Actions

Work Header

Prayers to Broken Stone

Chapter 23: Epilogue, part 2

Chapter Text

The council chamber, if it could be called that, was a tent at the edge of the battlefield, set at a point of neutral ground between the gates of Erebor and the city of Dale. The armies had cleared their dead from the field, but the scars that remained painted a picture of a battle so fierce that Thorin balked at the sight. The landscape itself was torn beyond the effects of Smaug’s desolation, and now the land was spotted with the burnt-out pyres of the dead. A battle Thorin had missed, that had been fought in his name, and that shame would never leave him. Yet there was more that must be done than wallow in his own failures, measures that must be taken to ensure such devastation never returned.

Thorin hesitated outside the tent, and as he did so he cupped his wrist in his opposite hand. It was a nervous habit that afflicted him since he regained his own form, the need to test again and again if any sign of his illness remained, if even the slightest hint of scales lingered beneath the skin. The absence of any kind of armor, or even a heavy coat, was unfamiliar and somewhat unsettling. It was all new, the lack of weight on his shoulders both physical and imagined, as if he’d cast off a burden so long borne it had become part of him. He felt exposed, even as he felt lighter than he had in years. It was the loss of so much that had defined him – anguish at Erebor’s loss, fear of being taken unawares by his grandfather’s illness, the shame of his failure to give his people a proper home, and of the illness that claimed him despite it all.

He was not sure he knew who he was without exile, or fear for the sickness of his line. Who was Thorin Oakenshield when he was not weighed down trappings of rank, and the memories of a century of leading his people, the pain of old betrayals, and humility that came from standing upon the brink of destruction? Especially when he emerged from it only by the grace of chance, and the most unlikely of companions. The mountain was behind him, reclaimed and empty of the monster that had haunted it for centuries. Unfinished business lay ahead. In between, he stood, only a dwarf of Durin’s line with a purpose made clear.

Who was he now? No one but himself, whole within his skin, and only now able to appreciate it for the wonder it was. His hand fell from his wrist, no longer testing for scales that weren’t there. Guards flanked the door, both elves of Mirkwood and dwarves of the Iron Hills. The latter inclining their heads in welcome, heavy steel helms obscuring their features. He nodded back and took a deep breath, looking down once more at the simple black trousers and long-sleeved blue tunic, the heavy iron-toed boots. He looked no different than any other dwarf who worked to restore the mountain, as ever he had been.

It was time.

Thorin pushed aside the canvas door to the council chamber, and four familiar faces awaited him, a hush falling over the room. Gandalf, Bard, Thranduil and his cousin Dáin sat at a round wooden table that looked as if it had been scrounged from the ruins of Dale, based on its height and the scorch marks around the edges. Retainers were present in the tent, rough Men of Lake-town, impassive Elves, and the familiar armor and tabards of the Iron Hills. He was the only representative of the dwarves of Ered Luin and Erebor at present, a disadvantage he would have to live with. All eyes were upon him. The floor was his.

“Gentlemen,” Thorin said, looking to each in turn. “Thank you for your patience. I must apologize for my long absence, but as you may have heard, I had taken ill.” He allowed a moment’s silence at this, punctuated by a quiet snort of disbelief from Thranduil, and the nods of his cousin and Gandalf.  "Before we begin, I believe some thanks are in order that we may all sit together today, and were not destroyed by the plagues that have befallen us, from within and from without.”

He clasped his hands behind him, and when he spoke his voice fell into the easy cadence of his many negotiations with the merchant guilds of Ered Luin, rather than the more fiery speeches of Lake-town, or upon the wall. “To Dáin, Lord of the Iron Hills. Cousin, allow me to convey my deepest gratitude both for your swift aid in our time of need, and your leadership in my absence.”

 “Ach, none needed,” Dáin said, waving Thorin away. His voice was its habitual deep gravel, thickened by the accent typical of his domain. “I should be thanking you for the chance to cut down orcs! ‘Twas a good fight, shame ye missed it. Suppose this means we’re even, though, for not sending my warriors with you when you first asked. Congratulations on your success, by the way.”

Thorin nodded, the corner of his lip twitching. “Of course. It seemed a fool’s errand, and well did I know it. A leader cannot be faulted for not sending good warriors to die. You came when it mattered.”

