Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 15

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“Tell me, burglar,” Thorin snarled. “Did you wait even an hour before going to fetch my kin?”

“I—I—” Bilbo said in a strangled whisper. He trembled and pressed himself flat against the cold stone of the wall, his eyes screwed shut against the dragon-spell gaze. Then Bilbo felt the brush of scales as Thorin moved in close, and hot breath bathed his neck. His heart thundered in his chest, wild and terrified.

There was a warm touch against Bilbo’s face and suddenly Thorin was pressing their foreheads together, and he released a choked sob, his voice broken and erratic, half-mad as he said, “Why didn’t you listen to me?”

Bilbo stilled. Finally he heard, over the pounding of his own heart, the uneven pace of Thorin’s breathing, thick and frantic as if on the edge of tears or hysteria. Bilbo raised a shaking hand, not knowing if it was safe to do so, whether it was suicidal. Fumbling blind, he trailed his fingers up Thorin’s chest, over the hard slick scales that covered it, and clasped his hand around the back of Thorin’s neck. Even while he knew he should be terrified, there was a part of him that was already calming, because Thorin was here, alive, when not hours before Bilbo had thought him lost forever. Bilbo’s heart lurched at the ridge of scales that ran up Thorin’s spine to the back of his neck, barring the way for his hand, so Bilbo moved his fingers up to where the ridges was smaller, and traced them along the back of Thorin’s neck to soothe him. A shudder passed through Thorin, wracking him from head to toe.

“Shhh, Thorin… Thorin, I had nothing to do with that,” Bilbo murmured. “They came on their own.”

Thorin was silent for a long moment, his breath coming out in feverish pants, tickling the tip of Bilbo’s nose. “I wish I could believe you,” Thorin said, sounding utterly wretched.

“And why can’t you?” Bilbo said, his fingers tracing circles on the nape of Thorin’s neck and he could feel the tension bleeding out of Thorin from that spot and radiating outwards.

“Because you have already been false once,” Thorin said, his voice cracking. “I have always wished that I could believe you, for the world seems a brighter place when I do, but you lied when I trusted you. You told me you did not possess the Arkenstone when you did, and I cannot suffer that again. Do you understand, Bilbo? I would not survive it, and now my heart tells me again that you are false.”

“It’s not your heart, Thorin,” Bilbo said gently. “It’s this place, this sickness. I swear I didn’t summon them, I wouldn’t have had time. Fíli and Kíli came here because they were worried about you, because they care for you.”

“But for how much longer, once they have seen this?” Thorin said, and broke away from Bilbo’s grasp. He must have gestured towards himself; but with his eyes closed Bilbo only felt the movement of the air. There was a pause. “Even you cannot bear to look upon me.”

Bilbo’s breath caught in his throat. “Thorin, no! It’s not like that— Oh, blast!” How could he explain the dragon-spell, when it would undoubtedly make matters worse? If Thorin already believed himself beyond saving, how would he react to learning that he had hypnotized Bilbo to stay with him during those long days upon the throne? Bilbo did not yet know himself what had been his own will, and what had been the dragon-spell. Instead he bit his tongue, swallowing back the words. “Listen to me: Fíli and Kíli…they’re your family, they only want to help. We can still fix this. Gandalf is outside—”

Thorin laughed. It was not his usual soft, almost shy chuckle. It was barking, disdainful, and carried the edges of the low, snarling tone of the other voice. “Ah yes, Gandalf,” Thorin hissed. “That is what this is about, is it not? What is has always been about.”

Unraveling. The word appeared unbidden amongst the swirling confusion in Bilbo’s head. Thorin was unraveling. He had seen it once before, in those first days after they entered the mountain, when Thorin had tilted wildly between euphoria at reclaiming their home and despair as he looked on the smoking ruin of Laketown, not daring to leave the mountain or give up his manic search for the Arkenstone. Bilbo knew he must be careful with what he said next, but was too baffled to think straight. His thoughts chased the thread of how Gandalf, of all people, could somehow be at the heart of this matter, and he felt himself to be walking on crumbling stone as Thorin swung from one extreme of emotion to another in the blink of an eye.

Bilbo took a deep breath, screwing up his courage and wrinkling his nose as he attempted to master his scattering thoughts. He spoke slowly. “I can’t say as I follow you. We were looking for a cure, and Gandalf has one. Why not leave here now, and put this all behind us?”

“And in exchange, I need only place myself back under the power of an enemy, and allow him to work his witchcraft upon me?” said Thorin scornfully.

“We’ve been over this,” Bilbo sighed. “You and Gandalf need never speak again if you don’t wish to. But go to him for help this one last time, please.”

“Go to him? You would like that very well, wouldn’t you?” Thorin said, his voice low and dangerous. “You have never been what you seem, have you burglar? It is only a wonder that I did not see it sooner. I was blinded, first thinking you were only a simple hobbit, and then by affection, just as I was meant to. You were well suited to this quest, chosen with care, possessing unknown quality.”

