Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter Text

Bilbo came to on the battlefield, his head aching as if someone had beaten it repeatedly against a wall, which in all likelihood was close to the truth with all the jostling he had received. Being invisible only meant the orcs could not target him, but he had received plenty of bumping and prodding, and even a few nicks from the edge of blades as he wove and dodged past, struggling to stay near his companions. Armored as they were from Dáin’s stock of infantry gear, the dwarves of the Company were almost impossible to distinguish from the larger host from the Iron Hills.

It was a coincidence for the storybooks indeed. Bard and Thranduil had been so busying arguing amongst themselves for they might best dig out the entrance to Erebor and claim their share of the treasure that they almost didn't notice when Dáin and his army arrived, which put a swift end to those negotiations. 

Bilbo had thought Thorin would make his appearance then, for surely the arrival of Dáin’s army had been the point of his little stunt of walling off Erebor. But the dwarf king, who Bilbo would have once called his friend, if not something more, something tenuous and unspoken and lost now with the Arkenstone, had never arrived. Gandalf must have noticed how Bilbo’s shoulders sank as the day progressed and no familiar dark head approached, tall and proud amongst the other dwarves, to issue his counter-offer with a fresh and well-trained army at his back. In the end he never appeared, leaving three lords of three races arguing over what to do with one another and with the mountain.

That was the moment the armies of Azog arrived from Dol Guldur. What purpose brought them there, none could say, though Bilbo had his sneaking suspicion that it was the Pale Orc's enmity towards Thorin that brought them to Erebor, for what use had the orcs for treasure and jewels? Only hatred of Dwarves, Elves and Men could bring them thence, and that they had in spades.

Battle was hardly the word for it. Chaos, a mêlée of four races scrapping amongst themselves with no central command or formal battle line. Then the Eagles swooped in and the army of Dol Guldur collapsed into a rout. Perhaps all battles were thus; Bilbo was not one to know, having never seen a great battle outside of his books. Still, he imagined they were usually a great deal more organized than this one, numbering only two sides rather than five.

Something thoroughly unreasonable and Tookish had prompted him beforehand to request his own set of dwarven armor and weapons from Dáin, and he too had joined battle, although he soon realized how thoroughly out of his depth he really was. On went his magic ring, and he spent the rest of the fight dodging the flailing of Elves, Dwarves, Men, and Orcs while trying to stay near his companions, striking out with Sting when they were in danger. Thus he saved Fíli and Kíli from Azog after they had together slain Bolg, and he bedeviled the Pale Orc with little stings across his ankles and calves long enough for Dáin to arrive with his vanguard. For Dáin had been at Azanulbizar and would have slain Azog himself then had Thorin not intervened. Mightily the two strove against one another, or at least they had been when something struck Bilbo on the head and he knew no more of the battle, or anything else for that matter.

Bilbo rubbed at the goose egg forming above his temple and had gone quite far across the battlefield, dodging the twitching orc bodies and the sadder, broken corpses of Elves, before he realized he was still invisible! He would have snatched off the ring then, but it occurred to him that he did not yet know for certain the outcome of fight and perhaps a bit of caution was warranted.

He was skirting along the edges of a mud-stained field tent when he heard the first familiar voice. It was Gandalf, who sound distinctly irritated, which was nothing new.

“For heaven’s sake, Bard, Thranduil—yes you too. I am quite done with your childish sniping. Until we determine if Thorin is still alive, Dáin is the acting king of the dwarves.”

“And what right does that give him to negotiate for the wealth of Erebor, promised to me by Thorin Oakenshield when he was a guest in my halls?” came the cool voice of the Elvenking. “Let me treat with his heir, the brown-haired one. He seemed amenable to my people.”

“Kíli was never the heir, you are thinking of Fíli. A simple mistake, but a common one. I’m afraid Fíli is not available to negotiate, his wounds from the battle…”

At that moment Bilbo wrenched the Ring off his finger, and rounded the corner into the tent. “Surely nothing has happened to Fíli!”