“Aye, good to have that settled. Don't be thinkin' I'm leavin' ye here alone with these cutthroats. The Iron Hills will remain here as long as ye need us,” Dáin said, settling back into his chair with a final glare around the room at Thranduil and his entourage.

Thorin inclined his head once more in acknowledgement, feeling bolstered by the promise of arms, unnecessary as they may be if all went as planned.

He turned next to Bard. “Bard, or should I say King Bard of Dale?” Bard grimaced at the title, but made no attempt to correct Thorin. “Your aid to us in Lake-town should have earned you the everlasting and unquestioned friendship of Erebor, never mind my own personal gratitude.” Bard eyed him with some suspicion, warranted perhaps, given their parting words. “I have no excuse for my actions, save that eagerness clouded my judgment, and illness my mind. For those without a home, loss can be a constant hunger that robs us of that which makes us reasonable. It is my greatest regret that we did not heed your words, and that we set the beast loose upon your town, wreaking upon you the same fire that yet lives in the nightmares of my people. For what has happened I can promise you, without stint or hesitation, the full support of Erebor in rebuilding your home, be it Dale, Lake-town, or both. Any help my people may grant to yours will be given without question. I am only sorry it took this long for this assurance to be made, and the tragedies that made it necessary.”

 “I—” Bard began, his brow furrowing. He cast a glance at Thranduil at his right, then Gandalf at his left. “I accept your offer on behalf of my people, Thorin son of Thráin, but there is much to be discussed, and the price will be high. There is bad blood yet, and there will be for many years. I will not betray them by giving in easily to the one who brought calamity down on our heads with his actions.”

“Nor would I expect you to,” Thorin replied. “We must determine the extent of the damages, but rest assured aid will begin immediately. To begin, those treasures of Dale that lie within the mountain, looted by Smaug will be returned to you immediately and without question.”

“Just as there are treasures that are owed to you, Lord of Mirkwood,” Thorin said. He had struggled with how to address Thranduil while he planned for this meeting, the word king curdling on his tongue, and Thranduil's given name was out of the question for so formal an occasion. He had briefly flirted with the idea of calling Thranduil by some Khuzdûl curse, or even the title he so richly deserved: oathbreaker, gondkarkâl, but Dáin had not been informed, and it would not do to have his cousin give away the joke, or for Dáin to leap across the table to kill said oathbreaker. So Thorin had set the idea aside grudgingly, and settled for a title that was accurate if not exalted. “Within the mountain are certain gems promised you by my grandfather, King Thrór, called by some the gems of Eryn Lasgalen. These will be given to you immediately and, in a gesture of good faith that I hope will serve as seed for continued trade between our people, we will waive the fee for our work. I’m sure you understand that King Thrór only refused delivery because the work was not yet finished, and subsequent… events that were beyond our control prevented a timely delivery.” Throughout, Thorin kept his tone easy and even raised his eyebrows innocently as he continued, “I am sure you will not hold our tardiness against us, after all, what is a century to an elf?”

It took a great deal of self-control to keep a straight face, a task not in any way aided by Gandalf’s sudden coughing fit. He could not let the mask slip just yet. After all, he was not yet finished.

“As for the reconstruction of Lake-town and Dale—” Thorin continued. Preventing his smirk became that much more difficult as Thranduil stiffened with outrage.

“Is that all?” Thranduil said coldly. “Those gems are only the smallest portion of the wages owed to the Greenwood. Perhaps you are not aware as you lay insensate within the mountain, but a battle was fought in which the enemies of Erebor were put to rout by my armies, and many of my people lost their lives.”

Thorin’s eyes glinted, his trap sprung. “Indeed, there is the matter of your armies to consider. I must commend you on your foresight, to have detected the forces of Dol Guldur so soon, when no others knew of their approach. Would only that you had marched a bit sooner, when Elven archers could have also leant aid against Smaug. A true stroke of luck.” Thranduil’s gaze was icy and imperious as he drew himself up, no doubt preparing some response, but Thorin gave him no time. “Unless you came here as invaders, for which it would be ludicrous to think Erebor owes you anything at all.”