Now Bilbo was thoroughly baffled. Were the situation not so dire, and Thorin’s voice not harsh as scraping stone, he might have barked a startled laugh. Being acknowledged for his accomplishments on the quest was one thing, but this was... well, this really wasn’t what he had in mind at all. “What are you trying to say?”

“What should have been obvious from the start. You say you are not a warrior, yet you slay wargs and spiders in battle as if you were born to it. You say you are not a thief, but found a manner to walk past goblins and elves unseen. Why would you come on this quest and claim no desire for treasure or glory? Why was it you that Gandalf sent to find me within the mountain, even when I had banished you and would have cast you to the rocks?” Bilbo felt the passage of Thorin’s movement and dared crack open an eye for a moment to stare at the floor. Thorin was circling in front of him as he spoke, as he had when they first met at Bag End, but the movement was tighter, more savage, like that of a caged animal. The tone of his voice was colder still, as if all they had gone through together since had never happened. “I will tell you why. Ever has the wizard sought to rule here on his own terms. He sent my father first, and when he failed, Gandalf lured me here with my heirs, then forbade us to enter unless he should come with us. Only you, of all the company, tried to stop us. Even now you act upon his will, seeking to put me back under his power,” Thorin hissed. “The spy in our midst.”

“A spy?” Bilbo gaped. “A spy indeed! Thorin, that is the most absurd idea I have ever heard. As if Gandalf would ever think I would have influence over you? Or that any of what has happened was intentional on my part; for goodness sake I didn’t even have the presence of mind to bring a pocket-handkerchief, let alone enact some master scheme!”

Thorin stopped his pacing and must have been regarding Bilbo. “No influence over me? I have taken your advice over that of my closest kin, and even now you seek to sway me. But reason tells me to study again all that you have done and see the pattern for what it is, rather than what I wish it to be. You are too good to be true, too perfectly suited to your purpose to be anything else. You have even found a way into my heart. Even as I look at you and feel as if I am being torn in two.” Thorin closed his hands around Bilbo’s shoulders and he flinched away, expecting the bite of claws even through the mithril shirt. Yet the touch was surprisingly gentle. “You saved my life, then stole the Arkenstone, helped me reclaim the mountain, then robbed me of my kin when they took your side against me. You gave me hope of release from this sickness, then violated my final wishes. I feel I’m being driven mad by the very sight of you. I wish to kill you and yet I wish to keep you.” Thorin let out a long, shuddering breath. “Which should I choose?”

“I think I would rather be kept, if it’s all the same to you,” Bilbo stuttered, nodding frantically.

“And yet I have never been allowed to keep that which I cherish, burglar. How convenient now that I need only give in to my enemy in order to have all I desire within my grasp. How could it not be a trick?” demanded Thorin.

“How could it be a trick?” Bilbo exclaimed. He felt himself grow incensed, as the situation spiraled away from him in the most baffling manner possible. “You have no enemies here, save for that thing inside your head! How could I be trying to trick you when I’m frightened half out of my mind? I don’t know what is happening or when this will end. I just want to leave this place, I just want this all to be over!”

“Then why did you stay?” Thorin said, the grip at Bilbo’s shoulders tightening. “Why did you not flee sooner, if you will only disobey my wishes, and cannot bear to look at me? Why did you linger, if not for some other motive?”

“Because I love you!” Bilbo said and the words were sharp as a cry that rose from the depths of the soul. He was too stunned, turned around, and desperately afraid to stop them. “I’ve loved you from the moment you first sang, from the moment I ran out my door after you!” And Bilbo was clutching at Thorin, dragging him close by the shoulders, because it was that or lose him again. Bilbo’s heart still ached from the throne, and he could not bear the thought of that loss, not another, or surely he would break. “I love you, and I almost lost you because of that damned stone, and I am losing you again to this sickness, and I will not be silent and proper a moment longer! It doesn’t matter how much I want to leave this place or how frightened I am, because I will never leave you here alone! Do you understand me, Thorin Oakenshield? I will fight for you, and I will stand by your side so long as there is even a shred of hope, and I would stay even if there were none! Not because of a wizard’s orders, or for treasure or fame. I am staying for you!”

With each word, the terror had drained away to leave something sharper and far more painful, and Bilbo panted as if he had run a race. Once he would have been mortified to say so much, but that was before the Arkenstone, the great battle, and the sickness. He had not spoken these words on the throne, and thought to never have the chance. The thought alone had left a scar on his heart that even having Thorin in his arms, breathing and alive, though driven mad by suspicion, could not heal. Even now, they may have only hours left together.

Thorin’s silence was not helping as it stretched, and Bilbo did not dare look up at him. He could not risk the dragon-spell; he could not risk falling back into that place of claustrophobic despair, bound up and convinced that there was no hope. He needed to be strong enough for both of them. Eyes fixed on the floor, Bilbo knew nothing of what was going through Thorin’s mind, only that he had gone still beneath his hands.

