Chapter Text
As Billy drove off in the Camaro, Steve's gaze remained fixed on the clouds of dirt that rose into the air as the tires screeched loudly against the road. Guilt made his chest heavy, but then another emotion overtook him and made his lips tighten. He suddenly felt empty, as if Billy had seized his heart and crushed it to the ground. The day had been too good to believe it would end this way, especially not like this, with Billy unable to look him in the eye.
"Steve?"
Max's faltering voice reminded him that he was not alone. The sounds of the carnival filled his ears again and Steve turned around, put his hands on his hips and willed a small smile to appear on his face.
"There goes my ride, huh," he tried to joke, but the feeling of sadness was just too much. Even being angry at the kids felt like a lot of effort. His eyes darted from one to the other: Max looking extremely guilty, El looking almost understanding, Lucas sending not-so-secret glances in Max's direction, Dustin's mouth twisted into a frown, Will standing a little closer to Mike, who was sending daggers in the direction of where Billy had disappeared. As Steve had expected, Mike was the first to speak.
"I told them this was a bad idea!" Mike exclaimed. "I told them, Steve!"
"Well," Steve said, his eyebrows furrowed, "you could have at least warned me!" he gestured wildly, dropping his arms immediately after. "I would have known how to handle it better!"
"I still don't understand why we had to tell him at all!" Mike groaned. Max glared at him.
"He had a right to know!"
"Why?" Mike took a menacing step toward her then, ignoring the way Will's arm failed to pull him away from Max. "So he could have another reason to smash Steve's face in?"
"Hey," Steve said, "he smashed my face in that one time because he didn't know."
"And now he wanted to do it because he did know," Lucas said, then winced as both Steve and Max turned to look at him. "Sorry."
"He's confused," El said.
"What if he didn’t go home? What if he doesn't want to see me anymore and ---!" Will asked, his eyes wide with fear. No one needed him to finish the sentence, the memory of Neil was still too vivid in everyone's minds. Steve's heart clenched. Lucas immediately squeezed Will’s shoulder and the boy seemed to calm down a bit, even if not completely.
"That's not true, Will. He loves you," Lucas said, glaring at Mike when the other dared to roll his eyes.
"Does he know that Jonathan and Joyce knew everything too?" Steve asked with thinly veiled urgency. Max let out a loud sigh that did nothing to hide her state of distress.
"What part of I told him everything don’t you get?" she said.
"Again, there was no reason to," Mike chimed in. "It's over. The Upsidedown isn’t an issue anymore. Right, El?"
El cast her eyes down and frowned slightly. She still had blood under her nose, and she wiped it away with determination. "I should talk to him again," she said finally.
"No," Steve's affirmation surprised everyone, but especially himself. "I'll do it. He's more mad at me than he is at you."
"He looked more disappointed than angry," Dustin said, speaking for the first time. He scratched his head under his baseball cap. "Give him some time, all of you. He's been through so much already. He’ll come around to this new piece of information. He’s a tough guy, he can handle it."
To say that Steve was surprised by Dustin's words would be an understatement, but at the same time, not even that small flicker of hope could smother the heavy weight that had settled on his chest. He wished he could be angry at everything the kids had done without confronting him first, then maybe he would have a reason to be angry at Billy too for being such a stubborn prick. He wasn't. Actually, he couldn’t blame Billy at all. He just wanted to go home and end the day in his empty bed.
"I'm going home," Steve said, putting his thoughts into words.
“Steve!” Max exclaimed again, walking to him and grabbing him by the arm. “You’re not angry with us, are you? We did it for a good cause!”
Steve patted her fiery red hair in what hoped was an reassuring gesture, but something must have showed on his face because she retracted her hand immediately. Without another word, Steve shoved his hands in his pockets and turned to walk away. He was going to go home on foot, and maybe the fresh air would take some of the bitterness off his mouth.
Billy woke up quite late. He had tossed and turned in his bed for a long time before he managed to finally drift off, and now the lack of a good night's sleep had added to his newfound irritation, making him even grumpier. He pushed away the covers and glanced at the sun filtering through the window slates. He hoped he was alone, but then he heard the clatter of silverware from the kitchen and let out a disappointed sigh. His ears pricked up to see if he could recognize the person just by their footsteps, but since he couldn't, Billy wondered if he could pretend to be sick and stay in bed forever to avoid any confrontation. There was no way Will would let him do just that, was there?