“Insolent princeling, do you so easily forget the alliance between our people? But for my armies you would have lost Erebor to the goblin hordes just as your kind did Moria and Gundabad,” Thranduil retorted.

Out of the corner of his eye, Thorin saw Gandalf press a hand to his brow. Dáin had gone purple with rage, and seemed to only hold himself back out of deference for Thorin, and Bard looked no happier now to be present at the infighting of elves and dwarves than he did when he first approached Erebor.

“We are not allies,” Thorin snapped. “Any connection between your kingdom and mine fell to ruin when you refused my people aid. Your people—,” Thorin stopped himself, clearing his throat, and took a deep breath. He skirted the edge of anger, but what he attempted now would require a delicate touch. “Your people owe us nothing, and with the free return of the gems of Eryn Lasgalen, nothing is owed in return. I will give the benefit of the doubt that you came to offer aid to Lake-town and Erebor, and had no designs on my kingdom, despite your timing. I am not against further dealings between our people, particularly trade, but clearly the terms of our old alliance were too onerous a tax on Mirkwood’s limited resources. You had your own borders to protect, falling as they were in to shadow, and I hold no further grudge with this fact in mind. It was our error to count on the aid of Mirkwood in our time of need, and that miscalculation of resources cost us our home. Erebor therefore has no desire to ask more of Mirkwood than it can give, including military aid. If you wish to establish trade relations at this council, I welcome them. As it is, you will be paid as befits what aid you gave.”

“And what is that supposed to mean?” Thranduil bit off, his eyes glinting with suppressed fury.

Thorin looked sidelong at Bard. “King Bard, what is the going rate for mercenaries in Esgaroth?”

Bard looked up, startled to be called upon. Then his lip twitched, as surprise gave way to some measure of amusement, and cunning. Thorin doubted there was much love lost between Bard and Thranduil, who had only just met in the past weeks, and Bard would have the interests of Dale to worry about before those of Mirkwood. His only interest in seeing Thranduil in the region was as a balancing point for Erebor, and it could still be possible to woo him away with gold and friendship, albeit belatedly applied. “Without promise of plunder? I should think ten coins per soldier would be a generous rate for a single battle.”

“Only ten gold coins?” Thorin exclaimed in undisguised shock, actually breaking eye contact with Thranduil to gape at Bard.

Bard gave a wry smile. “Silver, more likely. This region is not so prosperous as it once was.”

“This is outrageous!” Thranduil said.

“Of course we would not pay so little for the expertise of an Elven army,” Thorin said, holding up a mollifying hand to Thranduil. “Yet to repay only the commander would send the wrong message, that we do not value the efforts of his individual soldiers. I will personally see to it that your people are paid as befits their skill and long experience, either in gold or jewels as they choose, with their leader taking what cut a commander may expect in addition to the cost of fielding such a force. I entreat King Bard’s aid in working out the correct value, as he was present at the battle and I was not. After all, the armies of Lake-town lost much more in people and property, so it would be inappropriate for Mirkwood to take a larger share.”

Thorin firmed his expression; it was that or smirk at Thranduil’s expression, gone pale with fury. “If you should find the terms unacceptable, Lord Thranduil, you need only say so, though we will then expect a counter-proposal of how you wished to be paid. One which should include your exact reasons for coming to Erebor when you did, a tally of all aid given, and an explanation for why you stayed once you learned of Smaug’s death and before the armies of Dol Guldur arrived.”

“That’s enough, Thorin,” Gandalf broke in. Thranduil looked only inches from drawing his sword, while Dáin had settled back into his chair, crossing his arms over his chest with a self-satisfied smirk and a wink at Thorin. “Or should I say, your Majesty. My Lord Thranduil, the terms are just for what you have requested, and as a new ruler returned from exile, it is well within Thorin’s right to renegotiate old treaties. After all, I’m sure none of us are interested in starting another war?” Gandalf said, his blue eyes narrowing as he took in the room, and silence greeted his question. “Excellent. I will stay to see that a fair price is agreed upon for all. I trust they will be fair?” he said, directing the last at Thorin.

“Of course,” Thorin said, raising an eyebrow. “Erebor will need allies if it is to prosper.”

“Whereas I will not accept the Greenwood as mere a trade partner with Erebor. You will offer better terms,” Thranduil said, his gaze boring into Thorin.

