Chapter Text
"What happened to your face?"
"Ah, I just got in a fight." Wearing a smug grin like a well-worn suit, Billy leaned against the counter and stared at every single flavor of ice cream on display. He had no idea what to choose; in fact, he had no idea why he had stopped by Scoops Ahoy in the first place. He was not a big fan of sweets, but going to the ice cream parlor just to spite Steve had been too much of a temptation.
He had come to the Starcourt Mall just to stop hearing Max's whining about him being "nice and giving rides" to everyone but her (ridiculous), and now that he had left Max with Jane (whatever girls did in malls!) he was free to waste the rest of his afternoon. He did not even think about going back to the hell he called home. Even if it had been a mere thought in the back of his mind, it vanished as soon as he saw the "Scoops Ahoy" sign.
Steve hadn’t seemed happy to see him, but at the same time he had not seemed to mind his presence. He had hastily removed his silly cap, slipped it under the counter, shoved Robin away, who was ready to serve Billy first, and walked over to greet him. Apparently, "whatever happened to your face" was Steve's idea of a greeting. Not that Billy minded. It seemed less awkward than a "hello." At that, Robin gave Steve an annoyed look; Steve's eyebrow rose to his hairline. Robin shrugged. Steve looked even more puzzled. Whatever telepathic thoughts they were exchanging at that moment were a mystery to Billy.
So he avoided feeling like a third wheel and stared at the ice cream instead. Needless to say, nothing inspired him.
"Do you really have to fight all the time?" Steve asked when whatever he and Robin had going on was over. Billy raised an eyebrow. "Don't get me wrong, but jeez! It takes you less to throw a punch than it does to pick ice cream."
Robin let out a chuckle that turned into a nervous cough when Billy's glare cut her amusement in half. Satisfied, he turned his attention back to Steve. "It's not my fault your brand sucks. Is there nothing with alcohol in it?"
To say Steve was surprised would be an understatement. "Say what?"
"These seem pretty plain."
"Kids come in here," Steve reasoned, opening his arms wide and looking as if Billy had personally insulted him. "Do you really expect us to give them alcohol?"
"Actually..."
Steve's head snapped toward Robin, his eyes growing as big as saucers when he saw her haughty smile. She waved her index finger at Billy, and Billy walked over to her, intrigued. She walked around the counter to meet him halfway and gestured for him to come even closer, slipping a hand around his neck to gently pull him up to her eye level. She didn't have to try very hard, they were almost the same height. Billy's jaw muscles ached from grinning so hard, and he enjoyed watching Steve flail his arms in confusion and annoyance out of the corner of his eye. "Whiskey salted caramel ice cream sandwich. I can make that. How much are you offering?" Robin whispered in his ear. Billy felt Steve lurking over them, he felt his warmth against his shoulder and Billy pushed him away, much to Robin's delight.
"What do you need?" Billy whispered back.
"What are you schmoozing about?"
Robin and Billy both waved Steve away.
Billy fixed his gaze on Robin. A sudden flash of uncertainty crossed her freckle-covered face; Billy could feel the tip of her fingers sweat against his neck.
"Do you want to ask me out?" he asked, half joking, half serious. He felt, more than he saw, Steve jump in surprise behind him. The gasp that left Steve's lips was a real giveaway. Robin, on the other hand, lifted her eyes to him, her mouth forming a thin line, her touch still firm against Billy's neck. His heart skipped a beat at her determination and he studied her face even more closely, trying to decide if he wanted to give it a try or not. He wrinkled his nose. Robin was definitely not his type.
"I'm putting my life on the line here," Robin said, lowering her voice a bit. "Can I trust you?"
"Depends," was Billy's prompt reply.
Robin's mouth thinned even more. "I need you to get me alone with Heather every chance you get." Her voice was barely more than a whisper, and Billy couldn't be sure he'd heard her right. He rubbed his ear vigorously and tilted his head closer to Robin's. Unable to eavesdrop, Steve let out a loud sigh behind them, leaving them alone to serve a group of boys who decided to burst in at that very moment. Robin stepped back to check on Steve and then unceremoniously shoved Billy into the back room.