"Oh, fuck it all," he growled, finally slipping out of bed. He tiptoed outside and was heading for the front door when Jonathan's voice stopped him.
"Rough night?"
Billy's shoulders tensed, then collected himself, turned and stared at Jonathan's calm face. When his eyes fell on Will standing behind him, Billy's features softened reluctantly. No, he couldn't stay angry with either of them. Damn his soft heart.
"I've got breakfast on the table," Jonathan said, gesturing for Billy to follow him. "And Mom's cake. There's still a piece left, so you better hurry before Will eats it."
"Hey!" Will exclaimed. "You were the one who wanted to lick the plate clean! Billy," he turned to Billy who was still hesitating in the middle of the room, "believe me when I say I fought tooth and nail to keep that piece of cake for you."
Despite his best efforts to keep his face neutral, Billy chuckled. Taking it as a good sign, both Jonathan and Will flashed identical grins and walked back into the kitchen. More clattering, the sound of the fridge opening and closing, and Billy could do nothing but follow them. There was cereal, fresh milk and Joyce's cake waiting for him in his favorite sitting spot. Back to him, Jonathan had resumed washing the dishes, whereas Will stood awkwardly behind his chair, as if waiting for the shoe to drop. He had no idea Billy had decided to pretend nothing out of the ordinary had happened.
"Don't you have work to do?" Billy asked Jonathan's back.
"I took the day off," he said.
"Sit down," Will said and Billy did. He poured his milk on the cereal, then played with the spoon Will had placed on the table for him. He had no appetite, but for Will's sake he grabbed the slice of cake and shoved a piece into his mouth. Will seemed to relax at that
"Will told me what happened yesterday," Jonathan said, glancing behind his back before putting another plate on the rack. Billy nearly choked on his cake, tears forming as he tried to keep from coughing it all up. "Do you want to talk about it?"
"No," Billy croaked, eventually coughing and swallowing down the lump with a glass of milk. Will's eyes were wide and anxious, so Billy took a deep breath and forced himself to calm down. "Max told me everything. No need to talk about it anymore."
"Are you sure?" Jonathan asked, turning off the faucet and finally facing him. Will, still standing, glanced at his brother and Jonathan reciprocated the look, eyebrow raised. Billy hated himself for being unable to read their telepathic thoughts just yet. For a moment he wanted to say yes to Jonathan's question, but the words just didn't come out, so he decided to do something with his hands and ate the rest of the cake instead.
"I know it's a lot to take in, but Max wanted you to know everything, so you could understand--!" Jonathan said when the silent conversation with Will was apparently over.
"Oh, but I do understand," Billy snapped, feeling guilty as Will involuntarily flinched. He took a deep breath and looked at Jonathan instead. "I hope you know I'm not mad at Will."
"Of course you're not," Jonathan said. "I wouldn’t be so calm if you were. You're mad at Steve."
Billy laughed bitterly and ran a hand over his face. He felt the tears hot at the corners of his eyes and he swallowed around a lump in his throat. This time he had no cake to blame and hated himself for being so weak. Sensing the mood, Will hurried to sit down beside him, the chair creaking as he pulled it closer to Bill's. Jonathan sat down as well.
"You have no idea how hard Steve fought to keep the kids safe," Jonathan said. "You would have loved to see him hurling that baseball bat around like a pro," he added with a knowing smile, and Billy glared at him, unable to hate him even when he was being so openly teased. "He--!"
"Can we just stop talking about Steve?" Billy blurted out, much to Will's surprise. Jonathan just raised an eyebrow, that infuriating knowing smile still on his lips. "I don't want to talk about King Steve and his adventures in Whateverland."
"Sure you don't," Jonathan said in obvious disbelief. Billy glared some more, but Jonathan didn't even flinch. "You don't even want to know how he was the first person to try to stop the kids from doing something stupid."
"No, I don't, Jonathan," Billy said with raised eyebrows. "I don't want to talk about Steve at all."
"Right. Then you're not mad at Steve," Jonathan said. The constant use of Steve's name was getting on Billy's nerves.
"No!" Billy said, slamming his hand down on the table and regretting it immediately when Will balked away from him. "No," he repeated again, softer now. "I'm not mad at Steve. Because if I could, I would have done it all over again. Do you know what I thought when Max told me all this crap? I thought that if Max had died, my dad would have killed me."
