was not there.

He would have to live with that.

He would have to live with the knowledge that Molly had deserved a husband who saw her as herself, not as a collection of familiar gestures and carefully chosen scents. She had deserved a love that did not require her to compete with a ghost.

Will did not know whether he had ever loved her well enough to deserve her forgiveness.

He knew he had not loved her honestly.

And yet, beneath the shame, beneath the guilt that pressed its fingers into the soft places beneath his ribs, something else stirred.

Not relief.

Not happiness.

Recognition.

Hannibal had written that he wanted a life beyond the one he had constructed in his mind. Will looked at the words again and felt the years between them collapse into something terribly small. He thought of the letters he had written and hidden. The words he had crossed out. The pages he had torn apart because they had come too close to saying what he could not bear to admit.

I want you.

He had written it.

He had written it over and over, in different words, in different rooms, in different states of drunkenness and despair. He had dressed the admission in metaphors, hidden it beneath antlers and gardens and the ruins of things that might once have been beautiful. He had told himself that if he could make the feeling sufficiently ugly, sufficiently pathological, then it would cease to be a desire he was responsible for.

Hannibal had done the same thing.

For years, they had been writing to each other without sending a single letter.

Will looked at the empty drawer.

Molly had sent them.

He could picture the envelope in her hands, the deliberate pressure of her pen as she wrote Hannibal's name. He could picture her walking to the post office, carrying the evidence of her marriage's failure like something too poisonous to keep inside her own house.

She had made a choice.

And now, somehow, Hannibal had made one, too.

Will folded the letter along its existing crease. He did it carefully, smoothing the paper with the flat of his palm. He returned it to its envelope, then took it out again almost immediately.

He could not bear to put it away.

He read the final paragraph once more.

I want a life with you, Will.

Not a fantasy. Not a tragedy. Not another beautiful prison.

A life.

Will leaned back in his chair and closed his eyes.

For one brief, treacherous moment, he allowed himself to imagine it.

A kitchen. Evening light. Hannibal standing at the counter with his sleeves rolled to his elbows, making some elaborate meal Will would inevitably criticize. Books arranged on tables. Dogs underfoot. An argument about wine, perhaps, or the proper way to prepare fish. Hannibal looking at him with that infuriating, unhurried attention, waiting for Will to say something cruel enough to amuse him.

The silence after dinner.

The knowledge that neither of them had to leave.

He imagined waking beside Hannibal and finding him still there.

He imagined the first morning, the first argument, the first time he reached for Hannibal without having to wonder whether the distance between them was measured in miles or years or the bodies they had left behind.

He imagined a life that did not have to be justified by what they had done to one another.

A life that might be difficult, monstrous, and imperfect.

A life that was theirs.

Will opened his eyes.

The fantasy did not disappear. It settled inside him, taking up space that had been empty for so long he had mistaken it for a part of himself.

He looked at Hannibal's handwriting.

I am afraid that we will look at one another, at last, and find that recognition is not enough.

Will almost laughed.

Of course Hannibal was afraid of that. Hannibal, who could dissect a man with a glance and make a meal of the pieces, who had spent his life arranging the world into patterns he could understand, was afraid of the one thing he could not control.

Will's choice.

For once, Will did not resent him for it.

He rose from the desk and walked to the window. Outside, the garden was dark. The trees stood motionless beneath the night sky, their branches tangled together, their roots hidden beneath the soil. He had spent years looking at that garden and seeing Hannibal everywhere: in the carefully pruned shrubs, in the flowers he could never remember to water, in the wild things that crept in from the woods and made themselves at home.

He had thought that if he could keep the garden alive, he might prove something.

That a thing could grow in the absence of its maker.

That a house could become a home without the person for whom it had been imagined.

He had been wrong.

Not because nothing could grow in the absence of its maker, but because he had never stopped waiting for him to return.

Will pressed his forehead to the cool glass.

He could stay here. He could let Hannibal remain a letter, a collection of memories, an impossible future that he would mourn until the feeling became familiar enough to bear. He could tell himself that Hannibal was better off without him, that he was better off without Hannibal, that the two of them had already done enough damage to one another.

He could call that restraint.

He could call it mercy.

He could call it anything he liked.

It would still be a choice.

And for the first time, Will understood that refusing to choose Hannibal was not the same as choosing a life without him. It was merely another way of letting fear decide what happened next.

He had spent years allowing other people to name his nature. To decide what he was, what he ought to be, what he could be forgiven for wanting. He had spent years trying to make himself into a man whose desires could be explained away, whose violence could be contained, whose darkness could be managed so long as he never looked at it for too long.

Hannibal had never asked him to be that man.

He had asked him to be honest.

Will returned to the desk.

He placed the letter inside the drawer, then reconsidered and took it back out. He would not leave it there. He would not let it become another secret he could pretend had no bearing on his life.

He folded it once more and slipped it into the inside pocket of his jacket.

Then he sat down and opened his laptop.

He did not search for Hannibal's prison. He already knew where it was. He knew the procedures, the security measures, the legal restrictions, the things that could be done and the things that would be impossible. He knew the difference between a fantasy and a plan, and he knew that he had crossed that distinction long before he had admitted it to himself.

He began with what he knew.

The rest would come later.

Outside, the wind moved through the trees, stirring the garden into a quiet, restless murmur.

Will did not look up.

He had spent years imagining a life with Hannibal.

Now, at last, he was going to do something about it.