That was the one predictable thing about elves: their pride. Thorin had known all along that Erebor could not prosper without a close alliance with Mirkwood, one that Thranduil would not accept unless it was denied to him. And it had only taken the breaking of Thorin’s own pride for him to see it.

“That will require some negotiation, as Erebor has had its faith betrayed once before,” Thorin said smoothly. “First, we must determine how much everyone is owed of the treasure.”

The fun could not last forever, Thorin thought, pinching the bridge of his nose as the cacophony began, each side arguing for their worth and share. This was going to be a long day.


Long indeed, as evening fell while the negotiations dragged on. They had taken two meals there, and only half-way through,  servants had brought torches to light their way, what with the early fall of night in winter. Bard had not come unprepared and the beginnings of a ledger were presented, detailing the material value of Lake-town, and each item gone over one by one. Meanwhile Thranduil’s much vaunted Elven patience had been put to the test as he bartered for his own troops, and the terms that would make Mirkwood an equal partner with Erebor while still requiring payment for the Battle of Five Armies, as it was now called.

Thorin had been all too grateful when Gandalf called for them to adjourn for the night, despite Thranduil’s snort of disdain at the need for lesser beings to sleep. Bard’s strength was clearly flagging and Thorin had felt the press of exhaustion on his own eyelids as well. Yet he had not gone two steps outside the tent when he saw a familiar form. Gandalf stood at the edge of the torch’s light, with his hat pulled low against the wind, his pipe cupped behind his hand as he lit it. Thorin watched as Gandalf blew a smoke ring, the wind snatching it upward and away.

Thorin stopped, struck by warring instincts. He still could not say how he felt about the wizard. It was clear that much of his hatred stemmed from the illness itself, some attempt by the dragon’s voice to keep him from seeking out the one force with the power to cure him. Yet even without that simmering rage he still mistrusted Gandalf, though he had to admit he owed the wizard a debt of gratitude, and no dwarf may allow a debt go unpaid, for good or ill.

Thorin made up his mind and approached, taking his place beside Gandalf and crossing his arms, staring out into the night to the gates of Erebor beyond. The air was chill, but Thorin hardly felt it as he sought the words to encompass all that had come before. He looked over, catching Gandalf’s eye.

“Gandalf,” Thorin said with a nod. “A moment of your time, if you please.”

“Your Majesty,” Gandalf said, taking the pipe from his lips, returning Thorin’s nod. “Is there some manner in which I can assist you?” Thorin’s lips thinned on instinct, searching for some hint of mockery in Gandalf’s tone and fighting back a need to contradict the wizard, no matter what words came out of his mouth. 

“I would not hold you if there is somewhere else you must be,” Thorin said, forcing himself to keep his tone neutral. He looked out over the fields surrounding Erebor, shrouded in the gloom of night, the gates of the city lit by the burning braziers.

“Not at all, I always have a moment to spare for a friend,” Gandalf said, “ and I wondered when you would seek me out. I imagine you have questions?”

Thorin’s brow furrowed, surprised to hear ‘friend’ thrown about so casually. “Many. You have not been exactly forthright in the past, and there is much that still troubles me of what has transpired. You seem to know much about the nature of this curse, and try as I might I cannot understand how dragon sickness could linger in our blood so many Ages, and yet be defeated by so little? Why was this knowledge hidden? Who was Mîm, that he left the only account in all our vast histories of its origin?”

Gandalf puffed out a contemplative sigh and leaned on his staff as he thought. “Perhaps I should start with the easiest of these, for there is no single explanation. As to why the knowledge was hidden, I plead the same answer I gave to Bilbo. Since the First Age, when rumor first emerged of the corruption of the Petty Dwarves, it has been a matter of utmost shame and fear for your people. The knowledge was kept to a rare few, the seven Dwarf Lords, leaders of each clan, for they saw the knowledge as so traumatic to the identity of the dwarves that it was a peril in and of itself to spread it. They feared what would happen if your people ever learned that their greatest natural enemy, the drakes of Morgoth, came from within, that they were brought forth by vengeance for past wrongs. More than that, they feared the unscrupulous, those so driven by greed for power or wealth that they may see such a curse as a boon to their ambition. I confess, I too feared this. The dwarves of Erebor were made desperate by their loss, and it did not seem a stretch that one may think to fight dragons by becoming one himself.”

