Actions

Work Header

All That Is Gold

Chapter 3: Three

Summary:

Bilbo finally speaks to Thorin. Balin explains a little dwarf lore.

Notes:

Once again, no Khuzdul used. We're about to get some pining, though, so stay tuned. Happy Valentine's Day to everyone. Go get a little treat, whether you have someone to celebrate with or not. I made cupcakes the other day to eat for the next few days and I'm going to a little event so I'll probably get lunch out too.
I have seen the comments on the last two chapters and I really appreciate all the love and support for this story. I'm really glad you all have enjoyed it so far. I mentioned to my friend that I was writing something for the Hobbit and she laughed at me (good naturedly) so I'm making her binge the movies with me when she finds a weekend she's not working. I, however, am unemployed. It's so exhilarating to see so many people enjoy what I'm writing. Hopefully I'll get another chapter up this weekend. I'm thinking there will be two or three more so I can talk about lore a little bit.

Chapter Text

Bilbo left the kitchens with renewed determination. Footsteps echoing on the cavernous halls, he made his way to the mining quarter where he knew Thorin to be. The king had put his own focus into rebuilding the collapsed mines so that they could begin to return to the kingdom Erebor had once been. 
The great mines Bilbo found were deep in the belly of the mountain, branching out of huge caverns larger than any room Bilbo had ever seen. The stone walls glittered with jewels and metals, reflecting light off the elaborate iron contraption fixed into the floor and wired into some kind of pulley-system. 
“Pardon me, Master Dwarf!” Bilbo called, making eye contact with a dwarf bearing a deep black beard heavy with metal beads. He glanced around swiftly and then pointed to himself like he couldn’t imagine Bilbo would be talking to him, but Bilbo stepped closer. 
“Would you happen to know of the king’s whereabouts?” He asked. The dwarf blinked at him oddly before gesturing further down the cavern to a downward slope.
“He’s workin’ on a plan to get into the ruins down tha’ way,” he said. “He’s been at it nearly all day.” 
Bilbo bowed and thanked him before scurrying further into the depths of the mines to a section which seemed to have borne the brunt of Smaug’s mistreatment. The very mountain itself seemed to groan here under the strain of holding up crumbling walls and collapsing mineshafts. Very few of the tunnels were still standing, and those that did were shrouded entirely in darkness internally so that he couldn’t see at all if there was damage further in.
Bilbo found Thorin in the middle of a group of dwarves at the mouth of a mine, deep in a conversation Bilbo couldn’t understand. 
Shire rat! Do not speak to me of loyalty! Throw him from the ramparts!
Bilbo shook his head firmly and steeled himself as he walked closer. 
Thorin glanced up at the sound of his approach and his eyes went wide when he saw it was Bilbo coming towards them. He glanced around quickly, but Bilbo called out to him.
“You cannot avoid me forever, Thorin Oakenshield!” 
The dwarves around them had gone silent, some pointedly looking away and others watching with hidden smiles at the new king’s misfortune.
“Bilbo-” Thorin sputtered. 
“I have been trying to talk to you for weeks now, and yet you seem to always have an excuse.” Bilbo said furiously. “Have I truly upset you so terribly that you cannot even bear to look at me?”
“Of course you haven’t done anything wrong!” Said Thorin. There was no madness in his eyes. Whatever Bilbo was going to say next left him at once. 
“Then why won’t you speak to me? If you think you’ve been hiding this- this aversion then you’re wrong!” He said instead.
“Because I have no words!” Thorin exclaimed. Then he sputtered for a moment and he looked so tortured by whatever was running through his mind that Bilbo’s heart ached for him. “There are no words in any tongue spoken in Middle-earth that could adequately express to you how sorry I am. And I simply could not face you knowing I had nothing to say which would take away the hurt you must feel.”
At the edges of his vision, Bilbo saw that the other dwarrow were making themselves scarce, busying themselves with other things. 
“The things I said to you on the ramparts are unforgivable. I will carry this shame until the end of my days, and even beyond that in the halls of Mahal,” Thorin continued. “I would give you my braids and beads if I thought such a gesture would mean anything to you, but, if you would allow it, I would beg for your forgiveness as best I can with the words I do have.”
Then, right there, the King Under the Mountain fell to his knees before Bilbo as though he was not at all aware of the many eyes fixed on them. Bilbo flushed brilliantly as Thorin took his hand in both of his own. 
“If I thought you could stand to even hear my voice, I swear my apologies would have been the first thing from my lips when I woke. I have done you a terrible dishonor when all you have ever done is stand by my side. You have been the greatest of friends, Bilbo Baggins. Anything you would take from me in recompense is yours. Anything you ask of me, I will do.”
With trembling fingers, Bilbo reached out his free hand to place on top of Thorin’s and the king stared up at him in awe. The voice echoing in his mind upon seeing Thorin’s face had grown quiet, overtaken by the voice of the dwarf in front of him. 
“You are forgiven, Thorin,” Bilbo said easily. 
“You cannot mean that,” said Thorin in a small voice. 
“I do,” Bilbo told him. “If there is anything you can give me, it is your continued friendship. I have little use for much else.”
Thorin stared at him from the floor, eyes wide and lips parted in surprise. Bilbo looked away, feeling awkward.
“Get up from the floor now, please,” he said. Thorin did so without a word.
“Are you certain you wouldn’t get even the slightest satisfaction if I cut off my beard for you? It would be most proper,” Thorin asked. He hadn’t released Bilbo’s hand, but Bilbo couldn’t bring himself to force the issue.
“I would hate to see you harm such a lovely beard over something I have already forgiven you for,” Bilbo said softly.
“You are truly a wonder, Master Baggins,” Thorin replied. Bilbo looked away. 
“I’m sorry to interrupt your work,” he said. “I had to make sure you would listen to me.”
“Don’t apologize to me,” Thorin insisted. “I will always make time for you.”
Bilbo had a feeling that Thorin’s words carried some deeper meaning he didn’t understand, but he couldn’t figure out what that might be. 
“I’ll let you carry on with what you were doing,” Bilbo said with finality. “Perhaps you’ll have time to eat with the rest of us later?”
“Of course,” Thorin replied immediately. Bilbo offered him a small smile and left the mines, trying not to look too much like he was fleeing.


