Actions

Work Header

You Know I'm Such a Fool For You

Chapter 3: Chapter Three: Results May Vary

Chapter Text

Wayne’s eyes widened. “Pregnant? Are you sure that my boy is the father?”

Officer Callihan shook his head. “Jason doesn’t believe he’s the father, so a test was done. We’re waiting on the results. They should be in soon. It was sped up by the Carver’s influence. Apparently it looks very bad that their son is still in high school, unmarried, and may already have a child.”

Wayne held the file in his hand, reading the paper multiple times to understand what was being said. “My son might be a father to this baby?” There was a picture of the baby attached to the file. A tiny, beautiful little girl, wrapped up in a pink blanket, with dark hair, bright green eyes, and a little button nose. He couldn’t help but to smile. “She’s precious.”

“She’s a cute baby, but if she’s your son’s, we need to figure out who’s going to take custody of her,” Officer Callihan explained, “No offense, but you’re…” He paused.

Wayne raised an eyebrow. “Spit it out, boy.”

“Older. I doubt you want to raise another child, right?”

“I don’t like your tone.” Wayne thought about everything that was told, everything he read, and he leaned against the side of the trailer. “I need to think about it. Come back with the results.” He then went inside and shut the door.

The officer sighed, but went to his car and drove off.

Steve’s jaw was hanging open, surprised with everything he had heard. “Holy shit,” he whispered. His cigarette had fallen minutes ago, out of his mouth and onto the top stair, where it was slowly going out.

“Munson might be a father?” Billy asked, turning to look at Steve, “I can’t see him as a dad. He sells me drugs.”

“What?”

Both the boys turned to see Max standing in the doorway. “Eddie might be a dad? Holy shit! I have to tell Dustin.” Before she ran away, Billy gently grabbed her by the arm.

“Hold on, Maxine,” Billy said, grip gentle as he pulled her back, “There’s more to the story.”

Max pulled her arm away, but she stayed next to Billy. “Then tell me, what did they say?”

“They did an autopsy on Chrissy. She was pregnant, but they don’t know who the father is. They’re doing a test and they’ll have the results in a few days.”

Steve nodded. “The baby survived,” he added, “It’s a girl.”

“Well, I’m telling Dustin anyway. I promised to keep him updated,” Max replied.

Billy looked at Max. “Okay. Take your present. It’s on the table by the tv. You’re welcome.”

Max rolled her eyes, but there was a semblance of a smile on her face as she went back inside.

Billy turned his attention back to Steve. “So tell me, pretty boy. What has the former King of Hawkins High been doing since his reign ended?”

Steve shrugged, leaning against the railing. “Not much. I’ve worked a few jobs. I’m currently at the video store with Robin, you remember the redhead, right?” When he got a nod in response, he continued. “But my real job is wrangling the little assholes that like to bother me every day. Always the goddamn babysitter.” He paused to light another cigarette, taking a quick drag of it. “What about you, Hargrove? It’s been a while since I’ve seen you.”

“Well, you know what happened last time we saw each other,” Billy replied, glancing at the door, before going back to the brunette, “If I’m honest, I’m still kind of dealing with that. I just…don’t like to worry her with it. She stopped hating me. Why would I ruin it by asking her for help?”

“Believe me, being wrapped up in that shit is hard to deal with. It sucked. I can’t begin to tell you all the shit I’ve been through, all the times I’ve nearly died. So that being your first time? You slowly learn to manage it. Just surround yourself with people you love, people you trust, and they’ll help you through it, I promise,” Steve nodded, slowly exhaling the smoke from his lungs. “I know. You should have heard her defend you all day. She really loves you, Billy. She called you her hero.”

Billy listened to Steve, nodding in agreement, before he realized the last part the man said. His face softened. “Wait, really?” he asked, sounding surprised, “I don’t believe that for a second.” Hearing that put a small smile on his face. “Maybe I am doing an alright job raising her.”