Jonathan remained impassive, leaning against the table and waiting for the rest of Billy's reasoning, but Billy could see the pity behind the cold façade, and that was getting on his nerves too. For a moment the picture of Neil sitting in the same position, waiting for right opportunity to strike, flashed in his mind’s eye. His heart quickened. It was such a different picture from the one right in front of him that something inside him broke.
"You see?" Billy said, his throat tightening. "All I could think about was myself. My mind immediately went to all the things I would have suffered if Max had been hurt, and I would have fought Steve even if I had known all about monsters and stuff when shit hit the fan in this very same house that day. You can't tell me that Steve tried to save the kids because then... then…" Billy didn't know how to finish the thought, so he shook his head and snapped his mouth shut. "Forget it."
"Oh, I see how it is," Jonathan said and Billy glared, daring him to continue. Unfazed by Billy’s silent threat, Jonathan did anyway: "You think you're still the bad guy despite everything, because you would have done whatever it took to save your ass, no matter the case scenario,” Jonathan said and Billy's jaw tightened. "That's what's really bothering you, isn't it?"
Will's eyes snapped to Billy, and Billy looked down, away from all that understanding. "I'm not a good man, Jonathan. Steve is. You are. I'm not."
"So are you," Will said, putting a hand on his bicep. Billy turned to look at him, eyes wandering on the other’s face. There was a tender smile on his young lips, one that made Billy's heart skip a beat. "You are, Billy. To be honest, if you had known... you would have helped Steve try to keep us out of trouble. And you would have fought demodogs with your bare fists! You're brave and you're good. I trust you, Jonathan trusts you, Steve does, we all do. Whatever you’re telling yourself, it’s your dad talking, not you."
Billy's breath caught. He looked at Will, uncomprehending, then at Jonathan, as if begging him to help him with this. "But I...!"
"Enough of that," Jonathan said, standing up and, under Billy's surprised look, walking around the table to give him a loving squeeze on the shoulder. "I'll hit you with a frying pan if you try to say that again."
"I didn't say anything."
"Frying pan," was Jonathan's reply. Will chuckled.
"I want to see you try, you freak," Billy mumbled, and Jonathan laughed. With a shake of his head, he went back to the kitchen counter and started drying the sink.
"Now that that's out of your system, do you want to know how your Steve kicked some monster ass or not?" Jonathan said. If he hadn't felt sorry for his bowl of cereal, Billy would have thrown it at Jonathan just because. Will pulled the chair even closer to him and Billy gave up pretending he wasn't a tad curious.
"If you insist," Billy muttered, shoving cereal into his mouth. He pretended not to listen to Jonathan's story, but his attention was there, as was Will's closeness, warming him from the inside out.
The rest of the day, Billy realized he couldn't really shut out the world. It was as if something inside him had changed, and he felt more alive than ever, more in need of being a part of this, whatever it was, than ever before. He listened to Will's side of the story with interest, perched on the couch as Will showed him drawing after drawing of the Upsidedown. Billy felt a newfound respect for him and all the things he had done, and wondered how such a scrawny kid could be so much braver than he'd ever be. He promised himself to teach Will how to stand up to bullies, then wondered if Will really needed it at all. Later, when the doorbell rang and the rest of the kids burst into the house with more information and questions (surely invited by Will himself when Billy wasn't looking), Billy saw them all in a different light. Things had been awkward at first, he could still feel Mike throwing daggers at him and see Lucas standing protectively next to Max, but it felt different somehow, though he couldn't put his finger on the exact reason why.
As Jonathan and the kids played board games and tried to invite him into their DnD shenanigans, while all he wanted to do was be left alone with his thoughts and his music, Billy's mind couldn't help but drift to his mother. She used to do that too, trying to divert Billy's attention to far more amusing games than let him isolate himself when he was down. She could do it with just a smile, and when she was gone, Billy had suddenly built the very same wall around himself that his mother had fought so hard to prevent him from building. Now, suddenly, Billy saw his mother in all the children, in their own grins, in their glances when they thought Billy wasn’t looking.
They were all there and the only one missing was Steve. He suddenly missed Steve so much that it hurt. He wondered if he should call him, but on the other hand he was not sure if he wanted to do that just yet. He knew an apology was in order, but saying the one word felt awkward, something he wasn’t supposed to do. Maybe he had his father to blame for that, too.