 Balin had hardly moved from his spot when Bilbo returned to the office, seated in an old chair behind a great desk. He didn’t even glance up when he entered.
 “Did you talk to him?” Balin asked. Bilbo nodded and then spoke aloud.
 “I did.”
 “So, I suppose everything has been sorted now, then?” 
 “I believe so,” said Bilbo. He waited, but Balin had nothing more to say, so he heaved a great sigh. “I’m quite sure there is some job within this mountain that can be done by a hobbit, Master Balin.”
 Balin looked up from his books.
 “As I told you before, lad, you deserve the rest after everything you have done for us. We already owe you our lives tenfold as it is.”
 “I cannot stand to sit around like a useless lump while there is work to be done,” Bilbo insisted. “I’m no good with mining and construction, but I was a landlord in the Shire. I’m well enough with numbers. I can cook a decent meal. I can keep a garden.”
 “I’m quite certain there isn’t a garden to be kept within this mountain,” Balin said teasingly. Bilbo frowned at him and he relented. 
 “As much as your help would be appreciated with the records, you cannot read Khuzdul. However, you may be of use in negotiations if you can convince Thorin to bring you with him.”
 “I’m certainly no diplomat,” Bilbo pointed out.
 “You’re the most levelheaded of us all, I’d wager. So if you’d like a job so badly, it would at least give you something to do.” Balin said.
 Bilbo stepped over to the bookshelves and inspected the golden runes lining the spines of the books. 
 “Something else on your mind, laddie?” Balin asked. “I’m sure there’s space for you in the mines if you want to give it a try, though your bare feet may be a hazard.”
 “I’d argue your boots are more of a hazard than my feet will ever be,” Bilbo replied swiftly, but he turned back to face Balin, nibbling his lip. “It’s not about the work. It’s… something Thorin said earlier.”
 “What did he say?” Balin asked, now focused entirely on Bilbo, his records left abandoned.
 “He said… well… Balin, what does it mean if a dwarf cuts off their braids?” Bilbo asked. Balin was on his feet at once.
 “He what?” He cried.
 “He didn’t cut anything!” Bilbo said before Balin could do anything rash. “I just wanted to know what it would mean if he did. Is it bad?”
 “It’s… complicated.” Balin said, retaking his seat. “ For a dwarrow in Thorin’s position, to cut one’s hair is the greatest dishonor. Doing so in an act of repentance is the most public, most lasting sort of apology one can offer. I’m not sure if anyone told you in so many words, but he shaved his beard after Erebor fell so that he could visibly bear the shame of his people. Until it grows back entirely, it will make him appear less legitimate to others.”
 “He offered to give me his braids,” Bilbo said. “I was afraid he would take a knife to his beard in front of me.”
 “It would be appropriate for what he did to you, lad,” said Balin. “Even if you prefer to move on, to threaten the life of a companion like that is one of the greatest dishonors he could commit. It would be almost expected that his recompense would be of equal dishonor to himself.”
 “You really value your hair that much?” Bilbo asked. To someone who couldn’t grow hair anywhere other than his head and his feet, such an attachment was hard to imagine.
 “It is a dwarrow’s greatest pride,” Balin told him. “For him to offer to shame himself in that way should prove how highly you are regarded, Master Baggins.”
 “You think I’d know more than I do after traveling with so many of you for half a year,” Bilbo commented. “But it seems like I know more about the elves we stayed with for a few weeks.” Balin smiled. 
 “You should certainly know how secretive we can be,” he said teasingly. 
 “I’ve certainly gotten that impression,” Bilbo replied.