“I’m serious! She got upset when Dustin decided to be an asshole and insult you,” Steve explained, “But then again, he can be a pain in the ass to everyone. That’s just how he is. But if it means anything to you, Max is a really great kid, and I can tell she’s happier with you.” He gave a small shrug, before looking back at Billy. “It’s getting late. I should go.”

“Well, thanks, Steve.” Billy’s face softened, looking happy, a little in awe from that response. “Thanks for keeping my sister safe today,” he replied, “Come back tomorrow morning. I’ll make breakfast.” With that, he went inside without another word.

Steve walked back to his car and drove home, thinking about today, how nice Billy actually was. He wasn’t that bad, not nearly as bad as everyone makes him out to be. He was sure that if people saw how protective he is of Max, how caring and downright sweet he was when there’s no pressure on him, it would be different. Part of him was excited to go back to Billy’s house. He wasn’t sure why, but when he fell asleep, he dreamed of the beautiful blonde.

It’s been a week since then, consisting of the party bringing Eddie rations, waiting for the results, and hanging out at Billy’s house. Steve was up early, waiting by the phone after he showered and did his hair. Soon, it rang, and he stood, answering it. Before he got a word out, there was a voice on the line.

“Harrington, it’s Billy. Come over.” Click.

Steve sighed. “Good morning to you too,” he mumbled, hanging up the phone and grabbing his keys. It didn’t take long for him to drive to the trailer park, only a few minutes. Once he got there, he parked next to the baby blue Camaro he saw so many times before, and walked to the trailer. Before he could raise his hand to knock, the door swung open.

“Harrington! Hope you like your bacon crispy.” It was Billy, white tank top showing off his tanned, toned arms. His old gym shorts were hugging his thick thighs beautifully.

Steve couldn’t take his mind off of him, his mind went blank for a moment. “What?” was all he could manage.

Billy chuckled, shaking his head. “What’s the matter, Steve?” He leaned in, signature smirk on his lips. “Cat got your tongue?” He winked, before pulling away. “Come on, lover boy. Let’s get you some food. There’s an update.” He grabbed Steve by the wrist and pulled him into the kitchen, walking him down at the table, before motioning to the plates in front of them.

Electricity ran down Steve’s spine when he felt the touch. He sat down, grabbing a fork and quietly began eating the food, his growling stomach thanking him. “You said there was an update?”

“Yeah,” Billy replied, adding sugar to his coffee cup, “The same cop came when I was in the shower, but Max heard it all and filled me in. The kid isn’t Carver’s. It’s Eddie’s. The hospital doesn’t know who to give custody to, since Munson is missing and Chrissy is dead. They didn’t even give her a name yet.” He paused, taking a sip of his coffee. He then looked over at Steve, shrugging. “They’re all looking for Eddie. No one will say anything, so it’s like a wild goose chase trying to find him. Carver and his guys are still looking, even though they were warned not to meddle in the police investigation. They’re obviously not listening.”

Steve sat there, shaking his head. “That’s terrible. That poor baby growing up, not knowing about her parents…. There’s no way Eddie would be trusted with a baby after he’s framed for murder, even if it is his kid.” He sighed. “I don’t trust the guy at all. I mean, he nearly slit my throat that night.” He earned a surprised look from Billy. “It’s true. He did it in front of the kids. Pinned me against the wall and everything. I thought I was going to die right then and there.”

Billy looked…angry? Upset? Steve wasn’t sure. The emotion was quickly hidden as fast as it appeared. “Well, pretty boy. If I was there, he wouldn’t have had the chance to touch you.”

“You would have protected me?” Steve asked, cheeks heating up as he thought of Billy fighting for him. It made his heart soar.

Billy nodded. “Of course. You helped save my life. And you keep looking out for my sister. I have to pay you back.”

“No, you don’t. It’s not something you need to pay me back for. Of course I’m going to protect her.”

Billy thought about Steve’s words, trying to picture it, but couldn’t. “Wait, Munson pinned you against the wall? How did you not get out of it? He’s a twig!”