“You thought I would choose this fate of my own accord if I knew of it, as long as it meant reclaiming my home,” Thorin said, and could not keep the anger from his voice, cracking like flint on steel. Anger sparked, threatening the fragile wounds within, the shame and helpless rage he still felt over his own fall. Why was he even surprised? Gandalf had never shown himself above the casual disdain with which all races viewed the dwarves. Why should it be at all unexpected that Gandalf would see dragon sickness, which had so terrorized Thorin’s family and brought them low, as anything else than a fate they justly deserved and even embraced?

“In that I was wrong,” Gandalf interjected, snapping Thorin free of the dark turn of his thoughts. “Bilbo was quick to chastise me for my error, and quite correct in doing so.”

“Bilbo?” Thorin said, blinking.

“Yes,” Gandalf said with a hint of amusement. “I believe his exact words were that I underestimated you. There seemed to be no question in his mind that you were stronger than any temptation the illness may offer, and he was quite outraged on your behalf that I would even suggest it.”

Stronger? Hardly, but Thorin could not suppress the flicker of warmth within him at the thought of Bilbo’s defense, faith in Thorin that overcame the wizard’s judgment and had not wavered. Who knew from whence such faith had come? Thorin still could not grasp what brought Bilbo back to him again and again, what prompted him to stand up in defense of Thorin and all dwarves, and so could only remain grateful for it even as he was baffled.

“He was right,” Thorin said, managing some dignity as he pulled himself free of thoughts of Bilbo, who even now was healing within the mountain as a result of that faith. “For no dwarf worthy of the name would ever consider such a path, no matter its benefits.”

“And yet this goes to the heart of your other question, for Mîm in his final years allied himself wholeheartedly with the Enemy, Morgoth, and would have taken the curse unto himself had he lived long enough to seize the opportunity,” Gandalf said. “Mîm died a servant of evil, yet he was not always thus, having seen many hardships and terrors that could turn even the strongest of hearts to the Shadow. He lost his sons, his people, and his home, and these tragedies made him bitter and vengeful. I have no doubt whatever account of his you read held in it a kernel of truth, meant to record the knowledge of his people, but it was a truth designed to drive the reader to despair. For it is in despair that the curse takes root, and it was Mîm’s design to bring new servants to the Enemy. Knowing that, and what he suffered, I think he deserves our pity, and perhaps our understanding, but not our trust.”

“So those tablets were meant as a trap,” Thorin said, grimacing to himself. A trap he had blundered right into in his eagerness to learn more of the ailment, sealing his own fate.

“Indeed, and may very well be the reason for the speed of your malady, though I confess that alone does not seem to be enough,” Gandalf said, looking owlishly at Thorin, his brows drawing together as he did as if studying a mystery that yet eluded him. “Never before have I witnessed anything like it, Thorin. Even in the First Age, when Morgoth prepared for his assault on Gondolin, I never heard of a transformation so swift. Such dwarves that could escape his grasp came to the healers of the Elves, or to their own people for aid. Many ended their own lives rather than give in to the disease. Even so, those unfortunate souls had only the first stages of the transformation, with scales covering their skin, and this after months of contact with cursed gold.”

Thorin stilled, a chill washing him through that had nothing to do with the winter wind. He remembered his own change, skin flaking away to reveal scales that covered his body in a matter of days. Dread settled into his body like a stone.  “How is that possible?”

Gandalf shook his head. “I know not. Bilbo suggested the cause lay in the length of time Smaug spent upon the gold, the sheer quantity of it within Erebor, which surely surpasses all but the wealthiest kingdoms of the First and Second Age.”

“Perhaps it is only the weakness of the host,” Thorin said, a sick feeling twisting within him. Could that not be the case? A fault-line running through his family, made manifest within him, so that the steps between dwarf and dragon were only few, and quickly closed. He ran a hand down his forearm unconsciously, fingertips stopping to test again the blunt ends of his nails.

Gandalf’s brow drew together and he frowned down at Thorin. “Weakness? No, I should think it was not weakness at all. To tear oneself free of the Shadow by willpower alone is a remarkable feat."

