Chapter Text
Steve gives himself three full days to brood.
He decides this like it’s a rule, like if he sticks to some kind of self-imposed schedule it’ll make the whole sulking thing more respectable. Like an emotional detox, but with extra pizza rolls.
He knows Jonathan had told him all those poetic things about not being alone, about always being there for him. He’d even hinted that Steve had people beyond Robin and Eddie. That his little found family stretched wider than he gave it credit for.
But still, Steve holes up by himself.
He doesn’t want to bother anyone. He doesn’t want to face the explanations, or the looks, or the way Robin always knows how what to say to make him laugh and/or cry. It’s partly because he’s a masochist, and partly because, if he’s being honest, a few days alone in bed with a bottomless pile of movies is kind of the dream.
By the third rewatch of The Karate Kid, he feels sick.
He knows he’s not handling this like an adult. In a perfect world, he’d track down Robin and Eddie, sit them both down, and tell them exactly how they’d hurt him. Maybe even confess the whole crush-on-Eddie thing just to watch Robin’s eyes pop out of her head like a cartoon character. Then, in that perfect world, they’d all apologize, collapse in a big heap on the couch, and cuddle for hours.
Instead, he keeps MTV on, lets Billy Idol fill the room, ignores the phone when it rings, and goes the longest stretch of his life without working out. His old coaches would probably faint if they knew. He barely even feels guilty about it.
By the third day, though, he wakes up tired of himself. Turns out, he’s just not built to be a slacker. Who knew? Even his rebellion against adulthood can’t last very long. His body itches for structure, even if his head doesn’t.
So, he tries. He calls Keith to rearrange his shifts, pretending like he’s magically not sick anymore- Keith doesn’t even notice the change. He calls Dustin to reassure him: yes, he’s fine, it was just a cold, yes they’ll see each other soon, no, no visions. Dustin talks at him for twelve solid minutes about some new theory involving Vecna, and Steve forces laughs in all the right places.
He even calls his mom, apologizes for not answering in the past three (months) days, assures her the house is fine, yes, he’s still working, of course he’s eating vegetables, he’s nineteen, not a kid, yes, Christmas, maybe. Probably not.
He tries going for a jog, but it only tangles his head worse. His sneakers slap against the pavement, his breath comes fast, and all he can think about is how pathetic it is that he can’t outrun his own thoughts. He’s barely broken a sweat before he’s retreating back to the safety of his house, heart pounding with something that isn’t exercise.
He knows Robin’s been more than calling- she’s been showing up. She’s not subtle about it either: the ringing, the pounding, the yelling through his window. She’s like a kid in the middle of a tantrum, dramatic hand gestures and all.
And Steve, he’ll admit it, takes a little guilty pleasure in letting her stew. Watching her stammer and get frustrated from behind the blinds- it’s satisfying. Almost cathartic. Like scratching an itch. Sue him. He used to be somewhat of a bully, after all. That Mean Girl streak never really went away, especially when someone’s hurt him.
But there are two things about it that aren’t satisfying at all.
First: he hates hurting Robin. She’s his girl, his partner-in-crime, his person. And he can hear the crack of desperation in her voice when she’s shouting outside, and it just about breaks his heart.
Second: Eddie never comes.
Not once. Maybe he calls. Maybe. Steve can’t bring himself to check the machine. But Eddie’s not at the door, not pounding beside Robin, not throwing pebbles at the window like some kind of Romeo. And the absence is loud. Deafening. Steve can’t shake the thought: he could be dead in a ditch somewhere, and Eddie wouldn’t know. Wouldn’t care.
He doesn’t understand it. Eddie was supposed to be the asshole, right? So why isn’t he the one begging at Steve’s doorstep? Why isn’t he right there next to Robin, on his knees?
Steve is… well. Steve is basic. He’s an ex-jock. He listens to the big bands, watches the big shows. Sure, he’s got an obscure fact or two up his sleeve, courtesy of the kids and Robin and his own curiosity sometimes, but he’s not buried in niche films or underground singers the way she and Eddie are. He’s basic, yeah.
And that means his way of understanding people- empathy, motives, all that messy stuff, is basic too.
For him, logic’s simple. Always has been, even more so after everything they’ve survived: you do something, there’s consequences, you deal with them to reduce the damage. Easy peasy. It doesn’t always work, but you at least try to minimize the harm. That’s what you do.
That’s what they’ve been doing with the Upside Down. With Eleven. That’s what the government’s been doing every single time, handing out hush money to keep them quiet and obedient.
That’s not how Eddie works, apparently. Shocking, really, that the twenty-year-old metalhead, queer, alleged murderer isn’t exactly wired like everyone else.
And Steve hates that it still surprises him. He keeps expecting people to follow the same rulebook he does: you screw up, you show up, you fix it. Or at least you try. Even if you trip over your own feet, even if it’s messy, you still try.
But Eddie doesn’t, of course he fucking doesn’t. Drops off the map like he never cared in the first place. Which is insane, because Steve knows Eddie cared. He wouldn’t have run after him if he didn’t. Right?
So what the hell is this? Silence? Pretending Steve doesn’t exist unless they’re breathing the same air?
Robin, at least, is predictable. Loud, desperate, dramatic as hell, but at least she’s there. Eddie’s absence, though, is louder than all her pounding on his door. Louder than George Michael turned to the maximum volume on MTV. Louder than his own thoughts when he tries to drown them out with a too-hot shower.
And Steve tells himself he’s not gonna do it, he’s not gonna sit here and measure who cares more, who fights harder. He’s not some clingy idiot, tallying up loyalty points like it’s a competition.
But the thought still comes, sharp and ugly, no matter how many times he tries to shove it back down:
Robin fights for him. Eddie doesn’t.