“Yeah, a twig with a lot of upper arm strength!” Steve exclaimed. “Henderson said he’s in a band, so he’s carrying around a heavy guitar all the time. Besides…” He looked down, a little embarrassed. “It caught me off guard. I was really scared, and I panicked. I couldn’t get myself to move. All I could do was try not to cry.”

Billy frowned. “Yeah,” he replied, “It’s pretty damn scary nearly getting killed.” He would know. Flashes of memories in his head of all the times it’s happened to him; every knife against his throat, every time he was laying on the floor, in a pool of his own blood, nearly blacked out, vision blurry with tears. He shook his head, not wanting to think about it anymore, No, that was the past. He didn’t have to deal with that anymore.

“Billy? Are you okay?” It was Steve, breaking the train of thought.

Billy was grateful for that. “I’m fine,” he replied, looking over at the beautiful brunette next to him, “So… What’s the plan for today?” He forced himself to smile, not wanting to worry the man.

Steve shrugged. “I don’t know. We promised Eddie that we’d bring him some food, so I guess we’re going to do that. I wonder if he heard the walkie talkie message.”

“Who knows how he’s going to react to that,” Billy said, reaching in his pack of cigarettes and placing one between his lips. His words were a little muffled as he lit it, the cherry coming to life with the flame. “If it were me, I wouldn’t know what to do. I made a kid, so I’d want to be in its life, but being on the run? He’d need a babysitter or something.”

Steve sighed. Feeling daring, he reached over and plucked the cigarette out of Billy’s mouth, taking a long drag, before exhaling and handing it back to the flustered man.

The door opened then, and it was Max, dressed and ready to go. She noticed that both the boys’ cheeks were pink. “Will you two quit making out for two seconds? Nobody heard from Eddie, not since we left him last night. Dustin is worried, he asked if we could go now.” She looked at Steve as she said that.

Steve’s eyes widened at the comment, but he decided to ignore it. “Alright, let’s go grab Dustin and check on Eddie.”

Max hugged Billy, before going to the car. “I’ll see you later, Billy!” she called, before going in and sitting in the passenger seat.

Steve just watched, before turning his gaze to Billy. “I’ll watch her,” he said, “I remember the promise, don’t worry. Bye, Billy.” He walked to his car and drove off.

It was quiet, the car ride to the nearest gas station, picking up a few snacks for Eddie, then to the Henderson household, but once they pulled up to the driveway, Max turned to Steve. “So….you like him, don’t you?”

Steve’s eyes widened. “What?” he asked, surprised. Did he? Was it obvious?

“Don’t play dumb, Steve. I see how you look at him. I also see how he looks at you,” Max explained, “He talks about you.”

Steve blushed. “He… He does? What does he say?”

“Not much. Just that you’re different from how he remembers you. He said it’s nice to see you again.” Max smirked. “He also called you really cute. He wants me to bring you over more.”

“He thinks I’m cute?” Steve couldn’t help but to smile. “I think he’s cute too, and sweeter than I remembered.”

“Don’t let that go to your head, Steve. You already have a big ego.” Max reached over and honked the horn.

“Hey!” Steve gently smacked Max’s hand away, before looking in the mirror and fixing his hair. “Big ego…” he mumbled.

The back door opened, and Dustin slid into the back seat. “You’re so impatient that you had to honk the horn instead of walking your ass to the front door and ringing the doorbell?” He huffed.

“Hey, be happy I’m taking you to see him,” Steve replied, already pulling out of the driveway and making his way down the road. “Especially when he tried to kill me. He didn’t even apologize for it.” It became yet another fear for him. Every time he saw that man, he still felt the broken glass against his neck, his mouth dry. It made him have to sit in the car during the visits now, only looking out the window for any sign of danger.

Dustin cocked an eyebrow. “You’re still complaining about that? Steve, he did it because he was scared. But if you’re really going to be a baby about it, I’ll tell him to apologize for it. Okay?”

