Work Text:
The thing is, Steve had expected jealousy.
He hadn’t wanted it, only really found it attractive in the same way he found Eddie’s fingers bleeding across the body of his guitar attractive; he had grown up in a house that made family dinners too similar to the scene from ‘the lion, the witch and the wardrobe’, where Aslan is led to the stone table and killed, to be any more invested.
Plus Steve had used to be king of Hawkins High and whilst he had known that the girls he had fucked- mostly fumbled around with blindly and then driven home, making sure they left his beemer smiling- would leap at a chance to come back for a second go, they had known the deal; so the only ex he had had walking about was Nancy Wheeler.
His other ex had been dead.
He says ‘had been’ because stood in the Upside Down- with Robin and Nancy inside her bedroom a couple of hundred yards away looking for her gun stash, and Eddie The Freak Munson (who had bitten a bruise into the junction between Steve’s neck and shoulder the night before, as they pressed up against the wall of the boathouse, that he could still feel throbbing pleasantly now) straightening up behind him- a familiar shock of blonde hair and wicked teeth were snarling a smile that had a defiant lick of heat curling in his stomach.
It was losing though; dodging punches from the wash of anxious nausea swirling around him instead of just planting its fucking feet and taking the hits.
It was nearing seven months.
Six had hit him like a bullet to the chest; bloody and brutal, knocked all the air from Steve’s lungs and brought back screaming nightmares he had finally been getting used to not sharing a bed with.
Max had knocked on his door one night and without saying a word she had pressed her face into Steve’s chest and clawed at his back until her body was wracking itself with great gasping sobs. When he had delivered her into the arms of Susan and gotten home, he realised his shirt was completely dry. Like Max had needed to feel something so badly, her body had let her without having to give away anything at all.
Thinking about it now, it had been a red flag as well; he should have realised how much she was suffering.
It wasn’t about Billy, not all of her pain and hurt, but enough of it was, that Steve had become one of the only people who understood properly; the rest was fear and trauma, being left again by a dad who she hadn’t realised was doing awful things to the people she loved.
Billy had been awful, and terrible, and then he had collapsed during a test Steve already knew he had sent Nancy spiralling over because she was losing her mind at the idea of that guy beating her out for Valedictorian. He came back three weeks later, escorted in by Hopper and wearing a scar from temple to chin that the whole town knew Neil Hargrove had cut into place, before Susan had pulled a gun on him and fired a warning shot into the military man’s kneecap.
Instead, in a tentative voice whilst the two of them were waiting outside the arcade for the Party, Billy had told Steve he was sorry and didn’t expect forgiveness- offered information to prove shit that Steve would have believed anyway.
Steve had shrugged and said fine, told Billy all the kids needed to hear that too before he forgave him though. The blond had flushed such a gorgeous shade of pink that the older teen was pulled so hard into images his brain had never actually seen but stored away of Billy in his natural habitat; some Californian beach, wearing those ridiculously small trunks he seemed to save for lifeguarding, his mullet wet and sunbleached as it curled into his eyes: Those thoughts always made the shorter look younger, happier in the same way they left Steve breathless.
‘I already apologised to Max, and she said the same thing, so I apologised to Lucas next and I tried-’ Billy had swallowed then, hands splayed over the Camaro’s hood and head tipped back to the winter sun, and Steve had had to fight to find it in him to care about more than licking his neck. The blond shook his head- ‘I told him why I was scared, and that it didn’t make it better but I told him about some shit to give him proof I meant it.’
For a few months, that had been that.
Except, somewhere after all the sorrys, before the most awkward stand-off to ever happen between Hargrove and Henderson, but after soft-spoken Will Byers had asked to ride in Billy’s car more than once, Billy and Steve kissed slow and gentle in the dark of his house; only lit up by the soft green glow of his pool.
And then it was more than stolen glances and fingers linked under tables. By the time flowers had started being hidden by blankets and quilts and mattresses of snow, a fucked out Hargrove had already pressed his too-hot skin all over Steve’s and murmured how much he loved him before falling asleep.
And then Billy was missing.
And then Billy was possessed.
And then Billy was dead.
And then came Eddie.