“Please don’t do this,” Thorin said, and for all that Bilbo could feel him looming above, his voice sounded small. “Not this. Use any other weapon against me, kill me if you must, but I beg you do not attempt to manipulate me with this.”

“You don’t believe me,” Bilbo said. His shoulders sank, and his voice was as hollow as his heart suddenly felt.

“I have done nothing but insult you and ignore your worth. I have chased and terrorized you. I have almost killed you. These things alone might have justified your theft, as a matter of revenge. How could you harbor anything but hatred and disgust for me? I should not dare believe you.” Bilbo parted his lips to protest but choked on the words, not knowing how even to begin. He felt his heart was shattering, and his mind going blank, not knowing what he could say if Thorin rejected this, if even the most desperate of confessions was not enough to get through to him. Then Thorin was moving, and Bilbo knew that he was leaving, that there was nothing further that could be done—

—And suddenly Bilbo was being drawn close, crushed against Thorin’s chest and he felt Thorin bury his face against the side of his neck and they were flush against each other and he could hear the harsh flutter of Thorin’s breath against his throat and his heart hammering in his chest and the warmth of Thorin’s body surrounding him. “But I do. Mahal help me, I believe you. Though I am surrounded by enemies, and all hands are turned against me, I believe you. And I am afraid for how much I want it to be true, knowing how it clouds my reason. Even now my heart tells me you have simply found this greatest of weapons, and seek to use it against me. All I can do is beg that, if you lie, that you take back your words now, and not toy with this last hope that remains to me. Not this. Please.”

Thorin’s face was hot against his neck, and Bilbo trembled, fearing he would burst into tears again from the force and desperation of Thorin’s words. He freed his hands from where they were pressed between them and twined them around Thorin’s shoulders, drawing him close, his right hand coming up to cup the back of Thorin’s head. He felt he could not speak yet, not and trust his own voice to take on the calm and steadiness this moment demanded, so he only held Thorin in the silence while his own breathing slowed and his throat lost its tightness. There was too much to say, too much to ask, and his thoughts whirled until it appeared to him, a single question that felt long forgotten, that he thought to never would have answered, and Bilbo knew he must know.

“Amrâlimê,” Bilbo murmured, and settled his cheek against Thorin’s hair. “What does that mean, Thorin?”

For a moment there was only the harsh sound of Thorin’s breathing, still quick and desperate and when he spoke the words were choked as if torn from his throat. “It means ‘my love’.”

Ah, Bilbo sighed within his thoughts, and realized on some level that he had always known. But now they had both said it aloud, and no amount of dwarvish stubbornness or his own fretful misunderstandings could undo it. “And am I, still?”

There was another pause as Thorin took a shaky breath that fluttered against Bilbo’s skin. “Yes.”

“Amrâlimê, Thorin Oakenshield” Bilbo repeated softly. His tongue stumbled around the unfamiliar syllables, but it was worth it for the effect it had on Thorin, how every muscle in his body seemed to tense and then relax at the same time. “Is what you are to me as well, and I want to say that many times, over many years, in every language. I would say it now in Elvish, if I did not fear that would give you apoplexy.”

Thorin snorted a laugh and it was such an unexpected, welcome sound that Bilbo could not stop the wide grin that spread over his face.

“And this is why you followed me here?” Thorin said and something of that haunted, erratic tone was fading in favor of his familiar rumble.

“It’s why I followed you half-way across the world, poor love-struck fool that I was, never mind down a nasty, clockless, timeless hole,” said Bilbo.

“Don’t call my palace a nasty hole,” Thorin grumbled against his neck. “You wait until it has been cleaned and redecorated.”

Bilbo threw back his head and laughed in great aching peals. That horrible sick feeling was diminishing and his muscles relaxing. A few latent tears prickled the corner of his eyes but mostly he felt light, with the burden removed from his shoulders and heart. “There’s nothing I’d like better. Now love, if you would be so kind, would you consider saying the word that opens that door?”

“The door?”  Thorin said, and Bilbo was only just able to close his eyes in time as Thorin looked at him. “I can’t.”

“What? Why not?” Bilbo said.

Thorin shook his head. “I don’t remember coming here. Bilbo, I don’t know where we are.”


Sightless, unless
The eyes reappear
As the perpetual star
Multifoliate rose
Of death's twilight kingdom
The hope only
Of empty men.

Notes:

Quotes
“Dear me!” grumbled the hobbit. “More walking and more climbing without breakfast! I wonder how many breakfasts, and other meals, we have missed inside that nasty clockless, timeless hole?”...
...“Come, come!” said Thorin laughing— his spirits had begun to rise again, and he rattled the precious stones in his pockets. “Don’t call my palace a nasty hole! You wait till it has been cleaned and redecorated!”
- The Hobbit, by J.R.R. Tolkien (p. 243)

Translation
Amrâlimê - My love (Khuzdûl)

This chapter has fanart!
I Believe You by closetshipping (prepare for feels)
 

This story has fanart!
Thorin by olddudeskissing