Steve stayed quiet, just letting out a soft sigh as he pulled the steering wheel, turning onto the road and to the boathouse. Once the car was parked, he turned to Max. “Be careful, okay?”

Max smirked. “Do you not remember the promise you made to your boyfriend? You have to watch me, keep me safe.”

“He’s not my boyfriend…” Steve mumbled, though his cheeks turned pink at the thought.

Dustin frowned, confused. “Boyfriend? You don’t have a boyfriend. You’re not gay.”

Steve turned to look at Dustin. “No, I don’t, but even if I did, it wouldn’t be any of your business. Now, go see your felon friend.” He got out of the car. “Come on, Max. I have to keep my promise to your brother.”

“Eddie is not a felon!” Dustin’s eyes then widened. “You didn’t deny the gay part. Wait, is Billy your boyfriend?”

“No!” Steve snapped, cheeks an even deeper shade of pink. “Maybe. I don’t know! Shut up and let’s go!”

The others grew quiet as they got out of the car and into the building. Steve shut the door, standing by it, not making eye contact with Eddie.

Dustin handed Eddie the bag of snacks. “Hey, Eddie,” he said, “How are you doing? I know you didn’t really want to talk about the last message.”

Max walked a little closer to Eddie. “There was a new update, by the way. Cop came this morning and told your dad,” she explained, “I wanted to tell you in person. The results came back. They said it took a while, even with Jason’s family funding the test.” She watched Eddie’s gaze move to hers, and she grew nervous. Moving closer to Steve, she held his arm, before continuing. “The baby is yours. You’re a dad, Eddie.”

Eddie’s eyes widened, starting to glisten with tears. He sucked in a shaky breath, trying to process the news. “Shit…” he whispered, looking down, “W-what did he say? My dad…what did he say about it?”

Steve noticed Eddie getting upset, so he moved Max behind his arm, protecting her.

Max glanced up at Steve, before continuing. “He was shocked. You can tell he didn’t know what to say. But eventually, he said that he’d do it temporarily, just until they find either you or someone permanent to have her. He couldn’t keep your baby forever while not knowing where his own son is. If you’re dead or hurt. He’s always wanted a grandchild, but not like this. Not when his kid isn’t around to watch her grow up. I don’t know, Eddie. He looked really upset. He misses you.”

Dustin was quiet the entire time, listening to everything, heartbroken. “Eddie, I’m sorry. I wish I knew how to help.”

“Help? My dad is giving up on me, and the baby, and I’m wanted for murder because I fell in love with the Queen of Hawkins High! If you really want to help, Henderson, figure out how to clear my name so I can go back to my dad and my kid!” Eddie was crying now, clearly overwhelmed. He held his head in his hands, trying to calm himself down, little sobs and hiccups filling the building.

Steve listened, quiet. He had no idea what to say. “I think it’s been a long enough visit. Kids, get in the car.”

“Steve, have some compassion!”

“For what?! For the felon that fucked someone else’s girlfriend and then tried to kill me?!” Steve snapped. “Get your head out of your ass, Dustin. He fucked up! Now get in the car or I’m leaving you and you can walk your ass home!”

Eddie stood then, wiping his eyes. “No,” he said, voice breaking, “I’m sorry for threatening you, I really am. I was just panicking. I still am, honestly. I want to go home, but it seems like the cops are constantly patrolling around there, so I can’t. I want to see my dad. I want to meet my baby and live my life, but I can’t because Carver is a douchebag and he’s had it out for me for years. I don’t know what to do. I haven’t slept in a week. I’m living off of pringles and honeycomb cereal. I need a shower, and different clothes, but I can’t do that without people seeing me.”

“All you can do is wait, Eddie. We’ll figure out something, I promise,” Dustin said, “Just stay strong.”

Steve said nothing. He just pulled his keys out of his pocket and jiggled them, before walking out of the building. Once in his car, he started it and tried to form a plan. What was he supposed to do? He didn’t have the brains like Dustin or the other kids. He didn’t have powers. It would be so much easier if the others moved back from California, even if Mike returned from his trip. Maybe he could get Nancy involved. She’s smart. A car door opening broke his train of thought.