Eddie was a breath of fresh air that simultaneously smelt like weed and staleness, he was a pair of armbands tossed to him in the middle of a storm; Eddie couldn’t keep him from going under necessarily, but he was sure as hell gonna drag Steve back up to the surface when shit calmed down.
Maybe, just maybe he was ignoring Max a little, because looking at her when he could still feel his shoulders ache from being pressed about by him felt too much like admitting he had a type- made him too desperate to beg Eddie to run to somewhere far the fuck away and hide with him incase some messed up tentacle monster decided to play puppet master with his second boyfriend as well.
Back in the present though, Steve was more concerned with inane thoughts, idle ones that were taking the opportunity his destroyed psyche was presenting by pausing all important thoughts of danger to linger in the front of his mind.
Like, did he have a type?
Looking at Billy now- and he was so sure it was Billy because even from the six feet away the other boy had to be. He could see that damned scar Neil had given him, the one he had thumbed across with more care than he had taken with anything in his life before then (as though with one wrong move, Steve would press too hard and be left with two halves of the mask Billy put on each day) and it was irrational but Steve just felt it, in his bones, that nothing could make it branch downwards over him like lightning quite so exactly without it being his Billy- it was harder to tell.
Six months in the Upside Down probably felt like more than six months, because the mullet the other usually sported was pulled into some type of braid that fell to the middle of his back. Other than that though, the look was somehow the same. Billy was wearing a leather jacket covered in patches from bands and protests, ripped to shit jeans that Steve thought probably had less to do with style and more to do with apparently fighting demobats every day, and most noticeably a pair of fingerless gloves covering his palms.
Then there were his eyes. They were that same sparkling blue but dark in the low light of the other dimension. They made Steve think of the family trip the entire Harrington family had made out to his great grandmother's holiday cabin eight years ago. There had been a lake that they all sat around, piled in blankets and nestled around a fire, and when the moon finally lifted itself from behind the mountains it hit the water.
There had been a collective gasp from all of them.
Every ripple and curve of the surface of the water lit up with white fire, burning blue ribbon snaking its way around the shape of the valley in erratic, eccentric circles.
Steve realised he had missed all that fire under Billy Hargrove’s skin.
It was similar to the fire under Eddie’s. Eddie was a different kind of warm though. Even when the kids had been describing the way Munson had prowled along the cafeteria tables calling out the social hierarchy that hurt him and his friends and anyone who hadn’t been crowned King of Hawkins High with a vicious tongue, Steve could imagine the grin on his face as he did it.
He wondered if it was possible to want them both- the kindness that licked its way across Steve’s wrist when he was with Eddie that only burned when it felt vulnerable, and the red hot under the blond’s skin that was dangerous to stand close to until he remembered you were safe- and then he swallowed hard and tried to stop his hands from shaking.
Only tuning back in when he felt Eddie’s hand curl protectively around his wrist in case they needed to run, Steve realised he was hissing something at him, frantic repetitions of his name as though he was worried Steve had been pulled under the Vecna’s spell (God he wanted those kids to stop naming all the awful, traumatic shit that kept happening to them after a board game, but he was just glad they still played).
Then Billy spoke, and everything fell back.
‘Am I dreaming or is that you Harrington?’ Billy called out in that same Californian accent he had spoken in, and the brunette could suddenly taste the ghost of smoke curling out of the other’s mouth. His grin was feral and dangerous, but softer all the same. Like maybe Billy really thought he was dreaming and was trying not to disturb the hellscape around them in case he woke up. As though maybe it was worth being stuck in the Upside Down if Steve was there - he could see it because he felt the same.
Steve stalked forwards, dropping his bat to the floor and crossing the small space between them; he wanted to scream, wring Hargrove’s neck for not being dead, push him to the ground just so that Steve could be sure he was real.
Instead, his fingers curled into the lapels of the leather jacket, faded and soft with time, and he buried his face into the crook of Billy’s neck. For the blood rushing in his ears, he could barely feel the way Billy’s arms immediately wrapped around him in return. His voice was smaller than he wanted it to be, and he knew he’d catch shit later for the way it cracked in his throat, ‘yeah it’s me, don’t cream your pants.’
Then it all shifts because there are hands around Steve’s waist tugging him away from Billy’s and screaming and at one point he’s pretty sure Nancy is trying to shoot at Billy before they realise who he is.