"Did I hear what I think I heard?" Billy asked once they were alone, amused by Robin's antics, but also feeling a little uncomfortable. "You want me to..."
"Don't repeat that," Robin cut him off. Her arms opened wide before falling back to her sides. "I regret all my life choices right now. My anxiety is literally skyrocketing." She giggled nervously. "You know what. Never mind. I'll make you those sandwiches anyway. They're on the house! Isn't that great?!" She laughed again.
"Buckley, you want to...!"
"Ha ha ha!" Robin laughed hysterically. "Look at that!" She pointed to a shelf in the corner. "We have vodka! Give me a second to drown in it."
Scowling, Billy crossed his arms over his chest. "You're not right in the head, Buckley, but now your friendship with Steve makes perfect sense."
She rolled her eyes at him and straightened her back on her way to the shelf she had just pointed to. Billy followed her every move, narrowing his eyes at her and giving her a good, suspicious look. "You like girls."
Robin froze. She kept her back to him and jumped when Billy grabbed a chair and sat down. "Is that why you keep sneaking off with Heather? Does she..."
"It's complicated," Robin whispered, her shoulders slumping in resignation.
"It's not complicated," Billy frowned. "You want to fuck a girl."
At his harsh tone, Robin whipped around with a pleading look. "I swear I'll do whatever you want, I'll be your little personal slave, but don't tell anyone I'm a-"
"A freak," Billy said, crossing his legs and leaning against the back of his chair. "You, Robin Buckley, are a freak."
"Please, don't..." Robin's eyes became moist, the color draining from her face. Billy licked his lips, his stomach churning uncomfortably and making him feel nauseous.
"I won't." He swallowed a lump in his throat, surprised at the softness of his own voice. Robin's mouth dropped open in shock and wonder. "I'm just surprised you asked me and not Harrington," he added, his voice steadier and harder this time.
"I didn't think it through, to be honest. I just--" Robin pulled out another chair and banged her head on the table between them. "It's so hard, you know?" She wailed against the wood. "We have to hide all the time, and if-!"
"Are you trying to make me feel sorry for you?" Billy clicked his tongue. "I don't give a shit. You were a freak before, what with the fucking trumpet and all, and you're a freak now." Robin moved slowly to look at him again, cheeks red with humiliation. "Does he know?" Billy quickly changed the subject, pointing his thumb behind him.
"No."
"Aha."
"Don't tell him. I will. When the right time comes."
"Why me, Buckley?" Billy insisted, genuinely curious. She fidgeted in her seat, rubbing her arms as if suddenly cold.
"Heather speaks well of you, despite all the bullshit you throw around and your ridiculous machismo. I trust her judgment. She thinks the world of you..." she trailed off. "You're not going to expose me, are you?"
"Why should I? You spoke so well of me, I'm touched."
Robin shrugged, ignoring his sarcasm. "I don't know. You're the bully, not me. That's what bullies do, isn't it?"
Billy's frown deepened. "Thank you. I'll keep that in mind," he replied.
"So are you going to do it?" Robin asked, her eyes shining with hope. "Help me, I mean. Don't bully me or expose me and Heather, or I don't know what you're up to right now. Please. Please." She put her hands on either side of the table, a gesture that looked to Billy like a bad, awkward parody of a bow. He hated it when women begged, especially when they were all teary-eyed and stuff. His tongue flicked out to lick his lips. He toyed with the idea of letting her wait and then just storming out, but he didn't have the guts. Her eyes were wide with fear. He knew that look, he knew it too well. Maybe that was why he decided to indulge her.
"I'll try my best. For Heather's sake," he added quickly.
"Really?" Her lips curved into a smile. "You're a lifesaver!"
"I'm not doing it for you."
But Robin wasn't listening to him. She jumped out of her chair and moved around the room, picking things up as she went. "You're going to love these whiskey salted caramel ice cream sandwiches! I bet my head on it! You know what?" She stopped and pointed to him with a bottle filled to the brim with a beige liquid. "I'll make them for you every day! On the house! If you like them, of course."
