Actions

Work Header

Dreams: To Stay by His Side

Chapter 26: Silences and Rememberance

Chapter Text

Despite Thorin's promise to wake Bilbo when the elf returned with a new plate of food, he found that he was unable to do so. But it was not for lack of trying on his part. Bilbo simply would not wake. At the first sign of the torch, Thorin had put his hand over Bilbo's mouth and given him a firm shake to wake him. Bilbo hadn't even noticed. If it hadn't been for his continued breathing, Thorin would have thought that he was dead for all the response his actions earned him. With a sigh he realized that Bilbo would not be escaping once more this time around. The hobbit was simply too exhausted. He only hoped that Bilbo would not wake while she was within earshot. He could see no way to keep his hand over Bilbo's mouth and draw no attention to the hobbit's presence.

This time she said nothing before she entered, he glared at her as he always did, his anger not the least bit appeased by the hobbit sleeping against him. Bilbo was suffering even if he was not dead and it was the fault of her king that he was. Thorin would not forgive them just because they hadn't actually managed to kill his mate. They would have if Bilbo had not had the Ring. His continued survival was not due to them. he felt a sneer cross his face as she smiled at the fact that the bread was no longer on his plate. She thought that he had eaten it. He hadn't. He had hidden it in Bilbo's coat pocket for the hobbit to find later.

"Did you not find the soup to your liking?" she asked. It almost sounded as though she genuinely cared but Thorin knew better than to rise to her bait. She was an elf. He knew that she would take great amusement from him complaining about the food.

"I thought that perhaps the meat would tempt you to eat it," she continued. Thorin looked away from her without saying a word. He had tried the meat that came from the forest of Mirkwood. If anything the presence of their meat would put him off the soup even more. However he said no such thing. With a sigh she pushed the plate back towards him and walked out closing the door behind her in silence. Thorin flinched as he heard the bolt slide into place once more. He only hoped that Bilbo would not be too angry that he was still trapped here when he awoke.

ooOO88OOoo

"Give him three more meals, lad," Balin pleaded when a deep sigh from Fíli revealed that he was preparing to carry out his plan. "This place is a maze. He may have gotten lost."

"Maybe Thorin's sense of direction rubbed off on him when they were—"Glóin said only to cut himself off as he remembered that Throin was dead. "I'm sorry, lads," he whispered into the oppressive silence that had followed his use of Thorin's name. "That was in poor taste."

"No," Fíli disagreed gently. "Uncle would want to be remembered fondly. Though perhaps for something a bit more majestic than his horrible sense of direction."

"We don't get to pick what we're remembered for, laddie," Balin said with a soft sad laugh. "There are many things that Throin will be remembered for that I doubt he would have chosen. That is just the way of things. For me, he will always be the mischievous dwarfling that continually landed me into trouble with my father. He was never able to suppress those urges entirely. He was pulling pranks on Dwalin and me right up until we left Ered Luin, though he would deny it where he here."

"I'll always remember him as the King that gave me a chance," Nori said unexpectedly. "Most dwarves would never have allowed me on such an expedition but Thorin didn't care about my past. He knew that sometimes we all have to do what's necessary to survive. I'll always remember him for that.

"Thorin was a great warrior," Glóin said sadly. "That is what I will remember him for. Some of you lads only got to see hints of it but . . . Thorin was glorious in battle."

"He was," Dwalin agreed softly. "But what I will remember him for the most was how well he was able to suppress those instincts and help Dís raise her boys. Seeing him with you lads . . . that was what gave me the hope to court my wife. If Thorin could be gentle enough to raise children . . . well, it meant that there was a chance for me  as well."

"I have too many good memories of Uncle to pick a favorite but if I did . . . it would have to be the time that Fíli and I invaded his meeting with Dáin and the other lords stark naked as we tried to avoid a bath with Mother right on our heels," Kíli said with a laugh. "The look on his face as he tried to control his laughter and remain the stoic King of Durin's Folk in Exile rather than our Uncle Thorin while two naked dwarflings clung to him desperately . . . it was priceless. I thought that he was going to explode."

"I will admit that I'd never seen quiet that expression on his face before," Balin admitted with a laugh. "I still can't believe that he allowed you two to stay, provided of course that your mother was willing to bring you clothing."

"So you had two naked dwarflings in a council meeting?" Bofur asked with a laugh. "Are children really appropriate there?"

"No," Fíli agreed. "But Uncle could never deny us anything, not really. And we wanted to stay.

"At least there Mother couldn't give us a bath," Kíli added. Those that knew Dís weren't actually sure that they would have put it beyond her to fill a tub and bathe her sons right there had it suited her to do so, but they let Kíli believe what he would.

"The only bad part," Fíli continued with a sigh, "was that since we had told Mother that as his heirs we should be involved in matters of state as a way of getting out of a bath, he took that to mean that we wanted to attend ever meeting from then on out."

"If I recall he eventually changed his mind," Dwalin said with a laugh. He was still amused at how well the boys had managed to turn Thorin's revenge back on him.

