Chapter Text
Long, long before Will got lost in the Upsidedown, Dustin had read a very interesting article about the possibility of parallel worlds. He studied it day and night, even memorizing the equations that might explain such a theory. He doubted every word of it, mostly because he couldn't quite grasp the incoherence of it all. The fact that everything had a specific cause leading to a specific effect could only mean that in an isolated world like theirs, there could be no other cause than the one that had caused that effect, and therefore there could be no other world with another cause, simply because it was not possible for another cause to exist. As anarchic as the world seemed, it was easy to see that not everything was left to total chaos.
But then Will got lost, and chaos did happen. They discovered the Upsidedown, human flesh-eating monsters and the Mind Flayer, losing loved ones in the process, making the possibility of parallel worlds a certainty. In other words, Earth was not a completely isolated system, which meant it was decoherent and, as one German scientist put it, highly irreversible. The keyword being: irreversible.
Surely Dustin could never have imagined that accepting Billy Hargrove's help would lead to major changes in his life. Maybe if he had just ignored the jerk's suggestion - if you can call it that - his world would be continuing linearly. Unlike Schrödinger's cat, he'd be alive. Or he'd be dead from drowning. It should have been one or the other. But in fact it was Schrödinger's cat. Surely there was a parallel world out there where Dustin didn't like Billy, where they hardly talked and stayed the hell away from each other's existence. Maybe in such a world Billy was evil and killed people. But Dustin lived in a different world where he realized that Billy wasn't that bad, kind of crazy, sure, but not a bad guy. As far as he knew, Billy hadn't killed anyone...yet. So Dustin was both the Dustin who didn't know Billy and the Dustin who did. In both cases, the effects were irreversible. He could not go back to the beginning where Billy was just Max's psycho brother.
"You see where I'm going with this?" Dustin asked Will, who was staring at him with a dubious (make that extremely confused) look in his eyes.
They dragged their bikes toward the Byers' house. Dustin's looked as good as new after Steve had willingly and at his own expense taken it in to get the tire fixed. He had no idea how Steve knew about it, but he assumed Mike had told him at some point when Steve went to visit Nancy.
"You want an honest answer?" Will asked with a shy smile. Dustin didn't need to hear any more.
"I'll keep it simple," Dustin said with a sigh. "Billy's cool."
There was the ghost of a smile on Will's lips, which could either mean that Will didn't really believe him or that he was having trouble connecting the dots. Dustin leaned towards the latter, only because he knew Will was his friend and would never openly doubt him like Mike did. Not that Mike wasn't his friend, but he could be an annoying bitch sometimes - especially when he thought he was right.
"And what does Billy Hargrove have to do with the certainty of parallel words?" Will asked. His voice sounded sincerely intrigued and it sent a wave of happiness through Dustin. He felt his face light up.
"I'm sure, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that we live in a world where Billy is not inherently evil. Whatever happened to him, he's redeemable."
"You think so?"
"I know so."
"If you say so. Max seems to disagree."
"Not everyone likes their brother the way you like yours, Will," Dustin said with a heavy sigh. Will silently agreed with a nod of his head.
The back of his head still hurt from the blow his father had given him that morning. It certainly wasn't his fault that Susan had forgotten to buy eggs for breakfast, but maybe his father was right when he said that as the eldest son, the man in charge, he should have noticed the lack of eggs and gone out to buy them of his own free will. He also lived in the house, so he was partly responsible for all the shortcomings. On the other hand, he did not understand why Max and Susan, who also lived in the house, had no responsibility in this regard. Perhaps it was because they were women. There was no other explanation.
And so it was that he found himself walking through the streets of desolate Hawkins that morning, two dozen eggs crammed into their cartons in a plastic bag, one row on top of the other, ready to crack at the slightest tug, still half asleep from the long night he had spent staring at the ceiling for who knew what reason. It had never been difficult for him to fall asleep. He was always tired from all the weightlifting and the hours he spent in the sun checking on the brats screaming over the pool. But ever since he had met Dustin, he had started to think. He could never remember exactly what, but mostly he remembered the days he had spent with his mother, remembered the days when he had been, perhaps for the first and last time in his life, truly happy. No, maybe it hadn't been the last time. He'd felt it again, this will to live, and strangely enough, he'd felt it when he'd arrived in this shithole of a town, on his first day of school, and been told all about a certain King Steve. Strange. The idea that someone like Steve existed had made him like his current living situation, if only briefly. Never mind that Steve had turned out to be a half-witted idiot...