Thorin snorted. "Remarkable? Against that creature? The only remarkable thing was how long it took for me to see how small and pathetic it truly was."

Gandalf shook his head, frowning. "Thorin, I sensed a darkness nested within you that set loose would have covered the mountain and all the surrounding lands in shadow. Can you imagine the power it takes to turn one living being into another, much less a dwarf, who is created from the bones of the earth itself? Your people are resistant to evil in a manner that no other race can boast, for anything to change a dwarf requires the most ancient and powerful of magic. Small and pathetic? A host of wizards would have been hard pressed to tear away a single scale."

Thorin's eyebrows rose and he rocked back, speechless, as he thought back to the voice within his head, the dragon that had seemed less than a garden lizard once finally confronted. "You ascribe such power to my people, and yet you seem to hold us in little better esteem than do the elves, thinking we may be easily tempted by evil," Thorin said, and it was as much a question as an accusation.

"Quite the contrary, if I am wary of the temptation dwarves may feel, it is because should they fall, other races will not be far behind. For when it comes to standing firm against the shadow, there is no force greater than that of the dwarves.”

Thorin eyed Gandalf, searching for some sign of mockery or deceit. “Thank you,” he said grudgingly, finding none. He looked back to the mountain, frowning.

“There is something more that troubles you?” Gandalf said.

“Why?” Thorin spoke the word softly, half to himself, then looked up to Gandalf.

“Why did I aid in the recovery of one of the greatest kingdoms of Middle Earth?” Gandalf said with some amusement, before sobering. “I think it cannot be understated the good it will bring to the world to have Erebor once again strong in the North. However, as for aiding your people, it was because in the end, it was your birthright, and you had been hard done by.”

“I imagine it fit very well in to your broader plans, whatever those may be, to have the ruler of a powerful kingdom in your debt,” Thorin growled. “A stronghold and army you may call upon, and the ear of his—his closest companion.”

Gandalf leaned on his staff, frowning down at Thorin. “I think perhaps I should be flattered by your faith in me, but it is not my place to re-write the destinies of the people of Middle Earth. My power is not endless and my knowledge is not infinite. All I may do is encourage those who already have the will to help one another to do so. Yes, it is true that I aided you and your people because you were enemies of Smaug, but that was because I am sworn to aid all the good races of Middle Earth, the Dwarves no less than Elves and Men."

"And Hobbits," Thorin murmured.

Gandalf chuckled. "And Hobbits, for whom I have been noted to have a particular fondness. One that I have been questioned for in the past, by certain parties that for the moment will remain nameless." Thorin kept his gaze downcast but could practically hear the damned twinkle in Gandalf's eye.

"Yes, yes. I was wrong for doubting Master Baggins," Thorin said, waving a dismissive hand and attempting to disguise his chagrin. He was not here to talk of Bilbo, or hear the inevitable- if deserved- ‘I told you so’ from Gandalf. "In the future I will not be so quick to doubt your... eye for quality." Had he spoken Khuzdûl he would have used a word for a miner’s unerring instinct to find pure veins even amongst the hardest dross. Westron could be wretchedly imprecise in such things, but no doubt Gandalf read more into their relationship than Thorin would have otherwise wished. They'd hardly been subtle about it when the curse broke.

"My eye for quality, as you say, does not stop at Hobbits any more than my aid does," Gandalf said, still in that infuriatingly gentle tone. There was a rustle of movement and Thorin started, looking first in shock then irritation as Gandalf crouched beside him. Did he think to mock Thorin's height with his own unnaturally tall form? Thorin bristled. Until he saw that Gandalf was looking up at him, and there was no mockery to be seen. There was only sincerity in the quixotic and often annoying Wizard who wore the guise of a Man. "It was not only my duty to lend you what small aid I could for your recovery, it was my privilege. And that is why I sent Bilbo to you alone.”

“To send him into the mountain, knowing the dangers he faced… that, Gandalf, I cannot so easily forgive. Another could have easily served in my place as king,” Thorin said earnestly. “The far wiser course would have been to slay me out of hand, even if the cure could be found. To attempt otherwise nearly cost Bilbo his life.”