"Billy?" Max's voice snapped him out of his reverie, and Billy looked at her, then at all the kids watching him over their cards. "Are you okay?"
Billy swore he would never get used to this. "I need a smoke," he said. "Be right back."
He went out on the porch, looked for his pack of cigarettes, and took one out. He thought of all the cigarettes he had shared with Steve, and his stomach clenched. A door opened and closed behind him, and he didn't have to turn around to know it was his sister.
"You're not mad at me, are you?" Max asked, coming close to him. Billy let the unlit cig dangle between his lips, then leaned against the wall.
"Nah," Billy said, talking around his cig. "You said you were going to explain at some point."
Max remained silent and Billy looked at her with a raised eyebrow. "Were you afraid I was going to run away or something?"
"Like I care," she said. Then she tucked her hair behind her ear and looked at Billy sheepishly again. "Sometimes I wish you would have fought with us." She paused. "Put those muscles to good use."
Billy snorted. "No, thanks," he said, finally lighting his cigarette. "I've had enough monsters to last a lifetime."
Max watched him, pinching her nose as she always did when Billy smoked in front of her, but there was something softer about her now that Billy didn't mind at all. It was overwhelming, almost unbearable, and it got worse when Jane walked out and shared a look with Max. Billy hoped the kids wouldn't start interrupting his smoking time one by one.
Max sighed and said: "You should quit smoking, it’s disgusting," before going back inside. Jane remained on the porch, and Billy finally enjoyed his cigarette letting her watch him in silence. It was strange how it didn't unnerve him anymore.
"My dad used to make me think wrong things about myself, too," Jane said suddenly to his surprise. "But I have a better dad now."
"Do you read minds too, kiddo?" Billy asked, and Jane had smiled cheekily before joining the rest of the party inside, leaving him alone with his cigs.
That afternoon, Billy had work he couldn't skip, even though his world had turned on its axis overnight. With Dustin at his side, he jumped into his Camaro and drove to the pool. As if nothing had changed from one day to the next, Dustin rummaged through Billy's glove compartment and pulled out the Led Zeppelin tape. He started humming to the first song, tapping his fingers on his knee. Billy looked at him, amazed at Dustin’s antics, and cleared his throat.
"I'm-well, I'm sorry for the way I reacted yesterday," Billy said, his throat tightening, his attention fixed on the road ahead. Out of the corner of his eye he could see Dustin looking up at him, not surprised at all.
"You should tell Steve that," Dustin said, "although in retrospect it makes sense that you acted the way you did."
Billy snorted but then got serious again. The light traffic stopped him and he leaned back in his seat, looking at the line of cars in front of them.
"Steve just took everything in stride, he always does. He wasn't even mad at us," Dustin continued, "He was just like, yeah, okay, and went home. Imagine, he didn't even want to join us when Will told us that you haven’t wrecked the place and that it was safe for us to just drop by."
Bill raised an eyebrow. "Will said what?"
"Lucas thought you pulled a Katrina at the Byers house," Dustin said, not helping the situation much.
"And Steve didn't come to check if he was right," Billy said.
"I told him to give you some space, to be honest," Dustin grinned. The light was now green and people honked at him as Billy was too out of it to drive forward. "Dude, you have to step on the pedal."
"I know, dipshit," Billy said. With a sneer, Billy did as he was told, but then he turned right instead of straight, earning another handful of honks for changing lanes at the last minute.
"You're going the wrong way," Dustin said. "The pool is right there."
"Shut up," Billy said, his heart pounding in his chest. He had no idea what he was doing, and beads of sweat rolled down his forehead at the realization of what he was going to do. Dustin complained that they were going to be late, but then shut up and let out an "oooooooooh" when he recognized the neighborhood they were in. Not even five minutes later, Billy was parked in the Harrington's driveway. Dustin looked at him with a raised eyebrow.
"Shut up," Billy said and got out, then changed his mind, leaned back into the car and pointed a finger at Dustin. "You stay here. I'll be right back."
Dustin rolled his eyes, mumbled an okay and motioned for Billy to be quick. Billy scoffed, but closed his door and walked over to Steve's. He didn't dare look back at Dustin, but he could feel his eyes piercing the back of his shirt.