“Well, that was a lot.” It was Max, returning to her spot in the passenger seat.

Steve nodded in agreement. “I don’t know how to help him. I’ve been trying to form a plan, but I’ve got nothing. I wouldn’t know where to start.” It then hit him. “Wait, what about Lucas? I haven’t seen him since he made the winning basket that night at the game. He’s friends with the team, right? Maybe he could help us by telling us what Jason is planning.”

Max smiled. “That’s a good idea, Steve, but you’ll have to ask him yourself. We broke up.”

“What? Why?” Steve asked. He didn’t know Dustin was already in the backseat until he heard the voice.

“Because he’d rather hang out with the cool kids instead of his real friends,” Dustin explained, “He says he’s doing it for us, but that’s a bunch of bullshit. It’s a good idea, though. I’m surprised your brain produced a single coherent thought, Steve.”

Steve frowned. “Get out. You’re walking home.” He was already driving, though, not stopping.

“Then, Dustin, you ask him about Jason and the team. I know Chrissy was seeing the school therapist.I saw her walk out of there a few times. Maybe we can break into her office and see if it said anything in her files?” Max suggested with a shrug, “And Steve, you can be the driver.”

Steve sighed. “I don’t like the idea of breaking and entering, but it’s the best shot we got.” He parked in front of the Henderson house. “Dustin, you use your walkie and get a hold of Lucas. Keep us updated.”

Dustin nodded. “Alright. Say hi to your boyfriend for me,” he replied, chuckling as he got out of the car.

Steve gave Dustin the middle finger as he drove off, heading to Max’s house. He sighed, parking next to Billy’s Camaro and getting out.

Max got out of the car. “Come on, let’s tell Billy the plan and see if he can help us with it.” She ran to the trailer and opened the door, holding it open for Steve. “Come on!”

Steve followed, his lips curling into a smile as he walked inside. His smile grew bigger as he saw the blonde. “Hey, Billy.”

“Hey, amigo,” Billy replied, smirk on his face as he sat down on the couch, holding a beer out to Steve, “Sit. Have a beer with me.” His other hand had another can in it, already opened.

Steve did as told, sitting next to Billy, taking a sip. “Thanks,” he replied, cupping the can in his hands, “Would you like to hear what happened?”

Max sat on the other side of the couch, leaning against Billy’s side. “We told Eddie what happened.”

“You did? How did he react?”

Max shrugged. “He was pretty upset. He cried, saying he wants to go back to his dad, but he can’t.”

“Well, it sucks what happened, but how can any of you help?” Billy asked.

“Steve had a good plan. Why don’t you tell him, Steve?” Max stood, leaning in close to Billy’s ear. “Do it. Ask Steve out like you said you wanted to.” She said it loud enough for both the men to hear, causing Billy to choke on his drink and Steve to blush profusely. She then patted Billy on the shoulder. “By the way, I want pizza tonight,” she said, sounding sweet, before walking down the hall and into her bedroom.

Billy just watched his sister walk off, shaking his head. “She’s a pain in the ass sometimes. Sorry about that, just ignore her.”

“It’s alright,” Steve replied, trying to calm his racing heartbeat, “Believe me, she’s not the worst. Henderson is usually the one who likes to instigate.” He sucked in a breath, thinking of what Max said just now, as well as in the car. Was she telling the truth? He couldn’t ask! They definitely got closer hanging out but not enough to ask about feelings. Not yet.

Part of Billy felt grateful that the subject was changed. The other part of him felt he was losing his chance. He didn’t know whether to kill his sister or hug her. Steve made his heart skip a beat, he couldn’t deny it, even during high school when they met, but… He didn’t know if Steve was straight. He had to be. “Who’s Henderson? The one with the sister or the toothless one?”