“As for risking Bilbo, I’m not sure I could have stopped him—” Gandalf said wryly, then sobered. For he seemed to see something in Thorin that made him solemn. He searched Thorin’s face with eyes that held only kindness. “Thorin, Bilbo went to you under no one’s power but his own, because he believed it was worth the risk, and in truth, I don’t believe any cure I would have had to offer would have worked had I arrived with him. The darkness upon you was greater than the dragon sickness, and still I see its shadow upon you: this belief that your life is of little value.”

“Hardly a belief,” Thorin scoffed. Why had his voice gone hoarse? It was a labor to speak, his throat tight despite his efforts.

“Thorin,” Gandalf said, his brow drawing together, as if seeing something for the first time. “It is true that others could have served in your place, but as well? After all your battles and sacrifices? No. Erebor may have had another ruler, but it would not have had its king. Yet even if you had not been, had you lived utterly apart from all such great destinies, powers, and purposes," Gandalf took Thorin's slack hand in his own dry, wrinkled palms, "Thorin, you are worth saving."

Thorin tried to speak, but found that words had abandoned him. He could not bear to keep Gandalf’s gaze, and looked past him to the gates of Erebor. His home wavered in his vision, the braziers a golden smudge against the stone. He blinked, looking up to clear his vision, but still could not bear to speak. He nodded to Gandalf in acknowledgement and the wizard released his hand and stood.

“It is getting late, and my pipe seems to be finished,” Gandalf said, looking to the long stemmed pipe and away from Thorin. After a moment it was easier to breathe and Thorin cleared his throat, straightening. The wind was growing colder, sharper, which could be the only explanation for the dampness at the corner of his eye as he mastered himself. “I imagine you are expected?”

“So long as the rebuilding continues, I’m sure I will always be needed somewhere,” Thorin said, managing a soft chuckle, though his voice was thick.

“That,” Gandalf said, “was not what I meant.” But he said nothing further on the matter, and on some silent signal that Thorin had not known to exist between them, they began to walk back towards the gates.

They parted way at the entrance, Gandalf to the quarters leant to him within the city, and Thorin found himself wandering the corridors to the royal wing. A room of his own had been prepared, but so lost in thought was he, dwelling on Gandalf’s words, that he did not notice until long after he had passed them that he had wandered to Bilbo’s door. 

It was understandable, after all he’d spent his days and nights in a chair by Bilbo’s bed until the worst of the danger had past. He slept there often as not, unless Óin shooed him away to find his own rest, fretting as he did over any lingering hurt from Thorin’s encounter with dragon sickness.

Thorin’s hand hovered before the door, then fell back to his side. Bilbo would be within now, no doubt sleeping due to the late hour, recovering from injuries Thorin had inflicted. His presence could only serve to disrupt the hobbit’s much-needed rest. And what right did he have, in any case, to invite himself in to Bilbo’s room? Some days spent sleeping side by side, or camping on the road, were hardly excuses once the journey was ended. Thorin had his own quarters, and Bilbo his. They could see one another in the morning, when the days light made the lingering questions between them clearer. Thorin had no doubt that Bilbo would keep to his word, that he truly did wish to stay in Erebor and at Thorin’s side. That there was even affection, even love as Bilbo so often assured him.

But Thorin had been greedy once, and nearly lost all he had and all he was to it. It made him all the more aware of little moments of selfishness, of taking what was not given. Too much to process so soon after a day spent negotiating with enemies and tentative friends. Thorin turned away, seeking his own room, and only spared one glance back over his shoulder. If there was a light flickering beneath the door, then surely it was only his imagination.


Bilbo awoke to the sound of receding footsteps, and cursed himself for doing so. He’d only managed to snatch a few moment’s sleep the whole night, and the candle was burning low from his attempt to banish the darkness. His breathing was too loud in his ears, the room cavernous and empty. He closed his eyes again, squinching them shut as he tried to force himself back to sleep. The emptiness beside his bed was like a hole sucking the rest from him. It put his heart in his throat.

Foolish to expect Thorin to return here after the negotiations. He had his own quarters, his own life to attend to now that the illness was cured and Erebor reclaimed. He would find Thorin in the morning, find some time when he would not be a burden.

Bilbo had no claim on him, after all.