"He did," Fíli said, the smirk evident in his voice. "He only made us come until Kíli got especially bored one meeting and he and I might have entertained ourselves by trying to see who could get a ball of paper into the mouth of one of Dáin's advisors that was sleeping across the table."

"I managed it first," Kíli said proudly.

"He nearly choked on it!" Balin chided. "That is hardly something to be proud of!"

"But he didn't!" Kíli argued as Fíli said, "It freed us from meetings, didn't it?"

"And to think, Fíli's our king," Bofur sighed dramatically. "Let's just pray that he survives. I don't think the kingdom would survive Kíli."

"HEY!" Kíli snapped indignantly. "I would make a fine King!"

"Mahal help us if that happens," Dwalin sighed seriously. The others couldn't help but agree. Kíli was a fine lad but . . . he was not ready to be king just yet. Knowing him, he would likely turn his paperwork into confetti. No, if anything happened to Fíli they would be better off to name Dís as regent until Kíli was at least of age, if not longer.

"The same was said about Thorin once," Balin reminded them all. "Back when he was Kíli's age. I can remember more than just my father despairing of the future of the kingdom if that 'irresponsible prankster of a princeling' ever took the throne. Thráin was one of them. Thorin never feared for the kingdom if Kíli took over. That's a good sign, right lads?"

"Yes," Glóin countered, "but Kíli never had quite the pranking ingenuity of Thorin. Do you remember the one he pulled with Dís and Frerin on his father during—"

"Thror's birthday!" Óin laughed. "I thought Thráin was going to murder him, heir or not!"

"What did he do?" Fíli asked in excitement, he had never heard this story before.

"Well, lad," Balin began with a fond smile. "It was never proven, mind you. Thorin was always good at avoiding being caught—"

"Mostly because he tricked us into doing his dirty work," Dwalin muttered darkly, but with fondness coloring his tone. "I was punished more than once for some prank of his."

"True enough," Balin agreed. "At least he always apologized for causing us trouble. Anyway, he and your mother and your Uncle Frerin may have stuffed your grandfather's meat with greens."

"What?" Kíli asked wondering just how they had done that. How did one stuff a piece of meat with greens. "Was it a bird?"

"No, lad!" Glóin laughed. "It was meat. Somehow or another—don't ask me how they did it, if you really want to know ask your mother—they hollowed out his meat and replaced the middle of it with greens. It looked like a normal piece of meat up until Thráin took a bite of it and spit out a mouthful of grass. I got a good look at it as he dropped it back to his plate before rounding on his children. It was little more than a rim of meat over a ball of greens."

"I had never seen him so livid," Balin said with a laugh. "His entire face was red and it looked like the veins in his neck were about to burst."

"Claimed that his children had tried to poison him," Óin added. "Said they had no way of knowing that the grass they had put into his food wasn't poisonous. Wanted to know what would have happened had they have killed him."

"Sounds familiar," Fíli muttered rubbing his backside at the memory, though the physical pain of the indignity had long since faded.

"Come to think of it . . ." Balin said slowly as he searched his memories. "Dwalin, was that?"

"It was," Dwalin replied with a short bark of a laugh. "Thorin nearly repeated Thráin's speech to the letter. Including what came after. Only time I can ever remember Thráin raising a hand to any of them. You two had it easy," Dwalin continued, addressing Fíli and Kíli.

"Easy, yeah," Kíli muttered sulkily. It was one of the few times he could ever remember being spanked by his uncle and it had been witnessed by the whole of the company he was trying to impress. "Tell that to my hind end."

"Thorin at least drug you out of camp before he did it," Balin replied with a laugh. "Thráin didn't give his children the courtesy. "

"He didn't!" Fíli breathed, his eyes going wide. "Right there at the table?"

"He did," Dwalin, Balin, Óin and Glóin all confirmed. Fíli and Kíli's faces were twin masks of shock. No wonder they had never heard this story before. They couldn't see their mother sharing that story. If they had children they had no intention of telling them of their debacle with the pipeweed.

"I've never seen Thorin so embarrassed," Balin added. "I almost felt sorry for him. Almost."

"They never pranked their father again," Dwalin said with a shrug. "It must have worked."

"They did too!" Glóin countered. "They just never got caught again. Do you remember the situation regarding Thráin's missing ax?"

"Of course I remember it," Dwalin burst out angrily. "I was the one blamed for it. I swear I never touched it!" This statement led to a round of disbelieving snorts that led to yet more tales of the exploits of a younger Thorin and how his cousins continued to be pulled into the trouble (and how he continually managed to worm his way out of it). Fíli and Kíli were quite distracted and Fíli soon forgot about talking to the elf king entirely in his delight at hearing about his uncle during happier times. None of the others could blame him. This felt like a much more appropriate way of remembering Thorin's life than remembering just the sad parts of it. They may have shaped Thorin into the dwarf he became, but they were not all there was to him. As they exchanged memories and stories they silently pledged that Thorin would be remembered not only as King Thorin II Oakenshield, son of Thráin, son of Thror but also as Thorin the dwarf, brother of Dís and uncle of Fíli and Kíli. They owed him no less.