"I'd rather you do something else."
Robin's step faltered. She looked at him, confused. "Like what?"
Billy shrugged. "I'll think about it," he replied with a wolfish smile. Robin's reaction was an exaggerated roll of the eyes. Without another word, she set about making the sandwiches, pacing the room, going in and out to get the ingredients like a very busy bee. Billy enjoyed doing nothing, relishing her obvious irritation at his heavy silence. Much to his disappointment, Steve came to her rescue a few minutes later, dropping all his weight into the chair next to Billy and stretching his legs over his knees.
Now. That was insulting.
"I put a 'Back in half an hour' sign on the door. There's no way I'm serving all the customers by myself," Steve declared irritably. Billy's attention was too distracted by the hairy legs resting on his lap to make a good comeback. He arched an eyebrow, pointed at Steve's legs, and demanded an explanation from Robin through his angry glare. Robin, however, paid no attention. Humming a song to herself, she prepared the ice cream sandwiches with maniacal concentration, carefully piling them one at a time onto a plate. When she was done, she slid them across the table to Billy and presented them with a "ta-da!" and jazz hands. Steve immediately claimed them. He pulled his legs off of Billy's lap to make it easier to move around, and ignoring Robin's "hey!" of protest, he grabbed two of the three sandwiches and popped them in his mouth. Robin and Billy exchanged horrified looks. "They're not bad," Steve said, mouth full. It was a wonder either of them understood what he was saying.
"Those weren't for you!" Robin exclaimed, slapping him on the back. Steve broke into a choking fit, which made Robin panic and sent Billy rolling on the floor laughing. Steve gratefully accepted the glass of water that Robin hurried to bring him. He gulped down half of it and glared at Billy, who now had literal tears at the corner of his eyes.
"Serves you right for acting all jealous," Robin said when she was sure Steve was okay. She grinned at Billy, who, much to his own surprise, returned the grin with a wider smile of his own.
"Afraid I'm going to steal your girl, Harrington?" Billy asked, licking his lips. With another chuckle, he grabbed the last ice cream sandwich and shoved it into his mouth no less graciously than Steve had done earlier. "Not bad," he said.
"I'm not jealous," Steve muttered, his voice hoarse. "Since when are you two close friends?" he asked then, gaze studying Robin carefully.
"We always have been, right?" Robin half shrugged.
"Best of friends," Billy indulged her. His stomach hurt from laughing and he decided to leave before he lost his dignity by being too friendly with Robin. He winked; Steve's frown deepened.
"You're just messing with me." Dropping his shoulders, he ran a hand through his messy hair and gestured at the empty plate. "Can you make more of these? They were actually pretty good."
"No."
"She loves me and will make them just for me, won't she, Robin?" Billy said.
With a deep frown, Robin returned the empty plate to the sink, but then, much to Billy's dismay, her demeanor changed 180 degrees. A wolfish smile graced her face, similar to the one Billy had flashed at her not long before, shoulders square and cocky as hell. She slowly walked over to him and put an arrogant hand on his shoulder.
"Oh yeah, how could I not when you so kindly offered to take me and Steve to Lover's Lake?"
Steve almost fell out of his chair. "What?!"
"We're going on a double date, aren't we, Billy, dear?" Robin's grin grew wider. "You and Heather, me and Steve."
Billy licked his teeth and wrinkled his nose in disgust. His eyes swept over Steve's shocked face and then back to Robin. "You owe me twice. This is going to cost you, dear."
Robin's cockiness washed away in an instant. Billy shoved her hand off his shoulder and snorted, making a beeline for the door. "I'll pick you up at seven."
"Is no one going to ask me if I have plans tonight?" Steve asked.
Billy turned with a raised eyebrow. "You can have some time alone with me. It's the best thing that's happened to you in a long time." A wink and Billy made a hasty retreat, keeping the obscenities he wanted to shout to the world to himself as he made his way back to the car.