Gandalf, Thranduil, Bard, and Dáin all sat at a rough camp table and looked up as one as Bilbo entered.

“Bilbo, my dear friend! We thought you lost in the battle,” Gandalf said, and real joy brightened his face.

“Well, I’m found again, if a bit the worse for wear,” Bilbo said, indicating the throbbing lump on his head. “But never mind that, what has happened to Fíli and Kíli? And what of the others?”

“All well, all well, I can assure you, though similarly bruised and battered. Fíli took quite a blow to the head himself and is far too dazed to negotiate with these cutthroats, even if he were trained for such things.”

Bilbo sagged with relief, before he remembered the other pressing issue. “And Thorin? Is there any word from Erebor?”

Gandalf’s expression turned grave. “None, and I fear the worst. Even dwarves, hardy as they are, cannot go forever without food or water. The latter he may have, but unless Thorin is leaving by the secret door to forage then I fear for his health nearly as much as I fear for his sanity. Such treasure is enough to turn the heads of even the very wise.” He gave a sour look at his three companions, as if to indicate there were far worse consequences for those he did not number among the wise. “Even normal gold may have terrible effects.”

“It isn’t? Normal gold, I mean,” Bilbo said. Thranduil scoffed, at which Bilbo frowned with indignation.

“Long has the gold of Erebor been the nesting place of evil,” Thranduil said. “And not lightly does such a curse fall from the metal without the aid of one such as Mithrandir. There are foul magics that follow in the wake of dragons, for like orcs they are beasts twisted by the enemy from other beings. Where they go, wrath and ruin follow, not only from the fire of their breath. The very ground they walk upon carries their curse: the hunger for treasures that may break the souls and bodies of lesser beings.” Thranduil gave a smile then, as if to indicate how far above such things he counted himself. “One can only imagine what horrors have imbued the treasures of the dwarves, lying beneath Smaug for over a century.”

“Gandalf, is that true?” Bilbo said, keeping his gaze fixed on Thranduil, searching his face for mockery and deceit. Mockery there was in spades, but deceit was harder to read. Bilbo loved the Elves of Rivendell, but perhaps some of the dwarven bias had infected him in Mirkwood. His distrust of the Elvenking began the minute he imprisoned the dwarves in his halls, and it only grew as he saw the way Thranduil goaded Thorin when he was at his mercy.

“I have suspected as much,” Gandalf said. “Which is why I forbade Thorin to enter the mountain without me.”

“There was hardly any choice: Durin’s Day was here and you were not,” Bilbo pointed out, feeling compelled to defend Thorin’s decision even when he too had protested it at the time. A creeping anxiety was born in him at the Elvenking’s words, and he cast worried glances up at the mountain, as if he might be granted some special sight to pierce the miles of stone and see Thorin within.

“Often does necessity make mockery of our plans. Still, once the door was open, there was no need to go inside immediately. You could have opened the door and waited on the step, or taken turns camping just inside the entrance until I arrived,” Gandalf said, and Bilbo frowned, nose twitching, for he had no answer to that. It had all seemed so urgent at the time, with Thorin driving them on, that the thought had simply not occurred. “It matters not. What matters is that we have a city in ruins and three armies still outside the gate of Erebor who will not be sated without their share or at least some promise of future payment. And we have no way of getting in with any kind of large force.” Gandalf’s eyes gleamed. “Which may be where you come in, my dear Bilbo.”

“Oh no, my burgling days are over, I’ll not go in there to bring you back treasure, not a single coin! Thorin was right, you lot have no proper claim to it and I’m ashamed at how you all behaved over the Arkenstone, especially you two!” Bilbo cried, pointing at Thranduil and Bard, the former of whom looked affronted if a bit confused, as if he had been attacked by a particularly vicious squirrel.

“This is not a question of treasure or blame, Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said, cutting Bilbo’s tirade short. “They have agreed that their share of the treasure must wait until we have determined who exactly rules under the mountain, at least they will even if I have to bang their heads together a few more times.” Gandalf said with an added glare at the assembled lords. “No,” he continued, his voice softening, “this is a selfless errand, if far more perilous.”