He cleared his throat and made to knock, but the door opened before Billy could do more than ball his hand into a fist. Steve's face greeted his vision. Beautiful, stunning as always. His doe eyes wandered all over him, black lines showing that he had not had a good night's sleep either. Billy was kind of jealous that Steve looked good even like this.
They stared at each other, then Billy licked his lips and Steve's eyes were on his mouth instead. He didn't make it any easier. Steve was handsome and brave, and Billy wasn’t worth him.
"Hey," Billy finally said, earning Steve's gaze back on him.
"How are you doing?" Steve asked, then made a funny face, "You're not here to punch me in the face, are you?"
"No," Billy said, "and even if I was, I have someone who would cut my throat if I dared." He pointed a thumb behind him and Steve leaned over to see Dustin waving at him from inside Billy's car. "Can I come in? I won't be long."
"Sure!" Steve said a little too enthusiastically. He looked over Billy's shoulder again, then opened the door wider and let Billy in. Billy looked around, remembering the night he had spent in this house, and felt his face burn. He whipped around to face Steve and almost bumped into him as Steve stepped into his personal bubble. Steve let out an awkward laugh, Billy's hands found his waist to steady him, then immediately dropped to his side. Steve's scent in Billy's nose. Too close. Too damn close.
"I wanted to," Billy cleared his throat, took a step back, but Steve was there, his hand suddenly on his forearm, as if to stop him from leaving. "I want to..."
"I'm sorry I didn't tell you sooner," Steve cut him off. "But believe me, I did everything I could..."
"Shut up, I already heard it all from Jonathan," Billy said. "I'm not going to take another detailed account of how brave you are and how hard you tried to save the kids, because I'm not going to take another blow to my ego. I was supposed to be stronger and better than you, and now basketball is not enough to back me up."
Steve laughed quietly, his hand still hot on Billy's skin. Billy wondered why he was still letting him touch him.
"I was shocked, that's all," Billy said. "And, well, I still can't really believe it, because you have to admit that flower-headed mothers are physically impossible, right?"
Steve's eyes were on him. Billy hated it so much.
"Mostly, I'm not really proud of hitting your pretty face like that, after all the things I’ve heard," Billy said. A mischievous smile played on Steve's lips.
"We both know you enjoyed it," Steve said.
"Shut up. I'd rather not do that to your face anymore," Billy said. "I'd rather..." he stopped himself and looked down at Steve's fingers still on him. Steve followed his gaze and dropped his hand. Billy didn't want to admit it, he wanted that contact back.
"At least I'm still pretty," Steve joked, looking up at him again. "Right?"
"Is that what you're worried about?" Billy rolled his eyes. Steve shrugged.
"Looks are important."
"Did you bring your hairspray when you went to the downside-up world?"
"Upsidedown."
"Whatever," Billy said. Steve laughed.
"I might have."
"I don't believe you," Billy furrowed his brow, but Steve was looking at him, that smile trying hard not to break out in laughter. "What the hell are you so happy about?"
"I'm glad you're not mad at me," Steve said.
"I didn't say I wasn't!"
"Are you?"
"No!"
Steve did break into a big smile then, and Billy hated it, he hated Steve so much that if he could kiss him right then and there, he damn well would. He could, why not? Steve was just so close, it was like he was asking for it.
And then the opportunity was gone, a car honked and they broke eye contact. Steve looked inexplicably irritated, and Billy walked around him, opened the door, and yelled, "WHAT?" Dustin tapped his wrist like he had an invisible wristwatch and honked again. Some people moved the curtains to see what the fuss was about, and Billy's face grew hot under all those disapproving stares. Behind him, Steve snickered on the back of his neck.
"Jokes on you for bringing Dustin with you," Steve said. Billy turned around.
"I gotta go or the whole neighborhood will call the cops on me," Billy said. He looked at Steve again, long and hard and wondering, then willed himself to move. "Okay, well, see ya."
"Do you want to grab lunch together tomorrow?" Steve asked as Billy headed for the car.
"With Robin and Heather?" Billy asked back.
"Without them," Steve said from the door.
"Fine by me!" Billy got in the car, ignoring Dustin's curious looks as he turned on the ignition and drove off.
"Were you two fighting or things are okay between you now? I can't tell. Your face is fucking red."
"Shut up," Billy said, turning up the radio.
