Work Text:
An interesting phenomenon is that people always have a tendency to romanticize the outcome, or rather, to romanticize the experience of “getting the outcome.”
Certainly, having a wish come true is something worth celebrating. But wishes do not come with guarantees. Otherwise, they would not be called wishes. Some believe that making a wish is the act in this world that comes closest to idealism; you could even say that it is precisely an expression of it. There is always a powerful element of blind confidence in the act—many wishes have absolutely no chance of coming true, yet even when the person making the wish understands this, they may still blindly believe in possibilities that exist beyond logic and fact. They call this a miracle, attributing it all to an omniscient and omnipotent figure that exists only in their imagination.
What audacious certainty, to entrust one’s most vulnerable desires to an abstract definition that one has never seen with one’s own eyes, an abstraction that exists only in the imagination.
Hannibal had never believed in gods, nor had he ever cared to discuss his so-called miracles.
He could no longer remember how many strangers had approached him over the past three years, carrying a recorder or a notebook, wearing self-satisfied expressions as they asked him, “Do you still hope that one day you will be able to walk out of here?” There was always a conspicuous implication hidden beneath their words. They wanted to know whether he would resort to violence or clever words to get himself out of this place. He had never been able to conceal how utterly contemptuous he was of such vulgar and naked insinuations. His disgust was always so obvious that more than half of his interviewers would hurl abuse at him before leaving.
And the guards of the devil—Dr. Bloom-Verger and Dr. Chilton, who collected their share of benefits from these interviewers—were deeply opposed to his deplorable behavior. Hannibal, on the other hand, found it rather amusing. No one here could truly understand his thoughts. Even when he laid every one of them out on the table, people remained convinced that he was still manipulating their minds and their convictions. They even regarded his natural desire for attention as part of his means, as though he were that legendary siren and they their self-proclaimed exceptional Odysseus, capable of preserving their convictions even after hearing the seductive song, never noticing that their freedom was merely an incidental gift he had chosen to disregard.
To ignore is to reveal ignorance. The more a person ignores, the more ignorance flourishes. Everyone had already formed the prejudice that he was a demon before entering this room, and had willingly immersed themselves in it. Ignorance was a silent wall between them. He stood alone on one side of it, while those outside could hear nothing but the echo of a man speaking to his own shadow. Much like that classic thought experiment: a man who does not understand a single word of Chinese is locked inside a sealed room. He has a rulebook written in his native language, an inexhaustible supply of Chinese characters, and a slit through which he can exchange information with the outside world. If the man inside the room follows the rules and uses the language accordingly, can he truly be said to be using that language?
When the Hannibal Lecter inside this room displays the emotions of a human being, can those emotions truly be regarded as genuine human emotions?
He knew their answer, and he knew his own. He had understood it decades ago, before he had even completed his residency: no one in this world would ever want to see the real him. No one would understand what he truly thought, and even fewer would willingly remain beside him after seeing all of it, valuing, perhaps even loving, what he truly was. No one cared about him. Everyone who entered this place to visit him was interested in him because of his crimes, just as people before had been drawn to him because of his class, his wealth, and his manner of speaking.
No one truly cared about him.
Only one person would.
The person in this world who cared about him the least would care.
He had not seen Will Graham once since the day he surrendered. He had seen several photographs: in the witness list, in newspapers after his conviction, from the mouths of Dr. Bloom-Verger and Dr. Chilton, and in the photograph of the reconstituted family that Alana had shown him. How awkward Will looked in that photograph, as though he were holding a cup of appeasement that was about to overflow, completely at a loss.
On the bright side, he had never been so uneasy in front of Hannibal. On the darker side, he had never been so desperate for Hannibal’s approval.