Billy takes it all in his stride, and Steve seems to be the only one mourning the lack of closeness between them as the girls form an excellent barricade. Eddie’s hand has moved though, fingers intertwined with his, so it doesn’t ache as terribly as he imagines it would have. He turns then, eyes Eddie all over and sags because of all of a sudden he can feel it.
He can feel how fucking exhausted he is, and Steve doesn’t know how Eddie is even still standing.
Eddie was a fast development; where he had found himself falling for Billy in that slow, romantic way, his time with Eddie had started with a quick fuck in the back of Family Videos after they had shut one night.
Dustin had introduced them of course, told him that Steve should meet his new friend, and Steve hadn’t argued because he was kind of dying for people to hang out with him who weren’t:
Fifteen
His ex
His ex’s boyfriend
So far his only success had been Robin.
It had turned out better than he could have hoped for.
Eddie and Steve watched terrible movies in the low lights at the back of the theatre where no one could see him lean over to kiss him whenever he felt like it, they dipped their fries in one milkshake across from the arcade when Steve took the kids there and argued about why strawberry was so superior compared to chocolate, they pressed sweaty chests together in the same bed in his big empty house whenever either of them woke up from a nightmare.
After that first night together, he had stopped having the usual nightmares per say. There were still blurs of corpses and vines, of demogorgans and always a pair of broken glasses at the bottom of his pool, but now there was a different type of dream in the middle.
Scarred, boney fingers were holding his hips as Eddie invaded his space and pressed up against his back, chin hooked over his shoulder as he whispered things in Steve’s ear that made him blush even in the dream. Then there would be nothing except the sound of denim against his bare back and his own panting for a few moments whilst the other kissed the hinge of his jaw and around the base of his neck.
When that chin hooked over his other shoulder though, the skin felt a million times warmer, and there was more weight against his back, like Eddie was suddenly standing on his tiptoes. Even before blond curls had spilled across his skin, Steve had known it was Billy, and that’s when the whispering would change.
It was still filthy but now it was Billy rumbling too low murmurs about how bad he had always wanted to go to Paris, about how quick Steve had moved on to the next punk loser Hawkins had offered him, about how glad he was that someone else was taking care of him cause ‘a dick that good deserves a little TLC now and then.’
Steve would wake up choking on a laugh and half hard as tears slipped relentlessly over his cheeks.
But then Eddie had been witness to the fucking Vecna killing that cheerleader and Steve’s heart was on the floor. He had sobbed into his pillow that smelt of Eddie’s shampoo, wearing the almost threadbare jumper still under his bed that had been Billy’s, and begged not to lose him as well.
Somehow he didn’t seemed to have lost the boy he had loved in the first place.
With that in mind, Steve checked Nancy and Robin were holding guns (they weren’t) and he sighed heavily.
‘New plan then?’ He asked the group and clapped his hands together, the corners of his lips tugging up at the sound of Eddie snorting, his eye roll and the defeat in his shoulders almost as audible.
‘Yeah, personally I would like to get the fuck outta here,’ Billy huffed and scratched at the light stubble on his chin (only confirming Steve’s suspicions from when he was alive that he was actually incapable of growing a beard).
Eddie took a step towards the blond and pointed at him, bobbing his head in a nod, ‘seconded! I have a manhunt to be getting back to escaping from.’
Billy squinted but, to Steve’s eternal relief, let it go, almost like it wasn’t a surprise; then again, he thought, how many surprises could the other experience that topped ‘not dead and stuck in hell indefinitely’?
‘Oh okay! So me and Nancy were thinking right? And the spot that you got tentacled into the Upside Down is like, exactly where Patrick died, right? So what if-’ at this point, Nancy butted in to take over from Robin. Her eyes were kind and almost fond, hand patting the other woman’s arm as she explained more forcefully what their next move would be. The brunette met Steve’s dark eyes with her own blue ones- ‘we think there’s a gate for every death by Vecna, the closest one of those to us is Eddie’s trailer.’
Obviously, Steve hadn’t been expecting to find his dead ex, so he hadn’t really expected jealousy. His own brain had set him up with that, just wishful hoping that Billy would come back, but now he was and seemed to be coming back to the flipside with them and he couldn’t even figure out how to tell his current boyfriend that his dead ex was a gay man.