A loud laugh snapped him out of his thoughts. Billy stopped in his tracks and watched with interest as a group of kids threw a shoe at each other. He didn't immediately understand what they were doing, but he realized what was going on when he noticed the little boy with the funny hair in the middle of the circle of kids trying to get his shoe back. "Zombie boy! Zombie boy!" they chanted in unison as he jumped from side to side, trying to grab the sneaker as it flew from hand to hand.
No passerby stopped to give the bullies a piece of their mind. No one seemed interested in stopping them and helping the victim. Honestly, even Billy would have moved on, too busy trying to get the eggs back in time before his dad got the idea to smash them back-to-back on his head. Something held him there, however, and he temporarily forgot about his father, the eggs, and all the consequences of his delay. Among the screaming children, Billy recognized the slender, frightened figure of the Byers' younger brother. His eyes fell on his skinny legs, the sock growing dirtier and dirtier as the owner desperately tried to reclaim what was his. He was Dustin's friend, right? He looked around to see if the rest of the gang was around, but there was no one, just little Byers ready to burst into tears.
"Hey!"
He only realized he had been the one yelling when the kids stopped to look at him. With his eyes on them, his lungs begging for a cigarette, and his head starting to hurt from what he was about to do, Billy crossed the street to meet them halfway. He knew he looked menacing. His lips curved into a smile as he noticed the small step back the kids took when he arrived. They were nothing more than a bunch of cowards, five of them to be exact. Billy had dealt with people more dangerous than them. And he liked it. He liked how they trembled at the sight of him, how it made him feel important, commanding, strong. Quieter, he repeated: "Hey."
"What the hell are you doing?"
One of the boys dropped the shoe while the other four looked at each other, trying to figure out what to do next. Then one of the boys, perhaps the toughest of the gang, stepped forward and raised his chin in defiance.
"Mind your own business."
"I fucking am," Billy replied with a scowl. "And if you don't want me to beat the crap out of you, you need to leave that kid alone and get out of my fucking way, all right? I don't give a damn if people watch me pull your teeth out of your mouth one by one. Go cry to your mama if you want. I don't give a fuck. Now shoo!"
The five of them looked at each other again, this time with fear flashing in their small, beady eyes. The leader of the gang gave a little nod and the kids started running in five different directions. One even dared to push Billy out of the way, but he obviously couldn't even shake him out of his spot. What he did manage was to give the bag of Billy's groceries a gentle tug. In a matter of seconds, the bag tore like tissue paper. Paying no attention to the fleeing children, Billy focused all his anger on the shitty plastic bag as the egg cartons fell to the sidewalk, spilling their contents onto sun-dried chewing gums and cigarette butts.
"Shit!" Billy swore loudly. He picked up one of the cartons before quickly dropping it to the ground with a disgusted click of his tongue. "Look what you did, zombie boy!"
He turned his attention back to little Byers, who was looking at him with eyes wide with fear. Billy shook his head and kicked the boxes with all the anger he felt boiling inside. "Fuck you. Goddamn brats."
Out of the corner of his eye, he saw little Byers bend down to pick up his sneaker, but he didn't turn around to look directly at him. He felt ashamed. The broken eggs had taken his breath away, and he was sure that terror dominated every feature of his face. How could he go home now? He had no money. Every penny his father had given him had gone to those damned eggs. That's what doing a good deed was for! Every time he tried to help someone, it always ended badly... for him.
He turned to leave. He didn't know where. His bones and muscles ached with anticipation. Home. All he could do was go home and take responsibility.
"Hey, thanks."
Billy turned his head to face Byers. Auburn eyes stared right through him, over a narrow nose and trembling lips. He thought he had misheard, but then the boy swallowed and repeated louder: "Thanks.”