Hannibal had always held a firm optimism about their relationship, even though he knew that this optimism had always been one-sided—especially after Will realized four years ago why Hannibal had framed him—yet he still refused to compare that certainty to the blind confidence people possessed when making wishes. He was not blind. No one had ever seen Hannibal Lecter blind. His confidence came entirely from the experience he had accumulated over the years. He knew how to remove an organ before its owner bled to death. He knew how to guide a husband who had fallen on hard times into murdering his family. He knew that the things he desired would eventually return to him, and that they would never leave him again.
He knew, rather than hoped. This would not be a miracle. It was inevitable. His reunion with Will was inevitable.
He knew that Will had thought countless times that they would be better apart. He also knew that Will had thought even more times about the impossibility of truly separating from him, whether psychologically or physically. When Will walked out of Jack’s office for the last time, when he covered the furniture in his home with dust sheets, when he watched his dogs play in the backyard of his wife’s house, Hannibal knew that Will would think of him. Whether in the form of a mythical creature or in his own flesh, he knew he would appear in Will’s fantasies late at night.
But what he did not know was when they would see each other again.
Perhaps tomorrow. Perhaps next month. Perhaps a year from now. Perhaps ten years from now.
Will Graham was the most unpredictable man in the world, just as he himself had said; sometimes, he could not predict what his own next step would be. On the night Hannibal surrendered, the sentence he had not spoken was: “When you decide to run away with me, come and see me.” He knew he did not need to say it aloud, but he also knew that it was only an invitation. The other party had not agreed to it. Perhaps that was precisely why he had not said it, much like Schrödinger’s cat: only when you see it can you know whether it is still alive—and it was equally possible that the animal inside had already ceased to breathe, while the person holding down the lid simply did not wish to face the corpse.
Last moment…Hope deferred maketh the something sick.
There was a faint voice inside him that had been whispering ever since the moment he walked out of Will’s front door. It had never stopped. It told him that Will would not come. It told him they would never see each other again. It told him he would die alone. It told him that the narrow patch of sky above his head would be all the scenery he would ever see for the rest of his life. It said, you could have been sitting in your villa in Cuba, enjoying your fine wine and fine food, your latter years, your freedom.
You could have abandoned him.
You could have.
You should have.
But he cannot.
This interminable argument—with himself—had nearly driven him into an existential crisis. Or perhaps it was more accurate to say that ever since the day he entered that office and saw Will, he had been moving steadily toward an existential crisis tailored precisely for him. Everything he had once valued, his pursuit of beauty, his passion for transformation, his profound understanding of human physiological and psychological structures, his appreciation of food, seemed to have vanished completely the moment he walked out of Will’s backyard. He had left behind in that snow everything he had spent decades carefully designing for himself, and that was merely the beginning of a sacrifice for which he could never demand anything in return.
All he possessed was this small, four-sided patch of sky above his head, while another man, far beyond its edge, lived the ideal life prescribed by conventional understanding. A life without him. Even if their lives happened to intersect by accident, it would be no more than a bird passing across the sky, leaving behind in Hannibal’s little room a shadow resembling an illusion, gone in an instant, leaving only the faintest trace of the scent of life in the air. Sometimes he even wondered whether this was Will’s verdict upon him: that Will had taken him for an illusion of his younger, more innocent years, blinked, and made him disappear, remembering him only in moments of hazy recollection at night. Was that it? He could not ask, nor did he want to. He kept his hand pressed against the lid, unwilling to open it.
Abandonment requires expectation.
This was not a wish.
This was a delayed inevitability.
Although he knew perfectly well that the delay was caused by the other party, he still found himself asking: if he had used different means at different moments, would their circumstances be different now? Once again, the photograph Alana had placed before him three months ago appeared before his eyes—a boy, a woman, seven dogs, a man. They stood in the snow, much like the snow on the day Hannibal surrendered, but they were pressed closely against one another. The hand wrapped around the woman’s right shoulder must have been warmer than Hannibal’s hands, raised above his head, ever could be. But they are not your family, he whispered inwardly to the man. Your family is here.