“Sounds familiar,” said Bilbo dryly.

Gandalf ignored this. “Someone must enter Erebor and find Thorin. You are the only one I can trust not to fall under the sway of the gold.”

Bilbo’s heart leapt. In truth he had considered doing something similar, perhaps leaving a bushel of apples outside the door in an attempt to lure Thorin out, like a cat with a piece of fish, but just as he had considered it himself he had also considered the impossibility of it, and his heart sank to somewhere near his fur-covered feet. “Gandalf, I very much doubt Thorin is going to want anything to do with me after…after the Arkenstone debacle.”

“Indeed, that is an issue that still needs some resolution. As it was your share of the treasure, I believe you should have some say in the matter. What do you suggest, Bilbo?” Gandalf said.

Bilbo pondered this, his heart heavy with the memory of the theft. Even if he still thought his reasons were right he could not forget the look of pain and betrayal on Thorin’s face when the Arkenstone was revealed in the hands of his enemies. “It belongs to the dwarves. Give it to Fíli and Kíli, or Dáin if you must, for safekeeping. Then it must be returned to Thorin. After all, it belongs to his family and I was only borrowing it,” he said finally.  A cry of protest went up immediately from Bard and Thranduil while Dáin leaned back, looking satisfied.

“Oh, hush you two,” Gandalf snapped. “You never would have been permitted to keep it anyway. Master Baggins is right. The dwarves would have gathered to make war on you before the year was out. It is a legacy of their people, not a pretty bauble to stick in a tiara.” He turned back to Bilbo. “With any luck this news will bring Thorin back to his senses and we can put this whole unpleasant business behind us. Master Bard of Laketown tells me Thorin offered to share the wealth before you departed, we shall simply have to make him own up to that promise, but none of that will happen while he has walled up with the Arkenstone beyond his grasp.”

Bilbo considered, remembering the terror of that long drop, his teeth rattling as Thorin shook him. But then he remembered too their embrace high above on the Carrock, their whispered words far below in the dungeons of Thranduil, and the bliss on Thorin’s face as the door to Erebor cracked open. There was more to his friend than the madness that consumed him.

“He is in there somewhere,” Gandalf said, and Bilbo started, wondering if Gandalf had divined his thoughts. “My guess is the treasury, but he could be anywhere, for Erebor is vast.”

Bilbo chewed his lip then nodded. “I will do it.”

“I thought you might,” Gandalf murmured. “Though I must say your courage has increased manifold since I found you in the Shire, my dear friend.”

Bilbo shook his head. “Nothing of courage in it. Thorin is…well, he’s many things, but he is also my friend, after a fashion, and no hobbit can leave a friend to starve to death. I’ll get ready; there’s isn’t much time to waste,” he said, turning. He thought to wash first, and have his wounds dressed, before loading up with as much food as he could carry, perhaps a pony to carry it to the hidden stair. He had just headed to the door of the tent when Gandalf caught him by the shoulder and leaned down.

“Bilbo, you will need to be careful,” Gandalf said, putting his mouth to Bilbo’s ear. “Thranduil is right: not all may be well with Thorin’s mind.”

“Really Gandalf, I think I can handle one starving dwarf. After all, I handled thirteen of them in Mirkwood. I imagine nothing Thorin can dish out will compare to that unpleasantness; the worst should be well behind us now.”

He would later realize how very badly he needed to stop saying things like that.


 

There was really no time to linger, but still Bilbo visited the field infirmary while arrangements were made for his pack and pony. He thought to check in on Fíli and was pleased, though not surprised, to see Kíli there as well. The red-haired elven maiden he vaguely recalled from the dungeons of Mirkwood hovered behind the young dwarf like a shadow as he hunched over his brother’s cot. Fíli’s head was swathed in bandages, but the two seemed to be in good spirits, laughing over some joke Bilbo had missed when Fíli looked up and waved to the hobbit.

“Bilbo! We had just about given you up!” Fíli said. Kíli turned and with a startled laugh wrapped one hand around Bilbo’s shoulders and dragged him to the side of the bed.