Needless to say, Heather was over the moon about the double date at Lover's Lake. At first, Billy did not know if he should tell her that he knew her secret or not. He hesitated for a long time before picking up the phone and calling her, and Heather's joy at Robin's proposal ruined his mood even more.
"How did you get the idea?" Heather asked on the other end of the line.
So he made up his mind. Treat the matter as if he were ripping off a Band-Aid. "Because I know."
"You know what?" Her voice trembled imperceptibly.
"You and Robin. I know."
The silence that followed was deafening. Billy played with the chord, then took a deep breath.
"I don't care, just so you know."
The only sign that Heather was still standing at the other end was a choked breath.
"But you owe me a big favor, both of you. For getting me involved in this crap."
"Does Steve know?"
"He doesn't know right from left, that guy. Don't worry about him."
Heather was silent. A moment of hesitation, he could smell the fear. "Am I still your friend?"
"What a stupid question." Billy snorted. "See you at seven."
The time for the date came too fast, as if in a flash. Billy drove to get Heather and tried in his own way to make her comfortable with whatever they had on the radio. (Madonna. Not bad, but yeah, not really his type of music, to be honest). She hesitantly got into the car, wearing the prettiest dress she owned, and looked at him questioningly, shy as a doe. Billy didn't know what to say. He didn't feel comfortable either. He hadn't paid as much attention to his appearance as she had, and he realized right then that he looked more like a taxi driver than a fake boyfriend. He pushed the thought away. He was being used just like they were using Steve, so why bother?
Heather tried to smile as Billy drove away. She seemed to want to apologize to him with her eyes, but Billy was not worthy of forgiveness. He hadn't done anything.
"Okay," he said finally. "Are we done listening to this shit? Put on a good tape." Heather giggled and did as he said, rummaging through Billy's glove compartment and pulling out a tape at random. He turned up the volume as "Ride the Lighting" filled the car and felt like smirking when Heather's shoulders relaxed.
"You're a true friend."
Billy snorted. "You're just worried about the favor you owe me."
Heather smiled, and this time not out of shyness or worry. She meant it, and that made his heart flutter.
They arrived at Robin's in pleasant silence. Steve was with her, and they got into the car, chatting as if they were going to the movies, not Lover's Lake, where, as anyone with half a brain knew, couples went to make out. Steve and Billy exchanged glances through the rearview mirror, but neither said a word, letting the girls do all the talking.
Lovers' Lake shimmered on the horizon as the sun slowly set. They parked not far away and walked through the thick vegetation to the shore. Steve seemed comfortable in his own skin, laughing with Robin and participating in the conversation as if it were a normal date and not a farce. Billy was a little jealous of his malleability. Steve sometimes tried to get Billy to join in, but it was useless. He shuffled behind. He frowned. The irritability poured out of him in waves. He had no idea why, but whenever his eyes met Heather's, he quickened his pace and stopped being so sour at his destiny.
The farce unfolded naturally. They sat in a row on the shore watching the sunset, the boys on either side, the girls between them, close enough to touch. Billy pretended not to notice that Robin's hand was dangerously close to Heather's. At that moment, he wondered how he had missed the signs; those loving glances were just too obvious. Heather and Robin couldn't take their eyes off each other, and for a moment Billy felt jealous. He was used to being looked at like a treat. The mothers at the pool made sure he knew they were lusting after him every day of the week, and it felt great, exhilarating even, but it was nothing compared to these kind of looks. Only one person had looked at him with love in her eyes, and her memory had so long faded like a dream.
"We should get some firewood!" Robin exclaimed, jumping up and clapping her hands in excitement. "It would be great to make a campfire, don't you think?"
"You should have told me sooner," Steve said, lifting his eyes from the joint he was rolling. "I would have brought some marshmallows-"
"Next time!" Heather said, getting up as well. "Let's go, Rob."
"Shouldn’t we go instead?" Steve suggested, pointing at himself and Billy. "We are me-!"