“Previously toothless,” Steve corrected, “But he got his teeth. Some sort of surgery or something. I don’t know. Even with teeth, he’s an asshole. Kid’s a total genius, though. He goes to science camp, for fun! The others are smart, too. Like Wheeler, the one with the sister? Straight A’s, was in the AV club with the others, I think he was the president. Sinclair is smart, too, but he’s more into sports. Actually, he was part of the plan. Hopefully, at least. He’s on the basketball team with Carver. If we can get Lucas to tell us what they’re planning, see what they know, maybe we can get ahead of them.”

Billy nodded. “Sinclair, I know him. He used to come over when he was dating Max. I apologized to him when I was in the hospital, for being a dick to him. He accepted.” He heard the plan, and nodded. “A double agent? I like your brain, Harrington.”

Steve smiled, happy with the compliment. “Thanks. Max wants to break into the school therapist office to get access to Chrissy’s file, see if there’s anything that can help us.”

Billy cocked an eyebrow. “Like what?”

Steve shrugged. “I don’t know, but it’s worth a shot. We have nothing else. If the Upside Down is part of it, there’s gotta be something, like maybe she talked about weird shit happening to her.”

“It’s worth a shot. Just make sure she doesn’t get caught. I can’t have her getting in trouble with that shit,” Billy replied, sounding serious.

Steve nodded, understanding. “I’ll be there with her, make sure she’s careful.”

Billy seemed content with that answer. “Alright. What’s next?” He took a few sips of his beer, the condensation from the can dripping onto his hand. He wiped it off on his shirt.

“Well, until we hear from Lucas, and Max can get access to the therapist’s office, I think we need to get more hands involved in this. Like Nancy. She’s sharp as a whip, I’m sure she can figure out more than we can,” Steve explained, pausing to get more comfortable on the couch. He moved his leg, accidentally touching Billy’s knee. He felt daring, so he kept it there, heart skipping a beat when he felt Billy move closer, their legs completely flush against each other. Steve was sure his brain was short-circuiting at this point, but he kept talking. “Robin can help too. There’s gotta be something in the library that would help us. I don’t know what, but maybe it doesn’t hurt to look?”

“You know, Dustin really should give you more credit.” Max was standing in the doorway of the kitchen, listening to the boys talk in the living room. “You’re smarter than he thinks.” She moved closer to the couch. “I was coming to tell you that Dustin was able to get a hold of Lucas. He said he didn’t know anything else except that they’re looking everywhere. He’ll talk to them tomorrow.”

“He is pretty damn smart, isn’t he? Good job. Maxine, why don’t you try to get access to the office tomorrow? ” Billy smiled at Steve, throwing an arm over his shoulders. “And you, pretty boy, get hold of the girls, see if they’ll go to the library while we wait on intel from the possible double agent?”

Max nodded and went back to her room.

There goes Steve’s heart again, jumping right into his throat from Billy’s arm. It took everything in him to not lean into the touch. He cleared his throat, trying to get rid of the forming pinkness on his cheeks. “I’ll call them when I get home.”

“That works. Hey, do you want to stay for dinner? I’m ordering the pizza now.” Billy slowly removed his arm from over Steve’s, a soft sadness when he did. “Hey shithead!” he called. “What kind of pizza do you want?”

“Pepperoni!” Billy heard the annoyance in her voice and he chuckled. He glanced at Steve before he went to the phone. “You staying, Harrington?”

Steve thought for a moment, but shook his head. “I should really try to get a hold of the girls before it gets too late. Thanks, anyway. I’ll see you tomorrow?”

Billy smiled. “Sure, pretty boy. Goodnight.” He then took the phone off the hook, dialing the number.

Steve left, driving home. Once there, he kicked off his shoes, nudging them closer to their rightful spot near the doorway. He then moved to the phone, and dialing the number he knew by heart, having called it many times over the years. It took a good five minutes for him to fully explain everything that was going on, as well as the favor he had to ask her, but ultimately, she agreed. He then called Robin, and she accepted.

After the phone calls, he undressed and went to sleep.