“Well if it isn’t our burglar, returned to the land of the living!” said Kíli.

“Never left it, I’m pleased to say,” Bilbo said. “Though I hear Fíli here was a near thing. I’m sorry I could not do more but, well…” He pointed to the lump on his head, wrapped now in clean linens.

“There’s no need. There’s no telling what might have happened without you and your letter opener,” Fíli said.

“Has there been any word of Thorin?” Kíli piped in. At that, the room went quiet and the temperature seemed to drop several degrees. Bilbo shifted.

“None. I’m off to…that is, Gandalf suggested that I be the one who goes looking for him,” Bilbo said.

“But that’s a wonderful idea!” Kíli said. “Thorin trusts you.”

Bilbo stiffened. Of course, the brothers had not been there, had not been close enough to see Thorin’s fingers digging into his shoulders as he called Bilbo a descendent of rats and threatened to cast him down to the rocks. “Indeed. Well, Gandalf has managed to convince Bard to surrender the Arkenstone into your keeping. It should be along shortly. I’m hoping this news will cheer him.” Thorin's name stuck at the back of his throat.

“And what about us?” said Fíli. Kíli looked at his brother and back.

“But of course we’ll be going too, right?” said Kíli to Bilbo, who shifted again. A moment to exchange a few pleasant words to an injured comrade before he departed was growing far more complicated than he had anticipated.

“Gandalf made no mention of you; I’m sure he has his reasons. Oh! You must stay with your brother, Kíli,” Bilbo said, unconsciously wringing his hands together. He clamped them beneath his arms to keep them still. Fíli arched an eyebrow.

“If Thorin is being unreasonable, wouldn’t it make more sense to send us?” said Fíli. Kíli snorted.

“He’s never listened to us. At least, not me. Mr. Baggins has a far better chance if Uncle is being difficult.”

“Oh, but here’s a thought,” Bilbo exclaimed, as guilt got the better of him. “Once you’re recovered, you’re welcome to come join me, if Gandalf approves. After all, if I’m not back by then I’ll likely be needing your help anyway.”

Fíli did not seem convinced. “What exactly is the problem, Bilbo?”

“Oh, you know your uncle, he’s just upset about Thranduil being here. Decided to keep the mountain closed off until it’s all settled.” Fíli opened his mouth to protest when a gray head in a pointed hat appeared, poking through the tent flap.

“Time to go, Bilbo,” Gandalf announced.

Bilbo turned back to the brothers. “I must be off. Goodbye, Fíli, Kíli, my lady,” he added, bowing to the elf maiden. “I will be back by the end of the week, you will see. Farewell!”

The dwarf brothers chimed back their farewells and Bilbo ducked out after Gandalf. The wizard stood by a fuzzy dun pony laden with two heavy packs. It snorted at the sight of him, breath misting in the air.

“I will travel with you as far as the secret door, but I’m afraid I must turn back there,” Gandalf said.

“So you will not be coming with me to see him?” Bilbo said anxiously.

“Would that I could, Bilbo, for I have an ill feeling about Thorin’s silence. But I cannot leave three armies for one dwarf. Thranduil and Dáin are at each other’s throats, and I still do not know for sure which side Bard would take if they should come to blows. I must tell you I will be happy to be done with the whole Line of Durin and of Oropher for a few centuries once this is over,” he muttered the last under his breath. “Nonetheless, I can keep you company on the road and help you with your packs until then.”

“Well, thank you for that at least,” Bilbo said, trying to hide his disappointment, and more his sudden trepidation. Alone in the mountain with Thorin, with the bruises of the dwarf’s handprints still ripening on Bilbo’s shoulder… He had faced great spiders, a dragon, and more monsters than he wished to count but none quite matched this new terror, that of seeing a friend’s face twisted by anger beyond recognition. He released a shuddering sigh, letting it take the with it the edge off his of nerves.

“Shall we go?”


Those who have crossed
With direct eyes, to death's other Kingdom