Robin cut him off with a wave of her hand. Without another word, the girls quickly disappeared into the vegetation. Robin even had the nerve to wave goodbye to Billy, her mouth stretched into a gleeful grin. Scowling, Billy gave her a polite nod and remained in his spot by the lake. A shuffling next to him reminded him that he was not alone, that Steve was still there. Under Billy's puzzled gaze, Steve moved to sit beside him and offered him the joint he had just rolled for himself. Billy took it and brought it to his lips. A soft breeze washed over him and he shivered slightly.
Licking his lips, he handed the joint back to Steve.
"This is a lot better than the pool, right?" Steve's attempt at casual conversation should have annoyed Billy, but it didn't. In fact, he was kind of relieved that Steve was taking it so lightly. Billy glanced over to where the girls had disappeared before leaning to one side, elbow deep in the sand, his attention focused on the lake. "Dustin and the kids would like to swim here, I'm sure," Steve tried again, the awkwardness caused by Billy's stubborn silence evident in his tone.
"You haven't seen the ocean, man, that's why," Billy wanted to say. Steve nodded, took a drag and handed the joint back to Billy. "The pool and this lake have nothing on it," Billy added, slowly putting the joint back between his lips. Steve's saliva tasted sweet, or was it the weed? Definitely the weed. He inhaled deeply, so hard that it almost brought tears to his eyes.
"I've never been to the ocean," Steve said. "Do you miss it?"
Billy huffed. He puffed and sighed out the smoke and then handed the cigarette back to Steve, hating the way Steve's fingers brushed against his as he took it back. The brunet sat half-facing him, and from his position Billy had a good view of his arched back, the line of his arms circling his legs, and the outline of his face. There were moles up and down his forearms and even on the back of his neck, half hidden, half visible around the collar of his shirt.
Billy would never know what possessed him to say: "We should go there together."
Steve said "huh?" in surprise, obviously not expecting Billy to suggest something that sounded... oddly intimate, like inviting someone to your favorite hideaway.
Billy dipped his hand into the sand, curled his fingers around a stone, and looked at it disinterestedly. "Yeah, well. I'm sure Heather will love it," he muttered. "There's nothing sexier than a girl running around the beach in a bathing suit."
Steve took a slow drag, his auburn eyes holding Billy's gaze. With a sneer, Billy willed his attention elsewhere.
"How long have you and Heather been together?"
The question was like a bucket of ice water on his head. A bubble of laughter threatened to escape from Billy, but at the same time he felt so terribly offended by Steve's nonchalance that he would rather have hit the other over the head than humor him with a laugh. Then he grinned, hard and vicious, the only way he knew to keep his fists in check. It was a wonder how angry Steve's words had made him. Somewhere in the back of his mind, he was aware that the question was legitimate after all. Surprisingly, Billy and Heather had become quite close. She was beautiful, and Billy had a reputation as a lady-killer. This was a double date in Steve's eyes, but still. Still. Steve asking him if there was something between Heather and him felt ridiculous at best. And not just because of what Robin had told him. But because... because...
"You're an idiot."
"What?!" Steve exclaimed. "She's nice, and you seem pretty into her! I just thought-"
"You should thank God you're so pretty, because you sure lack brains."
"Asshole."
The arch of Steve's eyebrow made Billy even more angry. He clucked his tongue, pushed himself to his feet, and brushed the sand off his jeans with an abrupt flick of his hand. "I'm going to get those two. Date's over. We're going home."
"If you don't like her, don't lead her on, Billy."
The use of his first name brought tension to his shoulders. "What's it to you?"
"Is Heather trying to set me up with Robin? What is this all about? Don’t tell me you don't think these double dates are kind of awkward."
Billy snorted, but didn't dare comment. He marched into the vegetation instead, and he didn't care if Steve followed him, he didn't care if he bumped into Heather and Robin fingering each other. He didn't care. He just wanted to get home.
Fortunately, Steve didn't follow him.
He did, however, bump into Heather and Robin sucking faces.
Shocking them out of their skin and yelling "Date's over!" did wonders for his mood.