Billy huffed and waved his hand. He had no desire to start a conversation with the little weirdo. He just wanted to go home, take the beating he deserved, and crawl back under his covers. He had gotten enough shit for one day. But Byers had no intention of letting him go.
"Um... I'm sorry about the eggs."
Billy arched an eyebrow. Within seconds, Byers had grown taller and was smiling as if he was truly sorry. The two of them looked at each other as if trying to decipher some sort of puzzle. Billy couldn't decipher his own, but Byers seemed smarter than he was. Something changed in his face. It suddenly became more serious, almost friendly.
"My mom's got lots of eggs in the fridge. We could give you some... as payback."
"Don't worry, kid." Billy snorted. What a ridiculous suggestion! He started to leave again, his heart pounding as he felt Byers pull him by the shirt. He turned on his heel, ready to tell him to fuck off, but Byers didn't seem to be afraid of him. Quite the opposite.
“My name’s Will.”
“Billy.”
Billy had no idea what happened next. As if hypnotized, he followed the little Byers down the sidewalk. They walked in silence all the way to the Byers' house. He really must have been out of his mind.
Only when they reached the front door did Will start talking again, and this time with an enthusiasm that Billy had never dreamed a kid like Will could feel. The boy began to talk about his mother, how happy she would be to help him, and he also praised his brother, with a smile that went from cheek to cheek. For a moment, Billy was taken aback by all the talk, and even a little jealous, especially when he walked through the door of the Byers' house. He'd been there before, but the memories of that night were mingled, and more than the house, he remembered Steve's angry face and that damn baseball bat. But there was one thing that shocked him as soon as he entered the house. The smell of a close-knit, loving family, the house reeking of love, all the memories of a happy life scattered all over the walls and floor.... Everything felt so different from his own place. He heard the clatter of cutlery from the kitchen and saw Will running toward one of the rooms.
"Moooom!"
Mrs. Byers appeared in the hall with a ladle in her hand. She looked at Billy with suspicion, then at Will with tenderness. "What's going on, honey?"
"Billy was helping me with some bullies, but the eggs broke and now he needs more eggs because the ones he had are gone."
"Eggs? What eggs?" Mrs. Byers looked at Billy again. Her stare made Billy want to look down at his feet in shame.
"Nothing, madam. He's talking nonsense."
Mrs. Byers' snort made Billy snapping to attention. She smiled warmly at him as Will ran up and down the room looking for some kind of bag. "Must have been two dozen eggs, I tried to count them, but it was hard in all that gooey mess. Do we have two dozen eggs, Mom?"
"No, Will, but we can go buy them."
"Ma'am, that's not necessary."
"Oh, please." Mrs. Byers rolled her eyes. She set the ladle she was holding on the table and disappeared into one of the rooms. "You're Max's brother, right?" he heard her call over to him. "A lovely girl, isn't she? She doesn't talk much about her family, but I heard enough to get an idea."
Billy didn't have the heart to ask what her idea was.
Finally she walked out of the room, ready to leave. She nodded at him and showed him the car keys in her hand. "Shall we go then? Then I'll take you home. It's far from here. Did you really walk all this way?" she exclaimed to her son.
"I needed to clear my head," Will muttered. "Where's Johnathan?"
"At the photo studio. Let's go. I still have to cook."
"Cook? You?" Will teased her. Mrs. Byers gave him a small, tender slap on the head.
"Billy, right?" she said, looking up at him again. Being the center of her attention again made him feel very uncomfortable. He didn't usually feel this way about women, especially mothers, and had always managed to get away with a seductive smile and a slight bow of the head. But Mrs. Byers didn't seem like other mothers. Billy suddenly wanted to put his best foot forward and not disappoint her.
"Seriously, ma'am, that's not necessary."
"I need milk. This is as good a time as any."
With that, she pushed him out of the house. Will was already waiting in the back seat of the car.
Billy had no idea how he had ended up in this situation, but it must have been a dream.
The feeling of already belonging to a family didn't leave him until Mrs. Byers brought him home with two dozen eggs on his lap. Then the dream shattered into a thousand pieces and he realized that he wasn't meant to have what people like Dustin and Will had.