He knew that Jack had tried to contact Will because of the endless succession of killers, attempting to persuade him to return to the field. But according to Fredrick’s uncontrollable tongue, they had never succeeded. Apparently, Will had gone even farther into the mountains after moving in with his wife. Even Alana had only seen him once, around the time his son was born. His jawline looked more pronounced in the photograph than it had before, but Hannibal could not tell whether it was because he had changed the way he trimmed his beard, or because he had not been eating properly.
How he longed to feed him, even if the ingredients were nothing more than the most ordinary things.
But their relationship had always been like this. It could never truly settle for anything that was supposedly ordinary. Before he knew Will Graham, the affection he imagined seemed to him like the molecular structures he had once seen in pharmacology textbooks—simple, pure, predictable. He had never imagined that he would come this far for a man who stood almost entirely opposed to the conventional definition of purity. This man was cunning, evil, mercurial. Even the rationality of which Hannibal was so proud could not always suppress the negative influence he exerted upon him. Their affection was like a white candle, existing only in daylight or darkness, lit or extinguished, life or death. There was no gentle middle state, only the soot-blackened mark left upon the wall when the candlelight went out.
This was a relationship destined to wear them both down until the end of their lives. And still, he loved this perfect antonym.
When he thought of life, he thought of him. When he thought of death, he still thought of him.
He should leave.
He should have left long ago.
But he could not.
They had once discussed the Iliad, but at the time Will had been trying to frame him, and Hannibal could not distinguish how much of it had been sincere. So even though the response had sounded so enticing, he had still refused to accept it. Now he wanted to know: in another story, if Will were the one walking out of the underworld, would he have been able to resist looking back? And if he did look back, what, precisely, would have made him do it? His feelings for Hannibal were of course selfish, because he was selfish, because Hannibal was selfish. Yet beneath that almost instinctive selfishness, he always concealed something deeper, something that resembled a sacrifice, a form of selflessness. When he stood in Hannibal’s kitchen, knowing that what awaited him would very likely be death, yet still exposed his unguarded neck to him, they both understood that this would become the means by which he kept Hannibal forever.
That was precisely why Hannibal was still here.
He should have left long ago, long before he realized that this man would betray him before the face of social morality, long before Will told him that he had not found Hannibal interesting, long before they ever met for the first time. He should have gone far away.
He should have, but he could not.
Long before he knew Will, long before he realized that loneliness was his destined fate, long before anything in the world had ever existed, their ending had already been written. The Poincaré recurrence theorem said that everything within a closed and finite system would, given infinite time, repeatedly return to states it had occupied before. Across the boundless river of time, their lives converged again and again. He would sit in his office again and again and say, “Hello, Will.” Then walk through the snow again and again, sit in the courtroom again and again, stand here again and again, waiting.
This was inevitable fate, the design God had already arranged at the moment of creation.
This was the outcome he was certain to wait for.
-
Click. The door opened at the sound of the latch. It was his favorite guard.
“Today’s paper.” There was no further pleasantry. He approached him, the little cart stopping outside the door, the Sun placed at the very top of the pass-through slot.
“You are always so punctual.” The man inside the cell spoke gently, waiting until the door had closed again before approaching to retrieve his newspaper.
Orpheus ultimately lost his beloved forever because he could not resist turning around to look at Eurydice. Whether he turned because he did not trust Eurydice, doubted the Underworld, or lacked confidence in his own inability to know everything, that could naturally never be known. But Hannibal knew—when he saw the several brutal photographs of the crime scenes involving the victimized families on the front-page article—that he was about to walk out of this Underworld himself, and that his reward for not looking back would be the man who would inevitably appear beyond that door before the next full moon.
The weakened voice inside him was still saying: Go. Go, while there is still time.
His freedom. His latter years. His fine wine and fine food—
For the first time in three years, Hannibal Lecter smiled with satiety.
His Will Graham.
